We are announcing a NEW 75,000 Subscriber Lightsaber Giveaway, Sponsored by Artsabers: instagram.com/p/CrdsW99OsLw/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y= Instructions: Subscribe to PPSW on RUclips Follow @artsabers on Instagram: instagram.com/artsabers?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y= Share post on your personal story Like the Instagram post & tag 2 friends and you’ll be entered to win! (Comment multiple times by tagging 2 friends per comment to get extra entries for a better chance to win!)
If I had one criticism; the deaths of the Lars and Luke felt so forced and contrived, as if a hasty justification to write them out of the story. If you wanted Obi-Wan and Ahsoka to focus on just training Leia, you could've had Owen flat-out refuse them teaching Luke, full stop. Other than that, nice story.
Very much agreed, literally could've been as simple as Ashoka wanting to train Luke and convincing obi wan to push Owen causing him to flatly deny it to the overbearing nature of them and then they fuck off to join the rebels and eventually Luke and Leia do get trained
I know this is just a fanfiction. But I really love that no matter the time line or universe. Sidious may think his main rival and nuisance in his plans is Yoda, but in the end it's always something Obi-Wan does that screws him over the most. Which is especially funny when you remember how big Sidious' ego was and how losing to anyone but the Grandmaster of the Jedi is humiliating in his eyes... 😆
Well this is definitely gonna be an interesting and probably heartbreaking one, one id love to see one day is what if Sabine Wren became ruler of Mandalore in Star Wars Rebels instead of Bo-Katan?
I've some ideas for What If: - What if Palpatine wasn't elected the chancellor of the Republic in Phantom Menace? - What if Anakin's bombing run managed to kill Grievous on Malevolence - What if it was Saw and not Steela who died on Onderon? - What if Anakin killed Dooku in their duel during the Rako Hardeen arc? - What if Tarkin died in the Citadel meaning there would be no Tarkin Doctrine for the Empire? - What if Qi'ra joined the Galactic Empire with Han perhaps becoming an ISB agent? - What if Han killed Darth Vader during the battle of Yavin? - What if the Ashmead's Lock's prisoners succeeded in assassinating Mon Mothma meaning that Leia would become chancellor and the New Republic wouldn't demilitarize?
great short story I loved how the Kyber crystals imploded to blow up the death star taking Palpatine, Vader and Obi-Wan with them. Sad Luke had to die so young. Well done.
In light of all the survivors of Order 66 introduced by Disney, What if the entire Jedi Order survived and were just hiding from the Empire? Only the Jedi we visually see die are dead.
Well... that escalated... I guess we can say you hate moisture farmers too. What if Steela Gerrera survived? What if Hondo discovered Ezra before the ghost crew? (Pirate Jedi!) What if Tarkin Destroyed Lothal instead of Alderaan? What if Satine Kryze was a sith lord? What if Haji fired on the escape pod? (First off, Bolvan would have to do some paper work and then be told later it wasn't necessary anymore as the imperial senate was no longer a factor.) What if Obi-Wan used force heal on Padme? What if Captian Tarkin died at the citadel? What if Asajj Ventress and the Nightsisters successfully assassinated Dooku? What if Anakin was born a women? Kendall Skywalker. What if Anakin died to torture? (I don't know what you mean. -Dooku)
I would be very interested in your take on this scenario. The Empire allows a shipment of tainted food to be captured by the Alliance. This food makes it to Yavin IV. The lucky pilots end up sick, and the unlucky ones die.
I great idea for a star wars show would be a person who is a fake jedi but has the lightsaber, halocran, ect, and secretly he has the force but it takes something big and emotional to unlock it, also make it so he used the lightsaber with an invisible string making it seem like he used the force.
What if the pre-Phantom Menace Jedi, the Galactic Republic, or even the Galactic Empire, discovered Earth and established First Contact with the inhabitants on May 25, 1977, the exact same day that Star Wars: Episode 4: A New Hope premiered in our real world?
What if Ahsoka trained Ezra? What if Rex went with Ezra to Tattoonie? What if Kanan Jarrus went with Ezra to Tattoonie? What if Quinlan Vos trained Luke? What if Rex raised Luke? What if Anakin's force ghost trained Rey?
