Support those in the fight against gender ideology and SHARE this video: Billboard Chris www.billboardchris.com/ Andy Ngo www.andy-ngo.com/ Savanah Hernandez www.savsaysofficial.com/ Matt Thornton mattthornton.org/ Honey Badger Mom twitter.com/hunnybadgermom?lang=en
Honestly, I am sorry to say but I think that we are about 10 years away from actual murderous Chinese Red Guard levels of violence in this country. I just the stuff that my neighbors 9 year olds are learning in school, in 10 years these 9 year olds will be 19 year olds, And this revolutionary ideology will be their entire worldview and the core of their identity. I think we are headed to an American Holodomor.
I'm reminded of the words of Margaret Mead, "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has." Keep up this great work!!!
There was an actual study that showed if you can get 25% of people behind you, you change convince the other 75%. It's not just a nice quote; it's's a real thing that can happen. There is hope to fix this mess the country is falling into. 🙏
It’s sad it’s a small group.. most people are terrified of speaking up.. the violence and threats towards people who value the facts and the MAJORITY OF THE PLANET AGREES.. is criminal and insane! I DONT understand how this has happened.. so quickly.. THE INSANITY IS ABHORRENT.. and kids are suffering.
Jesus… “they know from the moment they can express themselves”. Really?! I just turned 34, and I’ve been on cross-sex hormones for 18 years. I’ve had a Colovaginoplasty. I’ve been wrong about my “gender” twice! And now de-transition is on the table. Everything I’ve learned about psychology and how the human mind works directly contradicts this idea that “we just know.” We don’t know shit. I’ve been tired of depression and chronic procrastination, so much so that this month I’ve let go; no more fighting. I dived so deep into my emotional troubles and childhood trauma caused by my dad something finally clicked. Here is what I found out just today after talking with my mom about my dad. When I visited him, I could never predict when I would get into trouble, What was ok or not. Because it depended on whether or not they were having meth withdrawals. I would get screamed at. Seeing no apparent pattern, my only option was to retreat inward. When I would shut down and retreat into my imagination, he would shame me and tell me to be a man, over and over. He would then repeatedly poke, push, and provoke. Like I was some dog in a cage… pure survival mode. The more he repeated it, the deeper I would go, “I wish I were a girl”, “if I were a girl, maybe he wouldn’t treat me like this.” The man was sadistic. His girlfriend was precisely the same. My whole life, when things got bad, I would fall deeper and deeper into gender dysphoria. Ancient legacy survival software installed deep. Because he kept poking and provoking me until I would snap like a dog. I was 7 years old… I had to comb through the entirety of my "lived experience" just to see this knot of trauma. It’s taken me 25 years to get to this point. It’s been a hell of a fucking day… My Street Epistemology journey begins now. I can’t stand on the sidelines anymore.
I get that too, albeit the opposite way as I'm female. I'm sorry you had to experience that, it really sucks to be pressured into old gender roles that aren't even healthy or even realistic isn't it. I got betrayed & molested on 4th grade, betrayed & almost groomed in middle school by a private guitar teacher, not to mention being limited in what I'm allowed to do, to have, to say, to wear, to be etc just because I'm a girl, and so at middle school I kept thinking "I wish I was a boy". So I don't have to be molested, underestimated, limited. Thankfully I got out of that by highschool, where my crush who's a girl told me "but if you were a guy, then we wouldn't have been friends and everything". Slowly realizing that what I don't actually wanna be a guy - what I really wanted was to just not be molested, underestimated and limited. Which I can fight for without changing myself entirely. Ironically though, from the beginning I already was a tomboy. As I grew away from the thought of being a guy, the people who emphasize gender in everything still baffles me all the same. By society's definition, I'm barely a girl & closer to a guy, without even trying. In the end, whenever my surrounding people are very gender-minded people who like to box people into 2 distinct gendered traits, I bid good luck to them as I'll not fit in either of them. lol.
So sorry you went through that. Many--maybe even most--kids have gender dysphoria because of some form of trauma. We used to know and accept that. But now, acknowledging that fact and trying to find out what that trauma is/was is called "conversion therapy." It's infuriating, because they aren't getting the help they need. Godspeed on your street epistemology journey, btw.
@@kristinandersen7790 Thank you! I appreciate the support. I'm sure I will connect eventually. I'll start with a blog and some Street Epistemology videos. I have a hard time reaching out. Maybe establishing myself online first would help.
@@jjQlLlLq I'm so sorry you had to go through that. No one deserves to be treated like that. Yeah, the ironies are glaring. There is no goal or destination with this stuff. Anyways, I hope things are improving. Thank you for sharing your experience.
He's playing a lot of language games and is effective rhetorically but I wouldn't call him informed. However, to people uninformed on the topic or that agree with his points he may sound convincing
Chris has a very soothing voice. It has a gentle and sincere tone like Morgan Freemans voice. He’s also well informed on this subject. He has done his homework. Not repeating slogans like the other side.
@@drpeterboghossian no, my dude, thank you for your insight, which is incisive, though your roleplay skills leave a little to be desired.😅May The Lord guide all your paths in this fight.
Thoroughly enjoyed this Peter. Same with the Keri Smith interview. Great work. It's a shame these important conversations are so difficult to get in front of the right people who desperately need to hear them.
"2 sexes, zero genders, and infinite personalities!" Protecting our children is definitely "on the right side of history." "Our kids our beautiful just the way they are."😍 Go Chris🤗
I'm not a smart man but sitting around a table, eating pizza and just talking with intellectuals sounds like a great way to spend an afternoon. Looking forward to watching this discussion.
That would depend heavily on which "intellectuals".... pick a random handful of supposed intellectuals from almost any modern University and you'd likely get a struggle session rather than a stimulating conversation.
