DIO is honestly the pillar (no pun intended) of the Joestars story. He was a true poison for them, yet also, the very reason of his own defeat. He thought he was destined for greatness, and because of this the Joestars became a bloodline of heroes, all admired by their closest friends and allies. Without him, the world would not be as safe. This is the sheer irony of fate.
And even though DIO hated the Joestars and wanted the entire bloodline wiped out, he still added to their family, by taking Jonathan's body and using it to sire four bastard Joestar sons (though he didn't know about any of them by the time he died).
@@number4493 Well, since he was adopted by George (as a favor to Dario), Dio was technically already a Joestar in part 1 chapter/episode 1, and could have lived a good, simple life with his half of the Joestar fortune.
@@theonewhocaredandasked9126 kira isnt really too much of a problem since he is still in morioh. And with diavolo it might end up the same way with him getting his daughter and killing bruno
Without DIO, nothing in JoJo could happen. The only parts that could possibly happen are Battle Tendency and Diamond is Unbreakable, but even then they're going to have massive changes. Parts 1 and 3 can't happen without DIO, Part 6 can't happen without Part 3, and Part 5 especially was only possible because of Giorno, who wouldn't even exist without DIO.
Without the battle on the boat at the end of part 1, Lisa Lisa would've been raised with her biological family and likely would've never met George Jr. So the Joseph we saw would never have existed to go to Japan and bang Tomoko Higashikata, so Josuke wouldn't exist either, and the Morioh gang wouldn't be able to come together as they did to stop Kira.
@@percrazie I mean, I did make this before I'd seen it in it's entirety. Honestly, I wanted to say something, but I wasn't sure what to put so I did this.
Literally without DIO in part one, Kars would have won in Battle Tendency since the Jojos at the time either wouldn't have hamon or their hamon strength wouldn't be enough to kill Kars at all
Kinda crazy how in retrospect Kars and diavolo are more important to the plot than dio since they made him into what he is No Kars no vampire Dio No diavolo no the world
Don't forget the fact that the only reason DIO has a Stand is because Enya gave him the arrow. Diavolo is less important to the plot than Enya, since she was literally the one who bought the arrows from him and brought them to DIO, granting him The World and making all the Joestars Stand Users. If Diavolo simply discovered the arrows and Enya didn't want to buy them off of him, JoJo wouldn't have happened.
Jonathan's mom, Mary Joestar, still died in a carriage crash, so Dario still tried to loot the wreckage, only to find George and baby Jonathan there, then George mistook the drunkard's greed for an act of kindness, after which he would still insist that he owes Dario a favor. In the original timeline, Dario asked George to raise his son, Dio. But with no Dio in the picture, what would Dario have asked for?
"Employ me and my wife." Dario gets sent to prison for some other reason (probably stealing other things in the house) but the woman is nice and is like a second mother to Jonathan, and George marries her. Reason why no Dio is because Dario is sterile, and JoJo gets a 1/2 brother or sister instead.
Jonathan would pursue the stone mask as an archeologist like his father, which would lead him to awaken the pillar men early. Maybe some fate shenanigans make it so he still trains hamon with Will and defeats the pillar men/it becomes a generational battle against them. Or you could make it so Jorge/Dario out of desperation in his old age actually activates the stone mask on himself and it would make him the main antagonist, with the rest of the parts still being possible (with some rewrites here and there).
@@zoefarr2600 without Joseph, the first time ceasar meets wamuu he dies. Reminder, no dio means no lisa lisa to train him, and his dad would still be eaten by the pillar men
Makes you realize how much of an impact DIO had on the story. It’s amazing storytelling by Araki tying in DIO to EVERYTHING, showing that the battle against DIO and Jonathan goes FAR beyond the grave.
Diavolo would still be in this timeline. He would probably still find the arrows whether Dio was alive or not. I don't think Kira would be a stand user in this timeline because that would require the arrow being sold to Dio's organization and passed down to Kira's father. Kira would just be a normal serial killer who would eventually mess up and be arrested.
i like this concept a lot of villains missing, then just causing the whole thing to change. you should do more of these, but with different characters, like "What if Kira Never Existed" because it's not only just really fun to think about, but also makes for really good videos. good video overall!
Another thing to bring up. No Dio means no ship gets blown up at the end of Phantom Blood. No explosion means no baby to be rescued. Meaning Lisa Lisa wouldn't even meet George Joestar, which means no Joseph and therefore the Joestars we know wouldn't even exist. Unless Lisa Lisa meets George anyways later in life because of Gravity. So that means even on that level Dio is responsible for the Joestars even existing the way we know them
i would love a video of what if Fate didn't exist. so like, events truly are unguided. Stand users aren't attracted to Stand users. The Zeppeli family don't NEED to die. Bites The Dust doesn't loop events, King Crimson doesn't have the fate stuff, so Epitaph is useless too. looking at the future without fate existing would make the future change because there's no solid set of events and you'll now act differently that you saw a future. Made In Heaven is one i don't have to explain.
i was Frothing at the mouth for another kaleb i a video soo thanks bro i always listen these when i do yard work and it makes it much more tolerable in the Texas heat
On a side note, assuming the world manages to make it through the Pillar Men crisis… Somehow, no Dio means Polnareff isn’t gonna be on the hunt for Diavolo, who could potentially get the Requiem arrow before Part 5’s original timeframe so depending on how King Crimson Requiem would work in this context, Italy may have problems somewhere between generalized memory losses and something much worse
I have a question. How strong would DIO be if he can stop time as long as he wants? Let's say that all his stats are the same, but he can stop time indefinitely. How strong would he be?
