No way! I love this product I don’t go anywhere with out it! My mom has severe bags and she almost started crying and said she doesn’t need surgery now. It’s worth the hard work to me.
I’m turning 50 soon & I have been using this product for a couple of years. It works great for me & I have told my friends about it. I won’t leave the house without it on. I don’t wear makeup on top of it. I could see how it wouldn’t work for people that need to put makeup on that area. I use it for the hollows/puffiness under my eyes. I was so happy & surprised the first time when I saw the results. After a few times, you do learn how much product to use & how to rub it in to eliminate or greatly reduce that white residue. You also get used to the tightening feeling. Nothing is gonna be great, except surgery, but I find this does a pretty good job
I have used this for years but I don’t use any other makeup except for a dot on my nose. It works once you figure out how to use it the right way. Also, I have very puffy eyes. This product makes me look younger.
@@sunnyram6714 I don’t rub it in. I use a very thin layer that I tap around the edges. I’ve used it long enough to know that too much product leaves a white residue. It’s best to swipe it across in the thinnest layer you can get. Also make sure to shake it up before you use it.
You are absolutely right. This product it's the same thing I bought last year (Remescar) and both of them don't work if you need make up. They have a lot of rules and even if you follow them you will always have a layer of white powder under your eyes and the magic moment lasts only 1 hour. Thanks for your honest review.
@martinamoreno2209 Yo ambien tengo 58 lo acabo de comprar y lo recibo hoy😅!! Serías tan amable de decirme como lo aplicas? Compre los dos hahahaha él ojos y el de la cara. Muchas gracias 😊
Hi Cheryl and Stacey, this reminds me of a product I bought when I was on vacation last year. I was absolutely astounded at the results, and was so swept up in the moment that I immediately spent waaayyy too much money to buy it! Of course, I could not repeat the results, and ended up with the same white ring under my eyes. I threw it away a few months later. Such a waste! I’m so glad you’re doing these reviews!
I’m very happy to of found you ladies page . I’m not a big makeup person. But do struggle with issues with dark circles and uneven skin tone. Thank you this and many of your videos helped me to not fall for the many tik toc and insta models hype of products. ❤
Thanks for the review, I have under eye issues and was looking to trying this product. I do not wear make up at all, only eyeliner. I was looking for a product that would not require a lot of time in the morning I am a Black American and white circles would not be acceptable under my eyes and this seems time consuming.
Thank you so much for reviewing this!! It’s disappointing that this particular brand has some good ideas but they have seemed to fall short on a few products I’ve seen other people review too.
Man thanks for this review! Everybody had great results on TikTok but I wanted to see a real, timely, filter-less review. It is a hefty price tag so I needed to be sure. Thanks so much!!!
You girls are absolutely right about this product. When I first applied this product, it worked! It suppressed my baggy eyes but when it dried, it left a white film and the product cracked under my eyes as I smiled or squinted making it worse. I just stopped using it.
hey ladies, when the white cast do appear, you just take a sponge very lightly damped and blotted over the area that you applied the product, and it is fine after that and then you can apply a liquid foundation and you can also add a little drop to that and it works perfectly fine fine, I also watched a video on Fumi doing a demonstration because she is a beautiful deep, chocolate, mature woman and she demonstrated two different ways and it was fabulous looking on her, that’s what she did. She didn’t rub she blocked very lightly would’ve very very damp sponge. She demonstrated two ways and then she did her make up and it was beautiful so you can use either the liquid make up powder but you don’t rub your foundation on, and you guys talking about the I didn’t see anything so difficult about waiting the extra few minutes because in life we don’t wait for one thing we wait for another, all you do whenever you have to go somewhere you start your make up at least a few minutes earlier and work it in your routine. It’s not really a big deal but I understand we as mature women we seem to more patient a lot of younger people are in a hurry, but when you get a little older you understand the process of time so whenever you want to do something you don’t mind putting in an extra time because you in a hurry in the morning, you just add that extra seven minutes by getting up an extra 10 minutes so you can achieve what you want, the product does work I didn’t expect miracles but I do like the idea that it blur your pores that wasn’t mentioned on the bottle but it actually blur your pores and it does give a blur on some of the lines not everything does not the stuff is a miracle worker but it did do some improvement not a miracle, so I’ll say the product does work because somebody’s products do not work that well on deep dark skin but this product works on all types of skin so I have to apply them for that because some products have a habit of leaving us out of the game , we’re not invited to the party maybe years down they’ll make it where we’re invited to the party but straight straight out the park Mr. Peter invited us to the party 🎈 🎊 🎉 and it did work!!! 🥰👩🏾🦲😍
Thank you for the review! I wonder if you do not have enough puffiness or wrinkles? I get better results from elevating my head in bed and keeping my eyes moisturized. 💜
I saw another application video online somewhere that said if you apply the gel with a small makeup brush, you will use less and a thinner application can be had, which helps prevent the chalky white film that some get when it is applied to heavily. A soft brush also does not pull the delicate eye tissue like your finger can. And it is more sanitary than your finger.
