Cardinal Müller: Vatican official prefers an empty church to one full of people who reject New Mass

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
  • In an exclusive interview with reporter Maike Hickson, Cardinal Gerhard Müller revealed that a senior Vatican prelate recently told him he would prefer an empty church to a cathedral full of young people who reject New Mass.
    Müller revealed that when he shared his joy at having participated in the recent Paris to Chartres pilgrimage, during which 20,000 young pilgrims packed Chartres Cathedral to attend the Latin Mass, an official of the Roman Dicastery for Divine Worship responded that it was more important that young people respect the new rite.
    In a wide-ranging interview, Müller also shared advice for the Catholic faithful worried about the conflicts in the Ukraine and the Holy Land and the possibility of the outbreak of World War Three.
    Hickson’s children, Isabella and Robert, filmed the interview.
    Download the all-new LSNTV App now, available on iPhone and Android!
    LSNTV Apple Store: apps.apple.com...
    LSNTV Google Play: play.google.co...
    ****
    HELP US FIGHT THE CENSORSHIP OF BIG TECH: 7xup.short.gy/...
    Find FULL and UNCENSORED content here to see beyond what we can show you on RUclips: 7xup.short.gy/...

Комментарии • 198

  • @steinfonell4915
    @steinfonell4915 3 месяца назад +28

    I did my Novus.
    I do my TLM.
    There is no point of return. Let the Ape-church, as blessed Fulton Sheen spoke about, let it fall. Let the flood clean our church.
    We will all be judged, and I hope our Pope will see how many who were praying for his soul and eternal life, when it time for him to meet our creator.
    I try but Our Lord knows how much I try, how much I care, and how much I love.
    About 1 million germans have keft the Church since 2020 ... and nobody care. That says it all...

    • @James-fk2ki
      @James-fk2ki 3 месяца назад +1

      Novus Ordo worked really well in mission lands like India, africa and asia. I vouch for Reverent Novus Ordo

    • @soldierofmary984
      @soldierofmary984 3 месяца назад

      The love Pope Francis.

    • @Alex-l1y5f
      @Alex-l1y5f 3 месяца назад +1

      Africa and much of Asia likes the Novus Ordo, but they also largely reject Fiducia Supplicans.

    • @CharlyBach-lb9nz
      @CharlyBach-lb9nz 3 месяца назад

      Es ist IHR eigener Weg, für den Sie sich entschieden haben. Warum beleidigen Sie die Mitglieder der Kirche? Verstehen Sie sich als der Pharisäer, der hochmütig dem HERRN sagt: "ICH danke dem Herrn, dass ich nicht so bin wie der Sünder dort hinten". Welche Überheblichkeit. Sie schließen sich selbst aus der Kirche aus.

    • @brianbacon5149
      @brianbacon5149 3 месяца назад

      @steinfonell4915 +JMJ Certainly popesplainers don't care. Nor do they care about sex abuse victims. For them it's all about hyperpapal power.

  • @jameswall6270
    @jameswall6270 3 месяца назад +61

    Latin mass is beautiful. It will never die.

    • @MrJacksuper
      @MrJacksuper 3 месяца назад +2

      yeah i get that, but if latin mass is causing you to disobey the direction that the Pope is leading us catholics, what is that to you? Holy Mass, may it be latin or new format mass is all about the sacrificial offering of the Lord Jesus on the cross for salvation. so if two have the same importance why not obey? what is in latin that YOU want that you cannot get in the new mass? i dont get that?

    • @Rockdeesec
      @Rockdeesec 3 месяца назад

      ​@@MrJacksuperTLM does not cause anyone to disobey our Lord and Savior. We follow the direction of the Lord not the current "bishop of Rome" or anyone else that is leading souls astray. What is off with you? NO is a mass of worldly times. It includes but not limited to, literal clowns, unconsecrated hands dolling out the Eucharist which is the body of Christ, pride flags strewn behind and around the altar. Xir, if you are not Catholic and have not attended a TLM please refrain from commenting.

    • @johnpglackin345
      @johnpglackin345 3 месяца назад +1

      ​@@MrJacksuperNovus Ordo Mass is making you worship God as a Protestant instead of Catholics. Which means you are breaking the third Commandment of thou shall keep the Sabbath Holy. Which also means you are not in a state of grave to receive Our Lord.

    • @vivrowe2763
      @vivrowe2763 3 месяца назад

      ​@@MrJacksuperGo to a Latin mass then say that!

    • @Iceland874
      @Iceland874 3 месяца назад +1

      Also the disrespect for our Lord’s Presence is horrible. Mass here is like a circus and breaks my heart. Think of how our Lord, Blessed Mother, St Joseph, and all the saints and God’s Holy Angels feel.

