Karen Read’s Future Hangs in the Balance as More Key Witnesses Take the Stand
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 май 2024
- IT'S HERE: STS HARDCOVER BOOK SIGNED COPIES FROM JOEL AND KARM: premierecollectibles.com/waldman
Pre-Order Joel's Book: Https://amzn.to/48GwbLx
👉 / survivingthesurvivor
STS Website: survivingthesurvivor.com/
STS Merch Store: www.bonfire.com/store/sts-store/
#STSNation,
Welcome to another episode of Surviving The Survivor, the podcast that brings you the #BestGuests in all of True Crime…
The trial for Karen Read, the Massachusetts woman who is accused in the 2022 death of her Boston police officer boyfriend, is underway with Day 2 of testimony.
Read, 43, of Mansfield, is charged with running down John O’Keefe, her Boston police officer boyfriend, and leaving him to die in a blizzard in the town of Canton on Jan. 29, 2022.
She has pleaded not guilty to charges of second-degree murder, motor vehicle manslaughter, and leaving the scene of a collision in connection with O’Keefe’s death.
#BestGuests:
Bob M. Motta II is partner with the Chicago criminal defense and Kane County family law firm of Motta & Motta LLC; he concentrates his practice in Family law/Divorce and criminal defense with a focus in Felony Drug cases, DUI and weapons charges. Put Mr. Motta’s aggressive pre-trial and trial strategy to work for you.
He’s host of the popular Defense Diaries Podcast.
Joshua Ritter was named the 2015 Outstanding Prosecutor of the Year by the Association of Deputy District Attorneys.
Upon joining his current personal injury firm El Dabe Ritter Trial Lawyers, Joshua has continued to devote his talents to the tenacious and zealous defense of his clients.
Joshua also hosts the podcast True Crime Daily: The Sidebar, which takes listeners behind-the-scenes of the country’s most high-profile and notorious legal cases.
Josh also hosts Courtroom Confidential.
#KarenRead #Turtleboy #AidanKearney #DavidYanetti #AlanJackson #JenMcCabe #BrianAlbert #MichaelProctor #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeCommunity #Canton #CantonCoverup #truecrimecommunity #truestory #truecrimenews #criminaljustice #justice #crime_news #crimestory #crime #murdermystery #stsnation 
Развлечения
I can’t even clean up my kitchen as fast they cleared this crime scene.
True dat, right?
Best comment ever !!
how do you know the crime scene was cleaned up? Regardless of what you believe, not one investigator searched the house to confirm there was a crime scene, there wasn't a crime scene. remember “i stayed in the Foy-yah”
@@sondrabuonadonna I was referring to how fast they left the house/property
@@diananewton6573Sold the house, re-homed the dog, got new cell phone(s) & put the word out - “Mums da word”
Imagine if John O'Keefe had been found dead outside a home where he and Karen lived, after Karen and John had been out drinking the night before, then Karen Read re-modelled her basement, sold the home, "rehomed" her dog, destroyed her phone, and done other things the McAlberts have admitted, would there be any question Read was guilty?
Nicole and Brian Albert were clearly lying about their phones making and answering calls without their knowledge; it's a literal impossibility. Something highly incriminating must have happened for them to attempt a cover up, I don't think it was just John being attacked by their dog and accidentally hitting his head.
It was 2 years later, when they decided to move and over 2 years later, when John got a new phone. He has every right to do that. Same with the dog. John had no dog bites on him, so stop making up your own theories. John was raising his sisters 2 kids, for 8 years, because the sister and her husband, both died suddenly. And these 2 teenagers now said John and Karen fought a lot and were supposedly going to take a break from eachother. Karen had 9 cocktail drinks that was caught on camera. Karen was the last person, seen with John. They were together. She drove. Karen needs to answer, "how did she leave John and why did she leave John..... how was John suppose to get home later.......
Or maybe they decided to move because of random people accusing them of murder based on the actual accused murderer's PR campaign.
@@outoftime7740 "how was John suppose to get home later." Do they not have Uber in Canton? Brian Albert also said John would be welcomed with open arms, there would be no problem finding him a ride home, like other people who left the party later.
@@Anna-cx4tg According to Brian Albert in court, he said the move was planned before the incident, and was a coincidence. He didn't say it was because of harassment.
@@bobcousins4810 That's not what he said. He said they had contacted a real estate agent before the incident because the market was good at the time and his brother had sold his house at a good price.