When it comes to protecting children, Chris is the absolute best!! And his comment here gives me a lot of hope, "We're not dealing with a million evil people pushing this. We're dealing with a million uninformed people pushing this."
Thank you so much to all of you for speaking up and doing all this work. I am still trying to find my own path to help. Also as a lesbian I would be so glad if the LGB just left the alphabet and the queer theory all together.
I think that’s necessary for the LGB to survive, not just because the TQs are trying to trans the gay away in young people, but also because acceptance of LGB people has declined in recent years because people can’t separate us from the TQs. They’ve really ruined a lot. I hope you find some good people to work with if you end up fighting this ideology. Stay safe! #LGBDropTheT
"There's no one right way to be a boy or girl ... Our kids are beautiful just the way they are, what are we doing cutting off their genitals?" That was dead-on perfect!! That was one of numerous highlights of this fantastic discussion.
This is a good example of the vast majority of people who love these kinds of echo chambers, too dumb to realize that's exactly what this is. It saddens me to think that Peter hooked so many people by pretending to be open minded, when in reality he's just another right wing ideologue.
Thank you for your work. I changed my mind on this topic. Two three years ago I was tolerant to transgender idea. What is the harm? But then the violent mob started attacks on twitter. Why is JK Rowling so evil I asked myself and started looking for answers. I am glad some random video (Peter's) from Portland uni about "harming by asking" helped to open my eyes. Why are students so afraid to have a discussion? Then What is a woman? and Tavistock and more.... Many greetings from Prague.
1:28:50: "We think we're this advanced society, because we have all this technology. Psychologically we're the same." Chris hits the nail on the head with this one. It's hubris, plain and simple. The idea that we can so easily fix what nature got so obviously "wrong" by using medication and surgeries. Of course humans are medically and psychologically flawed, but before you intervene the burden of proof needs to be met. When it comes to chopping healthy body parts off of children, the bar needs to be incredibly high.
What a great conversation. Mr Boghossian you should put this on podcast as well for reaching more folks. Just look at any of America's issues today and most of them are self inflicted issues from manufactured crisis. Savannah hit the nail on the head about George Floyd. Chris is on top of his game. I get Andy not being very optimistic, because it's like a cancer just eating away at everything.
Thanks Peter and Chris and the rest of the guys there. Trying to educate and help people who have for whatever reason lost their grip on reality is not easy.
@@ReverendDr.Thomas In a general sense ones reality will differ from other peoples. Reality, in the context of the subject being discussed here, can be summed up in two words, and the lady used those two words during the discussion " common sense " so I just use common sense to come to my conclusion, and that is the reality of the situation.
Thanks for what you do, all of you. It is greatly appreciated. I don't want my kids harmed by this or anyone else. I still can't believe that people are telling these lies and harming kids and adults like this. You're all very well spoken and reasonable people. And Savannah you're beautiful. Thank all of you for what you do. Much love from Maine
Thank you for your efforts, dedication and optimism. I feel Andy is right - you have most of the educational, medical and woke corporate entities working against you as they are obeying the demands of the cult and their financiers.
Amazing discussion. Billboard Chris is just... chef's kiss. He GETS it! I also always appreciate how Peter is willing to stand on the fence in order to tease out the most compelling argument.
I can tell everyone loves Chris. They just wish he wasn’t always on the edge of vocal activation and was a bit better at sharing the conversation space. Great conversation either way, and Chris does always have relevant and interesting things to say.
This is one of the best talks I have found to give to those who are skeptical about what’s going on. I am going to share with my brother in law, who thinks I am a conspiracy theorist for believing this stuff is happening. He is one of those who are sadly un-informed!
The truth will come out. All of you keep pushing!! Billboard Chris your passion and belief for this to change is amazing. This is a spiritual battle and God will have the last word!! Amen Amen Amen 🙂.
Unfortunately, we’re going to have to wait until the lawyers catch wind of the damage and start going after those who are committing such crimes against children. It will happen, but the damage is tremendous.
That’s the way I see it too. Petter and the rest are doing a great thing but they are up against the power structure and system that controls 95% of information flow.
Wait, so you’re saying the lawyers just haven’t heard about the 24-year olds with osteoporosis yet? The 23-year olds with hip dysplasia? Oh wait until they find out what Lupron did and why it’s no longer on the market..,,,
@@JumpCutThis No, I’m just saying the lawyers haven’t caught up yet and this craze hasn’t been going on very long. The lawsuits will probably come from the hoards of 20-30 year olds who were damaged in their teen years and haven’t fully matured. I think most people still don’t really know what’s going on.
Thank you for arranging this discussion Peter - & thanks to all your guests for bringing some hope into what often seems like a dark place right now ....
If you had a good childhood, protecting children is common sense. If you had trauma in your childhood, you can't remember the joy of being a kid. Those are the people trying to destroy the innocence of the children for their twisted ideology 😢 We all know kids are not ready for life changing decisions.
What a great discussion with awesome humans. I wish we had such people in our governments, US and Canada. I'd say that the moment a society is driven by emotions is the beginning of the end...
I love you guys. Two spirits. The way Chris expressed it is the way the First Nations people see it. There are two genders and a spectrum in between. It doesn’t matter where you lie in between. Let’s get back to reality. As a Canadian I’m concerned about the lack of constitution and the crazy safe spaces they’re trying to create in Canada. I’m a lefty at heart and I feel like the left has lost its way.
@@miroirs-jumeaux The term was introduced at a conferance in Manitoba in the 90's by a gay male activist. The elder first nations women were furious about how the concept was being mis represented. Look up Berdache. It is the precurssor of understanding how missionaries first described what they witnessed amongst indigenous ppls.
