Windows vs Windows Server | Speed Test
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 14 июл 2024
- Windows vs. Windows Server | Speed Test. How does a $1000 server OS compare to an ordinary consumer OS in benchmarks and real-world tests? This was very interesting…
Timestamps:
Intro 0:00
Startup 0:21
Login 0:51
Storage 1:06
RAM Management 1:21
CPU Management 1:49
Battery Life 2:24
Wi-fi Speed 3:15
Audio Editing 3:40
Video Editing 3:55
Opening Applications 4:20
Web Browsing 6:00
File Transfer 6:45
Virus Scan 7:07
Benchmarks 7:24
Conclusion 8:54
Playlists:
Microsoft Playlist: • Playlist
Windows Comparisons: • Windows Speed Tests
Similar to Windows XP vs Windows Vista vs Windows 7 vs Windows 8.1 vs Windows 10 or 32-bit vs. 64-bit speed comparison test, but a Windows vs. Windows Server performance test instead. 
Наука
Win Server by default typically runs the CPUs less hard / more efficiently for multicore processes, thereby causing the single thread apps to open slower. That can be changed in the power settings.
Finally a video which explains what this “windows server” version is.
Not really. Windows Server is just a Windows that can be used to route, set up Active Directory, create domains etc etc, so tbh comparing it to Windows 10 does not explain what is it
It’s Windows for servers
minecraft server hehe
@@GameNobz among us server hehe
@@DOHA104p3 nah i'm doing minecraft serves for a living ;)
1:36 Notice how Windows Server has Memory compression off - it says 0MB is compressed, unlike regular Windows 10 compressing some of the memory as needed.
Yeah because disabling it cause less issues and make the system more reliable
I have windows 10 pro and memory compression off by default
You still need to keep in mind that windows 10 is optimized for consumer usage.
And Windows server for server usage
Agreed
Can windows server be used as a personal os?
And the windows 10 drivers can be installed in windows server 2019?
@@alphateezeey4117 yes but ur not really supposed to, nor should you. it has stuff more geared towards servers and it is a bit of a security risk to have all the stuff it has/
@@alphateezeey4117 all windows drivers are universal, BUT windows server usually only works with the preinstalled drivers. also, with win server, you don't have any apps you have preinstalled with normal versions of windows (e.g. mail, photos, paint, camera, calculator, etc.)
He back again for the bazillionth time
The million millionth time
imagine getting windows server only for the old background
btw welcome back
lol
Why someone would do that though?
Instead of paying 1000 dollars for Windows Server 2019, he just download the wallpaper from the internet
@@SunIsLost yea
@@SunIsLost windows server runs on older software and is not new and shiny like the consumers windows 10. The reason for that is reliability.
2:05 it may also mean different thermal compounds under cpu, or paste applied on each ThinkPad with months in between, or different stages of dust accumulation, or the ThinkPad that is hotter(right) is to close to the ThinkPad on the left making it more difficult to evacuate heat efficiently, and the 91C limit on both could indicate a max thermal limit setting in bios before cpu throttling.
It's the same laptop. He just shot the two scenes separately and put them next to each other while editing. You can see at some points like 5:27 the difference in lighting when the color balances is offset. At the beginning I thought they were two laptops too, though.
@@JackMaslovCZLive yes you're right. I didn't catch that.
In case you were wondering, the main use for Windows Server is to function as an Active Directory (AD) domain controller. So in a company, user accounts are stored on a server rather than individual computers, which allows administrators to do things like reset passwords remotely, assign users to groups, and give them access to certain resources.
This also means users can log into the same account on another computer (though AD doesn't store the user's documents on the server...at least not by default).
just saying ur the only person that i subbed to as soon as i saw my the first vid that was made by them! some of my favorite youtubers im not even subbed to! i just feel like u answer every question that no one else does and i feel like i can relate, keep up the great work!
Whait, are you telling me, my ultra low-end laptop came with a 1,300 dollar Windows server copy.... when bought at 200 dollars?!!
Yes lol
You are so lucky dude
These tests are done really well, and I would love to see more!
there's a reason why it has "server" attached to its name.
It is for high capacity storage, more RAM, 24/7 run time and better reliability compared to Win10.
just wanted clear few things,
love your content ✌
#Win7User
#LinuxUbuntuUser
#NoPCUser
#iPadUser
@@Gumballcom37 i pad 🤣🤣
#win7andwin10user
Doing a speed test with two computers at the same time isn’t a proper test, one computer is going to take priority over the other on the router. Giving both heat sinks fresh paste would make this more of a fair test too.
