Episode 03: Ashok Kumar By Saadat Hasan Manto

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 8

  • @ranbirsinghraman1554
    @ranbirsinghraman1554 Год назад

    इस एपिसोड के आखिरी हिस्से वाली आपकी प्रस्तुति सुनकर एक ही साथ आह और वाह वाह निकल पड़ी। अंतिम जुमले के साथ जाम चटकने की आवाज़ ने रियलिज्म का अनोखा एहसास कराया। वाह साहब वाह। जितनी तारीफ करुं कम होगी।

  • @ranbirsinghraman1554
    @ranbirsinghraman1554 Год назад

    वाहहहहहहहहहहहह
    वाहहहहहहहहहहहह
    वाहहहहहहहहहहहह
    परवेज़ आलम साहब। आपकी यह पूरी की पूरी कलेक्शन बेहद शानदार और दिलचस्प है। आपका बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद शुक्रिया आभार । आपको अनेक शुभकामनाएं ।

  • @jameelasiddiqi9657
    @jameelasiddiqi9657 Год назад +1

    Great stuff. Very well presented. Loved the sound effects. Thanks for sharing.

    • @CINEINK
      @CINEINK  10 месяцев назад

      Thanks. You're such a connoisseur!

  • @HR-tq4fc
    @HR-tq4fc 2 года назад

    Great work keep it up you are doing well

  • @ShaherNama
    @ShaherNama Год назад

    Beautiful

  • @prernajain7482
    @prernajain7482 2 года назад

    Kitni layers hain is khakey mein. It is about Ashok Kumar but I could feel Manto's pain in it. He seems to love Mumbai, must have been really tough for him to leave his friends and his city.

    • @CINEINK
      @CINEINK  Год назад

      Thanks. We missed your comment. True, it's a multi-layered sketch where Manto realised that it was going to be difficult for him to sustain in that communally charged atmosphere. Ashok Kumar turned out to be a true friend but that was not enough. This is where a visionary like Manto failed miserably. He was a liberal- a genuine progressive as well as irreverent towards all isms. Pakistan was not for him.
      Sahir Ludhianvi had also left for Pakistan but he came back.
      Manto didn't. He was embarrassed to admit his blunder.