Liam vs. Noel Gallagher: Live Shows Comparison Vol. 1 (Updated)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 137

  • @c.t.7652
    @c.t.7652 4 года назад +70

    I think that Noel's a brilliant lyricist, but Liam definitely rocks it
    I think together they are the force that was Oasis. Liam's solo careers doing ok. But nothing like the following Oasis had. I suppose it's all about whose style of delivery is the one you/I/us prefer. Personally I go with Liam 👍😁

    • @bkarmark2602
      @bkarmark2602 2 года назад +1

      Liam is doing great nowadays. He played 200K fans in 5 days in Etihad and Knebworth

    • @jacobmassey3897
      @jacobmassey3897 4 месяца назад

      Noel used to have the bigger following simply because Liam wasn't able to perform the old tunes. Ever since the laters solo career took off he's had by far the bigger fanbase

  • @estebansoto9550
    @estebansoto9550 3 года назад +29

    Noel is a way better singer in every objective way, but you just can't ignore the feel that Liam's voice gives, and the way he sings, the emotions he expresses. Noel always had a better technique when it comes to singing, but Liam has his unique voice that nobody has.

  • @jackpowell1809
    @jackpowell1809 3 года назад +32

    As much as I love Liam. My god Noel sounds outstanding.

  • @adammahoney6537
    @adammahoney6537 4 года назад +23

    I think Liam brings more noise and RnR to his gigs (I'd rather attend an LG gig). However Noel occasionally brings a lot of emotion which I can get behind

    • @kaydenbush
      @kaydenbush 4 года назад +4

      That's almost exactly how I feel. Liam keeps that same energy, but Noel kinda changes it up in a nice way that suites his voice and style a bit better. Both are great in different ways.

  • @kizza4911
    @kizza4911 4 года назад +23

    Can't decide, guess I'll just have to settle with choosing an oasis reunion.

  • @portishphonic
    @portishphonic 3 года назад +27

    Noel has a sweet, lovely, voice that's perfect for acoustic music. Liam's is a force of nature and unique. Growing up, I was partial to Noel, now I'm partial to Liam's.

  • @OperationBlueprint
    @OperationBlueprint 3 года назад +11

    Absolutely love acoustic performances of those early Oasis songs. Ultimately that's how Noel would have written them.

  • @leisureit
    @leisureit 4 года назад +11

    First time ever I hear Liam singing Don't Look Back in Anger

  • @Fernando7777777
    @Fernando7777777 4 года назад +21

    I'll pick Liams voice in a bad day before Noel's all the time, but depends on tastes I guess. Together though...

  • @xzeikoz
    @xzeikoz 4 года назад +39

    Noel: acoustic versions
    Liam: electric versions

    • @jsull8510
      @jsull8510 3 года назад +1

      I think with their music style electric wins it for me

  • @brianpender7872
    @brianpender7872 3 года назад +9

    Liam’s voice now is so different from his younger day’s when he could hit the high notes! When Noel sang songs they sounded so calming! When Liam sang the same songs he could take that to a different level! Definitely miss oasis with them both performing!

  • @tanyacampbell29
    @tanyacampbell29 4 года назад +20

    Liam has the voice for me, the only problem is because of the way he sings he never gives his voice a chance to rest which he needs whereas Noel sings more softly. As much as I love them both Liam wins it for me because Noel’s sets are just too boring no stage presence at all.

    • @Az-bf5qo
      @Az-bf5qo Год назад

      Noel will always be a better singer

  • @chiphenderson5213
    @chiphenderson5213 4 года назад +15

    At 5:33, I'm just going to pretend that Noel is telling the world symbolically he's ready to have Liam back singing Live Forever and the world is right again

  • @davalpe
    @davalpe 3 года назад +37

    Noel gives us new versions of oasis songs, Liam gives us what we really want to hear from oasis

  • @willyc.8141
    @willyc.8141 4 года назад +43

    Rockin' Chair is so hard to sing, especially for Liam, what a performance, was it 2017?

    • @alexhk5406
      @alexhk5406 4 года назад +3

      I think it was from bbc 2017 and he lowered the key of the song since then.

    • @daniel_twine2816
      @daniel_twine2816 4 года назад +3

      Your being sarcastic right ?

  • @Beamboy555
    @Beamboy555 4 года назад +66

    Noel’s become what he hated. A manc Phil Collins with no rock n roll. Still great tho

    • @jonathanclulow73
      @jonathanclulow73 4 года назад +7

      Bean Hit the nail on the head there mate.

