Top 10 Palms that will survive without winter protection
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- Top 10 Palms that will survive a normal winter without protection, based on my own experience! Thats why some hardy Trachy species, like takil and manipur, are not in this top 10. They have proven not to be hardy enough in my garden. After many spear pulls I've stopped trying...
Music:
Eastminster van Kevin MacLeod is gelicentieerd onder een Creative Commons Attribution-licentie (creativecommon...)
Bron: incompetech.com...
Artiest: incompetech.com/
Hey Tropical Gardening I am in USA North Carolina,, zone 7.. I am in the process of having a new variety of Sabal Palmetto officially categorized by the NC State school of horticulture.. this palm is growing completely in the wild.. if you want to give a shot.. let me know i have about 2k seeds ready now
The hardiest ones are actually Sabal minor and Rhapidophyllum hystrix. But I would recommend Sabal minor in a wet climate and Rhapidophyllum hystrix in a dry climate because it tends to get spear pull if it gets too much water in the crown. Also, Sabal minor likes the wet environment.
Sabal palmettos should also be on here, there really cold hardy and look really good, there really popular in Virginia Beach, north and South Carolina, Georgia and Florida
Beautiful palms, but they are really on the edge in a northern European climate. Maybe it's possible in a good micro climate...
They are iffy in Virginia Beach even, the ones they have don’t look too good when I’ve seen them.
They are really best suited for the Deep South, we have them in South Alabama and they can handle this cold easily with no winter burn. South Carolina, Georgia and of course Florida they are really common
no they should not be on here bud
You need to try the Needle Palm from the U.S.Its the most hardiest palm in the world.
I have 1 in the garden for years now, strong palm! Even transplanting to the new garden wasn't a problem.
Good list of palms
Goede video! Ik heb met succes de naaldpalm (Rhapidophyllum Hystrix) gedurende 15 jaar gekweekt, met wintertemperaturen onder -30 ° C, in Cincinnati, Ohio, VS.
I have one Trachycarpus Fortunei palm in the yard and a few more in pots. In a month I will plant them in the yard. I can not wait. 😀❤
Cheers!
Great! Good luck with the palms
Thanks!
Cheers! 🙋🏻♂️
I really feel sorry for you people in the north that have to cold protect your tropicals to keep them from dyeing.I live near the Sahara so I have to heat protect most my plants in the summer!
haha, that's the opposite! You don't have to feel sorry, I love the challenge of keeping them alive and having a unique garden. ;)
Tropical Gardening :)
These are great palms to grow!
Finally, i can have a palm tree in my yard in WI!
hey mate...where do you purchase ur cold hardy palms that can handle the UK winter?
I'm not living in the UK, in the Netherlands we have some good webshops and nurseries for hardy palms like "garden palms"and "brabant palm"
I have a Trachy Fortunei now. I want a TRachy "nanus' also, maybe a few others. I am in zone 6a hardiness zone, BUT, I have a greenhouse for them to be in winter. They will have to be potted though. Maybe once they get REALLY big I can protect them while they are planted in the ground. I MUST say that this video says that the Sabal Minor is NOT super hardy that cold winds will damage the foliage and it grows slow so damage will be around fora good while, now, I have always heard that it is the HARDIEST palm you can get. The Sabal Minor AND the Trachy Fortunei.
It depends on the type of winter. Here we have a very wet and windy weather type and that's not good for a Sabal. Trachycarpus and Rhapidophyllum hystrix are better palms for this type of weather.
It depends where it is supposed to survive winter without protection. Here in Czechia it is very edgy. It can happen when somebody live in warmest parts of the country that most of them survive few winters without any protection and then one winter will come with few days of more severe frost and kill not only the leaves but whole plant. But if you live here higher around 500 metres or even higher above sea level it is impossible without heating cables.
True, this is for the Netherlands, we have slightly milder winters I think
Thanks for this video, I have 3 palms in my garden now (A Trachycarpus Fortueni, Cordyline Australis Red Star and a Phoenix Canariensis) and 100% going to get a Trachycarpus Wagnerianus thanks to you
Thanks, great to hear that! It are beautiful palms!
I bought a Trachycarpus Wagnerius on eBay this summer from a grower in Alabama and I love it. It is a beautiful palm! The fronds are a lot shorter than a Fortunei and stay upright. It is very wind resistant.
No Trachycarpus Takil? I keep reading it's the hardiest windmill.
Yes indeed, but this list from 2018 was based on my own experience. I was struggling with my Takils (very slow and much frost damage), maybe this weren't real Takils...? I don't know. In my new garden I have a real Takil and it's doing fine. But it didn't had a real winter. So I'm very curious if I should make a new top 10 😉
Great channel; do any of these grow edible dates,
Thanks! Jubaea has got edible fruit. But I never saw one with fruit in colder areas.
Thank you....dank u wel.
I just bought a Waggie (Trachy wag) for $7.58 on Ebay, BUT, it is a small baby one. That includes shipping.
Oh, nice! I got 114 pindos for 1911.00
@@QarsherskiyExotics I am NOT sure how hardy a "Pindo": is. My GH has gotten over 100F here, and my baby "waggie" seems to have been "cooked" to death. I kept it watered too. :( My plain old "TRachy" is fine still though. The baby "Waggie" COULD still be okay, BUT, it REALLY looks bad. It had NO freezing tempos at all, I kept the temps above 35F the whole winter, BUT, as soon as the sun comes out, my greenhouse gets over 100F in there. The vent will NOT open up, so, I CAN open the door and put on the ceiling fan and it will cool off, BUT, sometimes I can NOT get there to open it up soon enough before the temps skyrocket. It has NO ceiling vent, just a vent at the back of it that will NOT open up.
