Looking through the comments, I realized that I made some errors in the video.. Here are the corrections: 0:51 - It should be "5,800 Pound Per Square Inch"* instead of "per square pounds of pressure" 3:42 - It's 100 elephants* instead of 200 5:08 - David Lochridge, former director of Oceangate was fired** Not Rob McCallum Thank you to everyone pointing out the errors, I'll be more careful with my future uploads.
Have to respect a personal striving for accuracy and being willing to accept criticism.. seems to be becoming increasingly rare in modern society. Well done.
I hate to keep repeating myself but - I like how the internet is waking up to the fact that just because you have a degree, a diploma, an award, billions of dollars, a book, a medal, a pretty face, a rich background, a fancy wardrobe, a catchy name, a cool idea or invention, DOESN'T MEAN YOU ARE INCAPABLE OF DOING SOME STUPID SH_T.
Thank you! When I was in Grad school, there was a fellow student that everyone thought very highly of. And, to be fair, he was pretty great. Officer in student government, PhD candidate in molecular bio, published his first paper as an undergrad... but I also saw him passed out in the hallway at 2 AM because he was huffing ether in the lab while working on a project overnight...
Another example of extreme arrogance surrounded by unprincipled sheeple. It was not just him, but hundreds of people surrounding him who went along with his charade. Kind of like Fauci…
They didn't feel pain but their last moments were definitely in a panic knowing that they were in serious trouble. Especially if they were hearing cracking noise they knew, or at least rush knew they were doomed at that moment
Its called the “Stockton paradox” When a knowledgeable person in a specific field disregards the expert advice from a different field, it can lead to a situation where valuable insights or perspectives are overlooked and people die
Also called Borderline Personality Disorder (massive ego, narcissistic, tyrannical demeanour, etc). My ex has a very similar disorder. You do not have to be like rush to be an adventurous sort.
The extreme level of poetic and symbolic irony is so high with this case. Stockton Rush "rushed" a submersible that killed passengers due to his hubris and overconfidence, the same hubris and overconfidence that lead to the Titanic disaster, on a sub named Titan.
That is one of the first things I said about it. It probably degraded the hull via the past dives and it gave out under pressure. Carbon fiber literally shatters when it fails, this is the Hindenburg of submersibles…
Its not known if it was the carbon Fibre itself that failed. Other experts seemed more concerned of using 3 different materials together. This sub used carbon fiber, titanium and plexiglass. Other submarines rated for this depth only use 1 or 2 materials and are certified.
There are many kinds of carbon fiber layups, not all of them are shatter prone. Also whether it shatters or not doesn't really matter, you dead if the material fails.
@@mischiefpwns the glue itself holding the CF to the Titanium ring is very SUS. Repeated dives could make the rigid CF "pop" open leaving the CF & ring gap large enough to ingress and act as a can opener (instant with no warning).
From what i saw pulled up from the wreckage, it looks like the caps blew off before the actual carbon fiber shredded itself. The annimation thats getting passed around shows not only the hull, but the whole submersable imploding. Theres a chanel on youtube with some russian dudes who do a scaled down cersion where the caps blow apart… that seems legit
There’s reports now, that for 40sec’s or longer the sub was dropping vertically out of control of the pilot/owner… they KNEW it was going to happen… the owner stated he designed the sub to descend so slowly it won’t be noticed, however after loss of power, it descended 10x as fast as designed… vertically like a dart (if accurate by reports)… this would case everyone to tumble forward all on top one another…. Pitch black, falling uncontrollably, they KNEW and they probably were panicked. Sure, the implosion is so fast can’t be sensed…. But those 45sec’s could have been wildly chaotic before the implosion.
I'm not sure I believe that Spanish engineer. I hope he's wrong for the 4 victims, but I must say I wouldn't mind knowing that Rush realized that he was wrong.
this type of content and animation is dope, compared to your other channel i hope you get to use this as an outlet to branch out and explore more topics your interested in definitely looking forward to more
The Titan was the world's first genuinely throw away submersible. It was engineered to safely last ONE DIVE. Stockton Rush refused to do the adequate and proper research to prove that and killed himself and four other people. Had Stockton Rush done the proper research, he could have enlarged the Titan sub as well as reinforced and enlarged the viewport window so the experience was more memorable and charged the very rich people, he was taking down, a one million dollar each, trip fee, which could have allowed him to simply use a new sub every time. Instead, he's dead. Stockton Rush was NOT a visionary. Stockton Rush was NOT a genius. Stockton Rush was NOT an explorer. Stockton Rush was a fool and now Stockton Rush is a dead fool and the murderer of four people in that process of killing himself. The management of OceanGate knew this sub was getting more dangerous every time it went down, and they participated in concert with Stockton, to never tell anyone, especially the customers, about that fact. So, the entire upper management of OceanGate should be arrested for accessory to negligent homicide after the fact. The fact that they knew the carbon fiber was crackling much louder and worse on every successive dive as it went deeper, shows they knew it was delaminating but, they just had to get that cash! Four people are dead who should not be dead. Stockton wanted to kill himself, that's on Stockton. He should have been in that sub alone.
