Points that i have observed over many articles are that figures that cast shadows or 3d objects are haram, but 2d paper drawings are not, secondly the intention of making should not be of worship or in a way to nauzubillah competeing with Allah. Drawings should not depict nudity or inappropriate elements. A drawing should not be exhalted to a status that is glorified
but theres a hadith that Prophet Muhammad SAWS destroyed a picture on a curtain. it was 2d. secondly only shirk aint the main reason why pics r haram. its also haram cuz ur imitating Allah by creating stuff@@myth6142
I have been looking for a lengthy and comprehensive overview on this subject, and more so recently. Alhamdullillah, Allah (S.W.T.) had answered my prayer. May Allah (S.W.T.) shower His Mercy and Blessings upon Sh Dr. Yasir Qadhi, and all of us who are sincere in worshiping our Lord; Ameen.
@@srali7609 I would recommend you go back through the video and review the conclusion Yasir Qadhi came with. May Allah bestow upon you His blessings. Ameen.
I've been drawing since I was a kid and I recently found out about this and its very distressing. when he said some people are naturally inclined to drawing that struck a cord with me. I use drawing and painting as an emotional outlet and mountains and trees dont express my emotions the same way an animal or a person does. I've been trying to stop drawing people but its like an addiction, its so difficult. I become sad and irritated because the way I vent or express myself has been taken away from me. I dont know what to do. this feels like a punishment. my intention is NEVER shirk when I draw but I dont want to go to hell... I dont know.
While the Imam's perspective is that it's not allowed, he actually brought up the fact that there's no consensus on the matter since one of the four schools of thought felt that, based on all the Hadith he narrated, even the one you just mentioned, it's not a sin to draw pictures, it's just crafting actual solid images of living things which is forbidden. (Kid's toys are A-OK, it should go without saying. From what I know, digital sculpting in 3D/CGI is the same as flat art since it's all data at the end of the day. Still, you may notice my profile pic is from Shaun the Sheep, and I can only wonder what's the Islamic perspective on that...) Yasir Qadhi mentions that we often hear one perspective online, so I appreciate him for teaching us about the early Muslims' owning and permitting pictures when we're often warned about them. Since this is qualified scholarship, knowing this now was a great relief for me, and I hope you feel the same. In any case, Allah knows best. I hope Allah forgives and accepts us all. (I think my comments kept deleting for spam because I included a link to Egypt's Dar al Ifta on the permissibility of drawing pictures as we're the opinions of some of the early Muslim authorities. It's brief but you can look at that too. Sorry if you're seeing this multiple times.)
I have been having thew same , issue , I animate cartoon characters and draw them , i am also earning some from that , but when I came to know that it is haram and there is big punishment , I am thinking to just draw non living stuff ,as though I cant totally leave it ,I love drawing , that is my only skill
You must develop your talent. This is what kept us backward ..... . Once our mulla made, coffee, Radio, Tv HARAAM Thus keeping us behind in science and technology
@@HH-ep3dg What I've been told by my scholar is that drawing eyes and nose are haram, but I also hear only eyes, the entire face, art in general, it's so weird. I've been told to listen to what my scholar says though.
I feel the same too, its so stressing, i cant choose what to do right now. i've also drawing since i was a kid, so i understand you so well. I found out drawing is wrong, some scolars tells different but my heart is not feels right when i draw anymore. I feel like I'm turning my back on islam astaghfurullah. I dont know if it's the shaytans delusion, because I was wanting to draw more educational cartoons about Islam. My Allah helps us, and all muslims inshallah
Maa shaa Allah, this is more than a summary yaa Sheikh, you are indeed a blessing to this ummah, May Allah bless, reward you and your unborn generations for this great efforts.
This lecture cleared a lot of doubt that the other Ustadh didn’t give much clearance over the years. Alhamdulillah. So glad and thankful that we got DR YQ around us. So much of clearer knowledge without biases. Thank you Ustadh👍👍👍
@@ebrahimadan3630 It is not about going against Ustadh. It is about presenting the correct sources of information without sugar coating. Not bending the rules and applying the Quran in our life to become timesless possession, with proper understanding in the light of fast changing world, without altering any bit of it. Sheikh and imams write opinion and understanding of their time. He is our sheikh of this time. 🙏👍
Masha Allah. Smashed it. I've been really looking for a detailed discussion on this and your video has been the only one that has provided it. May Allah reward you immensely for working hard to bring clarity to the ummah
Jazakallah khair for the invaluable information . Subhanallah there is so much coherence in all your answers. May Allah make it heavy on your scales and make you and your family among those who enter Jannah without questioning- ameen
A very comprehensive lecture What impressed me the most is the beginning where the reference to Surat Saba hints at the “tamsal “ So rest of the lecture was entirely based on Hadees Which means that the Quran does not explicitly forbid all this Secondly some of the reasons of hatred for icons is because they had to be eradicated because they were worshipped at that time instead of worshiping one Allah Very understandable Islam was not for that time period It is there for the rest of human existence on earth So with the changing environment we need to adjust with it Obviously keeping the basic major principles of our deen absolutely strong In today’s world images cannot be avoided I so much like what he said at the end to avoid bad images which are so easily available these days So an image or a sculpture which is not used as an object of worship should not shake our deen Subhan Allah our deen has many many more salient features which give us strength and guide us through our journey in life May we Adher to them and stay at the right path Ameen
If drawing faces is haram then photographing a face must be and this video is included. It's hypocrisy to say otherwise. Some people worship the photos of pop stars and sports people so why condemn sketches of faces and not photos?
@@eatingeatingeating photography and drawing isn’t same thing. Photograpghy is basically capturing the light of what Allah (swt) is created. And in photography we don't change creation of Allah. But drawing is imitating creation of Allah. Those two are really different.
Alhamdulillah I have been looking for a source that covers this topic in a lot more detail. Thank you so much brother for clarifying this controversial topic.
Shukran for this very explicit and comprehensive lecture. May Allah increase you in wisdom and guidance for the service of the deen. Jazaakallaahu khaeran.
Jazakallahu khayr. May Allahu subhanu wa taala blessed you shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi, your family and the EPIC family. The ummah benefitted much from you.
Ma sha Allah. A beautiful ending there and lesson for us all. Stop taking a magnifying glass to the small things rather step back and look at the bigger picture.. no pun intended. May Allah guide us all . Ameen. Wa alaykumu salaam wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakaatuhu Sheikh.
Alhamdulillah listening a lecture like this opens the eyes to understand the best.I ponder on this topic because I hv to answer n guide my 10 yr who is much interested in drawing images of birds ,animals n humans and even had already drawn some beautiful birds .I feel even owing a picture which is not permissible to draw is not good as it may encourage the one who is drawing and lead us indirectly to a major sin.May Allah Guide us to choose what is right n help us to be on straight path because real life is ahead.
I agree with Ibn Hibane 100% on the famous Hadith about angels not entering a house when pictures are displayed, to apply specifically to the house of our beloved Prophet PBUH. When was the last time ANY one of us had a knock on the door from Jebreel alaihi salam?
Its true,our desires want to Make it halal,but as mentioned in alot of Hadiths,This issue is serious let's just ,never draw any any animate being again,and rather do something else maybe something similar but halal,So that we will be safe InshAllah,May Allah guide us and give us Sabr,we can't risk our hereafter for a small portion of this temporary world
@blehboop357 You're right,I think my desires are trying to find a way to make it halal but It's Haram as mentioned in alot of Hadiths...May Allah give Sabr to us ,I am earning too by this profession I always loved it but small portion of this world doesn't worth to risk our hereafter,I have thought to leave it and this time to not to do it ever again and instead do something similar but halal like inanimate things or video editing i love that too,plz Pray for me May Allah give Sabr to me and others who are in same condition,Its really hard,I always felt guilty for it that I am doing a big sin ,and finding an excuse to do it ,But no more InshAllah
I am finding these discourses of extreme help in understanding Islam. I come from a Christian background and spent my adolescence reading and researching other beliefs. Coming from Leicester (UK) my childhood was spent surrounded by various cultures which I found fascinating. I turned away from the Church due to questioning the doctrines and not being comfortable with the responses. Then in my mid twenties I discovered The Baha’i Faith and my soul rejoiced. I am 65 now and delving more deeply into varying Belief systems as I see they all lead to one Truth. My personal understanding is that all beliefs are steps in a journey towards one’s own Soul and towards God.
