Play Enlisted for FREE on PC, Xbox Series X|S and PS5 - Follow the link to download the game and get your exclusive bonus now. See you in battle! playen.link/generaldischarge Which one is your favorite - Army Rangers or Navy SEALs? Help us reach 5,000 Followers on Facebook: facebook.com/gendischarge PATREON: patreon.com/generaldischarge LINKTREE: linktr.ee/generaldischarge
That advice at the end is invaluable. Take a calculated risk, just don't quit. That really sums it up because the selection process is designed to do just that, make you quit.
@@trobertwthere is no competition. Both have objectives. Both are highly trained. They often operate tigether with different objectives within the same mission
There is no direct action force more capable and scalable than the 75th Ranger Regiment, they even have their Tier 1 RRC unit, but regular Rangers can be deployed from squads of 8 or 9 up to 1,500 a battalion, Rangers in Afghanistan in a single deployment killed or captured more than 1,500 terrorists. Neither joining the devgroup with normal seals nor together can they kill that many insurgents in one deployment, in the end I'm just saying that each unit is unique and the best at what it does.
All due respect man, that whack-mole-counterterrorism/counter insurgent is how we keep losing fights and our brothers. The war of attrition doesn’t work for us, foreign internal defense and intelligence operations are what really pay the dividends, that’s why CAG/ST6/ISA/SAD and other SMUs are preferred for high profile missions
I understand you!! and you're right, but what happens is that mostly foreign internal defense is done by the green berets, even the green berets during the Gwot created CiF companies that rescued hostages, and were in charge of direct action. Now that the USA is going against China the Green Berets have also just created HTD Hard Target Defeat units to break into underground bunkers, rescue hostages and search and destroy sensitive material. Many people don't like Green Berets because they don't do 24/7 Direct Action but the reality is that the more versatile a unit like the SF are teachers, who teach and then lead guerrillas to hit targets deep behind enemy lines, that's always going to have an advantage, because they can operate before, during and after the war, that's why units that only do direct action are limited, because they can't be used all the time.
The ending is not wrong. My Dad was medically rolled out of buds after a shoulder injury and was in limbo for a while. They wanted him to try SWCC but that never happed. It took a while but eventually he became an electronics technician and 9 years after he joined the Navy all together, he became a Seabee.
So weird I thought you were one of my siblings the way you said that. My dad exactly the same. Airborne Ranger. We’re adults and all still scared of him
@@jrocks273 Are you tough enough? 1. Get saved by the Lord Jesus Christ immediately. 2. Read the King James bible daily. 3. Pray and give thanks for all things daily. Those are the main three things. Romans 10:9 That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.
I was in the Army from 80s to 90s I was a sniper but not Ranger. Ive seen 3 training exercises that involved both seals & rangers. Also there's 2 types of Rangers, there's the lone guy who completes ranger school and wears a tab then there's a guy who belongs to a Ranger battalion. The 1 who belongs to the Ranger Battalion is on par with anybody including Seals. A unit from a Ranger Battalion can pretty much hold their own against a seal team. Even water operations, Rangers do that as well. When I saw them do joint training exercises you couldnt tell the difference - The marines [Raiders]have specialized units that are just as good also they were there competing. These exercises happened in Alaska, Panama, and California. The exercise in Alaska the Seals made a grand entrance, The Army & Marines repelled out of a Huge Helicopter but the seals came out of nowhere on a rubber raft onto the beach.
A ranger battalion could hold their own against a seal team huh? You realize that there are 600 rangers in a batllion and only 16 seals on a team? Well I guess yeah, a ranger batallion of 600 could hold their own against just 16 men lol. I SERIOUSLY DOUBT you were ever much more than a cook in the army and def not a sniper lol.
@@biztranfsboThere's basic rangers and then there's the most skilled rangers, depends on the tier. Tier 1 rangers can easily hold their own against Navy Seals.
The Ranger tradition begins with King Philip's War under Benjamin Church, who used the notation, "This day ranged _ miles". One of his men killed King Philip of the Wampanoag Indians.
@NomadSupreme911 lol dude raiders do not even compare to Rangers. Rangers are fitter, more aggressive, tactically far superior than a fucking recon. You know so many recon dudes regret not going rangers
If you want something done quietly but have promising book deals, send in the SEALS, if you want something done by professional "Make that guy dead and don't talk about it", send in the rangers.
@@deathfire096Rangers are the most toxic fuckin crybabies out of all the DOD. I guarantee there’s just as many Strangers that wrote books, but they don’t get the hype cause no one cares to hear from a ranger danger 😂😂
Comparing Rangers and SEALs is like comparing football players to rugby players. Different skill sets for different missions. But I’ve seen and worked with both. Rangers carry a higher caliber of competence and professionalism than SEALs. Fight me.
Doubt it. It's Army after all. These are the same people that shot Pat Tillman 3 times to the head and 2 times up close and then blamed it on the enemy. So much for a higher caliber of competence and professionalism. LOL
@@deathfire096 ever heard of ‘Code Over Country’ by Matthew A. Coleman? It’s an entire book on SEAL faux pas in the last 50 years or so. Read a book. Be enlightened. Your super heroes are overrated and under qualified for the missions they usually fuck up. 🤷🏻♂️
@@deathfire096 -ST6 leaves man behind on mountain in Afghanistan (captured on film) -ST6 murders Green Beret and tires to cover it up. -ST6 kills hostage with grenade, then sends false report -ST6 unnecessarily mutilates enemy bodies BTW, Rangers saved the one SEAL left on a poorly executed mission that should have never been conducted.
@@SNAKEEATER1776 Another Anti American Book? NO, thanks. I couldn’t help but wonder if he wasn’t bullied in school by alpha male types, because that’s how it seemed to come off. Let's compare all the screw ups since Vietnam to the Iraq war. Let's see who has the most screw ups. (wink, wink Army) I wonder why. I mean it's hard to swallow the Pat Tillman's case. Shot 3 times in the head and up close again and blamed it on the enemy? Is that what you call leadership.
@@SNAKEEATER1776 Saved? LOL they were on patrol in the area with the Afghanistan National Guard, it's their job. Now do the war crimes from Rangers since Vietnam. Come one, don't get timid now. Go look up Army Ranger John Needham in how he exposed war crimes by Rangers in Iraq and got punished for it. How Army Ranger Ray Girouard accused of war crimes of ordering the deaths of 3 unarmed Iraqi civilians. How about Army Ranger Alex Blum that turned into a criminal and bank robber. Army Ranger Elliot Sommer part of a 4 member Ranger crew in Fort Lewis robbing banks, rapes and killing in the war. 5 Rangers were arrested and charged with abusing detainees in Iraq in 2005. Rangers crimes are long and that's just in the Iraq/Afghanistan wars. I'm not touching Vietnan, where villages were burned down and people killed and raped. You open the can of worms when Rangers live in a china glass house. Thanks for the laugh.
Dude Roger's Rangers were a sick little group of psychos from the Isles, they knew everything from tomahawk combat, to wilderness survival to coded communications. Colonials were scared to death of them respectfully . I think the series TurN on HBO portrayed them pretty well.
Rangers and Seals have different missions. However, during the GWOT every military branch commander wanted a piece of the pie. For the most part, Navy and Marines should not have been so involved in land warfare occupation in the Middle East. But it obviously happened. Just food for thought
Army Rangers aren't Always writing books and making movies and they're the ones who help Navy SEAL's who seem to always be in some type of trouble after they've finished their training which lasts significantly longer than Ranger training
They're are plenty of books written by Rangers. Don't get mad at SEALs because no one wants to read them because people understand the Rangers are really just glorified conventional infantry.
@@NomadSupreme911ranger regiment are “glorified conventional infantry” who do raids, mission planning, rifle marksmanship, rucking, land navigation, small unit tactics, breaching, CQB, CSAR, medical training, airborne operations, land reconnaissance better than any vanilla SEAL team. Regular active duty light infantry does most of these things better than vanilla SEALs. Rangers also have out shot SEALs almost every year at the USASOC sniper competition which is the most prestigious shooting competition in the military.