I've watched many many videos on the Oceangate story. Yours was one of the best. :) Very informative, concise, great edition and graphics. I would gladly watch a part 2 with more details on the development, rescue, and aftermath.
Other than a few details you got wrong (you already acknowledged it below in the comments) It was nice brief informative video. I hope you make more like this.
You asked for feedback: You say they were unaware of their impending death but from what I've heard via supposed transcripts it seems they were fighting to resurface for quite a while and towards the end could hear it giving way worsening over time.
@JesseKlaus those "supposed" transcripts have been labeled a hoax by several people with access to the deep sea submersible community (some of whom reportedly had contact with the launch ship crew during the search for Titan).. The hoax transcript first appeared on an anonymous Tik Tok site. The faked log entry did not use the abbreviations used in valid Titan comms. Furthermore, the fake script is a replica of a communication between the ship and Titan on a dive that occurred in 2019, where they could not drop ballast, but did finally do it manually and returned to the surface. Anonymous Tik Tok users are not reputable sources.
Yeah, what a clown he was... The ONLY thing he did right was to be the driver on every dive. He didn't just sit safely at the surface while the Pringles can failed.
The Titan wasnt engineered. There was no testing. They even used outdated carbon fiber and parts scrounged together from Walmart. It was a hack job, put together by a hackmaster.
Gawd!!! I watched the 2nd video 1st... Now ALL I CAN SEE when I see the front port is a BATHROOM!! I thought the were scoping it out and getting a view! I was completely un aware that was the area where they drew a sheet to use the toilet!
I liked your video a lot! Nice job! Nice voice! Nice graphics! As for constructive criticism, here are my thoughts. - In your image of the cracks appearing on the sub, there is a mistake. The part that was white was not the carbon fiber hull itself but a "skin" of either vinyl or fiberglass. The carbon fiber hull was black. - 5,800 is five thousand eight hundred not 5.8 thousand. - Nargeolet is pronounced Nar zho ley, it's not your fault lol, it's French. - Newfoundland is not pronounced newFOUNDland but NOO fuhnd luhnd. Again, not your fault really. You can find out how to pronounce difficult words, names etc online beforehand perhaps. I think that's it! Well done for a first time!!! I'm subscribing! 😊 👋🇨🇦
better they redesign this to be a remote controlled drone, and you sit in a cockpit or virtual reality headset to give you the sensation you're in the submersible.
I read that at one point, on another dive, Rush gave the toy controller to a passenger and let him "drive". The sub started immediately going backwards and couldn't be made to work. The reason? The passenger was holding the controller upside down, so instead of pushing forward, he was pushing backwards... 🙄🤦🤣
While you’re considering modes of death, statistically most of you idiots will starve. And at the end of your lives, you’ll all still be unremarkable useless morons.
@mafiaer-info Implosion sequence (compression-heat-ignition-explosion) ON LAND is not comparable to what occurs in a large, very cold volume of water. First, the volume of gas in the hull was small, and compressed to a very, very small volume, so heat/ignition source is tiny. Second, the carbon fiber hull shatters in extreme compression, it does not dent and bend into a smaller volume, like your metal drum in the video. Because of the shattering, any heat-ignition of this small volume of gas took place in a huge volume of water. Any heat-ignition effects would be minimal, probably negligible. Implosion scenarios that take place in a large volume of air (which is also a fuel source for ignition) behave quite differently than in the volume of low temp water present here. My source is comments of engineers with some explosives background on another RUclips site.
with no seats if something adversely effected buoyancy balance such as a leak or loss of control all the passengers would end up piled on top of each other on one end making the craft end heavy and it would plummet like a rock to the bottom
This is actually a scenario described by a Spanish engineer! Imagine too, that if that happened, the contents of the "toilet" would go everywhere.. Shitty way to die...