  • @brianbacon5149
    @brianbacon5149 3 месяца назад +32

    +JMJ I'm not holy enough to withstand the irreverent, distracting, dissonant, banal and inane Novus Ordo anymore. Did it for 50 years. No more. I thank the Lord every moment for the TLM. I will never go back to the NO. Disgusting that this pope would rather shutdown the TLM and have empty decrepit NO churches that would eventually close. I'm fed up with Bergoglio.

    • @dterry95
      @dterry95 3 месяца назад +5

      The NO is the antithesis of holiness. Given what the Vatican prelate said, it seems Novus Ordo also stands for "No One will be saved, if we modernists have our way."

    • @CharlyBach-lb9nz
      @CharlyBach-lb9nz 3 месяца назад

      Ihre persönliche Entscheidung!

    • @Bryanisright33
      @Bryanisright33 3 месяца назад +1

      The words of consecration, as affirmed by the Ecumenical Council of Florence and five hundred years of popes, affirming all the popes before them who did not go against the following:
      "...the holy Roman Church, relying on the teaching and authority of the apostles Peter and Paul…uses this form of words in the consecration of the Lord's Body:
      This is my body. And of His blood: For this is the chalice of my blood, of the New and eternal Testament: The mystery of faith, which shall be shed, for you and for many, unto the remission of sins." ...
      As the Douay-Rheims Bible online commentary shows, the words are linked to Daniel 9:27.
      This stretches back to the Apostles, this continued on until Florence, was affirmed by the Council of Florence, continued on to the Council of Trent and past it, and was present in missals up until 1962.
      The word "all" is not the same as the word "many" and are two entirely different words.

  • @James-fk2ki
    @James-fk2ki 3 месяца назад +12

    Dear Catholics, greetings from India (Mizoram state) Please do not be intimidated by the doings of Pope Francis. Be faithful to Christ and live your life the best you can. Let's pray for our prelates that they conform to the teachings of Christ. Here in our parish we pray Rosary every Saturdays and sundays and offer prayers for the papacy and the church.

    • @soldierofmary984
      @soldierofmary984 3 месяца назад +4

      What did Pope Francis do? He is a very good Pope but unfortunately the devil is working through the media and twisting many things that are false.

    • @matthewbroderick6287
      @matthewbroderick6287 3 месяца назад +2

      James, those who claim Pope Francis teaches heresy and error, are themselves ignorant of Catholic teaching and Canon Law and Holy Scripture! As lies were told of Jesus Christ at His trial, so too even now of Pope Francis by modern day elders! Peace always in Jesus Christ our Great and Kind God and Savior, He whose Flesh is true food and Blood true drink!

    • @matthewbroderick6287
      @matthewbroderick6287 3 месяца назад +2

      ​@soldierofmary984 I totally agree with you! I have over 20 books by Pope Francis and Pope Francis has brought me so much closer to Jesus Christ and love of all humanity! Those who claim Pope Francis teaches heresy and error, are themselves ignorant of Catholic teaching and Canon Law and Holy Scripture! As lies were told of Jesus Christ at His trial, so too even now of Pope Francis by modern day elders! God's grace and peace to you always in Jesus Christ our our and Kind God and Savior, He whose Flesh is true ! food and Blood true drink

  • @horizon-one
    @horizon-one 3 месяца назад +7

    Thank you for such an important interview. Hearing from a Cardinal means a lot.
    God bless you all.

  • @jerryfaircloth
    @jerryfaircloth 3 месяца назад +33

    What exactly is invalid about the tridentine mass? Long before the internet, and before V2, any Catholic could attend mass in any country on earth and completely follow what was going on. That no longer is true.

    • @nathanbustamante1525
      @nathanbustamante1525 3 месяца назад

      There's nothing invalid about the tridentine mass. It's being used by schismatics to say that the new form of the mass is invalid or a danger to people's faith. That's why the old form of the mass is being restricted.

    • @jonathanb.6926
      @jonathanb.6926 3 месяца назад

      TLM was based on a faith that the last “vicars of Christ” wanted to cancel. Such is the scandal. Vatican II is the root of all this insanity.

    • @brianbacon5149
      @brianbacon5149 3 месяца назад +4

      @@jerryfaircloth +JMJ Pope Benedict said the TLM can't be suppressed. It dates to the Apostles and is the Mass of the Saints.

    • @JohnAlbertRigali
      @JohnAlbertRigali 3 месяца назад

      In order words, the Tridentine Mass (Traditional Latin Mass / Vetus Ordo / Usus Antiquior) still is and always will be valid regardless of what *any* earthly person says.

    • @nathanbustamante1525
      @nathanbustamante1525 3 месяца назад

      @@JohnAlbertRigali Council of Trent on the dispensation of the Eucharist says otherwise.

