"Clutching At Straws" is one of my favourite albums of all time. Fish's genius in investing the tiny details of everyday human life with epic grandeur is so evident here and the band's musicianship follows the contours of his lyrics so perfectly. Steve H gets all of that and delivers. (PS Every time I drive through Bilston Glen I find myself singing "Waiting for the whistle to blow".
God just hearing this, despite H’s vocals struggles in spots, reminds you of just HOW FUCKING GOOD this material was, is, and always shall be - Clutching at Straws - the greatest album ever made.
I think H's yelps are intentional - he can't do a scream like Fish could so he just kind of yelps it. He absolutely kills it other than those couple blips. I love both H and Fish but H has taken way better care of his voice and still sounds fantastic. Listening to Fish sing this from recent years is just tragic.
I absolutely adore this. Incredible musicianship on display here. H pays tribute to the brilliant lyrics and puts his own spin on it. Then... there is the audience who are in fine voice. There is nothing to dislike about this musical masterpiece reborn.
the rhythm section of Marillion would be a cliche to say the heartbeat but I'll say it anyway! Ian and Pete could have gone anywhere and still be amazing but they stuck to their guns and remain amazing in this great band. Both are criminally underrated!
Ian and Pete definitely make Marillion Marillion. They really fit together. Both of them are unusually creative players. I was told a couple decades ago that Pete Trewavas is more a guitarist than a bassist but for me that's ok He reminds me of the late Chris Squire and that really means quality. God Bless these guys and the whole band & the fankind!
Remember when I started listening to this band 35 years ago or so and my friends thought I was nuts. Now regard as of whether it's fish is banned or Hogarth's band they think it's fantastic. Rothery is a badd a** I'll say it again and again and again. One of the most underrated guitarists of all time
I love this album. My only wish would be that as next year is the 30th year anniversary Marillion would re record it with Steve H as he dose this amazing and with such passion. I would love a full studio re mastered album.
really, you like that singer singing this?, he is pathetic and destroys the song....., he hate to sing fish material.., you can see it..., he is good only at his u2 staff....
What an incredible sound, nothing like the sound of Steve R's guitar work & Steve H's incredible voice!!!! But, no matter how well Steve H sings the old stuff, nobody can ever match Fish! He's the original & by far the best👌👏
I love the old Marillion/Fish album, but so much I love the Fish'voice back, hwe no longer can sing the old stuff with the same emotion that Hogart acheive by himself.
Fish was singing those lyrics from the heart. They meant something to him. There are references throughout his work that are obviously from his own youth. When H sings them, it's just singing an old song he didn't write. He often seems a bit begrudged that he still has to do it.
Have to respectably disagree. The problem is he tries to sing them as songs. Fish's lyrics are really musical poetry, not song lyrics. It's why it sounds more awkward.
@@AliTaylor777 I like h's take, but I do think you're onto something there. I feel h focuses much more strongly on melody, whereas Fish's best performances are akin to sprechgesang and/or recitativo in opera.
Amazing musicianship. It is a shame that Mosely gets largely ignored in this masterpiece. Rothery, Tewaras, Kelly, at their best. Yes, I could do without H singing Fish songs....but that is all we have right now. The ability of Rothery/Kelly to create textures that continually change and adapt to a song is amazing....true brilliance.
a lot of credit must be given to h for even attempting to sing early marillion songs. I don't think anybody could do what fish did on the first four albums,and their early concerts! so the choice is listen, or don't listen I for one would rather hear marillion with h than no marillion at all?
Fish is irreplaceable. That said, Hogarth is a legit rock star. He was able to find the essence of the song and delivers that same exhilaration as the original. Brilliant.
Rispetto a Fish questo è un cane, dal vivo. Riesce anche a stonare, oltre che stravolgere la linea melodica. Cali di voce sulle note più lunghe, un falsetto tentato, insomma, niente a che vedere con Derek. Spero per lui che avesse una laringite quella sera. MAMMA MIA!!