@Microsoft Employee nope
He’s testing these on the exact same laptop, it’s not two laptops it’s the same one, just running both os’s to make it a fair test, it’s edited to put the laptops side by side, that’s why he has two left hands lol
@@AbiRose539 the problem is the RUclipsr is too lazy to explain this at the start of the video
@@AbiRose539 nope he has 1 left and 1 right
@@johnthemannn uh no?? He literally had two left hands in the video, it's an edited video, there's an incredibly obvious black cut line through the video
I think it's because Windows Server hasn't been updated since 2019, but Windows 10 is running on the latest 2021 update.
And here you have linux which doesn't take more than 400mb of ram idle😔
@@dazai2121 good luck with driver support
@@minkjay3218 Driver support isn't bad on linux, you do know most servers run linux, right?
@@minkjay3218 We don't live in 2010 anymore Linux driver support is nearly as good as driver support on Windows and sometimes even better because it's used in pretty much any Server.
It's gonna the a feature update to Windows Server 2021, 21H2 later this year.
ONE HUGE PROBLEM: If you didn't configure Server to prioritize "programs" over "background service" these tests are 100% pointless. The configuration is in System Properties > Advanced tab > Performance Options > Advance tab.
Great vid as always!
0:08 "Every other OS is free" while showing MacOS. Well guess what MacOS isnt free. You either buy the retail version or you buy an Apple product.
So you forgot about hackintosh
@@TechyMage I mean they're technically illegal and you can get Windows for free as well if you don't need customization...
macos is only free updates
@@johnthemannn Afaik Windows has free updates aswell right?
@@paulvorderegger1522 never said it didn't. im just explaining how he saw "Free" on the apple website.
The 91 degrees was because they then began thermal throttling
I didn't know the windows server was so expensive 😲
Because Windows Server is more expensive than running Linux due to licensing costs,
Windows Server 2022 is released, and i'm still using Windows 10 20H2.
THE LEGEND IS BACK!
Windows Server is for Servers and Datacenters which don’t require shut down or booting regularly
wrong choice of wording. don't want*.
6:33 timing was a bit off, you didn't press enter at the same time in this clip so we don't actually know which loaded first, but I'm assuming its still windows
No it's mac
@@elijahlee3610 no it's shit
@@rosify_. Mac is better than windows
@@iicarplaying1930 not really, mac is shit for gaming. It can’t even run 32 bit programs unlike windows 10
@@nolan3312 I admit Macs are not the best when it comes to gaming but you can play Roblox minecraft fortnite and other minor steam games in 60 to 200 FPS if you got a m1 MacBook Pro or air
A few things to consider:
1. These laptops come with a ton of drivers that have to be installed manually on 2019 and it is possible you have some divergence there.
2. Windows 10 comes with memory compression and software prefetch which might not be enabled on 2019 by default
3. The battery/performance profile settings seems different between the two, hence performance it is better to be benchmarked on desktops where these things might be set the same by default.
4. Windows 10 disk space "rot" over time is much more serious than the one on 2019 which makes the latter alot better with disk space management...
6:20 Windows 10 wins with .06 milliseconds, i still say same time
Make a part 2 where you use Windows Server 2022. It's available on the Evaluation center
You must wait a half year to win server 2022
great demo keep up the work :-)
Good job man keep upgrade all the best👍👍👍
Never expected that there was an abismal difference of the startup between these versions.
Wow amazing vid ❤️👍
windows 10 vs windows 11 pls
I installed win server to my L420 laptop. Where did you found the drivers ?
Fun fact: The reason why windows server battery life is better than normal windows 10 is due to the fact that server need longer to shutdown on ups if the main power is not stable or working.
bruh windows server has no battery life savers and the psu draws over 600w anyways so thats not how it works
@@johnthemannn So few words, so many errors. That is not what he meant.
Finally the legend is back WITH ANOTHER VIDEO!!!!
@sompots yes.
holy heck an actual upload
Love your videos you are best 👍
What do you think of Windows 11?
1:40 it means less software/bloatware runs in the background = less ram used on win server.
Welcome back to RUclips.
One thing worth mentioning. Software license on windows server tends to be way more expensive than on windows 10 counterpart. From 3x or so to 10x or higher. Sometimes windows server will need a license that is called “site license” compared to “personal/home license”.
And tbh, windows have come a long way that even personal use of windows 10 is good and stable enough that windows server’s extra stability and whatnot is not that necessary for most home/professional users, unless you legit run server grade software/hardware (e.g. ecc memory)
3:25 just test them one after the other, no need to test them at the same time
this is probably why server '19 failed miserably
He’s testing these on the exact same laptop, it’s not two laptops it’s the same one, just running both os’s to make it a fair test
@@AbiRose539 its not a fair test. its two laptops. look at the background and its not a greenscreen because its not grainy.
