MIRABEL'S VILLAIN SONG - We Don't Talk About Bruno | ANIMATIC | Encanto cover by Lydia the Bard
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2025
- Hello! Hi! Welcome! I am SO HYPED to see that you made your way to this video! I had THE BEST time turning Mirabel into a villain with some very talented friends and hope you enjoy watching her villain song and animatic as much as we loved making it!
If you would like to see more videos like this please consider joining my Patreon! All your support is MASSIVELY appreciated! I will also be uploading the instrumental track for this song to my Patreon very soon, so excited to see some of you cover this over the next few weeks! You can find my Patreon here - tinyurl.com/Pa...
For those of you that may be a little confused as to what’s going on, here is Mirabel’s Villain story for context.
STORY
Mirabel has always tried to be understanding, tried to accept that her family was meant to shine and she was meant to blend into the background. She tried to be loving and kind and helpful but her family responded to that kindness with cruelty. They refused to see Mirabel as a valued member of the family and in our story instead of forgiving and trying to connect with her family Mirabel rejects them.
Our Mirabel has allowed her disdain and hatred to grow, and now that darkness blinds her. Her pure heart tarnished by bitterness and her mind set on revenge. If they won’t see her as a valued member of the family then she’ll take away that which they treasure most. To be loved and valued less than a candle, it’s laughable really.
And so it’s about time Mirabel placed a mirror in front of her family, showing them exactly what she sees. Pepa, a frightened coward, hiding in her storms and constantly running from the truth. Dolores, like her mother, too afraid of the truth and of what it means to speak up. Isabela, putting on a performance everyday to avoid what facing herself could truly mean, what facing her thorns could mean. And Alma, the Matriarch, sitting so high above them all that she can no longer see her family, can no longer see what truly matter.
Every single member of her family saw Mirabel’s suffering, saw Bruno’s suffering and chose to ignore it. And so they are no longer worthy of her love, no longer deserving of all the sacrifices Mirabel has made to make this family work. And so, the thing they love and value most will be taken from them. Maybe then they’ll learn what truly matters, that is if they make it out alive.
I really really hope you enjoyed the song! We have put in literal months of work to get this out to you and are so hyped to see it released to the world!
Byeeeeeeee
PS: Really super duper fun links below!! The FUNNEST of links! I’m talking discord server, social media, patreon, music streaming, the list goes on… go have a gander!
──────
✨STREAM THIS SONG✨
LISTEN TO THIS SONG ON THE GO! - distrokid.com/...
My covers are all available on streaming services! Find Spotify/Apple Music link here to listen to all my other songs - linktr.ee/lydi...
You can find my music on other platforms too, just type in my name :)
──────
✨CREDITS✨
VOCAL/LYRICS - Lydia the Bard
ARRANGEMENT - Ben Tomalin - / bentomalin Make sure to check out the new musical he composed here ! / withoutthemusical
ANIMATIC - Shrubbug - / shrubbuggish_
──────
✨PATREON✨
Karaoke tracks, early access, mentions in videos, sneak peaks of work in progress and more!
Check it out here -
tinyurl.com/Pa...
Help support the channel by joining as a Patron! All funds raised will be spent on the channel so you will be directly supporting the content that comes out here!
──────
✨SOCIALS✨
INSTAGRAM - linktr.ee/lydi...
TWITTER - linktr.ee/lydi...
DISCORD - linktr.ee/lydi...
WEBSITE -linktr.ee/lydi...
I must hype up the Discord server, its the MOST wholesome place to be, follow the above link to join! Also you can ask me questions :)
──────
✨END SCREEN CREDITS✨
End screen/ Channel art - ...
If you’d like to use this song in an animatic or art project go for it please do just credit and tag me! Please do not simply repost this video on RUclips, TikTok or any other social media.
Thanks to my Patrons!
Mix&Match
Alex Hackman
Sprout
Emma Bridgeforth
Deanna
Megan Gruginski
HaseoThePKK
Taj Lee
Slayer
Geri
Chris Morse
Eleanor Abercromby
Kiera Carroll
Erenya
Raven Mcbain
Charlie N Perreault
Frederique
Kore
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Who shall I turn into a Villain next?? (Also for those that missed it make sure to check out Mirabels villain story in the description for context of the song)
STREAM THIS SONG HERE! distrokid.com/hyperfollow/lydiathebard/mirabels-villain-song
So much work goes into these videos so I thought I’d let the other wonderful people on this project introduce themselves!
BEN (arranger) - Hi I'm Ben Tomalin!
I'm a London-based composer and musician, mostly focused on musical theatre. I'm on instagram (though I don't post much) along with my new musical @withoutthemusical , which Lydia was actually in last year! I would really appreciate a follow on that account if you're interested, and we're heading up to the Edinburgh Fringe Festival this August if anyone's around!
