Theory idea Harry Potter if he was snape and lilys son Wild story cause how does that affect everything with Voldemort and dumbledore and Ron nd hermoione and Draco
I love the if Harry was in Slytherin theory video That’s was so good!!! The best thing about this was Draco redemption arc!!! I loved everything except for Harry and Hermione together. I don’t really see why Harry being sorted into Slytherin changes the affection Ron as for her, even if he developed a crush on Cho. Hermione’s crush on Ron starts early when she was the only one to see him for who he really was, a brave and capable wizard, but with Harry in Slytherin, Ron would have way more opportunities to shine. So I don’t see why Hermione wouldn’t still like him?!? And Harry never never considered Hermione as anything but a friend. So why would Harry being in Slytherin change that.
I love how we’ve got to the point where so much has been covered and J and Ben know so much that we’re doing an entire quiz on one specific chapter. Absolutely brilliant
How to work backwards to when Dumbledore died: The chapter of DH where Dumbledore's will is read happens on Harry's 17th birthday and Hermione criticizes Rufus Scrimgeour for examining the bequeathed items for the maximum of 31 days. So, July 31 - 31 days = June 30th.
The dates are always so fishy in these books. There's never any indication before this that Hogwarts keeps students to the very last day in June, nothing in HBP mentions that it was the final day of semester, Dumbledore's funeral seems left out of the calculations, it's all sideways.
I was first introduced to HP through my school's adaptation of the "Cursed Child" and um... had to play Scorpius in the scene where he tries to convince Snape to help him in one of the parallel universe. So I had to be the one saying the "You [Snape] killed Dumbledore, you were a triple agent this whole time because you loved Lily"... before getting that far in the books. YAY, great times!!!
27:15 It's cracking me up thinking about Draco calling "This way guys! Follow me!" To all the death eaters as he leads the way with all their hands against the wall.
The reason Bellatrix isn’t at the tower I think is because it shows Voldemort did not have much faith in the plan, after all he expected him to fail. So Voldemort sends some that he believes are expendable, sending Bellatrix would be to much of a risk, she is by far his best death eater that can do death eater things (cause snape can’t) that is available to him right now, a lot of his best people he sent to capture the prophecy because it should have been a relatively easy task but was extremely vital in his eyes. Whereas killing Dumbledore was an extremely difficult plan that he never expected to work. So he sends death eaters like Yaxley and the Carrows because they aren’t as important, as can be seen by them being stationed in the ministry and hogwarts next year, because they are loyal members to the cause but not as great at actual death eater things. This is different to Snape because on the one hand Yaxley and the Carrows were in institutions that Voldemort already controlled, whereas Snape was undercover in the school run by Dumbledore, arguably the greatest wizard of all time, and the only one Voldemort ever feared. One of them takes a lot of skill, the other does not. So in summary Voldemort didn’t want to send Bellatrix because it would be to much of a risk.
@@Zach90888 The large death eater is Thorfin Rowle . It's surely him not Yaxley because when he and Dolohov attack the Golden Trio at the Coffee-Shop he is discriped as the large death eater who was among the raiders at Hogwarts.
3:10 I heard stories of people going to buy the THP book a couple days after it was released, and people would just walk by and say the spoiler to those who were buying it... It was that bad... 10:55 Bellatrix was really only their because of her sister Narcissa. I don't feel Bellatrix cared one way or the other about Draco, and her reasoning for the vow was because she didn't trust Snape and wanted to try forcing the lie.
Correction involving Question 2: The book states that after Dumbledore's death, all lessons and exams were canceled. That means that the students were not only still doing school work in July, but the fifth and seventh years got screwed over (No NEWTs for Cho, for example).
I feel like that happened more often than not, Dumbledore cancelled exams a few times I think. Also, they were in school long enough after the death for the funeral, so I’d assume AT LEAST a few days
That’s a normal school calendar in the UK, with school starting in September and going until mid-July, with 1- or 2-week breaks sprinkled throughout the year (I got to spend three years in the UK as a child and loved their school calendar and still vastly prefer it over the American one I’ve had ever since- I’m an elementary teacher).
It was so fun working your panel at RTX! Love you guys! Something else that really made my weekend and was just such a simple small thing was when helping yall get set up you asked my name. I know it was just a courtesy but out of all the panels I worked that weekend that was the only time anyone asked. Itwas just a nice thing yall did and I really appreciated it!
i was like 50 pages deep. coworker saw me reading it and goes "Did you get to where dumble died!? i can't believe snape could be so evil" i threw my book on the table and just walked out for a bit.
The truly cruel version of the Snape Kills Dumbledore spoiler was that the transcript leaked online so some people read it and then drove past midnight launch parties shouting it.
Some people just think it's funny to ruin other people's fun. It's a pretty low-stakes example but that type of thing is how you know someone is a terrible person.
Someone also spoiled Snape killing Dumbledore when the movie came out. There's a videos of some guy driving past the line to the cinema, and yelling it out of his window. I'm no fan of spoilers, but listening to a whole line of people become dissapointed, at the exact same time, is oddly satisfying.
