Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
S1: ‘Caste’ is British Class Imposed on Indians - Unmissable Dr. Subramanian Swamy
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2018
- The Festival of Bharat - Series 1: Dr. Subramanian Swamy ji explains what many Indic scholars take for granted - that caste, derived from the Portuguese word ‘casta' - is essentially a legacy of the European class system bequeathed by Britain, to India. Another (brutally frank!) explanation by the inimitable Dr. Swamy.
HOW TO SUPPORT US
FoB RUclips Support Link: / @thefestivalofbharat
FoB Patreon Support Link: / festivalofbharat
MORE CONTENT
Browse The Festival of Bharat's RUclips channel for more exciting content, music & talks by other inspiring subject matter experts, artistes, scholars, change makers and public figures.
All of our content is available at no cost, and with no premium subscriptions required. You can help us spread the word as far and wide as possible by sharing our videos, and subscribing to our channel at / thefestivalofbharat
SOCIAL MEDIA
Like us on Facebook @ / festivalbharat
Follow us on Twitter @ / festivalbharat
Join us on Instagram @ / festivalofbharat
SUPPORT US IN SECONDS
www.paypal.com...
Swami is very knowledgeable and puts across his knowledge in very simple terms
not simple way but clever way he knows very well what he says but make fool of listener what they do not and will never know the intention of the speaker and meaning of the speech
@@MuhammadAslam-pd2yr now that's a clever way to throw mud on Dr. Swami because you can't counter his argument.
Take a lesson from me Brahman, khashatrya, vaisheya, and shudra now lets wright them down together (BKVS) now use vowel as your intellect and see what it becomes ( BaKVaS) now try this in hindi 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 let me add please you can also call it bulshit and check it on google what bushit means in sunskrit🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 please like and comment if you get my message
@@alpeshmittal3779 Good points to think on.
Nobody can defeat SHRI SUBRAMANIAN SWAMY in a debate Subject to HINDUISM,PATRIOTISM,ECONOMICS.He is modern times VIVEKANANDA.
Take a lesson from me Brahman, khashatrya, vaisheya, and shudra now lets wright them down together (BKVS) now use vowel as your intellect and see what it becomes ( BaKVaS) now try this in hindi 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 let me add please you can also call it bulshit and check it on google what bushit means in sunskrit🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 please like and comment if you get my message and one more funny thing is that you dont find this match in any dictionary in the world. They knew [creators of this bulshit] that once you started believing in this BaKVaS they can make you believe in any further bulshits .
Thoughts of Inderjeet singh
Varna and jathy , the two most misunderstood words by Europeans, and also by some of our politicians, so the country is paying the price.
Done on purpose ...they understood very well but misinterpreted for us and brain washed us on purpose to destroy santana dharma
DHARMA - A very deep meaning word,
1) Varnasrama darma
2) sanga darma
3) daesha darma
4) Kala darma
The very nature of DHARMA includes all these and at the same time transcends all these.
At best we can describe DHARMA in negative attributes only.
Example : a cold dark sun is not it's drama, a hot glowing moon is not it's drama.
i hope the above explanation has cleared the air.
@@sheelaprabhu1659 varna system is your own creation don't blame others for your own mistakes
But why upper caste hindus discriminate on lower caste
@@gajahmada9539 Because nobody knows varna is based on occupation..nobody reads and understands gita and vedas..even the so called lower caste ppl discriminate other lower caste ppl..It's a fact..
Swamy is so knowledgeable! Thank god he's using his power for preserving dharma.
I completely agree with you.
Caste system and reservation system both should be abolished. Dalits and backward class folks stop hating your fellow hindu brothers based on what happened in the past and stop falling prey for conversions and Brahmins and upper caste people, for god sakes you are not special by any means so start treating Dalits like your own and give them their due respect. Hinduism teaches equality.
They do not believe in it , problem is only if you believe you are upper caste or someone believes they are lower caste . Who has asked you to believe it ? Majority ppl do not believe in it . Hindus are most United ppl only divided by politics .
@@technocrat6184 They don''t even allow women into the temple , what unity you are taking about.
1%of Indian population are brahmin.. But amongst them 76% are govt officials&employees..tell them to resign and get treated as low caste guys for 50 yrs.. Not much than that.. Then we can forget they to can forget
kumar sub hey asshole...read some scientific reasons of physiology and its repercussions done at occult places....only at places where occult is used...so plz before...using words like this do research man...thanks
@@MrSubra25 i see you are talking about one particular temple here. I am a Hindu woman i have been to several temples big and small and i am treated with the same amount of respect there as any man. You should focus on your muslim women here who are not allowed inside a masjid.
Outside power is trying to destroy Bharat unite my Brothers and sisters...
I hope that we can see some serious research on how the caste system was before the British Raj, and how it became under the British Raj. Such a comparative study can really dispel a lot of confusion!
Dharampal historian research. Book The Beautiful Tree. Given in 1page. This book banned by Britisher but now free pdf.
But then people like this guy couldn't just blame the British for everything!!
@@descendedofrigvedicclans2216 It's universal across races and also in a temporal sense, it existed in the society long before substantial contact with Europeans.
Yes sir. British wanted to set up the lower castes against the upper, muslims against hindus and so on
Bruce Bat
#gobackbhim #gotohellbhim
#bhiminchulha #nomoredalit appeasement
Only modi, good people will in the country
No more appeasement to dalits so-called garib actually richie rich dalit
What is the meaning of lower and upper caste?
Who told them about such things? Don't put all the blame on the British. Why didn't the British establish such a caste system elsewhere in the world? This caste system was created by the Brahmins and Kshatriya to benefit them fully as they were in power.