Hi beautifuls! I too bought the PTR eye product and had the same issues with the white cast ☹️Have you ladies tried the Westmore Beauty 60 second eye effects. I like this one a lot more. It comes tinted and does a better job with firming my under eye bags 😊
This is my first time tuning in. Seriously the two of you are so pretty. Neither one of you look in your 50's. I recently bought this earlier this weekon sale from QVC. 🙏 Girls I'm about to find out.
Thank you so much for your review of this at my personal request. I too read alot about the white residue so won't be buying this . I appreciate this so much-you are two beautiful ladies & I love your channel
Thank you so much for the fantastic step by step video. It happened the same with me… do you have another review that worked for you? Please let me watch it! Thanks
I think it's for those that have more pronounced undereye bags like the lady that made it go viral. This instant eye tightner and others with similar ingredients work best if u have deep bags. None have worked for me and are more of a PITA as u described
I agree and had the same experience. It’s like you’re expected to stay expressionless while you have it on. Perhaps it’s good only for those who doesn’t wear makeup and have straight face. 😅
Hi purchased this product recently when it was on sale. I’ve tried to apply it different ways about eight times, and as one of you mentioned, my under eyes look worse! It’s very tricky to get the amount right and I have to have concealer. Even even at its best Application if my face is resting, there’s a little bit of improvement. But with any sort of movement, or of course, smiling, it looks absolutely worse. This product might work for some but not for me. I have tried so many times!
Try something light like Glossier stretch concealer. It's super glidy- not cakey. Light coverage- unfortunately full coverage will be cakey. I've tried it all
Hi! Have you tried using a color corrector? We like DRMTLGY Color Corrector, Tarte or to try color correctors on a budget price, e.l.f. Our favorite concealer is Fiera! Great for our mature skin issues!
This product DOES work. You guys just don't know how to use it. Mix oil base concealer and a tiny bit of the product together and pat it under your eyes. You cannot use oil-free concealer with this product.
I only use this stuff when I’m sick and super puffy/tired eyes. And not going to wear makeup. I’m aiming to wear less foundation/concealer. So I want something for those days. And this product is perfect for that and it lasts longer that way too. Because I’m not using it everyday. Only on my non makeup days. So if you’re someone who needs makeup everyday. This may not be the product for you
@Vault-Born Hi! We are so sorry we missed responding to this comment! We really love the City Beauty Lid Lifting Treatment. It is not advertised as a primer but we noticed our eyeshadow went on smoothly and didn’t crease! We did review this product if you want to check that video out!
I am definitely not a fan........I have tried and tried and tried. I put it under makeup and it caked. I put it over makeup and it caked. I put it on without any makeup and it left a film that looked terrible after I put my face makeup all around it. So I tried again this morning without any makeup under or over. It was so cakey that I had to come home and wash my face and re-apply my makeup without the "magic" eye tightener. I also tried the one advertised on TV (Plex....). Works just as badly. Help...........my undereyes are sooooooooooo puffy.