No. There’s not a spectrum of sex. Sex is BINARY as we a re a dimorphic species, mammals. The wokey crowd tries to say that it’s a bimodal distribution, it is NOT. Sex is the PHYSICAL reality, it’s Binary. Gender sure is all over the place bc it’s made up BS
You touched on the myth of “Gender Affirming Care.” I’ve been pushing for the phrase “Medically Assisted Self Harm” but maybe “Medical Assistance In Mutilation” would be more effective.
Thank you, Peter, for facilitating these raw (honest) presentations of so much knowledge & information and various personalities that have taken action in response to leftist aggression. You have wonderful skills in doing just this.
Wonderful conversation. I want to hear more about the roots of this. I’ve listened to James Lindsey on his case for it, and I want to hear more analyses on it.
Thankyou so much for the conversation. Im in the UK, i have always been a lefty and a feminist. I dont belive i could ever vote Conservative but im truly ashamed of the current hard left, whom, i had previously always associted myself with. This ideology blows my mind, its abhorrent. I appreciated hearing some of the optimism from some of you, as we have hang on to hope. I do belive it will collapse in on itself eventually. Im crossing my fingers that once the NHS ( Tavistock) is sued it will begin to collapse,because money talks and if we can debunk gender affirming care via the law suits, we open the flood gates for the department of education to be sued too...i think it will take time, but once those floodgates open, institutions will put the breaks on promoting the ideolgy out of fear of being sued, i like to think this will a ripple effect through other countries. That is my hope. I also think that the key to this is the separation of the LGB from TQ etc, this is a huge blind spot of the left - believing that the two are the same and anyone being negative about the ideolgy is the equivalent of the homophobic and therefore fear the prejudice of the past repeating itself. We have to keep trying to uncouple the LGB from this and Educate people that it is completely different and at odds with sexuality. Im currently a silent and frustrated onlooker too scared to publicly speak out because of a particular project i run in partnership with a very captured organisation. But i really do thank all of you who are speaking up. Im rooting for you all.
You don’t want children targeted and harmed, but also say you could never “bring yourself to vote conservative”? The left fully intends to continue trans surgeries for children. The left/right team mentality is how this has flourished 🌊This evil has become rooted in the politics of the left - they’re 💯 captured by gender ideology activists. If you tell your lefty friends you’re against gender ideology they’ll let you know you’re a fascist & need to be re-educated. The butchering of children will continue until we make it stop 🛑
The "slippery slope" is not a fallacy. What we're seeing is the logical conclusion for generations of hard leftism. But, you just can't ever vote conservative. Cool.
My wife and I were considering moving to Portland 6 years ago. Thank God we didn't. We have 3 young kids and I'm damn glad we didn't make the move. I didn't see it getting this crazy. But that city is bonkers.
Wow! Great conversation. This is so helpful and meaningful. Taking an issue like this and examining it from the perspectives of those who have literally been in the trenches facing it. Peter did a fantastic job of facilitating the conversation and guiding it. I tthink it's important we try to look at these issues as honestly as we can. No matter how uncomfortable it gets, no matter if there are aspects we even vehemently disagree with - we have to strip it down and see it for what it is, and try to find genuine paths forward. This has become such a huge issue in our society, it MUST be discussed. Well done, to all involved.
Bill board Chris you are amazing, keep up the fight to educate people of the truth, God's truth, faith is victory over the devil. Even if you don't fully believe. Thanks for being you
Chris is 100% correct at 1:17, the more parents become aware of what is going on, and a critical mass forms (and they are forming as we speak) then politicians will listen and there will be change. Its coming.
Great discussion. To Chris, I am hosting people at my house for brainstorming to create a postcard sized handout that will catch people quickly and inspire them to seek out more information on their own. I think I am going to mine this conversation for your one liners, making use of your tried and proven words. Thank you to all of you. Honey Badger mom, you are new to me. I will seek you out and follow on social media like I do the others. Thank you.
Thoroughly enjoyed this! Very insightful conversation and I feel I gained more knowledge on how to better address certain issues, so a huge thank you to all of you.
🔥🔥🔥 This was fire! More please, I love seeing and hearing all of my favorite faces around a table destroying the gnostic Marxists! 😆 The only thing missing from this discussion was me. You know where to find me Reid, I've got the inside scoop on how this is manifesting in the school system. It's summer time and all I've got is time and an abondance of "lived experiences" to share.
Marxism has nothing to do with the Gender Cult!🤦 are you nuts Gender Cult hijacked LGB, Marxism, Ancient Greece, Maori Tribe Legend, Red Army, Socialism, god knows who/what else... to ride in their bandwagon to promote Transhumanist Fascism Unless you idiots who make statements like you just made🤦🤡- start educating yourself, these hijackers gonna win, cause ignorance is the loser
@@Objectivityiskey anticommunism is to simply opposing communism what antisemitism is to simply critiquing judaism. it has nothing to do with legitimate opposition to communism. It is a bunch of half baked, factually false, ideological memes made to accompany offing millions of people, as it has done , just as much as Stalinism has.
This conversation is so good! Chris and everyone are just so clear and so calm and rational about this issue. I love the pushback on the Christianity angle. A person's motivations have nothing to do with the material facts.
When these people who support transitioning kids say “you are on the wrong side of history “, they are saying you are not part of the in-crowd. They have seen the social trend in favor of “affirmation” and transgender activism and they didn’t want to miss the bandwagon of consensus. It isn’t about learning over time what is right, it is about being part of the in-crowd. They don’t want tides to turn because that would put them back in the wrong camp from a social perspective, not a truth seeking one.
