Is Israel breaking the rules of war?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 май 2024
- The Economist’s defence editor Shashank Joshi spoke to legal experts to find out whether Israel’s response to Hamas’s terrorist attack is lawful.
00:00 - Is Israel breaking the rules of war?
00:59 - Blockade
01:32 - Bombardment
Sign up to The Economist’s daily newsletter: econ.st/3QAawvI
Is Israel acting within the laws of war?: econ.st/3tzVBv7
Joe Biden steers a risky course after a Gaza hospital blast: econ.st/3ty6RIl
Mapping Israel’s war in Gaza: econ.st/3M5xECv
Hamas tunnels under Gaza will be a key battlefield for Israel: econ.st/490c8ZG
To save Palestinian lives in Gaza, open the crossing into Egypt: econ.st/3M3PzJu
A short history of Gaza: econ.st/408EJYR
Israel faces the danger of fighting on a second front: econ.st/3twmikn
Will Israel’s agony and retribution end in chaos or stability?: econ.st/48RGPQI
Netanyahu wages war and fights for his own survival: econ.st/3Q0xDku
Hamas’s attack was an Israeli intelligence failure on multiple fronts: econ.st/3Q9Rgrp
Brutal urban warfare awaits Israel’s army in Gaza: econ.st/3tw0vJJ
By Invitation: The crisis shows the failure of Israeli policy towards Palestinians, says Shlomo Brom: econ.st/3FhRzKl
By Invitation: Nimrod Novik on the false premises and failure of vision that led to the Hamas attacks: econ.st/3LWaXAx
1843: “It’s an Anne Frank situation”: an Israeli professor hides from Hamas: econ.st/3RO3Qh9
Watch: Israel and the Palestinians: a century of conflict: econ.st/3ZS68hf
Listen: With no electricity, limited internet and dwindling food supplies, what is life like in Gaza?: econ.st/3PRoaM9
Listen: An interview with a senior political leader of Hamas: econ.st/3rMPIua
Yes 100% the law is law they are breaking the law,
I feel pain, unable to do anything. And the world couldn’t be able to do anything. The sad thing is that it is supported by the west that claims to be the champion of democracy and human rights.
Media keeps addressing symptoms and not the root of the pain and problem.
Which is what?
@@checo8187 I am sure you know fine well, but if I have to spell it out to you and you have been living under a rock for years and don’t read about history then it’s about 3 things: 1) end blockade 2) end occupation 3) two state solution with both Israel and Palestine citizens having rights, freedom and dignity. Both subject to international law that actually gets enforced. No bias, no killing. Equality, diversity and inclusion.
The root is that neither side give a toss about peace. NOTHING solves that.
Yes, because Israel breaking the supposed rules of war is not the root of the problem? How do you think Hamas became radicalized? They are the survivors of decades of school and hospital bombings and blockades, etc.
In the last 2 weeks, Israel has struck 22 hospitals in Gaza (and the West Bank for no reason because Hamas isn't even there). Churches, schools. THAT is where terrorists come from.
@@Makainternationalit seems you're the one whos been living under a rock. It's not even remotely that simple. If the roles were swapped and palestine had the power that Israel does they would have wiped them off the map years ago
Why is the Chinese 🇨🇳 regime backing Hamas organization and committing Muslim Uyghur genocide at the same time?
I don't understand Isalm's logic. When they broke the rules of war, no one talk about it and then suddenly they became a victims, then they keeps saying follow the rules of the war. Same thing: Many islamic countries, close down Christian churches to renovate to mosque but when Christian countries do, they says it is religious persecution.
Israel bombs a Church in Gaza today did you check the news sir !!
What about hamas beheading civilians?
Palestine is not Hamas. Wake up mate
Since 1947
So The Palestinians have the right to deffend them selves using force also ... Who is invading the other ?
There are no rules in war. War is war.
This is a very uncritical view, and frankly unempathetic
Yes it captured Palestine since for 72 years
These two guys should agree to a world wide legal campaign to state their claims to the land and whomever loses should be compelled to accept the verdict. These war they wage at every turn of a year is wearing the world down, affecting commerce, anxiety...the world needs peace.
Maybe someone should tell Hamas the rules of war, too.
You do realize that Hamas is not the same thing as Gazans, right? The issue is Israeli actions that affect innocent Palestinians living in Gaza.
