Why Prophet Muhammad Did NOT Write Any Hadith or Explain Quran?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- 🔥 Why Did Prophet Muhammad did not write Hadith?
Or Any other text/booklet/guide during his lifetime?
The above question is explored in the eyes of Quran in this lecture.
Also see:
• WHY Does Quran Tell Th...
• Did Prophet Muhammad P...
#hadith #realhadith #quranonly
#hadith #hadithinislam #quranite #quranonlymuslim
I’ve been doing my own research recently, perhaps due to my frequent Qur’ān recital esp surah Maryam to my 4 year old daughter every night since I was pregnant with her Allâh illuminated something inside me and nudged into this direction of finding the truth in the light of Quran. It’s only for the past several months I had this suspicion. By the way, may I know how did you figure which selected Quranic words that were modified in their meanings? How did you know it was salaah, masjid etc? I gained clarity after watching this video yesterday and then today I discovered Dua (dal wau ain the root word in an old Usmani script and I believe an earlier translation of Yusuf Ali) also means prayer so it’s unlikely salaah (sod lam ha) has the same meaning thus the derivatives of the root word also indisputably had been altered. Back to my question, how did you figure which words that were changed ?
Great observation and question! The words in Arabic language start with 'root' associated with it. In fact, all languages have root words since that is how we make words, and then form sentences. With that said, words in Arabic language may have various meanings/synonyms, so as far as Quranic text is concerned, the particular word in the Quran such as 'Salat' the root ṣād lām wāw occurs 83 times (corpus.quran.com/search.jsp?q=lem%3ASalaw%60p+pos%3An. So now, since The Quran is a complete book without any inconsistencies, my research entails looking at all 83 instances of the word Salat in the Quran, and not just the word but all verses in context. To adhere to Quran's claim being a consistent book, there can only be a consistent meaning to the word 'Salat', and that meaning is 'performing your duty', i.e, following Almighty's laws and commandments in the Quran. This meaning of the word Salat fits perfectly in all 83 instances. So prayer could also be considered as duty towards God, and essentially denotes the duty to both seek help and serve God (Surah Al-Fatihah Chapter 1: Verses 1 - 7 is the contract between man and God.) Hope this helps! I will make a detailed video on Salat soon as it is on my agenda. Thanks. Wsalaam.
@Bassam Thank you!
@@QuranAlone Salaam! Your explanation sounds like the reasoning offered by Sam Gerrans. After some more research, there are still a few inconsistencies in that reasoning in terms of physical instructions of wudu, times of day, etc. What are your thoughts on that? (Those verses do not talk about dua as prayer, and I would also contend that while dua means prayer, there is still a difference between praising God and seeking something from him).
@@enaf4843 Dua can be understood as the solution to a problem. 'Praying' to Allah in times of need is useless as He states in the Qur'an that He does not change a people until they change them self. In other words, once you have solved all your conflicts internally and externally, then the natural good results will manifest and you will be better for it. The Dua is the looking at a problem and using the Allah given laws and means to resolve them.
Salamun mem.
The way forward is slow and steady. May i suggest marvelous quran an moses phd student yt channels. I found they are truthful to the quran.
Slow and steady mem.
More than 20 years ago , I had a dream in which God told me to tell people to read Quran and that's how I got interested in this book and I swear Quran is complete and in detail and your presentation is excellent...praise to God who gives us guidance
Lol Without hadith you won't understand Quran.
@@maryammuslimah7660 He said that the "Quran is complete" and you took issue with that statement. But Allah (s.w.t.) says multiple times in the Qur'an that it is COMPLETE, so please don't be ignorant and go against the word of Allah (s.w.t.). If you need Hadith to understand it, fine your thing, but don't generalize it. Plus the Prophet (s.a.v.) and the Qur'an are very clear about Hadith:
[Quran 7:185] Have they not looked at the dominion of the heavens and the earth, and all the things Allah has created? Does it ever occur to them that the end of their life may be near? Which hadith (sayings, preachings, announcements, classical ahadith, etc.), besides this (Quran) do they believe in?
[Quran 31:6] Among the people, there are those who uphold baseless hadith, and thus divert others from the path of Allah without knowledge, and take it in vain. These have incurred a shameful retribution.
[Quran 45:6] These are Allah's revelations (Quran) that we recite to you truthfully. In which hadith other than Allah and His revelations do they believe?