I have also been considering starting a youtube channel of my compositions and the arrangements I've done for Lyds so let me know if any of you would be interested in that!
Thanks Lyds for inviting me!
SHRUBBUG (artist) - Hello! Im Shrubbug ^^ 🌱✨
Im a young filipino artist that aspires to be a character designer and animator one day! I like making fanart and aus of existing media and I especially love making characters to insert into existing stories! (Basically Oc insert jazz 😁)
Im mostly active on instagram!! So if you’d like to see more of my work, i go by @Shrubbuggish_, Id love to have your support!!
I’m planning on opening commissions, posting more art and hopefully more animatics soon! If you’re interested you should totally follow. (Oooo you want to follow me so bad. Im hypnotizing you to. /joke)
Thank you to Lydia for giving me such a wonderful opportunity! And Thank you for reading this! Hope you enjoyed the show :>!!
Perhaps you could do Belle, if Gaston wins and she can’t save her love in time, before he kills him and comes at her gloating and trying to force her to marry him again. She could come vengeful back to the village that always whispered behind her back, and now murdered the Beast without even knowing him. She could come alone, or with an army of equally vengeful furniture.
Lydia the bard could you make a tinkerbell villain song using the song called the frigate that fleis from the movie tinkerbell and the pirate fairy
You should do Elsa's villain song. This could be incredible! And elsa was à villain in the begining so...
@@maryfoxie Lydia did one already. She sang villain Elsa’s Into the Unknown. Though it was more sad than evil, so maybe doing something more energetic, like reimagining what villain’s Let it go would sound like, would be interesting. Or maybe Anna could be a villain instead.
While she isn’t a Disney princess I would very much love to see Anastasia villain song.
Honestly, a villain song where the villain points out all of the heroes’ flaws saying “this is why I do the things I do,” making the heroes doubt themselves, would be pretty chilling
The tangled show has a song that fits that description called "Ready as I'll ever be."
I’ve been making a playlist that are only these kinds of songs. Only has 6 so far.
@@antisocialmuffin6496and you're gonna hide it? Come on spill the tea
I actually I love this version very much. Mirabell didn't mince her word about her feelings toward her family. I enjoy watching the movie but it really tick me off on how they treat her mainly anr I have family that is like that.
I feel bad for you
I like how Mirabel said "How's it feel to stain YOUR family name", not "OUR family name". It kinda shows just how dissociated she's become with her own family and I love it
Or alternatively it could be that Mirabel feels like her lack of a gift stains her family name, or atleast thinks that Abuela thinks so.
alternatively, she thinks she's doing nothing wrong, so she doesn't think her name is being stained?
@@alakazamlover4908 that's actually a really great alternative wow lmao
@@emsiyes I am a very out of the box thinker when I put my mind to it
@@alakazamlover4908what if it's both?
I love how, despite this technically being a "villain" song, Mirabelle is mostly just defending herself and Bruno. Like, she's calling out everyone here and it's beautiful.
She killed them in the end
@@gabrieladapazlima7947 they could ve all just walked out yknow... it s not like she trapped them there
@@dreamergamer9291 i think that she closet the door in the end?
@@gabrieladapazlima7947 "oh no she closed the door!!!!! how are we gonna escape now!!!!!"
@@dreamergamer9291maybe we do what Bruno did when the hose was falling OR we can just slither through things
I love how the song is her villain story but still shows how kind natured she is by simply having her call everyone out for their horrible behavior and neglect
🤙 Determinism is Freedom 🤙
True
I like to imagine that the house supported Mirabel which is why it made no attempt to stop her from taking the candle. Casita and Mirabel clearly have the closest bond throughout the movie.
Maybe villain mirabel has casita transform into her own personal villain castle after its destruction. Capable of defending her from outside threats. Creating traps. And with mirabels revenge and casita keeping her safe she may not know what to do with her life. She just sits there waiting for something. Anything.
Casita is most definitely Pedro, and he already sacrificed himself for his loved ones, so why not twice?
In concept art released it was reviled that Mirabel and Casita were connected, as in that sequence every time she screamed her mothers flaws a part of the house would crumble.@@kingdoppelganger8951
Nope, if you know anything about European languages, specifically Italian, French and Spanish (Spanish being the language most South American societies take) if something ends in A, its most likely female, Casita is female, eg: Abuela = Grandmother, Abuelo = Grandfather, same goes for most other pronouns, there is no in-between, only she and he in those languages.@@EimiSeilin8262
Someone said that maybe Mirabel had an empathic link to the Casita. Afterall it responds far more to her throughout the movie than it does to anyone else.
“Finally free from chasing your love” NOW THIS IS HOW YOU DO A MODERN VILLAN SONG. Like it’s dramatic but just the right amount and there isn’t any break for humor. Just pure intimidating energy from someone in pain and done with it all. The people who made this have serious talent
this is amazing!!!
