I am from kashmir..watching your videos since 2015. I felt that the old traditional software of my mind have been changed into progressive one..❤ Long live sir.
I'm doing an assignment on Dialectical Materialism. This was better than any philosophical or political science lecture I've ever had in my university.
I am a great admirer and follower of Com. Taimur Rahman. I have also met with him in Kolkata, India and had a full length discussion on the Class Struggle situation in Pakistan in the year 2015 or 2016 under the banner of Kisan Mazdoor, the Urdu party weekly organ of C. P. I. (M) West Bengal state committee.We were not only satisfied with his explanation, but for the first time we learned that apart from a very weak class struggle in Pakistan, one of the main problem and setback is reason behind unprecedented rise and over all control of CORRUPTION and DISHONESTY at every level of the Government Administration as well as of the society as a whole. I am still following all his political classes and lectures since then. Both the countries toiling masses are fighting and struggling for the same goal that is SOCIALISM, an explanation fee society and CORRUPTION free nation. And one day "WE SHALL OVER COME."
I am a student of software engineering. In previous semester accidently watch one of the video from history of philosophy playlist. And then i watch whole playlist it was really not only interesting but change my way of thinking. You are such a wonderful person and a teacher. Thanks for teaching us.
While l was doing graduate work in chemistry at lmperial College London, l used to attend seminars on this topic at London school of economics. Now listening in urdu is like سونے پر سوھاگا۔ Prof.Dr Nasir Fazal Cambridge
person sir your lectures are so useful for me I am aspirant of CSS and I cannot afford heavy academic fees so you are more reliable person for me on online platform
I really appreciate your effort sir to explain this philosophy of socilaizm in such a beautiful way...I hope it will leave huge impact on people's mind and I really enjoyed your session
I am really very happy to see a Pakistani intelligent having such command on these things. Whenever I've tried to get some conceptual clearance through watching videos, I've always found Indians and no doubt, they are really talented and well learned. Now I am happy to see Pakistani intelligentsia coming forward. Proud of you Sir.
I am a strict Islamist and right-winger but a philosophy enthusiast and I think it's a blessing we have philosophy teachers like Dr. Sahab who have accessible style, explain with wit and without any ideological bias.
بہت بہترین لیکچر۔ کامریڈ میں شروع میں سوچ رہی تھی کہ آپ کیسے عام آدمی کو اتنا مشکل فلسفہ سمجھا پائیں گے۔ لیکچر سننے کے بعد دل سے دعا نکلی کہ آپ کو اس مشن میں کامیابی ہو گو کہ میں جانتی ہوں کہ آپ کو دعا کی ضرورت نہیں بلکہ لوگوں کے ساتھ کی ضرورت ہے۔ لیکن دعا میں بھی کوئی حرج نہیں۔ بیسٹ آف لک اور لال سلام
Comrade taimour Rehman you are doing jihad against them Allah give you a great reward just awesome I have never seen such a great teacher in my life ever in Pakistan Allah bless you
I have been your follower for a long time, a big fan, ever since i watched your first lecture i been wondering why a great learned person like you dont get involved in politics, dont you think that you can make a bigger difference and a much bigger impact being in politics,? it truly is a blessing to have people like you in our society
In Pakistan, the politicians come from landlord (zamindar) families. The crowd also support them blindly. The socioeconomic condition of the mass will never change unless there is representation from the others. In Bangladesh, we are lucky that the 22 richest families (present during East Pakistan period) are now abolished.
