I think a person with foreign parents, who's born in the Philippines should be given a chance to apply for citizenship when they come of age. They grew up in the PI as a filipino, they know the language and our culture. Why will you deport her to a country she barely knows? Kawawa naman!
+Wanderer1616 AS FOR ME.... OO INDIAN OR IBANG LAHI NGA MGA MAGULANG NILA PERO SANA ALISIN N YONG GANYANG POLICY,,,,, DAPAT SUNDIN NILA YONG SA PANATA NG MAKA BAYAN..... SA ISIP SA SALITA AT SA GAWA... ISAMA N DIN NATIN YONG PUSO..... PANAHON N DIN PARA BAGUHIN AT PATAKARAN NG GOBYERNO....
+Wanderer1616 Hindi naman issue ang citizenship sa video. VISA or PERMANENT RESIDENCE ang hinahanap niya. Immigration gave her a choice, Philippines or India citizenship, which she indicated she have to choose Philipines where she was born, grew up and loved. Ang dapat ayusin sa Immigration law ay Permanent Resident law para sa mga nanirahan ng matagal sa Pilipinas.
GAGANG Immigration Atty. !!!, you called this woman an undesirable immigrant who was born and raised here,lol. I don't think so this person violated any immigration law ... apparently what she needs is a guidance from you which is your primary job.She needs the specific details on how to acquire a naturalization so she will become a citizen of this country. Not confusing or fear mongering advised cause this will not help.
She's a Filipino, she was born in the Philippines, she speaks so well. It's not about the race, it's about the heart that matters here. As the saying goes ...as where your heart is,,,! peace
The Philippine nationality law is based upon the principles of jus sanguinis (Latin for right of blood) and therefore descent from a parent who is a citizen or national of the Republic of the Philippines is the primary method of acquiring Philippine citizenship. This is contrasted with the legal principle of jus soli where being born on the soil of a country, even to foreign parents, grants one citizenship. For those born in the Philippines to non-Filipino parents, the Administrative Naturalization Law of 2000 (R.A. 9139) provides a path for administrative naturalization for those who qualify.
In our LAWS.. she can't be considered as a Filipino :D even though she can speak Filipino Language fluently, she grew up here or Learned the culture... nothing you can't change the fact that she is an Indian.. Unless one of her parent is a Filipino.. then she can be have a permanent residency here in the Philippines.. but her parent is actually both Indian.. so she may need to apply an Visa for staying here in the Philippines.. or be deported for overstaying..
Just like Zyrah R. there is a new law now where a foreign national who is born in the Philippines can choose his/her nationality when one turns 18 years old. The person in the video is qualified under that law and she can apply for her Filipino citizenship if she so wishes.
Pwede cyang mag-apply ng citizenship as pinoy kc legal age n cya pero malaki babayaran nya and hindi dual citizenship iyon. Pwede din mag asawa cya ng pinoy pr less gastos cya.
She loved the Philippines .she act like a Filipino .she talk like a Filipino .her birthplaces is the Philippines why she cannot be a Filipino . I think it's all about money and politics
Mel Baltazar there are filipinos here in japan who act like japanese, talk like japanese, birthplace is japan but their parents are filipino overstay.. they can never have a visa. so you are saying japan is also about money and politics considering japanese is one of the most honest people in the world? don't blame the government. don't criticized the law. ang may kasalanan dyan ung parents nila because of their ignorance of the law. papasok k s ibang bansa eh dapat alamin mo mga batas nila
Acting like a Filipino, Speak like a Filipino or Born in the Philippines is actually not a REQUIREMENTS for her to stay or be a Filipino Citizen.. our LAW cannot considered her as a Filipino because her Parents are both Indian.. unless one of her parents is a Filipino.. there she can have a permanent residency.. but not..
Gabriel Vicente dapat sisihin ang parents nia dahil d sia pinanganak sa bansa nila at d nila inalam ang batas ng pinas. Dapat Lang na maghigpit din ang pinas dahil day ibang bansa hinihigpitan din nila mga Pilipino
There should be an exception with cases like hers. She grew up here, embraced our culture and learned our language. She will be a foreigner in her parents' native land. She is more Filipino than Indian.
Nakakaiyak naman ang ganitong batas. Same kami ng story. Purong Pinoy magulang ko pero pinanganak kami sa Malaysia. 11 yrs old edad ko nag grade one noong 2001. Buti nlng mas minahal ko ang Pilipinas kaya d na ako nagnais na bumalik sa lupang sinilangan ko.
Not that we don't want to but there's no policy fit for her situation... She has to give up her birthright as an Indian or she will never be awarded a citizenship besides sya naman nagsabi na pinay na sya so go for it but suffer the consequence of paying a bond. Filipinos are not easy to get you know... Magbayad ka muna!
sfv6 alamin mo ang batas ng pinas. May choice sia bibigyan ng pinas sia ng citizenship kung surrender nia un indian citizenship nia kaso si girl ayaw nia Bitawan ang pagiging Indian nia gusto niang maging dual citizen. Kaso ang batas natin ay dapat May dugo kang Pilipino para kaw ay maging isang Pilipino unlike in the USA OR UK batas nila ay tinatawag nila na “jus soli” meaning pede kang maging citizen sa bansang yun kung doon ka pinanganak. Kasi ang pinas d nagbibigay ng dual citizenship sa mga aliens meaning with foreign parents. Pero May special circumstances nmn na pedeng ibigay as naturalize citizen kung ang mga Pilipino ay Di kayang gawin ang isang trabaho at ang foreigner Lang ang pedeng Makagawa Nito then jan pede siang maging Pilipino kahit n d pinoy ang parents
This video is referring to Permanent Residency of other national who where born in Philippines. According to her, there should be more room for individuals like her to stay permanently without announcing any citizenship. Immigration had given her a choice between Philippines and Indian citizenship, which she is not decided to choose yet.
yes,she had the choice to choose citizenship but if she chooses phil.citizenship she has to pay huge amount ( as far as i know) to become a fil.citizen.( which is unfair to her.)
I feel for her lalo nung sabihin niya "Yung bansang sinilangan ko hindi ko matatawag na bansa ko, at yung bansa ng magulang ko, bansa lang talaga ng magulang ko. So, ano ako?
Kailangan pa bang patunayan na pinoy cya? Dito na cya pinanganak at dito na rin cya lumaki, exception ang mga cases na ganito so for me automatic na bigyan sila ng pinoy citizenship. Ganon din sa mga ibang pinoy na doon pinanganak sa ibang bansa!