That bit after question 5 where they were joking and switching Bill's name and saying like "I know a guy named Will Beasley" was really funny to me because I do actually know a guy named Will who's last name isn't too far off of that
They balance each other.....and she stays for the kids in Deathly Hallows - and (prob just Rickman and Smiths brilliant acting in the movie) you see that he doesnt want to fight her and understands why she is fighting
The fact that they know who Colin Cowherd actually amazes me I know they like sports but thats another level knowing like the 5th biggest sport show in America. New level of respect for the Carlins.
I just love these.. Have you guys ever thought about doing a video on Mary Poppins and Nanny McPhee and how they may be a byproduct of the wizarding world. Their powers, abilities and how taking muggle studies are perfect for becoming a nanny...
For some reason, every time I think of the events that unfolded at the Clock Tower, even though I like the implications of Snape casting Avada Kedavra on Dumbledore in the place of Draco and the question of who actually killed Dumbledore (the curse or the fall because of the color of Snape’s spell), I think it could have unfolded in a way that mirrored Ariana’s death. Picture this: it is just Draco and Dumbledore alone at the tower, with the former pointing his wand toward the latter, similar to how it went in the books. Harry suddenly appears with Ron, sees what Draco is about to do, screams “No!,” and decides to quickly cast Expelliarmus, but Draco’s adrenaline-filled on-edge state makes him react to Harry’s spell casting as the latter was drawing his wand, dodging it, and as Ron casts his own to help Harry, Draco deflects it back at him, knocking Ron back. Draco then quickly casts Sectum Sempra at Harry, cutting both his hands and making him drop his wand, disarming him in a brutal way as a way to both reflect how Harry cut him in the bathroom and to create a moment of parallelism between both to show how he is both different and very similar to Harry (using spells to disarm, but what each spell does represent their moral alignments and emotional states in the moment and their upbringing). Harry freezes as his hands are bleeding and looks attentively and in desperation at Dumbledore, who softly say’s “Please Harry, don’t” while Draco points his wand at Dumbledore, trembling, and screams at the protagonist, “Stand Down, Potter,” half-crying, with an expression of guilt for what he was about to do that almost felt like he was asking Harry to do everything to stop him, but also to truly stand down so Draco can kill Dumbledore and save his family from being murdered by Voldemort. Time starts moving slowly as Draco turns his back from Potter to look at Dumbledore one last time and ready his Avada Kedavra. Harry stands up and positions himself to “tackle” Draco to prevent him from firing the killing curse. Seeing that, Ron, who thinks Draco could instead kill Harry if fast enough to react to the protagonist’s attack like before, screams for Harry to stop, which actually makes Draco become aware that Harry is going to tackle him, making the former move his wand toward Harry and try casting Depulso to push the latter away from him. But Harry is too quick, and as the spell leaves Draco’s wand, Harry’s tackle to remove the wand from his hand pushes the spell in the direction of Dumbledore, ultimately causing the headmaster to fall from the Tower and die from the impact. This moment would haunt Draco, Harry, and Ron for a long time, being almost in a similar configuration to the fight between Grindelwald, Dumbledore, and Aberforth, with Ron feeling like he caused Draco to cast Depulso by trying to stop Harry (something that could have been explored further through their Horcrux conflict in the last book); Draco feeling like, even though he did not directly kill his headmaster, he inadvertently did by casting the charm that caused Dumbledore to fall, saving his family and helping him be promoted by Voldemort in the same way he was in the books, but feeling some form of hidden emptiness and remorse for doing so (which could justify a sudden redemption arc in the Battle of Hogwarts where he joins Dumbledore’s Army after dueling Harry one last time, a moment that would test Harry’s compassion, goodness, and forgiveness because he would use the moment to thrown all his anger after Dumbledore’s death at Draco and want to possibly kill him), and Harry feeling like he was the one that accidentally aimed the spell at Dumbledore, being the most responsible for his mentor’s death, somebody he loved dearly, much like Dumbledore loved Ariana so much. For Harry specially, after Voldemort cast Avada Kedavra at him and he went to the limbo King’s Cross, his conversation with Dumbledore could result in the latter being able to finally absolve himself from the guilt of his sister’s death by helping Harry forgive himself so the latter does not live a life blaming himself for this incident and suffer because of it, or at least, if that is not Dumbledore but a part of Harry’s consciousness or soul, Harry can help forgive himself by also releasing Dumbledore from his own suffering, something not even the greatest wizard could ever do, who would probably see and appreciate the gesture from the after life
From the Phineas and Ferb intro song to Harry Potter to the brothers reminding me again in this quiz I've always hated hearing about other kids' summers. Here it's 6 weeks and back to school you go.
3:41 I worked at a bookstore…a woman waited in line, read it as fast as she could and STORMED into the bookstore and YELLED I can’t believe she killed off Dumbldor! The store was packed, kids started crying, it was a mess.
The short summer holidays thing is a British thing. Our summer holidays tend to start mid to late July and last 6-8 weeks. Sometimes we call them the 6 week holidays.
It varies based on private or public and the state you're in. As well as how many, if any, days school was cancelled due to inclement weather. I was raised in Illinois and went to Chicago public schools. We started our year the first Tuesday in September (that Monday is a federal holiday, Labor Day, so no school) and our last day of the year was anywhere between June 19-22. People graduating from 8th grade or high school ended earlier by a week or two, usually. I had friends who went to Catholic schools and they usually started in August and ended in mid to late May. That was roughly the same timeframe for students in suburban school systems as well. If our public schools were ***officially*** cancelled due to extreme weather, if the cancellations were more than two days we'd have to stay in school a little longer if I recall correctly. That's probably not at much the case anymore thanks to technology. UNOFFICIALLY depending on the weather we were told we could stay home and it wouldn't be held against us on that day. Days in school is mostly a government funding issues. Catholic schools were a lot more relaxed about closing for bad weather as some of my neighborhood friends loved rubbing in my face.