This one I hated. If you don’t get a smooth, completely even layer, it looks awful. You have to take it off and reapply, and that is very irritating. Or you get those white edges. If you do get it on right, even if it works, it feels so tight and after a week I noticed it was really drying out my undereye area. And I don’t like that I can’t wear sunscreen under it. So, I decided to try the one from It Cosmetics. It’s much easier to apply, and not drying. No white edges. Looks much, much more natural. I put on my skin care, give it about 20 minutes to soak in, then I pat on 2 or 3 light layers. Lasts until I wash my face at the end of the day. The It Cosmetics one is far superior to the PTR.
They need to make a product you can put concealer on top of. Westmore beauty says if it oil free you can put concealer on top. Tried it, did not work. Tired of wasting money
Wish I had seen this review before buying this product (of course searches only brought up the positive ones). I had the exact same experience and looked worse after using this. What a waste of money. I’m subscribing to your reviews from now on. However, I did have the opposite experience with Fiera concealer, which did absolutely nothing for me. Guess the lesson is everyone’s skin is different and what works for one does not work for all.
Total fail for me. I bought 3 tubes. What irritated me was, every review showed a clear cream. My cream is white. It did absolutely nothing, except leave the white film. Never made it to adding any makeup.
I have a few very fine lines I thought the product was genuine but unfortunately it is not It is a scam with fake reviewers and very carefully edited videos Do not fool for the scam.
“so many instructions “. it’s simple straightforward instructions Basic & takes moments The products claims to smooth & tighten under eyes. & it does Not restore under eyes to how they looked in your 20’s This video sounds like the women were paid not to like the product Just thoughts
No way! I love this product I don’t go anywhere with out it! My mom has severe bags and she almost started crying and said she doesn’t need surgery now. It’s worth the hard work to me.
Hi! We're so glad it worked for you and your mom! That's awesome! Thanks for the comment!
I’m turning 50 soon & I have been using this product for a couple of years. It works great for me & I have told my friends about it. I won’t leave the house without it on. I don’t wear makeup on top of it. I could see how it wouldn’t work for people that need to put makeup on that area. I use it for the hollows/puffiness under my eyes. I was so happy & surprised the first time when I saw the results. After a few times, you do learn how much product to use & how to rub it in to eliminate or greatly reduce that white residue. You also get used to the tightening feeling. Nothing is gonna be great, except surgery, but I find this does a pretty good job
Thank you for sharing your experience! We glad that it does work for some people!
I love this product. I have been using it for years. I don't leave the house without it on.
Is it safe though??
I'm 63 and it works great for me, love it!
@laurieglanz6832 That’s awesome! Thanks for sharing your experience! 🥰
I have used this for years but I don’t use any other makeup except for a dot on my nose. It works once you figure out how to use it the right way. Also, I have very puffy eyes. This product makes me look younger.
Thanks for sharing your experience!
can you explain how to use it and what was mistake from video creator. Iam planning on buying it. Thanks ahead
@@sunnyram6714 I don’t rub it in. I use a very thin layer that I tap around the edges. I’ve used it long enough to know that too much product leaves a white residue. It’s best to swipe it across in the thinnest layer you can get. Also make sure to shake it up before you use it.
@@karenann5090 Thank you and it makes lot of sense.
I just bought it and is the best thing I ever used for for my eye bags. I love it
Hey how do you combat the residue ?
You are absolutely right. This product it's the same thing I bought last year (Remescar) and both of them don't work if you need make up. They have a lot of rules and even if you follow them you will always have a layer of white powder under your eyes and the magic moment lasts only 1 hour. Thanks for your honest review.
Thank you! This was on my list to purchase. Crossing it off now.
@NewWing333 We were really hoping it would work for us!
this product works im 58 its amazing u guys must not be doing it wrong
@martinamoreno2209 Yo ambien tengo 58 lo acabo de comprar y lo recibo hoy😅!! Serías tan amable de decirme como lo aplicas? Compre los dos hahahaha él ojos y el de la cara. Muchas gracias 😊
Hi Cheryl and Stacey, this reminds me of a product I bought when I was on vacation last year. I was absolutely astounded at the results, and was so swept up in the moment that I immediately spent waaayyy too much money to buy it! Of course, I could not repeat the results, and ended up with the same white ring under my eyes. I threw it away a few months later. Such a waste! I’m so glad you’re doing these reviews!