I believe this actually happened. My theory is that when Ahsoka went back to her timeline she filled Obiwan in and told him that Ezra and Maul would come to Tatooine
Yes, this was a fun video. I did enjoy it. Thank you for a fun little video, my friend. This video has me wondering what would have happened if Wilhuff Tarkin had died during the Clone War? Would the Empire have a Tarkin doctrine equivalent without him around? Would Thrawn be able to become the Grand Moff?
I’ve also been thinking about which planet makes more sense to have been the first planet any real Jedi/force users were on. Ouch-too with a darkside cave. Or Lothal with a powerful Jedi temple. With the planet having teleportation portals and doorways to a time travel destination
What if Obi-Wan took the Skywalker twins to raise them on Mandalore? What if Han Solo used blades alongside his blaster? What if Han had enough Force sensitivity to be self-taught in jumping higher, running faster, and reacting quicker in situations? What if Admiral Piett was a Rebel spy and filled the bridge crew of the Executor with people loyal to him and turned the Executor to attack the Imperial fleet at the Battle of Endor? What if the Ghost crew helped at the Battle of Yavin? What if Obi-Wan also trained to fight without weapons and by drawing the Force into his punches and kicks, allowing him to reflect blaster bolts and lightsaber blades away from him? What if Rex taught Luke and Leia how to fight like soldiers? What if there was a batch of clones that were all female? What if Chewie was a Jedi? What if the first Death Star had more weaknesses found in the plans? What if Obi-Wan and Satine, during their time as teenagers, somehow crashed onto Earth and got involved in the American Civil War on the side of the Union, with Obi-Wan joining the military and Satine helping as a nurse? (If you like any of these ideas, please let me know which and also be polite with your comments, please.)
I have a what if. What if Cal Kestus trained Luke and Luke Met Kata since they are both around the same age. Maybe Kata is a tad younger, but shes still better than Luke because she trained with Cal longer. BTDubbs, Im obviously talking about some romance between Luke and Kata.
Palpatine and Vader sees obi wan throw a Gaint crystal coming at them at the same time Vader swings his lightsaber and palpatines lighting meeting meet the Crystal realization to both sith: oh no 😶
yeah it definitely is going to be a interesting one 😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃 lol and can we all just appreciate the hard work and all the time he puts into his videos for us and he doesn’t even have to but he still does it
Star wars what ifs ideas What if obi wan got an new Padawan during the clone wars What if Anakin meet the wills of the force with Yoda What if the brother killed Anakin and the sister saved him What if Ashoka saved Leia and r2 and c3p0 where sent to her during new hope
I think it would be better if Vader took advantage of Sidious being distracted by Obi-Wan and killed Sidious. Obi-Wan and Vader would then fight to their deaths, which could happen as you put it, and thus the Emperor is dead, slain by Vader, and Vader destroyed the Death Star, Vader and Obi-Wan. Vader brought balance to the Force and destroys the Sith!
What if instead of tricking the galaxy by saying the Jedi were traitors Palpatine revealed himself as a sith and theatened everyone with force Lightning to vote him emperor
What if Anakin fell in love with Bo katan. Also what if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda ❤
What If The New Jedi Orden Trained Galen Marek? What If The Gray Paladins Trained Galen Marek? What If The Matukai Trained Galen Marek? What If Mind Walkers Trained Galen Marek? What If The Jal Shey Trained Galen Marek? What If The Baran Do Trained Galen Marek? What If The Zeison Sha Trained Galen Marek? What If The Potentium Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Dagoyan Masters Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Aing-Tii Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Warrior Of The Force Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Gray Jedi Orden Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Je'daii Order Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Jensaarai Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Gods Of The Mortis Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Force Priestesses Trained Ferus Olin? What If Bendu Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Scions Of Zakuul Trained Ferus Olin? What If The Witches Of Dathomir Trained Ferus Olin?
I got one, what if.... Pad may was a hand maiden and didn't like the fact she was being used as a decoy and felt like a slave herself, I think it would make a good twist when she supports AS to do what it takes to save her life!
We are announcing a NEW 75,000 Subscriber Lightsaber Giveaway, Sponsored by Artsabers: instagram.com/p/CrdsW99OsLw/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
Instructions:
Subscribe to PPSW on RUclips
Follow @artsabers on Instagram: instagram.com/artsabers?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
Share post on your personal story
Like the Instagram post & tag 2 friends and you’ll be entered to win! (Comment multiple times by tagging 2 friends per comment to get extra entries for a better chance to win!)
Meh, prefer Earth in Star Wars but Earth is either 20th or 21st century in another AU.
