Why Authentic Panama Hat Weavers Are Abandoning The Craft | Still Standing
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 янв 2021
- Authentic panama hats are handwoven in Ecuador. The craft has sustained weavers in the small village of Puzhio for over a century, but many are now dropping the tradition and leaving the country to find more lucrative work. The weavers that remain worry the tradition will disappear from Puzhio completely.
MORE STILL STANDING VIDEOS:
How One Of The Last Dye Houses In Egypt Keeps Ancient Hand Dyeing Alive | Still Standing
• How One Of The Last Dy...
Meet The Last Family Keeping The 400-Year-Old Rogan Art Alive | Still Standing
• Meet The Last Family K...
How Phyllo Is Handmade By One Of Greece's Last Pastry Masters | Still Standing
• How Phyllo Is Handmade...
------------------------------------------------------
#Panama #HatWeaving #BusinessInsider
Business Insider tells you all you need to know about business, finance, tech, retail, and more.
Visit us at: www.businessinsider.com
Subscribe: / businessinsider
BI on Facebook: read.bi/2xOcEcj
BI on Instagram: read.bi/2Q2D29T
BI on Twitter: read.bi/2xCnzGF
BI on Amazon Prime: read.bi/PrimeVideo
Why Authentic Panama Hat Weavers Are Abandoning The Craft | Still Standing | Still Standing
The key to preserving the craft isn't making teenagers connect to it more. The key is paying the artisans more, that's literally all there is to it.
❤
I totally agree!
Pay your workers!
True. If I make a trip to Ecuador I'll be happy to pay good prices for several hats to bring back. These are amazing craftsmen.
You going to pay them?
I feel sad when i see this series, so many underrated arts are gettin lost
Any idea how to purchase these hats?
I got one not long ago at zinglife.co. Beautifully crafted hats.
@Business Insider no
@@xavierpozo286 Thank You sooo much Xavier!!! Much Love!
@@mastersplinter5966 I recommend these three stores, they have reasonable prices, they sell Panama hats woven in Montecristi, which are superior to the Cuenca.
I have bought hats in these stores so I recommend them, they have good prices, the quality is the same, it depends if you want a leather or cotton sweatband.
www.panamahatsdirect.com/ has the highest prices but they are still reasonable.
www.panamahatcollection.com/ send the orders faster, the prices are similar to the previous page, a little lower compared to the first option.
www.viatoremspirit.store/en/ has best prices than the previous ones, they are a little more handmade. Here I bought my last hat.
Before getting younger people interested, weavers now should get a larger cut of the product.
Yeah, nobody it's going to want a job paying $5 a day unless you're not able to find something else to do
its idiotic, if you cant improve quality of your product or quantity produced, you should go bankrupt as others do,
if its not profitable JUST LEAVE IT for somebody who can make it profitably
@Business Insider hhashashah crypto is overpriced bullcrap, you donkey, waterfall is coming
@@trader2137 You are ignoring the fact that the amount the weavers make per hat is fixed, while the amount the hat is sold increases each year. Why does only the latter make sense? The store selling the hat has bills that increase each year, but so do the weavers. Which means that if the hat is increasing the price, the store is getting a higher margin of profit and that isn't passed on to the other members of the chain of production. That is idiotic.
@@LuizFelipe-lk1hs they are the producers, so they set the prices at which they sell, if they agree to sell for 5$ then the worth of it
I like how the retailer, who's probably selling these hats for $50+ to tourists while buying them for $15 from the Weavers Association, isn't saying that there's an issue with the payment structure for the Weavers who are the most necessary part of the supply chain, but instead that they need to get the younger generation involved.
All so he can keep his fancy store running while he's selling the product at 300% - 1,000% markup, without a care that the Weavers are probably getting 1/10th if not less of the retail value for creating the product he's built his business on.
You do realize the seller will not 100% sell the product so to make it worth, they had to charge 3x more than how much they paid for it. The seller is on bad spot just as the makers.