I'd like to share that I was one of the first victims of the spoiler. I was literally at the midnight book release of half blood prince and one of the people ahead of me in line got the book, turned immediately to the end and skim read it as they were heading to the door and just as they left they yelled out "Snape kills Dumbledore!" before sprinting out the door.
I was a little more lucky eventough I read all the books in German (at the point when the English Version was already puplished). I knew Dumbledore will most likely die because I read in a supplement of a News Paper that some guys who printed the book bet on him but who ever wrote the Article at least didn't spoil it was Snape. So it was still a shock too me when he died. But my brother spoiled to me Sirius Black will die after reading that somewhere in a Youths Magazine. I was kind of mad but on the other hand I didn't want to believe it Oh, and I overheared two fellow students talking about Deathly Hallows and one of them told the other that a readhead will die but had the other one guess which. Fortunatly they didn't get to the point of revealing it.
If anyone ever finds themselves in Whitby, UK: They found an 'actual' Hand of Glory in one of the old buildings (a pub I think), and it's currently being displayed in the Whitby Museum. There's also instructions with it on how to make it. It's pretty gruesome looking.
I'm reasonably sure it was Rowle on the astronomy tower, not Yaxley. The confusion is that both of them are often described as large blonde Death Eaters
Fun fact: studies suggest ignoring your facial expressions does allow you to focus and remember better. Same idea as turning down the radio to see better. It frees up more active memory and reduces distractions. So the face scrunching totally helps.
I got ten correct!! I got the date too! I figured out what age Harry was and I knew that they were already technically done with school so I knew it was in June and then I remembered that Dumbledore’s will was read a month later! I am so proud of myself!
I was at Otakon when the book dropped. Some people bought it, flipped to the end, and announced the spoiler to a crowded convention room over a speaker.
Schools in the UK usually only have 6 weeks holiday in summer, with the final week of july being the first week of the holidays, in fact I think this Friday is the last day before summer holidays, but they do get 2 weeks off at christmas and 2 weeks off at easter with a week off in-between (October, February, May)
Gibbon was the one who was hit by a killing curse from another death eater that narrowly missed one of the DA thanks to Felix, I knew it was a death eater but didn't know the name
Muggles in the UK only usually get 6 weeks of summer holidays, 'only 8 weeks'?! Hogwarts has private school holidays. The date question was brilliant, love that you both changed your mind on the year as well.
I guessed the same date, but it was based on harry, Ron, and Hermione receiving their bequests on Harry's birthday (which is 1 month and a day after Dumbledore's death)
"Snape kills Dumbledore was a spoiler before spoilers were a thing ...." Really? I'm sure people were spoiling "No, I am your father" way before the book came out.
OMG!! I'm still laughing at the idea of the DeathEaters using the "buddy system"!! Draco: Now, does EVERYONE have their buddy? Hold your buddy's hand; it's gonna get dark in here. Bellatrix: Uh, I don't have a buddy; we have an odd number! Draco: Ugh . . . Alright, fine, Aunt . . . You're up here with me, then. That's HILARIOUS!! 🤣🤣 (Yes, I'm watching/listening to this @ work right now. Shh! Don't tell anyone! I'm alone in my office right now; no kiddos . . . 🤫)
In my senior year at high school at the final assembly of the school year, the student body president got up to the podium and said "ahem. Snape kills Dumbledore." And just continued with his speech while the ENTIRE auditorium groaned loudly. I was cackling with glee.
Hogwarts: uses 3-headed 8500lbs heavy dog and fire spitting dragons to attack students. Also Hogwarts: uses children with wooden sticks to defend Hogwarts with their lives.
That is correct. In Deathly Hallows he was leading the gang of snatchers, including Scabior, that caught the Golden Trio. It was specifically mentioned that he was allowed to wear Death Eaters' robes, but had never been given the high honor of a Dark Mark on his arm, which Fenrir considered to be a shortcoming on his own part.
That's just the choice made in the movies. The description in HBP makes the details of the attack sound much more vague and serious at the same time, just that he won't look the same anymore and Ginny can barely even talk about it. Not just a scratch by any means, but he survived due to Greyback being in human form at the time.
@Levacque no, fenrir being in human form is why Bill isn't a werewolf, Fenrir wasn't trying to kill him. We know that because if greyback wants to kill you, he will.
I am not sure who was the first person to post the spoiler online, but someone was shouting it out at my midnight book release before I even had my chance to purchase the book. I honestly thought the guy was trolling and telling lies to get everyone riled up. No idea how that guy scanned through the book that fast. It couldn't have been more then 10 minuets.
The Carrows, Greyback, Corbin Yaxley, and the dude who accidentally got Avada Kedavra’d. Bobbins or something. Plus technically Snape and Draco I suppose.
Poor Ben. Banging the elbow on the corner of the table, a balmy day outside for the BRB, and a J win. But at least we got to here J exclaim "Butts on Face". We need that clip of Luke singing his song.