Jus loci po sa US, jus sanguinis po sa Pinas. Ayaw niya po igive up pagka-Bumbay niya so dapat siya ipadeport. Madami pong Indian Malaysians who embraced being Malaysians. So kung ayaw niya itakwil pagiging Bumbay, then she should go back to India.
mel saint, tama! Jus Soli sa USA, Jus Sanguinis naman sa Pilipinas. Isa itong priviligeo, hindi "rights". Kaya kung 'yong ina mo ay Filipino citizen, pero doon ka ipinanganak sa USA, magiging dual citizen ka. Pag dating mo ng age of majority, ipa decide ka na kung anong gusto mo maging...Filipino o Amerikano?
Bilib ako,sa KABULUKAN ng sestema sa Pinas,talagang BULOK,kami ay ipinanganak sa Pilipinas,at lumaki doon,ang Nanay namin ay ipinanganak dito sa Hawaii,ang Tatay namin ay ipinanganak,lumaki sa Pinas,at doon nga(Pinas)sila ikinasal,at kami nga,dahil nais namin na pumunta dito sa Hawaii,dala namin ang Family picture,birth certificate,school diploma at birth certificate ng Nanay namin,tuloy kami sa US Embassy,nagbayad kami ng 1,200,00 Pesos,binigyan kami ng US passport at nakalagay doon na kami ay US citizen since birth,tapos,narito na kami sa Hawaii,at may trabaho ako sa US Military Base.dito ,imigrante ka,pagkalipas ng limang taon,at nais mong mag-apply ng US citizenship puede,nakapasa ka sa interview,ilang araw lang makukuha mo na yong certificate of naturalization at puede ka ng kumuha ng US passport, na kabaligtaran diyan sa Pinas,nakakalungkot.
"Yung bansa na sinilangan ko hindi ko matatawag na bansa ko at yung bansa ng mga magulang bansa lang talaga ng magulang ko, so ano ako?" Ang sakit nun sa parte nya kasi pakiramdam nya sa sariling bansa nya wala syang lugar. Alam kong may batas pero napakaluma na at hindi makatao kasi kahit saan ko tingnan Filipino sya. Oo mukha syang Indian at Indian mga magulang nya pero nabuhay syang Pinoy. Samantalang yung mga "Pinoy" daw na buong buhay nila sa ibang bansa sila lumaki mas may karapatan na manatili dito kesa sa kanya? Na yung iba di nga marunong magsalita ng Filipino. Napaka-unfair ng batas sa kanya. Hindi to makatao sa totoo lang, paalisin ka sa bansang sinilangan mo na buong buhay mo yung lang ang bansa na kinikilala mo.
There is a new law now that if you are the sons or daughters of a foreign national but you were born in the Philippines and has been living in the Philippines ever since, you have the chance to choose your nationality and can apply for a Filipino citizenship when you turn 18 years old.. This is similar to germany's law that deal with this similar issue. The person in the video is qualified and can apply for Filipino citizenship.
As a filipino thats unfair,,yung mga sumisikat n mga half pinoy n sinasakyan nang ksikatan kahit hindi nmn dinadala ang glag ng pinas hinhabol nyo samantalang ang mga ganito kaso pinagdadamutan nyo sana baguhin n ang ganito sistema
we have antiquated laws...that should be looked upon & reviewed by our legislators & lawmakers!!...hindi puro senate & congressional hearings in aid of grandstanding in front of media people & the public!!
i think government should change the policy - if someone was born here and/or lived here until she reached 18, he/she should be a Filipino Citizen, wherever his/her parents came from, or what ethnicity they are. His or her parents can be Filipinos too through the naturalization process. It's just unfair for that girl, Koreans can live here but she cannot even though she was born here?? that's totally unfair.
The Happy Weird Boy 1987 Philippine Constitution is not fucked up... the kids are fucked up because of their parents ignorance of the the law. these kids also have options. when they reach their age, they have to choose which citizenship. nobody or no one can have 2 citizenship for the rest of their lives. for example here in japan, a child was born and , raised in japan but the child's visa depends on his/her parents visa. once his/her parents visa expired regardless he/she lived here in japan for 30 yrs., he/she only have ONE OPTION BUT TO GO HOME with his/her parents. now tell me, is the Japanese Constitution is fucked up? It's easy to say than done.
Gavin Abellera We are a multicultural country. Japan isn't. Why would the Philippine Constitution deprive people of other ethnicities or people without any filipino blood to live hereas a Filipino? If they were born here, they should consider them as Filipinos. We should stop thinking that only people with Filipino blood can be Filipinos. NO. We are a multicultural country and everyone is welcome. If a foreign person was born here and if she chose to stay here, she should be a Filipino.
The Happy Weird Boy lau ng sagot mo. nililigaw mo usapin. walang problema ang konstitusyon ntin.. like what i've said, meron xa option. renounce her indian nationality and apply for filipino citizenship. hindi pede ang gusto nia mangyari... ang gus2 kc nia mangyari INDIAN NATIONALITY XA tapos legal xa maninirahan dito. ano ibig sabihin nun? makakalibre xa ng bayad kc hindi xa maooverstay.. i told u meron dahilan mga magulang nia kung bakit sinanay siya s pinas. kung ano ang dahilan di ko sasabihin sau... pala isipan sau yan.. cguru di k p nag aabroad kya di mo p alam ang mga descarte pra makapanirahan ng legal s isang bansa.. the girl is confused just like you. malinaw sa batas n pagdating ng tamang edad mamimili xa kung ano ang nationality nia... di pede sabihin pinoy/pinay peo ayaw bitiwan ang indian nationality. cno niloloko ng batang e2.? e di sarili nia at mga taong naniniwala s kanya. narinig mo n b ung mga buntis n mexicana na nagpipilit o gumagawa ng ibang descarte para maka tawid ng US boarder? or sumasakay ng eroplano ng US pra pagnanganak cla s US soil or US teritory e automatic US citizen mga anak nila. so pati magulang magkakaroon ng papel s US? ganun ang gus2 mangyari ng batang e2. ano pangunahing bisnes ng mga bumbay? 5/6 di b? untaxable un marami p sana aq ikukwento sau tungkol s mga ganyang descarte pra nmn meron k alam.. at di ka maligaw o maguluhan gaya ngbatang e2
it is unfair to deport her. she lives in PI all her life. she knows more about PI than India. There are so many babies born in PI that are not even registered. She is registered as born from Indian parents on Pi soil. She have done nothing wrong to anyone. she is not a criminal. I DO NOT APPRECIATE THE PINAY STATING "SHE IS UNDESIRABLE"... YOU ARE ARROGANT!!! GIVE HER CITIZENSHIP!!!!! SHE DESERVE IT!!!!
