N-Acetylcysteine: Is It REALLY Dangerous? Dr. Anderson Explains
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 авг 2024
- CE COURSES FOR PROFESSIONALS: bit.ly/dra-continuingeducation
Dr. A discusses N-Acetylcysteine (NAC), highlighting respiratory risks, sulfite sensitivity, and the balance of benefits and risks, and its potential role in cancer treatment. In this video, Dr. Anderson explains this and more.
____________________________
CHAPTERS
00:00 Introduction
00:49 Understanding the Rotten Egg Smell in N-Acetylcysteine Pills
01:57 Cysteine's Risks with Respiratory Conditions and Allergies
02:36 The Respiratory Risks of Cysteine Metabolism
03:57 How Genetics and Toxins Impact Sulfite Sensitivity in Asthma
05:01 Understanding Sulfa Drug Allergies and Cross-Reactivity with Small Thiols
06:56 Understanding the Role of N-Acetylcysteine in Cancer Treatment
08:36 Balancing Treatment and Risk of N-Acetylcysteine in Cancer Treatment
___________________________
This video is NOT sponsored.
Connect with Dr. Anderson ~
DrA RUclips Channel: / @dra-online
DrA Instagram: / draonline
Continuing Education for Professionals: consultdranderson.com
Dr A Links: linktr.ee/DrAonline
Dr A Website: dranow.com/
____________________________
#integrativemedicine #functionalmedicine #doctorsofinstagram #doctor
____________________________
INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE REFERRAL LINKS
(Use these to find providers.)
[For your reference only - no referral or implication of professional superiority is claimed or intended.]
NAEM (Environmental Medicine) Providers: envmedicine.com/find-a-provider/
US Naturopathic Physicians: naturopathic.org/search/defau...
Canadian Naturopathic Physicians: www.cand.ca/findmynd/
Digestive Specialists: www.gastroanp.org/directory
Mold and Environmental Illness Referrals: drcrista.com/doctor-finder/
Mental Health focus: www.psychanp.org/member-direc...
Cancer Focus: www.oncanp.org/find-an-nd#!di...
New Hampshire Naturopathic Physicians [NHAND.org]: nhand.org/
A4M Integrative referral: www.a4m.com/find-a-doctor.html
I've taken 600/1200mg NAC as a mucolytic for 30 years, it has been a life changer. It doesn't adversely affect my asthma.
My wife has had asthma since childhood, she uses NAC and has not needed her inhaler for years.
Asthma is caused by undiagnosed crypto infection called chylimdma pneumonia it don't show up in blood test s , azitromycin Monday and Wednesday and Friday for 6 months with rifampin cures asthma it's caused by undiagnosed lung infection that cause Alzheimer's
I'm 57 and nearly died of Covid. I have had mucous buildup in my lungs due to allergies since puberty. I've taken NAC since coming home from the hospital in 2021 and my morning cough has greatly lessened due to its mucolytic effect.
I have severe decades long asthma, just took my first NAC capsule. Worried about uptick of asthma with this? Hope not.
@@Rbuffdogs get checked for hidden lung infection called chylimdma pneumonia by infection disease Dr like Dr Richard Horowitz armin labs Germany eli spot test is only test to do asthma is caused by undiagnosed hidden infection
Danes did a 4 year study of NAC. All good. Big improvements especially if you have COPD. Recommended dose of 1200 mg. per day.
Can you please tell me how to find this study, does Danes mean Danish, I googled it but couldn't find a 4 year study.
Thank-You good to hear this!!!
The cancer part should be detailed more. People typically take NAC not for respiratory reasons. More likely to support the mitochondria. This assumes continuous use of NAC.
Also, what cancers are most likely to be affected by it.
I take it for both reasons but I do not have cancer.
@@andrewrivera4029Not yet.
Yeah what the f*** why I leave out what times of cancers withholding seems a little sadistic
Thank you for the feedback - we'll do a video with more details on this in the future. For now the section discussing NAC & cancer has an example treatment approach that can be discussed with managing physicians. - Team Dr. A
I am so grateful to have found you! I am enjoying and will continue to listen and enjoy all your fine videos.
Thank you for the support! - Team Dr. A
One (healthy) way to stop cancergrowth is to completely stop eating sugar and any starchy product, e.g. bread. Intermittent fasting and fasting up to 72 hours is helping as well.
Young people do not like to hear it, but if you give up bread, sugar, starch, etc, then soon you will not want sugar any longer.
Correct.
Hardcore Carnivore (grass fed beef) is a cure for many forms of cancer
Correct.