And to save money. I had absolutely no problem with the use of a controller in this submersible. And you people need to concentrate more on the hull of the submersible. This controller thing has become an obsession with you people. Apparently many submersibles use game controllers and I love the concept as long as the systems they are operating are checked to see if everything is OK. But apparently on that day when the Titan sub was spinning in circles, Stockton Rush's idiots didn't check before the sub was set in the water. I wonder how far in debt Stockton Rush was? I will always feel that Stockton Rush had a death wish to kill himself and his passengers.
It's not the type of hand controller that is the issue. It is the issue of its power source: wireless, which is notorious for interrupts and outages, as Titan's history shows. In addition, having a couple extra hand controllers is pretty useless when you have no backups for your power source. Hand held wireless controllers are used in the military, but never in manned operations. In submarines they are wired, have several backup power sources, and never used as the primary vehicle controller, only to control smaller elements of operation, such as the periscope. Also, those hand controllers have sophisticated spark retardant features. The titan controller had none, like the rest of his on board electronics. Insane, in an enclosed space where oxygen is being pumped in.
There’s quite a bit of misinformation and incorrect information in this video… from the actual depth of Titanic, to the dimensions of Titan, and several other “facts” stated. Might want to cross check your info before publishing.
So the mother got cold feet and send her son instead because there are no refunds for the $250, 000 fee. The irony in that is, her son wasn't even born when the James Cameron movie Titanic was released, let alone knowing anything about the Titanic shipwreck a century plus years ago. I think the son agreed to go only to please his parents and their sick obsession with this century old gravesite at the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean and because he trusted them. I feel really sad for that 19yo kid..RIP
Wrong. Mrs. Dawood gave Suleman her spot because he wanted to please his Dad for Father's day. He was terrified of the dive but loved his Dad more. Don't blame the victims, the only donkey's derriere is the murderer Stockton Rush.
The skinhead standing to Captain Nemo's right is suppose to be Ocean Crap's chief engineer. They should be looking hard at inditeing him for capable negligence.
What's the point of your absurd question? If the pressure vessel fails nothing else matters. No safety device could help you in that event. You're alive one moment and dead the next. I'm assuming you're not stupid, but at best your comment is a bad dumb joke.
No, the implosion crushed them instantly and also incinerated the cabin in a millisecond. The men all died before they knew anything happened. Also, there were no seats to attach belts to. Finally, they did have sand bags and other ballast. The bags were made to eventually dissolve & allow the sub to ascend after a certain number of hours. It was pointless however, there was nothing & no one to help ascend.
Stop calling him a “visionary entrepreneur” He was a dangerous con man and a failure who killed himself and four others unnecessarily because of greed and malignant narcissism
Someone needs to build a radio control Titan Submarine and a scale model of the Titanic and put it down in a swimming pool, and dive the radio control Titan Sub to show the potential future jurors in the upcoming court case for compensation for the victim's lawsuit.
@@m3gAnac0nda It lost electrical power then it tilted forward so the little window was facing down and plunged like a rock for 40-70 seconds in complete darkness… 😬
Deduction versus speculation. You can think of deduction as using known laws combined with verifiable facts to determine a likely conclusion. Speculation can be seen as just imagining outcomes, both possible and outlandish. Known laws. Carbon fiber weakens when subjected to crushing pressures. Sensors can be placed in hulls to warn of imminent failure. Seams are inherently weaker than a solid, monolithic construction ... meaning fewer seams leads to a stronger vessel. The Titan was made of composite materials with large stretches of vulnerable seams held together by glue and rings bolted to the craft. Known facts. Titan and its carbon fiber hull had made several trips to crushing depths. There were sensors in the hull of the Titan. The integrity of the craft failed. Speculation. The ballast was released. The landing ramp was jettisoned. The power failed. The craft plunged to the bottom in an uncontrolled nose dive. There is an accurate transcript of the final communications. These speculations are all possible, but unconfirmed. One can deduce that the sensors warned of a problem and the crew, fearing instant death due to an implosion, tried to surface but failed. The attempt likely involved releasing ballast and the landing frame ... but they may not have had time or been able to do so or chose not to. Who knows? Citing sources seems to be a rare, if not unheard of, phenomenon. Be wary of clickbait and emotionally dramatic stories. Maybe they lost power. Maybe they were unconcerned and blissfully unaware of their impending doom. Stick to the facts and, maybe, place those facts within known behaviors of material at pressure, reactions of humans in similar situations, and likely probable factors (sensors working, cracks just before failure being louder than expected, concern at the sluggish rate of ascent, etc.)
Must have been absolutely terrifying, especially for the 19 year old who was already scared for the trip to begin with. Hopefully mr Rush never told his guests what he thought what the problem was, and that an implosion would be imminent. Otherwise I feel like those people must have been in a total state of panic :( They never felt the actual implosion so luckily they did not have to suffer that way.
