Beta 58a vs SM58 | Vocal Mic Shootout and Comparison!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
- Grab a Beta 58a Here: amzn.to/2U7nY0d
Grab a SM58 Here: amzn.to/2CEJbVv
This video contains Spoken Word and Singing vocal A/B shootout of the Beta 58a and the SM58 followed by a brief comparison of the features of the two mics.
Since I just got a brand new Shure Beta 58a, in this video, vocal mic shootout and comparison is the order of the day.
Thanks for watching!
Click to Subscribe:
ruclips.net/channel/UCmVB...
I've been wanting to do this comparison for a long time and finally got ahold of a Beta58a (for science.) I think it sounds brighter and more detailed- what do you think?
Tested both face-to-face, think the same.
I subbed cause you actually give us what we want for a review , thanks
Hey, thank you for that. What is it specifically you were looking for?
Thanks for the video! good comparison 🤘
Thank you for saying so, I appreciate it!
This is a perfect comparison vid. I wish all comparison vids were this straight to the point and useful!
Legendary comparison. Many thanks.
Fauxtaku Lounge no, thank you! What do you think, got a preference???
Just Bought the Beta58 Today I tried it out at a gig , live audio , sound is Beast cant go wrong with The Beta58 , previously I had the SM58 after Trying Beta58 , defenetily Staying with Beta. 🎸🎸📯🎤…subscribed 👍🏽
Thanks man! Love to hear that. I did a gig with mine last weekend and it sounded great as always! Can’t go wrong
I got the beta 58a ~ luv it!
Always sounds great just great lol. Nice rhyme bro.
Thank you for your video! Interesting... this is the second comparison in which I noticed, that Shure Beta 58A actually does a better job in rejecting handling noises, compared to the Shure SM58. Now i wonder, how the Shure SM58 would fare against the Behringer BA85A. That one is not great for handling noise either. Lets see, if I can find a comparison between those two somewhere.
Super helpful. Thank you!! 😄🎤✌️
I own a shure beta58 for singing and a beta57 for my guitar, piano or violin
Awesome Man! Your Mic Testing Is Awesome and Also your voice is Lovely. Best Wishes.
Thanks very much. Lmk if you have any questions, happy to help If I can
@@matteliasmusic Thank you so much. That's very kind of you.
Thank you !!!! ❤🎉
Beta 58a cuts thru better, keeping the vocals upfront in the mix. I sold my SM58 and traded-up to the Beta 58a - never looked back. Nice job. Fair & detailed comparison.
thanks dude! i agree totally, a beta will cut through the mix easier than a vanilla 58 for sure!
@@matteliasmusic Yeah . . . both great, rugged, and quality - but I feel Shure expanded on the Sm58 design, and made improvements with the Beta 58a. I also have an Audio Technica AT-4033 - that's a phenomenal Mic. Now I'm researching a High-quality Headphone Lead-vocal Mic - so I can play Guitar & Keyboards and move freely??? It never ends! Stay Safe brother.
@@michael_caz_nyc haven’t had a chance to try out any AT mics! And yes, haha good luck with your Gear Acquisition, it truly never ends
@@michael_caz_nyc i own the 4040 do you know the difference ?
@@vincentdelmas2792 No sorry. But I'm sure there's a comparison on the Audio Technica home page with regard to SPL and frequency response ect . . .
Alright, I'm sold. Gonna get me a Beta 58A now. Good video. Thanks dude.
Thank you!!Lmk how it works for you!!!
Works great. I definitely prefer it to the regular SM58.
The sm58 sound a bit muffle on the low bass frequencies and the beta is more clear sound . I do like the beta because u can also add the more lows and it will be more clearer
So - I'm just looking for a mic that works well in a live situation (as in - on stage with lots of noise).
I find lots of reviews in studios / home studios, but none of them address how these mics perform when being hand-held by a person running around on stage while a band is producing very loud music.. 🙂
Hi
I hesitate a lot between three microphones for sound quality. between the Shure 58A, the rode reporter, and the Sony ICD-TX660
what do you recommend ?
Hi. Howday!
Can you make a video how to differentiate Counterfeit Beta58a and the original one?
SM58 ALL DAY!
Great review!
Upgraded from a Sm58 to a beta 58 when I decided to get a wireless system. Best move ever!