In United States, if your parents are Filipino and you are born in the united state, you are American citizen. So she was born in the Philippines, isn't it she should be a.pilipino citizen?
A person born in the Philippines by birth right has to be able to elect or decide whether he/she wants to be a citizen of the country or not., otherwise be given a permanent status outright. One can not be left alone stateless if he/she did not take the parents citizenship.
Why pick on her when there's a thousand of illegal overstaying chinese doing illegal acts here.Why dont the govt do something about it first cause the chinese are a security and economic threat that this poor girl..If this girl needs me i'm available...
alveri717 Yan Kasi Ang kabuhayan nila Kaya nagpakahirap sila mag aral at makapasok SA gobyerno dahil pangarap nilang maging professional corruptor 😂 ayun natupad Naman Kaya Isa na sila SA mga ANAY ng gobyerno
Sabi nga ni Manuel Quezon, "mas pipiliin ko pa ang mala impiernong Pilipinas kesa sa mala langit na Pilipinas sa ilalim ng mga dayuhan." Ayan, ano nangyari? Naging impierno nga.
bulok talaga siste dto sa pinas..laki tlaga ng respeto ko sa mga dayuhang gustong maging pilipino..kahit sa totoo lng hirap talaga tayo dto eh..gusto pa rin nilang maging pilipino..ang di ko lng maintindihan pag may pera ang mga dayuhan o d kaya gaya sa mga sports kung gawin lng na import eh madali lng maging filipino citizen..samantalang silang mga may dugong dayuhan dto na lumaki at nag aral ang iba pa ngay dto ipinanganak d pa dn makakuha ng citizenship..malaki din nman ang maiiaambag nila sa pilipinas..kay sana baguhin na natin ang sistema dto
Letse! Kung americano lang yan na ipinanganak dito kung ipagduldulan ng Pinas yung passport ganun na lang. Para maging Pinoy yung kano na yun. Kapag ibang tao, hindi pwede. Dito na nga ipinanganak yung tao, dito lumaki, dito nag-aral, dito na rin magtatrabaho, hindi pa rin pwede.
ok palit tayu ng constitution ngyn 2015 kc reason mo anachronism...baka di mo alam ibig sabihin ng anachronism means it doesn't fit the time or 1840's ay di na applicable for 2015. lumipas ang 1 taon ang daming nangyari.. so reason ulit ntin 2015 is not applicable to 2016 palitan ntin ulit constitution... deym! kala mo cguru ganun lng kadali magpapalit ng konstitusyon. abay tatawanan n tayu ng ibang bansa nyan palit tayu ng palit ng konstitution...
***** parang s pera ntin...di k b nalilito nayun? kc ang dalas magpalit ng disenyo ng pera natin...pano na kaya kung palit tayo ng palit ng konstitusyon??? konting aral nmn ...jusko. meron nmn cla option. renounce their indian nationality apply for philippine citizenship as simple as that. but nobody or no one in any country one can have dual citizenship for the rest of their lives. they have to choose and decide. maluwag p nga s PINAS s ibang bansa deport n yan.
dj sam chivaker renounced his indian nationality and applied for filipino citizenship and his application was granted. un ung option n sinasabi ko. nsa puso tlga ni dj sam chivaker n pinoy xa hindi salita lng gaya ng batang eto...
I feel for her because I'm in the same situation. I was born in Manila with both parents foreign citizen. The Philippine government should change the OLD LAW with regards to permanent residence and citizenship. For we want to contribute our talent, resources and skills to our motherland. Not the distant land of our forefathers which we don't have much knowledge or any patriotic sentiments. By not acting quickly on this matter, Philippines will continue to loose bright talented people that can create jobs, commerce and much needed taxes to other countries which welcomes them with both open arms. I have left Manila for this main reason. And now lives in England running our Hotel and real Estate and pay taxes to UK. Uk - Winner - Philippine - Loser. Moral lesson, If you can't change them - " LEAVE THEM "
We don't need to argue mga kabayan kong mahal sundin natin ang law as totoo lang po Oo na sa pinas siya naregla o nagkabolbol for what i have read indian pa rin siya cos of her parents blood. sa America sila hindi basta makapasok. kaya viva filipinos world class talaga ang pinoy. ..👑🗼🏬
Law is law...akala nyo ba ang mga Pilipino abroad basta basta lang makukuha ang mga ganyan. Dami din kaya pinapauwi pabalik sa atin dahil sa mga ganyang problema. wala kang magagawa kong yan ang patakaran. Dapat ang mga banyaga sa atin sumunod din kong anong patakaran meron tayo kasi ganyan din ang mga ginagawa ng mga Pilipino sa abroad. Problema na nya yon ayaw nman nyang mgpanaturalize...may way nman ayaw nman nya!
Napapauwi lang ang isang immigrante kung may matindi siyang ginagawa na violation sa immigration law. Isa sa mga dahilan napapauwi ang isang immigrante or deportation. Maraming dahilan ang deportation kahit may legal papers ka pa. Since hindi ka naman citizen, pwede ka pa ring masipa ng mismong immigration. Ang batas ang batas it doesn't only intent sa Filipino pero sa lahat na dayuhan o immigrante.
True... Ayaw nya bitawan pagiging Indian nya e... Gusto pa nya baguhin ang batas ng Pilipinas... lol Kala mo napaka high profile para pinas pa mag adjust sa kanya
naKakalungkot kc paripariho nmn tayo nilalang ng Diyos, pero ung batas na napaka unfair Para sa mga katulad nya, sna mabigyan sya ng pagkakataon, Isa pa d2 na sya pinanganak at lumaki.
Government should let her to be a a citizen. She was born there. What kind of people who will deport someone back to her parent's origin country and she was not born in that country. It should be automatic if a foreigner born in the philippines, they should allow that person to choose their citizenship when they turn 18 or 21 years old.
@@alfredhitchcock45 oh talaga mas masahol pa pinoy sa indian eh lalo na pag naningil na haha. Pag utang bait pag singil galit haha tandaan mo ung salitang yan.