@@waqaralikhan6601 Excuse me, when did I say British created castes system. Im only saying they pitted one group against the other. Some form of caste system exists everywhere in the world. It becomes tribe in the saudi arabia, and race in europe. The islamic world has the highest % of consanguineous marriages and consanguinity is much more rigid than endogamy of the caste system.
@@anonfromnowhereinparticula1184 You are wrong and misled about the Muslims. There's nothing like that. There's no caste system in the world except for India. I am a Pakistani Pathan, I have been to the Punjab in Pakistan where the upper castes consider the lower castes inferior as animals and you know who the Punjabis were, they were the Hindus who converted into Islam, they still practice their Hindu culture up to a great extent.
In theory varna system is very normal. In practice, the villagers and uneducated people do immoral stuff like untouchability etc. that’s the problem. Blaming the British won’t help solve the problem at all
how can one person has this quantum of knowledge in every subject?
@@parmesancheese1052 this is what happens when you ancestors lost their dignity and accept invaders theory
Is swami a Quantum physisist
@@alpeshmittal3779 no he is not wrong read the real one
@@parth4780 He has bachelors in mathematics , masters in statistics , doctorate in economics
@@novacorpsc532 ooff
Bhai
Ek hi janam ke hai ye
British too has caste Royalty, Upper Class, Middle Class, Working Class. India's caste system was codified by the British.
Jyadatar logo ko malum hai ye Baat tabhi unke aane ke Baad logo divide and rule shuru kar diya tha ☺️😊
Who created Castes. Everyone quotes 'Manuu'. Did he create the system or write about how a large group of people are organized.
My take, consider any large body of people, Army, Police force, Maruti or Tata or Infosys employees.
Who are the Brahmins, the very top two rings of management who instruct what other people in the Org should do.
Kshatriyas are the tech managers, who approve future strategies or the Army colonels who oversee weapon procurement.
Vaishyas are people who oversee company cmmi and iso standards and the marketing people who get projects for the company.
Shudraas are software engineers, people who oversee automatic welding .
Kiran Rao
Caste comes from the Portugal word "Castas". The Portuguese used to follow the castas practice and also divided the Indian society in terms of Castas when they occupied Goa. Then the same was carried on by the British during the 1872 census.
bloodbathy
Britishempire.co.uk/article/castesystem.htm
I'm afraid it's not as simple as it looks to you brother. We can discuss this matter further if you want to.
Well... what you’ve observed is hierarchy. Caste comes with hierarchy, but not every hierarchy is caste
@ Kiran Rao
Brahmins at the very top because, the british-anglo saxons educated them and placed them at the Top Echelons of Administration.
There is difference between Education and Intellectualism. Intellectualism births Innovation. Education only creates Job Seekers.
That's not caste it's hierarchy. A lower caste person remains the same till he does.
Remove caste based reservation system.That will solve half the problem.
Also encouarage marriage between
Brahmin and dalit then can remove caste system
@@Virupa237 once the caste is removed, then what is the need of intercaste??
Remove both caste and reservation..
@@rishabhtyagi4277 you think it'll work😂. Indians will still search for the same caste
@@dr.abhinavsoppin there is no medicine for stupid claims.
No need such fancy words, we know Brahmins are the reason for Casteism. They claim to be high born or discriminate others.
No brothers they are not I have found them to be one of the best friends of mine even though I am a sc😁😁🙄🙄
Casteism was the part of society not religion. Because it was based in work and no where it has been mentioned in the religion and also if you compare it with varna vyavastha then you are a fool because varna vyavastha is based on one's own karma and guna and not on birth. Your ancestor could have been a brahmin or kshatriya or vaishya and mine could have been shudra. But the question is how it became rigid?
Richard Eaton, a professor of History, writes, "anyone could become warrior regardless of social origins, nor do the jati-another pillar of alleged traditional Indian society-appear as features of people's identity. Occupations were fluid." Evidence shows, according to Eaton, that Shudras were part of the nobility, and many "father and sons had different professions, suggesting that social status was earned, not inherited" in the Hindu Kakatiya population in the Deccan region between the 11th and 14th centuries.[115]
For northern Indian region, Susan Bayly writes, "until well into the colonial period, much of the subcontinent was still populated by people for whom the formal distinctions of caste were of only limited importance; Even in parts of the so-called Hindu heartland of Gangetic upper India, the institutions and beliefs which are now often described as the elements of traditional caste were only just taking shape as recently as the early eighteenth century-that is the period of collapse of Mughal period and the expansion of western power in the subcontinent."[120
For western India, Dirk Kolff, a professor of Humanities, suggests open status social groups dominated Rajput history during the medieval period. He states, "The omnipresence of cognatic kinship and caste in North India is a relatively new phenomenon that only became dominant in the early Mughal and British periods respectively. Historically speaking, the alliance and the open status group, whether war band or religious sect, dominated medieval and early modern Indian history in a way descent and caste did not."[121]
Richard Eaton, a professor of History, states that the presumption of a rigid Hindu caste system and oppression of lower castes in pre-Islamic era in India, and it being the cause of "mass conversion to Islam" during the medieval era suffers from the problem that "no evidence can be found in support of the theory, and it is profoundly illogical".[123
Jackson states that, contrary to the theoretical model of caste where Kshatriyas only could be warriors and soldiers, historical evidence confirms that Hindu warriors and soldiers during the medieval era included other castes such as Vaishyas and Shudras.[128]
Jackson states that, contrary to the theoretical model of caste where Kshatriyas only could be warriors and soldiers, historical evidence confirms that Hindu warriors and soldiers during the medieval era included other castes such as Vaishyas and Shudras.[128]
Eaton states that, "Looking at Bengal's Hindu society as a whole, it seems likely that the caste system-far from being the ancient and unchanging essence of Indian civilisation as supposed by generations of Orientalists-emerged into something resembling its modern form only in the period 1200-1500".[135]
Susan Bayly, an anthropologist, notes that "caste is not and never has been a fixed fact of Indian life" and the caste system as we know it today, as a "ritualised scheme of social stratification," developed in two stages during the post-Mughal period, in 18th and early 19th century. Three sets of value played an important role in this development: priestly hierarchy, kingship, and armed ascetics.