I'm sorry, but September 1st is NOT always a Monday in the books, only the first book, because it WAS a Monday in 1991. Most of her dates are fairly accurate to real world calendars, except for year 2, for some reason. Also she got the full moon dates off in year three, but most the rest of it is pretty solid.
A kid in my high school yelled “DUMBLEDORE DIES!” in the hallway right before I got to that part in the book and I still hate him for that like 15 years later
6:35 " . . the end of the year because there's no more classes." Or, end of the year because it's the end of the book and that's when all the fun stuff happens.
3:14. Even worse….I heard stories of people exiting the book store, and someone driving up and shouting out the window that Snape kills Dumbledore. Wow….Just….Wow. People can be such a-holes
I remember the day Half-Blood Prince came out, the local newspaper published a two-page story with "Dumbledore is dead, and Snape killed him" across the first page without warning
I think the first big online presence to do the ‘Snape kills Dumbledore’ thing might have been Maddox. He put up an article tagged no spoilers like the day it came out and the action and page was the first line in the article
FYI for anyone wondering, UK schools only have 6 weeks holiday in the summer. Term usually ends three weeks into July, so that's why students could stay if they wanted to, and the conversation was about sending students home early for the summer! 😊
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Liquid Luck Coffee! 🍫🍀
carlinbrothersmercantile.com/products/liquid-luck-blend
Love coffe and You guys!!❤❤❤❤❤☕☕☕☕☕
We all know it's not really liquid luck.
I bet Ron did aswell.
Theory idea
Harry Potter if he was snape and lilys son
Wild story cause how does that affect everything with Voldemort and dumbledore and Ron nd hermoione and Draco
I love the if Harry was in Slytherin theory video That’s was so good!!! The best thing about this was Draco redemption arc!!! I loved everything except for Harry and Hermione together. I don’t really see why Harry being sorted into Slytherin changes the affection Ron as for her, even if he developed a crush on Cho. Hermione’s crush on Ron starts early when she was the only one to see him for who he really was, a brave and capable wizard, but with Harry in Slytherin, Ron would have way more opportunities to shine. So I don’t see why Hermione wouldn’t still like him?!? And Harry never never considered Hermione as anything but a friend. So why would Harry being in Slytherin change that.
I love how we’ve got to the point where so much has been covered and J and Ben know so much that we’re doing an entire quiz on one specific chapter. Absolutely brilliant
And I still know more lol
How to work backwards to when Dumbledore died: The chapter of DH where Dumbledore's will is read happens on Harry's 17th birthday and Hermione criticizes Rufus Scrimgeour for examining the bequeathed items for the maximum of 31 days. So, July 31 - 31 days = June 30th.
That is impressive the math works out like that, she clearly paid the math budget the weeks she wrote that.
The dates are always so fishy in these books. There's never any indication before this that Hogwarts keeps students to the very last day in June, nothing in HBP mentions that it was the final day of semester, Dumbledore's funeral seems left out of the calculations, it's all sideways.
@@MegaLokopohardly. What about the funeral?
@@Levacque In England, term usually continues into mid-July, so it makes more sense when read with that knowledge
@@Levacque The funeral happened while school was still in session, it doesn't change anything.
CAN WE THANK J AN BEN FOR UNLIMITED HARRY POTTER CONTENT
Yes we can THANK YOU SUPERCALINBROTHERS
YES WE CAN. HARRY POTTER FOREVER! (Chadwick reference) 😔
Yes, thank you!
Unlimited is a bit of a stretch.
YESSS KEEPING THE FANDOM ALIVE
I was first introduced to HP through my school's adaptation of the "Cursed Child" and um... had to play Scorpius in the scene where he tries to convince Snape to help him in one of the parallel universe. So I had to be the one saying the "You [Snape] killed Dumbledore, you were a triple agent this whole time because you loved Lily"... before getting that far in the books. YAY, great times!!!
woah so a fairly recent fan ?
Jesus Christ, getting the licensing for that so soon after being on Broadway must have been a huge waste of your school's drama budget
@@neilfan1016 it was 2018/19, so yeah, but like I was 11 at the time
@@Levacque yeah, probably
People say the cursed child is garbage but I want to see how bad it actually is
OMG, Ben changing from 96 to 97 solved my anxiety.
Just seen that
27:15 It's cracking me up thinking about Draco calling "This way guys! Follow me!" To all the death eaters as he leads the way with all their hands against the wall.
The reason Bellatrix isn’t at the tower I think is because it shows Voldemort did not have much faith in the plan, after all he expected him to fail. So Voldemort sends some that he believes are expendable, sending Bellatrix would be to much of a risk, she is by far his best death eater that can do death eater things (cause snape can’t) that is available to him right now, a lot of his best people he sent to capture the prophecy because it should have been a relatively easy task but was extremely vital in his eyes. Whereas killing Dumbledore was an extremely difficult plan that he never expected to work. So he sends death eaters like Yaxley and the Carrows because they aren’t as important, as can be seen by them being stationed in the ministry and hogwarts next year, because they are loyal members to the cause but not as great at actual death eater things. This is different to Snape because on the one hand Yaxley and the Carrows were in institutions that Voldemort already controlled, whereas Snape was undercover in the school run by Dumbledore, arguably the greatest wizard of all time, and the only one Voldemort ever feared. One of them takes a lot of skill, the other does not. So in summary Voldemort didn’t want to send Bellatrix because it would be to much of a risk.