Nobody who purposely ran over and killed someone would leave an angry voicemail accusing him of cheating or not coming home. Thats just dumb.
You know what is dumb? The amount of people falling for this made up conspiracy theory. All these RUclips channels are jumping in the conspiracy theory gravy train when they know that Karen Read is guilty.
People say killing OK & leaving him on “their lawn” is too but what choice would they have had? Place him on a car & leave fiber & fluids on their cars? What happened to clothes from night before. Fact Nicole was cleaning I think has more to it once she learned perhaps, their dog, did do quick attack on O Keefe. Very sad bc these officers probably have had good cases, done great things. Their behaviors on this case involving the blue line leaves 2-4 very suspicious players here moreso than Karen Read. Check out TB backing his car up at 14 mph… he almost loses control & it wasn’t snowy or an SUV. Case is over charged w too many people willing to cover for another; not for murder but as to whereabouts.
And by 4th week, these people have circus worthy butt cheeks w all the butt dials and deletions! Ridiculous!!
The defense team are taking this position because they have been talking to the FBI for a long time, and they know that Karen is innocent. The most disturbing thing about this is that the defense team has been the only one who has been doing a real investigation into what happened.
Exactly! The prosecution aren’t trying to get John o keefe justice, the defense is by questioning everyone’s actions
Btw she could be drinking(Soda h2o)with lime!😅
Think Karen's doing well,not even the idiotic witness didn't rattle her??!!!The way the last witness testify with"smirky face
Btw she had:MS n prob benign(brain tumor)she doesn't
@chrislim7615 what're you talking about.. "smirky" face.. ?? Is she the only one allowed to smirk? If you're referring to Mathew McCabe, those weren't smirks.. try All knowing smiles...or those wtf kinda smiles... like "wow whatta dk" kinda smile.. etc...I'm blown away by people in these comments every day. Lol
As are others im sure, people don't get me either.
The FBI says he wasn’t hit by a car and her car never hit anyone, that’s not guilty for me.
MM group text "Tell them he was never in the house."
@@anapaz8060”THE GUY”. Even worse
I love Mr. Yannetti! He is my favorite on the defense team.
Thank you Joel and panel! Karen is 100% being framed. There are, said by locals, law enforcement who support Karen Read. I absolutely respect, honor and so appreciate all good and honorable law enforcement. Brian Albert is not good or honorable . In my opinion and apparently an opinion shared by Canton, Ma residents.
Why would Karen murder her love on the front lawn of a Police detective house where a cop party is happening.....kidding??
Brian Albert sold his house, gave away his dog, changed the floor in the basement, twice, factory reset his phone "the day before he was told to preserve it" broke his sim card in half, got a new phone number and phone carrier... all in less than a year, and it's all coincidence... yeah, ok... i just can't believe that! At all. I don't care if she's mad he ditched her and cussed him out on the phone. I would have too. Had Albert not been lying every step of the way, then maybe. Also that no one, I believe, is sayimg they saw the body. That girl is lying, no doubt.
And he retired
If Alberts is not a murderer he acts pretty damn guilty in terms of actions designed to cover up a crime.
My husband and I have been married 40 yrs ,and believe me if he has gone out with the lads and he doesn’t come home when I usually expect him, I start to panic especially when he doesn’t answer is phone ,I will come out with profanities and it’s just panic and thinking oh gosh what if something has happened to him,so I fully understand the things she said.
This shouldn’t even be a trial. Gmab. She was so framed
Let me break this trial down for you guys in layman's terms: Think of a sports league - any sports league out there (NFL,NBA,MLB,NHL), Now think of the absolute worst team in one of those leagues. That is literally how BAD the prosecution's witnesses are. I have never in my life witnessed such a sham. I don't understand how this case was allowed to happen. But of course, when the referee (judge) is clearly trying to rig the game in favor of one team, you understand why.
The defence is playing a beautiful strategy and they barely have to try. This case isn't even about Karen Read anymore, the prosecution is literally spending all their time defending their witnesses. That explains everything you need to know.
Or is it like a horse race where the front speed dies and the closer wins?
Yadda yadda yadda !
@@kabra72 Jen mccabe, see you on the stand
@@pistolpete8231 Love it...Can't wait!
Boom! You nailed it! Love the analogy 😂
The conspiracy seems hard to believe until you see all these witnesses come on and ALL act combative and evasive. If they don’t want to come off as suspicious, they’re doing a terrible job! I also wonder if the jurors are wondering why they alllll have attorneys? 🤔
Disagree with Karm. We are just so fed up with the witness evasiveness. They sound bald faced liars totally prepped.