    • @halina_ramanava
      @halina_ramanava 6 месяцев назад

      I think, you got the point, but Noel seems happy with his current status and I think it’s the only thing that matters. Love this man, he’s a great songwriter, though he pisses me off with his nanana-songs

  • @wesleypowell4585
    @wesleypowell4585 4 года назад +9

    Both are good. Liam is better in the big arenas in my experience. Although after seeing this Noel shouldn’t sing Supersonic, it’s half the song the way he sings it. Almost as bad as Mike Flower’s version of Wonderwall ha.

  • @gedmason6387
    @gedmason6387 2 года назад +8

    Liam is the sound of Oasis. Always has been always will be. Though i think they need each other more than they admit

    • @lordc1508
      @lordc1508 4 месяца назад

      noel has far outsold liam

  • @edoardocambi2321
    @edoardocambi2321 4 года назад +14

    Liam more energy, Noel more feelings

  • @myself3209
    @myself3209 8 месяцев назад +2

    Noel has a very clean and sweet voice, but I think Liams rough voice is what makes Wonderwall so unique.

  • @James_Lo
    @James_Lo 4 года назад +7

    The way I see it. Noel can sing.

  • @philiplidstroem8534
    @philiplidstroem8534 4 года назад +29

    As a young man myself I really prefer Liam. Not because he sounds better but because Noels performances seem like they are for people over 40 lol

    • @peterthirdandthebridges
      @peterthirdandthebridges 4 года назад +5

      That's cause I think the original oasis fans have moved on to noel while the new ones tend to go to liam

  • @jameswade4287
    @jameswade4287 4 года назад +16

    The difference between them now is that Noel's music is a lot like David Bowie's but Liam's music is like The Beatles, The Stone Roses and John Lennon

    • @oliverfield877
      @oliverfield877 4 года назад +8

      Liams music is nothing like John Lennon’s. John was a proper songwriter and very experimental. Liam gets songwriters to write him the same old song

    • @TheHarrip
      @TheHarrip 3 года назад +2

      @@oliverfield877fun fact, did you know Lennon wrote his lyrics over Motown songs then changed the chords? Google it, the more you know 👍

    • @oliverfield877
      @oliverfield877 3 года назад

      TheHarrip is that meant to have any correlation with what I said

    • @niallmccloy3075
      @niallmccloy3075 3 года назад

      @@oliverfield877 nothing like the roses either is it

  • @TheWonderStraw
    @TheWonderStraw 4 года назад +5

    Liam's got the voice. At least the better of the two.
    A real pity they can't sort things out. If the Davies brothers of the Kinks can do it then these two surely can!

  • @yeophoebe7390
    @yeophoebe7390 4 года назад +13

    Day->Liam ; nightfall->Noel

  • @Daz0566
    @Daz0566 4 года назад +51

    Sounds like to me Noel is trying to reinvent a lot of the songs. Whereas Liam is keeping them true to the Oasis days.

    • @wesleypowell4585
      @wesleypowell4585 4 года назад +4

      I think he needs to, his vocals don’t suit the way Liam sang them. It works in most cases. Supersonic is the only Noel version that I though was awful. The rest are good to have two versions depending on my mood at the time.

    • @longstare
      @longstare 3 года назад +2

      Let's be fair, Noel wrote these songs and has gone on record as saying that Liam changed how they were sung at the time. Noel's probably sticking to how they were always intended to sound.

    • @alanwaterworth6464
      @alanwaterworth6464 3 года назад +8

      @@longstare If that´s how they were always intended to sound, Oasis would never have been anything IMO. I saw them in a pub in Leeds called the Duchess, in 94, before Definitely Maybe came out when they started the promo tour. A small shit pub, with sticky floors and the smell of stale beer and cigarettes. They opened with Rock n Roll Star, massive sound, massive attitude, and you just knew they were gonna be massive. I saw them again in 96 at Maine road. One of the best gigs ever. I´ve since seen Noel and the High Flying Birds at Rock En Seine in Paris, in 2012, the performance was barely worth remembering, so much in fact, I barely remember it. It was like someone was playing songs you knew, but sitting around a camp fire, not at a festival. Green Day were on at the same festival the next day, they were the headline and main reason for going. They were epic. I´d pay a lot of money to see Oasis again so long as Liam is up front, cos without him Noel is more like a folk singer, and would still be playing the small shit pubs they started in. Imo.