@@NomadSupreme911 Spoken like a typical ignorant SEAL fanboy who underestimates ranger regiment because he thinks the only high-speed things rangers do are RASP and ranger school. Army Ranger school is a small unit tactics leadership school unaffiliated with 75th RR. Ranger school falls under the airborne and ranger training brigade. 75th RR falls under USASOC. Anybody can go to ranger school although priority slots always go first to entry level army infantry officers followed by soldiers assigned to 75th RR. SEALs dont get anywhere near the same level of land warfare training as rangers. The path of an infantrymen who has a 75th ranger contract looks like this. All infantrymen regardless of where they are going must attend one station unit training (OSUT) which was 14 weeks. OSUT encompasses basic training and AIT for infantrymen where they start learning infantry skills. As of 2018 OSUT is 22 weeks long. www.army.mil/article/214765/22_week_infantry_osut_pilot_program_trainees_graduate_at_forefront_of_soldier_lethality After 22 weeks of OSUT the ranger candidate will then attend three week airborne school followed by 8 week RASP(ranger assessment and selection program). During 8 week RASP ranger candidates continue to learn marksmanship, medical training, physical training, small unit tactics and mobility. After graduating RASP the candidate gets assigned to a ranger battalion. Before the candidate can serve as a leader in 75th RR he or she must graduate 8 week ranger school. Training is continuous in 75th RR focusing on the big 5: marksmanship, physical fitness, medical training, small unit tactics, and mobility. ruclips.net/video/DHK5QJOx72M/видео.html Regular entry level active-duty conventional infantry soldiers get more soldiering skills than SEALs who dont start learning land warfare until 3rd phase of BUDs. Rangers are often underestimated because they intentionally do not give their continuous training cycles fancy names.
The bottom line is that it is WAY harder to become a Seal than a ranger. Seals don't stop training after buds either. Ranger fanboys act like rangers are the only unit that keeps training.
@@NomadSupreme911 Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Yes even though your idea would also make another additional great video to dissect and watch here on GD. What makes your idea more appropriate than mine? I could say the same about your comment. Raiders and Rangers are more comparable because their both tier II, both have 3 battalions, both are described as light infantry (amphibious of course for raiders this is provided by wiki) both conduct and perform very similar missions and skill sets as well from Direct action, Raiding, Special operations, special reconnaissance etc. Size isn’t everything all the time. Their similarities and differences is what makes it an interesting video. Try thinking outside our comfortable little box before believing your ideas are superior to others.
@@praductjunior1519 tier isn't everything people think it is. Rangers don't receive the individual specialized training that other tier two units receive. Force recon gets WAY more specialized training than rangers but aren't officially special operators because they aren't a part of socom. Rangers are a highly trained CONVENTIONAL infantry unit on loan to SOCOM and JSOC to avoid the beaurocratic nightmare of SOCOM and JSOC having to ask the conventional military if they can borrow their best conventional infantrymen.
@@NomadSupreme911 Again, tier might not be everything’s it’s all hyped up to be (It’s just funding) but neither is battalion sized capabilities. You just turned your original opinionated statement into a fallacious argument. And for what? Initially your said Rangers and battalion level recon was more appropriate now you’re moving the goalpost onto FORECON and their training? Another hole in your hubris is, as respectable and SOC my Ricky Recon brothers are they don’t even fall under SOCOM. Like Raiders and Rangers do. Furthermore, if your sole focus is just this self perpetuating pontification of my idea is better than yours because Rangers and battalion recon make more sense because FORECON gets way more specialized training, then you should personally take the time and write GD. Informing them that they wasted their time and effort making a video comparing Navy SEALs and Army Rangers. Because we all know Navy SEALs are no battalion.
@@NomadSupreme911what individualized training don’t Rangers receive? Your understanding is pre 90s, and you keep equating ranger school with the 75th. My guess is you’re a regular army infantrymen who thinks you’re just as qualified as an actual Army Ranger because it feels good to brag without any of the training.
I guess General Discharge needs new clicks to get paid with another A vs B video. I'm waiting for the video of Submariners vs Tankers. Who has the better chow?
Do a video on the Irish Army Ranger Wing. They're the Tier 1 SF group of Ireland don't get nearly enough attention to themselves or the insane feats they've pulled off, such as beating the top US Tier 1 teams in the US'S national sniper competition, being the first non US-country ever to win.
@@spartanwarrior1 I know. They're so secretive, the only things you can find on them are the things the Irish government let's you know for promotional reasons. They're so secretive that they wear other countries uniforms when they're working with other teams since they're from a neutral country. Like when they went to Timor with the US and the Rangers did some stuff they technically wouldn't be allowed to do, so they wore US uniforms.
It’s not entirely true that all members of the 75th have their Ranger tab, especially among support MOSs. It was a rare, but I knew one MSG in the STB that didn’t have his tab.
Mos Def, they’ll send an infantry guy to ranger school first before a comms guy or a HQ platoon guy and at least back in the 80’s they’d make you reup to get the tab as you had to have 2 years left on your enlistment after ranger school to justify giving the school seat. I went to jumpschool in 1987 and they had the RIP recruiter there, I should have done it but I was a totally undisciplined kid and didn’t want to make the army a career so I didn’t do it. Biggest regret of my life but that’s life.
Regimental rangers don't necessarily go to ranger school before becoming a ranger. They have to ran through airborne school and rasp but can be deployed with the regiment multiple times before being assigned to ranger school.
@@275Vet-RLTW correct and as you may know this varies amongst career field and adds to the debate of “what is a Ranger.” A Ranger medic that I spoke to once, never attended RS. He said that the OpTempo was too high and that he was more of an asset to this unit along side them on train-up and deployments than in Ranger School.
That's good but you should be more concerned with your fitness, if you're not a PT monster already doing at least one 12mi ruck every week, preferably two, you had better get motivated FRFR or they are going to rip your balls of like a wet paper towel in RASP. Some of the guys you'll go through and compete with have been after it for YEARS already.
@@darkgardener9577A 12 mile ruck every week can work just fine in the short term but that’s gonna tear any inexperienced rucker to shreds eventually, they need to pace their training especially in that regard. Running on the other hand, they can do much more liberally
Bro you do the dopest military videos I stg. Also, I'm looking to go into the military as soon as I graduate and I want to become an ELITE medic, which branch would you point me towards in order to recieve the best of the best medical training that the military can offer? I watchedd some of your other videos on the subject but I would love to another video by you discussing the Tier 1 Medics and which one you would say has the better training. Thanks General!
@@TheMangolorian735 or the Navy and become a SARC, not saying they are tier 1 but ....If rescue is more your thing,do the PJ. if its the medical, become a SARC.
@@assclapper2231 Reinforce is save you dumb grunt. Rangers were being overrun by the Taliban. Rangers never get shot down? Ask Pat Tillman about that. 3 shots to the head and 2 to the chest at close range and then the Rangers blamed it on the enemy. Thanks for the laugh grunt. By the way, not only SEALs were killed in Extortion 17 but Army and Air Force operators since this was a multiple branch war. How old you are?
@@assclapper2231 Cope because neither units you mentioned fly’s the crashes y’all are talking about? Are you that fucking stupid or you’re glazing some people you couldn’t hope to be? No reason to cope because I prefer PJ’s.
It’s embarrassing that you guys bring up a tragedy like Extortion 17. SEALs went on that helicopter because they wanted to help their Ranger brothers in arms. Yet, you guys here on this forum go back and forth about how Rangers or SEALs are better like a sports team.
During World War II, Rangers provided vigilant internal security in Texas. Ranger duties varied from showing air raid warning training films to tracking down escaped German POWs later in the war. When U.S. Army Rangers landed in France, the German press thought those commandos were Texas Rangers. This apparently caused considerable anxiety among the German people. The Reich's minister of propaganda eventually had to clarify matters.
7:30. Seals are NOT only combat element in Navy.. Marine is nothing more then Navel infantry . As a Airborne Ranger. I have nothing but respect for Seals. However I do not remember an opp when seals had to rescue Rangers. On the other hand. I remember several opps when we saved seals. Just saying.
The Ranger Regiment doesn’t have a maritime component but some go through the Army’s Combat Diver school which is considered the toughest course In special forces. If we were to take some Rangers who are combat swimmer qualified and some Navy SEALS then they would compare greatly imo.
Army Combat Diver School is NOT the same as Navy Combat Diver School. Navy trains in deeper waters including from submarines. You will never see any Army CD operating from a submarine or taking siege of a ship at sea or port or take over an oil rig captured by the enemy. When the U.S. needs underwater gas pipelines to be blown up undetected they call the Seals.