Fantastic. Peter, loved how you 'role played' taking the opposite stance. Would love to see this as a game that you employ on campuses for not so sensitive students that want to broaden their understanding of opposing views.
Journalists citing Wikipedia is the saddest thing to me. We we taught in elementary school not to do that. They should lose their journalism degrees for such a blatant disregard for ethics and get sued for defamation.
I’ve lost friends as well because I don’t believe In transitioning children. I’ve been call a bigot and more and my friends refused to talk to me about the trans topic, they won’t listen to me and they don’t want to learn about what I know, I get completely shut down.
Peter B. made excellent arguments for the panel to answer and this perfectly drew out the illegitimacy and danger of transgenderism with regard to gender affirming care. Peter and the panel did an excellent job of revealing how radical the transgender advocates are and how willing they are to sacrifice children in the name of their 'cause'. Chris made a powerful point about the fallacy of transgenderism from the perspective of both religion and evolution! His most powerful point was, "The human mind is very weak psychologically. We're easily manipulated. We're easily persuaded. We're prone to cults. We're prone to group think and mass psychoses."
"Zero Genders"...I'm so glad someone is finally taking this approach. The "cisnormative" view is what needs to be attacked as it informs their entire perceived power structure that such identities are based around. That such societal identities are to be personally assigned to a system of perceived "norm/acceptance" ("gender") versus a group categorization of a much more basic, static element for societal understanding (sex). It's a difference in schema formation itself. It should be that abnormal preferences don't dictate one's identity to labels conveying norms.
Agreed. The part I don't get is they say man and woman are "social constructs" but then they say there's hundreds of genders.... are those not social constructs as well? Sounds like double think
Best discussion I think I've ever heard in my life. This is true diversity of thought. Everyone in this group has different religious views and life experiences. Every single person here brought their best thinking and research to this discussion. They came prepared! Kudos!
I love every bit of this conversation, the diverse people involved, the intelligence of the participance and the desire to make a peaceful change. I fear the have is the end state. I feel the situation, and i am not just referring to the “gender question”, will go so far that the snap back will be violent and extreme. And where do we go from there?
The indoctrination of our youth is terrifying - my 19 year old daughter stated that she was not concerned about freedom of speech “because I’m not a racist “. Just think about that statement. It was like a gut-punch to me. She then refused to engage in discussion about it at all.
Support those in the fight against gender ideology and SHARE this video:
Billboard Chris www.billboardchris.com/
Andy Ngo www.andy-ngo.com/
Savanah Hernandez www.savsaysofficial.com/
Matt Thornton mattthornton.org/
Honey Badger Mom twitter.com/hunnybadgermom?lang=en
Shared it on Twitter just now. Great video.
👏👏👏👏👏
Doctor Boghossian! 43:16
Someone needs to make a claymation!
What a great group, truly enjoyed this. Glad Andy was able to make it.
Honestly, I am sorry to say but I think that we are about 10 years away from actual murderous Chinese Red Guard levels of violence in this country. I just the stuff that my neighbors 9 year olds are learning in school, in 10 years these 9 year olds will be 19 year olds, And this revolutionary ideology will be their entire worldview and the core of their identity. I think we are headed to an American Holodomor.
"There are 2 sexes, no genders, and infinite personalities"
Perfect. Imma steal that line
This should be written on walls instead of ugly tags.
this should be a tool in everyone's tool belt! and it's all thanks to mr billboard himself :)
That was gold. I have so much respect and admiration for Chris.
Are you sure ?
Me too! Perfecto
"Trained to stay calm" which was the exact sign of being an adult back when being a grown up ment taking responsibility for your actions.
It's amazing that being calm and measured supposedly is something negative or some kind of superpower 🤯
I think that a few of the TrAs need training to stay calm 😂
@@snoopyfanno1 that's sort of like saying cats need to learn how to swim, the point is they don't want to
@@snoopyfanno1 They definitely do! More martial art training and less mindfulness coloring books! 😆🤣
His "Training" mainly consisted of not being 15 years old
I'm reminded of the words of Margaret Mead, "Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has." Keep up this great work!!!
It's a great quote.
There was an actual study that showed if you can get 25% of people behind you, you change convince the other 75%. It's not just a nice quote; it's's a real thing that can happen. There is hope to fix this mess the country is falling into. 🙏
@@hope-cat4894 There is also the 100th Monkey phenomenon...
It’s sad it’s a small group.. most people are terrified of speaking up.. the violence and threats towards people who value the facts and the MAJORITY OF THE PLANET AGREES.. is criminal and insane! I DONT understand how this has happened.. so quickly.. THE INSANITY IS ABHORRENT.. and kids are suffering.
I love Andy, he's such a gentle soul who gets so much hate. It's so unfair.
Yup.
@@drpeterboghossian Keep up the great work Dr. Boghossian!
He's a far right provocateur. I'm just glad he didn't use his fake british accent
I just can't imagine how anyone could conceive of him as a fascist
Jesus… “they know from the moment they can express themselves”. Really?!
I just turned 34, and I’ve been on cross-sex hormones for 18 years. I’ve had a Colovaginoplasty. I’ve been wrong about my “gender” twice! And now de-transition is on the table.
Everything I’ve learned about psychology and how the human mind works directly contradicts this idea that “we just know.”
We don’t know shit.
I’ve been tired of depression and chronic procrastination, so much so that this month I’ve let go; no more fighting. I dived so deep into my emotional troubles and childhood trauma caused by my dad something finally clicked.
Here is what I found out just today after talking with my mom about my dad.