Here's one for you: What if Obi-Wan and Yoda went to mustafar to fight/save Anikan, and then all 3 of them go back to kill Papa Palpatine
Didn’t they forget what happened on Mortis?
@@starwarslegacy8383---Weren't Ezra and Sabine in a relationship near the end of the Rebels series?
@@pyeitme508---That would be interesting. Maybe PP will do that if his current Earth in Star Wars series is very successful.
What if Ahsoka had an actual lawyer during her trial in season 5
Saul Goodman
@@easternestal4181 I would try to use a quote from Breaking Bad or Better Call Saul but I don't think I can do it justice.
Tow mater
Better call Saul for this
Phoenix Wright
If I had one criticism; the deaths of the Lars and Luke felt so forced and contrived, as if a hasty justification to write them out of the story. If you wanted Obi-Wan and Ahsoka to focus on just training Leia, you could've had Owen flat-out refuse them teaching Luke, full stop.
Other than that, nice story.
Agreed.
Also they don’t remember Mortis so that’s another thing that bugs me
I'm glad that I read your comment. You saved me 19 minutes.
Very much agreed, literally could've been as simple as Ashoka wanting to train Luke and convincing obi wan to push Owen causing him to flatly deny it to the overbearing nature of them and then they fuck off to join the rebels and eventually Luke and Leia do get trained
I know this is just a fanfiction. But I really love that no matter the time line or universe. Sidious may think his main rival and nuisance in his plans is Yoda, but in the end it's always something Obi-Wan does that screws him over the most. Which is especially funny when you remember how big Sidious' ego was and how losing to anyone but the Grandmaster of the Jedi is humiliating in his eyes... 😆
Obi wan: master of trolling for a reason
I always love when Obi Wan carries the video and takes a W
Well this is definitely gonna be an interesting and probably heartbreaking one, one id love to see one day is what if Sabine Wren became ruler of Mandalore in Star Wars Rebels instead of Bo-Katan?
I'd love to see Sabine rule Mandalore
I've some ideas for What If:
- What if Palpatine wasn't elected the chancellor of the Republic in Phantom Menace?
- What if Anakin's bombing run managed to kill Grievous on Malevolence
- What if it was Saw and not Steela who died on Onderon?
- What if Anakin killed Dooku in their duel during the Rako Hardeen arc?
- What if Tarkin died in the Citadel meaning there would be no Tarkin Doctrine for the Empire?
- What if Qi'ra joined the Galactic Empire with Han perhaps becoming an ISB agent?
- What if Han killed Darth Vader during the battle of Yavin?
- What if the Ashmead's Lock's prisoners succeeded in assassinating Mon Mothma meaning that Leia would become chancellor and the New Republic wouldn't demilitarize?
great short story I loved how the Kyber crystals imploded to blow up the death star taking Palpatine, Vader and Obi-Wan with them. Sad Luke had to die so young. Well done.
What if Rex’s rebellion expanded to a much larger scale
What if Sidious was abruptly separated from the Force during the Clone War?
So like he just becomes unforce sensitive?
@@Edgar_Hoods Basically. He'd have the tactical insight, but lack the raw power of a threat.
Luke can’t catch a break in these What ifs.
What if Ahsoka was a force sensitive bounty hunter?
As fast as “metal” and “old” could go 😂😂😂
Love how you were able to sum up everything that happened with Saw as 'It didn't work' XD
In light of all the survivors of Order 66 introduced by Disney, What if the entire Jedi Order survived and were just hiding from the Empire? Only the Jedi we visually see die are dead.
I can't put my finger on it but of all your What If stories i like this one the best.
You always have the most interesting stories. I wouldn't mind to see you branch out in terms of content but dont stop doing these
What if Ahsoka somehow came to Dagobah and found Yoda there?
Obi-Wan killing three issues with one Kyber crystal was kinda hilarious
What if Anakin was raised by Sith Purebloods and became the Outlander?
Thanks for making Obi-Wan Kenobi season 2
What if the Jedi council and the Jedi in the temple became aware of order 66 a few hours before it began.
Well... that escalated... I guess we can say you hate moisture farmers too.
What if Steela Gerrera survived?
What if Hondo discovered Ezra before the ghost crew? (Pirate Jedi!)
What if Tarkin Destroyed Lothal instead of Alderaan?
What if Satine Kryze was a sith lord?
What if Haji fired on the escape pod? (First off, Bolvan would have to do some paper work and then be told later it wasn't necessary anymore as the imperial senate was no longer a factor.)