@@HummusLad President Biden is actually doing a decent job. 13 million good jobs created in 2 years, 1 million in the manufacturing sector alone, insulin price cut for $650 to $35, infrastructure bill passed, sick leave for railway workers etc. And I'm not even American, but he is liked & respected in most of the world.
Looking through the comments, I realized that I made some errors in the video.. Here are the corrections:
0:51 - It should be "5,800 Pound Per Square Inch"* instead of "per square pounds of pressure"
3:42 - It's 100 elephants* instead of 200
5:08 - David Lochridge, former director of Oceangate was fired** Not Rob McCallum
Thank you to everyone pointing out the errors, I'll be more careful with my future uploads.
Have to respect a personal striving for accuracy and being willing to accept criticism.. seems to be becoming increasingly rare in modern society. Well done.
Ai writes his scripts
You also forgot that Titan has a T in the middle. Its Not Ti-in
I hate to keep repeating myself but - I like how the internet is waking up to the fact that just because you have a degree, a diploma, an award, billions of dollars, a book, a medal, a pretty face, a rich background, a fancy wardrobe, a catchy name, a cool idea or invention, DOESN'T MEAN YOU ARE INCAPABLE OF DOING SOME STUPID SH_T.
Thank you! When I was in Grad school, there was a fellow student that everyone thought very highly of. And, to be fair, he was pretty great. Officer in student government, PhD candidate in molecular bio, published his first paper as an undergrad... but I also saw him passed out in the hallway at 2 AM because he was huffing ether in the lab while working on a project overnight...
@@SGarrett1979 Nice. Shining example.❤
That's a great list! It's missing one thing though.....common sense.
Huh it's almost as if we are all flawed human beings... Who believes these people are infallible?
No one ever thought that
it was not a single mistake, it was a long chain of "I am smarter than the rest of you " type of mistakes
Another example of extreme arrogance surrounded by unprincipled sheeple.
It was not just him, but hundreds of people surrounding him who went along with his charade. Kind of like Fauci…
Years ago, I knew someone who had about a 14% chance of actually showing up for work.
They didn't feel pain but their last moments were definitely in a panic knowing that they were in serious trouble. Especially if they were hearing cracking noise they knew, or at least rush knew they were doomed at that moment
It was GOOD, and without too much BLAH BLAH. Straight to the point. Good job
Be safe, don’t “Rush” it. I see this becoming a safety motto
Like how boxer world-class champion Willie Pep influenced the creation of the saying "Put a Pep in your step". 😅
Rush and Implode
Its called the “Stockton paradox” When a knowledgeable person in a specific field disregards the expert advice from a different field, it can lead to a situation where valuable insights or perspectives are overlooked and people die
Dunning Kruger syndrome.
Also called Borderline Personality Disorder (massive ego, narcissistic, tyrannical demeanour, etc). My ex has a very similar disorder.
You do not have to be like rush to be an adventurous sort.
Yeah but the people that replaced the expert are extremely inspirational
They may not have felt anything but I bet they heard it, probably for a few minutes
I wonder how stockton would be spinning this if he hadn't been part of that trip
Ocean gate is the new heaven's gate
Or "Watergate II".
They had the ultimate Titanic experience
Brutal but true
Ya get what you pay for.
Never ever change the name of a boat! It's very bad luck...
And calling it Titan was just begging for trouble...
The extreme level of poetic and symbolic irony is so high with this case. Stockton Rush "rushed" a submersible that killed passengers due to his hubris and overconfidence, the same hubris and overconfidence that lead to the Titanic disaster, on a sub named Titan.
That is one of the first things I said about it. It probably degraded the hull via the past dives and it gave out under pressure. Carbon fiber literally shatters when it fails, this is the Hindenburg of submersibles…
Its not known if it was the carbon Fibre itself that failed. Other experts seemed more concerned of using 3 different materials together. This sub used carbon fiber, titanium and plexiglass. Other submarines rated for this depth only use 1 or 2 materials and are certified.
There are many kinds of carbon fiber layups, not all of them are shatter prone. Also whether it shatters or not doesn't really matter, you dead if the material fails.
@@mischiefpwns the glue itself holding the CF to the Titanium ring is very SUS. Repeated dives could make the rigid CF "pop" open leaving the CF & ring gap large enough to ingress and act as a can opener (instant with no warning).
@@zlonewolf Also the fact titanium deforms under those pressures differently than the carbon fiber. That absolutely could have been the failure point.