When I visited him, I could never predict when I would get into trouble, What was ok or not. Because it depended on whether or not they were having meth withdrawals. I would get screamed at. Seeing no apparent pattern, my only option was to retreat inward. When I would shut down and retreat into my imagination, he would shame me and tell me to be a man, over and over. He would then repeatedly poke, push, and provoke. Like I was some dog in a cage… pure survival mode. The more he repeated it, the deeper I would go, “I wish I were a girl”, “if I were a girl, maybe he wouldn’t treat me like this.” The man was sadistic. His girlfriend was precisely the same.
My whole life, when things got bad, I would fall deeper and deeper into gender dysphoria. Ancient legacy survival software installed deep. Because he kept poking and provoking me until I would snap like a dog. I was 7 years old…
I had to comb through the entirety of my "lived experience" just to see this knot of trauma. It’s taken me 25 years to get to this point.
It’s been a hell of a fucking day…
My Street Epistemology journey begins now. I can’t stand on the sidelines anymore.
Wow congratulations and I’m tongue tied. Connect with Chloe cole and others and go public!
I get that too, albeit the opposite way as I'm female. I'm sorry you had to experience that, it really sucks to be pressured into old gender roles that aren't even healthy or even realistic isn't it.
I got betrayed & molested on 4th grade, betrayed & almost groomed in middle school by a private guitar teacher, not to mention being limited in what I'm allowed to do, to have, to say, to wear, to be etc just because I'm a girl, and so at middle school I kept thinking "I wish I was a boy". So I don't have to be molested, underestimated, limited.
Thankfully I got out of that by highschool, where my crush who's a girl told me "but if you were a guy, then we wouldn't have been friends and everything". Slowly realizing that what I don't actually wanna be a guy - what I really wanted was to just not be molested, underestimated and limited. Which I can fight for without changing myself entirely.
Ironically though, from the beginning I already was a tomboy. As I grew away from the thought of being a guy, the people who emphasize gender in everything still baffles me all the same. By society's definition, I'm barely a girl & closer to a guy, without even trying.
In the end, whenever my surrounding people are very gender-minded people who like to box people into 2 distinct gendered traits, I bid good luck to them as I'll not fit in either of them. lol.
So sorry you went through that. Many--maybe even most--kids have gender dysphoria because of some form of trauma. We used to know and accept that. But now, acknowledging that fact and trying to find out what that trauma is/was is called "conversion therapy." It's infuriating, because they aren't getting the help they need. Godspeed on your street epistemology journey, btw.
@@kristinandersen7790 Thank you! I appreciate the support. I'm sure I will connect eventually. I'll start with a blog and some Street Epistemology videos. I have a hard time reaching out. Maybe establishing myself online first would help.
@@jjQlLlLq I'm so sorry you had to go through that. No one deserves to be treated like that. Yeah, the ironies are glaring. There is no goal or destination with this stuff. Anyways, I hope things are improving. Thank you for sharing your experience.
As a mother I sincerely thank you for the good works that you are doing to protect our children from this evil, anti-human, agenda.
and Peter is right: they need to be shot.
Chris is so well informed on this topic and has an extremely effective way of calmly informing people what is actually occurring.
👍
Its remarkable
No he isnt hes the tran equalovalent of a anti vaxxer
@@Phoneybeetlemaniacxs How so?
He's playing a lot of language games and is effective rhetorically but I wouldn't call him informed. However, to people uninformed on the topic or that agree with his points he may sound convincing
Chris has a very soothing voice. It has a gentle and sincere tone like Morgan Freemans voice. He’s also well informed on this subject. He has done his homework. Not repeating slogans like the other side.
The perfect type of person. Imagine having to make this guy seem hateful. Gonna be working overtime that week 😆
These conversations are so incredibly important. Thank you all.
Thank you!
@@drpeterboghossian no, my dude, thank you for your insight, which is incisive, though your roleplay skills leave a little to be desired.😅May The Lord guide all your paths in this fight.
Thoroughly enjoyed this Peter. Same with the Keri Smith interview. Great work.
It's a shame these important conversations are so difficult to get in front of the right people who desperately need to hear them.
"2 sexes, zero genders, and infinite personalities!"
Protecting our children is definitely "on the right side of history."
"Our kids our beautiful just the way they are."😍
Go Chris🤗
Hear!Hear!
And
AMEN
God bless
🙏
I'm not a smart man but sitting around a table, eating pizza and just talking with intellectuals sounds like a great way to spend an afternoon.
Looking forward to watching this discussion.
That would depend heavily on which "intellectuals".... pick a random handful of supposed intellectuals from almost any modern University and you'd likely get a struggle session rather than a stimulating conversation.
@@Gumbatron01✔︎ your privilege!
I would love more panel
Or round table discussions like this.
I want pizza
Recognising the value of open, calm discussion indicates your sense and therefore your natural intelligence.
When it comes to protecting children, Chris is the absolute best!! And his comment here gives me a lot of hope, "We're not dealing with a million evil people pushing this. We're dealing with a million uninformed people pushing this."
Being led by evil people with money and means. See: "Martine" Rothblatt, "Jennifer" Pritziker, Blackrock, etc.
Thank you so much to all of you for speaking up and doing all this work. I am still trying to find my own path to help. Also as a lesbian I would be so glad if the LGB just left the alphabet and the queer theory all together.
I think that’s necessary for the LGB to survive, not just because the TQs are trying to trans the gay away in young people, but also because acceptance of LGB people has declined in recent years because people can’t separate us from the TQs. They’ve really ruined a lot. I hope you find some good people to work with if you end up fighting this ideology. Stay safe! #LGBDropTheT
"There's no one right way to be a boy or girl ... Our kids are beautiful just the way they are, what are we doing cutting off their genitals?" That was dead-on perfect!! That was one of numerous highlights of this fantastic discussion.
This is how you have a conversation. So many unique perspectives.