This lecture with all its solid facts and figures compiled still makes one fell depressed...how difficults it is to remain on the safe side and not enter in the gray area and how much have v to shred in order to go with the flow...i wonder which branch of our faith will remain unmodified for the future generations and my heart aces.
if you are gonna follow fiqh this way your life will be so difficult. Allah made Islam easy for us. and many hadiths where rasulullah (saw) said the sahaba to make islam easy for others when sending for delegations
If drawing faces is haram then photographing a face must be and this video is included. It's hypocrisy to say otherwise. Some people worship the photos of pop stars and sports people so why condemn sketches of faces and not photos?
I am an artist I make a lot of portraits and my thesis was in the portrait series but I heard about it but I thought I am not disobeying Allah I am just doing what I like and It is a gift from Allah but now I researched about it and I feel very bad that I did it. I completed my graduation in art and it became my profession and I realized now that it is totally forbidden
Dr.Yasir Qazi this lecture was par excellence Masha’Allah and everything was very clearly understandable. JazakAllah Khair. Please do the same and explain in detail about keeping dogs as a pet or guard dog or keeping a dog in a muslim house , is it permissible or not and if yes , what are the conditions and the rulings. This is a topic that needs to be very clear just like having pictures and status in a muslim house . JazakAllah Khair
My question is how you going to own it without making it? Let say, if you buy it, that means you creating a need for it, so that someone can make it! You creating a market for it. It’s like you buy a stolen phone, thieves will continue stealing because there is a market for it. Allah knows the best.
Yeah it literally makes no sense. So buying it and owning it is allowed but making it is haram? what? If your owning/buying it then that means you're supporting haram
@@subihafeez4730 literally makes zero logical sense. You don’t have to be a scholar to see this inconsistency which is why I follow the Maliki position
Jazaaka Allah Khair I have a question so what about making games that involve people and animals in 3d or 2D games can you talk about this please in order to make the game we sometimes buy assets for some of us who are not 3d artists but if someone has artist knowledge he makes this asset using a computer to make both 2d or 3d people or animals.can you explain this please
May Allah give you guidance, save yourself from your nafs, try to draw nature without the living creatures Geometrical designs and flowers are a good choice to express your artistic talent
If drawing faces is haram then photographing a face must be. It's hypocrisy to say otherwise. Some people worship the photos of pop stars and sports people so why condemn sketches of faces and not photos?
Wow, why would something be haram for me when it was not haram for Prophet Salesman? If he had "tamatheel (statues)" made for him to decorate his castle/s, why can't a common man like myself have the same statues prepared for my home? After all, Prophet Sulayman did not "worship" his statues. In other words, Prophet Sulsyman had "tamatheel (statues for decoration, not the "asnaam (staues for worship)" that were worshipped. Note that Prophet Ibraheem did not destroy the "tamatheel" in the mushrik community of the worship place, what he destroyed were the "asnaam". Let's put on a thinking cap and consider the first hadith in Bukhari which says that our actions are dictated by our intentions. That being the case, if I draw a human being or make a statue of him, and my intention is not to worship him (as was the case with Prophet Sulayman), then I do not see any problem at all. I mean the whole issue is very simple: if you make images of any sort to worship them, you are destined fir Hell. But if you are making images for sake or just for a hobby, I see no problem. Now,what would the ulema say about Dolly the sheep? Was that sheep created to worship....or to create proof of concept. Isn't "insaan" the "khaliq" of Dolly the sheep? If you are confused and feel ready to say "astaghfirullah!", the think about Allah Who is "Ahsanul Khaliqeen (the best of creators)". Thus, a man can be a creator of anything, but the "best of creators".
blind following is same as worship in Eslaum. So if you follow these "sheikhs" on TheyTube and TV who tell you images are forbidden then you are not even a Mosslem because it was never forbidden in Eslaum and the Goraun/Koran says prophet Suleiman made statues and Eesa/Jesus was also an artist and made birds out of clay, and we know in Eslaum prophet Mohammad family had images like dolls and animal toys. Jews say that Suleiman/Solomon became a disbeliever/kafer, Jews say Jesus was fake and evil, Jews say Mohammad was fake and evil, the fake Bible forbids making images, its not the Mosslems and Allauh. These sheikhs are YAHUDIS, Kabbalist Jews, monafegeen, posing as moslems just like Saudi kingdom and government of Iran and Erdogan, etc. There are no sheikhs in Eslaum. No rabbis and laymen, no stupid followers without knowledge who must follow the rabbis who have the knowledge supposedly, thats Judaism. Islam with a moon symbol on TV is fake. Wake up and covert to original Eslaum, follow your heart, follow the Goraun and original sonnah which never contradicts the Goraun and fear nothing except to become bad. Real Mosslems are "terrorists", they are not allowed to become popular on the internet, not brought on TV to speak, they are not even allowed to have a mosque. Wake up, man.
1:03:00 Kids drawing in schools 1:04:00 What about images on kids' clothing or adults praying with clothes that have animal images on them (polo horse, lacoste alligator, etc.)?
Is there any way to abrogate this ruling that 'drawing living beings is totally prohibited'? Since in those times, people were addicted to worshipping images and artists tried to replicate living creatures but now it is a totally different matter
Yasir Qadhi must earn more money than any ingeneur or physican. He enriches our Ummah , so we should enrich him. He should have no financial worries and simply concentrate on our islamic issues. His work can not be measured in gold.
Salam wa Jazak Allahu Khair for this discussion. Out of curiosity, who would make the images for the coins such as for the khalifa. Also would drawing of things that do not exist like Pokemon or other fictional creatures fall under the soulless since they do not exist?
I am sorry! but I have to ask this question. Why is it allowed to own a picture like a drawing on a rug or pillow and the owner isn't a sinner while the person who made is going to hell (a cursed being in a way)? Somebody has to make the image for others to own it right. Also, it's pretty much similar to buying things from a thief it's haram, is it not. I think it's unfair! just my opinion. even to embroid a bird on a rug you have to hand draw it first, so... one does sin to survive because others want it and are willing to help them pay for their food. But then the one who enjoys the stained product isn't held accountable. I am sorry if my opinion goes beyond the rulings of Islam.
Because the rub or a pillow is something that will be degraded so it’s not seen as something that can be worshipped. To be honest the same thing can be applied to drawings on a computer and on paper. The prophet only got annoyed by images when they casted a shadow and were reverred as per hadiths by our mother Ayisha (RA) when he tore down a curtain. When he was talking about “the image makers” in the Hadith about “the image maker will be asked to put a soul into it” it is mainly referring to status and 3D imagery (one’s that cast a shadow) according to the Maliki school and some shafi scholars, and not ones that are on a plain surface (to my recollection). This position to me makes the most sense but do your own research. I have for a while and personally came to the conclusion that 2D isn’t haram at all but 3D definitely is
If drawing faces is haram then photographing a face must be and this video is included. It's hypocrisy to say otherwise. Some people worship the photos of pop stars and sports people so why condemn sketches of faces and not photos?