Yes but the Palestinians in Gaza Chose Hamas as their government. I would have expected the civilians there will claim from Hamas to leave if they just want to live in peace @@2triangles
@@shirisolomon7993 I don't know when the last election was in Gaza, but I doubt they were free and fair. I assume it's like in the West Bank where those in power excluded legitimate rivals. In any event, I hope you'd agree that election results don't reflect the views of all voters. (I certainly wouldn't have wanted to be put in the same bucket as the folks who voted for Trump.) Palestinians, I presume, are just as heterogeneous as "Americans" and "Jews" and every other demographic group. Like every other group in this world, they have some nut jobs, but the significant majority just want to live peaceful lives with their families. Would you agree with that?
@@2triangles more like hamas actions affect innocent civilians in Israel and innocent Palestinians in Palestine. Don't blame Israel for striking back sickos intentionally hiding among civilians to play the idiots into sympathy.
@@2triangles and what about innocent civilians of israel?
When the blockade is mentioned everyone conveniently forgets that Egypt does the same on their portion of the border.
Indeed. Presumably they are an "apartheid state!" as well.
When Egypt owned Gaza for about 20 years they didn't let Gazans leave then either. Funny how no one complained about it or yelled "Free Palestine!"
@@Wilson-xd4zqpeople who defend palestine hate jews there's no other logical explanation
Many countries have closed borders to neighboring countries. The blockade in the Mediterranean sea is not Israeli territory you dunce.
Egypt blocks its borders to entrance and exit by people but the blocking of food, water and medical aid is the result of Israel who bomb the border crossings preventing any support from being provided.
They have not followed international law for decades. Why would they start now?
And neither has Hamas who started this war to begin with
@@juicyfruit4378 The two are wrong. Get over it. Both are no better.
@@muhammadabyzard7970 Actually, this war wouldn’t have occurred without Hamas having initially attacking Israel - trying to compare a country with a terrorist organization on equal levels,is absurd. Nice try - now get over that.
@@juicyfruit4378 Yes. I'm not even denying that. But when you presents that Israel should be seen as a Saint. Then that's where I'm going to disagree. The two are just evil in many ways.
@@muhammadabyzard7970 can you quote me as saying or implying “Israel is a Saint?” No you can’t, because that’s not what I implied nor is it what I wrote - it is however what YOU interpreted and that’s on you and reflects what YOU think, rather than what someone wrote or implied. Again, this war started by Hamas attacking Israel and that is a fact. Do not attempt to tell or give me a historical lesson on the past relations as it’s not relevant to my comment which addressed the CURRENT situation at hand. There is nothing wrong with agreeing/disagreeing with what a person WROTE but not what you interpreted or thought I implied based in your own belief versus fact and that FACT remains that Hamas attacked Israel
they follow their own rules, which is, nobody else matters.
Their plan is to ethnically cleanse all of Palestine.
They follow their own rules, which is... War.
I think it’s safe to assume that in this conflict only one side will be anywhere close to playing by the rules of war.
The side that has been pushing for peace and almost landed on a thorough peace deal with Saudi Arabia and the UAE before Hamas attacked, yes.
And that is Israel.
Yeah Hamas isn't even pretending to respect laws of war.
@@BlueRadiumif you think giving Palestine the Russian equivalent of the peace in Ukraine than ya
I think it’s safe to say you’re a Biden bot 😂 Israel’s lapdog
Rules? What rules? When the chips are down, such regulations are tossed out of the window.
Name a war that did not break international law. 🤔
The question should be name a war that the Israeli did not start or committed war crimes
@@mohamadjamil3164war in south east asia. War in vietnam, indonesia, etc
@@gnicholaus4890 this does not justify the frequent and continuous killing and wars lead by Israel on its surroundings. Peace is the solution, not more wars and massacres. If others did it, it does not mean that any has the right to continue to do it
@@mohamadjamil3164 well u ask name a war, and i give it. I dont pick side
The emu war?
"rules of war" those two words shouldnt be put together like that...clearly clickbait
Hope people all love peace and can enjoy peace , enjoy family stay together.
Is there a video asking whether Hamas broke the rules of war?
Hamas is not State under UN, its not an apples to apples comparison
@@luisfernandogutierrez7625 I thought they are the governing body in Gaza? It sounds like you think it we should make it definitionally impossible for Hamas to commit war crimes?