Sir I am following you for last 2,3 years and there are very few channels like that of yours.Sir,I have some questions that always come in my mind while watching your lectures related to the "Hakoomat" to be given to "Mazdoors" and "Kisaaans" 1.Sir i believe that collecting the wealth or having the ownership is very natural process.From honey bees to ants every living organism thinks of his own community his own relatives his own closed ones-as you are talking about your closed ones:the mazdoors and kisaaans. 2.If mazdoors are given the rule,there would be again a set of people within those mazdoors who will be ruling,and again resulting in class difference. 3.If a mazdoor becomes the head of Packages mall,a guard becomes head of ittefaq foundries than who will be there to invest-more precisely how will the economies grow. 4.I believe that the very impetus behind technological, scientific, literary growth is the thought to have more,if mazdoors are given the rule, everything will start to stagnante,and growth and progress will slow down. 5.Sir, you were talking about equal opportunities,but your talk was itself self contradictory.At one point you talked about the physical differences among humans.If one is physically more stronger than there are equal chances that one can be mentally more stronger,more intelligent than others.One may have more leadership skills,and the other might have the aptitude to help or serve the leader.So if there are differences in human's physical and mental capabilities than why would they be treated equally?why would they have the same class? 6.Sir being very humble and knowing that i have very limited knowledge and a very average mind.The idea of giving power to Mazdoors and kisaan seems very unrealistic.However,the basic needs: education, justice and health should be given to all. Please shed light on these question.Regards
1. Animals collect means of sustenance. They do not create wealth. Creation of wealth is the result of purposive productive activity (labour), which is unique to humans. 2. Class differences are based on ownership of property. Not every form of hierarchy is a class difference. 3. The surplus created from every socialist enterprise will be invested either by the managing board of that enterprise or by the state at the national level especially for mega project. 4. Why would mazdoors not have the impetus to improve their lives? If the impetus belongs to all of humanity, it therefore also must belong to the majority of humanity (the working population). 5. I talk about end of class exploitation. Differences in physical and intellectual abilities will always remain. We have no issue with such differences. They are part of life. 6. That is the dominant idea of the dominating class. That without the super rich billionaires the world would stop working. I hardly think so. I think people like you are perfectly capable of running this world collectively and democratically and running it better than the super rich billionaires.
I am really honoured to have a reply from such a worthy person.Sir I have some counter questions too. 1.If accumulation of resources or simply having better living conditions than his other competitors is not a construvive idea than why would one think about new ideas,new businesses.One would be living in a comfort zone, where his every need would be fulfilled by the state having no pushing factor to do more resulting in slowdown of everything.For example the difference between the mindsets,the attitudes and the skillsets of managers and workers of MNCs and the SOEs makes the sense more clearer that how would a state or system look like where there would be no impetus for collecting wealth or having the ownership of resources. 2. Sir,if class difference is only the result of ownership of property,and not on the base that whether one belongs to the leadership class, military or policy making class or belongs to lower working class like sanitary workers than what you would say about the class difference in Hinduism.Is'nt it the result of different roles not the ownership?How does it make sense that one labourer building a house and the other making the economic policies within a same state would be in a same socio economic class? 3.Sir in this scenario there would be a group of people who would be in Managing board making the policies for others.It means that they will have more power than the others resulting in class difference.If you say that there would be checks and balances on those managing boards than it can be concluded that the real problem is related to strong accountibilty mechanisms, tight rules and efficient governance structures-not changing the system itself. 4.Sir why the billionaires are considered 'Firooons'.Billionaires spend more in CSR than the total budget of many countries.Billionaires create employment,create comfort. Billionaires like Elon Musk,Jeff Bezos, Zuckerberg are all first generation billionaires and no one is the son of any American President or a relative of any influencial personality,but they have achieved this through their own revolutionary ideas,hardwork and consistency. 5.Sir I believe accumulation of resources is the result of living organism's characteristic of competing for more .If there is no competion and everything easily comes at the doorstep than why would one put the effort.Bani Israel stands as a pertinent example.They were not even happy with 'Man o Salva'. Regards.
Beautiful lecture, introduction was also nice, a request for you The terminology which u use in Urdu, keep repeating it in English too, bcz here in India mny people struggle to understand, wrds like تاریخ، مفادات، اجتماعی ، تقسیم، وغیرہ۔۔۔۔۔ already u are doing so in ur lecture. ur lecture is received very well , only a few wrds to be repeated in English too. ur lecture on economy , politicsis circuleted widely in progressive circle in India.
![Mod Phil 9: Religion is the Opium of the Masses [Urdu]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X9CwaE0joLc/mqdefault.jpg)
I am from kashmir..watching your videos since 2015. I felt that the old traditional software of my mind have been changed into progressive one..❤ Long live sir.
@Humaira Asghar u from Pakistan na?
Friend, I am too a fan of Dr. Taimoor. But believe me, don't get carried away so easily. It's always better to listen to the other PoV as well.
आपकी उम्मीद रँग लाये आप आपकी जैसी सोच वाले काम याब हों आमीन
I'm doing an assignment on Dialectical Materialism. This was better than any philosophical or political science lecture I've ever had in my university.
He speaks volumes... I have never seen such a great teacher from Pakistan on RUclips, mostly are Indians.