@@johnthemannn I'm looking at the background, there's literally a direct straight line showing where he cut it for the 2nd piece of footage, also how would he have two left hands??
Difference in temp can explain differences in boot up times. Differences in temp can be explained in just that one thinkpad is dirty or more used, or different thermal paste, also can be just the silicon lottery, but i bet it is ambient difference, like the wind moving from left to right , so , the second is sucking air heated from the first thinkpad, and so on.
Windows server is meant to always be online a boot up test isnt fair
Windows server is made for servers, not for personal use, especially on a laptop
Amazing comparison. I can totally imagine how hard it is to make such videos. Nice work man.
the legend is back boois
WHICH RECORDER DO YOU USE FOR RECORDING THE VIDS ON PC ?
Was Windows Server set on preferring programs instead of Services in advanced Settings?.
Finally, A video after almost a million years 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think it might be fairer to compare Windows 10 version v1809 instead of the latest version versus Windows Server 2019, since server 2019 is based on 1809. Just saying.
I know right
Yeah, he should of done LTSC 2019 vs Server 2019 in my opinion, they are both based on Windows 10 v1809
It would have been better to compare it between Windows 10 and Windows 10 LTSC instead of Windows Server. If you ran the same tests on a server I'm sure Windows server would have demolished Windows 10.
What you tried is like trying to fire real bullets with a nerf gun.
It was still pretty interesting to watch.
It'll be very interesting to see what happens if you try Windows 10 vs LTSC.
LTSC is exactly like 10 but without and bloatware, cortana, microsoft store, windows update etc etc. I personally used both of them and Windows 10 LTSC was noticeably faster.
Love your content btw uwu.
Finally A new video!! Yay!
Watched the “Deleting iOS System Files” video and immediately subbed. Don’t regret that decision one bit.
How do you do the battery life tweaks in ordinary windows?
these tests are too specific to say the test for the battery of one laptop the battery may be more degraded than the other for temperatures the one laptop may be more dusty than the other the test for the speed of opening applications may the disks whether they are the same or not more or less degraded because as we know HDDs and SSDs degrade many more
i belive that having 2 speed tests running at the same time will confict with the other, do one at a time
I always get Windows for free, either by .ISO images or pre-installed with pre-built PCs
r/madlads
Never paid for windows and never will pay. When I need to activate windows I just search “how to activate windows 10 for free” on RUclips and click the first tutorial. Works every time.
@@whale4565 I just search for [CENSORED BY MICROSOFT] on Google
syek tcudorP
@@LegoWormNoah101 why did you erase “product keys”, write “CENSORED BY MICROSOFT” and product keys backwards at the bottom
@@dank980 I am avoiding a lawsuit
@@LegoWormNoah101 i don't think microsoft sues people based on youtube comments
solely based on my observations, I think it's because SuperFetch is disabled or missing on Windows Server, which leads to less RAM usage and less cached apps in the background so in return, longer app launches.
I can explain opening applications. By default on windows server, the system will allocate more resources to background services then user applications. If you open system properties advanced you can actually toggle off the setting. Hope this helps!
The bootup test was like 2 seconds slower for server edition but the bios took longer like 10 seconds longer to load. That is not influenced by the server edition. Feels a little rigged.
nice the legend is back
Office generally keeps running in background from startup I guess which is not the case in windows server
we really need you to make videos about win 11 ...you are only legit tech channel on yt
i can name channels more legit, linus tech tips, mrwhostheboss, and more
Can ya do a windows 11 review? it's in the beta program, I'd like to see your thoughts!
6:19 Windows 10 did won that test, I can see that it loaded it first in the slow motion.
Storage Used: Windows Server takes EXACTLY two thirds of windows 10 os
Please make a video on Windows 11 vs 10 vs 8 vs 8.1 vs 7
More than half of the tests doesn't rely on the os so i don't even know what this test was good for.
ikr
keep in mind that you are doing the wifi speed tests at the same time... considering its wifi i am 100 percent certain one is interfearing with the other. do one after the other for a proper speed test as wifi is a radio wave and having any 2 devices next to each other competing for radio bandwidth will effect performance.
He’s testing these on the exact same laptop, it’s not two laptops it’s the same one, just running both os’s to make it a fair test, it’s edited to put the laptops side by side, that’s why he has two left hands lol
@@AbiRose539 no, look at the background. 2 laptops. he has 1 left 1 right hand
@@johnthemannn 6:30 1 left and 1 right? Seems legit
Yes trigrZolt is back!