300% is a fairly reasonable markup. Clothing is an odd industry where markup can go up to 100%, which is about 3 times the original wholesale price. You just don't make enough profit margins usually with anything less.
@@apdroidgeek1737 That may be true, but their point wasn't that he should make less. It was that he doesn't seem to care that the weavers who give him a livelihood are being paid less, and instead of saying pay them more, he's saying just get more weavers to replace the lost ones.
The weavers should hire someone to finish the hats, and then sell these by themselves instead of selling to importers
@@apdroidgeek1737 if he does not sell he's losing 5 per hat, which is easily covered. If he's worried about not selling, all he needs to do is order less. Hats don't go bad, so this rule you speak of do not apply at all.
They deserve to be paid more
#MugUpWithUs
Mug Up - Một dự án của Manulife vùng Đại Việt
𝐘𝐨𝐮𝐭𝐮𝐛𝐞: ruclips.net/channel/UCxAcMxcV_UGuV3FkOTGVsXg
𝐅𝐚𝐜𝐞𝐛𝐨𝐨𝐤:
facebook.com/MugUpwithUs
𝐆𝐫𝐨𝐮𝐩 𝐂𝐨̣̂𝐧𝐠 Đ𝐨̂̀𝐧𝐠 𝐊𝐡𝐨̛̉𝐢 𝐍𝐠𝐡𝐢𝐞̣̂𝐩 𝐕𝐢𝐞̣̂𝐭 𝐍𝐚𝐦: facebook.com/groups/940256603123570
𝐆𝐫𝐨𝐮𝐩 𝐎̛̉ đ𝐚̂𝐲 𝐜𝐨́ 𝐁𝐮𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐬 𝐌𝐞𝐦𝐞𝐬:
facebook.com/groups/2844191305810538
Hãy cùng theo dõi kênh Mug Up để cập nhật tin tức mới nhất về kinh doanh và khởi nghiệp bạn nhé!
Well, sure they do, but unless someone farther up the chain is making an unreasonable killing there isn’t money too.
They deserve to be paid whatever they will accept. The fundamental business concept known as the law of supply and demand also applies to labor.
@Annette Charles Apparently you don't understand the business concept known as the law of supply and demand. The weavers will get paid more when they refuse to work for the amount of money they are now getting paid.
@@LucidDreamer54321 Self advocacy and being your own agent. It’s hard, but they are adults. 🤷🏻♂️
Designer brands would advertise this as hand crafted an bump up the price for crazy amount of $$$
That's the smart thing to do
Don't listen to them, they are a fake account
@@weysorprendio yeah I know already report them 👍
And people will blindly buy it
A lot of designer brands take these kinds of things and sell them at high prices but then pay the workers miserably.
I'm here at Ecuador and even though I'm from the coast I can recognize that the problem of those artisans is that they earn way less money than the middleman, so the solution is not to get more young people engaged in the tradition. Today's youth refuse to live with a daily $5 payout (if they sell a hat), and we should consider that this amount of money is not even enough to buy your three daily meals.
Also, most of the weavers are old people living in a country where even young ones struggle to find a job that offers the minimum wage of $400, that's why they don't look for other jobs (cause they lack education to work in any other occupations and won't be hired because of being too old).
So, maybe the last resource of these people is to become their own intermediaries although it could be difficult considering that implies additional expenses.
Honestly I think to make a factory where you can make 100s of hats a day and get paid an actual hourly rate. I bet youth would flock to that seeing as that’s how most countries have become industrial.
@@KRYMauL that's the idea but to start that kind of entrepreneurship some investment is needed. Also they gotta find a way to keep the hand made hats and to avoid a full factory product if the idea is to maintain that special feature.
@@JM51CASTILLO Okay, then go the sweatshop model, and weave each one with the help of machine. This would allow for multiple hats to made in an hour and for better wages. Say what you want about sweatshops because they're better than only being able to make a few a day and not even covering the cost of materials.