Man, I used a 58 only for many years, and I'm with you- upgrading to that Beta has made a big difference for me on vocals, the clarity and response is so great, at least for my voice. \m/
SM 58,the leyend
That's right my friend, many great things have been made with them
Which one is better for vocoder singing?
The beta58s are alot louder and has a better build quality but both are good mics
a wireless comparaison please
The difference is negligible . I still prefer the tried and true SM58 . For my voice which verges on almost baritone from tenor , I still prefer the SM58 Everything can be adjusted at the board . As far as price , I can get 3 SM58's and have lunch at the cafe nextdoor for what 2 Beta 58's cost .
@Emerito, Professor of Love!
That’s a riot . 😆
These are stage mics for live use and not anything that one would be using for a studio vocal track . I mean unless you’re a garage jockey . Sound better 😆More hits 😆
The difference between the two is negligible at best and subjective while settings at the board make a bigger difference in what comes out of the cones than you’ll ever achieve between the two mics . Then there’s the listener which will never be able to garner up any definition between the two even if all other aspects are equal .
I like the sm58 sounds more warm too me and sounds better on your vocals
Tom spiller thank you! I can definitely see why you’re hearing the 58 being more warm, and I also can’t disagree that my particular voice has some harsh mid-high stuff that happens sometimes and that might come across as less harsh on the 58.
@@matteliasmusic I think it's a good choice for your vocals. Goes well. What pre amp are u using? And I was going to ask u what u suggest for me. I wanted to record with the sm 58 with sonar 4 producer edition but im looking for a nice pre amp that sounds warming for home studio. What do u think?
Tom spiller for this vid I was using the onboard pres on my zoom h6 field recorded, and they’re OK. If you’re looking for a real velvety warming sound, you could try a tube pre! I have a single channel tube microphone preamp from ART that really does that classic tube warmth nicely, I snagged it used for like $30 that was a steal, but really they’re pretty inexpensive if you wanted to go that route
@@matteliasmusic okay. I'll give it a shot. My budget was around $700 maybe I can get a more high end Art. I just wanted something that adds warmth to my recordings. And everyone says its all about a good mic pre. I'll give it a try. Thanks bro for getting back to me.
Tom spiller of course dude, thank you for taking the time to talk with me after watching the vid. You can get something pretty cool for that price
good video, hey should i use either of these for spoken word while doing a let's play on a video game? about 1-2 feet from my mouth.
Layarion hey there, thanks! You certainly could, I would recommend having it closer to the sound source (you) if possible when using dynamic mics like this, that way you could avoid having to crank up the gain too much and have a slightly messier recording. For streaming or voiceover while gaming, i could recommend going with something like a Blue Yeti, in a similar price range with these, and as a bonus it’s got a USB output so you could skip the interface and go right into your computer if you like. A condenser mic like that would be my pic for that application, if you want the mic out of the shot and away from your face. I have owned a Yeti for several years and it works great for that kind of thing, it’s even what I use for video conferencing as well.
Thanks for the comparison. Im a rookie, and its nice to get good info. I heard the handleing sounds right away when you were doing the 180 degree example at start of your video. Maybe thats not a big deal, I dont know yet (rookie I am), I do want more volume though cuz my band mates turn my mic down too much, if they keep that up, Im gunna go solo and kick their arses:), anyway, you test seemed real, not so laboratory. My use will be live as well.// After you have used it for a while, what do you think?
022100bmlotus bandmates turning down the lead singer in the mix??? Let me talk to them for you 😡 LOL but yes both of these mics are legendary for their durability and reliability, if you’ve got the extra cash the Beta does offer somewhat more premium build features and a slightly more sparkly high end as you could see here, which may help you in cutting through a dense mix, but honestly if someone’s intent on meddling with your levels in the mix you’re going to have trouble no matter what you’re using
@@matteliasmusic Humor is good
022100bmlotus yes
I have both mics and to be honest I was disappointed with the beta 58 to Me sounds more like a condenser sm58 but I prefer the Sm58
Fair assessment, it all comes down to what you like. Lucky for you your ears prefer the cheaper one 🤓
@@matteliasmusic they both sound pretty close to me, the beta 58 sounds more brighter and a little more hollow sound and the sm 58 sounds more full sound and darker. Out of all the mics you have reviewed and used which one do u prefer?
