VFX Artists React to Bad & Great CGi 4
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 июн 2019
- CONSIDER SUBSCRIBING ► bit.ly/Subscribe_Corridor_Crew
Watch Season 4 From The Beginning ► • Studio Cleanup Turns I...
This Episode ►
The Crew is joined by VFX legend Andrew Kramer as they react to some of Hollywood's zestiest CGi moments: What makes a visual effect bad? What makes one great?
FOLLOW US ►
Instagram: bit.ly/_Corridor_Instagram
Sub-Reddit: bit.ly/_Corridor_Sub-Reddit
THE GEAR WE USE ►
Most Used Equipment: bit.ly/Corridor_Crew_Gear
Perfect Camera: bhpho.to/2FJpQmR
Puget Systems Computers: bit.ly/PC_Puget_Workstations
SUPPORT US ►
Translate & Subtitle: bit.ly/Make_SUBTITLES
Patreon Donation: bit.ly/_Corridor_Patreon_Support
Buy Merch: bit.ly/Corridor_Store
Subscribe to our Gaming Channel, NODE: bit.ly/Subscribe_to_NODE 
Развлечения
Thanks for watching er'body! If you want to watch this entire show from the beginning you can do that here ►
ruclips.net/video/_4WrKeoeZhk/видео.html
A good "bad" is the first Harry Potter when Neville falls during their first flying lesson. It's rough.
They should do all HP movies!
X lmao i just commented this. really happy/funny to see someone comment the same thing
they should analyse the evolution / progression of visual effects in harry potter from 1999 to 2011. it blows me away comparing the first to the last movie
Hey since this has enough likes to be seen by the guys, Id also like to mention that weird shot at the beginning of 1989 batman that looks like a cartoon batman figure was drawn onto the film, as he looks down at the 2 bad guys mugging the family.
Or just the Quidditch in general in that movie. It’s brutal lol
React to The Spy Kids. That would really be something.
I know the cgi sucks
IMAGINE IF THEY DID ALL THREE
Vainile Tron Moreau Spy kids 3D 100%
How about the time thingamajig one it’s crap
All the time in the world is crap
The fact that the mirror trick in Contact was done back in the days of VHS...
That is awesome.
that Contact cabinet scene is so invisible as an special effect that when you see it the first time, you can't tell exactly what happened but your mind goes like. "what?" and then you try to figure out how the heck it was made. A simple yet beautiful effect that has a relevant narrative in it... hats off
And the popcorn at the bottom of the stairs, the bowl the father dropped to start the scene, falls on the floor into the shape of a constellation 🔥
They look like they are having so much fun analyzing these
React to TRON VFX
These videos just KEEP GETTING BETTER .. . Awesome awesome guest. Awesome. Netflix, Amazon... make this a show. I'm thinking like Mythbusters. Analyzing and then showing us the behind the scenes to actually do them.
I am too!
Hammer Addiction4u wow thanks for stating the obvious
@USDutchkitty 84 Exactly! That breakdown was genius.
When quicksilver saves everyone from the exploding building is THE BEST SHOT IN THE X-MEN FILMS HANDS DOWN.
I second this; however, if that clip is too long, his fight scene in the Pentagon would work perfectly too.
I like the quicksilver scene in the pentagon way more than the exploding building one
Quicksilver scenes are pretty much the only scenes worthwhile if you wanna watch the newer xmen movies lmao
I like when MCU quicksilver dies. Not only because was it a great scene, but also because I hated him.
the exploding building one is too overdone, the pentagon one is just right
About the lighting in space:
Thats what was a major thing in filming Interstellar. They had these beautiful, 15:1 miniatures of all the spaceships and they had to light them with the hardest, furthest away source possible. So they set up one lamp at the other side of the studio and flagged it off the black walls, getting the harshest shadows possible on the models. But then they had to go for a super low frame rate to get the exposure they needed (since they shot film and couldn't just bump up the ISO), like 4-5 or even
Gravity = Zero Research with NASA and not even a 9th grade level of physics, but very beautiful shots and stunning movie from Sound + Visuals.