  • @clarataylor2739
    @clarataylor2739 3 месяца назад +50

    I am a new Catholic and not happy with the Pope canceling Holy Priest

    • @MrMercytres
      @MrMercytres 3 месяца назад +1

      Don’t be discourage what is happening in the Catholic Church . Be strong in the Lord. .Don’t get influenced with the social media especially with life site news . This channel try to bring down catholic Church . You must not listen to this channel at all .

    • @MrMercytres
      @MrMercytres 3 месяца назад

      You must focus on the gospel and Jesus . This channel lead people to division .

    • @0r14n583lt
      @0r14n583lt 3 месяца назад +3

      Welcome to the Church. Remember to hold on. It’s going to be a wild ride.

    • @BlairGordon-g8c
      @BlairGordon-g8c 3 месяца назад

      @@MrMercytres Riigghht, Lifesite just made up Vigano. The only way to assist the Church and her work of salvation is to expose the people of darkness within who are working against her.

    • @ordinarycatholic658
      @ordinarycatholic658 3 месяца назад +3

      Let no one take your focus off Jesus Christ in the Eucharist. Division in the Church is real, but our focus is unity in the Body of Christ. If we feed ourselves with church problems, we’re feeding our souls with things that won’t nourish our growth in holiness. Pray for the holy father and healing in the Church, and be at peace. There are things out of our control; thankfully, prayer is our greatest help to reach those we can’t otherwise.

  • @stephanottawa7890
    @stephanottawa7890 3 месяца назад +29

    Sometimes it is better to disobey the pope of Rome and save your soul.

    • @conce-ss5mg
      @conce-ss5mg 3 месяца назад +4

      If PF obedient to Jesus Christ teachings then I would obey him but PF shows disobedience to Jesus Christ. I pray for his conversion.

    • @CharlyBach-lb9nz
      @CharlyBach-lb9nz 3 месяца назад +2

      @@conce-ss5mg Wo zeigt er Ungehorsam gegen Jesus Christus? Warum beschuldigen Sie den Papst der Häresie, ohne auch nur EINEN Beweis zu liefen? Oder starren Sie lieber auf den Splitter im Auge eines Mitchristen, als auf den Balken in Ihrem eigenen Auge? Lesen Sie die Heilige Schrift und versuchen Sie es mal mit DEMUT, wenn Sie das Wort noch kennen...

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад +1

      @@conce-ss5mg Do you have the authority to declare the Pope as disobedient to Jesus Christ? Show us proofs that you have the authority to judge the Pope's soul.
      And why should you base your salvation on how a Pope sins or not sins? You must be faithful to the Church's teachings no matter who the Pope is and how good or flawed his personal relationship to Christ is.

    • @ThomasSt40
      @ThomasSt40 3 месяца назад +1

      "...schism is not committed when there are well-founded reasons to consider the election of the Pope doubtful, due to of the vitium consensuse of irregularities or violations of the rules that regulate the Conclave. (see Wernz - Vidal, Ius Canonicum, Rome, Pont. Univ. Greg., 1937, vol. VII, p. 439).”

    • @stephanottawa7890
      @stephanottawa7890 3 месяца назад +1

      @@ThomasSt40 That is a very good point, Mr. Thomas. Would a canon lawyer have to get to work and submit some evidence?

  • @margaretadamson6239
    @margaretadamson6239 3 месяца назад +16

    You had the unity in the old Mass. Everything changed after V2 and its horrible to listen to this man say he'd rather have empty pews. Leave the TLM alone, its beautiful, valid and the Popes of the past guaranteed the TLM.

    • @sleepinglioness5754
      @sleepinglioness5754 3 месяца назад +3

      Cdl. Muller was referring to a comment someone from the pilgrimage of Chartres made to him. It was not Cdl. Muller who made that statement. See the comment I posted with the transcript.
      This was a very confusing interview/video.

    • @adelinomorte7421
      @adelinomorte7421 3 месяца назад

      ***if you practice your catholicism properly it should not matter if it is in latin, if you fully understand it, or in your local language, if you also understand it. To practice a religion properly the most important is the catechism and free your practice from superstition (I witness superstition all my life in the practice) and be ready to be nailed to a cross like Jesus was, that is being a christian. How many of you made the stations of the cross , VIA SACRA ? ***

    • @JohnAlbertRigali
      @JohnAlbertRigali 3 месяца назад

      @@adelinomorte7421 It can be argued that most of the apostasies that have occurred since the institution of the Mass of Paul VI (“Novus Ordo Mass”) are attributable to it and the numerous liturgical abuses that have blossomed in it. Almost every “recovering“ (apostatized) Catholic with whom I’ve conversed has unwittingly testified to it.