I have a Sago palm that fared well too, I know, it is NOT a REAL palm though.
Besides the Trachy and the Sago, I have an Olive tree, and a Oleander that I have overwintered fine over the past winter. Okay, later.
@@juliegogola4647 now that is very interesting. Please tell me more about all of this.
@@QarsherskiyExotics Hi again, well, the GH gets like hell in there when the sun comes out. It has no working vent, so the heat just stay inside until I come out and manually open the door window and turn on a fan in there. Sometimes I don;t get to it until it gets horribly hot inside. I can keep the GH above freezing in winter with a heater and a "thermo-cube" that turns the heater on when the temps go below 35F inside.
My Waggie has died :( after I had repotted it, it had croaked, the heat may have stressed it too much plus the repotting. My Oleander has some branches that are looking cooked.
1 of my 2 Olive trees has croaked too, BUT, I had also repotted BOTH Olive trees and 1 lived and is now looking cooked. I really want to bring everything out of the greenhouse for the season but we are still due for some nights in the 30's F.
BTW, I live in the USA in zone 6a hardiness zone Pa.
Plants have lived through the worst of winter, only to get baked in my greenhouse in spring.
My greenhouse was an Amish built prefabricated greenhouse. It was already built and then delivered to my property.
I can only think that maybe if I were to use some shade fabric on the roof, it would help with the heating up, BUT, that would mean less sun rays for my plants too.
I haven't tossed out the Waggie yet, BUT, the base is all deformed, so, it is looking pretty dead to me. Maybe you can't help with the problem, BUT, what do you think about the shadecloth on part (at least part) of the roof? That is IF I can even get it up there, and get it to stay up there.
@@juliegogola4647 have you tried leaving the door open during the day and closing it at night and getting up early to open it? If I were you, I would even consider leaving it open day and night considering that it will likely get above 40 during the day. All of your plants should be able to handle a short 10a cold snap, right? I have a friend who has a majesty palm in zone 8B and it had significant damage but survived the winter with no protection regardless.
Survive the winter in zone 6 planted in the ground with no protection ?
Yes, in the Netherlands
Trying a Washington hybrid fillefera from seed supposed to be cold hardy to 6
In zone 6 they need winter protection. When damaged they will recover fast
Needle palm is the hardiest zone 6
Amazing channel! I susbcribing to ya.
Butia capitata?
Beautiful one, but not that hardy in the Netherlands
After some consideration I want a Trachy Wagnerianus NOT the "nanus". I already have a Trachy Fortunei potted in my greenhouse. I am just not sure where to get one at.
Wagnerianus grow very well in a pot. Good luck with it! Nanus is more rare and expensive, but very winterhardy!
@@TropicalGardening Thank you for your reply, I am keeping my 2 Trachys in my heated Greenhouse until they get a good bit of size to them, after that, I will try and make a heated shelter over them in winter after I plant them into the ground,. I have seen a video on RUclips of how a guy about 50-70 miles from me has kept his palms in winter in shelters with heat added successfully for several years, it is under "Growing palms in Avella, Pa" or something similar to that. He makes wire shelters covered with several layers of covering and adds "incandescent" bulbs for some heat. I will likely keep mine in my GH for several years before doing that. That guy has been having success for at LEAST 4 years most likely 6 years, I am just worried IF the power goes out, that COULD happen in my Greenhouse too though. Later. :)
What zone are you in? I’m in 6a
Somewhere between 8a and 8b
What about Butia Odorata.?
Are Jubae hardy? What is a sheltered place?
They are the quite hardy when settled. A sheltered spot: no wind and against a south faced wall for example 😉
Amazon palms?
Would these palms do well in Baltimore?
I think so!
The Needle Palm should for sure. The Trachycarpus Fortunei or Wagnerianus might do well in a protected spot.
Nice
Ik mis de butia capitata in deze rij
Die staat op plek 12 zoiets ;) Was in onze tuin niet echt winterhard zonder bescherming. Een gesettelde Jubaea of butia eriospatha zijn net wat beter bestand tegen onze natte winters. Maar wel een prachtige palm!
They all look alike, ha
No they don’t 😂
ik habben die last drie palms
How cold does the Netherlands get?
It doens't get to cold. Here in the south we have a few nights of -8 / -10℃. But the winters are wet and windy. That's the real challenge.
Tropical Gardening yeah, in the American south we get down to about 10F, or roughly -23C. Sorry, not very good with my conversions yet.
@@kool1dence162 That's pretty cold!
10 F is about -12 C. -23 C are about our lows here in S. Ontario🇨🇦 With ingenious methods of winter protection we are growing Trachycarpus fortuneii in Southern Ontario's mildest areas. On our west coast I have seen them to 10 meters. I love the look on people's face when they hear we grow palms in Canada.🤣😂
Hallo i live near Boarder between Neatherlands and Germany and i have in my Garden Fortunei Palm and Chamerops Humilis and Chamerops Humilis Cerifea and all my Palms have all 4 Winters surrive without Protect. For this Palms is this no Problem and the coldest Night this Winter was only -3.5 C° We have in this Zone very mild.
👍