I also love the fact that the artist drew Camilo reaching out for her like he does in the movie 😭
Omg now I’m tewatching AGAIN just do I can see that part 😭🥺
AND THE BUTTERFLIES TAKING A NEW MEANING ITS SO GOOOOD
1:35 - 2:01
Poison rose, you might think no one knows
But I see right through your disguise
I suffered all this heartache, I sacrificed for your sake
As you ruled and you reigned from above
Well now my pain is ending, I'm DONE with this PRETENDING
Finally free from chasing your love
Free from your love!
-
It's worth listening to the whole song just to hear or watch that climax again
I like how the original version was about how Bruno's visions impacted the family, but this version is about how the whole family impacted Mirabel! You did such a good job at flipping the script!
ikr
Frrr
It's amazing! 🤩
and Bruno to an extent
The original version I think also has a subtext of by not talking about Bruno, we also don’t talk about the problems the family has. The grandmother wants to keep up this image of perfection for the family, so by not talking about the family’s black sheep (Bruno) we are pretending like everything is okay even when it isn’t. Unfortunately, by talking about it the family’s image is perfected, which is what gets the grandmother to lash out at Mirabel and causes the big blowup at the films climax. This could be an alternate way that blowup happens, with Mirabel blaming everyone else for how she feels, rather than calling out the grandmother for how she’s been acting. Still could be a great scene if it ever happened.
I love this. It’s the epitome, of the saying, “A child who is not embraced by the village will burn it down to feel its warmth.”
🤙 🤙 Determinism is Freedom 🤙
In the movie, Bruno did say he didn't know whether Mirabel would save or destroy the miracle, so this is entirely possible! I love how it fits into the story so smoothly!
Yes, that's exactly what I thought!! There were two possibilities and this was the one they didn't go with!!
In my opinion Encanto would have been a more compelling movie if Mirabel had turned into a villain, makes me wish this song was in it
@@hearmeout1767 sadly its a disney kid movie they wouldnt allow the mc to be a villain but honestly yea this is much more intresting
an alternate timeline since future is not fixed in Bruno's prediction. Love this song!!!
@@hearmeout1767yea but it’s a kids movie I think they wouldn’t do that
I feel the phrase "The child who is not embraced by the village will burn it down to feel its warmth." fits this song well.
Same😅😅
While this can be true for many things, growing up as a child I wasn’t embraced by my family. However I never stooped down to their level.
Sometimes you can treat a kid with love and good parenting, and they’ll still turn bad.
And like me, you can neglect and abuse your child, but they still remain a good person.
What's this quote from?
@@cecil_thestar3752 It's a proverb.
@@lunatpr5594 Thanks!
gosh, the whole “Should’ve talked about Bruno” reminds me of old kings refusing to listen to their oracles’ warnings and self-fulfilling prophecies. the writing and animatic are both incredibly well done imo
You lost me at old kings lol
Macbeth be like
**flashback to tarquin and the sibyl**
Well they thought Bruno would lead to their downfall and as it appears that they should have kept him as they pushing him away led to their downfall
literally the plot of tangled the series season one lol
I think the most haunting thing about this is Antonio crying right at the end. Without an innocent child for her to focus her kindness on, this villain story is very possible. the entire song is a string of reprises & i love it.
As someone who loved the closeness Antonio and Mirabel shared, I personally wished she saved him from the wreckage. Not to be a hero, but like, what if he saw her side and wanted to be with her? That kinda thing.
I like now straightforward Mirabel is.
Isabella attacks her, boom, her gift is gone. No flickering. Just… instant.
Oh SHIT!!😱😱😱
@@davidvaldezjr5546?
@@bewtnewt I just realized that.
Her aunt and cousin would also like their curses - I mean gifts - removed plz.
@@LilianaKali Most gifts are curses with the exception of Antonio's.
I really love the line "How's it feel to stain your family name?" because it's totally mocking the fact that the family and Abuela especially are so focused on having this "perfect" image/reputation and Mirabel is taking that all away in a matter of seconds.
AGREE
Is more that anything to the abuela, since she is really the only one who really cares about the family name
I FEEL the perfect family image because everyone in my family is like “you have to perfect” “put your hair up” ITS ALWAYS THE HAIR😭
depressing, personally I prefer to glare at people if they tell me to do something I well don't need to do, I'm not a rebel, I'm a human being with a self-conscious, like everyone else should, we aren't a hive-mind, we are individuals.@@CatalinaYa
@@Benji-m2s ok🧍♀️
This one green eye that is seen through Mirabel’s glasses is so creepy, and so is her smile… It’s like straight out of a horror story. I would love to see casita under her rule, that would be one hell of a haunted mansion.