11:57 Haha great line. "This is everything I want in a film!" "Jeff Goldblum."
There's a lot of crazy CGi shots in *INTERSTELLAR!* (:
there's always crazy in Christopher Nolan's movie in terms of CGI, and the only one recent film that doesn't have much crazy it's the "Dunkirk" since there's not much CGI in there at all, you can see the modern shipping cranes on the beach shots. but really the practical are the ones that sells it
Most of the effects in interstellar are practical
@kiyosk only the black hole scene was proper cgi rest of them were practical
@@shivamshekhar5184 ??? No the black hole scene was completely practical. They created a black hole specifically for the film.
@@MrTurtleWings dude there is a whole video of how the black hole was created using computer and simulation
This is series could be on episode 165 and it wouldn’t get old. 😩 The chemistry these guys have is insane and the content is awesome. Keep up the great work guys.
They should do that Hugh Jackman Eddie the eagle ski jump scene
Agreed!
Still going. Still awesome
Seems like they did but not episode 165
They're on ep 141, 24 to go.
andrew is a legend. Period. He has teached so many people in the world. Long live to video copilot
Every vfx artist i know, learned from him including myself. The legend . #respect
Guess no one 'teached' you english.
@@karthikpavan8837 everyone here english very well.
Taught
It's "Taught" but your point still stands
I think I've been watching too many of these because you guys are starting to look CGI to me and the rendering is not that great.
Wut
You mean wrendering
but.. but their pores streches
@@johnarters7412did you really spell rendering wrendering XD
I'm in your walls
There should be a disater-related video:
Twister, Into the Storm, 2012, Cloverfield, The Day After Tomorrow, Volcano, San Andreas, Armageddon, Godzilla
(just some ideas to pick from)
Yes yes yes this!
I was so excited by the look and feel of 2012 before it was released, and some of the CG work is brilliant. But it is hands down the worst ever film for over the top Hollywood clichés.
Apocalypse Pompeii. I know it wasn’t a blockbuster or anything, but it has some pretty damn disastrous CGI in it.
I agree. Do some themes. Super heroes marvel. Super heroes DC. Disaster movies. Aging deaging. Lord of the rings Etc. Each theme is one episode. Each episode shows good and bad.
Friendship ended with Clint, Now Andrew is my best friend
Post that meme on r/corridor bro
@@thewilltheway You got it, sir
@@nyuppo You actually did it the absolute madman.
@@thewilltheway Hell yeah lol, the Gorski himself replied so Im counting this as a win
BUT WHAT ABOUT THE GOAT?
Andrew definitely changed my life with his tutorials, it was so good to see him here.
I watched Contact for the first time last year and I remember having a huge "WOAH!" moment when she opened the medicine cabinet. First from the jolt you get when you realize "reality" wasn't the way you thought. And then from the "But... how'd they do that... in '97?"
"Wait, that fire looks soooooo real"
"Its because it is real fire"
"Oh, so they killed a bunch of actors?" XDXD
An entire episode dedicated to LoTR: *The Lord of the Rings* and *The Hobbit* (WETA Workshop, baby!)
What VFX reason was it that made LoTR work, but didn't translate at all to The Hobbit?
Most people have at least an inkling but I for one would love to hear an in-depth breakdown from the Corr-Crew!!
Why not continue the worse-effects-end-result theme with The Thing (1982) and (2011)?
@kurvos In fairness, the hobbit films were just pretty damn bad. They were incoherent and soul less for the most part. Even the non-cg moments look like cg due to the fairy tale like filter or whatever they did to it. Every actor and object looks far too smooth and glossy which makes even real shots look like a cg render. It's weird. I don't even know exactly what they did to cause that affect, I just know it's there and I don't believe it's just the 48fps thing which may have affected it too. if you enjoy the films, that's awesome, but I don't think they're very great examples of cgi or storytelling.