Hey Tracey! You can feel our disappointment! It IS such a waste!! We're so glad you like our reviews! Thanks for the comment!❤
Plus you need just a little dab❤ or 2
Wow.. awesome review.. but mainly… so honest.. thank you so much!!
I tried FirmX for face (not for eyes), but I had a very similar experience (face looked worse than before). You saved me time and $$ -- many thanks!!!
Thanks for the comment!
Thank you for this entertaining review! I was very skeptical about this product and you guys really confirmed my suspicions!❤
@nancydirks-monasky39 Glad our review was helpful!! 🥰
I’m very happy to of found you ladies page . I’m not a big makeup person. But do struggle with issues with dark circles and uneven skin tone. Thank you this and many of your videos helped me to not fall for the many tik toc and insta models hype of products. ❤
Thank you, I was curious and almost scared that something that would tighten and I'm then untightened over time would cause more damage ,than good.
Thanks for the review, I have under eye issues and was looking to trying this product. I do not wear make up at all, only eyeliner. I was looking for a product that would not require a lot of time in the morning I am a Black American and white circles would not be acceptable under my eyes and this seems time consuming.
Thank you so much for reviewing this!! It’s disappointing that this particular brand has some good ideas but they have seemed to fall short on a few products I’ve seen other people review too.
@nicolep.1644 It is very disappointing! Thanks for the comment!
Man thanks for this review! Everybody had great results on TikTok but I wanted to see a real, timely, filter-less review. It is a hefty price tag so I needed to be sure.
Thanks so much!!!
Try it for yourself. It really is an Amazing product.
This product is amazing. Yes, it DOES work. I love it! I use a small angled makeup brush to apply the cream not my finger.
@conniebenevides2389 Thanks for sharing your experience and the application tip!
You girls are absolutely right about this product. When I first applied this product, it worked! It suppressed my baggy eyes but when it dried, it left a white film and the product cracked under my eyes as I smiled or squinted making it worse. I just stopped using it.
Love, love, love it. Also put just a little on eyelid and eye shadow and liner stays put for hours.
Thank you. I don't have that sort of money to waste, and this was on my wishlist.
@susanabler3039 Right! It was so pricey for even the smaller tube!
I'm 37 and I had that problem, I'm going to try the primer version because I heard it's better🤷🏻♀️🙏
hey ladies, when the white cast do appear, you just take a sponge very lightly damped and blotted over the area that you applied the product, and it is fine after that and then you can apply a liquid foundation and you can also add a little drop to that and it works perfectly fine fine, I also watched a video on Fumi doing a demonstration because she is a beautiful deep, chocolate, mature woman and she demonstrated two different ways and it was fabulous looking on her, that’s what she did. She didn’t rub she blocked very lightly would’ve very very damp sponge. She demonstrated two ways and then she did her make up and it was beautiful so you can use either the liquid make up powder but you don’t rub your foundation on, and you guys talking about the I didn’t see anything so difficult about waiting the extra few minutes because in life we don’t wait for one thing we wait for another, all you do whenever you have to go somewhere you start your make up at least a few minutes earlier and work it in your routine. It’s not really a big deal but I understand we as mature women we seem to more patient a lot of younger people are in a hurry, but when you get a little older you understand the process of time so whenever you want to do something you don’t mind putting in an extra time because you in a hurry in the morning, you just add that extra seven minutes by getting up an extra 10 minutes so you can achieve what you want, the product does work I didn’t expect miracles but I do like the idea that it blur your pores that wasn’t mentioned on the bottle but it actually blur your pores and it does give a blur on some of the lines not everything does not the stuff is a miracle worker but it did do some improvement not a miracle, so I’ll say the product does work because somebody’s products do not work that well on deep dark skin but this product works on all types of skin so I have to apply them for that because some products have a habit of leaving us out of the game , we’re not invited to the party maybe years down they’ll make it where we’re invited to the party but straight straight out the park Mr. Peter invited us to the party 🎈 🎊 🎉 and it did work!!! 🥰👩🏾🦲😍
Thank you for the review! I wonder if you do not have enough puffiness or wrinkles? I get better results from elevating my head in bed and keeping my eyes moisturized. 💜
@kimvillasenor4649 Yes! Thats what was so frustrating about this. We couldn’t use anything else along with it and we need our moisturizers! lol!