And ranger regiment infantry NCOs still smoke vanilla SEALs at rucking, land navigation, small unit tactics, CQB, breaching, mission planning, airborne operations, CQM, crew served weapon competency, land reconnaissance, and scalability.
will you make a video about Marine Corps Ground Intelligence Officers (specifically Counter intel). hitting topics like how to get in and everything you have to do after IOC. physical requirements, any knowledge you should have and how to prepare. I am a Contracted Officer Candidate and would like to know. If I was in touch with any Marine Ground Intel Officers I would ask them but unfortunately I know none.
Is not their fault that Rangers have low I.Q’s to even write a sentence let alone a book. The most famous Ranger was Pat Tillman and the Rangers shot him 3 times in the head and few times at close range and blamed it on the enemy. I guess that book isn’t selling well. 😂
@@joeseph4727 They all earned the right to write a book after the little pay the U.S. government pays them. Just like some people are jealous of them that they can't be them. If they could all write a book about their job they would.
One thing that separates the two, is that the US Army Rangers conducted over 7,000-days of nonstop combat operations. They are totally superior at ground warfare and have far better soldiering skills, with the ability to hump more weight, faster, at longer distances. The SEALs are better in the ocean, but the Rangers still have combat drivers for other water operations. SEALs are good at breaking contact, while the Rangers are good at attacking and conducting QRF and Rearguard actions.
I don’t think Ranger Regiment as a whole has a water capability. I think their focus, money, and training is on Raids/ Direct Action/ Shooting. I think RRC might though but that’s only a fraction of Regiment.
You referring to SF dive teams? Because they’re not Rangers. Rangers are bad ass, but seals are much more capable on a lot of things, and operate in smaller groups.
Army Rangers and Navy SEALs : Special Operations Forces ( SOF) from Two Branches of Service. One Team , One Firefight, where Sua Sponte / RLTW meets The Only Easy Day Was Yesterday. 🇺🇲🇺🇸🪖🎖️💣💥🔥🪂🤿🔱🦭🐸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Don’t make it through the Seal pipeline…welcome to the fleet as an undesignated striker, you’ll become intimately familiar with the location of the paint locker…
Those are the ones that sign undesignated. Look at it the bright side, once they do their 4 years ,they will have plenty of experience in maritime maintenance but they will be ALIVE! That is job security. Beats a job at security in grave yard shift at some company nobody even heard of.
It's a dumb question we do such different mission sets. You wouldn't send a SEAL platoon to combat jump and seize an airfield or to pull security around a huge area. You wouldn't call us to get in a gunfight on the water and seize a cargo ship. We all do what we do the question is not practical.
Ranger regiment does all land land warfare related tasks better than vanilla SEAL teams and most land warfare tasks better than ST6. SEALs are only super elite compared with the rest of the navy.
Been waiting for a video like this I’m 14 and deciding whether to pursue my career in soccer or potentially join the army as a army ranger or navy seal thank you for making this video comparing the two.
Why be a Ranger or Seal???? Do something that translates to a good civilian job after you leave the military!!! The main reason that people want a job as a Seal, Ranger, or whatever so they can brag to their friends saying they're "badass!!". Don't worry about being so-called "badass!". Americans LOVE to brag!! 😡😡🤬🤬
@@bigdee8189 Yep, and those dudes DOR faster than you can say Jack. Some people don’t want to transfer to the civilian life, or want to do something cool first, there are few places where one could make a living out of shooting guns and jumping out of planes.
A bar buddy, drunk, havent seen him in a while said to me after I asked about his son..."The seals took my boy out of rangers because he was doing so well and they needed him." I said "Yeah? wow, so he's a seal now?" And he said "Well no, cuz then special forces pulled him from BUD's because they needed him there so he will decide what he wants to do." -- Love americans!
Seals pick the lock on the back door and hope to be gone before anyone knows. Rangers kick the front door in and kill everything. Both bad ass just different missions. The Marcus Latrell story will tell you everything you want to know. Marcus is one of the toughest guy's to fire a shot in anger in a long time, he is definitely thankful for Rangers.
No Comparison both are Elite and Bad ass. It doesn't matter what branch of the Military They're all brothers/sisters fighting for our Country.They would kill/die for one another.:NO MAN LEFT BEHIND, IT DOESNT MATTER NAVY SEAL OR ARMY RANGER.. RESPECT& SALUTE TO BOTH🫡🫡 THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR SERVICES & SACRIFICES
My grandfather jumped into Munsan-Ni as an officer with 4th Ranger Company. Took some objective with a small team. Before 187th got there. Commander of 187 was pussed he took his glory. He took his medic, a conscientious objector, and a few guys uo the hill and trenches to take out some nests. He ran outta ammo. Used their weapons. Used his ka-bar. Got to the top. He ate a grenade shrapnel to the face and neck. Then north korean got hin in the groun with a bayonet. Grandpa grabbed his hands so he couldnt fire. His weapon having been blown away. Thats when his medic ceased to be a conscientious objector frim then on after killing gladly. Grandpa got the nickname Iron Mike. He later became commander of 5th group. Created and ran rhe largest MIKE Forces and Project Delta work. Credited with saving SF from Abrams. He then commanded JFK CENTER helping create the five new mission sets a team. I have some videos of him talking about it if any history buffs want. Theyre in the middle writing a book right now as he and his wife passed recently Retired MG.
95 percent of seals haven’t seen combat or deployed. ST6 is the only seal unit that is heavily used. Vanilla Seals also have a horrible reputation within the SOF community. Rangers…. Those who know know.
Ranger Pipeline is a lot shorter (2 months). SEAL Pipeline is 1 and a half years. Rangers usually operate as larger elements than SEALs. However, staying in Regiment is no joke. If you are not cutting it, you will get RFS’d.
@@joeseph4727 I want a challenge, navy seals sounds like something that can push me beyond my limits. I know rangers is very difficult and hard but I think being with them would limit me as to the seals extensive training
Even Navy SEALs need Heros. RLTW ! First worked with some SEALs from an East Coast Team in a far away undisclosed Jungle location. So I will say this: The Reputation they have in working with The Army, Rangers specifically, exists for a reason.
All communities worked together in the last wars. Rangers, SF, Delta, Seals, Devgru and Air Force will work together. They are got their specific mission.
@deathfire096 No Shit, this was BEFORE 9/11 also. My statement was just informing that, yes they work together and both are Professionals but there is animosity there. If ever given a 'choice' as to which unit I would rather/ love to work with again; it would be Force Recon Marines and/or MARSOC Marines. A SEAL couldn't carry their boots, and of course the CCT guys, they ARE Supermen. And they also carry the best Radios and can talk to God. (when they need to) RLTW !
@@bradleywayne3943 Why is there an animosity since both have their own missions and role in a war. Sounds childish. I don’t think the SEALs are losing any sleep because you want to work with the Marines. The SEAL and the Naval Warfare are a pretty tight community.
@deathfire096 You answered your own question. If you were a part of either one you would understand more, especially when you get to certain Teams or Units working with other Certain Elements of Other Branches. There are examples on examples of this shit playing out on the Battlefield both ways as well. Ex1 the Op in Sadr City that CPO Stumpf from DEVGRU and SFC Grey from 'Delta'. Each took care of their own. Ex 2 (good): The extraction of Lt. Redman. I could go on but this is just a 'comment'
@@deathfire096 I work with Seals, SF, MARSOC, and Rangers as a contractor on the other side of the world, l'm former USCG TACLET and SWAT sniper cop my boi, oh did l mention lm their boss too.
Seems like your remaking a lot of old vids. That’s dandy but could you make some more “fresh” ideas. One that would be cool is maybe a video on space force or the NGA agency
While the Rangers are Specialized unit, it shouldn't be called a Tier 1,(You can't even compare Rangers with Delta, DEVGRU or even the PJs). Rangers can't even be compared with the Seal teams. The base of this argument is that these units have received much more intensive trainning before become operational which place them a step or two up the ladder. At the end of the day We're all Brothers fighting towards the same goal and ammunition fired from the enemy doesn't differentiate between any Branch of Service or specific unit. All of our Brothers are special because every live is priceless. Semper Fi Brothers!.
strictly speaking from a civilians perspective, the main difference between SEAL's and rangers is SEAL' will typically tell you of their job, even tho you didnt ask. and when they retire or quit, they start a podcast or right a book talking about it while making youtube channels discussing CQB tactics and nitpicking police or home defense videos not up to snuff with highly trained tier1 guys. ranger's on the other hand, will keep it quiet and professional until they quit. then, they start either a coffee or metal working business and grow a beard and wear nothing but viking or samurai appearal, sometimes both.