I just reread that segment. They only describe him as a large death eater. He is never called Yaxley, probably why J missed it.
@@Ee-to-lit-kee who’s Jim?
@@Zach90888 The large death eater is Thorfin Rowle . It's surely him not Yaxley because when he and Dolohov attack the Golden Trio at the Coffee-Shop he is discriped as the large death eater who was among the raiders at Hogwarts.
Love that the "not a leap year" hint actually helped cuz Ben really did change his to the right day AND 1996 was in fact a leap year.
24:58 only Ben could make “coward” look like “Covid”
Theory idea: what if Tom Riddle got the job of defense against the dark arts so he never cursed the position?
The real question is, when does he stop teaching it? As soon as the war starts?
@@coolnerdlll6053 that’s another thing that would make this theory interesting
@@coolnerdlll6053 By staying though, he'd have plenty access to young minds for recruitment.
@@KaiLucasZacharyWhen he starts killing people on a nationwide scale, I think Dumbledore would fire him.
@@coolnerdlll6053 Yeah, fair. But that’s why we have the current reality. What would Dumbledore’s motive to hire him at all have been?
3:10 I heard stories of people going to buy the THP book a couple days after it was released, and people would just walk by and say the spoiler to those who were buying it... It was that bad...
10:55 Bellatrix was really only their because of her sister Narcissa. I don't feel Bellatrix cared one way or the other about Draco, and her reasoning for the vow was because she didn't trust Snape and wanted to try forcing the lie.
Correction involving Question 2: The book states that after Dumbledore's death, all lessons and exams were canceled. That means that the students were not only still doing school work in July, but the fifth and seventh years got screwed over (No NEWTs for Cho, for example).
I feel like that happened more often than not, Dumbledore cancelled exams a few times I think. Also, they were in school long enough after the death for the funeral, so I’d assume AT LEAST a few days
That’s a normal school calendar in the UK, with school starting in September and going until mid-July, with 1- or 2-week breaks sprinkled throughout the year (I got to spend three years in the UK as a child and loved their school calendar and still vastly prefer it over the American one I’ve had ever since- I’m an elementary teacher).
Maybe the Newt and Owl Exams in those years are just posponed to later in summer or the first week of September.
Ben: *points at mug*
J: “IS THAT PERFORMANCE ENHANCING COFFEE?!?!”
He said calmly
It was so fun working your panel at RTX! Love you guys! Something else that really made my weekend and was just such a simple small thing was when helping yall get set up you asked my name. I know it was just a courtesy but out of all the panels I worked that weekend that was the only time anyone asked. Itwas just a nice thing yall did and I really appreciated it!
i was like 50 pages deep. coworker saw me reading it and goes "Did you get to where dumble died!? i can't believe snape could be so evil" i threw my book on the table and just walked out for a bit.
The truly cruel version of the Snape Kills Dumbledore spoiler was that the transcript leaked online so some people read it and then drove past midnight launch parties shouting it.
Why are people like that? So unnecessarily cruel
Some people just think it's funny to ruin other people's fun. It's a pretty low-stakes example but that type of thing is how you know someone is a terrible person.
Round of applause for Ethan's Hagrid impression!
I love that you guys, when in doubt, just guessed Yaxley.
Someone also spoiled Snape killing Dumbledore when the movie came out. There's a videos of some guy driving past the line to the cinema, and yelling it out of his window.
I'm no fan of spoilers, but listening to a whole line of people become dissapointed, at the exact same time, is oddly satisfying.
Question 2 is such a satisfying set up and pay off 😂
For question six, a casualty is any injury due to a war, not just death, so Bill Weasley was technically a casualty.
I’d like to take a moment to thank everyone over at SCB headquarters for making RUclips awesome!
That bit after question 5 where they were joking and switching Bill's name and saying like "I know a guy named Will Beasley" was really funny to me because I do actually know a guy named Will who's last name isn't too far off of that
What do you mean "Snape and McGonagall don't get along?" They discipline students together all the time, she's the good cop to his bad cop.
They balance each other.....and she stays for the kids in Deathly Hallows - and (prob just Rickman and Smiths brilliant acting in the movie) you see that he doesnt want to fight her and understands why she is fighting
Yeah and In the book he peaces right out the window rather than fight her. These two are sympatico.
Yay another J vs Ben Quiz💚
THANK YOU!!!!
@@kimmiepollock9985 hmmm you're welcome?
@Dracoswife_Slytherin soooo sorry, wrong comment I replied too🤭🤭🤭
@@kimmiepollock9985 it's ok
I have never wanted a tie in the Quiz more! PKs sounds awesome!
So proud that my question not only was voted in but it stumped the bros 😎😎
The fact that they know who Colin Cowherd actually amazes me I know they like sports but thats another level knowing like the 5th biggest sport show in America. New level of respect for the Carlins.
I just love these.. Have you guys ever thought about doing a video on Mary Poppins and Nanny McPhee and how they may be a byproduct of the wizarding world. Their powers, abilities and how taking muggle studies are perfect for becoming a nanny...