@@eatingeatingeating Exactly! Like whoever invented the camera just found a way to imitate Allahs creation but unfortunately it’s permissible (I didn’t actually mean Unfrotunatley it’s just that something doesn’t make sense)
Hindus says plants have no soul that’s why it’s okay to eat it But it’s bad to eat animal as it has soul And Muslims say plants have feelings too and feel pain too and even worse that plants can’t show pain like animals The tree trunk cried when our beloved Prophet, Peace be upon him, stopped giving sermon next to it. And the Prophet, Peace be upon him, hugged the tree to console it So what did the tree have that made it cry These just talking points i am bringing up Allah Knows Best
i'm a bit gifted at drawing and designing. i've been working at printing office utilizing said gift. then i learn that in islam being an artist pretty much i haraam. usually there logical explanation about islam ruling but i just cant find any in this case (you see, my work usually just designing things like book cover / banner / phamplet. etc) . so uh.. what am i supposed to do? should i contnue this on since i just make a living (no other motivation) or should i 'waste' the gift and do something else for living
I have the same problem watch doctor zakit naiks video on this i think its pretty good. I think allah is testing us to obey his rules even if we dont understand the reasoning behind it. I know how you feel you feel uneasy and feel weird you feel like it doesnt make semse or the reason isnt clear. And you know what it doesnt have ro make sense because we cant understand everything. But still i would at least like to know every situation in which im allowed to draw certain things. Some say for finding criminals is ok but you have to draw to be able to it in the first place. Or that we should avoid drawing faces but what if we study about the human body. Or lets say you just want to be able to draw many things what about that? I feel your pain and i dont understand it so please if anyone knows someone who answers in a way that we are certain in what we draw and that we know its the truth and not false please say something this is a real problem for us. Allah will ask us to put souls into that what we draw we dont want that to happen thats really close to shirk maybe it is so pös answer this is a serious problem
I just saw a video called "drawing is 100% halal & 100% haram" if its true whats being said in this video then we can draw everything and anything as long as we dont do it to pray to it or to let other people pray to itt thats what i understood. If thats correct then it makes sense kind of. I still wonder if it may be haram because we "create" something. If i draw an animal i know it has no life but am i challenging allah? Im still confused but this video helped me clarify it very much
@@smarties5624 i recently ask a friend who happen who learned deeply about islam. he said that most of art (save for ornamental + poetry) actually forbidden with these reasoning : -music : the rule explanation is there hadith that put music in league with alcohol and zina, meaning that it just as bad. the logical explanation, music identic with party and 'fun', which usually in that moment people dont think about allah. he said there misinterpretation that some scholar allow music due long ago prophet muhammad SAW allow a girl to play her rabbana when he moved in to madinna (but that coz the girl was made a nazaar to do so) -drawing : the rule explanation is that allah hate it so much that he at judgment day will punish painter (and sculptor), force em to bring their creation to life (which they couldnt), then allah will turn these creation to life to torture their creator. the logical explanation that long ago artist tend to be arrogant so much creating something make them believe they were god equal or treat their creation as god itself. there also tendency to make a creation based on public figure of their time that due to how influental they were, after their passing that creation were worshipped
@@satyayana1399 thank you for your answer. I have a question about the second part. You said that long ago people were worshipping these paintings and artists were predending to be god. If i dont paint with that intention will it be halal? Because i dont paint and pray to these pictures or think im god. In fact i do the opposite i even try to become loose enough so that i will be able to destroy my pictures because it has no real value and i thank allah for creating these beautiful ideas in my head. If i think like that which i do is it halal? I don't think allah will punish me with hell for painting. Allah is the just god, oftentimes we dont see why something is wrong until later but painting is really difficult. Like you said, back then people prayed to these things but nowadays its not like that and i dont do it with this intention. So is it halal now?
Allah SWT will Grace you with His Blessings for obeying Him and following the advice from His messenger the Prophet Muhammad SAW. I practised Art, painting and some sculpture, exhibitions etc.for many years, a hearfelt passion. After reading the Qura'an I realised my situation and destroyed everything except unused materials which I gave to Charity. It felt good and gave me a feeling of freedom. I have never regretted it! Thank you Allah SWT.
blind following is same as worship in Eslaum. So if you follow these "sheikhs" on TheyTube and TV who tell you images are forbidden then you are not even a Mosslem because it was never forbidden in Eslaum and the Goraun/Koran says prophet Suleiman made statues and Eesa/Jesus was also an artist and made birds out of clay, and we know in Eslaum prophet Mohammad family had images like dolls and animal toys. Jews say that Suleiman/Solomon became a disbeliever/kafer, Jews say Jesus was fake and evil, Jews say Mohammad was fake and evil, the fake Bible forbids making images, its not the Mosslems and Allauh. These sheikhs are YAHUDIS, Kabbalist Jews, monafegeen, posing as moslems just like Saudi kingdom and government of Iran and Erdogan, etc. There are no sheikhs in Eslaum. No rabbis and laymen, no stupid followers without knowledge who must follow the rabbis who have the knowledge supposedly, thats Judaism. Islam with a moon symbol on TV is fake. Wake up and covert to original Eslaum, follow your heart, follow the Goraun and original sonnah which never contradicts the Goraun and fear nothing except to become bad. Real Mosslems are "terrorists", they are not allowed to become popular on the internet, not brought on TV to speak, they are not even allowed to have a mosque. Wake up, man.
My common sense tells me that the difference between owning and making sounds almost hypocritical. I'm sorry but I grew up in the West where toys and collectibles are common, never once did it come to my mind to venerate them. I still have childhood toys because I'm attached to them, but somehow this was fine as a kid but not as an adult even though the feeling is largely the same. If we say that making images is sinful, but owning is not so we are allowed to buy them, that sounds stupid because that means someone else will be punished because we really wanted that cute rug with the bird on it.
blind following is same as worship in Eslaum. So if you follow these "sheikhs" on TheyTube and TV who tell you images are forbidden then you are not even a Mosslem because it was never forbidden in Eslaum and the Goraun/Koran says prophet Suleiman made statues and Eesa/Jesus was also an artist and made birds out of clay, and we know in Eslaum prophet Mohammad family had images like dolls and animal toys. Jews say that Suleiman/Solomon became a disbeliever/kafer, Jews say Jesus was fake and evil, Jews say Mohammad was fake and evil, the fake Bible forbids making images, its not the Mosslems and Allauh. These sheikhs are YAHUDIS, Kabbalist Jews, monafegeen, posing as moslems just like Saudi kingdom and government of Iran and Erdogan, etc. There are no sheikhs in Eslaum. No rabbis and laymen, no stupid followers without knowledge who must follow the rabbis who have the knowledge supposedly, thats Judaism. Islam with a moon symbol on TV is fake. Wake up and covert to original Eslaum, follow your heart, follow the Goraun and original sonnah which never contradicts the Goraun and fear nothing except to become bad. Real Mosslems are "terrorists", they are not allowed to become popular on the internet, not brought on TV to speak, they are not even allowed to have a mosque. Wake up, man.
Asalamu Alaykum Dr. Yasir Qadhi May Allah bless you for providing us with this information. I just have a question. My life is based on many dreams that have already happened. Can I use abstract painting to do the images? It includes horses, people and other non human forms. If I paint an image of a fully dressed person’s back, is that disallowed? Again thank you for your help.
It seems like drawing things that have souls is permissable as long as the drawn animal is missing something vital, meaning you may leave out parts of the face or limbs. This is what I have gathered from this lecture and I can't guarantee that I am not mistaken.
I just need one answer Can i draw animate 2d pictures or not? It is only a side hobby and the artwork sits in one shelf in the corner. I dont worship it, neiter do i frame it on the wall...