Nicholas Dirks has argued that Indian caste as we know it today is a "modern phenomenon,"[c] as caste was "fundamentally transformed by British colonial rule."[d] According to Dirks, before colonial rule caste affiliation was quite loose and fluid, but colonial rule enforced caste affiliation rigorously, and constructed a much more strict hierarchy than existed previously, with some castes being criminalised and others being given preferential treatment.[187][page needed][
The emergence of a caste system in the modern form, during the early period of British colonial rule in the 18th and 19th century, was not uniform in South Asia. Claude Markovits, a French historian of colonial India, writes that Hindu society in north and west India (Sindh), in late 18th century and much of 19th century, lacked a proper caste system, their religious identities were fluid (a combination of Saivism, Vaisnavism, Sikhism), and the Brahmins were not the widespread priestly group (but the Bawas were).[199] Markovits writes, "if religion was not a structuring factor, neither was caste" among the Hindu merchants group of northwest India.[
First read this then comment . This is the origin of modern caste system with proof by historians and Wikipedia 😁😁😁
@@italianalcapone I hate secular dalits
@Prometheus tell that to the right winger
Wow... explained so easily... Thanks..Dr.Swamy...
All are knowing this ,but sadly no implementation... very sad.
Excuse me for my ignorance and clarify me why did we have a caste related topic in Mahabharat between Duryodhan, Bheeshma & Drona charya ? when Karna wanna fight with Arjuna but they denied him just because of caste Mr Swamiji please clarify me this. ( British took advantage based on this concept) so we need to give an answer.
They let him to fight arjun but arjun was prince and karn was a common man karn even do not do any job at that time so his varna by decided upon his father niether they killed karn when they come to know he is sutputra he was stopped from fighting with arjun because arjun was prince and a prince only fight with a prince.
It's high time to break all illusions of 'caste' and caste based 'reservation'. First and foremost one needs to know the origin of the word 'caste'. Certainly it's not from Indus (Bhāratam) civilization. The ancient Bhāratam existed way before a European discovery (of the sea route). It's often confused with varna-shrama-dharma (duties to be performed by social groups). There's a broad distinction between the Sanskrit word 'varna' and the European word 'casto' -> 'casta' -> 'caste'.
Ask yourself: does one need just a head or torso with arms or thighs or legs in the human body ?
That's the analogy for social groups within the Hindu society, proclaimed by Lord Krishna and it's available in sacred book Bhagavad-Gita, yet there's so much belief in hearsay (rumours) based on misconstrued and distorted views of European colonists (the agents of missionary, to name a few Friedrich Max Muller, Thomas Babington Macaulay, Bishop Robert Caldwell, Herbert Hope Risley, Et al.).
In all honesty, we Indians have not secured true freedom from European civilization slavery (colonial mindset still persists), just not yet.
Sir how to end caste reservation systems in Bharat ...it must end or else Hindus will be more divided day by day
Yeah. Because of reservation the dalits are looked down upon even though they are meritorius. It divides people. Does more harm than good.
We can not completely stop reservations. We can stop reservations step by step. We can first stop reservation for BC. We should not give reservation to BC, and MBC in private sector. We should eliminate land owning communities from reservation. Reservation for DNC, and SC will continue for some decades. We can stop all reservations only after that after long debates.
Ramanan Kannan i agree
Chuck your surname .
Jon Snow what should we do to end caste system??
Abolish reservations. ... give chances to talented n bright people.........who warships work.....
Today ...30/100 ... marks holders getting job but not 80marks wala not getting..jobs........ it's justice???
@Jon Snow he didn't think once before cutting his thumb because of his love to his guru
Jon Snow y are worshipping human ( Jesus ) as god😂😂😂he didn't have any power to save himself.U dumb people worshipping as a god
eklavya's thumb was cut because he stole the knowledge...
Abolish Caste! If you Abolish Caste System Reservation goes off automatically!
this they will not do, otherwise who call them the high caste people
Wrong title for this video. Makes it sound like 'Caste' system was created by the British. That is why I came here........
Caste system did exist in India but it was talent based not birth based. Sage Valmiki belonged Balmiki caste(Dalit) yet he was considered a Brahmin because of the knowledge he had.
Similarly Ravana was a Brahmin by birth but he was considered a Rakshas because of his deeds. It is clearly written in the Vedas(the only books which are the foundation of Hinduism) that qualities are more important than birth.
There is a video by Karolina Goswami on caste system,just watch it and you will understand it a lot better.
Turning caste system from talent based to birth based was a strategy of British to divide Indians and it worked pretty well.
Similar to Sati which was suicide , which happened after Islamic Invasions. Before Islamic Invasions the cases of Sati were extremly rare, to avoid rape and being kept as sex slaves women committed suicide by burning themselves alive. The tradition of burning women alive existed in Europe, it was called witch hunting remember the Salem witch trials?
Calling Sati a tradition was also a British propaganda to prove how uncivilised Indians are.
Namaste. Thank you so much for sharing your observations and views on this topic. We would love you to also follow our social media platforms, and engage with us there, too. Links to our Facebook, Twitter and Insta channels are below our RUclips videos. Dhanyawad.
If they created
why we we still following why there was higher and lower
Are we slaves of following cast system and reservation
@@nature-go1kh Because people are still not properly educated about what the British really did.