I have a question, how do i can connect my internet? I dont know how but i have a laptop and windows server 2022 and i cant connect the internet (Lan) idk
1:15 an explanation for this is because Windows 10 Server is a stripped down version of Windows 10. Windows 10 comes packaged with bloat and built in software where server doesn't even have edge by default.
I can confirm, Windows Server is purchased due to the Windows Server software and its ability to utilize Active Directory.
what do you think of windows 11? will you install it when it gets released?
if he has a system running a new amd cpu or a intel cpu higher then 7th gen then only after that he would be able to
@@blanchardhvh i have an i5-8600 and im running windows 11 just fine
also, incase you didnt know theres a bypass for TPM 2.0 and Secure Boot.
@@nullifiedpntr yes, currently you dont need those specs to run it, those are the specs for the official launch, not the insider build.
@@nullifiedpntr i5-8600 is 8th gen
This video deserves a billion views
It's like saying that soy meat is better than beef. These are different things. But human beings like comparisons and you are to be congratulated for solving this doubt.
Servers have as CPU priority background programs second from the video it is noticable that the server os is not activated wich might slow or kill some kernel accelerators
Biggest legend is back.
Well after win7 I switched to linux and I haven't even test any other win os so I cannot tell.
However back in the day we use to install windows server 2008 instead of windows 7. The deference was stability. After a tone of tweaking the server edition was as fast or faster and more stable than win7. The downside was some freaking drivers issues..
I can only guess that if you tweak win server 2019 the same way it could perform the same or even better...
Hey TrigrZolt, please make a video about Windows 11 insider!
You forgot to disable server-related features. Also it's not fair as they aren't the same version.
And forgot to change performance to „programs“ instead of background tasks. L
We use an think station server running 8.1 it’s decent I usually only see it when I log in remotely from time to time
Video can you do about the late version of windows 11
servers main purpose is to run the services background, unless like normal windows focus on foreground application... that's why a server can be accessed from any no. of systems
you need to test Windows server 2019 vs Windows 10 2019
Do a tutorial on how to update from windows 7 service pack 1 to service pack 2 or 3
Main difference is Windows Server supports more powerful hardware. Windows 10 Pro has a max limit of 2 TB of RAM, Windows Server allows for 24 TB. A desktop user is unlikely even to consider such a large amount of RAM, but servers can make good use of their greater RAM capacity Windows 10 has a limit on processors as well. The Windows 10 Home edition only supports one physical cpu, while Windows 10 Pro supports two. Server 2016 support upto 64 sockets.Similarly, a 32-bit copy of Windows 10 only supports 32 cores, and the 64-bit version support 256 cores, but Windows Server has no limit for cores.
Because 91C is the TDP limit of the processor. That’s where it’ll throttle on any OS.
additionally, the reason for the battery life being so much better is because that's something server prioritises. But not for laptops. Server optimises for UPSs and Backup Generators to ensure as much uptime as possible, even if the power has gone out.
with the opening tests. windows server probably has more checks before it opens programs thats why it would take longer.
2:23 i can guess the fan curves are different , also you need to see if the server is on turbo or not, the Windows home does try to save power , that results in less heat. In the case of Windows server, power usage is not a problem
Windows server is designed to run Server Functions - Communications, Web Hosting, Domain Hosting Services, Production Services, Hosting CRM. There are also additonal functions that can be added such as image hosting services, domain and active directory hosting. I do know Programmers that use Server for Web Hosting and Functionality testing. Otherwise, there is not much reason to use Windows Server.
could you try windows 11 vs windows 10?(although win11 is not release, use windows insider)
Where Server crushes Windows 10 is in number of simultaneous connections.
Windows 10 is limited to, I think, 20 simultaneous connections, as Server is unlimited.
you should try these systems on one pc first win 10 home / pro and next server
Can any body explain please
Why when ou policy get conflict with the domain controller policy the dc wins
I configured the ou policy to allow user x to shutdown the server but it didnt apply
I did the same in default domain policy then it still not applicable then when i configured it on domain controller policy then it works
Why ?
Does the domain controller policy affects only remote desktop users and the ou policy affects the laptops users? If no then why the shutdown policy failed for ou gpo
How logically this issue can be illustrated
was windows server 2003 more expensive than xp? it was made more restricted so it should be cheaper, right?
xp was $100
@@johnthemannn it was more in some contries
windows server is made for servers. so the reason it boots slower is because well i'm not fully sure but I assume that it's because it has to configure things differently due to server compatability
why do you use an old version of firefox on windows 7??????
You ran speedtest on the same wifi?