May Allah bless you Skeikh, it was very informative. But I feel that one angle was not covered and that is the prohibition made initially by prophet Mohammed pbuh was mainly based on the status quo of his time (meaning the idealotory that he was primarily sent for to destroy) and now that is no longer a threat could we have a more progressive view? Case and point when Muslim entered Egypt, not a single statute was destroyed especially when the Muslim understood that no one is actually worshipping them
Exactly my thought... Plus, if the people that are going to be the most severely punished on the day of judgement are al musawirun, with the meaning of those who (even innocently and with absolutely no ill intent) drew/sculpted living beings, then why isn't there anything clear about it in the Quran? No verse whatsoever? When it is repeated over and over that the only sin that won't be forgiven is shirk and kufr and that will lead to hell for eternity with all the details about their retribution... Why not clearly mention that imitating/replicating the creation is such an enormous sin that it deserves the worse punishments over anything else (and therefor even shirk and kufr???) and so that there would be no question about it and that everyone would be warned?
oh god, now that I'm finding out about this, I stopped drawing people and am aware the intention does not change it, but what about past drawings I made while being unaware they're actually bad? I understand about the fact that on the day of judgement the creators will be asked to bring these to life, I'm not exactly sure how to word this but, since I'm aware of the sin and have let go, is it still, like going to happen on the day of judgment, since I myself have drawn a lot of different people/animals but now I am aware of the sin and will no longer do it anymore and move on to landscape drawings instead
I’m an artist and was wondering if I can draw niqabi women with eyes but no mouth showing? Can this be considered a silhouette? Because you said you can paint a hand and this is okay, I’m wondering thank you. And for educational purposes is it okay if I draw? For example, Diego Rivera used to paint the history of indigenous people because in the Americas we where enslaved and not allowed to read or write so he painted our history, and I too want to paint for educational purposes of history, thank you. 💕
blind following is same as worship in Eslaum. So if you follow these "sheikhs" on TheyTube and TV who tell you images are forbidden then you are not even a Mosslem because it was never forbidden in Eslaum and the Goraun/Koran says prophet Suleiman made statues and Eesa/Jesus was also an artist and made birds out of clay, and we know in Eslaum prophet Mohammad family had images like dolls and animal toys. Jews say that Suleiman/Solomon became a disbeliever/kafer, Jews say Jesus was fake and evil, Jews say Mohammad was fake and evil, the fake Bible forbids making images, its not the Mosslems and Allauh. These sheikhs are YAHUDIS, Kabbalist Jews, monafegeen, posing as moslems just like Saudi kingdom and government of Iran and Erdogan, etc. There are no sheikhs in Eslaum. No rabbis and laymen, no stupid followers without knowledge who must follow the rabbis who have the knowledge supposedly, thats Judaism. Islam with a moon symbol on TV is fake. Wake up and covert to original Eslaum, follow your heart, follow the Goraun and original sonnah which never contradicts the Goraun and fear nothing except to become bad. Real Mosslems are "terrorists", they are not allowed to become popular on the internet, not brought on TV to speak, they are not even allowed to have a mosque. Wake up, man.
One doubt. How can one person own the paintings and drawings on pillow covers or coins without other person is creating. I didn't understand creating is haram but owning is not, but how can one own it when no one creates it
I have the same confusion with you. There will be supplies if there are demands. So owning images can indirectly cause more people to create images. Which can be translated to encouraging to create images.
I think it's not problematic if the muslim didn't create that image so owning it is fine if you're not using it for shirk & Allah knows best It's still confusing considering the sheikh mentioned the umayyad caliph created the coin with his image on it & the sahabah had no issue with that back then
This inconsistency is exactly why I follow the Maliki position on images. The ruling against them makes little logical sense in our current day and age, especially when you consider the prophets Hadith about images were in the time when idolatry was still prevalent. I think the other schools need to revise it with modern context personally.
@@jamrah8713 idolatry is still happening now lol so I understand why the rulings exist & why the prophet (peace be upon him) was concerned over this however I think it's hard to follow & somewhat more confusing when applying this to today you see?
So from my comprehension, drawing 2d digital drawing from imam maliki, is discourage and not sinful..the others state as prohibited.. other view as long it is not for worship and idolatry then its okay.. sculpting is haram cause it casts shadow, In the end of the day it all come from ure heart and intentionss..wallahualam
The hadith about Ibn Abbas in which a image maker came to him. So in those days who was the image maker? Was he the one making images to sell so people could buy and keep it in their houses to worship?
Points that i have observed over many articles are that figures that cast shadows or 3d objects are haram, but 2d paper drawings are not, secondly the intention of making should not be of worship or in a way to nauzubillah competeing with Allah. Drawings should not depict nudity or inappropriate elements. A drawing should not be exhalted to a status that is glorified
I like your point. I am a Muslim myself, and I absolutely agree with this!
yes
So may I draw something for fun?
I am more inclined with imam Maliks view on such things
but theres a hadith that Prophet Muhammad SAWS destroyed a picture on a curtain. it was 2d.
secondly only shirk aint the main reason why pics r haram. its also haram cuz ur imitating Allah by creating stuff@@myth6142
I have been looking for a lengthy and comprehensive overview on this subject, and more so recently. Alhamdullillah, Allah (S.W.T.) had answered my prayer. May Allah (S.W.T.) shower His Mercy and Blessings upon Sh Dr. Yasir Qadhi, and all of us who are sincere in worshiping our Lord; Ameen.
Aameen
Amin
Salam Alikum brother so in your conclusion would continue drawing or have you stopped
@@srali7609 I would recommend you go back through the video and review the conclusion Yasir Qadhi came with. May Allah bestow upon you His blessings. Ameen.
@@NazmusLabs lol i just wanted to know what you had chose thats all
I've been drawing since I was a kid and I recently found out about this and its very distressing. when he said some people are naturally inclined to drawing that struck a cord with me. I use drawing and painting as an emotional outlet and mountains and trees dont express my emotions the same way an animal or a person does. I've been trying to stop drawing people but its like an addiction, its so difficult. I become sad and irritated because the way I vent or express myself has been taken away from me. I dont know what to do. this feels like a punishment. my intention is NEVER shirk when I draw but I dont want to go to hell...
I dont know.
While the Imam's perspective is that it's not allowed, he actually brought up the fact that there's no consensus on the matter since one of the four schools of thought felt that, based on all the Hadith he narrated, even the one you just mentioned, it's not a sin to draw pictures, it's just crafting actual solid images of living things which is forbidden.
(Kid's toys are A-OK, it should go without saying. From what I know, digital sculpting in 3D/CGI is the same as flat art since it's all data at the end of the day. Still, you may notice my profile pic is from Shaun the Sheep, and I can only wonder what's the Islamic perspective on that...)
Yasir Qadhi mentions that we often hear one perspective online, so I appreciate him for teaching us about the early Muslims' owning and permitting pictures when we're often warned about them. Since this is qualified scholarship, knowing this now was a great relief for me, and I hope you feel the same.
In any case, Allah knows best. I hope Allah forgives and accepts us all.
(I think my comments kept deleting for spam because I included a link to Egypt's Dar al Ifta on the permissibility of drawing pictures as we're the opinions of some of the early Muslim authorities. It's brief but you can look at that too. Sorry if you're seeing this multiple times.)
I have been having thew same , issue , I animate cartoon characters and draw them , i am also earning some from that , but when I came to know that it is haram and there is big punishment , I am thinking to just draw non living stuff ,as though I cant totally leave it ,I love drawing , that is my only skill
You must develop your talent. This is what kept us backward .....
. Once our mulla made, coffee, Radio, Tv HARAAM
Thus keeping us behind in science and technology
@@HH-ep3dg What I've been told by my scholar is that drawing eyes and nose are haram, but I also hear only eyes, the entire face, art in general, it's so weird. I've been told to listen to what my scholar says though.
I feel the same too, its so stressing, i cant choose what to do right now. i've also drawing since i was a kid, so i understand you so well. I found out drawing is wrong, some scolars tells different but my heart is not feels right when i draw anymore. I feel like I'm turning my back on islam astaghfurullah. I dont know if it's the shaytans delusion, because I was wanting to draw more educational cartoons about Islam.