The 724 ce traveller from China described India as the only place without slavery and any racism, he described whole of India as culturally one. Varna system is a job classification and caste is a British project!
Good joke..So why still caste discrimination happened in India severely??
Dear FoB channel...You cut your videos too short and abrupt.. which doesn't let us know wtz b4 and after in the actual conversation..
U may please post the full versions too - some one who has ample time/interest may go through
Information is knowledge. knowledge is power of the individual and the nation. knowledge about the nation, history, geography, culture and its thinkers are
the strength of the population. Past is not last. 'Shradhavan Labhate jnanam'.
Schools, colleges, universities are doing their best. Education is progressing.
What makes a nation, comprehensieve knowledge of its roots, growth and achievements
may not be available in a capsule. Attractive introduction inspires Shradhavan to seek more and more. Power of performance of the nation is the beneficiary.
Library is voiced through intellectuals like Dr Subramanian Swamy through channels. Product and gift of development. More is welcome. Jai Bharat.
Mayura varma, first Kannada king was a Vedic brahmin who got initiated to Kshatriya cast and built Kadamba kingdom. So there is a huge difference in Varna and Jathi. One can change his varna but not jathi.
Jati is human animal that way varna is decided by karma guna swabhav
Remove caste stystem else hinduism will shrink to zero 🙏
@@hinduhistory1407 to dalit logo ko kyu maara ja raha hai
@@hinduhistory1407 abey tumlog jo khudko oonch samjate hai wo log maar rahe hai,victim kya tumlog doodh ke dhule ho kya maara hi jaa raha hai har jagah
Dalit ke mooch rakhne se gand q jalti hai
@@hinduhistory1407 chutiye sabko bola kya maine?
Seedha bolo na dalit hindu nahi hai baat khatam
Dr Swamy real hero.. please let us all unite regardless. We should be more accepting and helping the SC community, because of the British we unknowingly did a lot of damage to them but the time has come for us to come together. Caste system was introduced by the British, they changed our texts and created new meanings out of it, exactly like how they edited the old testament conveniently. There were different jaatis described in manusmriti, but a person's respect was never based on what he does or where he was born, it was always based on a person's character. The indigenous people were so soft and liberal when the British arrived they just took advantage of us and created divide amongst us, for eg they created the zamindar system to extort ridiculous amount of tax from the natives, which made the natives hate the zamindars, which was exactly their plan. They did this wherever they went, look at the state of Africa. They mapped us and gave us boundaries. The truth has been distorted and we were made to feel inferior. And that inferiority complex is still there among the youth. Please read the book destroying India by Rajiv malhotra sir. You will know what happened. The east India company also bought a lot of Christian missionaries. Look at what they teach to the poor in India claiming that we are devil worshipers etc to make them hate us more in the name of secularism, and the Congress encourage s this so they can use them as vote banks. How can a Hindu who is force converted to Christianity by the British brainwashing and torturing can be a Christian. Please watch the movie Django unchained, you will come across a black man who helps the white man to control the slaves. The Bible allowed slavery. It's their very nature.
The oneness of India comes from the Commonness❤
Swami is absolutely Awesome !!! Very knowledgeable and a great Indian
Indians have to look upto this people Swami , Swami Vivekananda and Sadhguru who opposes the western education.
As long as our cast based reservation is there day after its dividing people and our society ...... people fighting for that to get more reservation ....Japanese also have cast system but they removed that without wasting time in reservation and politics becoz they want to create one society then why we are wasting our time and now even after 70 years still everybody want cast
@@sirlordhenrymortimer6620 my point is cast system has no basis today but why we are waisting time on such made-up thing which is useless now
@@devawratvidhate9093first of oll japanes people doesn't have varn vyavastha it was persent in hindu religion so firstl ban the varn vyavastha In your religion the reservation is never will be the problem it was hindu religion which created the problem you Hippocrates blame reservation for your wilthy mindset that's it
*Varna is a mother of caste*
Untouchability is untouchability only due to caste.
Untouchability and caste are only due to Varna.
Swami is intelligent that's why he could easily fool innocent people. Will swami give his granddaughter or grandson in marriage to other caste people who are Hindus.
Reservations for OBC/ST/STs is only for Govt jobs, all the private jobs in MNCs are free to be occupied based on performance of the individual concerned. Capabale ppl are already national toppers or CEOs of MNCs, its only the incapable the cries in social media against reservations. Thank you Modiji for the continuation of reservations in govt colleges and jobs. Jaihind
Aren't those people incapable who need reservation to get the job?
@@gvbhnnnnnnhh they were made incapable and degraded part of society by the upper castes...
I agree. I was anti caste based reservation but I think it should be continued for at least 20 years more with some reforms ofc
eventually all reservation should be scrapped.
98% of jobs are in private sector ,without reservations, in rest 2% only having reservation facility. Even though ,RSS AND MAJORITY FACIST INDIAMS FEELINGBJELOUSEVABOUT IT. IF U DIVIDEVTHE COUNTRY AGAIN WHAT WISHES OF THE PRESENT RULERS 90% LAND WILL GET BY SC,ST,OBC. THESE PEOPLE DOES NOT REQUIRED RESERVATION IF DISTRIBUTE 20% PEOPLE LOOTED PROPERTY
Five varna:
1) Brahmans (priests and teachers)
2) Kshatriyas (rulers and warriors)
3) Vaishyas (merchants and traders)
4) Sudras (workers and peasants)
5) Harijans or Untouchables, which were not in the social order (sewage workers, road sweepers, etc.)
But again the jadhi or caste is another sub classification of occupation similar to varna. Example there are castes having "vellalar" as part of caste name in tamil. Meaning a farmer. When we split the caste name's we would get the name of occupation. Also these names are linguistic based.