  • @michellestansberry9101
    @michellestansberry9101 3 месяца назад +9

    I have both novas ordos and FSSP. The new mass is like going to a non denominational church. I know because I used to go

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      I, too, go to both the Novus Ordo and the FSSP. NO on weekdays and FSSP on Sundays and holy days. They don't conflict because they are two forms of the same Latin rite. Thanks, and God bless you.

  • @josepadilla-bx4jl
    @josepadilla-bx4jl 3 месяца назад +23

    Latin mass we must preserve the latin mass

  • @margaretadamson6239
    @margaretadamson6239 3 месяца назад +45

    Leave our TLM alone. We should have the ability to attend both Masses minus the clowns.

    • @johnpglackin345
      @johnpglackin345 3 месяца назад +2

      We all should be attending the Traditional Latin Mass.

    • @vivrowe2763
      @vivrowe2763 3 месяца назад +1

      ​@@johnpglackin345Not everyone has it, or don't you understand that?

    • @femaleKCRoyalsFan
      @femaleKCRoyalsFan 3 месяца назад +1

      @@johnpglackin345 unfortunately not everybody has it. I am blessed to be able to go to it here in Nebraska, but in the far western part of my state there is no Latin mass. it’s only available in the eastern part of the state.

    • @johnpglackin345
      @johnpglackin345 3 месяца назад +1

      @@vivrowe2763 Than start making a mess at the Novus Ordo Mass. Confront your fellow Laity in the pews. Do your part to help bring the Traditional Latin Mass back to the parish.

    • @vivrowe2763
      @vivrowe2763 3 месяца назад +1

      @@johnpglackin345 It has not been in the suburbs of Melbourne Australia since I was young. It's been cancelled in the city recently.

  • @paulyosef7550
    @paulyosef7550 3 месяца назад +9

    The new mass is just SOooo Lutheran, wimpy songs and all.

  • @femaleKCRoyalsFan
    @femaleKCRoyalsFan 3 месяца назад +4

    We were actually quite full at the 8 AM low mass that I go to, just three days ago. The FSSP chapel that I go to used to be inside of a Catholic hospital, but several nurses saved it from destruction after the hospital was torn down. A new hospital was built elsewhere in town. The chapel has very small pews. You can fit three people max. Maybe you can fit four young children, but you can’t fit more than two adults and a toddler & infant, comfortably. I even joked with the couple that takes me home the majority of Sundays that somebody from the church needs to win the lottery, Donate the money to the FSSP and build a new church so we can have a second location. Because the more the Latin mass is threatened with restriction, the more we seem to grow

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      God bless you for sticking it out with the FSSP. i, too, go to the FSSP in Sacramento. It's a small, modest church, and O, my! the pews are so uncomfortable LOL! But the priests seem so holy and the people are so prayerful and that's very touching. I'm sure if the fraternity had more money, they would have opted for more comfortable pews. But there's something so consoling to be reminded that Our Lord, too, was poor when He became man.

  • @Jennykre
    @Jennykre 3 месяца назад +18

    as time goes by, I'm more and more convinced that the less people in church means success for the Francis agenda.

    • @dr.davidhoward3179
      @dr.davidhoward3179 3 месяца назад +3

      True.

    • @Iceland874
      @Iceland874 3 месяца назад +2

      I agree.

    • @soldierofmary984
      @soldierofmary984 3 месяца назад

      I love Pope Francis. The church's are very full.

    • @msj5885
      @msj5885 3 месяца назад +1

      ​@@soldierofmary984good luck with that🤦‍♂️

    • @CharlyBach-lb9nz
      @CharlyBach-lb9nz 3 месяца назад

      Mir tut es sehr leid, wenn jemand den anderen Schuld dafür gibt, dass ER oder Sie sich selbst nicht im Glauben bemüht. Es sind immer die Anderen. Das klingt genauso glaubwürdig, wie die heuchlerischen Worte des überheblichen Pharisäers, von dem Jesus erzählt. Wenn das IHR Glaube ist, tun Sie mir sehr leid, denn das ist nicht der Glaube, den der HERR gelehrt hat.

  • @jameshogan6142
    @jameshogan6142 3 месяца назад +3

    If the Novo Ordo mass is to be universal it should be comprehensible to everyone attending. Most people outside of Russian nationals who are tourists in Russia will not be able to understand the language of the new rite in which the mass is celebrated.

    • @CharlyBach-lb9nz
      @CharlyBach-lb9nz 3 месяца назад

      So ist es. Nicht russisch-sprechende Menschen können selbst die Einwohner nicht verstehen oder Straßenschilder lesen, die in kyrillisch geschrieben sind. Das ist in China genau so. In fast jedem Land sind Reisende "AUSLÄNDER", die Sprache und Bräuche als unverständlich empfinden. Wenn sie es nicht vorher gelernt haben...