My Allah helps us, and all muslims inshallah
Alhamdullillah, I hope to have learned enough to continue my art abiding Islam. May Allah prevent us from arrogance, Ameen
Is it allowed should i listen to imam malik school and make a virtual youtuber channel for Islamic purposes?
I was just recently searching for Dr. Yasir Qadhi's opinion on this issue and could not find it. Eagerly waiting for this video.
Maa shaa Allah, this is more than a summary yaa Sheikh, you are indeed a blessing to this ummah, May Allah bless, reward you and your unborn generations for this great efforts.
Jzk for the clarity. Love that you go through things so clearly and inform us about all the schools of thoughts. Allah reward you and yours.
Jazaakumullah khayran for this comprehensive explanation sir, may Allah reward you abundantly sir.
This is a meticulous and careful presentation on the matter.
This makes absolute sense
Thank you
This lecture cleared a lot of doubt that the other Ustadh didn’t give much clearance over the years. Alhamdulillah. So glad and thankful that we got DR YQ around us. So much of clearer knowledge without biases. Thank you Ustadh👍👍👍
He is the best scholar in 21st century
This ustadh always goes against the previous sheikhs and causes doubts every time.
@@ebrahimadan3630 It is not about going against Ustadh. It is about presenting the correct sources of information without sugar coating. Not bending the rules and applying the Quran in our life to become timesless possession, with proper understanding in the light of fast changing world, without altering any bit of it. Sheikh and imams write opinion and understanding of their time. He is our sheikh of this time. 🙏👍
@@jarasparkles232 sheikh of this time?reformer?
@@sulejamito8968 That's ur opinion
لا إفراط ولا تفريط
May Allah bless you , I love your knowledge and lectures and the way you explain Jazak Allah Khairan
can you translate to me baraka laho fik
I think the Hadith in which every deed is judged by its intention should also be factored into the matter…
Masha Allah. Smashed it. I've been really looking for a detailed discussion on this and your video has been the only one that has provided it. May Allah reward you immensely for working hard to bring clarity to the ummah
Jazakallah khair for the invaluable information . Subhanallah there is so much coherence in all your answers. May Allah make it heavy on your scales and make you and your family among those who enter Jannah without questioning- ameen
A very comprehensive lecture What impressed me the most is the beginning where the reference to Surat Saba hints at the “tamsal “ So rest of the lecture was entirely based on Hadees Which means that the Quran does not explicitly forbid all this Secondly some of the reasons of hatred for icons is because they had to be eradicated because they were worshipped at that time instead of worshiping one Allah Very understandable Islam was not for that time period It is there for the rest of human existence on earth So with the changing environment we need to adjust with it Obviously keeping the basic major principles of our deen absolutely strong In today’s world images cannot be avoided I so much like what he said at the end to avoid bad images which are so easily available these days So an image or a sculpture which is not used as an object of worship should not shake our deen Subhan Allah our deen has many many more salient features which give us strength and guide us through our journey in life May we Adher to them and stay at the right path Ameen
Did he mention about drawingbcartoons being haram
Where are your punctuation marks gone?
If drawing faces is haram then photographing a face must be and this video is included. It's hypocrisy to say otherwise. Some people worship the photos of pop stars and sports people so why condemn sketches of faces and not photos?
You can avoid hanging images/portraits/paintings of animate things in your house. Its not hard.
@@eatingeatingeating photography and drawing isn’t same thing. Photograpghy is basically capturing the light of what Allah (swt) is created. And in photography we don't change creation of Allah. But drawing is imitating creation of Allah. Those two are really different.
Alhamdulillah I have been looking for a source that covers this topic in a lot more detail. Thank you so much brother for clarifying this controversial topic.
thank you so much for this I've been looking for a detailed discussion of this!
Shukran for this very explicit and comprehensive lecture. May Allah increase you in wisdom and guidance for the service of the deen. Jazaakallaahu khaeran.
Jazakallahu khayr. May Allahu subhanu wa taala blessed you shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi, your family and the EPIC family. The ummah benefitted much from you.
Ma sha Allah. A beautiful ending there and lesson for us all.
Stop taking a magnifying glass to the small things rather step back and look at the bigger picture.. no pun intended. May Allah guide us all .
Ameen.
Wa alaykumu salaam wa Rahmatullahi wa Barakaatuhu Sheikh.
Alhamdulillah listening a lecture like this opens the eyes to understand the best.I ponder on this topic because I hv to answer n guide my 10 yr who is much interested in drawing images of birds ,animals n humans and even had already drawn some beautiful birds .I feel even owing a picture which is not permissible to draw is not good as it may encourage the one who is drawing and lead us indirectly to a major sin.May Allah Guide us to choose what is right n help us to be on straight path because real life is ahead.
Jazakallahu Khayran for this lecture Shaykh
Clarity and Amazing points. Jazaakumullah Khayran.
Jazakum Allahu Khairan and Allah give you barakah in your knowledge so that you can help us more.
I agree with Ibn Hibane 100% on the famous Hadith about angels not entering a house when pictures are displayed, to apply specifically to the house of our beloved Prophet PBUH. When was the last time ANY one of us had a knock on the door from Jebreel alaihi salam?
I invite everyone to listen the HOLY QURAN.
Its true,our desires want to Make it halal,but as mentioned in alot of Hadiths,This issue is serious let's just ,never draw any any animate being again,and rather do something else maybe something similar but halal,So that we will be safe InshAllah,May Allah guide us and give us Sabr,we can't risk our hereafter for a small portion of this temporary world
May Allah forgive us all 😔😢
What about draw cartoon with a mask or glasses (without eyes, nose, lips etc) pls guide me.
@blehboop357 You're right,I think my desires are trying to find a way to make it halal but It's Haram as mentioned in alot of Hadiths...May Allah give Sabr to us ,I am earning too by this profession I always loved it but small portion of this world doesn't worth to risk our hereafter,I have thought to leave it and this time to not to do it ever again and instead do something similar but halal like inanimate things or video editing i love that too,plz Pray for me May Allah give Sabr to me and others who are in same condition,Its really hard,I always felt guilty for it that I am doing a big sin ,and finding an excuse to do it ,But no more InshAllah
@bleh boop Ameen InshAllah :)
Aameen ❣️
JazakAllah khair! This was very useful and helpful. May Allah reward you in both worlds, Aameen!
This is a great lecture Shayk I don't think I need any questions and answers in this matter again. Thanks.
May Allah swt reward you ya habibuna Shaykhuna ♥️
I am finding these discourses of extreme help in understanding Islam. I come from a Christian background and spent my adolescence reading and researching other beliefs. Coming from Leicester (UK) my childhood was spent surrounded by various cultures which I found fascinating.
I turned away from the Church due to questioning the doctrines and not being comfortable with the responses. Then in my mid twenties I discovered The Baha’i Faith and my soul rejoiced. I am 65 now and delving more deeply into varying Belief systems as I see they all lead to one Truth. My personal understanding is that all beliefs are steps in a journey towards one’s own Soul and towards God.
Oh Lord the Baha'i, the most contradictory religion in the world
This was the clearest explanation ever.
I invite everyone to listen beautiful recitation of The Holy Quran
This lecture with all its solid facts and figures compiled still makes one fell depressed...how difficults it is to remain on the safe side and not enter in the gray area and how much have v to shred in order to go with the flow...i wonder which branch of our faith will remain unmodified for the future generations and my heart aces.
if you are gonna follow fiqh this way your life will be so difficult. Allah made Islam easy for us. and many hadiths where rasulullah (saw) said the sahaba to make islam easy for others when sending for delegations
Relax! Have sincere intention and do best with given ability and all mistakes in guidance will be forgiven insha allah.