He’d probably be unstoppable since he can just take out anyone when ever even he wants, diavalo would get destroyed I’d think only completely busted stands like GRE, And wonder of U, would have a chance
Humorously enough I think Joseph has a [slightly] better chance of successfully pulling off his Hermit Purple gambit since DIO would be less cautious. …of course this assumes that Jotaro would even get the opportunity, but it’d be a pretty funny ending
Part 2, part 4 and part 5 can happen. As the video said part 1 and 3 are heavily influenced by Dio. Part 4 I think could still exist because Enya would still exist even without Dio. Enya was the reason Dio even got a stand, so it would only make sense that she would be selling stand arrows without ever meeting him. This means eventually Morioh would have stand users (maybe even Josuke) to defeat Kira. Part 5 can also happen as Diavolo would get an arrow if Enya existed, this means Bruno’s gang would be there but Giorno would never exist. Once again Bruno’s gang can turn on Diavolo and someone could get the Requiem stand instead of Giorno. Part 6 would just be a wholesome family story I guess (because no Pucci). Dio seems very necessary to the stories but you can honestly write a version without him by slightly buffing the side characters to make up for the lack of Jojo.
But you forget, Diavolo gave ALL of the stand arrows to Enya, (besides the one he kept) and so without Dio sending Enya to Japan to give a stand arrow to the Nijimuras, the Kira’s probably don’t get one either. Soooo no Killer Queen
It wouldn't be a stretch to say Diavolo would search for the Stone Mask eventually, to keep his empire and "future" eternal, and Pucci could be the new Dio with some tweaking, but I don't see him developing the Heaven plan on his own unless he spends centuries like Dio to know what to search for.
To the people who are talking about Weather Report, Weather gained his stand because he was a blood relative to Pucci like how Jotaro, Joseph, Josuke, and Holly gained their stands when Dio used the arrow (They gained their stands due to Dio Having Jonathan's body which was still as it's own being), and since Pucci never met Dio, he never obtained the arrow meaning neither Pucci or Weather gain stands.
I think you were right the first time, if Dario were a better father then Dio would never had developed that ambition and disdain torwards the Joestars
at least part 3 would still happen, but instead of defeating dio, it'd be defeating all stand users. it'd be a stretch, but maybe the stardust crusaders would still travel the world.
Fuck it, villains of part 3 as as Kids are trained to be the last hamon users and defeat The Pillar Men who actually managed to get their goal, so Ultimate Kars, Esidisi and Wamuu Vs Hol Horse, Oingo, Boingo, Maria, D'arby brothers, etc Stands never exist because no arrows basically, maybe only Diavolo, and he would be faced against the part 3 villains that survived 3 pillar men, maybe as they even get their original stands?
It’s crazy how despite how much terrible stuff Dio has done to the Joestars and having essentially ruined their lives, without him they basically wouldn’t exist nor even get any of their Hamon powers or Stands. So I guess you could call him a necessary evil.
@@HabitualThinker Considering how easy Josuke's life post and pre part 4 seems, along with everyone aside from Rohan, and the fact that only like 1 of his friends died, and he gets a super strong, super fast bodyguard that summon at anytime that heals any injury instantly, I'd say its worth it.
If kira and diavolo are still stand users, kira just hurts one town on ocassion and diavolo rarely even used his stand, he just kept his identity hidden, so really only difference between him and giorno is he sells drugs, so there's no world level threats besides the piller men, who might not even awaken yet
Tbh there wouldn't be any Lisa Lisa, because the boat Jonathan and Erina were in never exploded, so no orphaned baby Lisa Lisa, leaving even less Hamon users
I can’t help but feel like this video is just too similarly to the other video you made on Johnathan successfully killing DIO at the mansion or their fight at the DIO’s castle.
Here's an idea, and it's actually based on a fanfic I've read... What if Dio became a vampire much earlier due to an accident as a result of playing around with the stone mask as a kid, before he or the Joestars really knew what the mask actually did? In the fic, what happens is that Johnathan, Dio and Erina journey to America (accompanied by Speedwagon and Zepelli) to try and find a cure for Dio's vampirism, and while Dio is still a little shit at the beginning he actually, well... not necessarily mellows out, but becomes less of a little shit and directs his remaining little shit-ness towards more constructive outlets. Their journey leads them to the Yucatan, they encounter Santana who fights them for a bit, gives them some advice and a warning, and then goes back to sleep, and that's kinda where everything came to an abrupt end before the author went on hiatus. It's a good read, but it's a bit fanfic-y as it requires Dio to be less, well... Dio. I'd like to see your take on this scenario.
Joseph would have both Lisa Lisa and his dad during his life cause he lost his dad to a zombie that Dio made so if Dio didn't make him both of Joeeph's parents would be present (but Speedwagon wouldn't befriend the Joestars if it wasn't for Dio)
If dio was never there. Then the ship would have never crashed and erina would have never met baby Lisa Lisa. So the joestar family tree would have been completely different
Isn't becuase of speedwagon that the pillar men are found, so it might be possible that the pillar men are never discovered or at least their discovery is delayed.