@@KRYMauL I agree with that, maybe it is not the best option but is better than their actual way of working. They rather find some kind of sweatshop that boosts the hat production.
@@JM51CASTILLO I say sweatshop because that’s how you industrial people.
I wish that BI would add a link to buy some of these items they talk about. I would definitely buy a hat to support these local craft people.
They didnt gave any links ......😔
I actually am skimming the comments right now to see if anyone else did...huge oversight on BI's part
I am trying to skim around the internet to see, but I don't see an online shop directly from the weavers. The weaving group (as seen at 3:26) is Asociación de Toquilleras San Martin de Puzhio. There are some email addresses floating around for them if anyone wants to reach out to them directly.
They should just pay the weavers more instead of keeping the markup
Shit runs downhill My Man
Ecuador needs make it a heritage export and invest so they could directly sell online b2c. So many designers do “inspired” versions but can never get the authentic version
I am Ecuadorian and I am not a person that is that knowledgeable about the topic but the problem here is first that name, they are internationally know as PANAMA hat and that name is kinda difficult to erase from people's mind, and they are mainly manufactured by indigenous people (adults or elders) so is difficult to talk about technology and online selling as a small producer when you lack the education, money and skills on technology. I agree that the state or the Minister of turism could approach this in a different way but it is what it is sometimes. Also indigenous people get "robbed" because they sell the hats for really cheap prices like 3 dollars a hat, then they are bought by foreigners and sell internationally for over $100. :)
@@ariannaastudillo6569 Panama is easy to say in many languages and has prestige,it’s great marketing ( most people now know the hats are made in Ecuador (if not- time to educate buyers). How long would it take for makers to agree to-stop sales to under-cutters and cheap “backpackers”.
The Panama hat is one of the world’s culturally true luxury products and should be sold with pride. Keep “ young people” out unless they demonstrate determination to respectfully learn, this alone should increase prices.
@@anthonylemkendorf3114 I agree partially to your comment, Is great marketing for Panama i must say. And while I do agree that it takes skill to make, keeping out the younger generations is how a good tradition ends just look at Japan and how such beautiful crafts are dying because they keep out the younger generation. Sometimes is good for change and fresh ideas. Also Ecuador is easy to say in many languages too. Just because a country has "prestige" is ok to let that country take and own a tradition of your country. For me there is no excuse for it to be called Panama hat. Start saying Ecuadorian hat if you truly believe that they are a luxury product and if you respect the country that I am from. This coming from a Ecuadorian
@@ariannaastudillo6569 Te apoyo hermana, la gente de pueblo es muy allegada a sus costumbres, a sus tradiciones y solo la gente joven se habre a las nuevas tecnologías.
Hablemos del nombre, sigue siendo conocido como sombrero de Panamá, los jovenes no saben el enorme patrimonio que tenemos, desconocen nuestra historia y lo nuestro.
Eso sin olvidar el mal que hacen los medios. Por ejemplo, al poner semejante título, debieron poner sombrero ECUATORIANO
Solo queda que las generaciones venideras tomen las riendas, mientras que las viejas le despejan el paso para llevar el nombre de Ecuador a lo alto.
I am from Ecuador, and yes, this is really sad😔
Thanks for sharing a part of our awesome culture!🤍🙏🏻
I hope your artisans can find a way to sell directly to the customer as they should receive so much more for their art.
You know of a way we can help these weavers? If one of them would open a paypal account or something I would gladly send a tip for the hat I just bought.
So maybe if the weavers can't afford to live on $5 from an $80 hat they should get more than $5, seems simple to me. If I knew I couldn't afford to live off a job I wouldn't think it worth doing either
The video said that people are leaving this practice and getting a new job but obviously you cant just find a new job, not everyone have the skills or money to afford education to get a proper job.
that's the issue they aren't getting "Paid" they are selling them to companies to sell them again china has this their factories that make shirts for multiple brands each shirt might be sold for 1 dollar to the company then the company will put their logo on it and sell it to a stores which will then sell it to you and each time it sold to someone the price/ value of the shirt increases their knockoffs that come form the same factory but cheaper because they cut out the middle man. the truth is they should start selling them online directly to the consumer
I live in Guayaquil, Ecuador currently and now me and my family are planing a road trip to the mountains to buy hats.