I loved Fish's era for many years, till I discovered H's Marillion. But I still can´t get used to Fish's songs sang by H. They lose kind of authenticity.
Anyone comparing the studio vocals of a 29 year old Fish (1987) singing within his comfort zone to a 49 year old Hogarth (2007) interpreting live a song which may occasionally dip outside his favoured range is an idiot. Could you imagine Fish trying to interpret a more personal song from the Hogarth era like This Strange Engine at any age, live? Carnage!!!!!!
I do not agree. surely Hogarth is better kept. But I watched en listened to Fish's interpretation of his own performance from 1984. It was not the same. But it kept its poetic beauty and gained in humour! And that was in 2022. being a fan from 1984 on I am stil fan of both frontmen and regarding their albums different and equal at the same time. Absolutly loved fish's solo albums and loved the easter album and so forth! twice the amount of beautiful music!
It just don't reach the dramátic performance of early Marillion. They had an identity. Now I don't Know waht are they, for sure not the Marillion I usted to listen in the 80's as a kid
I treat them as 2 separate entities and enjoy the music on each bands era. There was then and this is now. No question Fish will put that energy in the early works but Hogarth is the modern sound and really is the bands logical coming of age.
Only a singer like Daltrey would've been acceptable, but whoever was to replace him the would never have delivered it his way, and even the big man couldn't in the end, get used to it, at least the band still got it, and Steve is still great in his style, he just isn't an 80's style singer his modern edge progressed them forward and for that I'm grateful because it changed them to become still relevant if anything the past was an albatross they should have listened to Hogarth and gone with a totally different band name but they didn't and for that were lumbered with the media's shit perception of them.
Do you know what? The band actually sound better live than on record. Maybe they just fill their album tracks with too many sounds? This is guitar, drums, keyboard and bass - all crystal clear. I think H does really well with another man's lyrics - he's putting everything into it. Maybe doesn't quite work towards the end of this track. Fish just sounded a bit more crazy/desperate!
Marrillon lucky to have had two very talented vocalists I prefer Fish Era Hogarth is a great singer but they seem to have lost something Fish made you sit up and listen but something seems missing although its a great performance great band always will be.
I love the music but Fish wrote and sang these songs from the heart. Hogarth is a great performer but it's painting by numbers. Very professional but without Fishes quirks and celtic twang it's not being delivered how he intended it. I think they should have just started a new band with a new name. I understand Hogarth had auditioned for other bands as well so he was always hetching his bets. There's nothing wrong with his singing. He's a great singer but it's a bit like blaze bay ley fronting iron maiden just not quite right in that context.
The the, it was hardly hedging bets, but yeah he wanted to change the name. And the fans wanted the old stuff, so basically he was snookered, he shouldn't put his slant on it, should just do a carbon copy and then show his style in HIS stuff that would've shut everyone up. As I remember Fish live towards the end was hardly perfect. He stopped singing Forgotten Sons just before Donington as he lost his voice and cancelled the UK leg of 85, then never did it again and Emerald lies, so he knew he had limitations to his own material, he wasn't a trained singer just a vocalist with excellent lyrics. I know it's a BIG just but he himself admits he wasn't singing from the right areas and had to bust a nut to get some notes out.
2 years later there is an answer:-D I think Ian is right and the rest of the band changed too early into the next part. If you sing along in your head it‘s the part where Fish sings „a catalogue of crime in Happy Hour“. Normally it goes on with „Do you cry in happy hour, do you hide in happy hour The pilgrimage to Happy Hour“, but the band cuts off too early into the guitar solo part. Thats why Ian is giving that look to his bandmates. ;-)
The band plays still unbelievable emotional and fresh. But H on Fishy lyrics? Thats like copying a masterpiece by Dali. Without Fish, the band should play this old songs only as instrumentals and let the audience do the singing. That would produce goosebumps to everybody. From an early MARILLION-fan since 85!