This version of Mirabel CRUMBLED casita
@@davidvaldezjr5546yeah, i saw that. But it would be cool if it got rebuilt into a dark thing under Mirabel’s influence. She technically crumbled it in the original, too (though it wasn’t exactly her fault), and it got rebuilt and had her on the front door, like a potential family leader to replace Abuela when the time comes. So I wondered what could happen to casita if it got rebuilt to serve this Mirabel’s wishes, if the protective magic of love got twisted into something much darker (while technically still being protective, of her and Bruno).
@@АнастасияАгаркина-й3э now that would be very interesting to see. I can see her as a protective dark queen. with a happy Bruno behind her throne, I could see him getting a little twisted and corrupted like her. lots of potential quick to the fanfiction!!
it would be interesting to see if casita would want to comply or would reluctantly and unwillingly obey her
@@lynxii3234from the theories going on a while back, mirabel's true gift is presumably the casita itself. How it is capable of moving on it's own and its connection to Mirabel's mental and emotional state throughout the movie. Like when it crumbled down when she had a fight with Abuela.
I feel that I need to remind everyone - Mirabel is 15. _Fifteen years old._ Still in her early teens, which to a lot of people are some of the most intense years of their lives, me being one of them. If I was in her seat at that age, the relationship with my family would be forever ruined at best or I would've burned everything down to the ground at worst.
Yet Mirabel shows unending compassion and love to everyone in her family throughout the entire movie. She gave everyone the benefit of the doubt and she never did or said anything to hurt anyone.
At no point did the family, _especially_ the grandmother, seem to fully realize what they had done to both Mirabel and Bruno. There was never a moment where they seemed to receive the guilt they should be feeling, and they never apologized for how badly they had treated them.
There was no doubt that they cared for them, but the way they acted is absolutely unforgivable in my opinion.
Mirabel and Bruno deserved so much better and got _so much less_ than that.
THANK YOU! That's easily my biggest problem with the movie! They both went through all that undeserved crap but the movie ends with THE ABUSERS getting REWARDED despite their horrible treatment!
The "abusers" were not doing it out of sadistic desire, they lost sight of why they were given gifts, and started to be treated more as tools. Everyone was suffering, and the ending brought everyone together
@@hajimehinata5854doesnt mean that they had to treat mirabel and bruno like that.
@@IIove0 I am not justifying the actions, it's just that everyone was being hurt, not just Mirabel and Bruno, but those 2 had it the worst because of the corrupted family ideals
the family, besides alma, never really apologized because what happened wasn't really their fault. i see alot of people commenting on how badly they treated them, but there's never really any on-screen evidence of them being harsh to them in specific. the most i can see is pepa coming off as rude to her, which is just a result from her always anxious and overly emotional personality. and then there's isabela, which if u have siblings, we all know that's just how sibling rivalries are. the "hatred" isn't one sided, and if u read the encanto books, it reveals isa's pov and her thoughts are not at all malicious nor were her intentions behind her actions. it was definitely NOT abuse considering they were all victims of generational trauma, and their was absolutely no cruel intent. as far as we know, the village is mostly what ostracized bruno, and alma clearly had no clear understanding of his gift. bruno left on his own accord, he simply wanted to protect mirabel from being ostracized. alma hated his name, i think, because of him leaving without a word. of course, they'll think of that bitterly. none of the family, nor townspeople actually, showed any cruelty toward mirabel, maybe other than the unintentional osvaldo. everyone was happy to see bruno, and clearly he didn't see a need for them to apologize.
I love how this is not even far off from the movie. Bruno explicitly says that her fate is uncertain. In the movie, we see her taking the "good path", but this was like, the other option.
FR tho, she could EASILY have take this path and still have been 100% justified- I still feel like she forgave everyone WAY to easily tho
That's what makes it so chilling. This just as much could have been the plot of the movie as the actual plot that we got.
The only change that needs to happen is that Mirabel and Bruno aren't as forgiving as they were in the movie.
I wish they could release a second version of encanto that's just her singing this song and crushing the family home and only after that does the family try to make it up to her or something
Undertale...
@@rykerscott127it’s a Disney movie so she was bound to forgive em
Honestly I love how this version doesn't just dance circles round the issue but rather just goes straight to the throat, especially that all of it is being directly shot at Abuela like bullets. However, she won't let everyone's shortcomings just be pushed over as they hold just as much blame as Abuela. If Disney had did this version, it totally would've sent a much bigger message.
I mean the message of the original was pretty powerful on its own. Alma isn’t a villain in the movie but this is an alternate story
I mean, it would send a bigger message yes... but Disney would never let the villan win
@@IrisWhiskeywould she really be the villain though? She didn't hurt anyone and was removing a toxic aspect of her family. I imagine this story would initiate after her song when her cousin got his gift and they started to treat him like a person, holding him higher than her and never giving her a chance. And then when she'd realize what actually happened with Bruno she would finally decide to destroy the candle instead of saving it.
@@shadesteel9247’d watch that so hard!!! I think it’d fit after the engagement party!