Thank you so much ❤️ These could sell well on Etsy, too...
Am I the only one who is surprised at the difference in design between the ‘unfinished’ and ‘finished’ hats, the finished one straight up looks like something out of Coachella.
the people that work the most get paid the least. if i owned the store i would pay them half the sale price if i could make enough to keep myself afloat
You would be broke
Spoken like a true person who has no idea how business actually works. Lol
@@ffic4life haha, yeah, for many good business is screwing others as hard as they can for every dime they can get
The video says the unfinished hats sell for $14. How generous of you to give them an extra $2 a day lol.
@@johnm91326 it also says the same hat would sell between 80 and 150 in america, thats the numbers i was going by
See this is where i'd love to buy direct from the source. Where i'd buy a hand crafted hat for $50 or $100 if it went back to the artist.
Three months and still no way of finding out how to buy them from these amazing artisans. Shameful
im really sad I didnt buy one of these. I visited ecuador a few weeks ago and saw a bunch of these at the airports and artesanal shops. hoping they're there next time I visit.
those at the airports are made in china..
It wouldn't have mattered, they wouldn't have been paid fairly
Virus ?
Those are fake synthetic s****, you should go to their village and buy from them directly
@@abyssstrider2547 haha yeah that's why I hesitated when I saw them in the airport. sad i didn't buy them from the market though, all the stuff there is locally made.
I truly enjoyed this video. The weavers need to band together to make their wages better. This is a craft that should not be lost. Absolutely beautiful hats
This does not even mention that there are still some hat artisans like my uncle who still use the old way of finishing the hats which is by hand with a mallet and a hand-carved wooden hat mold. He used to make them custom for each customer when I was a child.
All these artisans deserve more attention and better rates for their art and their tradition.
Hey Business Insider - please provide links in your episodes so we can buy directly from the makers themselves.
If Hermès suddenly started selling these hats with funny stamped designs, then each one would cost over $1000
Easiest way for them to continue is to diversify and become the retailers themselves opening chains in other countries and deny sales to big corporation. It'll be harder to get out their name, but appealing to social media would garner sympathy and increase outreach
Beautiful hats, I hope they survive.
The big problem seems to be that they are wholesaling to retailers who add a huge markup to their product. They need to retail on their own, charging appropriate retail prices. Sites like Amazon, Etsy, etc. make this possible, but the transition will be a challenge.
I wish them the very best luck!
Very impressed with the ladies craft
Beautiful hats
It shifted from being a documentary to a straight up AD for switch
I am from Ecuador and it is a great video. Edit: I only saw the first half of this video but the 2nd half is really really sad but it is the truth
These are the only hats I wear all summer. I will buy some!
Truly gifted,beautiful hats,I would love to have one. Thanks so much for sharing this.
It’s heartbreaking to see *so many* time honored traditions and arts being lost, simply because it isn’t as financially lucrative as it used to be/should be.😞
I mean it wont be "lost" but it just own't be common if thier less artist their less supply less supply makes them harder to get and if the demand is higher they can definitely make a living the other issue is the quality it last very long time as a result those that own one already don't feel the need to buy another companies nowdays know this footwear may only last a few years at most I had sneakers last less then 1 year there we will keep coming back to buy new ones to replace the others
So why hasn't the information for the weavers association where you filmed this ?. So we can support these people and not big corporations. Thanks
Time for vocal for local ! For all small and medium enterprises.
Thank you for this video, this is important my Country
She makes a great point. People think these are made by machines but they’re not. That’s the message to drive up their wages/cut.
Great video Thank you
I have an authentic Panama hat, it's one of the best hats I have ever had, really well made.