From what i saw pulled up from the wreckage, it looks like the caps blew off before the actual carbon fiber shredded itself. The annimation thats getting passed around shows not only the hull, but the whole submersable imploding. Theres a chanel on youtube with some russian dudes who do a scaled down cersion where the caps blow apart… that seems legit
There’s reports now, that for 40sec’s or longer the sub was dropping vertically out of control of the pilot/owner… they KNEW it was going to happen… the owner stated he designed the sub to descend so slowly it won’t be noticed, however after loss of power, it descended 10x as fast as designed… vertically like a dart (if accurate by reports)… this would case everyone to tumble forward all on top one another…. Pitch black, falling uncontrollably, they KNEW and they probably were panicked. Sure, the implosion is so fast can’t be sensed…. But those 45sec’s could have been wildly chaotic before the implosion.
vertically is the only way something can drop...
@@IAMPLEDGE
Well... technically yes, absolutely, but some things can spiral, or like act like a leaf.
I'm not sure I believe that Spanish engineer.
I hope he's wrong for the 4 victims, but I must say I wouldn't mind knowing that Rush realized that he was wrong.
@@abelis644He wasn't wrong. They died screaming.
Beautifully produced video!
You found all the good info, very well put together
this type of content and animation is dope, compared to your other channel i hope you get to use this as an outlet to branch out and explore more topics your interested in definitely looking forward to more
The Titan was the world's first genuinely throw away submersible. It was engineered to safely last ONE DIVE. Stockton Rush refused to do the adequate and proper research to prove that and killed himself and four other people. Had Stockton Rush done the proper research, he could have enlarged the Titan sub as well as reinforced and enlarged the viewport window so the experience was more memorable and charged the very rich people, he was taking down, a one million dollar each, trip fee, which could have allowed him to simply use a new sub every time.
Instead, he's dead. Stockton Rush was NOT a visionary. Stockton Rush was NOT a genius. Stockton Rush was NOT an explorer. Stockton Rush was a fool and now Stockton Rush is a dead fool and the murderer of four people in that process of killing himself.
The management of OceanGate knew this sub was getting more dangerous every time it went down, and they participated in concert with Stockton, to never tell anyone, especially the customers, about that fact. So, the entire upper management of OceanGate should be arrested for accessory to negligent homicide after the fact. The fact that they knew the carbon fiber was crackling much louder and worse on every successive dive as it went deeper, shows they knew it was delaminating but, they just had to get that cash!
Four people are dead who should not be dead. Stockton wanted to kill himself, that's on Stockton. He should have been in that sub alone.
I've watched many many videos on the Oceangate story. Yours was one of the best. :) Very informative, concise, great edition and graphics. I would gladly watch a part 2 with more details on the development, rescue, and aftermath.
Very good presentation and information, and understanding of what happened
I like your videos on this channel. Subbed.
"Tarnished?" Destroyed!
It’s really sad, anyway u look at it. Most sad is the boy didn’t want to go, but did so for dad on Father’s Day.
Unwavering ego was the primary cause.
I enjoyed this vid. It was well done.
Other than a few details you got wrong (you already acknowledged it below in the comments) It was nice brief informative video. I hope you make more like this.
what more videos with one error per 2 minutes? Hardly seems worth it.
You asked for feedback:
You say they were unaware of their impending death but from what I've heard via supposed transcripts it seems they were fighting to resurface for quite a while and towards the end could hear it giving way worsening over time.
@JesseKlaus those "supposed" transcripts have been labeled a hoax by several people with access to the deep sea submersible community (some of whom reportedly had contact with the launch ship crew during the search for Titan).. The hoax transcript first appeared on an anonymous Tik Tok site. The faked log entry did not use the abbreviations used in valid Titan comms. Furthermore, the fake script is a replica of a communication between the ship and Titan on a dive that occurred in 2019, where they could not drop ballast, but did finally do it manually and returned to the surface. Anonymous Tik Tok users are not reputable sources.
That's from that dubious "transcript", it may be fake.
"safety is just pure waste"
Yeah, what a clown he was...
The ONLY thing he did right was to be the driver on every dive.
He didn't just sit safely at the surface while the Pringles can failed.
The Titan wasnt engineered. There was no testing. They even used outdated carbon fiber and parts scrounged together from Walmart. It was a hack job, put together by a hackmaster.
Yes, waste of 4 lives. (I don't count the murderer.)
Gawd!!! I watched the 2nd video 1st...
Now ALL I CAN SEE when I see the front port is a BATHROOM!!
I thought the were scoping it out and getting a view!