I sincerely feel all your comments and views on this matter. Although, there was a time in my life where I was proud to be a Filipino. Sadly enough, I do not share the same feelings anymore. I am not surprised, nor am I affected by what's going on in the Philippines. And by saying that, doesn't mean i'm insensitive to other peoples fortunes. My point is, the Philippines is spiraling in a downward direction. And it seems that nobody cares. We, or should I say, they need a MAJOR CHANGE in every aspect. They have laws that were implemented during the beginning of time. Wake up everybody! Times change, people change, Their laws need to be re-thought, re-adjusted and re-written, So as to conform to our ever changing society. Even this issue of Citizenship....geez! Give her the citizenship she very well deserves. Mas Filipino pa sya kesa mga ibang politicians na........alam nyo na! And to the girl that wants to become a citizen of the Philippines, I hope you get what you want. And if for any reason they deny you? There are a lot more way better countries. I just feel for you, knowing that you don't have that sense of belonging to "somewhere". Goodluck sa iyo..
i dont think you really understand...she can chose to have or be a naturalized filipino citizen..but she has to cancel her indian citizenship..as we do not grant dual citizenship to a foreigner...now on view on this is this law aims to protect filipino citizens from being over run by foreigners as we know even thou philippines is third world as some people say but still lots and lots of foreign nationals want to settle down here..and we are not the only one who has that kind of law..even those rich country who their citizens do not have to compete that much for better opportunity they still impose those kind of law..what more is the philippines..kung sa ngayon na ganun ang batas natin klangan pa nating makipagcompete para makakuha ng mas magandang trabaho what more kung pati sa mga dayuhan magiging kasali natin sila sa competisyon.....but if she really wants to be a filipino citizen she has to surrender her indian passport..
joey4onda she had an option but the problem is she doesn't want to give up her indian citizenship and she doesn't want to spend money. she's lucky because she still have an option unlike here in japan eventhough u gave up ur filipino citizenship u will never get japanese citizenship
Mabuti pa mga Foreigner nagtatagalog. Lahat ng announcer magtagalog kayo. Maraming Pilipino sa Pilipinas at Amerika di nakakaintindi ng English. Importante communications.
Sana yung mga ganito kaso na dito na lumaki at pinanganak sana bigyan ng pagkakataon manirahan dito sa pinas baguhin sana ang batasbpatungol sa mga immigrants
I think a person with foreign parents, who's born in the Philippines should be given a chance to apply for citizenship when they come of age. They grew up in the PI as a filipino, they know the language and our culture. Why will you deport her to a country she barely knows? Kawawa naman!
+Wanderer1616 AS FOR ME.... OO INDIAN OR IBANG LAHI NGA MGA MAGULANG NILA PERO SANA ALISIN N YONG GANYANG POLICY,,,,, DAPAT SUNDIN NILA YONG SA PANATA NG MAKA BAYAN..... SA ISIP SA SALITA AT SA GAWA... ISAMA N DIN NATIN YONG PUSO..... PANAHON N DIN PARA BAGUHIN AT PATAKARAN NG GOBYERNO....
your right,....
+Wanderer1616 Hindi naman issue ang citizenship sa video. VISA or PERMANENT RESIDENCE ang hinahanap niya. Immigration gave her a choice, Philippines or India citizenship, which she indicated she have to choose Philipines where she was born, grew up and loved. Ang dapat ayusin sa Immigration law ay Permanent Resident law para sa mga nanirahan ng matagal sa Pilipinas.
TravelGnome agree
But LAW forbids her to stay.. we can't do nothing.. we have to obey to our constitution..
let's support jasmine
rogelio lenmark pascua kawawa naman sya anuh oo nga anu sya wala syang matawag na bansa nya..
She pilipino she born in philippine. Indian is better than china lol
I love Indians, They respect filipinos more.
wag mawawalan ng pag asa Jasmine one day your wish is granted
GAGANG Immigration Atty. !!!, you called this woman an undesirable immigrant who was born and raised here,lol. I don't think so this person violated any immigration law ... apparently what she needs is a guidance from you which is your primary job.She needs the specific details on how to acquire a naturalization so she will become a citizen of this country. Not confusing or fear mongering advised cause this will not help.
Undesirable Filipino Kasi un nagsabi Kaya naghahanap ng kadamay 😂😂😂
@Lash Coh thanks but NO THANKS TO NINOY; na SALOT!
She's a Filipino, she was born in the Philippines, she speaks so well. It's not about the race, it's about the heart that matters here. As the saying goes ...as where your heart is,,,! peace
The Philippine nationality law is based upon the principles of jus sanguinis (Latin for right of blood) and therefore descent from a parent who is a citizen or national of the Republic of the Philippines is the primary method of acquiring Philippine citizenship. This is contrasted with the legal principle of jus soli where being born on the soil of a country, even to foreign parents,
grants one citizenship. For those born in the Philippines to
non-Filipino parents, the Administrative Naturalization Law of 2000
(R.A. 9139) provides a path for administrative naturalization for those
who qualify.
In our LAWS.. she can't be considered as a Filipino :D even though she can speak Filipino Language fluently, she grew up here or Learned the culture... nothing you can't change the fact that she is an Indian.. Unless one of her parent is a Filipino.. then she can be have a permanent residency here in the Philippines.. but her parent is actually both Indian.. so she may need to apply an Visa for staying here in the Philippines.. or be deported for overstaying..
Just like Zyrah R. there is a new law now where a foreign national who is born in the Philippines can choose his/her nationality when one turns 18 years old. The person in the video is qualified under that law and she can apply for her Filipino citizenship if she so wishes.
Ayaw niya kasi bitawan yun pagiging indian national pwde na daw based sa video para maging filipino na sya
Pwede cyang mag-apply ng citizenship as pinoy kc legal age n cya pero malaki babayaran nya and hindi dual citizenship iyon. Pwede din mag asawa cya ng pinoy pr less gastos cya.
She loved the Philippines .she act like a Filipino .she talk like a Filipino .her birthplaces is the Philippines why she cannot be a Filipino . I think it's all about money and politics
Mel Baltazar there are filipinos here in japan who act like japanese, talk like japanese, birthplace is japan but their parents are filipino overstay.. they can never have a visa. so you are saying japan is also about money and politics considering japanese is one of the most honest people in the world?
don't blame the government. don't criticized the law. ang may kasalanan dyan ung parents nila because of their ignorance of the law. papasok k s ibang bansa eh dapat alamin mo mga batas nila
Acting like a Filipino, Speak like a Filipino or Born in the Philippines is actually not a REQUIREMENTS for her to stay or be a Filipino Citizen.. our LAW cannot considered her as a Filipino because her Parents are both Indian.. unless one of her parents is a Filipino.. there she can have a permanent residency.. but not..