As an ICu nurse with a group dog arracks . Ghose are dog attacks so I can’t get past that. ANC the dog “ rehomed” a nasty head injury losing 3 liters of blood when a human has 5L where is it. The cellar dug up and house sold. I don’t think it was ambush I think it was accident in basement. And Higgins took a proffer .
Agree totally! If and when Karen is free,will the real killers be arrested ,I believe no! It's who they know!!!
Disagree. They are too symmetrical and parallel. Ans there are two sets of scratches on upper and lower arm which don’t match in the separation between them which would be odd unless the dogs claw distance and size changed in a second. Dogs are more uneven in nature if it’s just a scratch. Also if they were true lacerations they would have a corner point at each end and then spread open in the middle showing as a oval or slightly curved appearance. John Okeefes have almost 90 degree corners on the bigger wounds in the upper arm. There are no puncture wounds either. Dogs teeth leave punctures. And they have bruising around the puncture spot. Okeefe’s injuries were abrasions. Not consistent with a dog scratch or bite and there is no dog DNA either
Yes!!...All your points, plus much more...Thanks for sharing!
You need to use a spell checker
From what I understand, his EBL was 3 pints, not 3 liters. So, approx. 1.5 L blood loss , not 3 L - but still, a pretty decent blood loss.....
It’s so quiet about Higgens. There is also questions about his Jeep/plow and its positioning.
The plow person didn’t see JO either!
The cell phone shenanigans by the people in the house itself is enough to suspect a cover up.
That doesn’t explain his face being beat up
Best ending ever !!! Karm shooshing Joel was fantastic. So so funny. We love Karm!!!! 😂😊
No dog dna because they didn’t swab his arm, and they couldn't get a sample from the dog either
Joel, I live here and I can tell you that "we" are in no way thinking Yanetti is to arrogant. His arrogance is based off of the people on the stand, he is matching them. The Canton crew needs to be met with this behavior because thus far arrogance has gotten them here. Bring it Yanetti!
Yanetti is the best! Far from arrogant!
Love Yanetti! But Alan Jackson is my favorite! Too many inconsistencies in all these witnesses.
You’ve gone flying in the snow, but….Did you land face up with your broken glass and cell phone sitting perfectly underneath you!??? 😂
He landed face down he got turned over. Phone under him. He could gave tried
to get up adrenalin. And fell about 10.feet into lawn.
So many people coming and going. Young and drunk and poor weather conditions. If we are to believe that JOK was hit by a car was any other vehicle looked at for damage? That thought alone gives me reasonable doubt.
The dog, the house, the basement dug up and house sold. ??????
The phone set up factor reset. The butt dial at 2 am to Higgins, then more than 5x the next day. Delivering donuts in a blizzard? 2 am texting how long it takes to die in the snow? Just bizarre.
Plus the last witness today mysteriously sees a Black Blob! She was the most obvious liar so far...
@@russianaloha4576why would this gal lie for these guys. It’s just so hard to believe.
@@Sunshinestatejen Then why would this gal refuse to tell this before the day of testimony? Yeah, I clearly see who she's trying to help!
So nice to see Karm at the end of the podcast. Joel, please make sure you and especially Karm get enough rest.😊
Just finished the life, have never missed a episode, I have to say tonight's show was the best ✌️❤️🇨🇦
I do not think the Defense have to prove their theory of Karen Read being framed. I think they know the culture they are addressing, so the people will carry the ball for them. Really smart.
The Defense is incredible.
I love how genuinely Bob respects and talks up his wife Alison.
This episode was really great, thanks to Bob Motta and Joshua Ritter, (great guy), and Rob D’Amico. Best panel ever, for sure!!!
I live in Boston area and this is only the tip of the iceberg
With no one in the house having any kind of consistent testimony let alone believable testimony the D is definitely putting that info out there.
I have watched every hour of this case. This is the BEST summary discussion I have heard. Bravo 🎉👏
Definitely ONE OF my Top 5 STS PROGRAMS as of yet!!! Karm is the icing on this STS 🎂 CAKE!! Love you, Karismatic Karm!!
It’s not clear whether Karen said “I hit him,” OR “I hit him??! I hit him?????” A question
It was a question not a statement
Let your mom speak! You interrupted her every few seconds
😂
He interrupts everyone.