For some reason, every time I think of the events that unfolded at the Clock Tower, even though I like the implications of Snape casting Avada Kedavra on Dumbledore in the place of Draco and the question of who actually killed Dumbledore (the curse or the fall because of the color of Snape’s spell), I think it could have unfolded in a way that mirrored Ariana’s death. Picture this: it is just Draco and Dumbledore alone at the tower, with the former pointing his wand toward the latter, similar to how it went in the books. Harry suddenly appears with Ron, sees what Draco is about to do, screams “No!,” and decides to quickly cast Expelliarmus, but Draco’s adrenaline-filled on-edge state makes him react to Harry’s spell casting as the latter was drawing his wand, dodging it, and as Ron casts his own to help Harry, Draco deflects it back at him, knocking Ron back. Draco then quickly casts Sectum Sempra at Harry, cutting both his hands and making him drop his wand, disarming him in a brutal way as a way to both reflect how Harry cut him in the bathroom and to create a moment of parallelism between both to show how he is both different and very similar to Harry (using spells to disarm, but what each spell does represent their moral alignments and emotional states in the moment and their upbringing). Harry freezes as his hands are bleeding and looks attentively and in desperation at Dumbledore, who softly say’s “Please Harry, don’t” while Draco points his wand at Dumbledore, trembling, and screams at the protagonist, “Stand Down, Potter,” half-crying, with an expression of guilt for what he was about to do that almost felt like he was asking Harry to do everything to stop him, but also to truly stand down so Draco can kill Dumbledore and save his family from being murdered by Voldemort. Time starts moving slowly as Draco turns his back from Potter to look at Dumbledore one last time and ready his Avada Kedavra. Harry stands up and positions himself to “tackle” Draco to prevent him from firing the killing curse. Seeing that, Ron, who thinks Draco could instead kill Harry if fast enough to react to the protagonist’s attack like before, screams for Harry to stop, which actually makes Draco become aware that Harry is going to tackle him, making the former move his wand toward Harry and try casting Depulso to push the latter away from him. But Harry is too quick, and as the spell leaves Draco’s wand, Harry’s tackle to remove the wand from his hand pushes the spell in the direction of Dumbledore, ultimately causing the headmaster to fall from the Tower and die from the impact. This moment would haunt Draco, Harry, and Ron for a long time, being almost in a similar configuration to the fight between Grindelwald, Dumbledore, and Aberforth, with Ron feeling like he caused Draco to cast Depulso by trying to stop Harry (something that could have been explored further through their Horcrux conflict in the last book); Draco feeling like, even though he did not directly kill his headmaster, he inadvertently did by casting the charm that caused Dumbledore to fall, saving his family and helping him be promoted by Voldemort in the same way he was in the books, but feeling some form of hidden emptiness and remorse for doing so (which could justify a sudden redemption arc in the Battle of Hogwarts where he joins Dumbledore’s Army after dueling Harry one last time, a moment that would test Harry’s compassion, goodness, and forgiveness because he would use the moment to thrown all his anger after Dumbledore’s death at Draco and want to possibly kill him), and Harry feeling like he was the one that accidentally aimed the spell at Dumbledore, being the most responsible for his mentor’s death, somebody he loved dearly, much like Dumbledore loved Ariana so much. For Harry specially, after Voldemort cast Avada Kedavra at him and he went to the limbo King’s Cross, his conversation with Dumbledore could result in the latter being able to finally absolve himself from the guilt of his sister’s death by helping Harry forgive himself so the latter does not live a life blaming himself for this incident and suffer because of it, or at least, if that is not Dumbledore but a part of Harry’s consciousness or soul, Harry can help forgive himself by also releasing Dumbledore from his own suffering, something not even the greatest wizard could ever do, who would probably see and appreciate the gesture from the after life
You guys had your tongues tied enough in this match you both get a point.
Taking this quiz I just felt like "if I say Yaxley often enough, it'll eventually be true"
From the Phineas and Ferb intro song to Harry Potter to the brothers reminding me again in this quiz I've always hated hearing about other kids' summers. Here it's 6 weeks and back to school you go.
That june 30 97 process was insane for both of them
The real winners are the viewers. Love the banter.
6:27 J should lose a point because he totally looked during the "no look high 5." #TeamYoungerBrother
3:41 I worked at a bookstore…a woman waited in line, read it as fast as she could and STORMED into the bookstore and YELLED I can’t believe she killed off Dumbldor! The store was packed, kids started crying, it was a mess.
Well this was an unexpected quiz 😅
The short summer holidays thing is a British thing. Our summer holidays tend to start mid to late July and last 6-8 weeks. Sometimes we call them the 6 week holidays.
I'd love for you to do a team created quiz on your What if Harry was in Slytherin! Let's see how well you know your own theories
British person here!🙋🏻♀️ We get 6 weeks summer holiday and 2 weeks for Christmas... interesting to see this differs in the US!
It varies based on private or public and the state you're in. As well as how many, if any, days school was cancelled due to inclement weather. I was raised in Illinois and went to Chicago public schools. We started our year the first Tuesday in September (that Monday is a federal holiday, Labor Day, so no school) and our last day of the year was anywhere between June 19-22. People graduating from 8th grade or high school ended earlier by a week or two, usually.
I had friends who went to Catholic schools and they usually started in August and ended in mid to late May. That was roughly the same timeframe for students in suburban school systems as well.