I reckon the best hats come from Montecristi, Manabí, in Ecuador. Some of the hats coming from Montecristi are called "Sombreros superfinos". Those are the finest of the finest, even water cannot get through them.
Really good looking hats
All it would take is one of their children to take an interest, establish an online presence and it could work out really profitable for them whilst ensuring the continued survival of the craft
Amazing skills
How can we help these women?!? They definitely deserve and need a raise!
If there was an online course where the local weavers would teach this craft, I would take it immediately. That would be a great way to get the weavers extra income and also keep the craft alive. 😊
This is such an awesome idea ❤️ Now calling tech-savvy kids there who can set up a skillshare for them or something..
Wow. Excellent work. May bien trabajo.
These are beautiful
May this video spark interest in the craft. Thank you 🙏🏻
Wow….look at those tiny, perfect stitches…from straw. I am impressed they can do it in a single day.
The weavers should start their own online shop, buy direct from them, leave the middleman/woman out of the chain.
I would like to buy two hats. But I want my money to reach the weavers directly. Where can I do that without me getting scammed?
I wish to know too
You travel and buy it yourself. Best way to do it.
@@joffrecueva5662 Not possible with Covid travel restrictions.
The Key is.... RESPECTING the talent of this beautiful women. RESPECTING ECUADOR... Recognize their Talent, pay them what they deserve. Stop exploiting them.
Compensate them with dignity. Profits are only designed by foreigners who trade for their own benefit , obtain their absurd unrealistic projections that benefit only them, without consideration of the invaluable work of this Millennial Artisans.
I loved watching this video.
I understand this yet again- as humanity approaching the Extinction Level Events .💥🌿
Simple math, if the end sellers want to stay in business, they need to share more profit with the weavers.
Nice video.
Amazing!!!
Yo entiendo que las personas quieran que sus tradiciones perduren
Pero muchas veces no puede ser así
Es triste pero es un proceso necesario las cosas siempre tienen un fin
Porque las civilizaciones siempre van cambiando
Y las tradiciones pasan a ser parte de los libros de historia y nada mas
This was wonderful! I wish an elder would teach me how to do this.
Wonderful story very nice hats. But sad there struggle. Alot of us anymore it seems.
I would pay for an art that I can wear than a art that is just a banana on a tape on a canvas.
Where can i buy these hats
@@mastersplinter5966 I got mine at zinglife.co recently. Superb quality and finish.
@@xavierpozo286
@@mastersplinter5966 thank you. Likewise!
Great video, where are the links to help out?
Damn those hats are beautiful
I hope to get one, one day. Believe it!
Hard work. Surviving 🤠
#MugUpWithUs
Mug Up - Một dự án của Manulife vùng Đại Việt
𝐘𝐨𝐮𝐭𝐮𝐛𝐞: ruclips.net/channel/UCxAcMxcV_UGuV3FkOTGVsXg
𝐅𝐚𝐜𝐞𝐛𝐨𝐨𝐤:
facebook.com/MugUpwithUs
𝐆𝐫𝐨𝐮𝐩 𝐂𝐨̣̂𝐧𝐠 Đ𝐨̂̀𝐧𝐠 𝐊𝐡𝐨̛̉𝐢 𝐍𝐠𝐡𝐢𝐞̣̂𝐩 𝐕𝐢𝐞̣̂𝐭 𝐍𝐚𝐦: facebook.com/groups/940256603123570
𝐆𝐫𝐨𝐮𝐩 𝐎̛̉ đ𝐚̂𝐲 𝐜𝐨́ 𝐁𝐮𝐬𝐢𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐬 𝐌𝐞𝐦𝐞𝐬:
facebook.com/groups/2844191305810538
Hãy cùng theo dõi kênh Mug Up để cập nhật tin tức mới nhất về kinh doanh và khởi nghiệp bạn nhé!