Haven’t watched video yet, but my predication is if Dio didn’t exist, there would be no Speedwagon Foundation. Without that, the Germans would’ve still found the Pillarmen, except there would be 4 instead of 3, and the Pillarmen would’ve created a German army of vampire thralls before any of the Joestars or Hamon users even heard about it. There would be no agreement to have the various contests in which the Pillarmen each die, since they never put rings on Joseph. 4 Pillarmen with an army vs a presumably successful and strong Joestar family, except they never would’ve found Hamon because it was never needed. After all, Joestars can take on worldly threats without any kind of otherworldly means. Caesar is also never instructed in the use of Hamon, if he exists at all in this timeline. The Hamon users would probably find the Joestar family through some complex series of events that could go in all kinds of directions, and they would team up. But it would be too little, too late. No time to train, no helpful German cyborg with his UV lights (he’s dead, and they never put up lights because there were no survivors from the first one). Kars becomes the Ultimate Lifeform with relatively little opposition and doesn’t even need to betray his allies to do it. He might kill them after, but he wouldn’t even need to do that since they are loyal to him and haven’t failed him this time. Decades later, after purging a large portion of the human race or enslaving them, he discovers the Stand arrow. If he hasn’t awakened his Stand naturally, he pierces himself and becomes the Ultimate Stand user. He’s an order of magnitude more powerful and dangerous than P1-3 Dio ever was, so his Stand is probably something at least as strong as stopping time. He has all the time in the world to eventually make the discovery of Requiem, becomes a being above all other existences, and remakes the universe from the ground up according to his twisted vision.
Now that I think about it, Stands would mostly exist purely in Italy because Diavolo discovered the arrows. Of course there are exceptions for characters who have natural stands and live elsewhere but that's just a small minority. For the most part since Dio doesn't exist, Enya wouldn't buy the arrows from Diavolo which means Part 3, 4, 6, and presumably 7-9 would not happen.
While watching this I realised something non of the joestars past George the second probably never would’ve existed unless gravity made so that Lisa Lisa’s parents met the Joestars and became family friends or something and then they hook up later but even if that happens Joseph probably never would’ve met suzie Q because Lisa Lisa wouldn’t have needed to flee the country meaning Holly wouldn’t have been born and neither would Jotaro or Jolyne. Tomoko meeting Joseph is a maybe but yeah the birth of pretty much every Jojo past Joseph is pretty damn unlikely in this scenario
If there are no joestars becoming hamon users then the pillarmen would probably win since the likelihood of stand users in part 2 is… very low, also Rohan got his stand from mastering manga writing.
Without dio the ship at the end of part 1 doesnt get blown up and lisa doesnt meet george so realistically anything after part 1 of jojo doesnt happen except the pillar men taking over or diavolo getting the stand arrow
Jonathan already had an innate "drive to stop evil" even before he met Dio. The first time we see Jonathan in the series it's him jumping into a losing fight because Erina was being harassed by some bullies and that shows us that Jonathan is the kind of person who will find cause to involve himself if he sees someone is being harassed or an injustice is being made. Dio made it extremely personal (so much that Jonathan's desire to stop him became one of revenge more than trying to stop an evil, it's something that Jonathan shamefully admits because it's not proper gentleman behavior to feel that way) but I still think even without Dio it would have eventually and inevitably been something or someone else that would drive Jonathan into action because it's in his nature to do so. Not to mention the Stone mask itself is pretty cursed and eventually leads to misfortune so something could have happened there (Vampire Jonathan could still be a pretty plausible outcome). Zeppeli also was coming (he knew the Joestars had the mask) but more importantly is the fact that Zeppeli would have never trained Jonathan in hamon unless he somehow found out Jonathan was adept to it (after all it's after he heal Jonathan that he sees how Jonathan conducts hamon like a pro that he decides to train him). Also if what Dio said about gravity still applied maybe Lisa Lisa and George II would still have met and had Joseph, but Lisa Lisa would have been a different person and so would Joseph.
Now I wanna see a video about what would happen if Kars and the Pillarmen didn't exist (like if it would mean that Dio would be more easily defeatable, if the future Parts would be less likely to happen, if Stands could have been introduced sooner/through some other means, etc.)
Wouldn't Kira not get a stand anymore since Yasuhiro was a servant of DIO and since there is no more DIO to recruit Yasuhiro,then there is no arrow getting into his hands so by extension,Kira doesn't get KQ but Diavolo 100% will still be a thing
Even if people says that Dio is the worst person to exist. I think he’s the best because he’s also the cause to make this all series so good. (Kars also is very important because he’s the one who created the stone mask so it will be cool to have the same thing with Kars)
Isnt Kakyoin, a born stand user? And Polneraff awaken his through training and avdol through his psychic abilities? Also I can imagine him running into jotaro at school and became friends and somehow jotaro tag along on kakyoin's adventures with avdol and polnerafff and got into a situation where he awaken star platinum.
Part 2 wouldn't have happened, since in the final battle in part 1, erina saves lisa lisa. Which means she wouldn't have had a kid with george, meaning no part 2,3,4,5,and 6
It's basically the world where Emporio is stuck in. Also although its non-canon. It's stated that the pillar men are always meant to awaken. Kars is always meant to become Ultimate Kars. And he is always blasted off into space by some version of Joseph Joestar. And that it has happened at least 24 times before the start of JoJo.
Actually Yoshihiro stole it from Akira so still no Killer Queen, and also if there were no stardust crusaders, Polnareff would’ve never brought the arrow to Italy for there to be the fight against diácono anyway
Something that you never brought up, but I thought was relevant: Because Pucci never met Dio and got the stand arrow to gain Whitesnake, Weather Report still loses his lover/sister and gets Heavy Weather. What is Pucci supposed to do then?
Wes got his stand through a family link/curse, I'm pretty sure, (like the Joestars) because Pucci got pierced by DIO's arrow, unlocking White Snake BUT ALSO Wes' Heavy Weather. So: no DIO = no arrow for Pucci = no White Snake = no family link/curse = no Wes' Heavy Weather = Wes successfully kills himself.