As someone that was born long after Fish left, and discovered them even later... I prefer Hogarth on almost all the songs... Especially Warm Wet Circles -> That Time of the Night and Script for a Jester's Tear... I'm mainly a prog fan, my favourite band being Genesis (from 1970-77, the stuff after that ain't too bad but I wouldn't call them my favourite band beyond that point) so you'd think I'd like Fish era more but I really don't! I especially love H's vocals from Brave onwards... Seasons End and Holidays he's not that great to be honest. Like a fine wine I suppose.
Life is a Journey from someone who’s favorite band is high school was fish era marillion and took like a decade to actually enjoy H because of this, I found commentaries like this not only ridiculous but disrespectful
They actually did a gig in 85 with the audience singing as Fish voice had gone, the famous top of the pops lavander lip sink was because of it, but as Forgotten Sons was never played again and also Emeral lies even Derek himself knew there was limitations to his vocal chords, and that was the beginning of the end for his voice. Sad but true. H should stick to what he knows, the band should do an instrumental medley if anything I actually feel that they should do more modern tracks now, I'd sooner TSE than Garden Party and Market Square Heroes etc.
Personally I'd sooner them do Fish era than not at all, the music is phenomenal, and ok h has his limitations but then come on so did Fish live. It's something about the feeling just isn't from the heart as it's not his lyric, but I'd sooner listen to Steve than say listen to Yes playing with the wrong Jon, that is just criminal and only did it once and just No never again.
Band sounds great and I do like H era Marillion, but I hate how H stretches out the vocal lines on Fish songs. Quit putting your own spin on it, Steve... Just sing it like the studio version. When he does, I think its is pretty darn good. Most version of Incommunicado, H sticks with the program, its bitey like Fish, and quite good. Sure Fish is better for his era tunes, but I stilll wanna hear the best era of Marillion tunes live and not to be mothballed just bc H doesnt relate to them.
Yeah you're spot on...no need to spin it, it's a cover so sing it how it was meant to be. Id love to hear Fugazi, Incubus, Jigsaw, P&J never liked Assassing Emerald lies, and Sheree chameleon but sadly he hates it and he'd never stick to it's proper portrail.
Nope, this is wrong , no offence I really enjoy his work , HIS, Fish's lyrics , in my opinion be done by anyone else , Steve may have had. as he had experiences that he can use to relate to , as he has stated , but THE MAN -FISH's lyrics are so personal that the feel, emotion, cannot be duplicated, Steve is a very talented vocalist, and the band has nothing at all to prove , play the songs if they need , loose and stop shamming the name with this KARAOKE show with a live band
"Clutching At Straws" is one of my favourite albums of all time. Fish's genius in investing the tiny details of everyday human life with epic grandeur is so evident here and the band's musicianship follows the contours of his lyrics so perfectly. Steve H gets all of that and delivers. (PS Every time I drive through Bilston Glen I find myself singing "Waiting for the whistle to blow".
God just hearing this, despite H’s vocals struggles in spots, reminds you of just HOW FUCKING GOOD this material was, is, and always shall be - Clutching at Straws - the greatest album ever made.
I think H's yelps are intentional - he can't do a scream like Fish could so he just kind of yelps it. He absolutely kills it other than those couple blips. I love both H and Fish but H has taken way better care of his voice and still sounds fantastic. Listening to Fish sing this from recent years is just tragic.
Fish was "the man" no doubting it..top top lyrical albums.
Sign Hotel Hobbies???
Agree, still playing that album and still in awe of the musicianship and song writing within it. For me this version is only lacking one thing...FISH
Ian Mosley is a very great drummer !
Seriously ❣️❣️❣️
I absolutely adore this. Incredible musicianship on display here. H pays tribute to the brilliant lyrics and puts his own spin on it. Then... there is the audience who are in fine voice.
There is nothing to dislike about this musical masterpiece reborn.
Grande MARILLION!!! Greetings From Santiago de CHILE 🇨🇱 It's Amazing Band
Not forgetting Pete , very underated bass player .
And Ian Mosley!
the rhythm section of Marillion would be a cliche to say the heartbeat but I'll say it anyway! Ian and Pete could have gone anywhere and still be amazing but they stuck to their guns and remain amazing in this great band. Both are criminally underrated!