Once again these principles need to be brought back to the society which in its way will develop a great civilisation for the next million years.
If varna is divided only on the basis of occupation, how many Brahmins who run industrial establishments claim themselves as Vaisyas? How many Sudras who are teachers are recognized as Brahmins? Then why shouldn't everyone be a priest? That too is a profession, let the practitioner be a Brahmin. Shouldn't everyone be given a chance? All the speakers here are brahmins who subscribe to RSS ideologies. It is well known that the promiscuous media does not interview ordinary people and does not invite the grassroots to debate
“It is a pity that Caste even today has its defenders. The defences are many. It is defended on the ground that the *Caste System* is but another name for division of labour; and if division of labour is a necessary feature of every civilized society, then it is argued that there is nothing wrong in the Caste System. Now the first thing that is to be urged against this view is that the Caste System is not merely a division of labour. *_It is also a division of labourers_* . Civilized society undoubtedly needs division of labour. But in no civilized society is division of labour accompanied by this unnatural undoubtedly needs division of labour. But in no civilized society is division of labour accompanied by this unnatural division of labourers into watertight compartments. The Caste System is not merely a division of labourers which is quite different from division of labour-it is a hierarchy in which the divisions of labourers are graded one above the other. In no other country is the division of labour accompanied by this gradation of labourers.”
- *Annihilation of Caste by Dr .B. R. Ambedkar*
What Shankara and Madhva spoke of Swabhaava that defines VarNa:
Shankara says that Swabhava or natural tendencies are acquired through previous births. It changes with births..
whereas Acharya Madhva says the Swabhava is linked to the soul and Swabhava doesn't depend on births. It is permanent and unchangeable.
Congratulations to you sir
From Dr Bapurao shrigiri asst professor of economics BIDAR Karnataka India
Yes society is divided in to four Varna anywhere in the world.caste system is not.originally, in India Varna was not by birth . Very nicely explaied
Try to eradicate caste system
You said varna sastra is good for human being but it was twisted by the Hindu high class people and slaved the lower class.So my point is as br ambedkar did abandon the Manu sastra and follow the Constitution of India
Can anyone post the link of the Full Video ,?
can't find it.
Caste or such systems is a political thing used to maintain order way before British,if all are equal than its chaos and fight for power all times....be proud of caste but not degrade and insult,its about changing mindset on how we treat people of other castes by being friendly,its not all negative but by changing times is exploited.....its a thing present everywhere not just India
Only when HInduism offers a "so called" Dalit the oppurtunity to be converted to a Brahmin(who is of the same race as that of the brahmin btw), hinduism will survive. Otherwise it will vanish off from India. If we dont take measures now then dont be suprised if India becomes a majority Muslim, Christian state like how Kerala has already become. Reforms in hinduism is a must caste surnames which differentiate a person based on birth should be abolished and intercaste marriage should be encouraged.Period.
Like Arya Samaj.
Where can o Watch full Videos of all these shorts ?
Yes Jatiwad must be removed from India..law of equality must prevail..
0:32 and here I broked 🙂💔
Thanks that such nationalist voices are coming out in todays cheap antiBhaarat propaganda by paid houses like wire, ndtv, abpnews, quint, Indiatoday, aajtak etc. We need more of such programs to educate Sanatan Hindus and our society.
Tu zee news aur republic bharat dekh
Just read dharampal's Beautiful tree book and Rajiv Malhotra's breaking India..These will clarify your doubts
Can somebody give the full episode of this one please.
It does not matter what the real classification is/was whether you call it caste or varna. The fact is some people were discriminated based on this system. After saying this the current problem facing the nation is not the caste/varna system, it is politicizing the this system that is the cause. First abolish all reservations and entitlements to people.
Let us speak from heart we follow it, the age old practice, I don't know how old but discriminate people based on caste in which they are born! still many are following it! that is the truth!
Swami's explanation is absolutely right in terms of accepting all from all strata to be in four varnas BY KEEPING ASIDE THE BORN BRAHMAN OR THE BRAHMAN OF BRAHMINS the Parappana alias Paraiyer.
Born BRAHMAN Paraiyer clan was imposed to be outcaste by vesha brahmins (from all society) to uphold the propaganda that keeps only the non bharathiyans as BRAHMANs for their bright skin.
This channel has outstanding amazing and must to be viewed content by all indians.then why does this not have million subscribers or 10 million views.Our TN youtube channels have stingy and worthless content and also have moto of opposing whatever the state and central government does.They work on principle of separatism but have 4 or 5 million subscribers.
Brahmano ne Ved aur upnishads diya, yog, ayurved, jyotish, darshan, Ganit, Zero aur bahut kuch diya. Par apne liye Bhiksha mangkar jina chuna. Jiski wajah se brahmin aaj bhi garib hai. Desh, dharma, aur sanskriti ke liye hamesha apne aap ko sacrifice kiya. Aur aaj unhe iske badle sirf gaali mil rahi hai.
Brahmin garib??? 🤣
The backwardness should be decided on the basis of race and also on the economic criteria.
Half of the population get reservation while half not reserved while the population of the shudras is much higher than that of upper castes. So percentage wise also general categories get more share than reserved class.If you want to abolish reservation why don't you do big andolan of removing caste based harrassment in each& every villages of India. If you do so the reserved category people will abolish reservation themselves.
10 000 year headstart and the brahmins are still complaining. I am from the global diaspora and my first time in India I saw the caste system in full display in every aspect of society. People look at your name, then your skin tone than evaluate what and who you are before you can even say hello. I am from a so called "upper caste" and I definitely understood my privileged. Even standing in line for darshan at a temple, I was asked my name and ushered into another line that the priest claimed was "more appropriate" for me. Dinosaurs like Subramanianswamy are committed to dragging our culture back to the dark ages.