Gavin Abellera kilala mo ba si blatche? kahit hilaw pa sa pilipinas eh nauna pang maging pilipino kisa sa kanila
You are correct Mel. It's about money and greed of political people, looking to put more money in their pocket.
Gabriel Vicente dapat sisihin ang parents nia dahil d sia pinanganak sa bansa nila at d nila inalam ang batas ng pinas. Dapat Lang na maghigpit din ang pinas dahil day ibang bansa hinihigpitan din nila mga Pilipino
Nalulungkot ako for her. She is more Filipino than anyone else. Ang galing niyang managalog🙈
There should be an exception with cases like hers. She grew up here, embraced our culture and learned our language. She will be a foreigner in her parents' native land. She is more Filipino than Indian.
Naku naman...kalungkot naman
Sa Pinas siya pinanganak at marunong siya ng wika natin, Filipina iyan.
Marlon Elias jus soli yang batas mo at FYI Di yan ang batas ng pinas dapat May Filipino blood ka
Sana mabigyan ka ng permanent Visa. Ang galing mo ng magtagalog super galing. God bless you all miss pretty.
Nakakaiyak naman ang ganitong batas. Same kami ng story. Purong Pinoy magulang ko pero pinanganak kami sa Malaysia. 11 yrs old edad ko nag grade one noong 2001. Buti nlng mas minahal ko ang Pilipinas kaya d na ako nagnais na bumalik sa lupang sinilangan ko.
Nakakaiyak naman ahai Diyos ko
Ganoon din ang nangyayari sa mga Pilipino na sa ibang bansa. Same experience .
Im so sad, ipinanganak s pilipinas. Bakit pinahihirapan nyo mga bata..bigyan nyo na karapatan n maging filipino..
We want to be fairly treated in other countries but we cant even accommodate her with one stinking visa?
Totally agree...
Not that we don't want to but there's no policy fit for her situation... She has to give up her birthright as an Indian or
she will never be awarded a citizenship besides sya naman nagsabi na pinay na sya so go for it but suffer the consequence of paying a bond. Filipinos are not easy to get you know... Magbayad ka muna!
sfv6 alamin mo ang batas ng pinas. May choice sia bibigyan ng pinas sia ng citizenship kung surrender nia un indian citizenship nia kaso si girl ayaw nia Bitawan ang pagiging Indian nia gusto niang maging dual citizen. Kaso ang batas natin ay dapat May dugo kang Pilipino para kaw ay maging isang Pilipino unlike in the USA OR UK batas nila ay tinatawag nila na “jus soli” meaning pede kang maging citizen sa bansang yun kung doon ka pinanganak. Kasi ang pinas d nagbibigay ng dual citizenship sa mga aliens meaning with foreign parents. Pero May special circumstances nmn na pedeng ibigay as naturalize citizen kung ang mga Pilipino ay Di kayang gawin ang isang trabaho at ang foreigner Lang ang pedeng Makagawa Nito then jan pede siang maging Pilipino kahit n d pinoy ang parents
@Ryan Lajara Pare, sorry for the delayed response, sorry but i traveled around Canada, Spain, US and proudly say that i still have my Phil Passport.
Kawawa naman sya! Pinoy na pinoy naman talaga ang puso niya kahit ang dugo niya ay pure Indian. Sana ma tupad ang wish mo girl someday.
This video is referring to Permanent Residency of other national who where born in Philippines. According to her, there should be more room for individuals like her to stay permanently without announcing any citizenship. Immigration had given her a choice between Philippines and Indian citizenship, which she is not decided to choose yet.
yes,she had the choice to choose citizenship but if she chooses phil.citizenship she has to pay huge amount ( as far as i know) to become a fil.citizen.( which is unfair to her.)
I feel for her lalo nung sabihin niya "Yung bansang sinilangan ko hindi ko matatawag na bansa ko, at yung bansa ng magulang ko,
bansa lang talaga ng magulang ko. So, ano ako?
Kailangan pa bang patunayan na pinoy cya? Dito na cya pinanganak at dito na rin cya lumaki, exception ang mga cases na ganito so for me automatic na bigyan sila ng pinoy citizenship. Ganon din sa mga ibang pinoy na doon pinanganak sa ibang bansa!
@Ryan Lajara if you're born in the US you're automatic US citizen.
Pwede sila maging pinoy basta itatakwil nya ang kanyang indian citizenship un ang paliwanag
Jus loci po sa US, jus sanguinis po sa Pinas. Ayaw niya po igive up pagka-Bumbay niya so dapat siya ipadeport. Madami pong Indian Malaysians who embraced being Malaysians. So kung ayaw niya itakwil pagiging Bumbay, then she should go back to India.
@@alfredhitchcock45 tama po
mel saint, tama! Jus Soli sa USA, Jus Sanguinis naman sa Pilipinas. Isa itong priviligeo, hindi "rights". Kaya kung 'yong ina mo ay Filipino citizen, pero doon ka ipinanganak sa USA, magiging dual citizen ka. Pag dating mo ng age of majority, ipa decide ka na kung anong gusto mo maging...Filipino o Amerikano?
I AGREE WITH HER,, SANA NAMAN PAKINGGAN DIN,,
Nakakaawa naman toh. Ano na kaya nangyari dto?
Nakipagasawa sa pinoy un pilipina na xa citizen na xa
Nakakalungkot naman
Bilib ako,sa KABULUKAN ng sestema sa Pinas,talagang BULOK,kami ay ipinanganak sa Pilipinas,at lumaki doon,ang Nanay namin ay ipinanganak dito sa Hawaii,ang Tatay namin ay ipinanganak,lumaki sa Pinas,at doon nga(Pinas)sila ikinasal,at kami nga,dahil nais namin na pumunta dito sa Hawaii,dala namin ang Family picture,birth certificate,school diploma at birth certificate ng Nanay namin,tuloy kami sa US Embassy,nagbayad kami ng 1,200,00 Pesos,binigyan kami ng US passport at nakalagay doon na kami ay US citizen since birth,tapos,narito na kami sa Hawaii,at may trabaho ako sa US Military Base.dito ,imigrante ka,pagkalipas ng limang taon,at nais mong mag-apply ng US citizenship puede,nakapasa ka sa interview,ilang araw lang makukuha mo na yong certificate of naturalization at puede ka ng kumuha ng US passport, na kabaligtaran diyan sa Pinas,nakakalungkot.