Great video. Your broadcast mic, does it sound rather better than those shure ones?!
Thanks so much! I was using a shotgun mic for my zoom h6. It sounds amazing , it’s very sensitive so turning the ac/heat off is real haha
@@matteliasmusic Hey Matt: Nice job, good review. Just bought a Beta 58 A. But the "ZoomH-6" caught my ear! I have an H-4. Can you do a review on that series? Thanks Man!✌♥️👍
@@johnroseman9087 I’ll add it to the list! Do you like the h4?
@@matteliasmusic It's the H-2. So far ..yes, but am still learning it
Just purchased the Beta 58A from Amazon for $137. I already have an SM58 so thought I'd give it a try.. SM58's are $99 almost everywhere, so only $38 more seemed like a deal.This will replace my Audio Technica ATM27HE which died and Technica discontinued it and will not even repair it. Great mic when it worked but very bad customer service. Mic was never abused either.
It's easy to set up
I generally find the Beta to be too trebley. The original 58 is warmer to my ears and I lose a lot of that with the Beta.
less than 1 inch
Agree 👍
I agree
Hello, I have the go xlr mini and I'm about to get the sE Dynamite but I can't decide which microphone is the best, I do stream on twitch btw, I hope you can tell me which one would be better for streaming!
So what was the verdict using it live on stage did you like the 58A sm58?
So I definitely do find myself grabbing the beta over the 58 for gigs almost every time, although I have to say that I always bring an extra 58 just in case because that thing can serve just about any purpose you could need a mic for onstage in case of emergency, even including miking a guitar cab if necessary.
A year since your last upload??
Can someone tell me:::
I bought Shure SM 58 beta. Today I tested my Shure PGA58 with 58 Beta and i didn't find much difference of sound eventhough Beta58 price is nearly 3 times more than PGA58. Am I doing something wrong?
shammishafi09 probably not doing anything wrong- but the differences in those mics are pretty stark, the PGA is basically a very entry level mic as I understand it. Differences would include overall build quality, durability, handling noise rejection, the beta 58a has a built-in pop filter where the PGA really doesn’t, as well as frequency response (the beta will be slightly better at picking up certain frequencies). I can certainly understand your disappointment if you had an expectation of like a night and day difference in sound quality being immediately recognizable- maybe what you’re looking for is the sound of some kind of a condenser mic? Depending on what your application is of course
@@matteliasmusic Many many thanks!!!!
As my living area is bit crowdy so dynamic mic is suitable more.
But Beta58A has more cleaner sound and I don't need pop filter.
are they better than a condenser mic for studio vocals in a place without acoustic treatment?
Could be. A condenser mic will likely pick up every little thing in the room which might include a bunch of echos and noise that you don’t want
What's the best beta sm58 or shure sm58 reply
My short answer is the beta- but it really depends on what you need it for, because there are design differences between the 2 mics that change their functionality
which performs better in live singing?
They're both great on stage and 10/10 reliable. Beta 58a has a little more natural brightness and so might cut through a mix more easily, but you can't go wrong either way IMO
❤
I prefer the sm58 . It’s sounds more warm and smooth . The beta58 is a little but more bright
Just bought the Beta 58a an hour ago
Gratz!! I've been using it for vocals heavily since I did this video and it always delivers, really nice sound.
Matt Elias
I bought it after listening to listen video 😎✊️ cheers man
Which one is better to scream/gutural metal vocals?
You can’t go wrong with either one. Both will hold up great on stage and sound great.
58 imho
Keep in mind that the SM picks up a lot of surrounding sound (cardioid pattern) from your band mates. The beta isolates your vocals better (supercardioid pattern).
Here is the biggest problem I've come across with most amateur producers and bands etc They look for a mic and ways for the singer to sit in the mix.....This is totally stupid no professional producer ever does this, You must build the whole song and mix around the singer or else your putting the cart before the horse. Think Kenny G, Acker Bilk is a perfect example, go listen to stranger on the shore, it was a world wide hit back in the day, he was the Kenny G of his generation, but he played the Clarinet people always say they can't get the Clarinet to sound good in a mix it's not meant to. You need to tailor the whole song instrumentation EQ to fit in with support and make that lead instrument blend and shine modern mixing technieques focus on the whole mix too much and not the goal.