If our public schools were ***officially*** cancelled due to extreme weather, if the cancellations were more than two days we'd have to stay in school a little longer if I recall correctly. That's probably not at much the case anymore thanks to technology. UNOFFICIALLY depending on the weather we were told we could stay home and it wouldn't be held against us on that day. Days in school is mostly a government funding issues. Catholic schools were a lot more relaxed about closing for bad weather as some of my neighborhood friends loved rubbing in my face.
I'd like to share that I was one of the first victims of the spoiler. I was literally at the midnight book release of half blood prince and one of the people ahead of me in line got the book, turned immediately to the end and skim read it as they were heading to the door and just as they left they yelled out "Snape kills Dumbledore!" before sprinting out the door.
I was a little more lucky eventough I read all the books in German (at the point when the English Version was already puplished). I knew Dumbledore will most likely die because I read in a supplement of a News Paper that some guys who printed the book bet on him but who ever wrote the Article at least didn't spoil it was Snape. So it was still a shock too me when he died. But my brother spoiled to me Sirius Black will die after reading that somewhere in a Youths Magazine. I was kind of mad but on the other hand I didn't want to believe it Oh, and I overheared two fellow students talking about Deathly Hallows and one of them told the other that a readhead will die but had the other one guess which. Fortunatly they didn't get to the point of revealing it.
This is one the funniest ones I’ve seen in the 6 years I’ve been watching you guys!
21:54 That was the second spell. Edit: Third apparently. Also, the first spell I remember was the Cruciatus curse, not stunning charm.
I laughed way too hard at "Getalongical". Or the fact that Ben was so proud of the joke. Either one, it was hella funny.
Normally in England we finish school at the end of July so June is early. Then we go back at the start of September
If anyone ever finds themselves in Whitby, UK: They found an 'actual' Hand of Glory in one of the old buildings (a pub I think), and it's currently being displayed in the Whitby Museum. There's also instructions with it on how to make it.
It's pretty gruesome looking.
I'm reasonably sure it was Rowle on the astronomy tower, not Yaxley. The confusion is that both of them are often described as large blonde Death Eaters
No Rowle was in the fight firing death curses everywhere.
“Snape kills Dumbledore” is our generation’s “Darth Vader is Luke’s father.”
Fun fact: studies suggest ignoring your facial expressions does allow you to focus and remember better. Same idea as turning down the radio to see better. It frees up more active memory and reduces distractions. So the face scrunching totally helps.
The spoiler that started all spoilers was Darth Vader being Luke's father. People told people who were waiting in line to see the movie.
Bro I'm in an hotel room on a really crappy bed rn but this video makes everything better
I got ten correct!! I got the date too! I figured out what age Harry was and I knew that they were already technically done with school so I knew it was in June and then I remembered that Dumbledore’s will was read a month later! I am so proud of myself!
There's only ONE thing from Cursed Child I consider canon and only because it fits her personality and that is Hermione becoming Minister of Magic.
the second quizmaster question simply says "casualty" not "fatality" so Bill would have been a perfectly acceptable answer...
I was at Otakon when the book dropped. Some people bought it, flipped to the end, and announced the spoiler to a crowded convention room over a speaker.
bowtruckles were also casualties, they burned when Hagrid's house was set on fire
golly gee i wonder who killed dumbledoor
edit: glad he changed the thumbnail
Schools in the UK usually only have 6 weeks holiday in summer, with the final week of july being the first week of the holidays, in fact I think this Friday is the last day before summer holidays, but they do get 2 weeks off at christmas and 2 weeks off at easter with a week off in-between (October, February, May)
Gibbon was the one who was hit by a killing curse from another death eater that narrowly missed one of the DA thanks to Felix, I knew it was a death eater but didn't know the name
Muggles in the UK only usually get 6 weeks of summer holidays, 'only 8 weeks'?! Hogwarts has private school holidays. The date question was brilliant, love that you both changed your mind on the year as well.
Man, TWO separate questions where we forgot about the Bowtruckles that burned in Hagrid’s hut?! RIP Bowtruckles
Gone but never forgot... Oh wait
im so glad im watching this. been having some hard mornings since our snooki passed away and these laughs gave me some strength
my boyfriend at the time showed up to the movie theatre to pick me up after watching that movie., with a shirt that said "dumbldore dies on page 596"
I guessed the same date, but it was based on harry, Ron, and Hermione receiving their bequests on Harry's birthday (which is 1 month and a day after Dumbledore's death)
"Snape kills Dumbledore was a spoiler before spoilers were a thing ...." Really? I'm sure people were spoiling "No, I am your father" way before the book came out.
OMG!! I'm still laughing at the idea of the DeathEaters using the "buddy system"!! Draco: Now, does EVERYONE have their buddy? Hold your buddy's hand; it's gonna get dark in here. Bellatrix: Uh, I don't have a buddy; we have an odd number! Draco: Ugh . . . Alright, fine, Aunt . . . You're up here with me, then. That's HILARIOUS!! 🤣🤣 (Yes, I'm watching/listening to this @ work right now. Shh! Don't tell anyone! I'm alone in my office right now; no kiddos . . . 🤫)
In my senior year at high school at the final assembly of the school year, the student body president got up to the podium and said "ahem. Snape kills Dumbledore." And just continued with his speech while the ENTIRE auditorium groaned loudly. I was cackling with glee.