"Yung bansa na sinilangan ko hindi ko matatawag na bansa ko at yung bansa ng mga magulang bansa lang talaga ng magulang ko, so ano ako?" Ang sakit nun sa parte nya kasi pakiramdam nya sa sariling bansa nya wala syang lugar. Alam kong may batas pero napakaluma na at hindi makatao kasi kahit saan ko tingnan Filipino sya. Oo mukha syang Indian at Indian mga magulang nya pero nabuhay syang Pinoy. Samantalang yung mga "Pinoy" daw na buong buhay nila sa ibang bansa sila lumaki mas may karapatan na manatili dito kesa sa kanya? Na yung iba di nga marunong magsalita ng Filipino. Napaka-unfair ng batas sa kanya. Hindi to makatao sa totoo lang, paalisin ka sa bansang sinilangan mo na buong buhay mo yung lang ang bansa na kinikilala mo.
There is a new law now that if you are the sons or daughters of a foreign national but you were born in the Philippines and has been living in the Philippines ever since, you have the chance to choose your nationality and can apply for a Filipino citizenship when you turn 18 years old.. This is similar to germany's law that deal with this similar issue. The person in the video is qualified and can apply for Filipino citizenship.
dapat na ma-amyendahan ang batas sa isyu na ito para magkaroon ng pagkakataon ang mga katulad nya na maging isang Pilipino.
As a filipino thats unfair,,yung mga sumisikat n mga half pinoy n sinasakyan nang ksikatan kahit hindi nmn dinadala ang glag ng pinas hinhabol nyo samantalang ang mga ganito kaso pinagdadamutan nyo sana baguhin n ang ganito sistema
Hope mapag isipan dn ng government natin bigyan ng change ang mga foreigner na gusto maging legal citizen.
follow up report please!
Hello Jazmine. Naayos mo na ito di ba? God bless you and your family.
so sad for that
kawawa naman,choose philippines nlng
tama yan ksi kahit sa ibang bansa mas mahirap pa nga maka kuha ng visa
Anu na kya update dito sana nman my magawang solusyon sa issue na to
Kawawa nman 😊
Kawawa nmn dapat automatic n silang pilipino dito pla ipinanganak e maiksi lng ang buhay pti b nmn un ginagawa p nlng komplikado
so difficult situation and confusing, it's sad
we have antiquated laws...that should be looked upon & reviewed by our legislators & lawmakers!!...hindi puro senate & congressional hearings in aid of grandstanding in front of media people & the public!!
Unfair nga nmn,bakit p Hindi pwede?dapat pwede nang maging pilipino yn
Grace poe paging
Same here sa malaysia,marami pinoy na same case nya
i think government should change the policy - if someone was born here and/or lived here until she reached 18, he/she should be a Filipino Citizen, wherever his/her parents came from, or what ethnicity they are. His or her parents can be Filipinos too through the naturalization process. It's just unfair for that girl, Koreans can live here but she cannot even though she was born here?? that's totally unfair.
The Happy Weird Boy it seems that u don't understand that philippines is a soveriegn country and it has its LAW and everybody should follow.
Gavin Abellera I know, and thats why they should change it. Besides the 1987 constitution is fucked up so its really necessary for them to change it.
The Happy Weird Boy 1987 Philippine Constitution is not fucked up... the kids are fucked up because of their parents ignorance of the the law. these kids also have options. when they reach their age, they have to choose which citizenship. nobody or no one can have 2 citizenship for the rest of their lives.
for example here in japan, a child was born and , raised in japan but the child's visa depends on his/her parents visa. once his/her parents visa expired regardless he/she lived here in japan for 30 yrs., he/she only have ONE OPTION BUT TO GO HOME with his/her parents. now tell me, is the Japanese Constitution is fucked up?
It's easy to say than done.
Gavin Abellera We are a multicultural country. Japan isn't. Why would the Philippine Constitution deprive people of other ethnicities or people without any filipino blood to live hereas a Filipino? If they were born here, they should consider them as Filipinos. We should stop thinking that only people with Filipino blood can be Filipinos. NO. We are a multicultural country and everyone is welcome. If a foreign person was born here and if she chose to stay here, she should be a Filipino.
The Happy Weird Boy lau ng sagot mo. nililigaw mo usapin. walang problema ang konstitusyon ntin.. like what i've said, meron xa option. renounce her indian nationality and apply for filipino citizenship. hindi pede ang gusto nia mangyari... ang gus2 kc nia mangyari INDIAN NATIONALITY XA tapos legal xa maninirahan dito. ano ibig sabihin nun? makakalibre xa ng bayad kc hindi xa maooverstay.. i told u meron dahilan mga magulang nia kung bakit sinanay siya s pinas. kung ano ang dahilan di ko sasabihin sau... pala isipan sau yan.. cguru di k p nag aabroad kya di mo p alam ang mga descarte pra makapanirahan ng legal s isang bansa..
the girl is confused just like you. malinaw sa batas n pagdating ng tamang edad mamimili xa kung ano ang nationality nia... di pede sabihin pinoy/pinay peo ayaw bitiwan ang indian nationality. cno niloloko ng batang e2.? e di sarili nia at mga taong naniniwala s kanya.
narinig mo n b ung mga buntis n mexicana na nagpipilit o gumagawa ng ibang descarte para maka tawid ng US boarder? or sumasakay ng eroplano ng US pra pagnanganak cla s US soil or US teritory e automatic US citizen mga anak nila. so pati magulang magkakaroon ng papel s US? ganun ang gus2 mangyari ng batang e2. ano pangunahing bisnes ng mga bumbay? 5/6 di b? untaxable un
marami p sana aq ikukwento sau tungkol s mga ganyang descarte pra nmn meron k alam.. at di ka maligaw o maguluhan gaya ngbatang e2
pumikit ka lng tapos pakinggan mo mag salita, pinoy na yan sakin.