I've had a few "what if" ideas. Not sure if they have been done (although I'll be surprised if no one else has done this) but: What if Joseph had died in Part 3 but gave his hammon to Jotaro? Just an interesting thought that probably doesn't have a huge impact. and What if Jotaro and Polnareff had switched who was going to explore where the arrows went? It could impact Part 4 but would for sure have Diavolo meeting Jotaro instead. Would Jotaro still be "rusty"? Would he have even met Jolyne's mother?
imagine polnareff taking jotaro's place, killing kira in morioh, meanwhile jotaro gets confronted by diavolo, and kills him early. giorno wouldn't join passione, unless he feels the need to join because why not. so, part 5 mostly wouldn't happen.
Wait how would Diavolo know what the arrows are used for? He learned about stands from eyna right? I mean I don't imagine he would just dig up the arrows and say "Yep I need to stab myself with this". Accually now that I think about he would probably just test it on other people first.
Honestly without Dio existing to push him along Pucci would just be a fairly normal priest but, he just feels like something is missing but, he doesn't know what which is pretty be since it means the universe doesn't end up getting accelerated and reset.
Imagine a world where Diavolo never unearthed the Stand Arrows and the pillarmen are not a threat, lets just say main character Ceasar managed to beat them
Or a world where Enya didn't buy the arrows from him. Diavolo didn't even know how the arrows worked, and Enya was the one who approached him about the arrows and spread them to DIO.
Welp if Jonathan doesn't die then the timeline just changes. erina and jonathan may find eachover since they do fit. and even then without hamon since zepli has no point and it changes tonpettys prediction since it involved dio but uh that means..... kars just wins. like just wins
Hmm... Diavolo sells the rest of his Arrows to Enya, who still exists, but Enya might not send two Arrows all the way to Japan without 2.5 years of DIO's influence, as DIO probably did it by using HP and divining there were Joestars there. Joestars may not even go to Japan either: why would Joseph marry Suzie, etc? So, it could be that there's no Stand Kiras, even if Junior's still a normal killer although his dad might still be a ghost, OR Nijis... ...although if they both travel to Egypt and get noticed: she is after all, still trying to expand on the Stand Using population, but might choose different people. Also, Enya has no way to control an untrustworthy Niji-dad... he will not be a blob, or controlled by a bud either, even if he does get sent an Arrow... Another influence is No SPW... Also Rey Infinito has a different outcome
DIO is honestly the pillar (no pun intended) of the Joestars story. He was a true poison for them, yet also, the very reason of his own defeat. He thought he was destined for greatness, and because of this the Joestars became a bloodline of heroes, all admired by their closest friends and allies. Without him, the world would not be as safe. This is the sheer irony of fate.
And even though DIO hated the Joestars and wanted the entire bloodline wiped out, he still added to their family, by taking Jonathan's body and using it to sire four bastard Joestar sons (though he didn't know about any of them by the time he died).
@@jruler93 indeed
@@jruler93 It's ironic that both Dio and Pucci became "Joestars" in their quest to destroy the bloodline
@@number4493 Well, since he was adopted by George (as a favor to Dario), Dio was technically already a Joestar in part 1 chapter/episode 1, and could have lived a good, simple life with his half of the Joestar fortune.
If DIO stops existing then the pillar-men would uhh kinda reach their goal.
The only way my boy Johnathan gets a good life 🥲
and The Pillar Men get awakened
@@justsomeguywholovesberserk6375happens either way
Not worth, I need that bi vampire lord more
diavolo and kira still a problem
@@theonewhocaredandasked9126 kira isnt really too much of a problem since he is still in morioh. And with diavolo it might end up the same way with him getting his daughter and killing bruno
Long ago, Jonathan Joestar was living with his father and dog in harmony. Then, everything changed when Dio arrived at the Joestar Mansion.
I see you had a good childhood
And then me and my brother found a treasure chest 100 years after jojo vanished
I never realized how much of a necessary evil Dio is to the series. Literally most of these parts wouldn't exist without his influence.
Without DIO, nothing in JoJo could happen. The only parts that could possibly happen are Battle Tendency and Diamond is Unbreakable, but even then they're going to have massive changes.
Parts 1 and 3 can't happen without DIO, Part 6 can't happen without Part 3, and Part 5 especially was only possible because of Giorno, who wouldn't even exist without DIO.
thanks. we watched the video too
Without the battle on the boat at the end of part 1, Lisa Lisa would've been raised with her biological family and likely would've never met George Jr. So the Joseph we saw would never have existed to go to Japan and bang Tomoko Higashikata, so Josuke wouldn't exist either, and the Morioh gang wouldn't be able to come together as they did to stop Kira.
@@percrazie I mean, I did make this before I'd seen it in it's entirety.
Honestly, I wanted to say something, but I wasn't sure what to put so I did this.
Literally without DIO in part one, Kars would have won in Battle Tendency since the Jojos at the time either wouldn't have hamon or their hamon strength wouldn't be enough to kill Kars at all
@@Hijiri_MIRACHION ❤️
Kinda crazy how in retrospect
Kars and diavolo are more important to the plot than dio since they made him into what he is
No Kars no vampire Dio
No diavolo no the world
Without DIO getting The World, none of the Joestars would've become Stand Users either.
Don't forget the fact that the only reason DIO has a Stand is because Enya gave him the arrow. Diavolo is less important to the plot than Enya, since she was literally the one who bought the arrows from him and brought them to DIO, granting him The World and making all the Joestars Stand Users. If Diavolo simply discovered the arrows and Enya didn't want to buy them off of him, JoJo wouldn't have happened.