Hardcore Carnivore, mostly grass fed beef, is a cure for many types of cancer.
Just today watched this YT video: “ Try doing this 1 thing to your rice… It triggers and irreversible”
Cooling or freezing RICE, pastas,
creates a resistance starch that has many health benifits.
(wash rice first) then cook, then cool and put in freezer.
Spaghetti let cool then freeze.
Potatoes… Cool and put in fridge.
Bread in freezer
I stopped sugars, bad oils and flour/breads years ago, saved my life!
After seeing this video, I m going to try the rice method.
Re introduced white potato’s abt 8 mos. ago using steamed
potatoes, cooled in fridge over night. (with big gob of butter! HEAVEN!
In moderation of course!😇
@@jamesmoore5630 does this include raw honey and almonds as well?
Thank you, Dr Anderson. You just tipped me off to a couple of concerns I have to learn more about. Very important stuff and I had no problem with your presentation
Glad you enjoyed the video, thank you for your support. - Team Dr. A
Doc A. - I am really thankful you have begun your RUclips series. Learning so much from you. Keep up the good work. Pennsylvania sends you its blessings. ☺
Glad you're enjoying the channel! Thanks so much for the support. - Team Dr. A
The one study I know of that tied NAC to cancer was done in mice, and they were giving them something equivalent to 7000 mg/day for a 70 kg human. More research needs to be done.
Very helpful, thank you.
Excellent explanation. thank you!
Great talk however, we need a summary at the end of video please
The video covers several topics related to N-acetylcysteine (NAC), its uses, safety concerns, and implications in cancer treatment. Here’s a summary along with a fact-check on key points:
NAC and Cancer:
Claim: NAC can potentially strengthen certain cancer cells if they are exposed to it.
Fact Check: Research has shown mixed results. While NAC can promote the survival of normal cells by contributing to glutathione production, its impact on cancer cells varies. Some studies suggest that high levels of glutathione might help some cancer cells resist chemotherapy, whereas others indicate that antioxidants like NAC could potentially reduce cancer risk. However, the effect depends heavily on the type of cancer and its stage, as well as the overall health and treatment plan of the individual.
Safety of NAC in People with Sulfa Drug Allergies:
Claim: People with sulfa drug allergies might react to NAC because it contains sulfur.
Fact Check: Sulfa allergies are reactions to specific compounds found in sulfa drugs, not to sulfur itself, which is a natural element found in many substances, including NAC. The risk of cross-reactivity between sulfa drugs and NAC is generally low, but caution is advised for individuals with a history of severe drug allergies.
NAC and Respiratory Conditions:
Claim: NAC can be risky for individuals with reactive airway diseases like asthma because it can increase sulfite levels which may trigger asthma symptoms.
Fact Check: NAC is often used to treat respiratory conditions due to its mucolytic (mucus-thinning) properties and ability to support glutathione production, which is critical for maintaining lung health. However, individuals who are sulfite-sensitive may experience issues, as NAC can metabolize into sulfites. It is crucial for individuals with asthma to consult healthcare providers before starting NAC, particularly if they have known sulfite sensitivity.
NAC Smell and Side Effects:
Claim: NAC can have a sulfurous smell and can cause urine to smell similarly due to its sulfur content.
Fact Check: NAC does contain sulfur and has a characteristic sulfurous smell. This is normal and not indicative of product quality. It can also cause a sulfur-like odor in urine when metabolized, which is a harmless side effect.
The transcript provides accurate information based on current scientific understanding, with an emphasis on the nuanced effects of NAC in different medical scenarios. It rightly points out that individual responses can vary, stressing the importance of personalized medical advice from healthcare providers.
Wow ty
Where are these supplements coming from? I have never experienced any of this. NAC is a precursor to glutathione. I have had nothing but positive effects and I also take MSm
I thought glynac continous was good for life extension purposes. Letting the body do the intricate balancing and providing enough for glutathione.
I saw a video stating that a bill is being introduced to ban NAC and other helpful supplements for our safety supposedly. Must be these things do work therefore the need to suppress availability.
IF it´s being banned it´s probably good for us.
Hey Dr. A! It's Chris from Bastyr SD,.. I am a kind of gut guy, so, I always have the microbiome in the back of my mind. The healthy microbiome has a mucous layer that is protective to the endothelial lining... Can oral supplementation with N-A-C thin out and deplete the protective mucous lining in the gut?? I'm thinking of IBS, IBD and even diverticular disease patients.