[Quran 77:50] Which hadith other than this do they uphold?
[Quran 50:45] .........remind with this Quran (Not Hadith) , those who reverence My warnings.
1. Ibn Saeed Al-Khudry reported that the messenger of God had said:
"Do not write anything from me EXCEPT QURAN. Anyone who wrote anything other than the Quran shall erase it."
2. From Ibn Hanbal:
Zayd Ibn Thabit (The Prophet's closest revelation writer) visited the Khalifa Mu'aawiyah (more than 30 years after the Prophet's death), and told him a story about the Prophet. Mu'aawiyah liked the story and ordered someone to write it down. But Zayd said. " the messenger of God ordered us NEVER to write anything of his hadith."
3. The famous book, "Ulum Al-Hadith" by Ibn Al-Salah, reports a hadith by Abu Hurayra in which Abu Hurayra said the messenger of God came out to us while we were writing his hadiths and said; "What are you writing?" We said, "Hadiths that we hear from you, messenger of God." He said, "A book other than the book of God ?!" We said, "Should we talk about you?" He said, Talk about me, that would be fine, but those who will lie will go to Hell. Abu Hurayra said, we collected what we wrote of Hadiths and burned them in fire.
Wishing you and your loved ones Peace and the mercy of Allah (s.w.t.)
@@mertmeh MashAllah..so much clearly prophet (s) forbidden the writing of hadith but yet we did it. just like other religious people who follow the words of people rather than the word of Allah. May Allah guide us.
@@DiscoverHealth Amin! My opinion has actually changed a little bit after having studied the Qur'an and Ahadith for montths now. The Prophet (s.a.v.) supposedly forbid the writing down of some of his sayings, so that it won't be confused with the Qur'an, but supposedly said in other Ahadith, to write some sayings down. The Qur'an also tells us to follow what the Prophet (s.a.v.) forbids and allows, so I think that there's some truth to Ahadith. Unfortunately we can't revive and ask the Prophet (s.a.v.) whether he said what he said in these Ahadith and if they are complete, hence why I can't say that the Hadith are the complete Sunnah or the complete truth. I try to follow the Hadith that are not against the Qur'an though such as not to keep a dog inside, not to listen to music, sitting while drinking, etc. but I couldn't say that those are 100% sinful, because as I said, I can't confirm it by asking the Prophet (s.a.v.). But since there are sayings of those topics, there must be some sort of truth to them, hence why I stay away from them. May Allah (s.w.t.) help us in our faith and give us knowledge and guide us to the right path!
@@mertmeh you are right we shouldn't follow any hadith that goes against Quran but I am constantly asking Allah (SWT) to guide me and just half an hour ago as I was praying salah and was asking for guidance it came to my mind that Allah asked to obey the prophet and what you mentioned is about what Allah inspires like Allah inspires every one of us with right guidance so Allah also guided Muhammed (s) with right choices which are a vast thing and cant be compiled in Quran as it will be so big. so to me whatever prophet has forbidden is by Allah's inspiration rather than revelation. so prophets lifestyle is also important but we should not be extremist and we should learn from previous deluded followers of other prophets how they went astray and we should not seek anything other than Quran unless we are 100% sure about it like the prophet (s) taught us how to pray and there is no harm in writing this but except for some basic things we should not go in detail as Quran asked us not to take any book other than Quran itself. I ask Allah to forgive us and guide us to the truth.
Hadith supporters points to the ayats in Quran that say "Obey god and obey messenger" to prove their claim. But my question is, if that was so why didn't the prophet or the khalifa a Rashedin ever write the hadith down.
Even there is a narration that says Khalifa Omar beat up some one for trying to write a hadith.
Obviously, Omar thought and knew that Quran was enough and it was written. Case closed.
The Sahaba used to say "Hasbuna Khitab-Allah." Sufficient for us, is the Book of Allah. They knew that they needed nothing else as all else, is from Man and not Allah.
As for the verses that state " Obey Allah, obey the Messenger."
Note, the very exact, chosen word by Allah swt, Allah uses the word MESSENGER as opposed to Muhammed. There is a vast difference in meaning if the word Messenger is replaced by the word Muhammed!