My voice sounds like a Waylon Jennings, Johnny Cash range. Would this mic be good for that range?
Sure would. I have another video comparing the beta58a to a Sennheiser e935 where I do some baritone johnny cash singing to test the low end. Check my channel, see if you like how it sounds. But honestly you can’t go wrong with one of these
@@matteliasmusic thanks🤘🏼
nice vocal , what about the other gear?
thanks! didn't test these with other applications this time since they're primarily vocal mics, but they are absolutely very versatile!
Less sibilance on the SM58 from your voice.
I’ve noticed that on other comparison videos and it’s why I’ll stick to the 58.
Annoyingly somebody stole my blue ring off my beta 58 mic when i set mines up in the studio... and Shure charge stupid amounts to replace that...
Sir I am full beginner. I want to record my written poetry professionally. Suggest me audio interface and dynamic mic. Which gives me professional level quality. Because my room is not sound proof. My total budget is 300 dollars. Tell me such a setup that I will not regret buying.
Can’t go wrong with focusrite Scarlett solo and an sm58.
@@matteliasmusic Can I use Audient's ID4? Do I need DBX too?
@@civilfieldengineer I’ve never used one but I’m sure an ID4 will work just fine
@@matteliasmusic Thanks sir 🙏
SM58 IS THE BEST!
i don't want the word - beta around me - fucking betaaaa - in Jesse Lee Peterson voice
Don't get it why people call the SM58 "built like a tank" - I mean, I get that the mic can still work, after many accidents,
but the grill is worthless: fell once on the carpet (floor) and already received a pretty ugly bump / dent.
It felt cheaper than a 30 dollars china mic from the market...
I guess the idea is that the grill takes the damage and the capsule stays safe. The beta 58a has a hardened grill and it seems to be a bit tougher
@@matteliasmusic Or....DON'T drop your mic.... I've had my 58 for 30 years and still looks new after 500+ gigs!!!
1:54. 2:01.
Wiww
Wewwwwwwwww
Beta sounds better
SM58 sounded deeper och fuller for spoken word and the Beta58 sounded better when you sang in it.
The bottom line for me Beta 58 is NOT $60 better as a matter of fact depends on what it been use for
Fair enough. Nothing wrong with an sm58, people have been using them for 50+ years for a reason
''i used to have Beta58a...very nice until i sang with Sennheiser....''
Sennheisers are really nice too! I have an e945 and I really like it, although i do still use my beta 58a as well. Do you use them on stage, or just at home/in studio?
@@matteliasmusic hey.... I'm a kinda blues rocker vocalist. I need a nice clean mic, and I can't decide between the bets58 and sennheiser that u mentioned... In your opinion... What's better?
Hey brother! Honestly you can not go wrong with either one. Think about the tone of your voice and your pitch range- it's possible that you might want to go with the Beta 58 if you say have a very piercing high end to your singing, but even then both mics will serve you well and last forever. Remember also that the Beta is slightly less expensive 🤙🤙
@@matteliasmusic ahhhh.. I'm so divided between sennheiser and this beta... Does the beta sound harsh?
@@andregolovan5110 No, not at all!
When you sang through the SM58 you sound like Bon Jovi. The Beta sounds crap on your voice.
SeanPatrickGreat HAHA there’s a comparison I’ve never gotten before, thank you, Jon BJ is a badass! What is it about the 58 that you like better?
@@matteliasmusic Ha Ha loved your reply
The Beta sounds better to the singer most of the time because people.dont hear their voices like others do, when it's your own voice people tend to want more sibilance. Many male RUclipsrs who want that news anchor sound, turn the mids up and sit on top of the mic, and it just sounds fake and annoying but to the guy on the Mike he sounds more "manly" Adrian I love you... But in real life they sound nothing like a sudo Barry White. Its like bad Photoshop for your voice. You look prettier but at the same time weird.
Professional Voice over artists and professionals on tv never do this Why......
For a Michael Bublé swing voice or a lower voice the Beta often sounds Beta I mean better. But on a voice like Bono or Bonjovi the SM58 would sound better. And for that Oasis or Jon Lennon sound a slightly higher male voice with less power the SM57 sounds better.
You could talk of hours about this one way or the other..... PEACE OUT!
Your comment is brilliant! I thought only I thought that way!