  • @holymarymotherofgodprayfor7388
    @holymarymotherofgodprayfor7388 3 месяца назад +6

    Again I repeat, if the pope had consecrated Russia to Mary's Immaculate Heart, none of this would be happening in the church. But since the pope disobeyed Our Lord and Our Lady, these are the consequences. People who are admonishing Trad Catholics about disobeying the false pope should be asking themselves first "why did the Pope disobey GOD.?! Why don't the bishops talk about this, they know this is the cause of the problems in the church. But, they will never admit they caused this and they are the problem!

    • @KateKing217
      @KateKing217 3 месяца назад +3

      It seems 🤔 the last 6 popes disobeyed Our Lady of Fatima 😥🙏🏾

    • @annap7678
      @annap7678 3 месяца назад +2

      According to Father Paul Kramer, sometime in the latter half of 2013 Vladimir Putin went to Rome to meet the new Pope and went on a walk with Francis (each accompanied by an aide) during which Putin asked him if he would go ahead and consecrate Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary. Francis declined to do so, remarking that Fatima is not a topic discussed within the Vatican halls. After the walk, after Putin took his leave of Francis, he stated to another person in his party, “This Pope is not a godly man.” I later heard that after Putin’s return to Russia, the Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox Church, in union with the Russian bishops, went ahead and carried out themselves the Consecration to the Immaculate Heart of Mary that Rome refused to do. The Russians did try to accomplish what God asked by going to the Pope first; failing that, they did their best to do it themselves. Perhaps we should hark back to a comment Jesus applied to the Scribes and Pharisees, substituting this Vatican and Pope for them, and say that God can raise up children for His Church from Russian stones.

    • @soldierofmary984
      @soldierofmary984 3 месяца назад

      Oh please stop your gossip about the Pope. God forgive you.

    • @holymarymotherofgodprayfor7388
      @holymarymotherofgodprayfor7388 3 месяца назад +3

      @@soldierofmary984 this isn't gossip troll, it's the truth!

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      @@holymarymotherofgodprayfor7388 What is the truth? Please tell me the truth about this Pope, with evidence and proofs to back up what you will say. I'm not snarky. I truly want to know. Thanks and God bless you.

  • @zalobo
    @zalobo 3 месяца назад +3

    PRAY, PRAY, PRAY FOR THE TRUE TLM OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH OF JESUS CHRIST

    • @edmundcoyle364
      @edmundcoyle364 3 месяца назад

      .

    • @CharlyBach-lb9nz
      @CharlyBach-lb9nz 3 месяца назад

      Wer oder was ist das TLM von dem Sie da sprechen? Eine Geheimsprache für Neu-Heiden?

  • @CatholicSinger
    @CatholicSinger 3 месяца назад +4

    Viva Marcel Lefebvre

  • @mya5980
    @mya5980 2 месяца назад

    👑✝️🕊️ For an increase of Holy Authentic Loyal Catholic Priests, Bishops and Cardinals. For GOD'S DIVINE PROTECTION UPON THEM as they courageously speak the TRUTH and Defend the restoration of our Catholic Church our 1 True Apostolic Catholic Church from JESUS CHRIST Our SAVIOR 🙏🏼

  • @UrsulaPainter
    @UrsulaPainter 3 месяца назад +1

    We do not all have the same human rights---not as long as the prince of the power of the air rules the earth.

  • @theien5929
    @theien5929 3 месяца назад +1

    The answer is obvious. STAND by an HOLD the TRADITION.

  • @patriciamariecunningham306
    @patriciamariecunningham306 3 месяца назад +1

    Latin holy Traditional Mass forever

  • @TP-om8of
    @TP-om8of 3 месяца назад +1

    @20:00. I don’t agree that the pope has a “right” to regulate the liturgy. Look at the mess Paul VI and Francis have created.

  • @reneestevens6683
    @reneestevens6683 3 месяца назад +2

    The new mass sounds like sacralidge

    • @soldierofmary984
      @soldierofmary984 3 месяца назад

      I attend the New Mass. The Church is very full. I think you people worry more about the liturgy then about Christ.

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      The new (NO) Mass is valid and legal and approved by the Church. Don't question it.

  • @JohnAlbertRigali
    @JohnAlbertRigali 3 месяца назад

    Good interview. The transcript contains some errors.

  • @NelsonAdvisors
    @NelsonAdvisors 3 месяца назад +1

    Isn’t there an eclipse covering the True Church?