@@briankaul1201 Governing what exactly? The Israeli air-striked hospitals?
Not Beheading inf@nts is rule #14..
Not Hogtying Families is #34
Not Butchering Young chlLdren is #11,14 and 15
Not Martyring your own people is Rule #65..
..and on…Isl@m Does this..They are Evil. They do not want peace. Quran (48:29 ) -
' Muhammad is the messenger of Allah. And those with him are ruthless against the disbelievers and merciful only among themselves "
That wouldn't be 'progressive'.
Yes, they are. But so is Hamas.
Which is fine, just every other country (especially the US) should try and remain neutral and not give each side arms or added protection otherwise we will all have blood on our hands.
Not all Palestinians are part of Hamas I would even say it's a very tiny amount
@@finalfan321 it’s very hard when civilians are known for helping out terrorist groups..
yes some do or are forced to. i have my doubt about all the children Israel is massacaring though@@Heismeiamyou
the question should be: Are hamas terrorists creating a war they can't win ?
And the answer is?
The rule is to win.
Can see where this 'News' article is going within the first few minutes. Great when only one side has to abide by the rules.
lol the title was is israel breaking the rules of law
Stop deflecting criticism from Israel, it's not exempt from international law.
If Israel does not abide to law then they're not different from the terrorists.
The fact that this is a question already delegitimizes the video.
In real war there are no rules. Economist is so out of touch with reality these days.
They are apologists for Those that behe@ded Infants!..They do not want peace. Quran (48:29 ) -
' Muhammad is the messenger of Allah. And those with him are ruthless against the disbelievers and merciful only among themselves "
Question: how do they ensure the aid gets to the civilians and is not stolen by Hamas?
Nobody can actually.
How do you assure the Palestinian children will grow up without getting bombed by Israel? You don't
That is the problem :/
@@farahamro2722 The end of radicalism on both sides will prevent civilians on both sides from dying in senseless wars again, okay? ;)
they set international law. they are the chosen one.
Yes
Hamas tunnel inhabitant's last words: "I smell....gas!"
I think that the fact that there is only one side of this conflict that people are even bothering to talk to about "rules of war" with any hope that they would listen tells you all you need to know about this conflict...
Lol yup exactly
I think looking at a complex issue in such a simplistic way is dangerous
I disagree. The conflict is actually very simple:
One side is a democratic nation that wants to live in peace, even says so in its declaration of independence, but is constantly provoked by the other side and dragged into violent clashes.
The other side is a terror organization backed and funded by Iran that openly admits it does not recognize its neighbor right to exist and operates to annihilate it.
So you see, the conflict is very simple to explain. It is very hard to solve but very simple and basic.
I think the fact that y9ou think that's "all you need to know" makes you a malevolent POS.
Dormant fake accounts being used to propagate the same agenda on a video tells a lot about who is wrong and who is right in this conflict
Rules of war! I'm not taking any sides here, nor agreeing with any of the carnage and suffering imposed on innocents on both sides. As a historian, just saying that historically, if any state or entity felt it was fighting for it's very survival/existence (and it could be argued both sides here are doing that) then the rules of war went out of the window. Wouldn't it be better to devote 100% of all efforts into ending the causes of the conflict rather than talking about the rules of war? Easy to say I know.
Thank you.
Palestinians right now are be genocied. Remember Israel was created under that argument?
Rule of War? okay. Who is going to implement the rule of war? who is the referee of war? Who can police the war? Did Putin respect the rule of war? did Americans respect the rule of war? Did the Japanese follow the rule of war? What country follow the rule of war? Only the losers of wars complain about the rule of war! Iraq, Iran, Saudi, HAMAS, HEZBOLA, Turkey, Poland, Israel, Lebanon, China and all countries that I fail to mention does not follow the rule of war. Why??? for those who are at war, for them there is no such thing! The UN is useless they only collect money! UN is called Ununited-Nations!
Except this war is so one sided that it would be hard for Israel to argue that Hamas poses any legitimate threat to the existence of Israel. What they want and what they are actually capable of doing are 2 very different things.
Hamas' it's attack did not make Israel fight for its existence lol
Yes. The answer is yes.
is this even a question ?
*“Rules of war”*
Doesn’t apply to Hamas.