@Tomato I follow Imam Malik's position though. Makes more sense to me.
If drawing faces is haram then photographing a face must be and this video is included. It's hypocrisy to say otherwise. Some people worship the photos of pop stars and sports people so why condemn sketches of faces and not photos?
@@Pain-jw3uu you won't understand our pain
Time Stamps would help people get through these Q&A.
I am an artist I make a lot of portraits and my thesis was in the portrait series but I heard about it but I thought I am not disobeying Allah I am just doing what I like and It is a gift from Allah but now I researched about it and I feel very bad that I did it. I completed my graduation in art and it became my profession and I realized now that it is totally forbidden
May Allah give patience to you , We can still draw non living things
It's not totally forbidden you just might have to draw other stuff
You can make landscapes ,seascapes , buildings calligraphy and lot more halal things .
Dr.Yasir Qazi this lecture was par excellence Masha’Allah and everything was very clearly understandable. JazakAllah Khair.
Please do the same and explain in detail about keeping dogs as a pet or guard dog or keeping a dog in a muslim house , is it permissible or not and if yes , what are the conditions and the rulings. This is a topic that needs to be very clear just like having pictures and status in a muslim house .
JazakAllah Khair
Great info Masha Allah Sheik I learnt a lot🤲🏼🤲🏼🤲🏼❤️
Thank you Sheikh for clarifications of displaying photos and pictures.
Jazakallah kheer, may Allah bless you and your family 🙏
Thank you very much for this clarification. May Allah reward you
May Allah bless you.. protect you..
MashaAllah
JazakiAllahukhaerian
This explanation was wonderful. Thank you so much for doing it on such depth. May God bless you...
Who is the reciter? Beautiful rendition. In fact, all Quran recitations are beyond beautiful!
I am reading comments now exactly for same reason to find if anyone knows who is the reciter
The reciter is Shaykh Sajjad Gul.
@@fokruddinahmad5118Jazakallahkhair!
My question is how you going to own it without making it? Let say, if you buy it, that means you creating a need for it, so that someone can make it! You creating a market for it.
It’s like you buy a stolen phone, thieves will continue stealing because there is a market for it.
Allah knows the best.
Awesome point
Yeah it literally makes no sense. So buying it and owning it is allowed but making it is haram? what? If your owning/buying it then that means you're supporting haram
@@subihafeez4730 literally makes zero logical sense. You don’t have to be a scholar to see this inconsistency which is why I follow the Maliki position
It's not a fair position where artists are considered doomed whereas non artists, who may own an art, are save?
If we can't draw, so we can't play games as well right? Because the game characters were drawn by artist. In some ways, we are with them.
Jazak Allah Khair. What about animation used for kids Islamic videos??
Eloquent speaker mashallah
Asalaamualakum this is the only comprehensive talk on line on the subject.
barakAllahu feek beloved Sheikh.
Jazaaka Allah Khair I have a question so what about making games that involve people and animals in 3d or 2D games can you talk about this please in order to make the game we sometimes buy assets for some of us who are not 3d artists but if someone has artist knowledge he makes this asset using a computer to make both 2d or 3d people or animals.can you explain this please
I actually highly passionate in sketching/ drawing/ painting a human face or full body both manually and digitally 😢 Astagfirullâh
Some Muslims do this when doing animations but they don't draw the face or they make the animations look obviously inhuman
May Allah give you guidance, save yourself from your nafs, try to draw nature without the living creatures
Geometrical designs and flowers are a good choice to express your artistic talent
If drawing faces is haram then photographing a face must be. It's hypocrisy to say otherwise. Some people worship the photos of pop stars and sports people so why condemn sketches of faces and not photos?
And stop taking digitalls pictures to this is haram
Enter Islam whole heartedly
What about taxidermy ? You’re not creating an image . Rather hunting a deer , and keeping the face Allah created as a mount.
JZK for the great exposition.
I have my graduation pic on my wall in my bedroom definitely coming down subhaanallah 😓
Me too! 😔 But it's not a big sin, my dad said it's okay!
You can keep pictures in files or hided as long if you don't hang it on walls while praying!
@@mariomarioplushseries2536 bruv its you again
Wow, why would something be haram for me when it was not haram for Prophet Salesman? If he had "tamatheel (statues)" made for him to decorate his castle/s, why can't a common man like myself have the same statues prepared for my home? After all, Prophet Sulayman did not "worship" his statues. In other words, Prophet Sulsyman had "tamatheel (statues for decoration, not the "asnaam (staues for worship)" that were worshipped. Note that Prophet Ibraheem did not destroy the "tamatheel" in the mushrik community of the worship place, what he destroyed were the "asnaam".
Let's put on a thinking cap and consider the first hadith in Bukhari which says that our actions are dictated by our intentions. That being the case, if I draw a human being or make a statue of him, and my intention is not to worship him (as was the case with Prophet Sulayman), then I do not see any problem at all. I mean the whole issue is very simple: if you make images of any sort to worship them, you are destined fir Hell. But if you are making images for sake or just for a hobby, I see no problem.
Now,what would the ulema say about Dolly the sheep? Was that sheep created to worship....or to create proof of concept. Isn't "insaan" the "khaliq" of Dolly the sheep? If you are confused and feel ready to say "astaghfirullah!", the think about Allah Who is "Ahsanul Khaliqeen (the best of creators)". Thus, a man can be a creator of anything, but the "best of creators".
The main thing is that we don't " worship" these images!
blind following is same as worship in Eslaum. So if you follow these "sheikhs" on TheyTube and TV who tell you images are forbidden then you are not even a Mosslem because it was never forbidden in Eslaum and the Goraun/Koran says prophet Suleiman made statues and Eesa/Jesus was also an artist and made birds out of clay, and we know in Eslaum prophet Mohammad family had images like dolls and animal toys.
Jews say that Suleiman/Solomon became a disbeliever/kafer, Jews say Jesus was fake and evil, Jews say Mohammad was fake and evil, the fake Bible forbids making images, its not the Mosslems and Allauh. These sheikhs are YAHUDIS, Kabbalist Jews, monafegeen, posing as moslems just like Saudi kingdom and government of Iran and Erdogan, etc.
There are no sheikhs in Eslaum. No rabbis and laymen, no stupid followers without knowledge who must follow the rabbis who have the knowledge supposedly, thats Judaism.
Islam with a moon symbol on TV is fake. Wake up and covert to original Eslaum, follow your heart, follow the Goraun and original sonnah which never contradicts the Goraun and fear nothing except to become bad.
Real Mosslems are "terrorists", they are not allowed to become popular on the internet, not brought on TV to speak, they are not even allowed to have a mosque. Wake up, man.
Beautiful voice.beautiful Arabic accent
Assalamu alaikum sheik. Please explain zikr Qalb vs zikr lisa.. jazakallah. May Allah s blessings be with you forever.
It would be amazing if the sources could be mentioned in the video or linked in the description :D
Waailakumsalam wa rehmatulahay wabarakatahu. Jazak ALLAH khair brother. ALHAMDULILAH
1:03:00 Kids drawing in schools
1:04:00 What about images on kids' clothing or adults praying with clothes that have animal images on them (polo horse, lacoste alligator, etc.)?
Avoid such clothings
And cartoons./animation ??
Is there any way to abrogate this ruling that 'drawing living beings is totally prohibited'? Since in those times, people were addicted to worshipping images and artists tried to replicate living creatures but now it is a totally different matter
The best always!
wa'alaikum assalam wa rahmatu'LLAHI wa barakatoh
Perfectly said since my childhood no pictures in my house except duah and Quran
حفظكم يا شيخنا
حياكم الله
JazakAllah sir
Yasir Qadhi must earn more money than any ingeneur or physican. He enriches our Ummah , so we should enrich him. He should have no financial worries and simply concentrate on our islamic issues. His work can not be measured in gold.