SAME
I love how at some point, in the end, the whole family is just crying and scared, meanwhile Camilo is just running towards Mirabel, this shows how much even when you think no one loves you, there‘s just that one person that‘ll always be with you
probably has something to do with the fact that she skipped his part when she was reading her family lol
@@no-yn6uy she also said nothing of Julieta, Luisa, or Antonio! She only targets the ones who she feel have done wrong (and, to be fair, she's right)
I was really hoping that more people noticed that too
Yeeeessss!!!!! I thought this was soooo cute!!!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I was your 1k like 😊
I just love the detail of Camilo reaching out to her as the house was crumbling down, it warms my heart so much, and through out the video he doesn't like say or do anything bad to her, it also represents in the movie when hes chasing her while shes going to the candle. He still loved her during all of it, and that shows that he wanted to help, and that it helps the idea that their like best friends.
1:09 you can tell that he's worried about her. While making sure Antonio is being comforted.
2:23 is the scene I was talking about .
And at 2:22 you can see him looking at her which leads to him reaching out to her
@@Clover.404_akyeah that's what I was about to comment about. He was like "oh boy." Or oh this will not end well.
I love the message about apathy - it’s not just that they caused her and Bruno’s suffering, but that they ignored it. I especially loved the lyrics about Dolores’s silence.
Once again dolores's scene is the best
me too! i was so pissed at dolores when she said “i knew he didnt leave, i heard him everyday” in the movie. like, why was that was the only thing she could stay quiet about? she immediately started blabbering when mirabel had an issue 🤨
@@madsd5822RIGHT?? she was so quick to call out mirabel when she heard him everyday??
Probably because she did think Bruno was in trouble. She thought she was protecting him the same way she she blabbed about Mirabel because she thought she was in trouble
@@akmi1931 but neither of those things actually ended up helping. bruno wouldn’t have been stuck in the walls for like 10 years if she would’ve spoken up (which wouldnt have made for a very good movie to be fair, but it just annoys me that she doesn’t speak up unless its to tattle on mirabel, even though she knew mirabel did NOT wanna tell anyone).
Mirabel grabbing Isabela's vine and turning it to dust gave me chills. The artist did a fantastic job, and your vocals were beautiful as always!
Also the light on Isabela's door going out as well. Nice touches all the way around.
It's poetic on so many levels. The fact she had to grab the vine at all implies she had to act in her own defense: against her family. The candle was all about their bond as a family. The magic dying in that moment was a poetic nail in the coffin. You can't take back attacking someone. Not even your own blood. In an alternate storyline, that alone could have been Mirabelle's plan all along to kill the magic. She just needs someone to wield it directly on her.
I also noticed that after Izabella’s vine turned into dust, her door glow disapeared :)
Seriously I don't like the ending, they let the family off the hook easily
@@ericelestineyorfrylle1525Yeah, the family didn't deserve their powers at all. Not after how they all treated each other, especially Mirabel.
Its kinda crazy that the reason Mirabel didn't get a gift was because Alma lost sight of why she was given a miracle. The only reason Antonio got a gift was because Mirabel didnt want him to have a gift to be useful, she wanted him to have a gift because she wanted him to be happy.
Oh damn I finally get it
That is so smart. It explains also why his gift is more "nice to have" than useful.
My theory is that that happened afterward, that when Mirabel wiped her dress, she had waved off the magic, notice how no one else did that. (either that or Mirabel was Casita's choice to take over for Alma once Alma passed away, she was pretty old)
@@Benji-m2s The producers of the movie disproved that theory. It's not true.
@@madnelliotss D**N IT.......... :(
The line " Time to bring this family down, yeah I'm the villain in your fairytale now" hits so hard
2:02
that is genuinely my favourite part.
"Every sound you heard but your silence was deafening" THAT LINE GAVE ME CHILLS
Me tooo
SAMEEE
Mirabel literally has a backstory that would inspire any villain. The fact she wasn't evil shows that she's stronger than the rest of her family.
Edit: rip my notifications haha. thank you for the comments. I enjoy seeing other peoples points of views. Try not to fight though please.
exactly being evil would have been the easy way for her but I think her pure maturity and kindness shows how strong she actually is despite being only 15
Her family is pretty strong too, even without gifts. The gifts mean that they’d have to take upon more responsibility at a super young age. The nature of some peoples gifts too, Luisa literally sings about taking on every family burden, for example
She really did have a good set up to possibly be a villain backstory and so did Bruno especially Bruno. After everything that happened I wouldn’t blame either of them for being villains if that’s where the story went
Honestly I thought the same about both her and Bruno, but I get what they did. Still would make an interesting Twisted Tales story.
the whole family its strong tho- they were kinda of village bordline slaves
The fact that she left most of her family out of it is astounding. She only truly attacked four people, her aunt that would literally blow up on people, her cousin who would never speak up about the things she heard, abuala who started the hate against anyone "not perfect," and her golden sister who seems to have always hated her.