“Did they just kill a bunch of extras?” Lmao wtf😂😂
Andrew was my go-to guy when I was dabbling with vfx back in college! It was such a nice surprise and a nostalgic throwback to see him in this episode!! Loving the episodes so far! Subbed!
I'd love to see the X-Men apocalypse Quicksilver scene be analysed. I read it took months to film, but I may be wrong. Nonetheless it's a masterpiece.
I'm surprised they didn't go there when talking about X2
yeah my favourite x-men scene ever
ruclips.net/video/ymIezyXEJ5w/видео.html
It was the final scene of the film shot too
Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone when they learn to fly brooms for the first time and Neville gets his robes caught and breaks his arm. The VFX are terrifying!! Or the troll scene or quidditch scenes!
Taryn Cole oh god I just watched philosophers stone and CGI Neville is atrocious LOL
Compare the early movies to the later ones!
@@TheSplashchannel1 of course the later ones are better in CGI because tech got Better
Love Andrew Kramer and his work. As someone in post production I really appreciate his keen eye for detail and ability to make vfx look very natural with seemingly little effort.
wow that shot from contact is incredible. not only a great effect but one that greatly enhanced the visual story telling of the scene. you got a powerful visual of the characters feelings. we didnt even need to be told. just through a brilliant transition.
Captain america the first Avenger, all the skinny steve stuff. Also the Spiderman 2 train fight.
The skinny Steve stuff is so impressive, it's amazing how well it's done
Yep that be a great one!!
I want to see X-Men Quicksilver scenes.
Hulk 2003
Ella Seibold I thought that too, the first time I saw it, watching on a computer screen. Then I watched more recently on my home projection screen in HD, and I was shocked at how obvious it was that his face is cut out and pasted onto another actor’s head. It’s strange how different screens can make visual effects look more apparent sometimes.
Would love a “District 9” analysis. That finale with Wikus taking down everyone with a mech is so good.
Jordan Vanhoozer that scene is known for being one of the best CGI/VFX of any movie ever.
reaction to KGB "Skinny Bob" Alien video.
Would like them to react to some of Doctor Who's bad (and sometimes good) CGI.
Honestly, Niko's smile and laugh is one of the most beautiful ones I've seen in a human. ❤️
Rajat Saini 😐
I discovered Andrew and Video Copilot when I was 19. I owe this man so many beers. The reason I know anything about Aftereffects is because of him. The tutorials were also so funny that I'd keep pausing the videos just to catch my breath again. So, yeah. Thanks a lot, Andrew. :)
Dude... Niko has a damn sharp eye.
How the hell does he notice such tiny invisible details!? I'm betting he cheats... >;]
Yeah... He cheats.
Maybe he's watching in 60fps
Channels his inner Dobie.
I think he has prior knowledge of the clips.
He must've hacked this server
React to Sharkboy and lavagirl
That would have been a funny video xd
Niklas Vilhelm haha too true
Spykids 3d
hey wanna check out my youtube channsl
I've always watched video copilot and corridor digital since i was just starting in vfx back in 2014. And you're here in one video together. My two idols. Damn.
8:07 the force awakens was released in 2015, not 2014 🤔
This guy needs to be a regular. I'd love people with all different type of backgrounds in movie making.
Speaking of Peter Jackson, can you do a LOTR CG Reaction pls?
Ripping lotr may feel a bit like blasphemy for these guys but i second that. Do lotr plz.
LOTR of by far my favorite franchise ever, and my favorite movies ever. I've seen the extended versions atleast 15 times. And in my eyes they're perfect, the example how movies should look like. Perfect cast, perfect writing, and perfect effects.
Plenty of real actors with tons of make up instead of the CGI fuckfest called the hobbit movies...
one of my favorite series of videos I just stumbled upon while watching random videos. I am subbed and a follower now
That mirror shot from Contact has always been one of my favorites, amazing stuff.
I'm not sure if this quite fits your wheelhouse, but the CG World of Warcraft cinematics might be interesting to look at. I've never seen orcs that real-looking that weren't practical effects.
Warcraft movie too. Lots of orcs, all CGI, look more lively than human actors.