There are no rules in war....Israel should take control of Gaza
We’re talking about palestine not just hamas
Palestines nurtured Hamas and let them grow ! If they had not supported terror, this war would not have started at the first place !
One is a terrorist organisation the other is a nation
Do you know how the Palestinians lived for 70 years?@@deepaklksify
Trillions on past Wars, Here we are again. The real pain comes when the Draft starts and your Sons will be fed to the meat grinder.
they breached the law, so where's the police?
Yes. Next question.
Which group is using innocent civilians as human shields? Which group specifically targeted civilians, including children?
Both
lol you believe what they tell you? Easily manipulated to justify the bs response
muslims
Isreal
Israel
No , international law is decide by power
an interventionist and militant mindset has brought about a shadow over the world's economies, disrupting the natural flow of progress and balance.
The interventionist approach, where powerful entities seek to control and manipulate economic systems for their gain, creates a world of inequality. It fosters an environment where the few prosper while the many struggle, leading to imbalances that weaken the very foundations of our global economy. The pursuit of short-term gains often takes precedence over the long-term well-being of both people and the planet.
Militant actions, whether economic or political, result in conflict and instability. These actions divert resources that could be better used for nurturing growth and development. Such mindsets perpetuate a cycle of competition and hostility that hinders cooperation and mutual benefit.
Yes, they always do
Is Isreal still breaking the rules of war. All rules were broken when they occupied Palestine since the beginning
The Palestinian people have the right to defend their usurped land by all possible means. The Palestinian people are not like the Red Indians or the people of Tasmania, whom you were killing in cold blood. The people have the right to recover their lands and expel the racist Israeli coloniser.
Israel is playing hardball now and the tough guys are going in.
Tough guy? The idf who dance tiktok video?
Israel only has a small population. The 1400 deaths on oct 7th in a country the size of the usa would equate to 35, 000 deaths as the same percentage of population.
I am a Jew and I am appalled by the disproportionate reactions this terribe government has manipulated. I do not agree with any type of violence, as violence doesn't bring peace. Innocent Israelis are suffereing and innocent Palestinian are suffering. There is no winner here. I hope the world see it for what this really is. I am so ashamed.
Definitely, it is !
Breaking the rules of war is fair game if the opponent did it first.
@@yiweilin917 chatgpt does it better than you mate
@@finalfan321 does what better?
create comments. i'm talking about chatgpt 2 not 4@@yiweilin917
You know why Gaza has no electricity? because the UN and Israeli money that came in Gaza went for the purposes of building tunnels under Shifa hospital and rockets. I do not think that US provided Japan with electricity in WWII.
Yes.
Are you going to make a video asking if Hamas broke the rules of war when they slaughtered innocent people for no reason?
What about Israel slaughtering innocent Palestinians for the past 75 years?
Rules of war doesn’t apply to terrorists
Rules of war .. LoL
What is this football match
YES !
So as long as no one from Hamas had ever been in a building ever, it should be safe...
Mas bien la pregunta es, cuales reglas no ha roto israel?
WHAT PART OF ISRAEL WAS ATTACKED IS SO HARD TO UNDERSTAND????????????????????????????
I am writing to you today as a dedicated reader of The Economist for several decades, a publication I have come to deeply respect for its insightful analysis and commitment to unbiased reporting. However, recent coverage of the Israel/Palestine conflict in your magazine has left me somewhat surprised and concerned about the magazine's impartiality and honesty in reporting.
The Economist has long been a trusted source of information, known for its balanced approach to complex global issues. Nevertheless, as I have followed your coverage of the Israel/Palestine conflict, I couldn't help but notice what appears to be a certain bias in the reporting. It seems as though The Economist may be leaning towards one side of the conflict, which has raised doubts about its credibility in my mind.
I implore The Economist to maintain its legacy of journalistic integrity and fairness. The Israel/Palestine conflict is a deeply sensitive and complex matter, and it is imperative that your publication presents all sides of the issue and strives for a comprehensive, unbiased viewpoint. We, as readers, rely on The Economist to provide us with accurate and objective reporting that presents the facts without taking sides. The magazine should stand as a paragon of trustworthy journalism, a beacon of truth, and a source that distinguishes itself from sensationalist or biased news outlets.