I doubt you’ve ever met a SEAL in your life judging by this comment. I have known many SEALs. None of them told me anything about their military service for years. You are taking the actions of a handful of dudes and deciding that an entire organization is nothing but ignorant, money hungry loudmouths?
How many SEAls walked up you and told you they were SEALs? your post is full of b.s. Rangers are easy to spot. Weird haircuts , tab, Ranger tattoo or Ranger shirt and most can't swim. The main difference is SEALs are by far better fit even when they retired. Most Rangers get fat and become drunks.
@@nolanfrazier3482 this guy is full of b.s. NO SEAL will walk up to a civilian and tell them they are SEAL and tell you of their job without being asked. SEALs are a very tight community and they stick with themselves with the wives and kids on base. It's funny about social media and books, Rangers write books and are in social media talking about their pipeline. I just finished watching 2 videos on Yourtube on Rangers training and graduation. This is what you call selective outrage about books.
It’s a joke dude, a common joke amongst those in the ranger/seal community, not your creepy neighbors di:/. Don’t take it up the but so hard. And yes, I have met several seals and rangers including too good friends who are the very definition of quiet professional.. unless it’s making fun of others special operations community members, then it’s a free for all. Chill homie. Have a laugh drink a beer. Enjoy the show and for goodness sake Understand internet humor
The way it’s been explained to me is the that Navy Seals are the Fleets( navy and marine corp ) answer to the Rangers And Marsoc is the Fleets Answer to the Green berets.
Navy Seal s can take down an Airport too. I think here in the war on Terror and all that. Seals took a Airport and held it for some one to come take it off their hands.
@deathfire096 uh no you're dumb. 75th Ranger Regiment is part of SOCOM but when they go OCONUS, they fall under JSOC working along side Delta. That's why they get two fundings.
In light of recent and ongoing events, please do a video covering Ukrainian Special Forces. Complete badasses with an interesting origin story. I started watching your content last year and love the format and presentation. 🇺🇦🔱🌻
Play Enlisted for FREE on PC, Xbox Series X|S and PS5 - Follow the link to download the game and get your exclusive bonus now. See you in battle! playen.link/generaldischarge
Which one is your favorite - Army Rangers or Navy SEALs?
Help us reach 5,000 Followers on Facebook: facebook.com/gendischarge
PATREON: patreon.com/generaldischarge
LINKTREE: linktr.ee/generaldischarge
Reconnaissance marines vs army rangers
Please do Army Counterintelligence next.
Army Rangers Hooah. I like Navy Seal too.
@@ericbelton6239 nice
@@SayNoToDemocide1 nice
That advice at the end is invaluable. Take a calculated risk, just don't quit. That really sums it up because the selection process is designed to do just that, make you quit.
Both are tremendous units with very different missions. People should stop treating both like a sports team.
Thank you !!! Kill’s me to here civilian talk about these different units like they are football teams
Or maybe the competition between them is a good thing. Compete with each other to be the best to destroy the enemy better
@@trobertwthere is no competition. Both have objectives. Both are highly trained. They often operate tigether with different objectives within the same mission
One is Army, one is Navy. At the end of the day, despite the camaraderie between us, we’re all part of the Armed Forces. Phuck that separation of vs
That’s the cool thing kids do
There is no direct action force more capable and scalable than the 75th Ranger Regiment, they even have their Tier 1 RRC unit, but regular Rangers can be deployed from squads of 8 or 9 up to 1,500 a battalion, Rangers in Afghanistan in a single deployment killed or captured more than 1,500 terrorists. Neither joining the devgroup with normal seals nor together can they kill that many insurgents in one deployment, in the end I'm just saying that each unit is unique and the best at what it does.
No shit they’re literally an infantry battalion. Even the regular conventional army and marines killed more people than special operations…
All due respect man, that whack-mole-counterterrorism/counter insurgent is how we keep losing fights and our brothers. The war of attrition doesn’t work for us, foreign internal defense and intelligence operations are what really pay the dividends, that’s why CAG/ST6/ISA/SAD and other SMUs are preferred for high profile missions
I understand you!! and you're right, but what happens is that mostly foreign internal defense is done by the green berets, even the green berets during the Gwot created CiF companies that rescued hostages, and were in charge of direct action. Now that the USA is going against China the Green Berets have also just created HTD Hard Target Defeat units to break into underground bunkers, rescue hostages and search and destroy sensitive material. Many people don't like Green Berets because they don't do 24/7 Direct Action but the reality is that the more versatile a unit like the SF are teachers, who teach and then lead guerrillas to hit targets deep behind enemy lines, that's always going to have an advantage, because they can operate before, during and after the war, that's why units that only do direct action are limited, because they can't be used all the time.
SAS/SBS 🎉
Facts
The ending is not wrong. My Dad was medically rolled out of buds after a shoulder injury and was in limbo for a while. They wanted him to try SWCC but that never happed. It took a while but eventually he became an electronics technician and 9 years after he joined the Navy all together, he became a Seabee.
My dad is a U.S. Army Special Forces Green Beret. Still scared of him, but he’s a badass.
So weird I thought you were one of my siblings the way you said that. My dad exactly the same. Airborne Ranger. We’re adults and all still scared of him
My big brother was 2nd Batallion 75 Rangers, went in at 17 and went straight to Georgia after basic.
Nice
@@emmanuelawosusi2365 yeah he’s a great guy, my other two older brothers followed his footsteps and went in years later.
@@nubbletv3822 that whats up
Who f*cking cares!!??
Cool
*”One’s harder to get into, the other is harder to stay in.”*
I'd say that's true. Being in a Ranger Batt... is harder than being in any other SOF unit. The standard is no mother fucking joke.
@@MM-qt8gzy’all are forgetting CCT.
@@MM-qt8gz can you tell me.more about it I've been acting to.join the forces but I'm stuck between marine or ranger school
@@jrocks273
Are you tough enough?
1. Get saved by the Lord Jesus Christ immediately. 2. Read the King James bible daily. 3. Pray and give thanks for all things daily. Those are the main three things. Romans 10:9 That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.
@@storm2945I’m gonna join the air force after I’m done with the army
I had a friend in college who was a UDT. This was back in the 1970's. He told me a little bit about what they did on D-day.
you were in college with a 50 year old?
@@AF-bl1lkgi bill
BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA! My thoughts, exactly!!@@AF-bl1lk
I was in the Army from 80s to 90s I was a sniper but not Ranger. Ive seen 3 training exercises that involved both seals & rangers. Also there's 2 types of Rangers, there's the lone guy who completes ranger school and wears a tab then there's a guy who belongs to a Ranger battalion. The 1 who belongs to the Ranger Battalion is on par with anybody including Seals. A unit from a Ranger Battalion can pretty much hold their own against a seal team. Even water operations, Rangers do that as well. When I saw them do joint training exercises you couldnt tell the difference - The marines [Raiders]have specialized units that are just as good also they were there competing. These exercises happened in Alaska, Panama, and California. The exercise in Alaska the Seals made a grand entrance, The Army & Marines repelled out of a Huge Helicopter but the seals came out of nowhere on a rubber raft onto the beach.
Yeah. Being tabbed isn't the same as regiment.
A ranger battalion could hold their own against a seal team huh? You realize that there are 600 rangers in a batllion and only 16 seals on a team? Well I guess yeah, a ranger batallion of 600 could hold their own against just 16 men lol. I SERIOUSLY DOUBT you were ever much more than a cook in the army and def not a sniper lol.
@@biztranfsboThere's basic rangers and then there's the most skilled rangers, depends on the tier. Tier 1 rangers can easily hold their own against Navy Seals.