I am a great admirer and follower of Com. Taimur Rahman. I have also met with him in Kolkata, India and had a full length discussion on the Class Struggle situation in Pakistan in the year 2015 or 2016 under the banner of Kisan Mazdoor, the Urdu party weekly organ of C. P. I. (M) West Bengal state committee.We were not only satisfied with his explanation, but for the first time we learned that apart from a very weak class struggle in Pakistan, one of the main problem and setback is reason behind unprecedented rise and over all control of CORRUPTION and DISHONESTY at every level of the Government Administration as well as of the society as a whole. I am still following all his political classes and lectures since then. Both the countries toiling masses are fighting and struggling for the same goal that is SOCIALISM, an explanation fee society and CORRUPTION free nation. And one day "WE SHALL OVER COME."
I am a student of software engineering.
In previous semester accidently watch one of the video from history of philosophy playlist.
And then i watch whole playlist it was really not only interesting but change my way of thinking.
You are such a wonderful person and a teacher. Thanks for teaching us.
While l was doing graduate work in chemistry at lmperial College London, l used to attend seminars on this topic at London school of economics.
Now listening in urdu is like سونے پر سوھاگا۔
Prof.Dr Nasir Fazal Cambridge
You speak the words of my heart.Allah bless you sir.
person sir your lectures are so useful for me I am aspirant of CSS and I cannot afford heavy academic fees so you are more reliable person for me on online platform
Kia alfaz hain ❤️❤️❤️ pakistan pa ap jaisay insano ki zarorat ha jo logon ko is apni value se roshnas karway apni taqat ka istamal sikhayen
ڈاکٹر صاحب آپ عام آدمی کی سمجھ کے مطابق لیکچر دیا ھے بہت خوب جناب خوش رہیں سلامت رہیں
Salute you sir.
Ur really doing a great job.
Lot of respect.
ایک فوجی کا سلیوٹ ہے آپکو
Comrade Professor ko Lal Salaam ✊🏽❤️
Plz don't stop this series. U will be the Allama iqbal for this deplorable nation ❤️
Great Lecture! Salute to you! Dialectical Materialism. Mazour Kisan Party - Zindabad. To educate the working class. Class Struggle.
I really appreciate your effort sir to explain this philosophy of socilaizm in such a beautiful way...I hope it will leave huge impact on people's mind and I really enjoyed your session
eye opening. one of your best.
I wish we could get instructors like you in every institution.
I am really very happy to see a Pakistani intelligent having such command on these things. Whenever I've tried to get some conceptual clearance through watching videos, I've always found Indians and no doubt, they are really talented and well learned. Now I am happy to see Pakistani intelligentsia coming forward. Proud of you Sir.
I am a strict Islamist and right-winger but a philosophy enthusiast and I think it's a blessing we have philosophy teachers like Dr. Sahab who have accessible style, explain with wit and without any ideological bias.
زبردست شکریہ مشکل موضوع پے لیکن آپ مے بہت اچھے طریقے سے اور آسانی سے سمجھایا۔ بہت شکریہ
Very informative. Always converse with language of the common people.
Punjabi vach samjawan da bht he shukria.❤😘
Jazakallahu khaira for updating authentically
Sir, Simply you are commendable.
following you for 4 years now and just want join you in your movement one day
the present situation on Pakistan confirms your analysis
Simply wonderful and true, love you Dr Taimor
excellent lecture. Thanks a lot
Really wonderful knowledgeably bite
Excellent lecture and fully understandable as this in simple language of Punjabi and Urdu easily understood by most of the people,thanks from India
When you're so into the lecture that you switch from Urdu to Panjabi. Mashallah!
I am from Indian kashmir, watching you since 2014
بہت بہترین لیکچر۔ کامریڈ میں شروع میں سوچ رہی تھی کہ آپ کیسے عام آدمی کو اتنا مشکل فلسفہ سمجھا پائیں گے۔
لیکچر سننے کے بعد دل سے دعا نکلی کہ آپ کو اس مشن میں کامیابی ہو گو کہ میں جانتی ہوں کہ آپ کو دعا کی ضرورت نہیں بلکہ لوگوں کے ساتھ کی ضرورت ہے۔ لیکن دعا میں بھی کوئی حرج نہیں۔ بیسٹ آف لک اور لال سلام
دل سے دعا نکلتی۔۔۔۔۔۔ ہاں کوئ ہے جو اس میٹیریل دنیا سے ماوراء ہے۔ بہت ہی اعلی لیکچر۔
ALLAH pak app ko apni haf zo aman may rakhy
AMEEN
One of the my best utuber mentor,thanx sir i learnt a lot of your lectures.