Jonathan's mom, Mary Joestar, still died in a carriage crash, so Dario still tried to loot the wreckage, only to find George and baby Jonathan there, then George mistook the drunkard's greed for an act of kindness, after which he would still insist that he owes Dario a favor. In the original timeline, Dario asked George to raise his son, Dio. But with no Dio in the picture, what would Dario have asked for?
Financial aid
"Employ me and my wife." Dario gets sent to prison for some other reason (probably stealing other things in the house) but the woman is nice and is like a second mother to Jonathan, and George marries her.
Reason why no Dio is because Dario is sterile, and JoJo gets a 1/2 brother or sister instead.
@@Gamfluent Or no Dio's mother, or Dario was Sterile, or Dio died in childbirth, or Dio was Dia (a girl).
There are many probable causes for no Dio...
Knowing Dario, probably money for booze.
Without Dio, the Pillar Men still awaken and proceed to take over the world as the ultimate life forms.
I’m sure Hamon would still exist though, right?
@@rurijo3169 Yeah but no Joseph, and considering how Ceasar died, they would take over the world with no problem
@@Rainbow51000 Caesar wouldn't have been an angry street punk though, and might have had way more training, be less of a hothead, etc...
Jonathan would pursue the stone mask as an archeologist like his father, which would lead him to awaken the pillar men early. Maybe some fate shenanigans make it so he still trains hamon with Will and defeats the pillar men/it becomes a generational battle against them. Or you could make it so Jorge/Dario out of desperation in his old age actually activates the stone mask on himself and it would make him the main antagonist, with the rest of the parts still being possible (with some rewrites here and there).
@@zoefarr2600 without Joseph, the first time ceasar meets wamuu he dies. Reminder, no dio means no lisa lisa to train him, and his dad would still be eaten by the pillar men
Makes you realize how much of an impact DIO had on the story. It’s amazing storytelling by Araki tying in DIO to EVERYTHING, showing that the battle against DIO and Jonathan goes FAR beyond the grave.
Series realistically ends at part 2 without bullshitting our way through it
Diavolo would still be in this timeline. He would probably still find the arrows whether Dio was alive or not. I don't think Kira would be a stand user in this timeline because that would require the arrow being sold to Dio's organization and passed down to Kira's father. Kira would just be a normal serial killer who would eventually mess up and be arrested.
Ik I'm kate, but yeah, thats exactly the case. In fact, Diavolo sold the arrows to Enya, which got Dio the arrows in the first place.
Super late, but yeah, everyone in Team Bucciarati and Team Risotto would be dead. Diavolo still kills Trish and wins.
i like this concept a lot of villains missing, then just causing the whole thing to change. you should do more of these, but with different characters, like "What if Kira Never Existed" because it's not only just really fun to think about, but also makes for really good videos. good video overall!
Another thing to bring up. No Dio means no ship gets blown up at the end of Phantom Blood. No explosion means no baby to be rescued. Meaning Lisa Lisa wouldn't even meet George Joestar, which means no Joseph and therefore the Joestars we know wouldn't even exist.
Unless Lisa Lisa meets George anyways later in life because of Gravity.
So that means even on that level Dio is responsible for the Joestars even existing the way we know them
George: Oh it's raining outside better stay at the home for today.
**Part 1 ends**
*Jonathan Jostar kill off Dio*
Miguel O'hara: That's not allowed.
*Jonathan Jostar's death*
Miguel O'hara: It's a canon event.
i would love a video of what if Fate didn't exist. so like, events truly are unguided. Stand users aren't attracted to Stand users. The Zeppeli family don't NEED to die. Bites The Dust doesn't loop events, King Crimson doesn't have the fate stuff, so Epitaph is useless too. looking at the future without fate existing would make the future change because there's no solid set of events and you'll now act differently that you saw a future. Made In Heaven is one i don't have to explain.
At least one of Dio's vampires don't eat their own baby.
i was Frothing at the mouth for another kaleb i a video soo thanks bro i always listen these when i do yard work and it makes it much more tolerable in the Texas heat
On a side note, assuming the world manages to make it through the Pillar Men crisis… Somehow, no Dio means Polnareff isn’t gonna be on the hunt for Diavolo, who could potentially get the Requiem arrow before Part 5’s original timeframe so depending on how King Crimson Requiem would work in this context, Italy may have problems somewhere between generalized memory losses and something much worse
I have a question. How strong would DIO be if he can stop time as long as he wants? Let's say that all his stats are the same, but he can stop time indefinitely. How strong would he be?
He’d probably be unstoppable since he can just take out anyone when ever even he wants, diavalo would get destroyed I’d think only completely busted stands like GRE, And wonder of U, would have a chance
If you can stop time indefinitely, then you're unstoppable, even if you're not strong enough to bisect people.
nice pfp
Humorously enough I think Joseph has a [slightly] better chance of successfully pulling off his Hermit Purple gambit since DIO would be less cautious.
…of course this assumes that Jotaro would even get the opportunity, but it’d be a pretty funny ending
@@-AirKat- yea thats true and would be funny its sad that in the actual show he showed dio the trick
Counterpoint: Without Dio, very few of the canon Stand users would have ever gotten their Stands.