Beautiful crafting :'0
Where’s the link to a company website so I can directly buy a hat it would help there business also it would help me during summer time
They need to have control of the whole process including sales and export....🤫
From the $5 they earn per hat, to the $80 that each one is sold in the US, there is a 160% profit margin.
Their product has a large demand.
So, the problem is in the implementation of the business model.
Someone needs to teach these weavers to set up their own online business and sell their stock directly to the developed world.
I'd love to buy the hats directly from the weavers!! Seriously, let me pay however much it costs in the US directly to the weavers! Cut out the middlemen!
Someone needs to go over there and set up a direct to consumer website to keep the guys afloat and let them thrive and then come back here and send us all the link
wow, I had no idea they were handmade!!!
How can we buy the hats directly from them. Sweet grass baskets in Charleston SC the weavers and artisans got together and they weave and sell their arts.
I just ordered one on etsy, hopefully i helped.
They should not only pay the artisans more, but I think we should all buy more hats, like look how hot the sun is, I think I’d be even better if we all bought hats
É verdade os jovens não querem seguir a tradição aqui no Brasil é do mesmo jeito são poucas pessoas que ainda fazem chapéu de palha, eu amor fazer 😍
Pls ship to india we love those hats😍
This series is so important. Those high skilled workers are underpaid and overwork
Dam I would buy 100 of those hats if I could
I don't wear hats, but I would buy a bag made like this!
skilled and hardworking craft of Panama, has been a popular fashion wear.
They're not from Panamá, they're from Ecuador!
Correct, there is a bit of history behind the name. Funny enough the history is explained here. zinglife.co/the-panama-hats-origin-and-the-oxymorons-of-history/
@@xavierpozo286 The article is quite interesting, although it doesn't mention some other interesting facts like it was an Ecuadorian who taught Colombians how to make hats using reverse engineering
@@felipeary wasn’t aware of this
Do y'all have a link so we could buy directly from them? I would definitely buy directly from them, but I don't know how.
If you want to help these people, put a link on here to a website so we can order directly!
when you go on vacation you should personally go to crafters and give em some extra to show we appreciate you!!!
Sir, it's not about values it's about appropriate compensation!
Beautiful and very sad -
Is there an online website to buy one?
Save This Art !!!!#
It'd be cool if places like @NOVICA could help them reach a larger customer base, so they could keep the tradition alive
Please add a link of the store
Do they have an Etsy store because I’d cop these?
They need to sell directly because they deserve every cent of profit.
Someone tech-savvy living in that town could open an etsy shop for all of them to earn for their daily living ❤️
I found this information very interesting 🤔. I always wanted a hat like this, I think I will try to get one in the future. 😌
They could make a start up and take over the market. That younger man who owns the museum and sells the hats could get funding for a Startup especially appealing to sustainability, artisans, organic products, hand made in the country of origin. I know ppl who would Easily pay 80$ to 180$ for a good quality hat. They should also pair up with wardrobe boxes and produce a spring hat for each year that is exclusive to a subscription. Shoot maybe I'll get in touch with them. The artisans could easily get 30% of each sale. That would DEFINITELY appeal to more ppl. They could also pair up with other Artists and do collab pieces. Send hats to influencers with backstory and there goes our Branding and Advertising.
Where is the link to purchase one
Don't let this become a lost art... This needs to be preserved, it is a culture. Truly saddened by this. 😞
They're are original from Ecuador, but other Latino American countries like neighboring Colombia make them as well. Aguadas, Caldas is a town that lives from El Sombrero de Toquilla; El Sombrero de Hiraca.
It should cost over $ 100 at least,
For quality and the time of work.
Gosh there are so many in recognized businesses that need to be recognized, and they need their time to shine.
$100 for the community
Seeing what I paid for one in Spain (supposedly woven in Ecuador), I'm sure they could receive way more than 5€.
We should really pay people more, directly.
Middlemen are making money without breaking any sweat. These weaver unions should sell directly to the retailer.
Expensive in the stores - F. A. for the makers. Should be able to buy direct.