Yeah, unique perspectives of people who agree about everything rofl
This is a good example of the vast majority of people who love these kinds of echo chambers, too dumb to realize that's exactly what this is. It saddens me to think that Peter hooked so many people by pretending to be open minded, when in reality he's just another right wing ideologue.
Thank you for your work. I changed my mind on this topic. Two three years ago I was tolerant to transgender idea. What is the harm? But then the violent mob started attacks on twitter. Why is JK Rowling so evil I asked myself and started looking for answers. I am glad some random video (Peter's) from Portland uni about "harming by asking" helped to open my eyes. Why are students so afraid to have a discussion? Then What is a woman? and Tavistock and more.... Many greetings from Prague.
This is brilliant.. a very informative conversation. I hope every day that this madness will end 😢
1:28:50: "We think we're this advanced society, because we have all this technology. Psychologically we're the same." Chris hits the nail on the head with this one. It's hubris, plain and simple. The idea that we can so easily fix what nature got so obviously "wrong" by using medication and surgeries. Of course humans are medically and psychologically flawed, but before you intervene the burden of proof needs to be met. When it comes to chopping healthy body parts off of children, the bar needs to be incredibly high.
Naturalistic fallacy.
What a great conversation. Mr Boghossian you should put this on podcast as well for reaching more folks. Just look at any of America's issues today and most of them are self inflicted issues from manufactured crisis.
Savannah hit the nail on the head about George Floyd.
Chris is on top of his game.
I get Andy not being very optimistic, because it's like a cancer just eating away at everything.
I upload these as podcasts as well: allthingsreconsidered.buzzsprout.com/
Thanks Peter and Chris and the rest of the guys there. Trying to educate and help people who have for whatever reason lost their grip on reality is not easy.
In your own words, define “REALITY”. ☝️🤔☝️
@@ReverendDr.Thomas In a general sense ones reality will differ from other peoples. Reality, in the context of the subject being discussed here, can be summed up in two words, and the lady used those two words during the discussion " common sense " so I just use common sense to come to my conclusion, and that is the reality of the situation.
@@martin-d4h 😬
So dad o I but I’d really like to see more new faces in this scene. NGO, Savannah and Chris are great but we need new blood
@@ReverendDr.Thomas Reality: The state which exists regardless of how we feel about it.
Chris is so brilliant, eloquent and brave. Thank you.
What a great group of free thinkers. Awesome and very important content. Thanks PB 👍🏻
Thank you!
Thanks for what you do, all of you. It is greatly appreciated. I don't want my kids harmed by this or anyone else. I still can't believe that people are telling these lies and harming kids and adults like this. You're all very well spoken and reasonable people. And Savannah you're beautiful. Thank all of you for what you do. Much love from Maine
Billboard Chris is phenomenal.
Thank you for your efforts, dedication and optimism. I feel Andy is right - you have most of the educational, medical and woke corporate entities working against you as they are obeying the demands of the cult and their financiers.
Thank you all for doing this. Seriously. ❤
Thank you for the support!
Great discussion. Billboard Chris speaks so clearly.
Amazing discussion. Billboard Chris is just... chef's kiss. He GETS it! I also always appreciate how Peter is willing to stand on the fence in order to tease out the most compelling argument.
I have literally gone out to buy a pizza, at 11pm, just to eat it and listen to this. I kid you not!
Ha, great! Hope you enjoyed the pizza & the video.
I can tell everyone loves Chris. They just wish he wasn’t always on the edge of vocal activation and was a bit better at sharing the conversation space. Great conversation either way, and Chris does always have relevant and interesting things to say.
I'm trying to follow the conversation but I can't stop staring at that damn pizza.
This is one of the best talks I have found to give to those who are skeptical about what’s going on. I am going to share with my brother in law, who thinks I am a conspiracy theorist for believing this stuff is happening. He is one of those who are sadly un-informed!
The truth will come out. All of you keep pushing!! Billboard Chris your passion and belief for this to change is amazing. This is a spiritual battle and God will have the last word!! Amen Amen Amen 🙂.
Unfortunately, we’re going to have to wait until the lawyers catch wind of the damage and start going after those who are committing such crimes against children. It will happen, but the damage is tremendous.
That’s the way I see it too. Petter and the rest are doing a great thing but they are up against the power structure and system that controls 95% of information flow.
When children come of age to divorce their parents and sue their doctors, hospitals and therapists….
Or, you know, just suspend them from nearby vertical ligneous growths
Wait, so you’re saying the lawyers just haven’t heard about the 24-year olds with osteoporosis yet? The 23-year olds with hip dysplasia?
Oh wait until they find out what Lupron did and why it’s no longer on the market..,,,
@@JumpCutThis No, I’m just saying the lawyers haven’t caught up yet and this craze hasn’t been going on very long. The lawsuits will probably come from the hoards of 20-30 year olds who were damaged in their teen years and haven’t fully matured.
I think most people still don’t really know what’s going on.
Chris has obviously done his homework very thoroughly, thus no one can "gotcha!" him. Smart.
Thank you all for fighting the good fight. You're doing a very good job and I thank you. Keep at it.
What a great group of people to have a conversation with!!!
It was excellent.
Great conversation . This is how mature rational people communicate.
Bill board Chris is brilliant x
Thank you for arranging this discussion Peter - & thanks to all your guests for bringing some hope into what often seems like a dark place right now ....
Awesome conversation. Educated and well spoken. Very inspiring. Thank you, Peter!
If you had a good childhood, protecting children is common sense. If you had trauma in your childhood, you can't remember the joy of being a kid. Those are the people trying to destroy the innocence of the children for their twisted ideology 😢
We all know kids are not ready for life changing decisions.
Agree!
Sense made!