Part 2, part 4 and part 5 can happen. As the video said part 1 and 3 are heavily influenced by Dio. Part 4 I think could still exist because Enya would still exist even without Dio. Enya was the reason Dio even got a stand, so it would only make sense that she would be selling stand arrows without ever meeting him. This means eventually Morioh would have stand users (maybe even Josuke) to defeat Kira. Part 5 can also happen as Diavolo would get an arrow if Enya existed, this means Bruno’s gang would be there but Giorno would never exist. Once again Bruno’s gang can turn on Diavolo and someone could get the Requiem stand instead of Giorno. Part 6 would just be a wholesome family story I guess (because no Pucci).
Dio seems very necessary to the stories but you can honestly write a version without him by slightly buffing the side characters to make up for the lack of Jojo.
But you forget, Diavolo gave ALL of the stand arrows to Enya, (besides the one he kept) and so without Dio sending Enya to Japan to give a stand arrow to the Nijimuras, the Kira’s probably don’t get one either. Soooo no Killer Queen
It wouldn't be a stretch to say Diavolo would search for the Stone Mask eventually, to keep his empire and "future" eternal, and Pucci could be the new Dio with some tweaking, but I don't see him developing the Heaven plan on his own unless he spends centuries like Dio to know what to search for.
To the people who are talking about Weather Report, Weather gained his stand because he was a blood relative to Pucci like how Jotaro, Joseph, Josuke, and Holly gained their stands when Dio used the arrow (They gained their stands due to Dio Having Jonathan's body which was still as it's own being), and since Pucci never met Dio, he never obtained the arrow meaning neither Pucci or Weather gain stands.
That's gonna suck a lot for Pucci after he accidentally kills his sister.
I think you were right the first time, if Dario were a better father then Dio would never had developed that ambition and disdain torwards the Joestars
Bro imagine all the part 3 minor antagonists (with natural stands) going around trying to be the next Dio.
That sounds so chaotic!
at least part 3 would still happen, but instead of defeating dio, it'd be defeating all stand users.
it'd be a stretch, but maybe the stardust crusaders would still travel the world.
"I'll wait for her." Honestly true
you know it’s a good night of staying up when kaleb uploads
Fuck it, villains of part 3 as as Kids are trained to be the last hamon users and defeat The Pillar Men who actually managed to get their goal, so Ultimate Kars, Esidisi and Wamuu Vs Hol Horse, Oingo, Boingo, Maria, D'arby brothers, etc
Stands never exist because no arrows basically, maybe only Diavolo, and he would be faced against the part 3 villains that survived 3 pillar men, maybe as they even get their original stands?
to quote a very loud guy: *'THAT'S WHY HE'S THE GOAT! THE GOAT!"*
Koichi is absolutely getting kidnapped and killed by yukako
That music around 3:18... A fellow man of culture, I see
It’s crazy how despite how much terrible stuff Dio has done to the Joestars and having essentially ruined their lives, without him they basically wouldn’t exist nor even get any of their Hamon powers or Stands. So I guess you could call him a necessary evil.
Having a stand isn’t really worth the suffering that is being a stand user.
Without DIO, Diavolo wins. Kira doesn't become a stand user, though.
@@HabitualThinker Considering how easy Josuke's life post and pre part 4 seems, along with everyone aside from Rohan, and the fact that only like 1 of his friends died, and he gets a super strong, super fast bodyguard that summon at anytime that heals any injury instantly, I'd say its worth it.
If kira and diavolo are still stand users, kira just hurts one town on ocassion and diavolo rarely even used his stand, he just kept his identity hidden, so really only difference between him and giorno is he sells drugs, so there's no world level threats besides the piller men, who might not even awaken yet
Tbh there wouldn't be any Lisa Lisa, because the boat Jonathan and Erina were in never exploded, so no orphaned baby Lisa Lisa, leaving even less Hamon users
“What if the joestar bloodline wasn’t special stands didn’t exist and none of the villains where villains”
you should do a video on trying to make the strength stand strong by making only a few changes
It ironic how many horrible fates DIO's mere existence stopped, considering DIO is probably the most evil character in the show
I mean in the SBR Universe Dio doesn't have as much of an impact as he does in the PB Universe so I could see another chaotic stuff happening
Peace.
World peace.
That's the answer.
I can’t help but feel like this video is just too similarly to the other video you made on Johnathan successfully killing DIO at the mansion or their fight at the DIO’s castle.
my ass wants to eat the forbidden Hamon jelly..
Here's an idea, and it's actually based on a fanfic I've read...
What if Dio became a vampire much earlier due to an accident as a result of playing around with the stone mask as a kid, before he or the Joestars really knew what the mask actually did?
In the fic, what happens is that Johnathan, Dio and Erina journey to America (accompanied by Speedwagon and Zepelli) to try and find a cure for Dio's vampirism, and while Dio is still a little shit at the beginning he actually, well... not necessarily mellows out, but becomes less of a little shit and directs his remaining little shit-ness towards more constructive outlets. Their journey leads them to the Yucatan, they encounter Santana who fights them for a bit, gives them some advice and a warning, and then goes back to sleep, and that's kinda where everything came to an abrupt end before the author went on hiatus. It's a good read, but it's a bit fanfic-y as it requires Dio to be less, well... Dio.
I'd like to see your take on this scenario.
Kira wouldn’t even have a stand since Yoshihiro got the arrow from Enya
To be fair; Wammu admitted he only won because he got lucky that Caeser made a 1 second mistake
Joseph would have both Lisa Lisa and his dad during his life cause he lost his dad to a zombie that Dio made so if Dio didn't make him both of Joeeph's parents would be present (but Speedwagon wouldn't befriend the Joestars if it wasn't for Dio)
Lol the bit about hermes "I'll wait for her"
If dio was never there. Then the ship would have never crashed and erina would have never met baby Lisa Lisa. So the joestar family tree would have been completely different
Bro made Jojo’s Average Stroll
Isn't becuase of speedwagon that the pillar men are found, so it might be possible that the pillar men are never discovered or at least their discovery is delayed.