Ian and Pete definitely make Marillion Marillion. They really fit together. Both of them are unusually creative players. I was told a couple decades ago that Pete Trewavas is more a guitarist than a bassist but for me that's ok He reminds me of the late Chris Squire and that really means quality.
God Bless these guys and the whole band & the fankind!
Simply Completo!!!
Top!!!!
Wonderful band♥️
Mind blowing stuff!!!! Steve Rothery what an incredible feeling in his solo's ... I wish the solo at 6:01 would last forever!
Oh yeah totally
I agree
But then there'd be no 7:46 imagine 6:01 melting into 7:46 and on an on until that time of the night and beyond
Mamma mia...What a great piece of music...love Marillion!!!
Remember when I started listening to this band 35 years ago or so and my friends thought I was nuts. Now regard as of whether it's fish is banned or Hogarth's band they think it's fantastic. Rothery is a badd a** I'll say it again and again and again. One of the most underrated guitarists of all time
Let's not forget the brilliant Mark Kelly counter pointing and layering it marvellously on the keys too..:)
Absolutely .....brilliant musician 🎹👍💥
Let's be honest:: Mark has carried this band for 40 years.
This is Progressive Life! Not only Progressive Rock!🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
I love this album. My only wish would be that as next year is the 30th year anniversary Marillion would re record it with Steve H as he dose this amazing and with such passion. I would love a full studio re mastered album.
For the 30th, they'll be playing it at the weekend in Leicester in a couple of weeks.
Hell no. He should leave well alone. His approach is completely different to Fish and it doesn't work for this material.
MARILLION MY LOVE 💝FROM POLAND 🇵🇱🔥👍🖐
cool - always a pleasure
Brilliant version of the Fish era, But Steve does it fantastic too
🤙
super song super sänger super gruppe !! angela
really, you like that singer singing this?, he is pathetic and destroys the song....., he hate to sing fish material.., you can see it..., he is good only at his u2 staff....
Não serve para cantar as músicas da era Fish, fica muito ruim.
i love this band forever and ever im Of Monterrey México is my favorite band all the albums
Steve Rothery musicalidad emocion autentica maravilla .
What an incredible sound, nothing like the sound of Steve R's guitar work & Steve H's incredible voice!!!! But, no matter how well Steve H sings the old stuff, nobody can ever match Fish! He's the original & by far the best👌👏
I love the old Marillion/Fish album, but so much I love the Fish'voice back, hwe no longer can sing the old stuff with the same emotion that Hogart acheive by himself.
I didn't like the old marillion , "the genesis copy"
I like better steve Hogarth's marillion
Steve's voice all day long!!!
Fish was singing those lyrics from the heart. They meant something to him. There are references throughout his work that are obviously from his own youth. When H sings them, it's just singing an old song he didn't write. He often seems a bit begrudged that he still has to do it.
Mosley at the top !!!
Great stuff!
Essa música é muito bela!!! Essa versão é demais!
Rothery Crack Master ! 🔥🎸
It’s just not the same...couldn’t even continue listening 👂....Fish was a poetic genius....it rolling from his mouth was pure beauty
Should play the songs yeah but just let the audience sing.
Agreed. Still very well performed though.
@@paulgoudfrooij6561the lyrics just don’t work for this singer…
Brilliant 😍
WHEN I SAW MARILLION WITH HOGGY AS THEIR LEAD THROAT, I MUST ADMIT HE SHOWS ALOT OF CLASS IN DEVOTING A GOOD DEAL OF TIME IN PLAYING FISH'S STUFF....
Huge fan of Fish, but i love hearing Hogart sing songs from the Fish era, he does such a wonderful job!
Have to respectably disagree. The problem is he tries to sing them as songs. Fish's lyrics are really musical poetry, not song lyrics. It's why it sounds more awkward.
@@AliTaylor777 I like h's take, but I do think you're onto something there.
I feel h focuses much more strongly on melody, whereas Fish's best performances are akin to sprechgesang and/or recitativo in opera.