    • @longstare
      @longstare 3 года назад

      @@alanwaterworth6464 You don't have to justify your opinion to me, I'm just relaying what I've seen come from Noel's mouth. Every artist has an audience anyway, sometimes I'm in the mood for Noel's stuff, sometimes I'm in the mood for Liam's stuff. I don't prefer one to the other overall.

    • @alanwaterworth6464
      @alanwaterworth6464 3 года назад

      @@longstare I wasn´t justifying my opinion, just offering it, based on personal experience of various performances. Noel is on record saying they wanted to be big, as big as the Beatles and that they were the best band in the world at the time and that they wanted to get out of where they were. Everyone thought they were arrogant dicks at the time but the fact that we´re still having the conversation over 26 years after they hit the headlines proves they were justified. I know plenty of very good musicians who are far more talented than Noel but will never enjoy the commercial success that Oasis enjoyed because the music lacks the charisma and energy that Liam brought to the band. Noel is doing it more kinda folksie now because he can afford to, because of that success, which is fair enough. I just hope he eventually acknowledges the massive difference having Liam up front made and they manage to sort their differences out enough to do one last tour. Then again, they never intended to keep doing it until they were pensioners like the Stones either, they wanted to go out at the top. So maybe it will never happen. But we´ll still have the memories of one of the best decades in British music because of them.

  • @jonathanclulow73
    @jonathanclulow73 4 года назад +11

    Liam is without doubt the greatest front man of his generation. Noel is one of the greatest songwriters of his generation. Hard to call, depends which side you look at it in my opinion. Great vid by the way 👍

  • @andrewcox9914
    @andrewcox9914 4 года назад +17

    Depends if you’re in the mood to snort gear and punch the shit out of someone or in the mood to chill out and stare at the stars.

  • @mickharrison90
    @mickharrison90 4 года назад +26

    It's weird hearing Supersonic acoustically

    • @dafunkystar
      @dafunkystar 4 года назад +8

      i cannot get with acoustic supersonic nope nope nope

    • @papibara4320
      @papibara4320 4 года назад

      abstract octave completely agree

  • @claudioaloise5149
    @claudioaloise5149 3 года назад +5

    Liam voice of the rock...

  • @dapigbear312
    @dapigbear312 2 года назад +5

    Supersonic proves my point noel sounds like someone busking Liam Sound like well Liam Gallagher no way to put it

  • @slimdowndaddy7919
    @slimdowndaddy7919 2 года назад +2

    Both sound great... liam is definitely the better singer... so much attitude. Noel will always be one of the greatest song writers

  • @lautaroc1621
    @lautaroc1621 4 года назад +4

    Los 2 son genios, yo prefiero a Liam en solitario, pero los acusticos que hace Noel...ufff , en fin ojala algún día arreglen sus diferencias, la vida es corta

  • @betsybk11
    @betsybk11 3 года назад +6

    LIAM wins this 100% - #1 SUPER ROCK N' ROLL STAR! Liam can never be replaced! Liam appeals to ALL ages! Kids, college age, & up to my Uncle who is 70 years old.
    I don't care how much his vocals have changed with sore throats & straining his vocals from Hashimotos....LIAM IS THE ROCKSTAR of the 2 brothers! Plus, Liam sang his freaking heart out back in the day & still does which takes a toll on nearly every lead singers voice as years pass by.
    Noel now sounds like an older band singer when bands age & start putting a softer, more mature sound on their music to appeal to the more senior crowd.
    Vocals forever belong to Liam! Even when he is hoarse & blows out his vocal chords. I dig that raspy sound he gets sometimes. Noel belongs to the electric guitar & his Oasis songwriting.
    * Although - you must admit that Liam has proven to be a great songwriter in his own right & a great acoustic guitarist!*
    I would personally pay $500 USA dollars & drive a long distance to see Liam Gallagher any day!
    Noel? No offense meant to Noel, but I would pay $50 USA dollars if he was at a venue closeby.
    (By the way, this is not meant to seem rude or negative towards Noel!)
    I just gave my honest opinion along with the 6 other people in my home today hanging out.
    No Liam? No Oasis! Great frontman.