I encourage The Economist to remain true to its founding principles and uphold its reputation for honest reporting. Please ensure that the magazine's coverage of the Israel/Palestine conflict remains objective, balanced, and transparent. By doing so, you will reaffirm your commitment to delivering the truth and the facts to your readers, without falling into the trap of sensationalism or partisan reporting that can be associated with certain other media outlets.
In conclusion, I sincerely hope that The Economist will take my concerns to heart and make the necessary adjustments to ensure the highest standards of journalistic integrity are maintained in its reporting. I look forward to seeing a continued commitment to unbiased and honest coverage in the pages of your magazine, preserving the trust of long-standing readers like myself.
Thank you for your attention to this matter, and I remain a dedicated reader, hopeful that The Economist will continue to be a beacon of journalistic excellence.
What side do you believe they are biased against? I don’t know much about this news organization, I’m just curious.
I have the same question@@tiffanyh1274
Hamas has broken the rules of war and all this talk about Israel is irrelevant.
Are you implying Israel should do the same? Does Israel aspire to become Hamas?
''rules of war '' ? The saying said it clear '' There are no rules in love and war '' :))
I thought the same thing lol
Yeah, that's probably article 5.
@@nanashipersonne4151 Israel is not in NATO :))
Blud it is using white illegal drugs of rockets against Hamas which is illegal according to the U.N ( United Nations )
Can someone explain to me how is there no water?
How are they living? Are they zombies? How long a human can hang without it?
You don’t seem the sharpest knife in the draw
@@amacca2085 but you are? Please answer my question?
they exists just on donations from other countries, including eu and us.
for 70 years they built nothing. it's israel give them water, electricity, and jobs.
Yeah cause Hamas is playing by the rules.🤦🏾♂️
I find it amusing that war has laws and rules, almost an oxymoron.
Edit: It appears that some individuals who lack proper reasoning are struggling to comprehend my point. Once a war has begun, it becomes impossible to enforce laws or rules. As humans, we are fundamentally against war for this reason. Picking a word from my writings to build an argument against is just petty. I hope you find your way in life.
I find it amazing how the west pick and choose when and who to apply these so called “rules of war”.
I find it amazing that west likes to blame russia for war crimes and sanction them while simultaneously not applying the same rule for their allies
Glad you are amused. 1,500 Gazan children killed in the last few days.
Nothing amusing about rules of engagement. I don't think you've thought this one through, buddy. Would you like to bring the enslavement of war captives back in vogue? Proliferation and use of bio and atomic weapons?
you will be surprised which country make it and which one actually free from it
Article 51
Nothing in the present Charter shall impair the inherent right of individual or collective self-defence if an armed attack occurs against a Member of the United Nations, until the Security Council has taken measures necessary to maintain international peace and security.
There's an exception for Israel in there. It's unwritten.
The same question should be asked if Hamas, who caused this war to begin with / wasn’t their surprise attack a violation of international humanitarian law?
pretty obvious to anyone who isn't brain-dead that it was a war crime. but if you need more time to figure it out then go ahead.
If your city surrounded many years, you will not have many options
@@H.Doc11 and Hamas attacking Israel worked out so well for Gaza?
@@H.Doc11What, but to massacre hundreds of people in their homes? Torture, mutilation, kidnapping, depraved acts? Apologise and leave here.
And there is no Hamas in the west bank yet hundreds are being killed each year and they are being forcely displaced out of their homes, and lands are taken away from them!!
the only rule in war is don't lose
Really interesting the speech only about Gaza, like nothing happened in Israel during all these years.
How about war is a violation to humanity.
Yes. Please stop the brutality!
Stop ISL&M and peace will ensue..
Only way..
Yes, they are but of course they'll get a pass thanks to reasons we all know
Breaking the rules of war is fair game if the opponent did it first.
@user-tv4lo9ch5v Shhh dont speak jewish truths otherwise youll get branded as antisemitic
@@yiweilin917 just copy pasting. fail wannabe troll. your life must be great
you should ask how many times they have broken the rule.
How many times has Hamas broke the ceasefires which seemed to help end the conflict but the problem got bigger as we see it. Time to try a different tactic and get rid of the root cause.
Heal the world
Make it a better place
For you and for me, and the entire human race
There are people dying
If you care enough for the living
Make a better place for you and for me
empty words
It's hard to imagine a region in this world where Pakistanis are oppressed generation after generation. Being imprisoned and waiting for death every day, the child cannot grow to the age of eighteen.