  • @bilbaogonzalo
    @bilbaogonzalo 3 месяца назад +1

    That official, denounced by our Cardinal Müller, is a Satanist or a Mason, which is the same thing.
    It is necessary to pray more so that the traitors to the Church of Christ infiltrated in the clergy, worse if in the Vatican, convert or are identified and removed.
    "Clama, ne cesses. Quasi tuba exalta vocem tuam et adnuntia populo meo scelera eorum et domui Jacob peccata eoru (Is. 58, 1)".
    "Cry out, do not cease (to pray), like a trumpet, lift up your voice, and declare to my people their iniquities, and to the house of Jacob, their sins."

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      How did you know the anonymous Vatican official that made the comment is a "Satanist or a Mason?" Do you have proofs or evidence to back up what you say?

  • @rasi2020
    @rasi2020 3 месяца назад +1

    Too bad that before uploading the video nobody thought to correct this stupid use of "rights" in the subtitles instead of the correct "rites"!

  • @kalanuarte683
    @kalanuarte683 3 месяца назад +2

    Did that make any sense? Can’t figure out what side he is on.

    • @conce-ss5mg
      @conce-ss5mg 3 месяца назад

      I'm also confused.

    • @sleepinglioness5754
      @sleepinglioness5754 3 месяца назад

      Cdl. Muller was referring to a comment someone from the pilgrimage of Chartres made to him. It was not Cdl. Muller who made that statement. See the comment I posted with the transcript.
      This was a very confusing interview/video.

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      Yes, it makes sense.
      Okay, I'll try to explain it to you, and if you need documental proofs, just let me know:
      The Chartes pilgirimages are SSPX. SSPX is in schism, meaning, it's not in full communion with Rome and has no legitimate canonical ministry in the Church.
      Pope Benedict XVI, in a Letter to Bishops said the SSPX problem is not merely a matter of discipline but doctrine. Apparently, Vatican II (the council itself) is doctrine, and until SSPX accepts it, they're not in union with the Church.
      We all know that the Novus Ordo is a fruit of Vatican II and SSPX does not recognize it. Pope Benedict,, in his motu proprio Summorum Pontificum, declares that the NO is a valid and legit form of the Latin Rite. The Latin (Roman) Rite, according to Benedict XVI has two forms: the Ordinary Form (the NO) and the Extraordinary Form (VO or TLM). They are both valid and legit.
      Thus, what the anonymous commenter was saying is: Better a valid and legal Latin Rite Mass than an illicit SSPX Mass. Better the NO Mass than the SSPX.
      i hope this helps., Again, if you need to see papal quotes from official Church documents, just let me know. Thank you and God bless you.

  • @angelicamicaelaalcaraz2462
    @angelicamicaelaalcaraz2462 3 месяца назад

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @JamesPetrycia-zj7yq
    @JamesPetrycia-zj7yq 2 месяца назад

    His biggest enemy are other Cardinals. He has no idea what the hell he talking about.

  • @sleepinglioness5754
    @sleepinglioness5754 3 месяца назад

    The heading of this video is misleading.
    Go to 15:27 where Cardinal Muller is asked to comment on his impression of the pilgrimage of Chartres. He referred to what a member of that pilgrimage said to him that "it is more important that they are respecting the newer form [?] of the Latin rite. If not, they should not come. It [is] better that they not come, better to have an empty Church, than a Church full [of] young people...against the pastoral..."

  • @waynehajek6346
    @waynehajek6346 3 месяца назад

    RITE(s) in lieu of Rights!

  • @Deathbytroll
    @Deathbytroll 3 месяца назад +3

    We had various sub rites in the Latin church but all were liturgically strong and the changes were organic and not rebuilt from the ground up like the NO.

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      All those subrites were also approved by the Church and are in full communion with the Pope. They maintain Church unity as components of the "One, Holy..."
      But there are quite a few TLMs around that illicit and have no canonical stature in the Church. I think TC was primarily targeting those illicit Masses (not Ecclesia Dei or diocesan TLMs.) But of course, the Pope could not reach them with a motu proprio because they don't listen to him, are disobedient, and are tearing apart the fabric of the "One, Holy..."

  • @dannyharvanek3908
    @dannyharvanek3908 3 месяца назад

    The absence of “logo’s” in the world !!

  • @vjerniboguii4969
    @vjerniboguii4969 3 месяца назад

    ♥♥♥ 16.53.

  • @MisuTee
    @MisuTee 2 месяца назад

    Jesus Himself said "Go in through the narrow gate, because the gate to hell is wide and the road that leads to it is easy, and there are many who travel it. But the gate to life is narrow and the way that leads to it is hard, and there are few people who find it." Few people will be saved and majority will go to Hell.

  • @imatrOlda
    @imatrOlda 2 месяца назад

    well trident council did make an authoritarian decision and limited many very old rites existing in that time. so I like the idea of variety of rituses but in fact Tridentinum was a move to more uniformity and Vat I was even more. I wish Trident ritus would be practiced and has been after Ben XVI, but it is a fact that those who want only the old ritus like to claim the post Vat. ritus is less worths. So they use the diversity argument only if it suits them, but then do not tolerate the others. In general tolerance is probably not the most obvious feature of the traditionalist I would say.