@@AliTaylor777 Poetry without singing is nothing, lol. Hogart does his job well.
Steve R!!Nails to our skin and to our soul!!LEGEND
Niente da dire per l'aspetto musicale, la voce purtroppo no!! Steve fantastico come sempre.
Ciao gli ho visti dal vivo 25 anni fa 🎸🎶🤘🔥😎
La prossima primavera li vedrò di nuovo dopo oltre 30 anni dall'ultima volta
Tight. This is the non fish vs h post you were looking for.
Can anyone tell me what year this concert was ? And is it available on dvd or bluray please. This track is superb
J'ADORE !!!!!
J'ADORE +++++ (with H.)
Warm Wet Circles and That Time of the Night (The Short Straw)... Amazing togheter :)
Amazing musicianship. It is a shame that Mosely gets largely ignored in this masterpiece. Rothery, Tewaras, Kelly, at their best. Yes, I could do without H singing Fish songs....but that is all we have right now. The ability of Rothery/Kelly to create textures that continually change and adapt to a song is amazing....true brilliance.
Lamentablemente, hoy por hoy Fish la canta peor y es una pena la forma que perdió su voz, distintiva de la mejor época de Marillion
Rothery at it‘s BEST
geetar like an angelic screaming banshee, my mates,x
God I miss Fish...
Los AMO!
the legacy of the poet
Uno dei migliori brani dell era Fish
a lot of credit must be
given to h for even attempting
to sing early marillion songs.
I don't think anybody could
do what fish did on the
first four albums,and
their early concerts!
so the choice is listen,
or don't listen I for one
would rather hear marillion
with h than no marillion
at all?
And let's not forget.. this is still fingers brilliant!!
Wonderful
Not bothered whose doing the vocals... Band sound great on this ..Steve Roth take a bow again!!!
Fish is irreplaceable. That said, Hogarth is a legit rock star. He was able to find the essence of the song and delivers that same exhilaration as the original. Brilliant.
Totally awesome!!
Rispetto a Fish questo è un cane, dal vivo. Riesce anche a stonare, oltre che stravolgere la linea melodica. Cali di voce sulle note più lunghe, un falsetto tentato, insomma, niente a che vedere con Derek. Spero per lui che avesse una laringite quella sera. MAMMA MIA!!
This textless verion of Hotel Hobbies sounds almost better than the original...
I loved Fish's era for many years, till I discovered H's Marillion. But I still can´t get used to Fish's songs sang by H. They lose kind of authenticity.
i Like H a lot! But, Fish can never really be replaced! Sorry
And yet in a very real way he was, and quite successfully too
But he was
Total albums Fish 4 Total Albums H 16 I rest my case..
Sorry bud. H is amazing and they moved on. Unlike Pink Floyd.
H and what THEY wrote is why I came to Marillion.
Brave…
Done!
Anyone comparing the studio vocals of a 29 year old Fish (1987) singing within his comfort zone to a 49 year old Hogarth (2007) interpreting live a song which may occasionally dip outside his favoured range is an idiot. Could you imagine Fish trying to interpret a more personal song from the Hogarth era like This Strange Engine at any age, live?
Carnage!!!!!!
I do not agree. surely Hogarth is better kept. But I watched en listened to Fish's interpretation of his own performance from 1984. It was not the same. But it kept its poetic beauty and gained in humour! And that was in 2022. being a fan from 1984 on I am stil fan of both frontmen and regarding their albums different and equal at the same time. Absolutly loved fish's solo albums and loved the easter album and so forth! twice the amount of beautiful music!
I agree this sounds a bit strange, knowing Fish’s version. Still a great song and very well performed of course.
Hogarth não serve para cantar as músicas da era Fish, e não é por conta de idade, mas de interpretação.
Wow, amazing rendition of Fish era classics!
Can't take the lead singer seriously, fish is marillion marillion is fish
Fabulous h
Where was this performance???
Hotel hobbies /Warm wet circles/That time of the night
Les breaks au piano de la mort qui tue.