Jazakillahu khair for being so thorough sheikh👌beautifully explained
Salam wa Jazak Allahu Khair for this discussion. Out of curiosity, who would make the images for the coins such as for the khalifa. Also would drawing of things that do not exist like Pokemon or other fictional creatures fall under the soulless since they do not exist?
What should we think of these AI art models that draw for us given a prompt?
jazakAllah Khair for the video
أقوال العلماء يحتج لها ولا يحتج بها
Mashaallah ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Very useful lecture shaykh
I am sorry! but I have to ask this question. Why is it allowed to own a picture like a drawing on a rug or pillow and the owner isn't a sinner while the person who made is going to hell (a cursed being in a way)? Somebody has to make the image for others to own it right. Also, it's pretty much similar to buying things from a thief it's haram, is it not. I think it's unfair! just my opinion. even to embroid a bird on a rug you have to hand draw it first, so... one does sin to survive because others want it and are willing to help them pay for their food. But then the one who enjoys the stained product isn't held accountable.
I am sorry if my opinion goes beyond the rulings of Islam.
Because the rub or a pillow is something that will be degraded so it’s not seen as something that can be worshipped.
To be honest the same thing can be applied to drawings on a computer and on paper. The prophet only got annoyed by images when they casted a shadow and were reverred as per hadiths by our mother Ayisha (RA) when he tore down a curtain. When he was talking about “the image makers” in the Hadith about “the image maker will be asked to put a soul into it” it is mainly referring to status and 3D imagery (one’s that cast a shadow) according to the Maliki school and some shafi scholars, and not ones that are on a plain surface (to my recollection). This position to me makes the most sense but do your own research. I have for a while and personally came to the conclusion that 2D isn’t haram at all but 3D definitely is
Salamu alaikum.
Exactly the issue I had today with my son. JazakAllahukhair
If drawing faces is haram then photographing a face must be and this video is included. It's hypocrisy to say otherwise. Some people worship the photos of pop stars and sports people so why condemn sketches of faces and not photos?
@@eatingeatingeating
So do not look in the mirror ever again.
@@eatingeatingeating Exactly! Like whoever invented the camera just found a way to imitate Allahs creation but unfortunately it’s permissible (I didn’t actually mean Unfrotunatley it’s just that something doesn’t make sense)
@@sologamer8287 The Qur'an does not prohibit art or music. It is superstition to assume art attempts to out-do God.
Hindus says plants have no soul that’s why it’s okay to eat it
But it’s bad to eat animal as it has soul
And Muslims say plants have feelings too and feel pain too and even worse that plants can’t show pain like animals
The tree trunk cried when our beloved Prophet, Peace be upon him, stopped giving sermon next to it. And the Prophet, Peace be upon him, hugged the tree to console it
So what did the tree have that made it cry
These just talking points i am bringing up
Allah Knows Best
i'm a bit gifted at drawing and designing. i've been working at printing office utilizing said gift. then i learn that in islam being an artist pretty much i haraam. usually there logical explanation about islam ruling but i just cant find any in this case (you see, my work usually just designing things like book cover / banner / phamplet. etc) . so uh.. what am i supposed to do? should i contnue this on since i just make a living (no other motivation) or should i 'waste' the gift and do something else for living
Draw inanimate objects only, don’t draw any animals or people
I have the same problem watch doctor zakit naiks video on this i think its pretty good. I think allah is testing us to obey his rules even if we dont understand the reasoning behind it. I know how you feel you feel uneasy and feel weird you feel like it doesnt make semse or the reason isnt clear. And you know what it doesnt have ro make sense because we cant understand everything. But still i would at least like to know every situation in which im allowed to draw certain things. Some say for finding criminals is ok but you have to draw to be able to it in the first place. Or that we should avoid drawing faces but what if we study about the human body. Or lets say you just want to be able to draw many things what about that? I feel your pain and i dont understand it so please if anyone knows someone who answers in a way that we are certain in what we draw and that we know its the truth and not false please say something this is a real problem for us. Allah will ask us to put souls into that what we draw we dont want that to happen thats really close to shirk maybe it is so pös answer this is a serious problem
I just saw a video called "drawing is 100% halal & 100% haram" if its true whats being said in this video then we can draw everything and anything as long as we dont do it to pray to it or to let other people pray to itt thats what i understood. If thats correct then it makes sense kind of. I still wonder if it may be haram because we "create" something. If i draw an animal i know it has no life but am i challenging allah? Im still confused but this video helped me clarify it very much
@@smarties5624 i recently ask a friend who happen who learned deeply about islam. he said that most of art (save for ornamental + poetry) actually forbidden with these reasoning :
-music : the rule explanation is there hadith that put music in league with alcohol and zina, meaning that it just as bad. the logical explanation, music identic with party and 'fun', which usually in that moment people dont think about allah. he said there misinterpretation that some scholar allow music due long ago prophet muhammad SAW allow a girl to play her rabbana when he moved in to madinna (but that coz the girl was made a nazaar to do so)
-drawing : the rule explanation is that allah hate it so much that he at judgment day will punish painter (and sculptor), force em to bring their creation to life (which they couldnt), then allah will turn these creation to life to torture their creator. the logical explanation that long ago artist tend to be arrogant so much creating something make them believe they were god equal or treat their creation as god itself. there also tendency to make a creation based on public figure of their time that due to how influental they were, after their passing that creation were worshipped
@@satyayana1399 thank you for your answer. I have a question about the second part. You said that long ago people were worshipping these paintings and artists were predending to be god. If i dont paint with that intention will it be halal? Because i dont paint and pray to these pictures or think im god. In fact i do the opposite i even try to become loose enough so that i will be able to destroy my pictures because it has no real value and i thank allah for creating these beautiful ideas in my head. If i think like that which i do is it halal? I don't think allah will punish me with hell for painting. Allah is the just god, oftentimes we dont see why something is wrong until later but painting is really difficult. Like you said, back then people prayed to these things but nowadays its not like that and i dont do it with this intention. So is it halal now?
What r ur thoughts on cartoons and anime drawings
I am wanting to know about childrens colouring books. Are they permissable for children to colour and then discard?
Is digital art prohibited? I tend to draw as a pasttime and i use a drawing tablet on my desktop. I tend to draw action scenes. Thank you!
Allah SWT will Grace you with His Blessings for obeying Him and following the advice from His messenger the Prophet Muhammad SAW. I practised Art, painting and some sculpture, exhibitions etc.for many years, a hearfelt passion. After reading the Qura'an I realised my situation and destroyed everything except unused materials which I gave to Charity. It felt good and gave me a feeling of freedom. I have never regretted it! Thank you Allah SWT.
Jazakallah khair! I like drawing weird stuff for example wooden things, hands, trees with one or two eyes on it. Is this allowed?
blind following is same as worship in Eslaum. So if you follow these "sheikhs" on TheyTube and TV who tell you images are forbidden then you are not even a Mosslem because it was never forbidden in Eslaum and the Goraun/Koran says prophet Suleiman made statues and Eesa/Jesus was also an artist and made birds out of clay, and we know in Eslaum prophet Mohammad family had images like dolls and animal toys.
Jews say that Suleiman/Solomon became a disbeliever/kafer, Jews say Jesus was fake and evil, Jews say Mohammad was fake and evil, the fake Bible forbids making images, its not the Mosslems and Allauh. These sheikhs are YAHUDIS, Kabbalist Jews, monafegeen, posing as moslems just like Saudi kingdom and government of Iran and Erdogan, etc.
There are no sheikhs in Eslaum. No rabbis and laymen, no stupid followers without knowledge who must follow the rabbis who have the knowledge supposedly, thats Judaism.
Islam with a moon symbol on TV is fake. Wake up and covert to original Eslaum, follow your heart, follow the Goraun and original sonnah which never contradicts the Goraun and fear nothing except to become bad.