Comrade taimour Rehman you are doing jihad against them Allah give you a great reward just awesome I have never seen such a great teacher in my life ever in Pakistan Allah bless you
Allah bless on comrade??????🤣
I am also freedom movement activist and ramdomly found this channel
Inshallah sir one day your dream come to be true....
Laal salam comrade Taimur!
omg.. you are an inspiration, sir!
Excellent work sir to aware people
Wah, wah, wah...you are my new HERO!!
He is a pure person , seems much like bhutto ,
His concept is soo clear , it's awesome and much Worthy while watching and listening you ,
Respect ❤️
May you always be happy and healthy
Laal salam and love from India sir ❤️
आपका की चर्चाएं बहुत ही सही व अच्छी लगीं।
स्टॅलिन के विषय पर आपके विचार जानना चाहता हूँ।
A big Thanks from India
Slaute sir,you are doing great job.Jazak Allah
Wao great teacher .lst time these concept in Urdu...
Informative lecture
I m from india ,,upsc me philosophy liya aap video toooooo good hai sirji,,bas kabhi kabhi urdu samaj nahi ati
Am preparing for upsc too and sir's lectures are useful for my psir optional
@Hannibal Ad Portas english
جیسے ہم آ پ کی بھاشا سمجھتے ہیں، آ پ بھی ویسے ہی سمجھنے کی کوشش کریں۔۔۔
Hello. You'll gradually learn, dear. Try to understand the words in context or use Rekhta Dictionary. It has the feature of Roman Urdu to Hindi :)
Great lecture by Dr Taimoor. Love it
Best best best lecture by a great man.
EXCELLENT educational, comrade. Thank you.
U too r excellent
Much appreciated sir... Stay safe and blessed 🥰
I have been your follower for a long time, a big fan, ever since i watched your first lecture i been wondering why a great learned person like you dont get involved in politics, dont you think that you can make a bigger difference and a much bigger impact being in politics,? it truly is a blessing to have people like you in our society
He is a politician bhai saaaab
Very very Educational thanks comrade
You are Excellent Sir. I like you very much.
Islam is the only solution for every problem in the world like economic, and social problems etc
دوئی ( تضاد)
نفس امارہ (thesis )
نفس لوامہ ( anti thesis)
Synthesis
نفس مطمئنہ
Amazing explanation, comrade. Bahut madadgar.
it's remarkable sir..
and thank you for your great message..
Oh. What a teacher? Salute sir.
Stunning lecture sir!
No words to praise your effort. Really inspiring teacher.
Exceptional explanation!!!
No words to say May Allah bless you and us (mazdor class) with success Ameen
There's no allah in communism
You are national treasure sir
sir i am convinced.... and i support your agenda ..
But you need to continue questioning , Marxism is a science which cannot progress without questioning
Zabardast lecture ever...👏👏👏
Sir please make a series of Muslim political thought
In Pakistan, the politicians come from landlord (zamindar) families. The crowd also support them blindly. The socioeconomic condition of the mass will never change unless there is representation from the others. In Bangladesh, we are lucky that the 22 richest families (present during East Pakistan period) are now abolished.
My favorite teacher
Very Informative sir!
Greatest conclusion class interest
Level level sir you have made it easy as pie
Tremendous
Red salute comrade. Your explanation is tremendous.
What a great teacher he is bravo
Very well Done Sir.....Fan of you
Good one sir I always wait for your informative lecture
Sir u r doing a wonderful job MAY ALLAH BE with you
Pagal ho gaya hy ..... is ki nazar paraye paisoun per hy .... k os ko gareeboun myn batay ..... apna dheela nahe daina
Well done sir, You are great. love from Quetta city.
Excellent, Thanks a lot Sir I appreciate your hard work.
Mashallla Allah sir g Stay blessed
I think that today i have got something new and special
Weldone Comrade long live working class.
You are very talented sir.❤❤❤
Asalamu alaikum
Very beautiful lecture, may Allah bless you.
From......Kashmir
Taking online classes but still dependent until watching your lecturers.
Well, nicely explained sir!!
Sir I am following you for last 2,3 years and there are very few channels like that of yours.Sir,I have some questions that always come in my mind while watching your lectures related to the "Hakoomat" to be given to "Mazdoors" and "Kisaaans"
1.Sir i believe that collecting the wealth or having the ownership is very natural process.From honey bees to ants every living organism thinks of
his own community his own relatives his own closed ones-as you are talking about your closed ones:the mazdoors and kisaaans.
2.If mazdoors are given the rule,there would be again a set of people within those mazdoors who will be ruling,and again resulting in class difference.