It just don't reach the dramátic performance of early Marillion. They had an identity. Now I don't Know waht are they, for sure not the Marillion I usted to listen in the 80's as a kid
I treat them as 2 separate entities and enjoy the music on each bands era. There was then and this is now. No question Fish will put that energy in the early works but Hogarth is the modern sound and really is the bands logical coming of age.
Fish at the time was irreplaceable. New time now though. Life and change rolls on.
That's the same for me.
Only a singer like Daltrey would've been acceptable, but whoever was to replace him the would never have delivered it his way, and even the big man couldn't in the end, get used to it, at least the band still got it, and Steve is still great in his style, he just isn't an 80's style singer his modern edge progressed them forward and for that I'm grateful because it changed them to become still relevant if anything the past was an albatross they should have listened to Hogarth and gone with a totally different band name but they didn't and for that were lumbered with the media's shit perception of them.
Do you know what? The band actually sound better live than on record. Maybe they just fill their album tracks with too many sounds? This is guitar, drums, keyboard and bass - all crystal clear.
I think H does really well with another man's lyrics - he's putting everything into it. Maybe doesn't quite work towards the end of this track. Fish just sounded a bit more crazy/desperate!
Hogarth's takes on Fish-era songs are really underrated.
band is awesome but i miss fish
Fish is/was a genius,with his vocal poetry and the band's musicianship was a match made in heaven,respect Steve Hogarth,but he's no Fish just saying
H carried away Marillion to another level IMHO ;-)
amo a marillion las dos etapas mas con hogarth le puso algo mas genuino pero fish hizo muy buenos discos los amo
Totally agree
LOVE
Adds in middle of the song are unessisary & very annoying utube!!
Who is this Mr Fishy?
I'm sorry I'm a huge fish fan
No need to apologize for it.
Hogarth makes this pretty much important to listen to
Después de jimi hendrix sigue en la fila steve rothery
The brave album only lists this song as 10 min.
Brave album?? it was clutching at straws
darren mello the LIVE VERSION they are playing, not the studio but thank you regardless
It is a history :)
Marrillon lucky to have had two very talented vocalists I prefer Fish Era Hogarth is a great singer but they seem to have lost something Fish made you sit up and listen but something seems missing although its a great performance great band always will be.
Only Fish can sing Warm Wet Circles. Period.
I love the music but Fish wrote and sang these songs from the heart. Hogarth is a great performer but it's painting by numbers. Very professional but without Fishes quirks and celtic twang it's not being delivered how he intended it. I think they should have just started a new band with a new name. I understand Hogarth had auditioned for other bands as well so he was always hetching his bets. There's nothing wrong with his singing. He's a great singer but it's a bit like blaze bay ley fronting iron maiden just not quite right in that context.
damn straight my friend
Couldn't agree more mate
The the, it was hardly hedging bets, but yeah he wanted to change the name. And the fans wanted the old stuff, so basically he was snookered, he shouldn't put his slant on it, should just do a carbon copy and then show his style in HIS stuff that would've shut everyone up. As I remember Fish live towards the end was hardly perfect. He stopped singing Forgotten Sons just before Donington as he lost his voice and cancelled the UK leg of 85, then never did it again and Emerald lies, so he knew he had limitations to his own material, he wasn't a trained singer just a vocalist with excellent lyrics. I know it's a BIG just but he himself admits he wasn't singing from the right areas and had to bust a nut to get some notes out.
Ian for president
OMG
WONDERFUL MARILLION !!! ALWAYS WONDERFUL !!! mm
Lo mejor
Shit the bed! This is so damn good!
What is Ian doing at 1:56?
2 years later there is an answer:-D
I think Ian is right and the rest of the band changed too early into the next part.
If you sing along in your head it‘s the part where Fish sings „a catalogue of crime in Happy Hour“. Normally it goes on with „Do you cry in happy hour, do you hide in happy hour
The pilgrimage to Happy Hour“, but the band cuts off too early into the guitar solo part. Thats why Ian is giving that look to his bandmates. ;-)
Roman, correct, thats why singers are important for a band. Hilarious and cheerful this is, though..