This was the best show ever! From the guests to Karm's surprise entrance! Beautiful all around
This is the conundrum that presents in potential outcomes of OVERCHARGING.
It would be absolute insanity for anyone inside the house to leave a murder victim right on their own property.
Why? If karen had stayed home that morning they could claim John was hit by a plow. Case over. No one would have questioned it. Karen messed up their plan by waking up and looking for him.
What a fun show. The best looking guys on this show❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥🔥🔥
Oh, this episode is a keeper. Watching it on Wednesday morning, loving it, and rewatching. Love today's guests - their opinions are well thought out; the Karen Read case is so polarizing. Karmela's appearance at the end capped it! You sent us to school with this episode gentlemen, thank you.
I feel defense went all out to not only get KR acquitted, but to get focused scrutiny for the case to continue for justice for JO.
Karm thinking the young kid was hot!
Karen with her roller in NYC.
Karen locked in the museum bathroom!
Karm wanting to go to bed!
Karm for the win!
Brian Albert didn’t have a choice BUT to leave him outside!!! He couldn’t be inside the house when they found him - it was a last min decision
Missed this jem! But what a great podcast!!! OMG🥹🥺❤....Great panel as ALWAYS! Karm and Joelly ..Good luck with the book tour, greetings from 🇬🇧 😊
Just bought the book on Kindle, cant wait to read it. ❤ u Karm! ❤ You're the highlight of every show you're on!
I got your book today, Joel!!!!!! WOOOHOOOO can't wait to read it - in the words of Tina Tuner you, Karm and COE are, "Simply the Best!"
I believe they set a crime scene outside to distract the police,and so they had plenty of time to clean the basement, and they all helped to clean it up.
I have high respect for Bob Motta. Bob's analysis of this court case, Karen Reed vs the State of Massachusetts, is very accurate. Bob's analysis of the evidence (lack there of) leads me to believe that Karen Reed is innocent of all of the charges levied against her.
Timestamp: 11:00
11:28 This theory is very plausible. My brother nearly died in a freak rollerblading accident. He was rollerblading backwards and had long jeans on. He was skating backwards and the bottom of his jeans went under the back wheel and he landed backwards and slammed his head on the asphalt. Luckily his friend was with him, got the attention of my father, and them paramedics arrived. He was admitted to the ICU for bleeding around the brain (contusion); he also had a severe concussion. He was placed into an induced coma for 3 days to allow for his brain to swell. The physicians were very close to opening his skull due to the swelling 😢 Luckily by a miracle he began responding (healing) and the swelling diminished based on the very high level of care he recieved. The main doctor stated "You can't hit your head like that again because you will die"
It took him 6 months for a minimum recovery. His symptoms lingered beyond 2 years. Excessive sleepiness, seizures, severe headaches, mood changes, lack of appetite, lethargic, etc... finally after 2 years the symptoms subsided and he considered himself as fully recovered to the best of his ability. ❤☦️🙏 Did this officer die of blunt force trauma to the head?
Great job lads watching the replay in the uk
Spot on. Both Nagel siblings had eyes where the car was but they didn’t see Karen hitting officer O’Keefe
No one on panel hs mentioned Julie Nagle admitted drinking for almost 8 hours!
Her name is spelled "NagEL" -- NOT "NagLE." (Please don't insult my accomplished, respectable & decent Irish maternal family name!! 😅)
That’s also could explain why if she thinks she sees something in the lawn she thinks nah, couldn’t be.
She walked in high heels
She said she wore high heels as they went with her outfit and she looked down so she wouldnt fall.
Trial not over
I wish the panel members names were on the screne & easily identifyable.
They were on at the beginning but I agree that it would be helpful to have them up throughout
If experts testify that there is blood on the taillight, I will view that with suspicion and question the blood was planted. We all saw those pictures of the blood collected from the scene in a stop and shop bag that was open with no evidence tape sitting right beside the rear right bumper of the car in the sallyport at the police station. To add to this, there is video missing from the sallyport and the lead detective claimed he took possession of the vehicle much later than he actually did. The blood in the stop and shop bag could have been smeared onto the taillight as the bag was just sitting there open. And if there are taillight pieces embedded in clothing, I will again be suspicious, as the first 4 police officers did not see any pieces of tail light on the lawn but suddenly, the retired police chief finds a piece of tail light while driving past.
Totally agree, plus so much more that fully points to a cover-up and a framing of Karen Read and there is an ongoing Federal investigation of the investigation of Officer John O'Keefe's death.