And then during the song her sis pretty much conferms what she was saying when she goes for the vine killshot.
I should also mention that even though Casita is crumbling around her due to her snapping I think Casita is still on her side as evidence by her being able to waltz right out of the house and the fact that her sister's power turned off at the perfect moment even though the candle was still lite
I imagine the song in the link happening right before this one, mostly because of the "but I heard a different take" line
ruclips.net/video/p7h5uM_9nXs/видео.html
@@connormcconnell7805 Imagine these words being the last words that Bruno spoke. Those words were not trying to stop Bruno from doing something, but it was as he was reaching out to the light. Turning this song into Bruno's Requiem.
His voice shuddering, calling out to not be forgotten as it 'all fades to black.'
Mirabel's lines feel so much more impactful hearing them come from a girl who's trying to hold onto her last string of love as the person who was treated just as bad-if not worse-than she.
As this song goes quiet, the light from his eyes fade... and Mirabel's kindness fades with it.
i feel like abuela should be the only one she's mad at all together cause abuela is the reason the others are acting like that it's all abuelas fault
@@ChrissaTodd while true those were the worst actors aside from abuela
pepa is just rlly emotional, dolores literally said she heard him everyday, and while i dont have much of an excuse for isa and abuela, abuela was a victim of alotta trauma, so was isa. doesn't excuse their actions but doesn't make them the bad guys jsjsjs. some of the ppl in these comments r forgetting this is just an au and everyone in the family is a victim of trauma
I think what makes this so amazing is that she isn’t even particularly “ evil “
She genuinely had a reason to be this way. She was treated awfully.
She’s not even like killing anyone or anything, she’s taking away the one thing they all care about and the same thing that caused her grief in the first place.
In a way, her destroying the miracle is her way of getting everyone to her “ level “
For them to no longer have a reason to see her as lesser as none of them have gifts anymore.
I would honestly root for her tbh
Even as a villain.
The house fell on them they died.
@Kizaco They were standing in an open courtyard, and it's not like the door Mirabel left out of is the only potential exit or that she locked it behind her. It's entirely likely that they're just trapped in the courtyard with Casita collapsed around them. Given the tone of the other Encanto villain songs, and that they need to be alive to suffer the consequences, I'd even wager that Mirabel used her control of the candle to insure the house didn't collapse directly on top of them.
You can definitely interpret it as Casita falls everyone dies, but that's not the only vaid interpretation or even necesarily the most likely outcome given the other factors involved.
@@The_Lord_of_Cryptidsnah
“It’s your end of days” is pretty much them saying that they died
Villain arnt born they are created so this being the start of her villain arch would fit they finally make her snap
@@Castformsupremacy Not really, it can and has been used to describe a fall from grace or pulled down in the public eye, it's the end of their days flaunting their gifts.
I know everyone talking about how much the Madrigals deserve it but that shot of Antonio clutching his parents and weeping punched me in the stomach. Poor kid had his gift for like two days and lost it, his home, and his cousin. He looks terrified
I wondering who was in the last scene. Thank you
While for the younger ones it would be unfair for the adults its pretty understandable. The entire family except Her mom, the husbands and the strong sister(i cant remember any of their names) are painted as massive assholes and the ones who arent are complicit by apathy. The entire movie is just of a family being dicks to each other.
I noticed it from the very beginning
@@BOYVIRGO666Their not painted as massive assholes. Their painted as deeply flawed due to generational trauma and the expectations placed on them.
@@astralaurora4165 Iv had this conversation with numerous people and the generational trauma thing doesnt work since most of the problems they have are not generationally based. They are entirely around their distrust and mistreatment of one person. Bruno. This is covered specifically in 'We don talk about bruno' and his later description of his perspective of those events. Anything he said regardless of context was taken as him reading the future so everyone started acting like he was fucking with them on purpose. This is not generational trauma. This is interpersonal relationships failing because everyone else treated 1 person like shit despite knowing how his powers worked.
The generational trauma bit falls apart more when you look at the family members who are notably not assholes. The muscle sister(again cant remember her name but she was pretty good) is treated objectively like a pack mule, in fact its alluded to in her song. Her treatment is not generational trauma, her treatement is a very common latin family trope of one member of the family taking on the brunt of work and burden. My grandmother in my family would be this person and yeah its super common. Mirabels mother just seems detached from the entire thing and clearly has no intention of telling her family to chill the fuck out and how the hell is that generational trauma? That is her allowing bad behavior in ways that are very common to alot of families, avoiding conflict in favor of general comfort.