I was completely un aware that was the area where they drew a sheet to use the toilet!
Thx 4 sharing. ❤❤
Well, using game controllers isn't uncommon. It's simple and reliable. The military is actually using it for the guns on some weapons
yes, for guns, not for the main navigation. FFS.
@@IAMPLEDGE what is even the problem specifically with using a game controller on veichles, especially when the same general design is used for drones
for a first time video it was pretty good
I liked your video a lot! Nice job! Nice voice! Nice graphics!
As for constructive criticism, here are my thoughts.
- In your image of the cracks appearing on the sub, there is a mistake. The part that was white was not the carbon fiber hull itself but a "skin" of either vinyl or fiberglass. The carbon fiber hull was black.
- 5,800 is five thousand eight hundred not 5.8 thousand.
- Nargeolet is pronounced
Nar zho ley, it's not your fault lol, it's French.
- Newfoundland is not pronounced newFOUNDland but
NOO fuhnd luhnd.
Again, not your fault really.
You can find out how to pronounce difficult words, names etc online beforehand perhaps.
I think that's it!
Well done for a first time!!!
I'm subscribing! 😊
👋🇨🇦
He rush into it
better they redesign this to be a remote controlled drone, and you sit in a cockpit or virtual reality headset to give you the sensation you're in the submersible.
But then you don’t get to smell that cold cold sweat of terror
no, better to leave it to the experts. The type of craft you describe already exists. There is no need to design it.
VR isn't the same. Rich people want to SEE the Titanic.
0:04 “In this video, we’re going to dive deep into the details…” was that pun… intended? 💀
7:13 "Rushed development"
@@WarningSign1000 haha good one
"visionary" ;-)
They will be making a movie soon just like they made a movie of the titantic even thought it was a tragic event
❤
Let me find out he forgot to change the battery in the controller and didn't bring extra batteries 🤔
I read that at one point, on another dive, Rush gave the toy controller to a passenger and let him "drive".
The sub started immediately going backwards and couldn't be made to work.
The reason?
The passenger was holding the controller upside down, so instead of pushing forward, he was pushing backwards... 🙄🤦🤣
“The immense pressure of 5.8 thousand pounds per square pounds of pressure?” 0:50
He fixed that.
Be constructive now, it's his 1st video.😊
@@abelis644pointing out the error is being constructive.
I will point out, that you pointing out that error has already been pointed out. Do ya get my point ?😊
Let’s say Stockton has an 86% failure rate, do you want to get in that plastic tub now?
He was many things, but he was not a visionary.
HAHA! He said DIVE DEEP into the DETAILS!!!! Ha ha ha ha ha ha
The nose dive would have been awful situation to be in .
Such a cute deep sea coffin for 5
Interesting comment.
And it gets a like from the creator! Wow
@@frankdux4515upset you?
@@RedVoteRedemption really upset about only these 5, why not more?
@@kcleong7135 space tourism will eventually kill
While you’re considering modes of death, statistically most of you idiots will starve. And at the end of your lives, you’ll all still be unremarkable useless morons.
I wonder if Stocktons Wig survived.
@mafiaer-info Implosion sequence (compression-heat-ignition-explosion) ON LAND is not comparable to what occurs in a large, very cold volume of water. First, the volume of gas in the hull was small, and compressed to a very, very small volume, so heat/ignition source is tiny. Second, the carbon fiber hull shatters in extreme compression, it does not dent and bend into a smaller volume, like your metal drum in the video. Because of the shattering, any heat-ignition of this small volume of gas took place in a huge volume of water. Any heat-ignition effects would be minimal, probably negligible. Implosion scenarios that take place in a large volume of air (which is also a fuel source for ignition) behave quite differently than in the volume of low temp water present here. My source is comments of engineers with some explosives background on another RUclips site.
They tried to save money on the hull. Instead of steel or titanium they used carbon Fibre. Then they said it's in an experiment sub.😂😂
with no seats if something adversely effected buoyancy balance such as a leak or loss of control all the passengers would end up piled on top of each other on one end making the craft end heavy and it would plummet like a rock to the bottom
This is actually a scenario described by a Spanish engineer!
Imagine too, that if that happened, the contents of the "toilet" would go everywhere..
Shitty way to die...
I find it amazing that there were no seats, belts of grips. Utter incompetence.
great video needs more views
And to save money. I had absolutely no problem with the use of a controller in this submersible. And you people need to concentrate more on the hull of the submersible. This controller thing has become an obsession with you people. Apparently many submersibles use game controllers and I love the concept as long as the systems they are operating are checked to see if everything is OK. But apparently on that day when the Titan sub was spinning in circles, Stockton Rush's idiots didn't check before the sub was set in the water.
