Très bonne vidéo gg et est-ce que tu pourras faire une vidéo histoire de l'Algérie stp parce que aucun mapper ne l'a fait mais par contre pas une comme tu l'a faite sur la vidéo surtout entre 1830 et 1880 où c'est pas trop professionnel mais une avec plus de détails
Commendable effort but I have many questions for many inaccuracies but the one that stands out the most to me is how the Yoruba have this massive empire at 3:33. They are in places where they historically never existed. Then Oyo Empire (The Yoruba's largest state) is over in Ghana for some reason as well when it should have been in Eastern Nigeria and Benin. Ghana would have been predominantly Akan.
@@fatherdiobrando1281 Yes I know what Yorubaland is. My point is that it's territorial extent in this video is incorrect. The Yoruba have historically never been in those places. They would have been in Western Nigeria, Benin, and Togo.
I think it also may have helped if you distinguished between tribes/ethnic groups and centralized states/kingdoms. For example some mappers will show stateless peoples in italics and no borders while the centralized states will be in normal fonts with hard borders.
This is amazing! Thank you for including non-centralized people groups! This shows clearly how populated Africa was even without states. But why is Zimbabwe and nearby states not colored and listed as distinct nations?
@@eren.mapping Hey i have a question, what is that, if i am not reading it wrong, nyani civilization in africa? i'm making a map in a game set in 1748 and i can't find what it was
Je suis retombé sur ta vidéo, et mon dieux que j'avais oublié quel était aussi bien faite, il manque juste quelques royaume comme celui de mauretanie 🇲🇦 ou encore de Numidie 🇩🇿 mais sinon tu à géré 👍♥️ J'ai une question : c'est quoi le différence entre les État colorier et non colorier ?
Looking at the community tab, I think China's alternative video is next Edit: The polska one is required at this point, most neighboruing countries of it have been done already! Cannot wait for the romanian one aswell 🇷🇴❤🇹🇷
For the chinese vidéo i have a lot of Problème so i think its gonna take time for, but im gonna watch what people want see. What aboute you? You want an Romania history ? 🇹🇷💛🇷🇴
Bismillah let's goo Edit: Eren You forgot About macrobia The horn of Africa trading city states Opone,mufune,Mundus Edit: You forgot to put ajuraan and adaal
I have to say it since nobody else did. It should be Every "Year" not "Years." I notice you made the same mistake on all of your videos. Also I'm wondering why you have "Nok" appearing in the 11th century. Nok dates back to 2000 BC and it was an ancient civilization but not much is known about it so we don't really know if it was a kingdom or empire. Like the Indus Valley civilization for example.
Some wrong facts first of all fezzan They had banu khattab state Khormans Awlad Muhammad kel ajjer Those were stated that i think you should mantion and how about make a fezzan mapping video
Nice effort but you go the position of Nri completely wrong, didn't include Ife and Igodimogo(early Bini) at the right time and also go the position of Takrur completely wrong. Kanem also never extended south of the Chad while Bornu only really vassalzied that region. I really don't get what source would have Yoruba peoples spread from Ivory coast to Niger and at this point I am more concerned about seeing the source that says that and rechecking somethings. Anyways, that's all I know and care enough to point out in detail.
@@stefistroe3308 clear as day in the video he has the Roman’s existing in Africa in 700 ad I just double checked. Plus Roman’s didn’t get into Africa until 146 bc after the fall of Carthage.
![Kings and Emirs - History Of Africa with Zeinab Badawi [Episode 6]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vCyQgTJ6WgA/mqdefault.jpg)
Missing the Kingdom of Rwanda throughout.
Alternate History of England would be cool. Anyways, great video.
It'd be nice to see another alternate history video, but I do like these comprehensive looks!
damn really cool vid, also thank you for making the video look nice.