The Grandmother treats mirabel like crap out of long term fear of a vision of the future that she does nothing to do anything about and a very obvious disdain for her not being 'part of the family' when it comes to said powers. I mean the childrens room thing alone would be considered deeply disrespectful to basically anyone. This completely ignores her complete lack of defense of her Son Bruno who she apparently loves very much but not enough to do anything about it when everyone treats him like shit.
When this movie came out everyone called it an example of generational trauma being the villain but thats not how the actual story plays out. No one seems to have any functional fear or damage done by the revolution before them other than a fear of the outside world which is only lightly touched on, instead the entire central premise of the movie is around how much they distrust each other and treat each other like dicks. Again Turning Red(a much better movie) has actual generational trauma in it, expressing how the central problem of the movie functions in the characters lives and how it shaped their family.
Now as a breakdown of how the more unpleasant ways that mexican/latin in general families can treat each other its pretty on point. I have family members who act like these people.
at 2:23 i noticed how camilo reached out to mirabel. they're the same age and were raised together, seeing him look so upset and concerned for her made me choke back a tear. imagine seeing the person you've been with since literal birth go from sweet to a villain and there's nothing you can do to stop it anymore
I was hoping someone would notice that!
I also noticed that and it physically hurt me. I love Camillo so much so to see him like that not only adds to the beauty of this but also adds despair.
@@ezravon3799same 😭 what an underrated character though fr
i experienced this
I want to also point out the fact that she neither digs into him or Felix, the only one who did, in fact, talk about Bruno, despite completely roasting the three other leads of the song (Pepa, Dolores and Isabela) and Abuela
I love the symbolism surrounding Mirabel crushing the yellow butterfly, Since yellow butterflies are used to represent hope in a way it represents her either giving up on being accepted as she is or her hope dying due to the constant rejection.
There's the fact that Mirabel had saw a yellow butterfly back and the river, the one that she and Bruno followed in the vision and what helped Alma to see that Mirabel was "what Pedro sent her to save the miracle" - being the one that taints the miracle instead! The symbolisms on this video are top-notch haha
@@icxflames Sadly Alma failed to see the help until it's too late. The help apparently decided to destroy the Miracle instead. Pedro must be facepalming in heaven. At this point, even this good man would agree with his nieta. And given this song's title, one might wonder if Pedro agreeing to Mirabel's actions and justifications have something to do with the alienation of his only son and decides to put his foot down against his wife.
Or its like shes crushing all the hope for the family,like its to late
@@gzapray7203 obviously he agreed with mirabel, if casita and the candle are manfestations of his love and become the power of the family, mirabel being able to do all this musical and caos needed to need the original power aprovance at least.
mirabel at least it's the favorite of someone, even if it's her dead grampa....
@@Shaii-f2x Pedro would be like, "Go get them girl. You have my blessing. Just save yourself and remind them of your worth and who you are."
I really love the line "yeah, I'm the villain in your fairytale now!" near the end, since it calls to the perfection and expectation of it within the family. It's a way for Mirabel to say she's embracing the role her family has pushed upon her, and the following verse really hammers in the reason she's done that!
🤙 🤙 Determinism is Freedom 🤙 🤙
The way she steal the other’s music and twists it to mock them and blames them like they blamed her…
I’m obsessed.
Yeah
Like we don't talk about Bruno and other song if she sings them
Fr.
Me to I'm obsessed fr I replayed it so may times ⏲️🤣😂
YEAH I'M THE VILLAIN IN YOUR FAIRYTALE NOW LOVE IT 2:05 so scary but really BEAUTIFUL
The fact that this entire song is about the pain she suffered from her family, and her anger towards her family for treating Bruno the way they did, just shows how much she cares about her Uncle. She was mad at them FOR Bruno.
I love how much Mirabel worries and cares for her Uncle, cause we all know someone had to care about Bruno when no one else would.
And Antonio as well. I didn't see him anywhere, maybe she kept him safe to not suffer along with the rest of family.
@@ApenasUmaEstoriaum he is there… you just need to look a bit more closely (sorry for my bad English)
@@AixaSanchezVelazquez what minute? I don't see. Don't worry, I'm not English speaker as well.
1:09
@@Dwalb and in 2:10 in he’s mother’s arms and in 2:23 in he’s mother’s arms again and finally in the end 2:32 (i hope i’m right)
The idea of Mirabel growing tired of being neglected made the perfect villain ark and the fact that Bruno’s vision actually came true and Mirabel was the cause for Casita falling was perfect
His prophecy was still true in the original version, the Casita (and therefore the family as they knew it) was destroyed by Mirabel and her rift with the family, the difference being that in the movie they rebuilt the Casita and the family to be something better than it was.