@@biztranfsbo i really don't give a fuck what you believe
@@biztranfsbostop playing so much call of duty bro. The Rangers' achievements make Seals look like imbeciles
one is in the army the other is in the navy
As simple as that 😂
They are spec ops. But ranger deploy for
Tasks that require a decent number of troops while seals deployments are much smaller
@@paleriderpublishing451 but now ranger got their own elit unit / group too: the regimental reconnasaincce company.
Lol smart-ass answer 🤣
I was wondering…couldn’t put my finger on it…so thanks….haha😅
The Ranger tradition begins with King Philip's War under Benjamin Church, who used the notation, "This day ranged _ miles". One of his men killed King Philip of the Wampanoag Indians.
A force recon/raider vs rangers would be a dope video
Force recon and raiders have way more individual specialized training than rangers. Rangers should be compared to BATTALION recon.
@NomadSupreme911 lol dude raiders do not even compare to Rangers. Rangers are fitter, more aggressive, tactically far superior than a fucking recon. You know so many recon dudes regret not going rangers
@@MM-qt8gz you need to read your own comment. You switched from raiders to recon. You do know there is a difference?
If you want something done quietly but have promising book deals, send in the SEALS, if you want something done by professional "Make that guy dead and don't talk about it", send in the rangers.
if you want to mess up the mission and shoot your own and then blame it on the enemy and be jealous of the Seals, send it to the Rangers.
@@deathfire096so you have nothing better to do than go and reply to all these comments by whining about the army? 😂
@@dominomurphy4223 I only reply to dumb people. 😂
@@dominomurphy4223 He's probably someone who never made it pass MEPS.
@@deathfire096Rangers are the most toxic fuckin crybabies out of all the DOD. I guarantee there’s just as many Strangers that wrote books, but they don’t get the hype cause no one cares to hear from a ranger danger 😂😂
As a former 2nd bat Ranger we encouraged professionalism and modesty. My experience with SEALs indicated that wasn't as strongly emphasized.
Comparing Rangers and SEALs is like comparing football players to rugby players. Different skill sets for different missions.
But I’ve seen and worked with both. Rangers carry a higher caliber of competence and professionalism than SEALs.
Fight me.
Doubt it. It's Army after all. These are the same people that shot Pat Tillman 3 times to the head and 2 times up close and then blamed it on the enemy. So much for a higher caliber of competence and professionalism. LOL
@@deathfire096 ever heard of ‘Code Over Country’ by Matthew A. Coleman? It’s an entire book on SEAL faux pas in the last 50 years or so. Read a book. Be enlightened. Your super heroes are overrated and under qualified for the missions they usually fuck up. 🤷🏻♂️
@@deathfire096 -ST6 leaves man behind on mountain in Afghanistan (captured on film)
-ST6 murders Green Beret and tires to cover it up.
-ST6 kills hostage with grenade, then sends false report
-ST6 unnecessarily mutilates enemy bodies
BTW, Rangers saved the one SEAL left on a poorly executed mission that should have never been conducted.
@@SNAKEEATER1776 Another Anti American Book? NO, thanks. I couldn’t help but wonder if he wasn’t bullied in school by alpha male types, because that’s how it seemed to come off. Let's compare all the screw ups since Vietnam to the Iraq war. Let's see who has the most screw ups. (wink, wink Army) I wonder why. I mean it's hard to swallow the Pat Tillman's case. Shot 3 times in the head and up close again and blamed it on the enemy? Is that what you call leadership.
@@SNAKEEATER1776 Saved? LOL they were on patrol in the area with the Afghanistan National Guard, it's their job. Now do the war crimes from Rangers since Vietnam. Come one, don't get timid now. Go look up Army Ranger John Needham in how he exposed war crimes by Rangers in Iraq and got punished for it. How Army Ranger Ray Girouard accused of war crimes of ordering the deaths of 3 unarmed Iraqi civilians. How about Army Ranger Alex Blum that turned into a criminal and bank robber. Army Ranger Elliot Sommer part of a 4 member Ranger crew in Fort Lewis robbing banks, rapes and killing in the war. 5 Rangers were arrested and charged with abusing detainees in Iraq in 2005. Rangers crimes are long and that's just in the Iraq/Afghanistan wars. I'm not touching Vietnan, where villages were burned down and people killed and raped. You open the can of worms when Rangers live in a china glass house. Thanks for the laugh.
Dude Roger's Rangers were a sick little group of psychos from the Isles, they knew everything from tomahawk combat, to wilderness survival to coded communications. Colonials were scared to death of them respectfully .
I think the series TurN on HBO portrayed them pretty well.
Tomahawk combat 😂 that’s a new one
@@na8522 definitely is for a milk drinker like you 😭
This shit sounds epic looking it up. Your a good man thank yoy
Rangers and Seals have different missions. However, during the GWOT every military branch commander wanted a piece of the pie. For the most part, Navy and Marines should not have been so involved in land warfare occupation in the Middle East. But it obviously happened. Just food for thought
Good info on the Ranger regiment and how the scroll differs from the tab
Army cooks vs Navy cooks. Who cooks the better and healthier food.
National guard cooks are better 😂
Great vid! I've enjoyed watching your channel grow throughout the years! Hooyah!
Please do United States Army Counterintelligence next!
Army Rangers aren't Always writing books and making movies and they're the ones who help Navy SEAL's who seem to always be in some type of trouble after they've finished their training which lasts significantly longer than Ranger training
They're are plenty of books written by Rangers. Don't get mad at SEALs because no one wants to read them because people understand the Rangers are really just glorified conventional infantry.
@@NomadSupreme911ranger regiment are “glorified conventional infantry” who do raids, mission planning, rifle marksmanship, rucking, land navigation, small unit tactics, breaching, CQB, CSAR, medical training, airborne operations, land reconnaissance better than any vanilla SEAL team. Regular active duty light infantry does most of these things better than vanilla SEALs.
Rangers also have out shot SEALs almost every year at the USASOC sniper competition which is the most prestigious shooting competition in the military.
@@sgedeon01 it takes like sixty days to become a Ranger. They're just infantry. Period.
@@NomadSupreme911 Spoken like a typical ignorant SEAL fanboy who underestimates ranger regiment because he thinks the only high-speed things rangers do are RASP and ranger school.
Army Ranger school is a small unit tactics leadership school unaffiliated with 75th RR. Ranger school falls under the airborne and ranger training brigade. 75th RR falls under USASOC. Anybody can go to ranger school although priority slots always go first to entry level army infantry officers followed by soldiers assigned to 75th RR.
SEALs dont get anywhere near the same level of land warfare training as rangers.
The path of an infantrymen who has a 75th ranger contract looks like this.
All infantrymen regardless of where they are going must attend one station unit training (OSUT) which was 14 weeks. OSUT encompasses basic training and AIT for infantrymen where they start learning infantry skills. As of 2018 OSUT is 22 weeks long.
www.army.mil/article/214765/22_week_infantry_osut_pilot_program_trainees_graduate_at_forefront_of_soldier_lethality
After 22 weeks of OSUT the ranger candidate will then attend three week airborne school followed by 8 week RASP(ranger assessment and selection program). During 8 week RASP ranger candidates continue to learn marksmanship, medical training, physical training, small unit tactics and mobility.
After graduating RASP the candidate gets assigned to a ranger battalion. Before the candidate can serve as a leader in 75th RR he or she must graduate 8 week ranger school.
Training is continuous in 75th RR focusing on the big 5: marksmanship, physical fitness, medical training, small unit tactics, and mobility. ruclips.net/video/DHK5QJOx72M/видео.html
Regular entry level active-duty conventional infantry soldiers get more soldiering skills than SEALs who dont start learning land warfare until 3rd phase of BUDs.
Rangers are often underestimated because they intentionally do not give their continuous training cycles fancy names.
The bottom line is that it is WAY harder to become a Seal than a ranger. Seals don't stop training after buds either. Ranger fanboys act like rangers are the only unit that keeps training.
Basically SEALs do sneaky behind the enemy shit while Rangers have the ability to do that but their main focus is head to head and direct combat.
not in the ocean or any port.
This was an awesome vid gentleman. Any chance on getting a Marine Raiders vs Army Rangers anytime soon?
Rangers vs battalion recon would be more appropriate. Raiders are more capararable to seals and green berets.