You both look beautiful
I saw another application video online somewhere that said if you apply the gel with a small makeup brush, you will use less and a thinner application can be had, which helps prevent the chalky white film that some get when it is applied to heavily. A soft brush also does not pull the delicate eye tissue like your finger can. And it is more sanitary than your finger.
Thank you ladies for the review!! It saved me the money and the hassle!!
Glad I only got a sample. Thanks ladies.
Thank you both for your honesty on something that's so expensive.
@mfaf550 🥰
Hi beautifuls! I too bought the PTR eye product and had the same issues with the white cast ☹️Have you ladies tried the Westmore Beauty 60 second eye effects. I like this one a lot more. It comes tinted and does a better job with firming my under eye bags 😊
@aliciacapozziello2802 Hi!! That white cast was frustrating 😔 We are actually testing the Westmore Beauty now and will be filming a review soon!! 🥰
This is my first time tuning in. Seriously the two of you are so pretty. Neither one of you look in your 50's. I recently bought this earlier this weekon sale from QVC. 🙏 Girls I'm about to find out.
Same - I thought, what do two women in their 30’ know about wrinkles.. Now I feel worse about how I look ! 😂
Thank you so much for your review of this at my personal request. I too read alot about the white residue so won't be buying this . I appreciate this so much-you are two beautiful ladies & I love your channel
@Novemberbaby333 We had such high hopes!
It’s very finicky with me , sometimes it takes me one try and I’m good to go! Other times I have to take it off and try again multiple times , 😭
Me too. Sometimes I wipe it off multiple times but it does help deflate the puffy eyes I have.
@@karenann5090 it worked super well for me on the beginning but nowadays I have to reapply quite a few times 😭 but I won’t stop using it!
I put concealer first then dabbed lightly this product it works
Thanks for sharing your experience!
This product is AWESOME❤❤❤❤ I look 15 years younger!!
@gionagrace6279 Thank you so much for sharing your experience!
Do you wear makeup with this ?? Thank you!!
Thank you so much for the fantastic step by step video. It happened the same with me… do you have another review that worked for you? Please let me watch it! Thanks
I’m agree! I tried to used it and never figured the right way to make it work. 😢
I think it's for those that have more pronounced undereye bags like the lady that made it go viral. This instant eye tightner and others with similar ingredients work best if u have deep bags. None have worked for me and are more of a PITA as u described
I agree and had the same experience. It’s like you’re expected to stay expressionless while you have it on. Perhaps it’s good only for those who doesn’t wear makeup and have straight face. 😅
How this product work ,can apply night time or when it use thanks
Hi can any of u lovely ladies tell me how long does the effect last?
What happens when your face gets all sweaty? Will it stay on?
Works so fantastic ❤
Hi purchased this product recently when it was on sale. I’ve tried to apply it different ways about eight times, and as one of you mentioned, my under eyes look worse! It’s very tricky to get the amount right and I have to have concealer. Even even at its best Application if my face is resting, there’s a little bit of improvement. But with any sort of movement, or of course, smiling, it looks absolutely worse. This product might work for some but not for me. I have tried so many times!
Hi! Thank you for sharing your experience! We're glad we weren't the only ones that had issues with this!
Yes I love it but struggling with covering my dark circles
Try something light like Glossier stretch concealer. It's super glidy- not cakey. Light coverage- unfortunately full coverage will be cakey. I've tried it all
Hi! Have you tried using a color corrector? We like DRMTLGY Color Corrector, Tarte or to try color correctors on a budget price, e.l.f. Our favorite concealer is Fiera! Great for our mature skin issues!
This product DOES work. You guys just don't know how to use it. Mix oil base concealer and a tiny bit of the product together and pat it under your eyes. You cannot use oil-free concealer with this product.
I only use this stuff when I’m sick and super puffy/tired eyes. And not going to wear makeup. I’m aiming to wear less foundation/concealer. So I want something for those days. And this product is perfect for that and it lasts longer that way too. Because I’m not using it everyday. Only on my non makeup days. So if you’re someone who needs makeup everyday. This may not be the product for you
Thanks for sharing!!