The band plays still unbelievable emotional and fresh. But H on Fishy lyrics? Thats like copying a masterpiece by Dali. Without Fish, the band should play this old songs only as instrumentals and let the audience do the singing. That would produce goosebumps to everybody.
From an early MARILLION-fan since 85!
As someone that was born long after Fish left, and discovered them even later... I prefer Hogarth on almost all the songs... Especially Warm Wet Circles -> That Time of the Night and Script for a Jester's Tear... I'm mainly a prog fan, my favourite band being Genesis (from 1970-77, the stuff after that ain't too bad but I wouldn't call them my favourite band beyond that point) so you'd think I'd like Fish era more but I really don't! I especially love H's vocals from Brave onwards... Seasons End and Holidays he's not that great to be honest. Like a fine wine I suppose.
Life is a Journey from someone who’s favorite band is high school was fish era marillion and took like a decade to actually enjoy H because of this, I found commentaries like this not only ridiculous but disrespectful
Marillion fan since 1883, crap idea.
They actually did a gig in 85 with the audience singing as Fish voice had gone, the famous top of the pops lavander lip sink was because of it, but as Forgotten Sons was never played again and also Emeral lies even Derek himself knew there was limitations to his vocal chords, and that was the beginning of the end for his voice. Sad but true. H should stick to what he knows, the band should do an instrumental medley if anything I actually feel that they should do more modern tracks now, I'd sooner TSE than Garden Party and Market Square Heroes etc.
EAR CANDY !!!
Without fish we can live
Without marillion impossible
Personally I'd sooner them do Fish era than not at all, the music is phenomenal, and ok h has his limitations but then come on so did Fish live. It's something about the feeling just isn't from the heart as it's not his lyric, but I'd sooner listen to Steve than say listen to Yes playing with the wrong Jon, that is just criminal and only did it once and just No never again.
Marillion is Fish and Fish is Marillion.......
hotel hobbies at first.....
do you have the ownership of this vid ? i dont think so. reported
fish the real voice from marillion .......
Band sounds great and I do like H era Marillion, but I hate how H stretches out the vocal lines on Fish songs. Quit putting your own spin on it, Steve... Just sing it like the studio version. When he does, I think its is pretty darn good. Most version of Incommunicado, H sticks with the program, its bitey like Fish, and quite good. Sure Fish is better for his era tunes, but I stilll wanna hear the best era of Marillion tunes live and not to be mothballed just bc H doesnt relate to them.
Yeah you're spot on...no need to spin it, it's a cover so sing it how it was meant to be. Id love to hear Fugazi, Incubus, Jigsaw, P&J never liked Assassing Emerald lies, and Sheree chameleon but sadly he hates it and he'd never stick to it's proper portrail.
Fish! its not 100% Marillion. sad story. but without fish its not Marillion from the early days, point.
Karaoke?
Marillion ... Einzigartiges Team. Geschichte der Weltmusik, aber nur mit Derek William Dick.
much better than Fish
Malky McWhirter you clown he couldn’t lace Fish’s boots lad
@@geoffbanton4049 I am just giving my opinion as a Marillion fan which hopefully I am entitled to ..why does that make me a clown?
Nah man, not even close.
Sorry, no Fish, no Marillion... No champagne...
IMHO, Fish is way more suited on vocals for this.
damned adverts......
Nope, this is wrong , no offence I really enjoy his work , HIS, Fish's lyrics , in my opinion be done by anyone else , Steve may have had. as he had experiences that he can use to relate to , as he has stated , but THE MAN -FISH's lyrics are so personal that the feel, emotion, cannot be duplicated, Steve is a very talented vocalist, and the band has nothing at all to prove , play the songs if they need , loose and stop shamming the name with this KARAOKE show with a live band
Sorry to say, but this music's belong to Fish, without him singing, doesn't have the same feeling. To poor this version...
Carlos get a life it's over F***in' 30 years ago!