Jotaro won't even exist since Joseph haven't met Suzie q which means that jolyne also wouldn't exist
Oh god there's nobody to stop Alessi💀
mikitaka would probably still go to morioh, and he would still have earth, wind and fire. so maybe he could fight yoshikage kira?
What if Dario Brando became the villain of Phantom Blood in this scenario?And if he became a vampire he created a progeny of hybrid childrens?
Neat!, Keep up the good work! ☮💖
No one:
Kaleb: what if dio never existed
“JOHNATHAN NORMAL ADVENTURES” 😅
Or
Edit: “Johnathan normal life in londan”
Haven’t watched video yet, but my predication is if Dio didn’t exist, there would be no Speedwagon Foundation. Without that, the Germans would’ve still found the Pillarmen, except there would be 4 instead of 3, and the Pillarmen would’ve created a German army of vampire thralls before any of the Joestars or Hamon users even heard about it.
There would be no agreement to have the various contests in which the Pillarmen each die, since they never put rings on Joseph.
4 Pillarmen with an army vs a presumably successful and strong Joestar family, except they never would’ve found Hamon because it was never needed. After all, Joestars can take on worldly threats without any kind of otherworldly means. Caesar is also never instructed in the use of Hamon, if he exists at all in this timeline.
The Hamon users would probably find the Joestar family through some complex series of events that could go in all kinds of directions, and they would team up. But it would be too little, too late. No time to train, no helpful German cyborg with his UV lights (he’s dead, and they never put up lights because there were no survivors from the first one).
Kars becomes the Ultimate Lifeform with relatively little opposition and doesn’t even need to betray his allies to do it. He might kill them after, but he wouldn’t even need to do that since they are loyal to him and haven’t failed him this time.
Decades later, after purging a large portion of the human race or enslaving them, he discovers the Stand arrow. If he hasn’t awakened his Stand naturally, he pierces himself and becomes the Ultimate Stand user. He’s an order of magnitude more powerful and dangerous than P1-3 Dio ever was, so his Stand is probably something at least as strong as stopping time.
He has all the time in the world to eventually make the discovery of Requiem, becomes a being above all other existences, and remakes the universe from the ground up according to his twisted vision.
Now that I think about it, Stands would mostly exist purely in Italy because Diavolo discovered the arrows. Of course there are exceptions for characters who have natural stands and live elsewhere but that's just a small minority. For the most part since Dio doesn't exist, Enya wouldn't buy the arrows from Diavolo which means Part 3, 4, 6, and presumably 7-9 would not happen.
7-9 would probably happen still as it's completely separate from the main universe.
Jojos slightly normal adventure
Only part 2 and 4 would probably happen without Dio
Pretty sure there is no Kira in this timeline, the arrow that got him was one of the ones used by dio to make his army of stand-users.
Yo without bruno's gang La squadra could still find Diavolo and MY BOY Risotto could, possibly clutch out a win
new theory video:
what if it hadnt rained that day?
I think Wammu said that ceaser could have beaten Kars so with Mario and the rest of the hamon school they probably win .
I'm sorry but the way he talks about Caesar getting inevitable snuffed at 2:26 just took me out bro. 🤣🤣🤣
While watching this I realised something non of the joestars past George the second probably never would’ve existed unless gravity made so that Lisa Lisa’s parents met the Joestars and became family friends or something and then they hook up later but even if that happens Joseph probably never would’ve met suzie Q because Lisa Lisa wouldn’t have needed to flee the country meaning Holly wouldn’t have been born and neither would Jotaro or Jolyne. Tomoko meeting Joseph is a maybe but yeah the birth of pretty much every Jojo past Joseph is pretty damn unlikely in this scenario
If there are no joestars becoming hamon users then the pillarmen would probably win since the likelihood of stand users in part 2 is… very low, also Rohan got his stand from mastering manga writing.
Without dio the ship at the end of part 1 doesnt get blown up and lisa doesnt meet george so realistically anything after part 1 of jojo doesnt happen except the pillar men taking over or diavolo getting the stand arrow
I feel like if anything went differently in parts 1 and 2 then the pillar men just win
I have a cool video idea What if dio actually died in part 1 (When they were at the castle or on the boat)
Jonathan already had an innate "drive to stop evil" even before he met Dio. The first time we see Jonathan in the series it's him jumping into a losing fight because Erina was being harassed by some bullies and that shows us that Jonathan is the kind of person who will find cause to involve himself if he sees someone is being harassed or an injustice is being made. Dio made it extremely personal (so much that Jonathan's desire to stop him became one of revenge more than trying to stop an evil, it's something that Jonathan shamefully admits because it's not proper gentleman behavior to feel that way) but I still think even without Dio it would have eventually and inevitably been something or someone else that would drive Jonathan into action because it's in his nature to do so. Not to mention the Stone mask itself is pretty cursed and eventually leads to misfortune so something could have happened there (Vampire Jonathan could still be a pretty plausible outcome). Zeppeli also was coming (he knew the Joestars had the mask) but more importantly is the fact that Zeppeli would have never trained Jonathan in hamon unless he somehow found out Jonathan was adept to it (after all it's after he heal Jonathan that he sees how Jonathan conducts hamon like a pro that he decides to train him).