What a great discussion with awesome humans. I wish we had such people in our governments, US and Canada. I'd say that the moment a society is driven by emotions is the beginning of the end...
I love you guys. Two spirits. The way Chris expressed it is the way the First Nations people see it. There are two genders and a spectrum in between. It doesn’t matter where you lie in between. Let’s get back to reality. As a Canadian I’m concerned about the lack of constitution and the crazy safe spaces they’re trying to create in Canada. I’m a lefty at heart and I feel like the left has lost its way.
That two-spirit idea came to a woman in her dreams in the ‘60s. It is not « what the natives believe ».
@@miroirs-jumeaux The term was introduced at a conferance in Manitoba in the 90's by a gay male activist.
The elder first nations women were furious about how the concept was being mis represented.
Look up Berdache. It is the precurssor of understanding how missionaries first described what they witnessed amongst indigenous ppls.
@@miroirs-jumeaux I'd be interested to read more about that, can you recommend any background material?
The left has become evil. Just look at the results and the continued push to imprison anyone who disagrees With them
No. There’s not a spectrum of sex. Sex is BINARY as we a re a dimorphic species, mammals. The wokey crowd tries to say that it’s a bimodal distribution, it is NOT. Sex is the PHYSICAL reality, it’s Binary. Gender sure is all over the place bc it’s made up BS
I want to go to a pizza party at Peter's house 😂 Excellent conversation.
Me too!!
You touched on the myth of “Gender Affirming Care.” I’ve been pushing for the phrase “Medically Assisted Self Harm” but maybe “Medical Assistance In Mutilation” would be more effective.
Great video, please do more on this subject
Thank you, Peter, for facilitating these raw (honest) presentations of so much knowledge & information and various personalities that have taken action in response to leftist aggression. You have wonderful skills in doing just this.
This meeting is like the bloody Avengers. Awesome. Chris continues to be a total chad.
Wonderful conversation. I want to hear more about the roots of this. I’ve listened to James Lindsey on his case for it, and I want to hear more analyses on it.
All of my favorite people all in one place!? I hit the like button so fast.
It really is a fantastic conversation between very intelligent people
"The only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for good people to do nothing."
If by good people you mean liars and fear mongers. Are violent people good in your book?
This is so good. Everyone should have to watch this!
What a completely brilliant discourse! Thank you!
I love this kind of thing. Long-form conversation. Pleas to more of this
Thankyou so much for the conversation. Im in the UK, i have always been a lefty and a feminist. I dont belive i could ever vote Conservative but im truly ashamed of the current hard left, whom, i had previously always associted myself with. This ideology blows my mind, its abhorrent. I appreciated hearing some of the optimism from some of you, as we have hang on to hope. I do belive it will collapse in on itself eventually. Im crossing my fingers that once the NHS ( Tavistock) is sued it will begin to collapse,because money talks and if we can debunk gender affirming care via the law suits, we open the flood gates for the department of education to be sued too...i think it will take time, but once those floodgates open, institutions will put the breaks on promoting the ideolgy out of fear of being sued, i like to think this will a ripple effect through other countries. That is my hope. I also think that the key to this is the separation of the LGB from TQ etc, this is a huge blind spot of the left - believing that the two are the same and anyone being negative about the ideolgy is the equivalent of the homophobic and therefore fear the prejudice of the past repeating itself. We have to keep trying to uncouple the LGB from this and Educate people that it is completely different and at odds with sexuality. Im currently a silent and frustrated onlooker too scared to publicly speak out because of a particular project i run in partnership with a very captured organisation. But i really do thank all of you who are speaking up. Im rooting for you all.
You don’t want children targeted and harmed, but also say you could never “bring yourself to vote conservative”? The left fully intends to continue trans surgeries for children. The left/right team mentality is how this has flourished 🌊This evil has become rooted in the politics of the left - they’re 💯 captured by gender ideology activists. If you tell your lefty friends you’re against gender ideology they’ll let you know you’re a fascist & need to be re-educated. The butchering of children will continue until we make it stop 🛑
The "slippery slope" is not a fallacy. What we're seeing is the logical conclusion for generations of hard leftism. But, you just can't ever vote conservative. Cool.
What makes them hard left
My wife and I were considering moving to Portland 6 years ago. Thank God we didn't. We have 3 young kids and I'm damn glad we didn't make the move. I didn't see it getting this crazy. But that city is bonkers.
Wow! Great conversation. This is so helpful and meaningful. Taking an issue like this and examining it from the perspectives of those who have literally been in the trenches facing it.
Peter did a fantastic job of facilitating the conversation and guiding it. I tthink it's important we try to look at these issues as honestly as we can. No matter how uncomfortable it gets, no matter if there are aspects we even vehemently disagree with - we have to strip it down and see it for what it is, and try to find genuine paths forward.
This has become such a huge issue in our society, it MUST be discussed.
Well done, to all involved.
Canada and the world is lucky to have Chris.
Excellent conversation. Thank you!
Bill board Chris you are amazing, keep up the fight to educate people of the truth, God's truth, faith is victory over the devil. Even if you don't fully believe. Thanks for being you
This was an outstanding conversation to witness. Thank you.
Agree!!
What an inspiring group of brave and awesome ppl! ❤👏👏👏
Billboard Chris needs to do many more podcasts. Hello podcasters out there.
Thanks for posting this, Peter. It's really important context for what was to come the following day.
Chris is 100% correct at 1:17, the more parents become aware of what is going on, and a critical mass forms (and they are forming as we speak) then politicians will listen and there will be change. Its coming.
Love you guys. All of you are massive hero's. Donation made.