3.If a mazdoor becomes the head of Packages mall,a guard becomes head of ittefaq foundries than who will be there to invest-more precisely how will the economies grow.
4.I believe that the very impetus behind technological, scientific, literary growth is the thought to have more,if mazdoors are given the rule, everything will start to stagnante,and growth and progress will slow down.
5.Sir, you were talking about equal opportunities,but your talk was itself self contradictory.At one point you talked about the physical differences among humans.If one is physically more stronger than there are equal chances that one can be mentally more stronger,more intelligent than others.One may have more leadership skills,and the other might have the aptitude to help or serve the leader.So if there are differences in human's physical and mental capabilities than why would they be treated equally?why would they have the same class?
6.Sir being very humble and knowing that i have very limited knowledge and a very average mind.The idea of giving power to Mazdoors and kisaan seems very unrealistic.However,the basic needs: education, justice and health should be given to all.
Please shed light on these question.Regards
1. Animals collect means of sustenance. They do not create wealth. Creation of wealth is the result of purposive productive activity (labour), which is unique to humans.
2. Class differences are based on ownership of property. Not every form of hierarchy is a class difference.
3. The surplus created from every socialist enterprise will be invested either by the managing board of that enterprise or by the state at the national level especially for mega project.
4. Why would mazdoors not have the impetus to improve their lives? If the impetus belongs to all of humanity, it therefore also must belong to the majority of humanity (the working population).
5. I talk about end of class exploitation. Differences in physical and intellectual abilities will always remain. We have no issue with such differences. They are part of life.
6. That is the dominant idea of the dominating class. That without the super rich billionaires the world would stop working. I hardly think so. I think people like you are perfectly capable of running this world collectively and democratically and running it better than the super rich billionaires.
I am really honoured to have a reply from such a worthy person.Sir I have some counter questions too.
1.If accumulation of resources or simply having better living conditions than his other competitors is not a construvive idea than why would one think about new ideas,new businesses.One would be living in a comfort zone, where his every need would be fulfilled by the state having no pushing factor to do more resulting in slowdown of everything.For example the difference between the mindsets,the attitudes and the skillsets of managers and workers of MNCs and the SOEs makes the sense more clearer that how would a state or system look like where there would be no impetus for collecting wealth or having the ownership of resources.
2. Sir,if class difference is only the result of ownership of property,and not on the base that whether one belongs to the leadership class, military or policy making class or belongs to lower working class like sanitary workers than what you would say about the class difference in Hinduism.Is'nt it the result of different roles not the ownership?How does it make sense that one labourer building a house and the other making the economic policies within a same state would be in a same socio economic class?
3.Sir in this scenario there would be a group of people who would be in Managing board making the policies for others.It means that they will have more power than the others resulting in class difference.If you say that there would be checks and balances on those managing boards than it can be concluded that the real problem is related to strong accountibilty mechanisms, tight rules and efficient governance structures-not changing the system itself.
4.Sir why the billionaires are considered 'Firooons'.Billionaires spend more in CSR than the total budget of many countries.Billionaires create employment,create comfort. Billionaires like Elon Musk,Jeff Bezos, Zuckerberg are all first generation billionaires and no one is the son of any American President or a relative of any influencial personality,but they have achieved this through their own revolutionary ideas,hardwork and consistency.
5.Sir I believe accumulation of resources is the result of living organism's characteristic of competing for more .If there is no competion and everything easily comes at the doorstep than why would one put the effort.Bani Israel stands as a pertinent example.They were not even happy with 'Man o Salva'.
Regards.
Thanks 😊 comrade for this one 👍🏻
Red salute comrade... Thank you
Lal salaam comrade.Surkh hoga Hindustan,surkh hoga Pakistan,Surkh hoga saara jahaan.
Please deliver full length lectures on Existentialism in Urdu with all its aspects its implementation in modern times
Laal salaam Comrade Taimur 🔨 🌾
The transition from academic to impassioned transition from Urdu to Punjabi 😂
Beautiful lecture, introduction was also nice,
a request for you The terminology which u use in Urdu,
keep repeating it in English too,
bcz here in India mny people struggle to understand,
wrds like تاریخ، مفادات، اجتماعی ، تقسیم، وغیرہ۔۔۔۔۔
already u are doing so in ur lecture.
ur lecture is received very well , only a few wrds to be repeated in English too.
ur lecture on economy , politicsis circuleted widely in progressive circle in India.
Good to see you. He is teaching to working class.
Very informative
looking forward to join mazdoor kisan party as a passionate worker
Excellent .....