I want them to talk about Manusmriti
Ur Bible is full of Racism
@Kino Fan jati isn't mentioned anywhere, Varna is.
share this video on facebook, kimbho app and watsapp
There's is always different between stories and realties .
But this Swamiji doesn't know that
Varna means inequality
Inequality mean Varna
Watch Rajiv Malhotra's videos; he also said the same thing after an intense research. Brits (no offense to the present day British as we all are friends) created this caste system as part of their divide rule strategy - this is the reason the innocent Dalits sided with British against India. Another divide that the Brits created is the obvious Hindu-Muslim divide that created another nation - Pakistan.
Does anyone know anything about 13 point roster system used by the UGC ?
Caste system is still considered best for marriage purpose . If there is a common ness between two families life wil be l somewhat easier for the couple because here marriage is between two families not just boy and girl. How to avoid reservation is to be debated. Equal opportunity to all is a dream only. Survival of the fittest is the general rule for all liviing beings.creating more jobs will remove the need for reservation.
@Kino Fan There was a time when someone was denied learning vedas and sasrtras, spiritualisms. That was the only education for scholars. Not all people wete interested in it.. they has their own family sttucture learning based on their profession. . But today education is common to all. No one is denied schooling. Anyone can join and learn at par. If u argue he is getting more marks because of his caste u accept his knowledge is superior. . I dont think so. All can score irrespectice of caste. Need of reservation doesnt arise if all get opportunity. .but marriage needs understanding the family culture food habits spiritual understandings. There is common behavior among them. So i support the system of castes and oppose reservation as it haa nothing to do with brain workings.
Dalits and women were banned from reading or listening to the vedas. ..... and untouchability was practised by brahmins and upper castes on helpless dalit people .......If it was just a division of labour .....why the ill treatment towards innocent people Mr swamy
Because it is due to a poisonous book whose name is manusmriti which is not a part of religious scriptures
@@hattorikanzo8242 wrong manusmriti written by britishers real manusmriti favour shudras more then bhraman check difference between real and wrong manusmriti.
@@davanderprasadmaithani8993 can u pls tell me original source where i can trust
@@hattorikanzo8242 from vedrishi.com order manusmriti you will receive two books one real and one edited by britishers you can also see its unboxing on RUclips.
Varna Vaivastha is an Indic Anthropological Interpretation of Any Society which comes through you as per your reincarnation and life path these aren't caste based birth based but rather Roles and Responsibilities towards the Profession itself while maintaining Dharma and it's four pillars of Cleanliness, Truth, Compassion & Austerity
Tatva Varna Dharma
Akaasha Sadhu Surrender
Vayu Vaishaya Compassion
Agni Kshtriya Cleanliness
Jal Brahmin Minimalist
Dharti Shudhra Truth
Panch Tatva Prakriti
Panch Tatva Pravitri
Panch Tatva Shareer
Panch Tatva Samaaj
Aham Brahmasmi
I am the Universe
1 Aham Shudhra (Dharti)
2 Aham Brahamin (Jal)
3 Aham Kshtriya (Agni)
4 Aham Vaishya (Vayu)
5 Aham Sadhu (Akaash)
6 Aham Atama
7 Mahadeva Namo Namaha (Paramatma)
7 Chakra 7 Colours 7 Week Days 7 Primary Nav Grah other than Rahu & Ketu who are always on a retrograde while Rahu represents what you seek to resolve this life time (descend), Ketu represents your past life time which you mastered (ascend)
Within in Society Chatur Varna
1 Shudhra Artist | Shiva + Rudra
2 Brahmin Seeker | Brahma + Manu
3 Kshtriya Protector | Shakti + Tri Gun
4 Vaishya Explorer | Vishnu + Vayu
5 Sadhu Self Mastery | Sadhana
Reclusive Hermit who ran Gurukul & Ashram in Van away from society for better and higher learning process as it's an ideal place for attaining Shantata (Ideal state of mind coming from Navras) or mental state to imbibe knowledge.
Chatur Varna is for Karma Setup while
Gurukul is for establishing Dharma in all aspects so that each Varna works in accordance to one another as the panch Tatva work with one in prakriti.
All 5 together constitute Panch Varna Vaivasya, Panchnama are not tribals or those outside Chatur Varna but Panchnamas are Sadhus, Sant, Rishi's, Babas, Naga Babas who have renounced everything to pursue Sadhana.
As even in a tribal setup one would come across Chatur Varna system being practiced as someone would be a shaman or a warrior or an explorer or artists which is as Prakriti as in any kingdom or empire or Civilisation. The western interpretation of tribal comes from the word tri as most indeginious, pagan followers have a common lineage of believing in the concept of Trinity of Brahma Vishnu Mahesh or Poseidon, Zeus & Hades or pick any Civilization from Egyptian to Nordic to Greek to Romans and the trinity prevails but with different interpretations names and perception.
Thus we always had a
Panch-ayat System
Ram Rajya Pra-panch
Gram Rajya Sar-panch
Gram Raj Panch-ayat Raj
64 Kalas of Krishna 16 Kala Varna 4x16= 64
112 Sadhana of Mahadev 7x16= 112
In a Gurukul System where Education was taught on Bhiksha Siksha Diksha i.e. imbibing knowledge with humility than Ahanakar students would visit neighbouring village one by one to collect Bhiksha and their overall Interactions to the people along with their inclination towards studies and skills being taught would define their Pravitri. Living and residing in the Garva of Gurus the students would display their instinctive attributes towards each Varna and through their proficiency they would be allocated a certain Varna at their Graduation by the Guru's. If 9 months of Mother's Garva then 108 months in the sharan of Guru or 9 months of 12 years in a Gurukul.