NAC is way less toxic under every condition compared to “marinating “ cancer cells in sugar. How about a video on that doc? And in your presentation you imply that NAC will strengthen cancer in certain cases by… strengthening the dysfunctional mitochondria?????? You can’t have to both ways doc, either cancer is a disease of mitochondrial dysfunction or genes…
I think I'm more likely to get triggered by the choppy editing of this video than NAC
I appreciate the editing to make the video shorter and to the point.
Just listen to it and look away from it if you want valuable information from him
Wow. Why haven't I found you before? You really know biochemistry and shared more about NAC than I ever knew. I started my son on L-cysteine after his pesticide poisoning in second grade. Both plasma and urine tests showed he was low in cystine and taurine, and he had become chemically sensitive. It reduced his symptoms by about 70%. We went on to learn more about detox. I've worked with many chemically sensitive/poisoned people and we've used L-cysteine or NAC for years. But I didn't realize all the complications that you described. I did know one person with cystinuria who could not take it. Thanks for the education. I'm an instant fan.
what about using NAC for a biofilm buster? This has been recommended as a good way to break down biofilm. If not what would you recommend? Thank you
This is a great topic, we'll pass it on for a video - Team Dr. A
Could you please help me to respond if it is safe/helps for MCAS? As this was prescribed for endometriosis
There’s a dr. From England, a woman I think first name Tina (youtube) who recommends it for MCAS
All my questions have been answered
I’ve noticed I get anxiety and negative thought patterns pretty quick when I take anything with NAC. What kind of testing would I determine what my issues is with it and what type of doctor should I seek out for this?
It is not good for histamine intolarance people. That can be the cause of the anxiety.
It makes my allergy worse.
This is not good vid all in all. Lacks detail and depth. Does nothing positive.
He got enough mileage out of NAC having made 6-8 clips on it. He finally killed it by scaring people off with cancer-getting -stronger without specifying which cancers. To me, he seems like a fake!😅
What type of dose is what you call marinating?
thanks
So if somebody has asthma or a little bit of sulfur or sulphate issue. Or do we cycle it like you said in your video
@Begeye-bh5ux I notice nothing taking it. But I have sulfa allergy though
If you think NAC smells bad, try Valerian Root.😂
This is true. It really pongs 😂
I wish I had a doctor with a Jethro Tull album cover framed on his office wall!
Satanist doctors are the best..
How can sulfite be removed from the body? Read that l-Citruline acts to do this.
I have SLE and discoid lupus. History of hep C treated in 2014. Hepascore of 2. My fatigue is so bad I cannot stand it. WBC 3.5 max. Goes down with infections. Complements WNL but on the lower side. CRP and sed rate normal and usually are. Do you think it would be ok to try reduced glutathione or NAC?
Make sure to discuss with your integrative provider! You'll want someone who knows your case and can monitor your response to any therapies - Team Dr. A
Thank you for addressing the NAC/cancer issue. Does this mean that otherwise healthy people should not take NAC everyday for longevity purposes?
Good question! I've been taking 1200 mg - 2400 mg a day, every day...
Some suggests taking breaks
I've taken NAC every day for years because it was supposed to be good for you. Guess I should take a break.
no one here has an answer?
@MarquosXoloVanda I watched the video again and his biggest response to everything he brought up was "it depends." I think basically he said not to flood your cells with it everyday. Take a break. I'm going to just start taking it 3-4 days week, instead of everyday.
what about nac for nafld?
I have a sensitivity to sulfatrim . Can I have an allergic reaction ?
Who edited the choppy speech patterns into this video? VERY VERY ANNOYING.
Does Glycine helps with assimilation of NAC?
There is a study that shows a correlation between NAC and arthritis. Normally, I would not give much on it because it is just a correlation and no causative effect was proven. But I also experienced joint pain several times while being on NAC with and without glycine. So now I am kind of worried if there is a causal effect, not just a correlation. My guess is that glynac should be dosed in a way to improve gutathione, but not more than necessary, making bloodwork a must to figure out the optimal dose to decrease the chance for side effects. Or maybe not take it at all.
I've been taking it for years & don't suffer joint pain. I also haven't had so much as the sniffles since I started taking it 5 years ago. Covid never touched my family as we all take NAC.
@@carrierichardson6619 how much do you take? Do you take it with glycine? Do you take any other antioxidants?
I've done a 3 year study on NAC at 2,000 mg per day and I feel great.
Cancer? I'd be worried if I were vaccinated with mRNA and DNA fragments.
I would not want to dissuade the vaccinated from taking NAC or even augmented NAC.
Please see the related section on NAC & Cancer for how one might change dosing during cancer treatment - this can be discussed with managing physicians. - Team Dr. A
How about NAD+ and Myeloma
So i got a complex cyst on kidney still waiting for ultra sound appt .. i shouldnt take NAC?