Real Mosslems are "terrorists", they are not allowed to become popular on the internet, not brought on TV to speak, they are not even allowed to have a mosque. Wake up, man.
What about cartoons?
And what’s meant by a silhouette that a child is allowed to draw? If a child draws like a stick-drawing, is that okay?
My common sense tells me that the difference between owning and making sounds almost hypocritical. I'm sorry but I grew up in the West where toys and collectibles are common, never once did it come to my mind to venerate them. I still have childhood toys because I'm attached to them, but somehow this was fine as a kid but not as an adult even though the feeling is largely the same. If we say that making images is sinful, but owning is not so we are allowed to buy them, that sounds stupid because that means someone else will be punished because we really wanted that cute rug with the bird on it.
blind following is same as worship in Eslaum. So if you follow these "sheikhs" on TheyTube and TV who tell you images are forbidden then you are not even a Mosslem because it was never forbidden in Eslaum and the Goraun/Koran says prophet Suleiman made statues and Eesa/Jesus was also an artist and made birds out of clay, and we know in Eslaum prophet Mohammad family had images like dolls and animal toys.
Jews say that Suleiman/Solomon became a disbeliever/kafer, Jews say Jesus was fake and evil, Jews say Mohammad was fake and evil, the fake Bible forbids making images, its not the Mosslems and Allauh. These sheikhs are YAHUDIS, Kabbalist Jews, monafegeen, posing as moslems just like Saudi kingdom and government of Iran and Erdogan, etc.
There are no sheikhs in Eslaum. No rabbis and laymen, no stupid followers without knowledge who must follow the rabbis who have the knowledge supposedly, thats Judaism.
Islam with a moon symbol on TV is fake. Wake up and covert to original Eslaum, follow your heart, follow the Goraun and original sonnah which never contradicts the Goraun and fear nothing except to become bad.
Real Mosslems are "terrorists", they are not allowed to become popular on the internet, not brought on TV to speak, they are not even allowed to have a mosque. Wake up, man.
Asalamu Alaykum Dr. Yasir Qadhi
May Allah bless you for providing us with this information. I just have a question. My life is based on many dreams that have already happened. Can I use abstract painting to do the images? It includes horses, people and other non human forms. If I paint an image of a fully dressed person’s back, is that disallowed? Again thank you for your help.
It seems like drawing things that have souls is permissable as long as the drawn animal is missing something vital, meaning you may leave out parts of the face or limbs. This is what I have gathered from this lecture and I can't guarantee that I am not mistaken.
What do you mean your life is based on many dreams that have already happened ?
@@parsival484 if i leave the leg one eye etc it would be ok right?
@@dramallama079 it seems that way judging by this lecture
I just need one answer
Can i draw animate 2d pictures or not?
It is only a side hobby and the artwork sits in one shelf in the corner. I dont worship it, neiter do i frame it on the wall...
May Allah bless you Skeikh, it was very informative. But I feel that one angle was not covered and that is the prohibition made initially by prophet Mohammed pbuh was mainly based on the status quo of his time (meaning the idealotory that he was primarily sent for to destroy) and now that is no longer a threat could we have a more progressive view?
Case and point when Muslim entered Egypt, not a single statute was destroyed especially when the Muslim understood that no one is actually worshipping them
Exactly my thought... Plus, if the people that are going to be the most severely punished on the day of judgement are al musawirun, with the meaning of those who (even innocently and with absolutely no ill intent) drew/sculpted living beings, then why isn't there anything clear about it in the Quran? No verse whatsoever? When it is repeated over and over that the only sin that won't be forgiven is shirk and kufr and that will lead to hell for eternity with all the details about their retribution... Why not clearly mention that imitating/replicating the creation is such an enormous sin that it deserves the worse punishments over anything else (and therefor even shirk and kufr???) and so that there would be no question about it and that everyone would be warned?
oh god, now that I'm finding out about this, I stopped drawing people and am aware the intention does not change it, but what about past drawings I made while being unaware they're actually bad? I understand about the fact that on the day of judgement the creators will be asked to bring these to life, I'm not exactly sure how to word this but, since I'm aware of the sin and have let go, is it still, like going to happen on the day of judgment, since I myself have drawn a lot of different people/animals but now I am aware of the sin and will no longer do it anymore
and move on to landscape drawings instead
if you didn’t know it was a sin you won’t be punished for that
Salaam Sheikh May I ask about the graduation picture displayed on the wall due to honor? Thanks May Allah Azzawajjal be with you!
Just don’t display just in case
55:17 - 102:00 photography and movies
Mashallah brother
I’m an artist and was wondering if I can draw niqabi women with eyes but no mouth showing? Can this be considered a silhouette? Because you said you can paint a hand and this is okay, I’m wondering thank you. And for educational purposes is it okay if I draw? For example, Diego Rivera used to paint the history of indigenous people because in the Americas we where enslaved and not allowed to read or write so he painted our history, and I too want to paint for educational purposes of history, thank you. 💕
blind following is same as worship in Eslaum. So if you follow these "sheikhs" on TheyTube and TV who tell you images are forbidden then you are not even a Mosslem because it was never forbidden in Eslaum and the Goraun/Koran says prophet Suleiman made statues and Eesa/Jesus was also an artist and made birds out of clay, and we know in Eslaum prophet Mohammad family had images like dolls and animal toys.
Jews say that Suleiman/Solomon became a disbeliever/kafer, Jews say Jesus was fake and evil, Jews say Mohammad was fake and evil, the fake Bible forbids making images, its not the Mosslems and Allauh. These sheikhs are YAHUDIS, Kabbalist Jews, monafegeen, posing as moslems just like Saudi kingdom and government of Iran and Erdogan, etc.
There are no sheikhs in Eslaum. No rabbis and laymen, no stupid followers without knowledge who must follow the rabbis who have the knowledge supposedly, thats Judaism.
Islam with a moon symbol on TV is fake. Wake up and covert to original Eslaum, follow your heart, follow the Goraun and original sonnah which never contradicts the Goraun and fear nothing except to become bad.
Real Mosslems are "terrorists", they are not allowed to become popular on the internet, not brought on TV to speak, they are not even allowed to have a mosque. Wake up, man.
So I can draw Nature Like rocks the sky trees mountains and river's but not faces animals and anything with a sole right?
One doubt. How can one person own the paintings and drawings on pillow covers or coins without other person is creating.
I didn't understand creating is haram but owning is not, but how can one own it when no one creates it
I have the same confusion with you. There will be supplies if there are demands. So owning images can indirectly cause more people to create images. Which can be translated to encouraging to create images.
I have the same question, it's pretty weird ngl
I think it's not problematic if the muslim didn't create that image so owning it is fine if you're not using it for shirk & Allah knows best
It's still confusing considering the sheikh mentioned the umayyad caliph created the coin with his image on it & the sahabah had no issue with that back then
This inconsistency is exactly why I follow the Maliki position on images. The ruling against them makes little logical sense in our current day and age, especially when you consider the prophets Hadith about images were in the time when idolatry was still prevalent. I think the other schools need to revise it with modern context personally.
@@jamrah8713 idolatry is still happening now lol so I understand why the rulings exist & why the prophet (peace be upon him) was concerned over this however I think it's hard to follow & somewhat more confusing when applying this to today you see?
Who else feels like going coin hunting?
So from my comprehension, drawing 2d digital drawing from imam maliki, is discourage and not sinful..the others state as prohibited.. other view as long it is not for worship and idolatry then its okay.. sculpting is haram cause it casts shadow,
In the end of the day it all come from ure heart and intentionss..wallahualam
The hadith about Ibn Abbas in which a image maker came to him. So in those days who was the image maker? Was he the one making images to sell so people could buy and keep it in their houses to worship?
What's your general view on drawing living things?just asking brother