Absolutely right Varna is not caste.
Because Varna changes in one's life and where he/she is and what is the immediate action .
The immediate action changes from one to another and so Varna changes from time to time in one's life and it is division of work.
Sanatan dharm hi satya h🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Not just knowledge but self knowledge.
All four has to depend on rest of three. 👍🏻
Varna is no caste system? Then what stoping you from marrying someone other than from your caste/varna??
@Prometheus lol if you follow the old text, then what stoping you? Why can't the Hindu society can't left go the jathi system and other social evils comes with it
Brahmans and the British the most to blame is Hindu Brahmans as they felt they better and superior
Good thesis to make believe.
Does he mean to say that there was no caste system before the advent of colonial rule?
If so, then this Manu Dharma had come in to practice only after the British came.
In other words, it was actually brought by the British.
Then how about Vyasa Mahabharatham's, " chaturvarnam mayam srishtyam".
Now he brings in another theory that the caste system is in other countries.
Appreciate if he could mention the names of castes prevalent in the western countries.
He takes chauvinism to it's peak. Of course, the listeners like such lullabies in all awe!!!
Ive never heard this about Brahmins not being accepted or dalits being a small caste is this true
Please Hindi version too ,
So we can use more to educate the people.
If reservations are done away. The best of the best shall lead organizations.
The rising tide would lift all boats.
Equality and equity are not the same thing. You cannot expect an underprivileged person from a modest background to compete with a wealthier person on merit alone. Minority rights are fundamental to the Indian Constitution.
Firstly get all citizens on the same level and then talk about the doing away with reservation
Lot of people say caste system was manipulated by British to divide people....
But does anyone know about the interaction of Sabri with Rama and Laxman in Ramayana ?
How can division of labour make anyone with realtively lesser profession an untouchable and not even allowed to read vedas and enter temples ????????
But it's no where written in vedas that shudra cannot enter temples.
@@shivangihere9141 thats what you need to understand and preach to the hidutva extremists and upper class brahmins
@Prometheus no Hindu house l find manu smriti. Veda Upanishads and Gita are authority of Hinduism. Not smritis. 😂😂😂. Got any thing else other than manusmriti ?
@@WiseWisdom141 no need to preach anyone. The lower caste must move towards University instead. And most of the leftists are upper caste Hindus for your information.
Varna is power of 4
To rule a country
Must have 4 ministry
Braman education
Satria defence army
Vaisiar merchant trading
Sutrar operation. Function
See vishnu. Letchmi sit near leg
Without functioning all jammed
@Sundar Rajan the duty of these departments are to contribute and spread thst to ensure others also have got it. Therefore snybody doing that is also refered by that occupation. These are name of profession. Nobody owns it.
@Sundar Rajan general knowledge is needed. But without the sutarer nobody is there to do manufacturing. Producing. Engineering. On whuch the eorld revolve. That is why Letchimy sits near leg of vishnu. Same for satrian.
Agree with Dr. Swamy but the ground report says a completely different story. Caste discrimination is real and it happens everywhere in India. But upper castes wouldn't know that because they don't go through it.
Misinterpretation/misuse as pointed.
I agree but then solution is to end all discrimination and create a merit based system where all are given equal opportunity
In fact, there are to varnas. The lowest adds and multiplies, highest takes away and divides.
So at the end he said unity but India is divided even before Christians Muslims Sikhs existed Hindu have been fighting eachother since it's beginning of pagan from worshipping one God to worshipping god's creations
Swami ji true
4th is land?? Or skills?
If you look at light and diamond from a far distance.. it looks similar ... but when you touch it ..their physical appearance is almost opposite .. light is transcendent ..higher dimension .. and diamonds are hard crystals like trapped souls ..lowest dimension sanatan dharma is all about merging with light i.e ultimate truth moksha ..and every other theory religion is all about becoming crystals i.e nothing but sucking souls and acting like light..when you make someone slave you are actually sucking their soul .. which feeds your ego and makes you diamond...earth is mere dot in this universe..and there are infinite species out of which there are diamond and light species..diamonds are scared of light because they cannot shine in light so they try their best to hide it from the earth ... its like warfare between Narcissist and Empath ..so illuminati and pyramid.. or tower of babel is all about becoming diamond.. by sucking soul.. so you cannot say who is bramhin and who is shudra ... cosmic game is very vast as compare to this varna and stuff...
In Gita krsna says " i created the 4 varnas". Ye sirf theory reha gaya hai.
Great leader great thought
Caste is not decided by birth.
At the age of 25 are all Sudra
No Brahmin Kshatriya accept this 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🙏🙏
Sabko pta hai khokli baate hain baba sahab itne padhe likhe the itne intellectual the phir bhi woh achut hi kehlate the toh yeh khokli baate na hi karo toh acha hai 😂
Forget it sir,even people who are in the business of interpreting gita have not been able to come to terms with varna and jati.they use it as per the situation.After all it was krsnas invention.It had to break down just like his own promises and rules that he himself broke depending upon the time situation and person he encountered on the kuruksetra.😂
Then today you should accept these outcasted people( made during mughal and British era) in today generation .
Are you saying my man Manu has nothing to do with it ?
YOU HEARD WHAT HE SAID
@@bhramitaatma6026
Yeah, I heard what he said but I didn't hear anything about Manu or his Smrithi.
@@mohan02 Hinduism is an open system, it's not a dogmatic religion like Abrahamic religions. It is not fixated on a single book. But this openness has a downside also.
Just like in recent time fake baba and gurus are miss using religion for their personal agenda like that in ancient time some manu wrote manusmiriti that doesn't mean it's a single source of Hinduism and it is fixated on it.