Great discussion. To Chris, I am hosting people at my house for brainstorming to create a postcard sized handout that will catch people quickly and inspire them to seek out more information on their own. I think I am going to mine this conversation for your one liners, making use of your tried and proven words. Thank you to all of you. Honey Badger mom, you are new to me. I will seek you out and follow on social media like I do the others. Thank you.
Truly impressive discussion!! Everyone in that room is amazing. Thank you all so much!!!!!
Thanks for watching!
Thoroughly enjoyed this! Very insightful conversation and I feel I gained more knowledge on how to better address certain issues, so a huge thank you to all of you.
🔥🔥🔥 This was fire! More please, I love seeing and hearing all of my favorite faces around a table destroying the gnostic Marxists! 😆
The only thing missing from this discussion was me. You know where to find me Reid, I've got the inside scoop on how this is manifesting in the school system.
It's summer time and all I've got is time and an abondance of "lived experiences" to share.
Marxism has nothing to do with the Gender Cult!🤦 are you nuts
Gender Cult hijacked LGB, Marxism, Ancient Greece, Maori Tribe Legend, Red Army, Socialism, god knows who/what else... to ride in their bandwagon to promote Transhumanist Fascism
Unless you idiots who make statements like you just made🤦🤡- start educating yourself, these hijackers gonna win, cause ignorance is the loser
Woah, keep the gnostics out of this....
You guys’ anticommunism ruins everything, and stops people from taking serious conversations seriously.
@@tidakada7357 Are you implying that Communism doesn't suck?
@@Objectivityiskey anticommunism is to simply opposing communism what antisemitism is to simply critiquing judaism. it has nothing to do with legitimate opposition to communism. It is a bunch of half baked, factually false, ideological memes made to accompany offing millions of people, as it has done , just as much as Stalinism has.
This conversation is so good! Chris and everyone are just so clear and so calm and rational about this issue. I love the pushback on the Christianity angle. A person's motivations have nothing to do with the material facts.
When these people who support transitioning kids say “you are on the wrong side of history “, they are saying you are not part of the in-crowd. They have seen the social trend in favor of “affirmation” and transgender activism and they didn’t want to miss the bandwagon of consensus. It isn’t about learning over time what is right, it is about being part of the in-crowd. They don’t want tides to turn because that would put them back in the wrong camp from a social perspective, not a truth seeking one.
Billboard Chris is literally a sweetheart, it makes me sad that he was injured :(
Fantastic. Peter, loved how you 'role played' taking the opposite stance. Would love to see this as a game that you employ on campuses for not so sensitive students that want to broaden their understanding of opposing views.
Journalists citing Wikipedia is the saddest thing to me. We we taught in elementary school not to do that. They should lose their journalism degrees for such a blatant disregard for ethics and get sued for defamation.
Thank you all for the work you are doing. Keep up the great work.
Godspeed to all you,guys.
Decent people need to unite.
Abigail shrier needs to write a follow up book and call it the irreversible damage done
I’ve lost friends as well because I don’t believe In transitioning children. I’ve been call a bigot and more and my friends refused to talk to me about the trans topic, they won’t listen to me and they don’t want to learn about what I know, I get completely shut down.
Billboard Chris has already reserved his seat in heaven
GREAT conversation! Everybody was wonderful, but this was the first time I've heard Billboard Chris speak, very impressed!
This was an amazing conversation. Thanks for letting us be a fly on the wall.
Savannah Hernandez is a fantastic reporter/journalist, balls of steel.
Fantastic! thanks Peter.
Peter B. made excellent arguments for the panel to answer and this perfectly drew out the illegitimacy and danger of transgenderism with regard to gender affirming care. Peter and the panel did an excellent job of revealing how radical the transgender advocates are and how willing they are to sacrifice children in the name of their 'cause'.
Chris made a powerful point about the fallacy of transgenderism from the perspective of both religion and evolution! His most powerful point was, "The human mind is very weak psychologically. We're easily manipulated. We're easily persuaded. We're prone to cults. We're prone to group think and mass psychoses."
"Zero Genders"...I'm so glad someone is finally taking this approach. The "cisnormative" view is what needs to be attacked as it informs their entire perceived power structure that such identities are based around. That such societal identities are to be personally assigned to a system of perceived "norm/acceptance" ("gender") versus a group categorization of a much more basic, static element for societal understanding (sex). It's a difference in schema formation itself. It should be that abnormal preferences don't dictate one's identity to labels conveying norms.
Agreed. The part I don't get is they say man and woman are "social constructs" but then they say there's hundreds of genders.... are those not social constructs as well? Sounds like double think
Love billboard chris❤❤❤ love andy ngo work. Tell billboard chris to keep his work up.
Great appreciation for what you are all doing!
Best discussion I think I've ever heard in my life. This is true diversity of thought. Everyone in this group has different religious views and life experiences. Every single person here brought their best thinking and research to this discussion. They came prepared! Kudos!
Thank you.
I love every bit of this conversation, the diverse people involved, the intelligence of the participance and the desire to make a peaceful change. I fear the have is the end state. I feel the situation, and i am not just referring to the “gender question”, will go so far that the snap back will be violent and extreme. And where do we go from there?
Parent. 🙋🏻♂️ You’re absolutely right about us.
The indoctrination of our youth is terrifying - my 19 year old daughter stated that she was not concerned about freedom of speech “because I’m not a racist “. Just think about that statement. It was like a gut-punch to me. She then refused to engage in discussion about it at all.
Unbelievable work
Thank you for this
Loved the conversation! I try to have it everywhere I can!
Shoutout to the pizza thief 😂
Thankfully the senate in Oregon walked out to stop these evil bills. There is hope even in Oregon.
Thank you for sharing this discussion with the world. Very informative!
Thank you for having this conversation.
Great conversation on such important topics! Thank you