I got it but it is milky white !! Is this ok ???!!!
I Love this product. I have used it for several years nobody believes I am 71. I think you put too much on. I do not use concealer though.
Thanks. Super valuable!!
do you have any suggestions for a primer/eyeshadow/whatever that can help apply eyemakeup to an eye area w/ wrinkles without ending up with creases?
@Vault-Born Hi! We are so sorry we missed responding to this comment! We really love the City Beauty Lid Lifting Treatment. It is not advertised as a primer but we noticed our eyeshadow went on smoothly and didn’t crease! We did review this product if you want to check that video out!
MIX THE CONCEALER OR MOISTURIZER,OR FOUNDATION
I am definitely not a fan........I have tried and tried and tried. I put it under makeup and it caked. I put it over makeup and it caked. I put it on without any makeup and it left a film that looked terrible after I put my face makeup all around it. So I tried again this morning without any makeup under or over. It was so cakey that I had to come home and wash my face and re-apply my makeup without the "magic" eye tightener. I also tried the one advertised on TV (Plex....). Works just as badly. Help...........my undereyes are sooooooooooo puffy.
This one I hated. If you don’t get a smooth, completely even layer, it looks awful. You have to take it off and reapply, and that is very irritating. Or you get those white edges. If you do get it on right, even if it works, it feels so tight and after a week I noticed it was really drying out my undereye area. And I don’t like that I can’t wear sunscreen under it. So, I decided to try the one from It Cosmetics. It’s much easier to apply, and not drying. No white edges. Looks much, much more natural. I put on my skin care, give it about 20 minutes to soak in, then I pat on 2 or 3 light layers. Lasts until I wash my face at the end of the day. The It Cosmetics one is far superior to the PTR.
They need to make a product you can put concealer on top of. Westmore beauty says if it oil free you can put concealer on top. Tried it, did not work. Tired of wasting money
Where can i get it
There are links in the description box of the video
Wish I had seen this review before buying this product (of course searches only brought up the positive ones). I had the exact same experience and looked worse after using this. What a waste of money. I’m subscribing to your reviews from now on. However, I did have the opposite experience with Fiera concealer, which did absolutely nothing for me. Guess the lesson is everyone’s skin is different and what works for one does not work for all.
Burns my skin. Dries down white and leaves whilte patches underneath my eyes.
😮.
I just bought this & while it works, I can't wear makeup with it so then I have dark circles & chalk under my eyes.
@sunsetatshabooms4558 Agree! I need to be able to cover my dark circles! - Stacey
Egg white does the same.
Also, I THEY DID REFUND THE SHIPPING AND HANDLING.
I couldn’t get past the residue.
Did nothing for me. I just tried it. I look the same.
I just got this product, I tried it and it doesn’t work for me!! Waste of money..
I audibly gasped when you said 55 and 55, not that there's anything wrong with looking your age, but you both look late 30's at the oldest to me!
@Vault-Born You are the sweetest!! 🥰
Total fail for me. I bought 3 tubes. What irritated me was, every review showed a clear cream. My cream is white. It did absolutely nothing, except leave the white film. Never made it to adding any makeup.
You're supposed to apply it with a brush.
If you bought it at Ulta return it and get your 24 bucks back.
I have a few very fine lines I thought the product was genuine but unfortunately it is not It is a scam with fake reviewers and very carefully edited videos Do not fool for the scam.
Baking sodas all you need....
I think if you have Botox it will work
“so many instructions “. it’s simple straightforward instructions
Basic & takes moments
The products claims to smooth & tighten under eyes. & it does
Not restore under eyes to
how they looked in your
20’s
This video sounds like the women were paid not to like the product
Just thoughts
I used this twice and can hardly see a difference. Very disappointing.
3-5 minutes is not that much time 😂
We live in such a fast paced culture these days that everyone has ADHD 😆
The secret ingredient is just egg white.
thanks for your review..won't be buying it
You used too much product if it’s caking and doing all that 😊
Smh...no good👎 So disappointed. I'm hoping it works for others.
@micheboohawaii9430 We were so disappointed!