I wonder how far in debt Stockton Rush was? I will always feel that Stockton Rush had a death wish to kill himself and his passengers.
I agree 1000%. The controller was the least of their worries. The controller, controlled solenoids, relays, motors. They had backup controllers.
It's not the type of hand controller that is the issue. It is the issue of its power source: wireless, which is notorious for interrupts and outages, as Titan's history shows. In addition, having a couple extra hand controllers is pretty useless when you have no backups for your power source. Hand held wireless controllers are used in the military, but never in manned operations. In submarines they are wired, have several backup power sources, and never used as the primary vehicle controller, only to control smaller elements of operation, such as the periscope. Also, those hand controllers have sophisticated spark retardant features. The titan controller had none, like the rest of his on board electronics. Insane, in an enclosed space where oxygen is being pumped in.
Sadly he risked his own life.With all this money for the trip.aHe is not alive to enjoy it
There’s quite a bit of misinformation and incorrect information in this video… from the actual depth of Titanic, to the dimensions of Titan, and several other “facts” stated. Might want to cross check your info before publishing.
Toy submarine.....
7” Plexi Glass that weighed 80lbs. This guy was out of his mind
"Don't worry, those cracking sounds happen every time, it's totally norm......................
yeah and like fireworks and bullets it should be used a maximum of once (at at push).
@@IAMPLEDGE They would all still be here if that rule was followed.
What did the Crip gang member say to the other Crip gang member on the sub? “What’s craccin Cuhh “
You people need to get off this game controller, that controller was the most reliable and technical advanced system on the whole sub,
Should expand a new company called
" Ocean gate deep sea coffin ⚰️" entrepreneur .
"Rush" development lol
overall very informative and thorough analysis. would luv some intro music.
So the mother got cold feet and send her son instead because there are no refunds for the $250, 000 fee. The irony in that is, her son wasn't even born when the James Cameron movie Titanic was released, let alone knowing anything about the Titanic shipwreck a century plus years ago. I think the son agreed to go only to please his parents and their sick obsession with this century old gravesite at the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean and because he trusted them. I feel really sad for that 19yo kid..RIP
Wrong.
Mrs. Dawood gave Suleman her spot because he wanted to please his Dad for Father's day.
He was terrified of the dive but loved his Dad more.
Don't blame the victims, the only donkey's derriere is the murderer Stockton Rush.
The skinhead standing to Captain Nemo's right is suppose to be Ocean Crap's chief engineer. They should be looking hard at inditeing him for capable negligence.
Can't. Waivers were signed.
Everyone wants to point fingers.
Thanks
In your opinion: If the sub was fitted with airbags and seatbelts than do you think the passengers could have survived?
What's the point of your absurd question?
If the pressure vessel fails nothing else matters.
No safety device could help you in that event. You're alive one moment and dead the next.
I'm assuming you're not stupid, but at best your comment is a bad dumb joke.
no. Mainly because it didn't have any seats.
I really hope this is sarcasm or satire.
No, the implosion crushed them instantly and also incinerated the cabin in a millisecond.
The men all died before they knew anything happened.
Also, there were no seats to attach belts to.
Finally, they did have sand bags and other ballast.
The bags were made to eventually dissolve & allow the sub to ascend after a certain number of hours.
It was pointless however, there was nothing & no one to help ascend.
Well it wasn’t a single mistake it was a plethora of mistakes over many years.
"Oceangate has tarnished their reputation"? You reckon? I've never heard a more useless observation in all my life.
How to spot a non-Canadian. They always pronounce Newfoundland as NewFOUNDland.
You mean how to spot a non Newfie. Many mainlanders pronounce it like that.
@@LadyHeathersLair
Newfie is derogatory.
Carbon fiber is great for holding internal pressure. It is not good for resisting external pressure.
Stop calling him a “visionary entrepreneur” He was a dangerous con man and a failure who killed himself and four others unnecessarily because of greed and malignant narcissism
Facts.
He was a visionary.
Stay mad. 😊
No replies will be seen
It wasn't even a real Xbox controller. It was an off brand cheap version which are notoriously buggy.
Although you are right, the controller had no part in the implosion.
I have a Logitech G F710 controller (wireless game pad)
Someone needs to build a radio control Titan Submarine and a scale model of the Titanic and put it down in a swimming pool, and dive the radio control Titan Sub to show the potential future jurors in the upcoming court case for compensation for the victim's lawsuit.
There won't be a lawsuit. Waivers were signed.