Everyone has bhagavad geeta in their home, no one keeps manusmiriti
Caste system will exist as long as untouchability of Dalits prevails. When untouchability exists, reservations should be there
So we indians have proved Bhrigu and Bhardwaja wrong after all? Now we have infinite number of Castes and no one knows what Varna is? The theoretical version of varna in Bhagwad Gita and the ground issue are poles apart.Why shouldn't our certificates mention our varna as against caste??? Si by that definition how many genuine brahmins are there in india who got only knowledge but no property worthy of mentioning? Narayanamoorthy of Infosys? Vijaya Mallaya? Sachin Tendulkar? The reality does not live up with the theoretical base.varna system has broken beyond recognition.
The hereditary caste system has no basis whatsoever in the ancient Vedic scriptures of India. In fact, the hereditary caste system is actually CONTRARY to what the Vedic scriptures teach. Originally, caste was never hereditary, it was originally only an organisation and categorisation of society based on occupation and what occupation you had was, in those ancient times, determined by whatever your predominant guna was ('guna' is a Sanskrit word that means something like 'mode' or 'tendency' in English). This is confirmed by Lord Krishna (who is considered to be God Himself in a human form by many Hindus) when He says in the Bhagavad Gita: “According to the three gunas and the work ascribed to them, the four divisions of human society were created by Me. And, although I am the creator of this system, you should know that I am yet the non-doer, being unchangeable.”
Also, all of the four castes were equally necessary for Vedic Civilisation to function properly. Kshatriyas are the arms, Brahmins are the head, Vaishyas are the stomach and Shudras are the feet. This is what the Vedic scriptures declare and the message is that a person needs a head, arms, a stomach and feet to properly function and that, in a similar way, society equally needs Brahmins, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas and Shudras to properly function. Also, the Vedic scriptures declared for the first time anywhere in the world thousands of years ago "Vasudhaiva kutumbakam" (which in Sanskrit means "The world is one family"). Furthermore, Lord Krishna also states in the Bhagavad Gita in Chapter 5, Verse 18: "The learned, with the eyes of divine knowledge, see with equal vision a priest, a cow, an elephant, a dog and a dog-eater."
Also, the Vedic scriptures were the first scriptures in the world to declare thousands of years ago the fundamental oneness of all living things, for example the Katha Upanishad says: "As the one fire, after it has entered the world, though one, takes different forms according to whatever it burns, so does the internal soul of all living beings, though one, takes a form according to whatever He enters and is outside all forms."
@rahil ganatra I'm not trying to fool anyone and I only gave you facts. But I now see that talking to you is like talking to a brick wall, which is why I will never talk to you again.
Sir, Let Sankaracharya declare Ambedkar as a Brahmin by Varna based system. In one stroke he would be compensate for centuries of blunders of Hindu pundits of caste system. The nation would go into raptures
Until you realize that you are only convincing yourself, you won't last, you will yourself stop diverting the people of India
Why was Siddhartha Gautama talking about the atrocities of the caste system in 5th Century BC? Can we be honest about the failures about our culture and move forward into the new century? What and who ever intended "Varna" as a choice does not apply to what it has devolved into in modern day India and the global diaspora. People living in Western Countries are listing their caste on their wedding invitations, so please be honest about what the caste system is truly about: privilege and exclusion. I am a proud Hindu from a so called "upper caste" raised and educated in the "West," but India's flirtation with neo-Brahmanical hegemony is problematic and disheartening to me. Just like our ideas about our origins has shifted from Aryan Invasion theory to Out of India theory, this too is out of India and needs to be acknowledged.
Where Buddha talk about cast
Which book you are talking
If you study actual book of Buddhism you will find cast and gender inequality there also
And Buddha was not a historical figures
@@kumark5569 He was just a dream of Asoka? Be honest sir.
India was never a unity under any hindu leader in recorded history. Even at the time of Alexander it was a continent of 150 raajwara's or sovereign states battling each other. If the brahmin really had the proclaimed venerated knowledge and no greed for wealth and power, then why varna system couldn't prove it's truth over a period of thousands of years, as swamiji saying that varna system was the unity in india. It was was the muslim rulers that united india for a substantial time and their legacy was continued by British. And had the stubborn extremist groups allowed the division of bengal and right to separate electorate for Muslims, india would have continued to exist as one unit.
We Can Respect Each Other Than There Is No CASTE OR VARNA!
To Difference People With Caste or Doing there work
He Told About Maharishi Viswamitira He Bron With Two People With There Lifestyle So, Nothing Gone Wrong But We Thinks Making Our Wrong
Example : British ppl Differentiate By Our Works Made Caste Telling Those Words Everyone But No One Can Follow The Rule Respected Those Ur Work What You Have Sree Krishna Bhagavatha Gita!
So never discriminated to the caste or other
JATI OR MATHI ! Fucking shit
JATI SYSTEM Not Followed By the Maharshi Viswamitira MOM & DADDY 🙏
We need to understand this and never vote anyone who asks for iur vote on basis of jatis
it doesn't matter what was happening / what is written in the texts ... what's important is what's happening ... he says brahmins shouldn't own anything but today brahmins have business houses , which is vaishya's forté .. but has there ever been any vaishya priest in any temple of significance ? ...(now i know apologetic brahmins and general category army will say a few handful - like 10-12 temples whose name no one has ever heard out of more than 10000 temples of india having a few dalith priests. but never ever a dalith or even a vaishya is even allowed to enter the temple's sanctum sanctorum) .. my elder brother was beaten out of temple in front of me when he was just standing in the arch entrance of the garbha gruha of a jagannath temple and at that time he was just 11 or so .. so this is how the other world lives .. first remove reservations from the temple prayer room