  • @dr.davidhoward3179
    @dr.davidhoward3179 3 месяца назад

    🙏🏻😇⛪❤️‍🔥👑🕊️🕯️

  • @kozanutria7728
    @kozanutria7728 18 дней назад

    Number of people do not matter.
    We see full churches in NO as well.
    Whatatters is whay this peole are in the church in first place. In NO and in VO are people who come not for God.

  • @BlancaHolland-xx9ny
    @BlancaHolland-xx9ny 3 месяца назад +6

    I was praying for the Catholic brethren and the LORD JESUS -YESHUA told me that the church was going to cause a come out of the faithful of the word the Bible foundation: as the people realize that Francis is not true to the LORD JESUS -YESHUA teachings: but pandering to the woke agendas from hell. Brethren stand strong and keep the faith.

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      Blanca, I suggest you go to your bishop and tell what Our Lord told you. The Church will look into it to determine if it's authentic and worthy to be believed. Thanks and God bless you.

  • @protasiocanalita6436
    @protasiocanalita6436 2 месяца назад

    Sir. If We're Forced To Commit. A. mortal sin by keeping air attending an. Mass that Insults our Lord Jesus Christ, we shall do 2:39 what the early Catholics do ask for martrydom. Their desire to make us insult our Lord Jesus Christ is ( no comment) . We shall give way for poor Francis followers. Of course pope Francis has a lot of elites to give him money Right???

  • @imatrOlda
    @imatrOlda 2 месяца назад

    ”latin rite” (ritus) nicht ”latin right” , bitte

  • @normaavelarpalacio5337
    @normaavelarpalacio5337 2 месяца назад

    What does he mean the Catholic Church is not a monarchy? Is he saying that Christ isn't King?

  • @simonewilliams7224
    @simonewilliams7224 3 месяца назад

    You, we must protect and reserve the Traditions and the Traditional Latin Rite and Traditional Practices and Prayers.
    OR
    You can leave Jordon Peterson and his wife to lead in your stead.

    • @CharlyBach-lb9nz
      @CharlyBach-lb9nz 3 месяца назад

      Wie sieht es denn in IHRER Familie aus? Praktizieren Ihre Kinder oder Ihr Mann noch den Glauben? Oder haben sie sich auch schon fremden Göttern (dem Geld, der Macht, dem Besitz) zugewendet. Es ist traurig, dass auch Familienangehöre von sogenannten "Wahren Katholiken oder Christen" ihren Glauben meist nicht mehr leben. Aber unehrlich sind und sagen: wegen der deutschen Messe gehe ich nicht mehr in die Kirche. Glauben Sie wirklich den Worten und der Gegenwart Christi in der Messe, oder glauben sie nur den Traditionen, die irgendwann auch mal "neu und unverständlich" waren?

  • @douglasdamron6007
    @douglasdamron6007 3 месяца назад

    Do any cardinals do push-ups?

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      I don't know. Why do you ask?

  • @philipcollins218
    @philipcollins218 3 месяца назад

    Love the drag

  • @brotherandrew3393
    @brotherandrew3393 3 месяца назад +1

    People like Müller do not fill the Church.

    • @jameshogan6142
      @jameshogan6142 3 месяца назад +3

      That is because there are very few people who are a cardinal.

  • @Hope_Boat
    @Hope_Boat 3 месяца назад +4

    The orthodox Church is so much relevant ☦️

    • @JMJ_James
      @JMJ_James 3 месяца назад

      Please be serious. The various orthodox communions are all full of opposed doctrine and division. Become Catholic soon, think of your eternal soul

    • @Rockdeesec
      @Rockdeesec 3 месяца назад

      If it is "so much relevant" where are they in the world converted souls? They don't, all i see is them attacking Catholics online. They are getting worse than prots at their attacks. The Catholic church is infiltrated for a reason.

    • @msj5885
      @msj5885 3 месяца назад

      @@Hope_Boat just kidding about those second and third marriages, right?

    • @Hope_Boat
      @Hope_Boat 3 месяца назад

      @@msj5885 The practice of the orthodox Church has not changed since the Apostles :
      _I tell you that anyone who divorces his wife, except for marital unfaithfulness, and marries another woman commits adultery._
      Matthew 19:9
      Do divorce has always been accepted by the Church in case one spouse is not repenting and lives in adultery.
      Saint John Chrysostome explained why : the Church has a duty to save the soul of the other spouse by using her power to tie and untie.
      Roman Catholics have evolved from the ancient rule and innovated. That's their business. We remain faithful to the deposit of the faith. They also suffer from amnesia and have no idea what's was the rule before their innovations and condemn what mustn't be condemned. Lord have mercy on us all sinners.