The last part was GREAT- but the ending was truly AMAZING!!! Including, the icing on the cake… COE: “Joel, you’re still live!!”🤣 bahaha!
@survivingthesurvivor
I watch almost all of your shows. This show was one of the best! Great personalities, moving fast, lots of knowledge. You should try to have this same group back on for more of the Read trial.
Oh right, he stubbles with a broken skull and a broken glass o ever to the other side of the lawn!
I think he got moved by a snow plough.
@Truth1561 That has not been proven.
Awesome chat thanks
Yeah, the dog accidentally gave him 2 black eyes. Sounds legit
Love the show !! ❤
This is a great panel.
Y’all are asking the right question but you’re asking it the wrong way.
The question isn’t
*WHY* would Jackson & Yannetti choose such a high risk strategy?
The question is
Why *WOULD* Jackson & Yannetti choose such a high risk strategy?
Do you think J + Y are ignorant of the risks of a 3PC strategy?
Do you think J + Y are simply cavalier with their client’s life and future?
Or do you think that J + Y might have a reason for going forward with a high risk strategy? Is there something different about xL
Great guests tonight. TY!!
Great panel!
Joel & Karm-we NOW need a second book about your book tour shenanigans!!!! Part 2!
Oh my Karm,I have laughed so much! You've made my week ❤
Karen knew exactly where to go
She laughed and rolled her eyes the other day.
I received my book and so excited to read. TY Carm & Joel for writing this book!
This point about one or both of the Nagel family having their eyes on that vehicle at all times is an excellent catch. The problem is it’s just that- a catch. You can’t bank on the jury figuring that out for themselves. In fact, it’s such a subtle point I’m not even convinced the defense team will pick up on it.
Somebody ought to write to them and clue them in to this very solid point.
Absolutely terrible
“Story Hour by Karm!”
Got your book yesterday and am deep in it! Love it! Definitely best seller to me! God bless you and Karm in your travels! Great guests, of course!!
They did not ever say what happen in the house , they said that “ something happened in the house “
We have a closer view of body language than jury
Love you Karm❤ I am going to buy the audible version of the book. So excited to read about ur life!
Yes I totally agree, she was in a terrible panic.
Love all these guests!❤❤❤❤
The crime was manslaughter with failure to report and coverup, not murder.
The Bloke bottom 😂
Best show ever! ❤
John okeefes Arm, IS the oddest element....SELF defense wounds No doubt!!
Joel l!! I received my book today! I’m so excited and super excited for you and Mama! Can’t wait to dive in! Congrats again💪
IMO I think she probably hit him with her car, but I think the case was immediately ruined by the lack of proper investigation
John and Karen, maybe others, were invited to the house of a witness who stated he came home and went straight to bed. Then son who saw a vehicle outside unknown to him but doesn't check it out. Girlfriend sees something but tells no one for ages of time past and also calls for a ride then when ride shows up decides to stay. Hmmm. Police officer disposes phone. What the heck are these people hiding? The family of John are suffering even more die to this circus
Amazing ending😂.
Yannetti is from Boston, he's even got the accent 😊 Jackson is the out-of-stater.
Bob is correct on that first question atleast! 😅💙😎
Karm’s appearance was priceless! You guys are awesome too! Love your thoughts on the case!
#BESTGUESTS ❤❤❤ all of these guys. Great FBI True episode S3E8
On a spring evening, my husband was struck by a hit-and-run driver and left unconscious on the roadside. There were no witnesses but a driver spotted him soon afterwards & called an ambulance. The ER that treated him and the hospital physicuans told us (my husband has no memory of the incident) that he had been badly beaten. After a few days in the hospital he recovered but we only learned what really happened a week later after a cctv video showed the car striking him.
You never know.
Just bought your book on audible!
Next they will say she was in a fugue
You guys are so funny and your Mum, I adore her xx❤
Are there ferrel pigs in Boston? Could this be a cryptid? Are we gonna hear from the leaf blower? These are the questions I need answers for.
I think this was a sad accident. I don’t think anyone was sober enough and I think they are all too self involved to do this on purpose.
That was so great and then Karm at the end bonus!
How do they know about the floor being torn up
For a long time I thought Karen was putting on a duck face pout , but then I saw her family & they all have the protruding upper lip especially her dad.
Can’t info still be retrieved on a cell phone even if the phone is no longer in service. Couldn’t celebrities sp? Still be able to retrieve all the cell info?