  • @iaincarter2599
    @iaincarter2599 4 года назад +58

    When noel does an oasis song it sounds like a cover but when Liam does it it's the real thing

    • @jsull8510
      @jsull8510 3 года назад +6

      I suppose that’s wot happens when 98% is his voice in oasis

    • @MozTheBoz
      @MozTheBoz 3 года назад +3

      Of course you'll feel that way because that's how you were familiarized with the songs. I actually prefer Noel's arrangements. If he went solo earlier in his life and put up those songs with those arrangements it would still be a hit.

    • @DerekDerekDerekDerekDerekDerek
      @DerekDerekDerekDerekDerekDerek 2 года назад

      That's weird because most of the best oasis songs are originally and only sung by Noel

  • @adamburns1903
    @adamburns1903 4 года назад +3

    I love Noels slide away

  • @hollydaniels7447
    @hollydaniels7447 4 года назад

    I kinda like how Noel let's the croud take over on Live Forever. He makes it emotional.

  • @TheHarrip
    @TheHarrip 3 года назад +8

    Noel wishes he could sing like Liam. That simple truth ends the argument of who sings better. We can all sing the songs like Noel. Try matching Liam.

    • @moon1890
      @moon1890 3 года назад +5

      Right Liam would have been a star with another decent songwriter, while noel wouldn’t, simple as that

  • @marcusnolte7476
    @marcusnolte7476 2 года назад +1

    This round goes to Noel. Original tuning, spot on, and I don't personally like album recreations so.. Liam has the songs tuned town and still has to push to 110% . That happens to the best of singers

    • @Riffmaster227
      @Riffmaster227 Год назад +2

      Legit every song Noel changes the key. Liam’s still in the OG keys.

    • @marcusnolte7476
      @marcusnolte7476 Год назад

      @@Riffmaster227 you mean the other way round ?

    • @timmynoshoe8404
      @timmynoshoe8404 Год назад +3

      Noel literally plays at least 2 tones higher in every song

  • @adamlevy4592
    @adamlevy4592 4 года назад +2

    Well they’re noels songs so his delivery is probably how he wrote them before oasis recorded them, Liam does them how oasis would

  • @gabrielavilte3405
    @gabrielavilte3405 4 года назад +5

    I like both but I prefer Liam.. I love Liam ..

  • @themichael3105
    @themichael3105 4 года назад

    I can choose either way. They are both God-like.

  • @jimi4906
    @jimi4906 4 года назад +5

    If you need a good nights sleep go to a NG concert. If you need rock and roll go to a LG concert.

  • @krisbowditch827
    @krisbowditch827 2 года назад +2

    Noels live music lacks the ummph , good background music in a cafe or pub.. 🥱not Friday night gig night. live it up feel .. smash fest🤪✊👍

  • @cobrakai388
    @cobrakai388 20 дней назад

    Its kinda like before reaching the age of 35, you prefer Liam's version.
    After reaching that age and get older and older, you prefer Noel's version of the songs.

  • @geraintgriffiths9435
    @geraintgriffiths9435 2 года назад +2

    Noel turning all his rock classics into folk music is a mistake Liam still rocks the classics so he's def better

  • @joekool95
    @joekool95 10 дней назад

    This video should be called Liam vs Noel live show recording comparison. It's hard to compare their shows when Liam's was recorded professionally while Noel's is shaky audience android video. It's real shame that we don't have the same quality recording. They both look like they give phenomenal shows. I just wish that we had better professional recorded footage of Noel's shows. Much of the video and audio is horrendous.

  • @jupitorious7925
    @jupitorious7925 2 года назад

    both are great..

  • @Riffmaster227
    @Riffmaster227 2 года назад

    Liam FTW!

  • @scottbeattie1581
    @scottbeattie1581 4 года назад +5

    Liam wins outright

  • @H하또
    @H하또 2 года назад

    둘다 오아시스 그자체다! 구분지을 필요가 있을까?
    형제들은 위대함 그자체bbbbb

  • @DKH1103
    @DKH1103 3 года назад +4

    Noel sounds nice enough, but with Liam you’ve still got that thrilling rock n roll sense of danger.

  • @bluelotusnefertoum2144
    @bluelotusnefertoum2144 4 года назад

    Best acoustic wonder wall by Noel

  • @aidantanner2059
    @aidantanner2059 3 года назад +1

    Noel anyday.

  • @Thedarkestant
    @Thedarkestant 18 дней назад

    Noel = ballads. Liam = rock.

  • @CATRIFACIA1
    @CATRIFACIA1 Месяц назад

    Listening to Noel is like listening to Míchael Bublé singing oasis songs.