Those who can grasp the difference in the inference of using the two different words will have understood something that millions of muslim fail to understand!
ruclips.net/video/Hezu7LieSfM/видео.html
I wish the case was closed, brother: unfortunately most of us today follow the man made religion built on hadits rather than the simple, natural and rational din Allah gave us through the Qur'an.
@@user-k229 yes exactly. And even if this verse implied anything else other than the Quran, it couldn’t refer to Hadith, since the Hadith isn’t even written or authorised by the prophet (it even says this in Hadith), so even that is unacceptable.
Prophet forbade the writing of Hadith or anything other than the Quran. Abubakar also made a speech at the death of the prophet prohibiting hi speeches. Omar similarly called the people to bring all Hadith from the prophet and were burnt.
The Quran is self explanatory and many verses are/were difficult to explain at the knowledge at the time
But without hadiths how would you know how to pray,when to pray,how often to pray,how to make zakat,how to make hagg?
@@muhammedaliaydin8977, peace!
Since Allah teaches us that the Quran is complete, it is logical to search inside of the quran for answers to questions.
For instance "salat": You will find specific times in the quran, but you won´t find any hint that "salat" means "ritual prayer". Therefore, you should try to grasp the real meaning of the word "salat".
The original semantic meanings of "salat" according to the Arabic lexicons are for example "following closely, keeping a firm hold on, commitment to what Allah orders to do, turning towards and bringing closer, raising the intellect to Allah".
Yes, you will also find the meaning "specific form of worship with times and rituals which are laid down and established in the sharia". But we have to take in consideration, that the sharia is not laid down in the Quran, rather it is established by human beings who are regarded as "ulama = scholars".
Peace!
@@muhammedaliaydin8977we know salah through fihq gamded down traditions! Did you learn salaht through reading hadith or was you shown in practice? Early madina I think maliki they clearly state they had Quran then sunnah through (fihq) and then they had hadith which was nothing more than historical records and not a law giver
Salamun dr.
I found u among those who are truthful to interpretation of the quran. There are concept, there are context, there are nested meaning, there are non arabic words among others.
I am a non arab and only a leaner and i view a lot of quran only channels.
In humbleness, may i highlight that there is a duty distinction between rasul/messenger and nabi/prophet.
May Allah guides whosoever seeks guidance. Sukran.
Brother you brought very important topic which I was asking myself for many years unfortunately your so important message and explanation have very bad audio quality recording just think how important this message is I wished and you may agree put on your headphone or in car the audio quality is like you are calling to someone and he is recording on his phone it would have been much better because this topic need very clear narration and good quality sound I hope you will correct me if I am wrong but i completely agree with you this how it all happened
Soon the world will know The Truth about Allaah ❤❤❤The Almiighty
Soon the world will know The Truth about Rassoelloellaah ❤❤❤
The Time is Near
That because he is both Rasool and Nabi. The distinction is Rasool is dictated by Messages (Verbatim) and Nabi is the one decipher the Quran and put it into practice.
As Rasool he is Perfect to convey the message, but as Nabi he is infallible, that's why Allah address him as Nabi, when he made mistakes. But when regarding the Quran, Allah address him as Rasool.
Assalamu alaikum so how do you pray according to the Quran alone
You cannot LMAO
As well as you wouldn't know how to perform Wudu Hajj Umrah Nikah Divorce Inheritance etc
@@deesouthska8716 hadits (hadeeth) . Nb : malay family language use ث as 'ts' and 'th' .
First, hadits in the shahabat and tabi'in time, were used to help muslim people to do ibadah, amal , and any of what we call syariah (shareea) today, and to make it easy to do. But today , we use the hadits to make syariah difficult.
As we know. Beard is absolutely just sunnah, but now, muslim man who doesnt appear his beard, will be judged as if he isnt muslim. It happens in indonesia.
Second, as we know, the takfiri qoum( قَوْمٌ تَكفير ) more prioritise hadits than quran.
Example, they use hadits bid'ah ( بِدعة ) for judging others muslim. But we know in al Hujurat : 11, that we are forbidden to mock another.
والله أعلم
🙂
@@surgamudah don't lie.. i'm a muslim from indonesia and i sHave my Beard.. no one ever Judge me as non muslim..