@@NomadSupreme911 Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Yes even though your idea would also make another additional great video to dissect and watch here on GD. What makes your idea more appropriate than mine? I could say the same about your comment. Raiders and Rangers are more comparable because their both tier II, both have 3 battalions, both are described as light infantry (amphibious of course for raiders this is provided by wiki) both conduct and perform very similar missions and skill sets as well from Direct action, Raiding,
Special operations, special reconnaissance etc. Size isn’t everything all the time. Their similarities and differences is what makes it an interesting video. Try thinking outside our comfortable little box before believing your ideas are superior to others.
@@praductjunior1519 tier isn't everything people think it is. Rangers don't receive the individual specialized training that other tier two units receive. Force recon gets WAY more specialized training than rangers but aren't officially special operators because they aren't a part of socom. Rangers are a highly trained CONVENTIONAL infantry unit on loan to SOCOM and JSOC to avoid the beaurocratic nightmare of SOCOM and JSOC having to ask the conventional military if they can borrow their best conventional infantrymen.
@@NomadSupreme911 Again, tier might not be everything’s it’s all hyped up to be (It’s just funding) but neither is battalion sized capabilities. You just turned your original opinionated statement into a fallacious argument. And for what? Initially your said Rangers and battalion level recon was more appropriate now you’re moving the goalpost onto FORECON and their training? Another hole in your hubris is, as respectable and SOC my Ricky Recon brothers are they don’t even fall under SOCOM. Like Raiders and Rangers do. Furthermore, if your sole focus is just this self perpetuating pontification of my idea is better than yours because Rangers and battalion recon make more sense because FORECON gets way more specialized training, then you should personally take the time and write GD. Informing them that they wasted their time and effort making a video comparing Navy SEALs and Army Rangers. Because we all know Navy SEALs are no battalion.
@@NomadSupreme911what individualized training don’t Rangers receive? Your understanding is pre 90s, and you keep equating ranger school with the 75th. My guess is you’re a regular army infantrymen who thinks you’re just as qualified as an actual Army Ranger because it feels good to brag without any of the training.
I guess General Discharge needs new clicks to get paid with another A vs B video. I'm waiting for the video of Submariners vs Tankers. Who has the better chow?
Do a video on the Irish Army Ranger Wing. They're the Tier 1 SF group of Ireland don't get nearly enough attention to themselves or the insane feats they've pulled off, such as beating the top US Tier 1 teams in the US'S national sniper competition, being the first non US-country ever to win.
the less the public knows about them, the better.
@@spartanwarrior1 I know. They're so secretive, the only things you can find on them are the things the Irish government let's you know for promotional reasons. They're so secretive that they wear other countries uniforms when they're working with other teams since they're from a neutral country. Like when they went to Timor with the US and the Rangers did some stuff they technically wouldn't be allowed to do, so they wore US uniforms.
Just stop. Before I laugh myself to death
@@kajemi2 Look it up
Very good explanation for a short video.
It’s not entirely true that all members of the 75th have their Ranger tab, especially among support MOSs. It was a rare, but I knew one MSG in the STB that didn’t have his tab.
Mos Def, they’ll send an infantry guy to ranger school first before a comms guy or a HQ platoon guy and at least back in the 80’s they’d make you reup to get the tab as you had to have 2 years left on your enlistment after ranger school to justify giving the school seat. I went to jumpschool in 1987 and they had the RIP recruiter there, I should have done it but I was a totally undisciplined kid and didn’t want to make the army a career so I didn’t do it. Biggest regret of my life but that’s life.
Regimental rangers don't necessarily go to ranger school before becoming a ranger. They have to ran through airborne school and rasp but can be deployed with the regiment multiple times before being assigned to ranger school.
@@275Vet-RLTW correct and as you may know this varies amongst career field and adds to the debate of “what is a Ranger.” A Ranger medic that I spoke to once, never attended RS. He said that the OpTempo was too high and that he was more of an asset to this unit along side them on train-up and deployments than in Ranger School.
I was hoping you would make this video. I am trying to enlist in October with a option 40 so I am trying learn everything I can about Rangers
If you buy the ranger handbook it will tell you about ranger history throughout its existence and more in terms of tactics, medical, etc.
That's good but you should be more concerned with your fitness, if you're not a PT monster already doing at least one 12mi ruck every week, preferably two, you had better get motivated FRFR or they are going to rip your balls of like a wet paper towel in RASP. Some of the guys you'll go through and compete with have been after it for YEARS already.
Me too but, have to get reevaluated for adhd before joining
@@darkgardener9577A 12 mile ruck every week can work just fine in the short term but that’s gonna tear any inexperienced rucker to shreds eventually, they need to pace their training especially in that regard. Running on the other hand, they can do much more liberally
@@Zero_Twice_00 ranger handbook is for ranger school. I can promise 75th doesn't use the ranger handbook lol
Bro you do the dopest military videos I stg. Also, I'm looking to go into the military as soon as I graduate and I want to become an ELITE medic, which branch would you point me towards in order to recieve the best of the best medical training that the military can offer? I watchedd some of your other videos on the subject but I would love to another video by you discussing the Tier 1 Medics and which one you would say has the better training. Thanks General!
If you are wanting to be an Elite medic, then go into the Airforce and go through their special operations pipeline to become a PJ
@@TheMangolorian735 or the Navy and become a SARC, not saying they are tier 1 but ....If rescue is more your thing,do the PJ. if its the medical, become a SARC.
Great video, you should do a vid on the SBS (special boat service) from the UK
Rangers saved the Seals many times, Seals have never had to save the Rangers
Extortion 17 happened because a helicopter of seal team six operators was shot down while flying to rescue some army rangers
@@assclapper2231 Reinforce is save you dumb grunt. Rangers were being overrun by the Taliban. Rangers never get shot down? Ask Pat Tillman about that. 3 shots to the head and 2 to the chest at close range and then the Rangers blamed it on the enemy. Thanks for the laugh grunt. By the way, not only SEALs were killed in Extortion 17 but Army and Air Force operators since this was a multiple branch war. How old you are?
@@assclapper2231I don’t get why that matter acting as if any team was flying the bird lol?
@@assclapper2231 Cope because neither units you mentioned fly’s the crashes y’all are talking about? Are you that fucking stupid or you’re glazing some people you couldn’t hope to be? No reason to cope because I prefer PJ’s.
It’s embarrassing that you guys bring up a tragedy like Extortion 17. SEALs went on that helicopter because they wanted to help their Ranger brothers in arms. Yet, you guys here on this forum go back and forth about how Rangers or SEALs are better like a sports team.
During World War II, Rangers provided vigilant internal security in Texas. Ranger duties varied from showing air raid warning training films to tracking down escaped German POWs later in the war. When U.S. Army Rangers landed in France, the German press thought those commandos were Texas Rangers. This apparently caused considerable anxiety among the German people. The Reich's minister of propaganda eventually had to clarify matters.
please make Army cooks vs Navy cooks. Who makes the best meal.
You got it!
7:30. Seals are NOT only combat element in Navy.. Marine is nothing more then Navel infantry . As a Airborne Ranger. I have nothing but respect for Seals. However I do not remember an opp when seals had to rescue Rangers. On the other hand. I remember several opps when we saved seals. Just saying.
The Ranger Regiment doesn’t have a maritime component but some go through the Army’s Combat Diver school which is considered the toughest course In special forces. If we were to take some Rangers who are combat swimmer qualified and some Navy SEALS then they would compare greatly imo.
Army Combat Diver School is NOT the same as Navy Combat Diver School. Navy trains in deeper waters including from submarines. You will never see any Army CD operating from a submarine or taking siege of a ship at sea or port or take over an oil rig captured by the enemy. When the U.S. needs underwater gas pipelines to be blown up undetected they call the Seals.
@@assclapper2231 that’s why We have the regular military for. You don’t use a Porsche 911 to haul patio garbage.
@@assclapper2231 you hit yourself like faster than I could. 😂
@@assclapper2231 prove what Rambo?
@@assclapper2231 you must be former Army grunt. Not the brightest bulbs. 😂
The Rangers can best be thought of as elite light infantry - technically, they’re not operators. The SEALS are operators
And ranger regiment infantry NCOs still smoke vanilla SEALs at rucking, land navigation, small unit tactics, CQB, breaching, mission planning, airborne operations, CQM, crew served weapon competency, land reconnaissance, and scalability.