What if Obi-Wan used force heal on Padme?
What if Captian Tarkin died at the citadel?
What if Asajj Ventress and the Nightsisters successfully assassinated Dooku?
What if Anakin was born a women? Kendall Skywalker.
What if Anakin died to torture? (I don't know what you mean. -Dooku)
What if Qui Gon was Anakins Father?
What if padme became Darth Vader
YESSS SOO COOL ALL WAY WANT THAT IT IS better then her dad
What if the Jedi council didn’t give up Ashoka
I really liked the twist and turns of this what if.
What if Ahsoka kept her Lightsabers when she left the Order?
Well done man. Well done.
Loved it!
Very short but definitely a sweet one! 😂
What the f is my algorithm doing? I was literally just THINKING about this while taking a sh*t. I open YT and this is one of the first vids I see.
What if Darth Bane never created the Rule of Two?
Yeah such a a bummer I wished he did reunited with Obi-Wan in Tatooine :(
I would be very interested in your take on this scenario. The Empire allows a shipment of tainted food to be captured by the Alliance. This food makes it to Yavin IV. The lucky pilots end up sick, and the unlucky ones die.
I great idea for a star wars show would be a person who is a fake jedi but has the lightsaber, halocran, ect, and secretly he has the force but it takes something big and emotional to unlock it, also make it so he used the lightsaber with an invisible string making it seem like he used the force.
Calm him down, help him make friends...it didn't work.🤣🤣🤣
palpatine- enough vader let me show you how it's done
vader- at least when i do it i don't give the jedi a opening to suicide bomb us
What if Luke was actually at crait
Nicely done!
This was a great video, good job.
best of what ifs
Pretty sure Ahsoka was working for Bail and Phoenix Cell as early as a year after ep-3.
Great story certainly enjoyed this one :)
I got one you could do.
What if Satine didn't die and her and Obi-Wan raised Luke.
OK I got 2 video ideas.
1st: What if Sidious and Talzin had a child after Maul was taken?
2nd: What if Padme lived but believed Anakin was dead l?
What if the pre-Phantom Menace Jedi, the Galactic Republic, or even the Galactic Empire, discovered Earth and established First Contact with the inhabitants on May 25, 1977, the exact same day that Star Wars: Episode 4: A New Hope premiered in our real world?
You should do a part two tmr
Damn fucking damn you killed Luke holly shit
What if Captain Rex found Obi-Wan?
What if anakin had a much higher midichlorian count
So that's the face behind the voice... 😆😆
what an awesome move to throw the kyber crystal to kill vader and the emperor
What if Ahsoka trained Ezra?
What if Rex went with Ezra to Tattoonie?
What if Kanan Jarrus went with Ezra to Tattoonie?
What if Quinlan Vos trained Luke?
What if Rex raised Luke?
What if Anakin's force ghost trained Rey?
I believe this actually happened. My theory is that when Ahsoka went back to her timeline she filled Obiwan in and told him that Ezra and Maul would come to Tatooine
Yes, this was a fun video. I did enjoy it. Thank you for a fun little video, my friend. This video has me wondering what would have happened if Wilhuff Tarkin had died during the Clone War? Would the Empire have a Tarkin doctrine equivalent without him around? Would Thrawn be able to become the Grand Moff?
Could you do a video of if kannan and Ezra managed to save Luminara Unduli after order 66.
I’ve also been thinking about which planet makes more sense to have been the first planet any real Jedi/force users were on. Ouch-too with a darkside cave. Or Lothal with a powerful Jedi temple. With the planet having teleportation portals and doorways to a time travel destination
U MUST CONTINUE!!!!
What if rex and the bad batch stole the venator in the bad season 2
You killed off Luke? Oh well still a better fate than what Disney gave him 🤣
What if Anakin had a m count of 100.000
What if the Night Sisters defeated General Grievous during the clone wars
This would give Mother Talzin enough time to Kill Count Dooku
What if Obi-Wan took the Skywalker twins to raise them on Mandalore?
What if Han Solo used blades alongside his blaster?
What if Han had enough Force sensitivity to be self-taught in jumping higher, running faster, and reacting quicker in situations?
What if Admiral Piett was a Rebel spy and filled the bridge crew of the Executor with people loyal to him and turned the Executor to attack the Imperial fleet at the Battle of Endor?
What if the Ghost crew helped at the Battle of Yavin?