  • @soldierofmary984
    @soldierofmary984 3 месяца назад

    I see Novus Ordo Mass very full. The title of this video is full of lies.

    • @msj5885
      @msj5885 3 месяца назад +2

      @@soldierofmary984 leave this to the grown ups

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад +1

      @@msj5885 That's all you have?

    • @Ann-p5g
      @Ann-p5g 3 месяца назад

      The NO is full of abuses

  • @MrJacksuper
    @MrJacksuper 3 месяца назад +1

    First and foremost disobedience will result shcism which painfully ruptures the very fabric of unity and all Catholics must understand this! Not sure why its so hard to obey where in fact this is what the bible is all about. and the Lord keeps repeating the importance of obedience. However, whoever is that senior Vatican prelate that cardinal muller is referring to quoting "he would prefer an empty church to a cathedral full of young people who reject New Mass" is irresponsible. if he could only felt the pain for those martyrs who defended the faith, if he could only experienced the hunger, thirst, physical pain by walking thousand miles for the sake of spreading love of Jesus, if he could only witnessed miracles after miracles for those who are called for the service of the kingdom etc, then he could have not said so. normal reaction to people who used to the old ways/tradition to be surprised, feeling strange and some will reject the new direction-guidelines of the church and we(responsible catholics) should/must be patient explaining to members that it is part of the process in the evolution of the Church. the Church must move forward under the guidance of the Holy Spirit! This is what the Lord Jesus is telling us in His promised in john 16:13 "But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all the truth. He will not speak on his own; he will speak only what he hears, and he will tell you what is yet to come" > one requirement for this tho is PRAYER. i noticed those higher officials of the Church-priests including Catholics like me have failed doing this. we cannot overemphasize the power of prayer that the Lord is always reminding us! This is our sword and shield for spiritual bottle! yet we don't understand these things! no wonder we are now in chaos!!!

    • @cheesylisteningobscura8737
      @cheesylisteningobscura8737 3 месяца назад +7

      No, Christianity is not “all about obedience.” Any decent moral theologian will tell you this.
      The highest virtues are the three theological virtues of Faith, Hope, and Charity. Under these are the four cardinal virtues of Prudence, Temperance, Fortitude, and Justice. Finally there are the subordinate virtues. Obedience is subordinate to the cardinal virtue of Justice.
      With a subordinate virtue, it is possible to sin either by defect or by excess. An excess of Obedience is shown when one obeys a command that is contrary to a higher virtue (such as Faith, Charity, or Justice, for example).
      An unjust law does not bind the conscience. Sometimes disobedience is the right thing to do.

    • @brianbacon5149
      @brianbacon5149 3 месяца назад

      @@cheesylisteningobscura8737 +JMJ Popes St. Pius V and Benedict XVI said the Mass of the Ages cannot be suppressed. Bergoglio is OK with sacrilege in a NO PRIDE mass, but wants to shutdown the Mass of the Apostles???!!! I don't accept that. That jeopardizes souls and is unjust. We have a DUTY under Canon 212 to protest. Just because a pope says something doesn't mean it's right and just despite what Hyperpapalists claim. Hyperpapalism is a sin and abdication of responsibility baptized Faithful. What do these Hyperpapalists say about Bergoglio's newest discussion draft to upend legitimate papal authority? They're simply lazy drones.

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад

      @@cheesylisteningobscura8737 Obedience is so important in the Church because that's a glue that maintains her "one-ness." It's the virtue of Faith, as in "I believe...in the ONE, holy catholic church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins...etc.
      Long before the earth was created, the first sin ever committed against God was that of disobedience. Satan said, "Non serviam," and that's pretty heavy.

    • @marietta1335
      @marietta1335 3 месяца назад +1

      "First and foremost disobedience will result schism which painfully ruptures the very fabric of unity and all Catholics must understand this! Not sure why its so hard to obey where in fact this is what the bible is all about. and the Lord keeps repeating the importance of obedience."
      Thank you, Mr. Jacksuper. People need to remember this. Thanks again and God bless you.

    • @brianbacon5149
      @brianbacon5149 3 месяца назад

      @marietta1335 +JMJ. Of course not. The paramount virtues as defined in the Magisterium are the Theological virtues of Faith, Hope and Love. Next come the Cardinal virtues of Prudence, Justice, Temperance and Fortitude. Obedience to a pope who circulates false teaching or covers up sexual abuse is far down the list of virtues. In fact it could be sinful and the road to hell. Pax Domini vobiscum.

  • @Rosiedelaroux
    @Rosiedelaroux 3 месяца назад

    Is the woman on the left transgender?