❤
Hopefully they recovered the cameras. The thing had inside and outside cameras.
F yeah, wanna see the panic as the bs alarm went off
@@m3gAnac0nda
It lost electrical power then it tilted forward so the little window was facing down and plunged like a rock for 40-70 seconds in complete darkness… 😬
@@joebidenshandler2149 so funny 🤣🤣
@@joebidenshandler2149
That's from the transcript that may be fake.
They lost power... Cameras need some juice to work.
Never change the name of a marine vessel, bad luck.
do you really think that luck played a part in this? Next you'll be telling me it was an act of (some imaginary) god...
@@IAMPLEDGE
😅
“Military Grade” = “made well enough, by the lowest bidder”
Off camera he said they fkdup🎉
This sub was built to fail,
New-what?!
Newfoundland.
A Canadian province.
He pronounced it wrong.
@abelis644 lmao I know that. His pronunciation.
Who would even take the Ocean gay
Hi
Greetings!
@@Mafier-Documentary not tryna be rude, though the 14% means how many times they actually made it down
which was 13 0ut of 90 dives
@@PGRustic I see. Thanks for letting me know, I corrected it.
@@Mafier-Documentary np good video btw
"Per square pounds." Smh
Diogenes' barrel was better built than the Titan.
The macaroni Christmas tree I made in grade 1 was better built than the Titan... and prettier with its gold paint. 🎄
Deduction versus speculation. You can think of deduction as using known laws combined with verifiable facts to determine a likely conclusion. Speculation can be seen as just imagining outcomes, both possible and outlandish. Known laws. Carbon fiber weakens when subjected to crushing pressures. Sensors can be placed in hulls to warn of imminent failure. Seams are inherently weaker than a solid, monolithic construction ... meaning fewer seams leads to a stronger vessel. The Titan was made of composite materials with large stretches of vulnerable seams held together by glue and rings bolted to the craft. Known facts. Titan and its carbon fiber hull had made several trips to crushing depths. There were sensors in the hull of the Titan. The integrity of the craft failed. Speculation. The ballast was released. The landing ramp was jettisoned. The power failed. The craft plunged to the bottom in an uncontrolled nose dive. There is an accurate transcript of the final communications. These speculations are all possible, but unconfirmed. One can deduce that the sensors warned of a problem and the crew, fearing instant death due to an implosion, tried to surface but failed. The attempt likely involved releasing ballast and the landing frame ... but they may not have had time or been able to do so or chose not to. Who knows? Citing sources seems to be a rare, if not unheard of, phenomenon. Be wary of clickbait and emotionally dramatic stories. Maybe they lost power. Maybe they were unconcerned and blissfully unaware of their impending doom. Stick to the facts and, maybe, place those facts within known behaviors of material at pressure, reactions of humans in similar situations, and likely probable factors (sensors working, cracks just before failure being louder than expected, concern at the sluggish rate of ascent, etc.)
Greed kills.
Dafuck is per square pound
I think 14% was the successful dive rate. So 14% of the dives actually made it to see the Titanic. Otherwise great video.
Yes you're right. Thank you for notifying.
@@Mafier-Documentary
Hey there, I left you a comment at the top.😊
Nice job!
5, 800 pounds, *per *square *inch.
o
TALKING SLIDE SHOW ⚠️
So?
Do better for a first video!!!
It was pretty good.
Do better research they were AWARE for at least 20 minutes of severe problem and tried to ascend.
Must have been absolutely terrifying, especially for the 19 year old who was already scared for the trip to begin with. Hopefully mr Rush never told his guests what he thought what the problem was, and that an implosion would be imminent. Otherwise I feel like those people must have been in a total state of panic :( They never felt the actual implosion so luckily they did not have to suffer that way.
That's not necessarily true.
The "transcript" hasn't been verified yet.
It's a shame that trump couldn't have been on board. Although it's questionable on whether he could even afford it.
But Donald needs his Attends all the time, it would have been really smelly in there.
TDS
@@HummusLad
President Biden is actually doing a decent job. 13 million good jobs created in 2 years, 1 million in the manufacturing sector alone,
insulin price cut for $650 to $35, infrastructure bill passed,
sick leave for railway workers etc.
And I'm not even American, but he is liked & respected in most of the world.
@@BobConnor-n2g
That would be so disgusting...🤮
Yeah that would have been "jenius"!!! 😅
Check new theory @benzproducts not carbon fiber
ruclips.net/video/ruHiSRL5fok/видео.html
They will be making a movie soon just like they made a movie of the titantic even thought it was a tragic event