Hogwarts: uses 3-headed 8500lbs heavy dog and fire spitting dragons to attack students.
Also Hogwarts: uses children with wooden sticks to defend Hogwarts with their lives.
The spoiler of Dumbledore’s death is like the spoiler for trials of Apollo.
Spoiler warning if you haven’t read it.
Jason’s death
Here's a "What if?" for you guys to explore: What would happen if Dumbledore was killed by being struck by lightning?
What could Harry have accomplished with the Elder Wand if he chose to keep using it? Could he have healed Frank and Alice Longbottom?
When Ben had the right day and month but wrong year, I almost had a heart attack. 😂
Fenrir Greyback wasn't a death eater, was he?
He was an ally, but I don't think he was an official death eater
That is correct. In Deathly Hallows he was leading the gang of snatchers, including Scabior, that caught the Golden Trio. It was specifically mentioned that he was allowed to wear Death Eaters' robes, but had never been given the high honor of a Dark Mark on his arm, which Fenrir considered to be a shortcoming on his own part.
@@arinerm1331 Can Fenrir do magic like Lupin?
@@dragonweyr44 No one could do magic like Lupin!
Im pretty sure bill was scratched not bitten. Aren't his scars described as being more like they were from claws than teeth?
That's just the choice made in the movies. The description in HBP makes the details of the attack sound much more vague and serious at the same time, just that he won't look the same anymore and Ginny can barely even talk about it. Not just a scratch by any means, but he survived due to Greyback being in human form at the time.
@Levacque no, fenrir being in human form is why Bill isn't a werewolf, Fenrir wasn't trying to kill him. We know that because if greyback wants to kill you, he will.
I am not sure who was the first person to post the spoiler online, but someone was shouting it out at my midnight book release before I even had my chance to purchase the book. I honestly thought the guy was trolling and telling lies to get everyone riled up. No idea how that guy scanned through the book that fast. It couldn't have been more then 10 minuets.
The Carrows, Greyback, Corbin Yaxley, and the dude who accidentally got Avada Kedavra’d. Bobbins or something. Plus technically Snape and Draco I suppose.
Truly enjoy how both freak out a little at the specification of a *YEAR* for the incident, like that's the hard part. 😆
That build up of them trying to figure out question 2 and getting it right instantly lowered my stress level for the day 😂👏🏻
"Day, month, year" Ben says, pointing at his screen. I wonder what the 30th month is in his books xD
Poor Ben. Banging the elbow on the corner of the table, a balmy day outside for the BRB, and a J win. But at least we got to here J exclaim "Butts on Face". We need that clip of Luke singing his song.
I'm sorry, but September 1st is NOT always a Monday in the books, only the first book, because it WAS a Monday in 1991. Most of her dates are fairly accurate to real world calendars, except for year 2, for some reason. Also she got the full moon dates off in year three, but most the rest of it is pretty solid.
🎉it's my birthday 🎂🎉 always a great time watching yall videos let's go 😂
Please tell me I'm not the only person who saw Ben write covid rather than coward in answer to the insult Harry shouted at Snape...
"most infamous spoiler ever" ?
For a guy who has a son called Luke, does "Luke, I am your father" not ring a bell? lol
WOW!!! 6/30/97 You BOTH got it!!! 🤯
When was it mentioned that Yaxley was there? The text says "four death eaters", and only the Carrows and Greyback are mentioned by name
A kid in my high school yelled “DUMBLEDORE DIES!” in the hallway right before I got to that part in the book and I still hate him for that like 15 years later
School ends here in the UK towards the end of July (this week is the last week for most I believe), they have 6 weeks off.
6:35 " . . the end of the year because there's no more classes." Or, end of the year because it's the end of the book and that's when all the fun stuff happens.
I think Ben just claimed Harry called Snape a Covid.
3:14. Even worse….I heard stories of people exiting the book store, and someone driving up and shouting out the window that Snape kills Dumbledore. Wow….Just….Wow. People can be such a-holes
I remember the day Half-Blood Prince came out, the local newspaper published a two-page story with "Dumbledore is dead, and Snape killed him" across the first page without warning
WHY?! Why did the LOCAL newspaper do that?!
@@KelseyBurns3 I should clarify, by "local" I mean the biggest newspaper in my local state, the one synonymous with my state
@@TaliesinMyrddinwhy though?! Still why? Who thought it would be a good idea to ruin th book for everyone?
@@KelseyBurns3I have absolutely no idea, they wanted the newspaper equivalent of clicks, I guess
Darth Vader was Luke’s father was the ultimate spoiler. Shape killing Dumbledore was a distant second.
I think the first big online presence to do the ‘Snape kills Dumbledore’ thing might have been Maddox. He put up an article tagged no spoilers like the day it came out and the action and page was the first line in the article
FYI for anyone wondering, UK schools only have 6 weeks holiday in the summer. Term usually ends three weeks into July, so that's why students could stay if they wanted to, and the conversation was about sending students home early for the summer! 😊
1:365 chance and both get it right! That was cool to watch the gears turn.
Just pointing out that Sirius does explain to Harry how to use the two-way mirrors. He tells him to look into the mirror and say his name.
WOAH WHAT AN AD FOR THAT COFFEE GREAT JOB GUYS