God bless ate..para samin pinay ka at karapatan mong tumira dito..
it is unfair to deport her. she lives in PI all her life. she knows more about PI than India. There are so many babies born in PI that are not even registered. She is registered as born from Indian parents on Pi soil. She have done nothing wrong to anyone. she is not a criminal. I DO NOT APPRECIATE THE PINAY STATING "SHE IS UNDESIRABLE"... YOU ARE ARROGANT!!! GIVE HER CITIZENSHIP!!!!! SHE DESERVE IT!!!!
ano na kaya ang story nito ngayon . (December 2023)
In United States, if your parents are Filipino and you are born in the united state, you are American citizen. So she was born in the Philippines, isn't it she should be a.pilipino citizen?
No. The Philippines does not confer citizenship by Jus Soli, but by Jus Sanguinis
Dapat pag ganyan gawin ng Filipino citizen
You can make it don't be afraid
Kawawa nmn dito pinangak eh...papa deport...dapat ang batas marunong din tumingin sa sitwasyon at commonsense
Just saw her IG, she was awarded Naturalization last June 2016.
Ano IG nya?
I admire her she deserve to be a filipino citizenship even her parents both indian because she born and live in out country which is the Philippines.
A person born in the Philippines by birth right has to be able to elect or decide whether he/she wants to be a citizen of the country or not., otherwise be given a permanent status outright. One can not be left alone stateless if he/she did not take the parents citizenship.
Luv u Jasmine.
She needs to have a chance for her citizenship
Wala n lupa ang tunay n pinoy
Kun ganun, dapat ireview ni Sec. Cayetano ang batas tungkol dito at mabigyan naman sila ng chance to be a Filipino!
Why pick on her when there's a thousand of illegal overstaying chinese doing illegal acts here.Why dont the govt do something about it first cause the chinese are a security and economic threat that this poor girl..If this girl needs me i'm available...
alveri717 Yan Kasi Ang kabuhayan nila Kaya nagpakahirap sila mag aral at makapasok SA gobyerno dahil pangarap nilang maging professional corruptor 😂 ayun natupad Naman Kaya Isa na sila SA mga ANAY ng gobyerno
Sabi nga ni Manuel Quezon, "mas pipiliin ko pa ang mala impiernong Pilipinas kesa sa mala langit na Pilipinas sa ilalim ng mga dayuhan."
Ayan, ano nangyari? Naging impierno nga.
Yan ang bayani na hindi nag iisip ng mga salitang binibitiwan
Sana naghangad na lang sya ng mas ikakabuti natin kesa sa ikakasama natin
Don't deport her guys. have mercy..
bulok talaga siste dto sa pinas..laki tlaga ng respeto ko sa mga dayuhang gustong maging pilipino..kahit sa totoo lng hirap talaga tayo dto eh..gusto pa rin nilang maging pilipino..ang di ko lng maintindihan pag may pera ang mga dayuhan o d kaya gaya sa mga sports kung gawin lng na import eh madali lng maging filipino citizen..samantalang silang mga may dugong dayuhan dto na lumaki at nag aral ang iba pa ngay dto ipinanganak d pa dn makakuha ng citizenship..malaki din nman ang maiiaambag nila sa pilipinas..kay sana baguhin na natin ang sistema dto
Letse! Kung americano lang yan na ipinanganak dito kung ipagduldulan ng Pinas yung passport ganun na lang. Para maging Pinoy yung kano na yun. Kapag ibang tao, hindi pwede. Dito na nga ipinanganak yung tao, dito lumaki, dito nag-aral, dito na rin magtatrabaho, hindi pa rin pwede.
Yuki T. law is law. ignorance of the law excuses no one. dapat dinala ng magulang nila s bansa nila ung mga bata.
ok palit tayu ng constitution ngyn 2015 kc reason mo anachronism...baka di mo alam ibig sabihin ng anachronism means it doesn't fit the time or 1840's ay di na applicable for 2015. lumipas ang 1 taon ang daming nangyari.. so reason ulit ntin 2015 is not applicable to 2016 palitan ntin ulit constitution... deym! kala mo cguru ganun lng kadali magpapalit ng konstitusyon. abay tatawanan n tayu ng ibang bansa nyan palit tayu ng palit ng konstitution...
***** parang s pera ntin...di k b nalilito nayun? kc ang dalas magpalit ng disenyo ng pera natin...pano na kaya kung palit tayo ng palit ng konstitusyon??? konting aral nmn ...jusko. meron nmn cla option. renounce their indian nationality apply for philippine citizenship as simple as that. but nobody or no one in any country one can have dual citizenship for the rest of their lives. they have to choose and decide. maluwag p nga s PINAS s ibang bansa deport n yan.
***** magisip-isip k rin. di mo b naisip n posibleng sadyang sinanay ng mga magulang nila cla s pinas? kung ano ang dahilan di ko alam.
dj sam chivaker renounced his indian nationality and applied for filipino citizenship and his application was granted. un ung option n sinasabi ko. nsa puso tlga ni dj sam chivaker n pinoy xa hindi salita lng gaya ng batang eto...
Sayang. . Ang ganda pa nmn. . Lahian na yan 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Kawawa nman
I feel for her because I'm in the same situation. I was born in Manila with both parents foreign citizen. The Philippine government should change the OLD LAW with regards to permanent residence and citizenship. For we want to contribute our talent, resources and skills to our motherland. Not the distant land of our forefathers which we don't have much knowledge or any patriotic sentiments.
By not acting quickly on this matter, Philippines will continue to loose bright talented people that can create jobs, commerce and much needed taxes to other countries which welcomes them with both open arms. I have left Manila for this main reason. And now lives in England running our Hotel and real Estate and pay taxes to UK.
Uk - Winner - Philippine - Loser.
Moral lesson, If you can't change them - " LEAVE THEM "
We don't need to argue mga kabayan kong mahal sundin natin ang law as totoo lang po Oo na sa pinas siya naregla o nagkabolbol for what i have read indian pa rin siya cos of her parents blood. sa America sila hindi basta makapasok. kaya viva filipinos world class talaga ang pinoy. ..👑🗼🏬
william Lao
dapat na bigyan pansin ang usaping ito ng mga mambabatas para na rin sa ikapapanatag ng loob ng mga banyagang dito na nga ipinanganak at lumaki.
may exception dapat ang mag to
Bakit ganyan katagal Naman makakuha ng permanent Visa Pilipinas nga ipinanganak
200k?! Anu yan. Mas mahal pa kesa sa pag pa us citizen.