@@nu-n9922 first, what for did i lie. second, so i can assume you are aswaja. you seldom to watch video from the people who always claim that sunnah is what they do, and attend in their "pengajian". and third, of course you will not be judged. because aswaja is majority in indonesia 🙂, as long as we together with aswaja people.
@@surgamudah i never go to pengajian, nor revere any ustadh.. i don't care what they teach, if they don't go against The Qur'an and Sahih hadith, then i have no quaLms..
And most muslim in indonesia are following the Syafi'i school of thought, while i follow all the 4 madhabs and others.. as long as the Sunnah is easy, suit me, and have stRong basis from sahih hadith, then i will follow it..
But never once any of them call me a non muslim because i didn't grow my Beard.. did you even understand what a Sunnah is?
Was prophet literate or illiterate?
Pl.point out verses which say that prophet was able to write and read.
The Qur'an say he was a Messenger to an ummi nation, so this cannot mean an illiterate one, as well as the verse says woe to the ummi who write words in their own hands and say they are from Allah. You cannot be illiterate and write at the same time! Proper understanding:
62:2 He it is Who has sent a Messenger among those who had never before received a Scripture - to convey unto them His messages, to make them grow in humanity, to instruct them in the Scripture and wisdom, Judgment and establishment of God's Rule on earth - whereas before that they were obviously lost in error, [Ummi = Gentile = Non-Israelite = Unlettered = A nation (the Arabs) that had never received a Scripture before. Zaku, Tazkiah = Growth = Purity from vice = Development of the 'self' = Self-actualization. Hikmah = wisdom = Judgment = Governance = Political Rule]
You need proof to deduct a quality or trait from someone, not the other way round, the burden is upon you to prove he was illiterate. You say he’s illiterate only on your ignorance on the Arabic language.
Brother prophet MUHAMAD wrote the best HADITH' HASSINAL HADITH the QURAN. This SURAH 29-48 You did not recite before it any book nor did you write with your right hand otherwise the falsifier's would have doubted. Meaning the prophet did not recite a book before QURAN nor did he write a book before QURAN. These verses also support my claim 25-4 to 25-6 were people are accusing him of writing ' also 96-1 , 96-3 , 96-4 were ALLAH tells him to read and ALLAH taught him by the pen.
Salamun alailum, what r d reasons why d prophet did not write his sunnah & hadith? What i heard some of his sahabas wrote down collections of his ahadith & sunnah, where r they now? Pls i want ur reply soon so that i wont be having any doubts. God bless u & grant u more rewards for ur efforts. More power & maasalam.
May allah give u hidayah..ameen
To me as well.
@@elprofesor8571 yes he gave me hidayah now i reject those radical sects like sunni,shia,sufi,jamati,etc and lies about prophet like hadeeths and sunnah which has nothing to do with islam :-
www.quran-islam.org/main_topics/fully_detailed_scripture_(P1210).html
www.quran-islam.org/main_topics/islam/pillars/al-salat_(P1192).html
www.quran-islam.org/main_topics/islam/pillars/al-zakat_(P1193).html
www.quran-islam.org/main_topics/islam/pillars/al-seyaam_(P1194).html
www.quran-islam.org/main_topics/al-hajj_(P1195).html
www.quran-islam.org/main_topics/al-shahada_(P1191).html
www.quran-islam.org/main_topics/misinterpreted_verses_(P1224).html
www.quran-islam.org/articles/part_1/history_hadith_1_(P1148).html
www.quran-islam.org/articles/part_1/history_hadith_2_(P1308).html
Did allah or Muhammad command in the Qur'an for the Qur'an recitation to be in written form?
If the Qur'an is the only recitation of allah, then the Hadiths tafsirs etc is the word of who to who?
Can the Qur'an be the only source of reference for muslims in Islam?
Like the Torah and prophets for the Jews and the Bible for Christians?
If the Qur'an is clear enough to understand then what is the purpose of the tafsirs, as the tafsirs is to one way of understanding the Qur'an, so are there other ways of understanding the Qur'an?
If so, how many acceptable ways are there?
If allah gave the Torah and the Gospels and the prophets, then why didn't those have a equivalent of Hadiths tafsirs etc in Hebrew?
Were there Hebrew equivalents of Hadiths tafsirs etc for the Torah and Gospels, if so what were they called?
If so, Who wrote them?
Voice is not clear,
How do you guys know the context of the Quran without hadith.