The old soldier cinematic still takes the cake for me
I’d love to see them react to the Warcraft movie. Lots of people said the effects were bad, or at least didn’t mesh well with the human actors. I’d love to hear their thoughts
I have a suggestion::::::::;:::::::::::
React to the og TRON
And then the new TRON
See how they improved
Alexander Kerensky Absolutely
Lol this is the most likes I have ever gotten
Feels pretty good
@Alexander Kerensky completely agree
The scene from Contact got audible gasps from the audience. I immediately went back for the next showing just to see that transition.
I never usually comment but I just wanted to say thank you to this particular series of videos for helping me through the worst nausea I've ever had in my life. You guys rock and I appreciate the cool little VFX knowledge tidbits 👍
You should make these at least 30 mins long, or even 1 hour!
I'd totally watch it
right! they feel so quick when watching them lmao
Ignacio Cozza if they do one long one that means they only get monetized for one video, if they do multiple short ones they get paid for more than just one
@@blving but if the video is longer you can put more ads in between. But I do think the 15 minute videos are a better idea
Agreed
Yes! I want to deep dive into the details more.
Do a whole episode about practical effects mixed with vfxs, I comment on every one of these videos please😭
The gods of the hallway have listened to you, friend. ;D
The man, the myth, the legend. I owe all my VFX skills to Andrew Kramer. Thank you Andrew and CC Crew.
I absolutely love your show and love videocopilot. You guys rock!
PLOT TWIST: The couch they are sitting on is cgi.
They need a bigger and better couch. That thing shakes whenever one of them moves.
They definitely need to add some weird gratuitous VFX into these some time.
Return of the king. The army of mordor marching towards minas tirith
We need Andrew in all of 'VFX Artists React' series. PERIOD!
Man I remember using andrews stuff way back in university, was a really great help! Though about 8 years later I'm in the games industry now :D
Who else loves the fact that they can produce great content that they love making, while racking up ton of views?
Please do either of the quicksilver scenes from X-MEN days of future past or apocalypse.
while at it maybe do a MCU's as a comparison
That Contact scene is so good that I literally could not figure out what you were going to be showing because it never once occurred to me that it obviously would need to be CG. I'm dumbfounded. Wow. See now THAT is effective CGI - when the audience doesn't even think about how impossible that camera shot was because you just feel like you're there. That's wild. Nicely done!
loved this episode when it first aired.. was getting nostalgic and watching Contact today, had to pause the movie and rewatch this breakdown to get the most out of it!
please react to x men days of future past on quicksilver scene when he break out magneto
NXT GNT yes that scene is so cool
I was literally about to comment that
yeessss
or when mystique transforms
Godzilla 1998
Blade Runner 2049, espically around 00:13:38, that shot is one of the most amazing VFX shot i've ever seen, the perfect mix between practical elements and vfx elements, and the soundtrack makes it only better! You guys have to talk about that amazing shit!
Blade runner is sex
Yes
@@nikoopperman931 There is only sex. Everything is sex. Do you understand that what I'm telling you is a universal truth?
mcscruffy I’ve been asking for them to that movie for the longest!
Which one?
That Nightcrawler scene was freaking nuts! I’m hoping to pull it off for myself and play around with it cause of how sick it looks.
Its great to see Andrew Craimer here. Thanks for inviting him.
Nightcrawler's scene just blew my mind, he's my favorite superhero ever, and seeing that on the cinema as a 15 year old was the most amazing thing.
Carla Ramos I was about to say the same, when that came out it was mind blowing.
I'm just shy of 54 and learned to read with these comics. Literally waited my whole freaking life to see comic books come to life on the big screen. These movies came along and that one scene made my life. 👍
@@PrisonMikesloveChild middle guy talking out of sync 4:02
I was 11 and oh the nostalgia, Nightcrawler was my always my favorite too and to get this scene was just the tops
I think I was 9 and I was blown away at how cool it was
OMG!! Andrew Kramer!!!
This is like the most epic crossover ever!!!
Great episode guys! and Andrew Rules!