Seems to flare my Psoriasis even at low doses
Don't thy use it to detox Tylenol overdose.
I take 600mg a day of NAC for bipolar disorder and have done for a long time. I've found it beneficial. I'm a little concerned about your safety warning, but I believe 600mg is a fairly conservative dose. I'm loathe to stop taking it, but a little concerned about it now.
This guy probably pushed the jab
NAC makes me dream in high definition. It’s insane. I’m not sure what it does to the brain to cause that but when I wake up I feel like I just lived a whole different life in my dream. I read it can cause kidney stones. Not sure if that’s true but as someone who has them in the past i really don’t want to experience that again. It does improve my breathing / oxygen levels according to my smart watch.
Is that why I've been having vivid dreams??? And even started turning to nightmares.. I assumed it was the melatonin but I stopped taking melatonin and the vivid dreams keep happening. I wonder why it would cause kidney stones
I always had vivid dreams now started NAC, no dreams.
@@dawnstead3329 that's so weird i wonder what's going on there and why it does the opposite for some people
The hands never stop✋
Dr Anderson, how do I remove heavy metals with a supplement or more natural method? Thank you.
Chlorella
zeolite and activated carbon
QQQ How and why is NAC beneficial for cystic fibrosis
It breaks down mucus, prevents scarring, fibrosis
I take Nac with lysine, arginine, glycine, and Serine. I also take a booster for nitric oxide. I take enough Glutathione to make sure the gut does not run out.
Oral NAC bioavalibility is very low.... Need to find a more effective way to input it into the body....
Wow I have been taking NAC for 8months
For liver support bc of MCAS.. now this.. WTH..
It's not all bad, make sure to watch the whole video to get a full sense of the pros and cons. -Team Dr. A
Also can take glutathione create asthma issues is that what you’re saying
I noticed that this last time, a lot of factcheck about supplements are active on this platform. I wonder who paye them. He’s not even a Doctor.
It is important to note that when you are young glutathione levels tend to be higher and as you age they decrease.
I've heard it's important to take NAC with glycine. Why is that?
Check out the other video about GlyNAC - Team Dr. A
@@DrA-Online thanks
Like they were banned in USA Covid times…
If they banned it for use when it was recommended in the Covid suggested remedies along with other supplements, it has to be beneficial as Pharma outlawed any “treatments” including iverm€ct!n.
You didnt really explain the mechanism why one shouldnt use NAC all the time in the case of cancer. Very blurry response.
I take it everyday 500mg. Can it effect psychiatric drugs?
There are certain cancers that are more dangerous to younger people, likely for similar reasons, there bodies are replete with the very things that make you cells run strong.
I had skin reaction to NAC, Dr called it folliculitis. Anyone else have this?
WOW I HAVE BEEN TRYING TO FIGURE OUT WHATS WRONG WITH MY SKIN AND THIS IS POSSIBLY IT.. I WILL STOP TAKING NAC AND SEE. THANKS FOR SAYING SOMETHING,
What was your skin reaction? I had skin rash.
NAC made me sick as hell. Felt like nitric oxide poisoning.
You also had nitric oxide poisoning?!
@@Psi-Inkthats what it felt like but im not sure. I felt the same kind of sick like i do when i eat beets. But it also coul have been hydrogen sulfide poisoning or massive ROS release or possibly all of the above.
❤
Sulfur molecule Glutathione is a substance made from the amino acids glycine, cysteine, and glutamic acid. It is produced by the liver and involved in many body processes. Glutathione is involved in tissue building and repair, making chemicals and proteins needed in the body, and in immune system function
No. NAC is worth any of the risks.
Elaborate?
@@MarquosXoloVanda The goverment wants to ban it
Whomever is responsible for the captions placed on the screen (by the content creator-not via autogenerated) needs to learn how to spell.
NAC has shown to increase lifespan of CKD patients by more than thirty percent.
What is CHD?
Chronic kidney disease
@@heidiscorestrengthpilatesa1283 you know what else is good for that... a teaspoon of baking soda in a glass of water every morning:)
Government doesn't want you to have it period! That says alot !
Respiratory. Check your sp.
NAC causes anhedonia is some people including myself.
Well, that's no fun! (Ba-dum-TSSH!)
but are you too old to rock and roll, & too young to die?
No actionable information here.
Buy MSTR
Well that was no practical help.
First of all don't believe a word of this .
Nice fear porn "doctor"
Dangerous? You click bait hack...
Nice, took down the idea for later thanks! - Team Dr. A