Allah told us to follow the prophet. How do you follow him swm, without hadith.
No, Allah says obey Allah and obey messenger (Rasool) not obey prophet (Nabi).
@@__Amira__ same thing. He is a prophet and rasool. My point stands. Thanks for the technical correction.
@@__Amira__ muhammad (saw) is literally have the Title of Rasulullah, just like how isa (as) have the Title of Al-Masih.. and you say he (saw) is not a Rasulullah? 🤦
Muhammad passed on the Quran to us. You obey him by obeying the Quran. Obeying the Quran is also obeying Allah. Thus, it all leads back to the Quran.
@@EessaTube exactly
Such important message and your audio is bad not clear
He is OK! Please turn on subtitles CC on your screen right on the top.
He tries to deliver the message from God and this is good!
This is a message of ignorant people. It's not even close important.
عمدہ خیالات ہیں 👍🏽
Salamun alaikum, S d noun & verb u r talking here relevant to ur topic why d prophet did not write down his ahadith & sunnah? I think i'm stupid enough to understand ur explanation, all i thought u r going to give reasons as to why prophet did not write down his sunnah, bt instead u r differentiating uses of noun & verbs. More power, maassalam
Salam Alaikum,
I am really in two minds about hadiths.
I understand the hadith-followers, who say that"without the hadiths you wouldn't know how pray,when to pray,how often to pray,how to make zakat,how to fast,how to make hagg.
On the other hand,I also agree with some points of the so called"quranists " or "Quran only followers" who say that all the hadiths can't be trusted since it came 2 centuries after the Prophet's (PBUH) death.
And at the time where Buchari collected his hadiths there was not a single sahaba alive who could've confirmed the hadiths as authentic.
I am following hadiths, but I try to follow hadiths which don't contradict the Quran or adds something to the Quran (The Dajjal is one example)
Salam Alaikum,brothers and sisters.
The Hadith followers arguments turns into dust once you understand that there are not ritual worships mentioned in the Quran. Five times prayers, Hajj etc are all human made and should be abandoned once and for all.
Its really dangerous what you are doing. Picking up the valid Hadiths it seems. But how do you know your choosing the correct ones? Isn’t it like trying to pick the good grains from a dish full of rotten foods?
ruclips.net/video/04Hc5ihwa_A/видео.html
@@AKMMahfuzulIslam ruclips.net/video/04Hc5ihwa_A/видео.html
To follow vain desires is a form of id ol🙏
Hadith are memorised. They dont need to be written down on paper to verify them.
For verification you need to do other things like know the chain etc.
I used to teach Psychology, including Forensic Psychology and the issue of memory and witness statements. I also taught Criminology and covered some of those same areas. The evidence from decades of extensive research is that episodic memory [i.e. memory for events, things that have happened or things people have said] is flawed, malleable and requires the brain to fill in gaps in that memory with what it thinks should go into the gaps. Since the hadith are people's memories of events and sayings, passed on by word of mouth, from one person to another, over 100 years before being written down, they will, undoubtedly, be flawed.
Memorisation of the Quran, on the other hand, is a different type of memory. It is learned by rote, a procedural skill, requiring procedural memory, which is very different from episodic memory. The authenticity and accuracy of the Quran was also easy to check from the beginning of its revelation to now, because so many people had learned it, cover to cover, word-for-word. That has never been the case for the hadith.
@Isa Darby your wrong. Hadith have also been Memorized. Not only the hadith but also the chain.
Yes some hadith are unreliable. That's why we have a whole science on hadith. We have authentic and weak hadith and those in between, based on this science.
For a hadith to be authentic it has to go through a process such as is the person reliable. Who else heard it. Does it fit in with everything else the prophet said. Etc etc.
The hadith and the Quran compliment each other. Can't understand the context of the Quran without hadith.
@@SajidAli-pn5ut I've looked at the so-called 'science' of hadith. It is not a science at all. It fits none of the requirements for something to be called a science. It is thoroughly flawed.
@@EessaTube in your opinion. And your opinion does not matter.
@@SajidAli-pn5ut It isn't opinion. I'm basing what I'm saying on verifiable scientific research into memory.
What you've offered so far is worse than opinion. You have openly misquoted the Quran and made claims about the Quran and Allah that are false.
Think about it carefully before you claim the Quran says this or that.