Très bonne vidéo gg et est-ce que tu pourras faire une vidéo histoire de l'Algérie stp parce que aucun mapper ne l'a fait mais par contre pas une comme tu l'a faite sur la vidéo surtout entre 1830 et 1880 où c'est pas trop professionnel mais une avec plus de détails
très bonne idée
What history does Algeria have to make a video about! lol
To be honest, this video have feature the Algerian history
@@zlakhalAlgeria dominated your country
@@zlakhalmassyl numidia fatimide regency of algiers zirids...
Very good presentation! there is no better for now! best wishes 😁🥰
Thank you Hazboullah
@@eren.mapping Al hamdoulilah ☝️
I am Moroccan, thank you for highlighting the history of my country. Your map design is legendary 🇲🇦👑👍👍
Shukran Akhi 🤝
@@eren.mapping wow
Oh yeah Eren you are great!
Not me its God who is great !! 🤌🤝🏻
@@eren.mapping oh wonderful!👍🏻🇮🇹
Amazing Video!
Commendable effort but I have many questions for many inaccuracies but the one that stands out the most to me is how the Yoruba have this massive empire at 3:33. They are in places where they historically never existed. Then Oyo Empire (The Yoruba's largest state) is over in Ghana for some reason as well when it should have been in Eastern Nigeria and Benin. Ghana would have been predominantly Akan.
I think it was meant to be yorubaland, a cultural region that lines up with the map
@@fatherdiobrando1281 Yes I know what Yorubaland is. My point is that it's territorial extent in this video is incorrect. The Yoruba have historically never been in those places. They would have been in Western Nigeria, Benin, and Togo.
I think it also may have helped if you distinguished between tribes/ethnic groups and centralized states/kingdoms. For example some mappers will show stateless peoples in italics and no borders while the centralized states will be in normal fonts with hard borders.
@@FromNothing ah, I guess I misunderstood
Can we see an Alternate History of Britain and United States in your world. It would be pretty Neato if ya could.
müq video olmuş 🤙🤙🤙🤙🤙
This is amazing! Thank you for including non-centralized people groups! This shows clearly how populated Africa was even without states.
But why is Zimbabwe and nearby states not colored and listed as distinct nations?
Ethiopia before all
Turkic states in Africa:
Tulunids
Ikhshidids
Bahri Mamluks
Ottomans
Husainids
Deyliks
Khedivate
🇸🇴❤☪️💪🏾😎👍🏾
MüQ❤
South Morocco🇲🇦not Sahara
❤️ great video
@MapNas no it is simply a terrorist and insurgent front that has no state, no government, no history or even territory
Its independent.
@@alvaro1999ificationاقوال عبيد شنقريحة
Pls, make alternative history of Great Britain
Abi sen toplulukda alternatif Çin tarihi videosunu yükleyecektin ona noldu?
Zorluk çikti ama inşallah bir gun yeniden yapma firsatim olur
@@eren.mapping İnşAllah olur🤲
@@eren.mapping Hey i have a question, what is that, if i am not reading it wrong, nyani civilization in africa? i'm making a map in a game set in 1748 and i can't find what it was
je trouve la carte plus détaillé et plus précise, gg!
Merci camarades
i found a mistake you forgot to put Muhallabids from 768 - 795
İlk abi sa
Ve aleykum selam
Mükemmel
What's your source for Luba-Ka kingdom that early?.
qu'avez vous utilisez comme logiciel ?
As tu déjà vue un magicien dévoilé ces secrets ?
Good video
Thanks dear
Güzel video
👍
Hey EREN!
Do you remember me?
I'm Sparta, we used to be friends on Discord.
Do you still have it?
If the answer is yes, can you give me your tag?
Je suis retombé sur ta vidéo, et mon dieux que j'avais oublié quel était aussi bien faite, il manque juste quelques royaume comme celui de mauretanie 🇲🇦 ou encore de Numidie 🇩🇿 mais sinon tu à géré 👍♥️ J'ai une question : c'est quoi le différence entre les État colorier et non colorier ?