*Palestinians…..*
Palestinians NOT Pakistanis
Perhaps the child shouldn't be indoctrinated into the ways of the bomb then? Nest ca pas?
@@jonnyh9388 When a child will see that his home has been snatched, parents put behind bars & has been imprisoned in an open air prison, then when terrorists walk up to him & ask him to join, How would he decline when he has nothing else to loose, since all means of peaceful dialogue have been closed
The root cause of this problem has been that Palestinians haven't been treated equal to Israeli citizens, their peaceful protests were countered with brute force leaving a field open for terrorists to recruit
why other arabic countries do not help them? why it's israel who gives them water and electricity?
There are no rules of war in this situation. Hamas chose to use civilians to guard military assets, as such everyone in gaza is a military combatant
There are no rules in war
Who cares? Its the victorious ones that decides what war crimes are.
Were the Hamas respecting something.?
Hamas uses civilian houses to store weapons. Flattenning those houses is militarily justified.
There were no rules in the first place.
i pray for all people
rules only in paper its not a sports war.
Oh it's a sports war?
Hamas is not a State under the UN, its a silla comparison.
I remember how Palestinians danced and celebrated 14 days ago
Why? Because their weapons are bigger?
Contested? I suppose some would defend Germany's actions in 1939-1945 as "contested" too.
An episode on the amount of money invested in making weapons and other military technologies as well as how much the investors raked in before, during, and after a war will certainly help answer the question of why wars happen.
I know Americans who fought and turned Iraq into rubble, got out of the service and became tradesmen (specifically electricians in my anecdote), then got paid to rebuild the communities they destroyed. What an interesting world we live in.
Well we know why this war happened. Because one side doesn't want peace; indeed it never has, and it is more than happy to sacrifice the lives of its own civilians to ensure that peace will never be achieved.
@@mljh11
I think the point went over your head.
Not at all. My comment is in reference to this particular war, which has more relevance to the video. And as for the Middle East in general, I'd say religion and cultural differences arguably play a bigger role in conflicts than any military industrial complex-related factors.
Organized conflict is a trait only observed in Chimps, the closest relative to Humans. Evolution and human nature are the reasons why wars happen.
yes
The woke Economist in an unholy alliance with Hamas.What do THEY say about human shields being used by Hamas?
These laws are primarily concerned to countries and their armies. The law still lags when dealing with non-state actors like terrorist organizations. Hamas' doctrine has them place all their military assets in, under and around civilian infrastructure to protect itself. There are no provisions in any laws regarding cases like these.
This is a completely false and dangerous rhetoric and have been used by the Israeli government to bomb hospitals, schools and refugee camps. The notion That H**s builds infrastructure around Hospitals has been contested multiple times. This same question was asked by a podcast interviewer, if H***s was hiding in an Israeli Hospital do you bomb the hospital. Just like the Canadian pm there are rules to war.
So how if hamas hiding in ur city and you locked inside without food, electricity, and everything you need to survive. And you keep bombed from the sky, will you still saying this??
i dont know, my society doesn't promote killings and evil like hamas and will not vote such groups in power. hamas has plenty of food and supplies but they keep it to themselves.@@akhmadrizqihidayat9726
Absolutely and they have been for decades
Everybody has their own rule. Just watch out.
Literally both sides in every single war ever has broken almost all "rules of war"
And yet the Palestinians are willing to go to the ICC to be investigated for war crimes but Israel is refusing to do so. We know who's the guilty party.
@@rogersevers123 ugh yeah the people who are going? Lol
lol they do so because they have nothing to lose. @@rogersevers123
There is no simple solution to this especially since the rules of war set by the UN are much more complex then just the ONE Article he mentions.
Yes it is so complex. Israel should carry on ❤ to defend
So it’s all about Israel and Hamas can do whatever they want? Since Hamas violated all of the stated legalities isn’t proportional whatever Israel wants to do?
Stop the fxxking war !!!!
Is hamas breaking the rules of war? Then a proportional response would be the same.
The rules of law saved hamas and Gaza may times before. Lawyers, something Hamas don't worry about.
Well, it is a terrorist group. Such entities are by nature lawless. This is why they are labeled as a terrorist group in the first place, genius 😅
And you have to ask the question? 🤦🏻♂️
why do we learn history by repeating somethings wrong and passing hatred from generation to generation?