What if Obi-Wan also trained to fight without weapons and by drawing the Force into his punches and kicks, allowing him to reflect blaster bolts and lightsaber blades away from him?
What if Rex taught Luke and Leia how to fight like soldiers?
What if there was a batch of clones that were all female?
What if Chewie was a Jedi?
What if the first Death Star had more weaknesses found in the plans?
What if Obi-Wan and Satine, during their time as teenagers, somehow crashed onto Earth and got involved in the American Civil War on the side of the Union, with Obi-Wan joining the military and Satine helping as a nurse?
(If you like any of these ideas, please let me know which and also be polite with your comments, please.)
What if the Jedi were allowed to use their emotions.
What if the Grand Inquisitor trained Ezra
What if Ahsoka became a bounty hunter after leaving the order.
What if Ahsoka had a child.
what is the music at 8:16 and 10:06?
When is the next part of Earth season 2 and what can we expect from it
I have a what if. What if Cal Kestus trained Luke and Luke Met Kata since they are both around the same age. Maybe Kata is a tad younger, but shes still better than Luke because she trained with Cal longer. BTDubbs, Im obviously talking about some romance between Luke and Kata.
It was all great except for killing off Luke 😔
grandmaster Asoka Tano ftw
Damn you for killing off Luke so cheaply bruh. Lol 😅
What if Padawans were trained away from the Clone War?
Palpatine and Vader sees obi wan throw a Gaint crystal coming at them at the same time Vader swings his lightsaber and palpatines lighting meeting meet the Crystal realization to both sith: oh no 😶
What if Ezra used the world between worlds too try to save the Jedi order
yeah it definitely is going to be a interesting one 😃😃😃😃😃😃😃😃 lol and can we all just appreciate the hard work and all the time he puts into his videos for us and he doesn’t even have to but he still does it
What if the Vong invaded during the clone wars
What if Leia was given to Beru & Owen and Luke was given to the Organa?
I want to see a story about maul and Dooku teaming up but it doesn’t work out after maul makes fun of qui gon
16:04 is that david jason in the back
only thing I dislike is the death of luke but I understand why u did it but beautiful story
Star wars what ifs ideas
What if obi wan got an new Padawan during the clone wars
What if Anakin meet the wills of the force with Yoda
What if the brother killed Anakin and the sister saved him
What if Ashoka saved Leia and r2 and c3p0 where sent to her during new hope
I think it would be better if Vader took advantage of Sidious being distracted by Obi-Wan and killed Sidious. Obi-Wan and Vader would then fight to their deaths, which could happen as you put it, and thus the Emperor is dead, slain by Vader, and Vader destroyed the Death Star, Vader and Obi-Wan. Vader brought balance to the Force and destroys the Sith!
Poor Luke.
What if instead of tricking the galaxy by saying the Jedi were traitors Palpatine revealed himself as a sith and theatened everyone with force Lightning to vote him emperor
What if Trilla, Cal and Cere killed Darth Vader
What if luke was never found on hoth?
What if Luke and Leia weren't Anakins.
( An affair )
What if ahsoka found cal kestis
What if Anakin and Ahsoka were the same age and/or siblings?
What if Anakin fell in love with Bo katan. Also what if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda ❤
What if anakin was declined training by the Jedi order and following that obi wan left the order and took anakin to train him on mandalore
What if anakin lost the pod race ?
poor luke
What If The New Jedi Orden Trained Galen Marek?
What If The Gray Paladins Trained Galen Marek?
What If The Matukai Trained Galen Marek?
What If Mind Walkers Trained Galen Marek?
What If The Jal Shey Trained Galen Marek?
What If The Baran Do Trained Galen Marek?
What If The Zeison Sha Trained Galen Marek?
What If The Potentium Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Dagoyan Masters Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Aing-Tii Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Warrior Of The Force Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Gray Jedi Orden Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Je'daii Order Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Jensaarai Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Gods Of The Mortis Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Force Priestesses Trained Ferus Olin?
What If Bendu Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Scions Of Zakuul Trained Ferus Olin?
What If The Witches Of Dathomir Trained Ferus Olin?
Luke getting killed off for no reason and so fast really felt unnecessary everything else was good tho
I got one, what if.... Pad may was a hand maiden and didn't like the fact she was being used as a decoy and felt like a slave herself, I think it would make a good twist when she supports AS to do what it takes to save her life!
Yooo face reveal your actually really attractive
U