RE: the lighting in Gravity. I think the thing they missed about the "dark side" of objects and characters being too illuminated is earthshine (it's a thing, look it up). Light is not only coming from the sun, it's also being reflected off of Earth. It's so intense that, in areas with low(-ish) light pollution, you can sometimes see the dark half of the moon faintly illuminated. That's despite the fact that the moon is roughly a quarter million miles away. The shuttle orbited at around 300 miles, give or take.
While planetshine is a thing, it is rather faint. Enough that you don't get harsh shadows like on the moon, but not nearly enough to look like you're sitting above a pool like the Gravity shots do. The reference footage of the car in space was pretty close to Earth too, and the shadows were already sharp.
the spacex spacecraft is less reflective than the very white space shuttle that they are operating from in Gravity. we have actual video from people working on hubble from a space shuttle. it is pretty similar to what is seen in the movie.
Blade Runner & Blade Runner 2049, absolutely gorgeous works of art!
Andrew Ko two of my favorite sci fo films of all time and blade runner 2049 was so beautiful 👌
YESSSSSSSS
I'd still love to see a reaction to Ex Machina's VFX. The work on Ava was just staggering.
Exactlyyyy!!!
The effort is admirable, but honestly, the design of mechanical parts themselves is... almost amateurish. It's like they asked somebody who does models for Poser to design Ava. Or at the very least, some youtube short. I mean, chicken fence, seriously?
Annihilation too! I especially love the bear monster
second!
@@DarthBiomech I liked it. But even if you didn't you have to give kudos to the integration. Afaik they did not do full CGI replacement. There are portions of her taken from the plate and portions re-done. Then the room glass reflections. Essentially they had to do all of those replacements several times for every reflection. The inside model had to be precisely matched to actresses skeleton too, so the movement would work. It's an CGI masterpiece like it or not.
Loved the "Nightcrawler" effect! They finally caught on film what it should have looked like, imo. :)
Video copilot taught me just about everything I know about VFX. I've even paid for very expensive classes and the stuff they went over is the same stuff that Andrew goes over in his videos for free. It's the best VFX resource on the internet.
yall should react to the hologram waifu three way in bladerunner 2049
YES
Agreed. do it you guys.
Even to all of blade runner 2049, men this movie was a blast to look at
Reserve an entire episode for that movie alone, I'd say.
Agreed. In fact, they should dedicate a complete video to Blade Runner 2049, that movie is a cinematic masterpiece, especially visually.
I can’t believe you got Andrew Kramer 👊🏻
I didnt even know he had a physical form. I just assumed he was a computer created disembodied voice!
everyone mistakes my last name and calls me andrew kramer
Andrew is a legend.been a fan since the bullet, 2008. Much love from Nigeria 🇳🇬
Another great video!
Gravity was amazing! It felt so real and gave such an eerie vibe of how it feels like to get almost lost in space! So intense!
A movie you guys should review is that movie with the fallen superheroes and it has this guy named “Dr. Manhattan” in it... I can’t remember the name of the movie!
Nightcrawler took out the whole army of soldiers in that White House by himself. They really worked hard on that one, great stuff.
React to skinny Captain America. I've heard that's pretty crazy VFX wise
No more than the Winklevosses.
yes please react to this!!
cant tell if youre being sarcastic hahaha its two actors
That was nice af
@@Tantagotantago10 not for all shots
woah, cool to see andrew in this. his video copilot tutorials were what got me to take on after effects
OMG IT'S SO COOL YOU GUYS BRING ANDREW KRAMER TO THIS SHOW! HE IS LIKE.. MY TEACHER, and maybe everyone's teacher too!
They could have just used a bigger couch to fit Clint in :(
Thx for the likes😉
Kinema Reviews ikr! I wanted to see/hear him too
@@Shereeda2202 he probably got hurt badly, I mean they were beating him in their bosstown dynamics
They could have added him with CG
@@JustKrin hahaha
This series is the best on this channel and the reason for my subscription.
I am interested because of the information they are giving rather than just reactions.