Without watching the vid:
SEALs = scalpel
Ranger = sledgehammer
Sounds about right
Anyway to do US Navy Seals vs Korean Navy Seals? Or Crom vs KSK? Would love to see more international special operators if possible
Lmao Korean navy seal xD
@@AutomnEscrime you’re really laughing at South Korean navy seals?? Lol ! Google them. They’ve ran some pretty badass missions
@RedHotStoveAustin year they are pretty badass but not enought compared to actual navy seals
What is Crom?
You meant JW GROM vs KSK?
@@kimpapkimpaha7698 yes, misspelled it
will you make a video about Marine Corps Ground Intelligence Officers (specifically Counter intel). hitting topics like how to get in and everything you have to do after IOC. physical requirements, any knowledge you should have and how to prepare. I am a Contracted Officer Candidate and would like to know. If I was in touch with any Marine Ground Intel Officers I would ask them but unfortunately I know none.
SEALS write books and actively seek interviews
Is not their fault that Rangers have low I.Q’s to even write a sentence let alone a book. The most famous Ranger was Pat Tillman and the Rangers shot him 3 times in the head and few times at close range and blamed it on the enemy. I guess that book isn’t selling well. 😂
I feel like both guys write books. Also, the books really provide a lot of details about units that no-one would know about.
@@joeseph4727 They all earned the right to write a book after the little pay the U.S. government pays them. Just like some people are jealous of them that they can't be them. If they could all write a book about their job they would.
@@deathfire096if Seals had high IQ they wouldn‘t actively seek the camera.
@@kimpapkimpaha7698 that’s nothing to do with IQ. Plenty of Rangers on social media. According to you they have low IQ. 😂
Navy seals do podcasts when they are done serving
A couple of dudes do it and now you’re basing the whole organization off of that?
One thing that separates the two, is that the US Army Rangers conducted over 7,000-days of nonstop combat operations. They are totally superior at ground warfare and have far better soldiering skills, with the ability to hump more weight, faster, at longer distances. The SEALs are better in the ocean, but the Rangers still have combat drivers for other water operations. SEALs are good at breaking contact, while the Rangers are good at attacking and conducting QRF and Rearguard actions.
I don’t think Ranger Regiment as a whole has a water capability. I think their focus, money, and training is on Raids/ Direct Action/ Shooting. I think RRC might though but that’s only a fraction of Regiment.
This has got be the most ignorant statement I have ever read in my life.
@@Charles-nc4zj and 11 morons gave him like. LOL.
You referring to SF dive teams? Because they’re not Rangers. Rangers are bad ass, but seals are much more capable on a lot of things, and operate in smaller groups.
Along with providing search and rescue capabilities.
Nice video good comparison
They both have the BEST Equipment
SEALS are tier 1 and tier 2 and all are Combat Divers. Seals wins easily this part.
@deathfire096 you have no idea what you're talking about lmao. Regular SEALs aren't tier 1 clown
Army Rangers and Navy SEALs : Special Operations Forces ( SOF) from Two Branches of Service. One Team , One Firefight, where Sua Sponte / RLTW meets The Only Easy Day Was Yesterday. 🇺🇲🇺🇸🪖🎖️💣💥🔥🪂🤿🔱🦭🐸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Don’t make it through the Seal pipeline…welcome to the fleet as an undesignated striker, you’ll become intimately familiar with the location of the paint locker…
Those are the ones that sign undesignated. Look at it the bright side, once they do their 4 years ,they will have plenty of experience in maritime maintenance but they will be ALIVE! That is job security. Beats a job at security in grave yard shift at some company nobody even heard of.
It's a dumb question we do such different mission sets. You wouldn't send a SEAL platoon to combat jump and seize an airfield or to pull security around a huge area. You wouldn't call us to get in a gunfight on the water and seize a cargo ship. We all do what we do the question is not practical.
Comparing SEAL teams to US Army Green Beret (Special Forces ODA teams) or SEAL Team Six to Delta Force would have been a better point of comparison.
Ranger regiment does all land land warfare related tasks better than vanilla SEAL teams and most land warfare tasks better than ST6. SEALs are only super elite compared with the rest of the navy.
Not really. SEALs and 75th are way more comparable than Green Berets. Green Berets mission is totally different
I just watched all of warfighters from history channel and man army rangers seem awesome
Like from 🇪🇸. Interesting comparison.
@6:09 SEAL's just be flagging everyone!
Thank you!
I've been waiting for this! Let's fucking go 💯
Been waiting for a video like this I’m 14 and deciding whether to pursue my career in soccer or potentially join the army as a army ranger or navy seal thank you for making this video comparing the two.
It’s obviously not something you’re taking seriously.
Why be a Ranger or Seal???? Do something that translates to a good civilian job after you leave the military!!! The main reason that people want a job as a Seal, Ranger, or whatever so they can brag to their friends saying they're "badass!!". Don't worry about being so-called "badass!". Americans LOVE to brag!! 😡😡🤬🤬
@@bigdee8189 Yep, and those dudes DOR faster than you can say Jack. Some people don’t want to transfer to the civilian life, or want to do something cool first, there are few places where one could make a living out of shooting guns and jumping out of planes.
@@nolanfrazier3482 Hardly make a living, go soccer kid, you only have one chance for that, you can join the army when you’re in your 30s.
@@biglennyslastsight8759 Sling it down range like a man
"DO YOU EVEN WANNA BE HERE?!"
well yes, thats why I clicked on the video
I wouldn't say there better. They each play there part. Both are elite
Difference between us and seals.......we rescue tad pools. They've never rescued us.
Yeah, blocking force and assault force. Rangers as blocking hahaha
Wow its almost like rangers are commonly a QRF and SEALs arent. Even then the SEALs made a rescue attempt on rangers before.
Do a video on navy divers specifically please. All jobs under the umbrella of diver and training.
ruclips.net/video/OlJEGcDCHs0/видео.html
A bar buddy, drunk, havent seen him in a while said to me after I asked about his son..."The seals took my boy out of rangers because he was doing so well and they needed him." I said "Yeah? wow, so he's a seal now?" And he said "Well no, cuz then special forces pulled him from BUD's because they needed him there so he will decide what he wants to do." -- Love americans!
That's like saying, "What's better a hammer or a screw driver."
Seals pick the lock on the back door and hope to be gone before anyone knows. Rangers kick the front door in and kill everything. Both bad ass just different missions. The Marcus Latrell story will tell you everything you want to know. Marcus is one of the toughest guy's to fire a shot in anger in a long time, he is definitely thankful for Rangers.
The rangers have killed more HVTS than seals they actually started giving rangers more missions because they can handle everything thrown at them
As an ex army combat engineer 12b, do a video on Army Sappers
If anyone outside the military is serious about joining the answer is pretty cut and clear which is the better one
Can you do a vid on the cooks of each branch
how about who buffs the floors the best and who cleans the best showers.
I'm a bit biased...
B-Co 2/75 RLTW-ATW
No Comparison both are Elite and Bad ass. It doesn't matter what branch of the Military They're all brothers/sisters fighting for our Country.They would kill/die for one another.:NO MAN LEFT BEHIND, IT DOESNT MATTER NAVY SEAL OR ARMY RANGER.. RESPECT& SALUTE TO BOTH🫡🫡 THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR SERVICES & SACRIFICES
My grandfather jumped into Munsan-Ni as an officer with 4th Ranger Company. Took some objective with a small team. Before 187th got there. Commander of 187 was pussed he took his glory. He took his medic, a conscientious objector, and a few guys uo the hill and trenches to take out some nests. He ran outta ammo. Used their weapons. Used his ka-bar. Got to the top. He ate a grenade shrapnel to the face and neck. Then north korean got hin in the groun with a bayonet. Grandpa grabbed his hands so he couldnt fire. His weapon having been blown away. Thats when his medic ceased to be a conscientious objector frim then on after killing gladly. Grandpa got the nickname Iron Mike. He later became commander of 5th group. Created and ran rhe largest MIKE Forces and Project Delta work. Credited with saving SF from Abrams. He then commanded JFK CENTER helping create the five new mission sets a team. I have some videos of him talking about it if any history buffs want. Theyre in the middle writing a book right now as he and his wife passed recently Retired MG.
Sry typos. My hands don't work well
Title: which one’s better End of video: one’s not better than the other
Hey GD could you do a video in the future on what knives operators use thanks
The 75th is also there to get the Seals butts out of a fire if needed. Just call, they haul!!