Well,
sad:(
pareho din dito sa malaysia pag parehong foreigner ang magulang di nagiging citizen dito except na lang kung may permanent residence ang 1 sa magulang
Law is law...akala nyo ba ang mga Pilipino abroad basta basta lang makukuha ang mga ganyan. Dami din kaya pinapauwi pabalik sa atin dahil sa mga ganyang problema. wala kang magagawa kong yan ang patakaran. Dapat ang mga banyaga sa atin sumunod din kong anong patakaran meron tayo kasi ganyan din ang mga ginagawa ng mga Pilipino sa abroad. Problema na nya yon ayaw nman nyang mgpanaturalize...may way nman ayaw nman nya!
Napapauwi lang ang isang immigrante kung may matindi siyang ginagawa na violation sa immigration law. Isa sa mga dahilan napapauwi ang isang immigrante or deportation. Maraming dahilan ang deportation kahit may legal papers ka pa. Since hindi ka naman citizen, pwede ka pa ring masipa ng mismong immigration. Ang batas ang batas it doesn't only intent sa Filipino pero sa lahat na dayuhan o immigrante.
Sa america kahit ang mga magulng ay illegal na naninirahan.. at nagkaron sila ng anak dito.. automatic us citizen ang anak nila..
True... Ayaw nya bitawan pagiging Indian nya e... Gusto pa nya baguhin ang batas ng Pilipinas... lol Kala mo napaka high profile para pinas pa mag adjust sa kanya
bakit hindi sila bigyan ng pagkakataon lalo na at nakikita naman natin na deserving sila?
If she born in the Philippines she must be a filipino. That's what that means. I'm sorry for her Philippines lawmakers should prioritize this.
I think that was really unfair for ...just give her chance she a human too a just like us .
Roger Hantic i think its not unfair, its like she had an option but the problem is she doesn't want to renouce her indian nationality
It's not unfair. Gusto niya lang iretain pagka Bumbay niya and be dual citizen. Nakabased na po un sa Indian law.
yes unfair nga po. dapat may permanent residence na sya
remember the "dura lex ced lex"
Sana maging Pinay na sya
Galing nya mgtagalog
Bayad daw muna ng P200k Yun lang paraan wlang alternatibo lupet tlaga masahol p US passport.
This is absolutely wrong ipinanganak sya at lumaki sa Pilipinas it's her right to be a citizen
Laarnie Curcher Hindi ganyan Ang bTas ng pinas dapt May Filipino blood ka
naKakalungkot kc paripariho nmn tayo nilalang ng Diyos, pero ung batas na napaka unfair Para sa mga katulad nya, sna mabigyan sya ng pagkakataon, Isa pa d2 na sya pinanganak at lumaki.
May point si ate....
ano na pong balita sa kanya?
yes tama that's s so ridiculous,,,, tama kahh
Government should let her to be a a citizen. She was born there. What kind of people who will deport someone back to her parent's origin country and she was not born in that country. It should be automatic if a foreigner born in the philippines, they should allow that person to choose their citizenship when they turn 18 or 21 years old.
kung 10 years na sya eh.. bakit di pa sya mabigyan..
She was born in the philippines so she has the right to become a filipino citizen
Kumusta na kaya si jasmine ngayon?
Filipino citizen na po siya nagpanaturalize na siya. Barya lang sa 5-6 ang 200k
mel saint nagpanaturalise na
dapat me rights ang mga banyagang born sa pilipinas o lumaki na dito.
Wag tayo masyadong colonial mentality. Di mo alam ugali ng Bumbay ang kukupal ng mga yan.
@@alfredhitchcock45 oh talaga mas masahol pa pinoy sa indian eh lalo na pag naningil na haha. Pag utang bait pag singil galit haha tandaan mo ung salitang yan.
I sincerely feel all your comments and views on this matter. Although, there was a time in my life where I was proud to be a Filipino. Sadly enough, I do not share the same feelings anymore. I am not surprised, nor am I affected by what's going on in the Philippines. And by saying that, doesn't mean i'm insensitive to other peoples fortunes. My point is, the Philippines is spiraling in a downward direction. And it seems that nobody cares. We, or should I say, they need a MAJOR CHANGE in every aspect. They have laws that were implemented during the beginning of time. Wake up everybody! Times change, people change, Their laws need to be re-thought, re-adjusted and re-written, So as to conform to our ever changing society. Even this issue of Citizenship....geez! Give her the citizenship she very well deserves. Mas Filipino pa sya kesa mga ibang politicians na........alam nyo na!
And to the girl that wants to become a citizen of the Philippines, I hope you get what you want. And if for any reason they deny you? There are a lot more way better countries. I just feel for you, knowing that you don't have that sense of belonging to "somewhere". Goodluck sa iyo..
i dont think you really understand...she can chose to have or be a naturalized filipino citizen..but she has to cancel her indian citizenship..as we do not grant dual citizenship to a foreigner...now on view on this is this law aims to protect filipino citizens from being over run by foreigners as we know even thou philippines is third world as some people say but still lots and lots of foreign nationals want to settle down here..and we are not the only one who has that kind of law..even those rich country who their citizens do not have to compete that much for better opportunity they still impose those kind of law..what more is the philippines..kung sa ngayon na ganun ang batas natin klangan pa nating makipagcompete para makakuha ng mas magandang trabaho what more kung pati sa mga dayuhan magiging kasali natin sila sa competisyon.....but if she really wants to be a filipino citizen she has to surrender her indian passport..
bhogz zantilmo ang dami mong sinabe but youre just not making any sense!!!
joey4onda she had an option but the problem is she doesn't want to give up her indian citizenship and she doesn't want to spend money. she's lucky because she still have an option unlike here in japan eventhough u gave up ur filipino citizenship u will never get japanese citizenship
Mabuti pa mga Foreigner nagtatagalog. Lahat ng announcer magtagalog kayo. Maraming Pilipino sa Pilipinas at Amerika di nakakaintindi ng English. Importante communications.
So yung mga intsik paano nging Pilipino citizen?
Kakaawa naman,hindi naman siguro dapat siyang ideport.she should be given a fair treatment at sa ibang lahi na dito na pinanganak.
Sana yung mga ganito kaso na dito na lumaki at pinanganak sana bigyan ng pagkakataon manirahan dito sa pinas baguhin sana ang batasbpatungol sa mga immigrants
The woman deserves philippine citizenship..
Be Humble she applied a naturalisation now and it was accepted
Come on! Give her a chance to have her here we don't want her to be deported here