Also if what Dio said about gravity still applied maybe Lisa Lisa and George II would still have met and had Joseph, but Lisa Lisa would have been a different person and so would Joseph.
At least Jonathan's dog is still alive.
Now I wanna see a video about what would happen if Kars and the Pillarmen didn't exist (like if it would mean that Dio would be more easily defeatable, if the future Parts would be less likely to happen, if Stands could have been introduced sooner/through some other means, etc.)
Dio's just arrested and rots in prison most likely.
jojo is just one giant butterfly effect
Wouldn't Kira not get a stand anymore since Yasuhiro was a servant of DIO and since there is no more DIO to recruit Yasuhiro,then there is no arrow getting into his hands so by extension,Kira doesn't get KQ but Diavolo 100% will still be a thing
are you gonna talk about Demonic Heartbreak? it's cool.
maybe there's not much to talk about, just asking
Would Joseph have even met Susie Q since he didn’t get caught up in the pillar men
Even if people says that Dio is the worst person to exist. I think he’s the best because he’s also the cause to make this all series so good. (Kars also is very important because he’s the one who created the stone mask so it will be cool to have the same thing with Kars)
He's ballin He's shoot
He he he
Isnt Kakyoin, a born stand user? And Polneraff awaken his through training and avdol through his psychic abilities? Also I can imagine him running into jotaro at school and became friends and somehow jotaro tag along on kakyoin's adventures with avdol and polnerafff and got into a situation where he awaken star platinum.
Part 2 wouldn't have happened, since in the final battle in part 1, erina saves lisa lisa. Which means she wouldn't have had a kid with george, meaning no part 2,3,4,5,and 6
It's basically the world where Emporio is stuck in. Also although its non-canon. It's stated that the pillar men are always meant to awaken. Kars is always meant to become Ultimate Kars. And he is always blasted off into space by some version of Joseph Joestar. And that it has happened at least 24 times before the start of JoJo.
I was wondering how they would deal with the pillar men lol
Actually Yoshihiro stole it from Akira so still no Killer Queen, and also if there were no stardust crusaders, Polnareff would’ve never brought the arrow to Italy for there to be the fight against diácono anyway
Actually dio had to do with stand arrows spreading, so without him Kira and all of Passione probably have no stands
I thought about that question 2 days ago 😅 Actually, I thought what could have happened if Dio had never escaped his coffin.
Something that you never brought up, but I thought was relevant: Because Pucci never met Dio and got the stand arrow to gain Whitesnake, Weather Report still loses his lover/sister and gets Heavy Weather. What is Pucci supposed to do then?
Wes got his stand through a family link/curse, I'm pretty sure, (like the Joestars) because Pucci got pierced by DIO's arrow, unlocking White Snake BUT ALSO Wes' Heavy Weather.
So: no DIO = no arrow for Pucci = no White Snake = no family link/curse = no Wes' Heavy Weather = Wes successfully kills himself.
I've had a few "what if" ideas. Not sure if they have been done (although I'll be surprised if no one else has done this) but:
What if Joseph had died in Part 3 but gave his hammon to Jotaro? Just an interesting thought that probably doesn't have a huge impact.
and
What if Jotaro and Polnareff had switched who was going to explore where the arrows went? It could impact Part 4 but would for sure have Diavolo meeting Jotaro instead. Would Jotaro still be "rusty"? Would he have even met Jolyne's mother?
imagine polnareff taking jotaro's place, killing kira in morioh, meanwhile jotaro gets confronted by diavolo, and kills him early. giorno wouldn't join passione, unless he feels the need to join because why not.
so, part 5 mostly wouldn't happen.
Wait how would Diavolo know what the arrows are used for? He learned about stands from eyna right? I mean I don't imagine he would just dig up the arrows and say "Yep I need to stab myself with this".
Accually now that I think about he would probably just test it on other people first.
Honestly without Dio existing to push him along Pucci would just be a fairly normal priest but, he just feels like something is missing but, he doesn't know what which is pretty be since it means the universe doesn't end up getting accelerated and reset.
Imagine a world where Diavolo never unearthed the Stand Arrows
and the pillarmen are not a threat, lets just say main character Ceasar managed to beat them
Or a world where Enya didn't buy the arrows from him. Diavolo didn't even know how the arrows worked, and Enya was the one who approached him about the arrows and spread them to DIO.
Pucci never gets maiden heaven since Dio gave him a stand arrow so there won't be a universe reset.
He never said there'd be a Universe reset
Man has changed this thumbnail like 3 times
Welp if Jonathan doesn't die then the timeline just changes. erina and jonathan may find eachover since they do fit. and even then without hamon since zepli has no point and it changes tonpettys prediction since it involved dio but uh that means.....
kars just wins. like just wins
Hmm... Diavolo sells the rest of his Arrows to Enya, who still exists, but Enya might not send two Arrows all the way to Japan without 2.5 years of DIO's influence, as DIO probably did it by using HP and divining there were Joestars there. Joestars may not even go to Japan either: why would Joseph marry Suzie, etc?
So, it could be that there's no Stand Kiras, even if Junior's still a normal killer although his dad might still be a ghost, OR Nijis...
...although if they both travel to Egypt and get noticed: she is after all, still trying to expand on the Stand Using population, but might choose different people.
Also, Enya has no way to control an untrustworthy Niji-dad... he will not be a blob, or controlled by a bud either, even if he does get sent an Arrow...
Another influence is No SPW...
Also Rey Infinito has a different outcome
Jojos almost normal adventure
Danny’s alive
Bahahaha 8:10 👀
Even though the story does get reset a lil bit they still all end up good (least the part 6 crew does)