LOL. You mean give a ride back to the base like they do to Delta?
4:31 motherfuckers pulled up with saws on their backs 😂 FAFO!
95 percent of seals haven’t seen combat or deployed. ST6 is the only seal unit that is heavily used. Vanilla Seals also have a horrible reputation within the SOF community.
Rangers…. Those who know know.
Rangers aren't going on any combat deployments anymore because we're in peacetime lmfao
@@geekedonxans7795 Rangers are literally deployed to Syria as we speak lol.
@@geekedonxans7795 🧢 the rangers are more utilized than seals and have killed more HVTS Google it
Can you talk about wich squad concept is better
3 teams of 3 troops +squad leader
Or 2 teams of 5 including squad leader
Or any other concepts
92G cook left me speechless
Perfect video I was considering either seal pipeline and ranger pipeline, im going to use this video to decide
Ranger Pipeline is a lot shorter (2 months). SEAL Pipeline is 1 and a half years. Rangers usually operate as larger elements than SEALs. However, staying in Regiment is no joke. If you are not cutting it, you will get RFS’d.
@@joeseph4727 I want a challenge, navy seals sounds like something that can push me beyond my limits. I know rangers is very difficult and hard but I think being with them would limit me as to the seals extensive training
Army is easily the best branch
No Marine corps
each branch is best at what they do
@@qomz8791 No only Marine corps 😂
@@germanic_lenkrad5282 But all Marines seem to hate their lives.
@@nolanfrazier3482 marine corps is easily the worst they do all hate their lives lmaooo
Hey General Discharge please do Special-Forces VS Seals
Even Navy SEALs need Heros.
RLTW !
First worked with some SEALs from an East Coast Team in a far away undisclosed Jungle location. So I will say this: The Reputation they have in working with The Army, Rangers specifically, exists for a reason.
All communities worked together in the last wars. Rangers, SF, Delta, Seals, Devgru and Air Force will work together. They are got their specific mission.
@deathfire096 No Shit, this was BEFORE 9/11 also. My statement was just informing that, yes they work together and both are Professionals but there is animosity there.
If ever given a 'choice' as to which unit I would rather/ love to work with again; it would be Force Recon Marines and/or MARSOC Marines. A SEAL couldn't carry their boots, and of course the CCT guys, they ARE Supermen. And they also carry the best Radios and can talk to God. (when they need to)
RLTW !
@@bradleywayne3943 Why is there an animosity since both have their own missions and role in a war. Sounds childish. I don’t think the SEALs are losing any sleep because you want to work with the Marines. The SEAL and the Naval Warfare are a pretty tight community.
@deathfire096 You answered your own question. If you were a part of either one you would understand more, especially when you get to certain Teams or Units working with other Certain Elements of Other Branches. There are examples on examples of this shit playing out on the Battlefield both ways as well.
Ex1 the Op in Sadr City that CPO Stumpf from DEVGRU and SFC Grey from 'Delta'. Each took care of their own.
Ex 2 (good): The extraction of Lt. Redman. I could go on but this is just a 'comment'
Lol. No seal dreams of being a little buzz cut boyscout ranger.
If I’m in the infantry, 11b, and I make the jump to rasp and fail (for any reason) is there a chance your allowed to retry as long as you don’t quit ?
Yes, absolutely. As long as you aren’t a disciplinary problem. They may ask you to wait a certain amount of time before reattempting
Can you do army special forces vs navy seals next?
I still cannot figure out how ww2 UDT were able to swim with their huge balls weighing them down
kids, wannabes, and 40 yr old role players who still live with their parents would argue over this.
The difference between a Ranger and a SEAL, is one won't stop telling you he is a SEAL ever 5 minutes during a conversation.
I doubt you have met any Seal in person and I doubt they would want to talk to you. lol
@@deathfire096 I work with Seals, SF, MARSOC, and Rangers as a contractor on the other side of the world, l'm former USCG TACLET and SWAT sniper cop my boi, oh did l mention lm their boss too.
Seems like your remaking a lot of old vids. That’s dandy but could you make some more “fresh” ideas. One that would be cool is maybe a video on space force or the NGA agency
While the Rangers are Specialized unit, it shouldn't be called a Tier 1,(You can't even compare Rangers with Delta, DEVGRU or even the PJs). Rangers can't even be compared with the Seal teams. The base of this argument is that these units have received much more intensive trainning before become operational which place them a step or two up the ladder. At the end of the day We're all Brothers fighting towards the same goal and ammunition fired from the enemy doesn't differentiate between any Branch of Service or specific unit.
All of our Brothers are special because every live is priceless.
Semper Fi Brothers!.
Can you do video on the nuclear emergency search team(Nest)
strictly speaking from a civilians perspective, the main difference between SEAL's and rangers is
SEAL' will typically tell you of their job, even tho you didnt ask. and when they retire or quit, they start a podcast or right a book talking about it while making youtube channels discussing CQB tactics and nitpicking police or home defense videos not up to snuff with highly trained tier1 guys.
ranger's on the other hand, will keep it quiet and professional until they quit. then, they start either a coffee or metal working business and grow a beard and wear nothing but viking or samurai appearal, sometimes both.
I doubt you’ve ever met a SEAL in your life judging by this comment. I have known many SEALs. None of them told me anything about their military service for years. You are taking the actions of a handful of dudes and deciding that an entire organization is nothing but ignorant, money hungry loudmouths?
How many SEAls walked up you and told you they were SEALs? your post is full of b.s. Rangers are easy to spot. Weird haircuts , tab, Ranger tattoo or Ranger shirt and most can't swim. The main difference is SEALs are by far better fit even when they retired. Most Rangers get fat and become drunks.
@@nolanfrazier3482 this guy is full of b.s. NO SEAL will walk up to a civilian and tell them they are SEAL and tell you of their job without being asked. SEALs are a very tight community and they stick with themselves with the wives and kids on base. It's funny about social media and books, Rangers write books and are in social media talking about their pipeline. I just finished watching 2 videos on Yourtube on Rangers training and graduation. This is what you call selective outrage about books.
It’s a joke dude, a common joke amongst those in the ranger/seal community, not your creepy neighbors di:/. Don’t take it up the but so hard.
And yes, I have met several seals and rangers including too good friends who are the very definition of quiet professional.. unless it’s making fun of others special operations community members, then it’s a free for all.
Chill homie. Have a laugh drink a beer. Enjoy the show and for goodness sake
Understand internet humor
@@krazykripplefitness8760 you are hilarious. You Chris Rock. You are not a Seal or Ranger but here you are cracking jokes as if you were Ranger. 😂
When SEALs get in trouble or need rescued ...they call their heroes.. the Rangers.
The way it’s been explained to me is the that
Navy Seals are the Fleets( navy and marine corp ) answer to the Rangers
And
Marsoc is the Fleets Answer to the Green berets.
Since I'm a 2 strike felon I can't get an apartment. I'm homeless.
Hey general discharge please do Compares us navy seals and us army special forces
Navy Seal s can take down an Airport too. I think here in the war on Terror and all that. Seals took a Airport and held it for some one to come take it off their hands.
I feel like Navy SEAL training is harder than Army Ranger training, but that depends on the person.
I rather do 2 months of Ranger training and NO ocean than 6 months of BUDS with ocean.
And rangers are only one who is part of jsoc. That tells you something
@@MM-qt8gz NO. Devgru (ST6), Delta, AF 24th, Ranger Recon ( just Recon) are part of JSOC.
@deathfire096 uh no you're dumb. 75th Ranger Regiment is part of SOCOM but when they go OCONUS, they fall under JSOC working along side Delta. That's why they get two fundings.
@deathfire096 Wrong, when Regiment deploys they work directly for JSOC.
In light of recent and ongoing events, please do a video covering Ukrainian Special Forces. Complete badasses with an interesting origin story. I started watching your content last year and love the format and presentation. 🇺🇦🔱🌻
Nah dreamybull is stronger
I go for Ranger first. Navy S is the 2nd. I like both but, overall I stick to Rangers.
One Talks about it the Other keeps it to themselves
Makes me want to play more Call of duty MW2 2022
The army has Chuck Norris and the Navy has charlie Sheen.
both bad actors. LOL