  • @eduardocarbonari228
    @eduardocarbonari228 2 года назад

    Liam all day

  • @rktyler3470
    @rktyler3470 3 года назад

    I think Liam is trying to do the oasis thing. Noel is maturing and changing his presence

  • @Chazza1909
    @Chazza1909 Месяц назад +1

    Liams voice in those rockin chair and slide away clips sounded awful. Still love LG tho

  • @gideonMorrison
    @gideonMorrison 2 месяца назад

    There is only one answer: Liam

  • @rizallagher2365
    @rizallagher2365 4 года назад

    Amazing Noel

  • @bmxaholic7600
    @bmxaholic7600 3 года назад

    Ovsly liam❤

  • @leandroale5048
    @leandroale5048 4 года назад +1

    God

  • @Ultegra10SPD
    @Ultegra10SPD 2 года назад

    Better together.

  • @chriswhyatt9679
    @chriswhyatt9679 4 года назад +3

    Noel every time

  • @dickyMuhammad23
    @dickyMuhammad23 4 года назад +1

    LG

  • @btbtm5189
    @btbtm5189 8 месяцев назад +1

    Really don’t like Noel singing the rock ones like a melt

  • @bethmyers2931
    @bethmyers2931 4 года назад +2

    Liam

  • @evaristo_1272
    @evaristo_1272 2 года назад +3

    Bottom line. Noel wrote those songs but…. He wrote them with Liam’s voice in mind.

  • @tashrif46
    @tashrif46 3 года назад +1

    Noel should have sung Slide Away. His version is masterful

  • @AUSS13KA0S
    @AUSS13KA0S 4 месяца назад

    Liam is a way bettet singer i dont understand people saying noel is better. Noel sounds too effeminate. Liam's voice strikes a perfect semblance between soul and ferocity.

  • @Elnont
    @Elnont 4 года назад +19

    All these fanboys trying to make excuses - just admit that Noel sounds better live than Liam.

    • @oliverfield877
      @oliverfield877 4 года назад +4

      All these Liam fanboys making these stupid excuses. Like Liam has more of a rock n roll voice or he’s more exciting than Noel. They all know deep down that Noel is better singer and has been for the last 20 years.

    • @Elnont
      @Elnont 4 года назад +2

      Oliver Field just say you want Liam to be your boyfriend

    • @Beamboy555
      @Beamboy555 4 года назад +6

      I disagree it’s why they were so good together. One brought hard rock charisma and energy the other brings brilliant acoustic and good vocals. They genuinely were just a btec manc John and Paul

    • @daniel_twine2816
      @daniel_twine2816 4 года назад +1

      Bean eh surely it would be Liam that brings the good vocals ya ding up until the later years haha how daft is that to say moron

    • @c.t.7652
      @c.t.7652 4 года назад +3

      @@Beamboy555 100% agree with you. But in the end it's subjective. Certain people prefer noel, & others Liam.....its not rocket science is it, not when its down to each individuals choice. 👍💥🔆

  • @123macks
    @123macks 2 года назад

    Noel’s signing as if he’s dead

  • @someonesaccountforwritingn9894
    @someonesaccountforwritingn9894 2 года назад

    i prefer noel but id much rather go to a liam gig

  • @DanielPyle
    @DanielPyle Год назад

    I know I'm in the minority, but I can't stand Liam's voice. It's so nasally and irritating. It's definitely distinctive, and I guess maybe I can understand why people are drawn to that unique sound, but I've tried so many times over the years, and his voice just grates on my nerves too much. I think Noel is a million times better.

  • @jackominty3633
    @jackominty3633 Год назад

    It's Liam. All day long.

  • @thekedellas
    @thekedellas 4 года назад +3

    No comparison. NG has talent in different areas , LG doesn’t.

  • @matthewkozlov7836
    @matthewkozlov7836 4 года назад

    Wow it's depressing how much better Noel is (Live Forever exempted)

  • @lukegreig4441
    @lukegreig4441 3 года назад +1

    Noels voice is sooooo much better let’s be honest. Liam can’t fucking sing anymore 😂

  • @LukeD-Always
    @LukeD-Always 2 месяца назад

    Both shite

  • @thekingspanttree8495
    @thekingspanttree8495 Год назад +1

    Liam's got the spirit, but his voice is fucked. Noel just sounds like he's busking Oasis tunes.