Les non colorié sont des états pas si développé que les coloré
Peut être économiquement etc.. exemple
@@eren.mapping Merci de m'avoir rep
bu da türkçü ama güzel video
Niye hayirdir yazdığın yorum aztekce mi?
Ethiopia: 3000 years of contiguous history
Looking at the community tab, I think China's alternative video is next
Edit: The polska one is required at this point, most neighboruing countries of it have been done already! Cannot wait for the romanian one aswell 🇷🇴❤🇹🇷
For the chinese vidéo i have a lot of Problème so i think its gonna take time for, but im gonna watch what people want see. What aboute you? You want an Romania history ? 🇹🇷💛🇷🇴
Late respone, i cant be super active on this account, but yes, ive always wanted one
Bismillah let's goo
Edit:
Eren
You forgot
About macrobia
The horn of Africa trading city states
Opone,mufune,Mundus
Edit:
You forgot to put ajuraan and adaal
No review the video you can see
You can see Ajuran Mogadiscio and majerteen
@@eren.mapping yh sorry
It was very small I nearly missed it
Thnx for the vid
❤️❤️
Hope to see alt history soon
I have to say it since nobody else did. It should be Every "Year" not "Years." I notice you made the same mistake on all of your videos. Also I'm wondering why you have "Nok" appearing in the 11th century. Nok dates back to 2000 BC and it was an ancient civilization but not much is known about it so we don't really know if it was a kingdom or empire. Like the Indus Valley civilization for example.
Nice video 🇧🇬❤️🇹🇷.I support 🇹🇷not🇬🇷.🇧🇬❤️🇹🇷
But we are all brother 🇹🇷🇧🇬🇬🇷🇦🇱
@@eren.mappingAgree , but Greece never be our friends.Serbia?She also support Turkey 🇹🇷now .
You started to use terrain
The history of Morocco is very amazing. 🇺🇸❤️🇲🇦
Oh and some wrong about the senussi they were huge see there maps on google they are huge empire
You forgot mauretania kingdom and Numidia
Some wrong facts first of all fezzan
They had banu khattab state
Khormans
Awlad Muhammad
kel ajjer
Those were stated that i think you should mantion and how about make a fezzan mapping video
Salam alaykum thanks for your comments akhi
@@eren.mapping no need brother
Ethiopia, the owner of Italy 😊
Nice effort but you go the position of Nri completely wrong, didn't include Ife and Igodimogo(early Bini) at the right time and also go the position of Takrur completely wrong. Kanem also never extended south of the Chad while Bornu only really vassalzied that region.
I really don't get what source would have Yoruba peoples spread from Ivory coast to Niger and at this point I am more concerned about seeing the source that says that and rechecking somethings.
Anyways, that's all I know and care enough to point out in detail.
The Yoruba are generally from an area that stretches from Western Nigeria to the Ghana To go border
Geschichte Afrikas
This seems kinda inaccurate. Where’s Alexander the Great? Also romans in 700 ad? Is that meant to represent the Byzantines?
Dude... you mean 700BC?
@@stefistroe3308 clear as day in the video he has the Roman’s existing in Africa in 700 ad I just double checked. Plus Roman’s didn’t get into Africa until 146 bc after the fall of Carthage.
@@stefistroe3308 Rome didn't exist in 700 BC
@@orangetoes223 The Byzantines are Romans. They have always looked upon themselves as Romans until their fall in the 15th century.
@@FromNothing yeah I was being nitpicky. You’re right. Still seems a bit off other than that.
Egypt carrying Africa as usual
Sahara libre
Exagerating the history of merrakech man see some real maps pls dont make videos out of lies
Algerian?? 😂
We are pity of You
algerien 3tay
Stop marginalizing our history, go from here if you don't want to watch, and stop distorting our history
How is he exagerrating ?marrrakech ruled your anccestorrs for decades before you pledged alligance to the turks and franks