@@PipesTobaccoWhiskey Jeremy McKenna stated on a podcast recently that 507 is just repackaged PS400, Sutliff hasn't added anything to it and that the misinformation is about PS400 having perique in it.
OK, you guys are doing exactly what I was hoping someone would do! One of my favorites is Orlik Golden slice, and you did a nice reference to that in comparison with why you are smoking. I’m also looking for a replacement for vanilla roll cake!
Jeremy M at Sutliff said they’ve been buying 507c from STG for 20 years and it’s the same as LNF. He also said neither has perique. This was all mentioned on the Greywoodie podcast recently.
I canned Peter Stokkebye Luxury Twist Flake bulk three and a half years ago. When I opened the Mason jar last week, the lid exploded off and flew five feet. This was probably the result of secondary anaerobic fermentation. Be careful when you open your jar.
I bought a 1 1/2 pounds of twist flake last year to age and I’m very happy I did. I have a 4ish year old sample that I dive into every once in a while and I still really enjoy it. Sad to see all the HH lines leaves. Wish I had bought a pound of the each one.
This was one of the first blends I really loved. Very enjoyable sweetness, I find it easy to smoke. Also probably the best looking flakes there are. Personally I enjoy ps403 and ps400 more but all three are delicious and the value is unbeatable. My favorite straight Virginia is is still Mac baren Virginia no1 😢
Great video guys! Was watching y’all’s top 5 video from four years ago again. Do you think your list has changed where y’all could do another top favorite video again? Would love to see that!
I’ve smoked about 3-pounds of this in the past six years. Easily in my top-5 tobaccos of all time; buttery, creamy and pleasant. Have it in the morning with a cup of black coffee and you’ll thank me later!
Peterson Irish Flake might be a good alternative to Old Dark Fired. They are different but comparable. Irish flake is probably less dark and more floral, but in the same vein.
Id be interested to see your thoughts if you did a comparison of Virginia Slices to the Peter Stokkebye Navy Flake. They sure look, smell, and taste the same which matches the comment we read.
@ nice! Let me know what you think when you get them. I listened to the podcast today where Jeremy McKenna confirmed Sutliff has been buying that product from STG and it’s the same as the Stokkebye. That’s good news for us Virginia Slice lovers!
@@PipesTobaccoWhiskeythat’s what they say. I have a jar of each and they smell exactly the same,they do taste similar as well. I was sceptical too when I saw that fellas comment on FB. But it was the navy flake he was referring to not the twist.
@@donpasko6378that’s what I read as well, I have both fresh from a few weeks ago. I took both out and they both look and smell the same to me too. The twist flake is a different animal, I like it as well.
Jeremy M at Sutliff said they’ve been buying 507c from STG for 20 years and it’s the same as LNF and neither has perique. This was stated on the Greywoodie podcast recently
The comment from STG was Navy flake PS400 being the same as Sutliff 507c
But Navy Flake has Perique in it…507 doesn’t?
@@PipesTobaccoWhiskeyJeremy McKenna confirmed on the Grey Woodie show that PS400 is the same blend and neither have Perique.
@@PipesTobaccoWhiskey Jeremy McKenna stated on a podcast recently that 507 is just repackaged PS400, Sutliff hasn't added anything to it and that the misinformation is about PS400 having perique in it.
@@DocBanjo that is what I remember Jeremy saying. Pipe On
OK, you guys are doing exactly what I was hoping someone would do! One of my favorites is Orlik Golden slice, and you did a nice reference to that in comparison with why you are smoking.
I’m also looking for a replacement for vanilla roll cake!
Me too!!!
Thanks for the comparison. Hope you continue with others.😎
👍
Great video guys, awesome blend
👍
Jeremy M at Sutliff said they’ve been buying 507c from STG for 20 years and it’s the same as LNF. He also said neither has perique. This was all mentioned on the Greywoodie podcast recently.
Hmmmm
Finally. Maybe I'll open that jar that's been sitting for 3 years...
😂
I canned Peter Stokkebye Luxury Twist Flake bulk three and a half years ago. When I opened the Mason jar last week, the lid exploded off and flew five feet. This was probably the result of secondary anaerobic fermentation. Be careful when you open your jar.
@@megahamartolos6638😂😂
I bought a 1 1/2 pounds of twist flake last year to age and I’m very happy I did. I have a 4ish year old sample that I dive into every once in a while and I still really enjoy it. Sad to see all the HH lines leaves. Wish I had bought a pound of the each one.
😢
This was one of the first blends I really loved. Very enjoyable sweetness, I find it easy to smoke. Also probably the best looking flakes there are.
Personally I enjoy ps403 and ps400 more but all three are delicious and the value is unbeatable.
My favorite straight Virginia is is still Mac baren Virginia no1 😢
👍
Great video guys! Was watching y’all’s top 5 video from four years ago again. Do you think your list has changed where y’all could do another top favorite video again? Would love to see that!
A few of mine have shifted, but pretty much the same. Now Nathan is another story…😂
@ I bet!
I’ve smoked about 3-pounds of this in the past six years. Easily in my top-5 tobaccos of all time; buttery, creamy and pleasant. Have it in the morning with a cup of black coffee and you’ll thank me later!
Mmmmmm….
Peterson Irish Flake might be a good alternative to Old Dark Fired. They are different but comparable. Irish flake is probably less dark and more floral, but in the same vein.
I’ll give it a try…
Correct!!!! PS Navy Flake is the correct flake as per STG. Not Twist Flake.
Hmmm…the Navy Flake has Perique in it, though.
Id be interested to see your thoughts if you did a comparison of Virginia Slices to the Peter Stokkebye Navy Flake. They sure look, smell, and taste the same which matches the comment we read.
As soon as it becomes available…sold out on smokingpipes.
@ Virginia Slices and the Peter Stokkebye Navy Flake now both back in stock on Smokingpipes as of this afternoon.
Yep…ordered a pound each! 😂
@ nice! Let me know what you think when you get them. I listened to the podcast today where Jeremy McKenna confirmed Sutliff has been buying that product from STG and it’s the same as the Stokkebye. That’s good news for us Virginia Slice lovers!
It’s luxury navy flake that is the same as 507C
But 507C doesn’t have Perique in it and Navy Flake does??
@@PipesTobaccoWhiskeythat’s what they say. I have a jar of each and they smell exactly the same,they do taste similar as well. I was sceptical too when I saw that fellas comment on FB. But it was the navy flake he was referring to not the twist.
@@donpasko6378that’s what I read as well, I have both fresh from a few weeks ago. I took both out and they both look and smell the same to me too. The twist flake is a different animal, I like it as well.
Jeremy M at Sutliff said they’ve been buying 507c from STG for 20 years and it’s the same as LNF and neither has perique. This was stated on the Greywoodie podcast recently
Anyone know a replacement for the sutliff great outdoors blend? Is my favorite supposed to be a match for the old field and stream blend.
That was the only one I knew of…