Happy to see you all together.
all i know about VFX was from you, you rock man. I started watching you tutorials in 2011.
Blade Runner 2049, the body/hologram overlay sequence.
Yeah the film looks amazing in general
Laz321 HOLY DICK YES
@@luisdinnebeer341 The whole film is amazing.
React to movies like Avatar, Alita, even the newer Planet of the Apes movies would be great. Anything WETA would be dope.
LOTR is WETA.
10:39 that's WETA
Yes, I'd love to see them react to Caesar's journey.
Game of thrones wildfire explosion
@Hoàng Nông WETA Digital, Peter Jackson's visual effects company
You guys will love the CG in Bad Boys For Life...I never noticed these things till I subscribed to this channel. Damn muzzle flashes!
If that wasn’t the smoothest, chillest sponsor thrown in at the end there, IDK what is. Wow, well done.
4:17 I'm so glad you included this shot from Contact. I remember watching the movie at a drive-in theater and wondering how in the hell they did that mirror trick. Good stuff.
5:23 even his nipples get hard. don't ask y i noticed that
Can you guys do Harry Potter and the Sorcerers/Philosophers Stone, the Quiditch Match scene.
Oh hell Yh!
Look at the Troll scene agh
The brick shifting scene in diagon alley
Oh, the part in there where Neville gets his robes caught while learning to fly a broom, the effects are TERRIFYING
Yes. More like the whole movies CG
Andrew Kramer, YES! Do more with him PLEASE.
Andrew has made soooo much for the Community... goatest GOAT!!! Cheers from France
Please do a de-aging special (MCU, BR2049 and others).
P.S. You should also react to Birdman.
Or just aging (Benjamin Button, Logan, etc.)
BR was a full CGI face reconstruction ala Rogue One. No original actor involved (at least for the on set performance side). MCU's tech is where you see the marriage of 3D replicas, stand-in actors, manual 'airbrushing', and makeup combined.
Leonardo Guerini yas
The fight against Agent Whiskey, in Kingsman: The Golden Circle, is worth looking at.
this shot is so awesome to look at
I remember rewinding that Nightcrawler scene all the time !!🔥👍💪
Awesome
I don't know how I end up hre a week ago.😂😂
And m addicted to your channel.
And its worth watching.
Great job.
Loving this series guys! Bring Andrew Kramer back for another episode too.
It's SuperSaf
didn't thought I'd find you here
Mad Max: Fury Road (Blending Practical effects and CGI)
didn't they already do that?
Barely any CGI in Fury Road
I specially made a search for this video as I was a big fan of Andrew but just got in touch with corridor recently and I thought...hey this reuinon had HAD to happen. And here we are. Eminences!
Love you guys!
And MORE ANDREW!
Andrew provided such detailed insights! I'm so glad he joined.
r/iamverysmart
@@desshiwaza4065 legend
TingTingin - Fortnite Battle Royale no u
You should make “horror movies edition” and react to CGI that we see in horrors🧟♂️🧟♂️🧟♂️
yeah!!.. "the thing" or "the fly" :.)
Yeah do it for a Halloween thing!
@@pedropoma4195 blue guy talking out of sync 4:02
Sleepaway Camp ending shot
American Werewolf in London transformation
Woahhhh Andrew Kramer literally taught me everything I love about vfx
Love these episodes! Can you talk about the Doctor Strange "open your eye" scene? And also the CG face in the curious case of Benjamin Button.
Do the most recent Planet of the Apes trilogy, the motion capture from Serkis and the CGI apes look incredibly realistic.
@John Smitty Because you didn't change your glasses. Check in with your ophthalmologist for a new prescription.
the opening shot in the second one is just perfection. pure, simple perfection
The mocap that was only used as reference and completely redone in post by character animators?
@John Smitty What are you even talking about? The apes in War were hyper realistic. Definitely the best mo cap so far.
React on dueling in harry Potter. Like if you guess agree
This is such a cool Episode!
That Contact shot still blows my mind...so freakin good!!