@@garbagemancer8592 I think the prophecy in the original was not that she would destroy the family, but rather that the fate of the family depends on her, whether it would be good or bad, since the prophecy in the original has two sides depending on how you look at it
@@mort5566literally…
This is the side where she destroyed casita
yeah this song makes the most sense as she clearly is angry from the neglect she got
The line “free from your love” just hits me so hard, it explains the fat that mirabelle feels trapped within her family, and pressured by the love to do anything to earn it. It shows that all through her life she was trapped in their love because she was afraid, she finally breaks from the love when she pays them back for everything they deserved (well abuela atleast)
🤙 Determinism is Freedom 🤙 🤙
“A child, who is not embraced by the village will burn it down to feel its warmth.”
I quite love the idea of the dark Encanto takes. Because of how any of the central children (not Antonio or Camilo) has good motivation to become villains after Bruno is proven innocent. But Mirabel has different motivation to hate her family, but she still loves them.
You could even argue for Camilo if you fall into the idea that his shapeshifting gives him serious identity issues and that he's only wanted for who he can turn into, never himself (that would be more the towns fault than the family, but still)
Imo Dolores and Isabella have some pretty solid reasons to become villains.
Dolores probably knows horrible secrets about everyone she loves, and she's expected to just keep quiet about it for the family's sake even though nobody is considerate about how awful her power is (or the fact she's about to lose the guy she loves.)
Isabella isn't even allowed to be herself and could easily snap from the pressure of being forced into a loveless marriage. She could be an even more powerful version of Poison Ivy.
@@mistydemorrow4955 the original idea was for Camilo to appear at the end of the movie looking like somebody else/what he really looks like.
They thought this would make the ending of the movie to messy so it got scrapped.
@@BritishBoysWeO7 Wasted potential I say. They could have even added more in like what mistydemorrow said, Camilo having identify issues, whats her face hearing everything but keeping silent in fear of what would happen if she spoke up about what she heard, little miss weather lady who just blows up all the time to avoid the issues at hand. The only ones who seemed well adjusted was mirabels mother and the youngest child since he was too young to be directly involved
Yup
2:17 “I’ll reclaim all that I’ve lost, see you understand what your apathy cost.” goes so unbelievably hard. It’s my favorite line & I’m absolutely obsessed with it
Omg same!!
@@Catathyst besties 😼
@@mariiexpalso just wanna say, I love ur Noah PFP 😻
@@Catathyst TYYY I love him so much 😭
Noah
YES THIS IS IT!!!!! This is literally what A LOT of people imagined happening with Mirabel watching Encanto for the very first time. Her backstory, her initial family treatment and repressed feelings and emotions were ALL the perfect recipe for a villain, however since she is a Disney Main character they couldn't let her be one even though she had every reason to be one, THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS VISION TO LIFE!!!!
I truly do think Disney should let the sweet main character be the villain we root for.
My fiance and I were so hoping Mirabel would lash out like this. None of them except her parents, Felix Antonio and Luisa deserved kindness
@@Rainbow_Butterfly I'd have to disagree with Julieta, Augustine, Felix, and Luisa.
Julieta and Augustine are Mirabel's parents, if anyone should be supporting her, it should be them, but what do they actually do in the movie, they sit there and worry. They don't really do much else, even during the family photo in Antonio's room, they don't say "Mirabel, come join us" or anything. They take the picture without her, and don't even mention her name, just letting her sulk off away from everyone else. It isn't until it's too late that they both try and defend Mirabel from Abuella.
Felix is just as guilty as Pepa, due to encouraging her to just calm herself down instead of actually dealing with the problem. He's no less guilty than she is with her ignorance, and in fact, encourages it. When the original "We Don't Talk About Bruno", Felix stands by as she talks poorly about her own brother. He does nothing to try and give an actual reason, but instead lets her out of control emotions take of her.
Luisa is just as guilty as Isabella is, for the same reason. Luisa is putting herself in so much pressure to help maintain the family name, just as Isabella does. So, for the same reasons, Luisa neglects Mirabel. That doesn't mean she's rude to Mirabel, like Isabella, but the point remains, think of it from Mirabel's perspective, Isabella treats her horridly and ignores her needs. Luisa ignores her need for compassion entirely, so why shouldn't Luisa be the same?
However, Antonio could also be placed into Mirabel's circle of hate. When he got his gift, it could have felt like a betrayal, or being cut off from a good friend. It could also be a hint of jealousy, but otherwise, Antonio is on her good side, even going to help her when the rest of the family is convinced she needs to be stopped.
They should make a what if movie with this alternatived and this song and back story I would pay to watch it
I could see a movie where this is the climax and the rest of the movie is her redemption arc. Possibly by Bruno's hands.
@@shadowscribe That would be amazing honestly
The lyrics in this are absolutely phenomenal, especially at 0:48. Every syllable hits exactly like the original song but with a completely different meaning. The fact that it's so perfect means that this channel is on par with a Grammy and Tony award winning lyricist. That's incredible
I love how Villain Mirabel makes SO much sense. The gifts returning was all dependant on Mirabel. If not for Mirabel, the magic, everyone's gifts, wouldn't have returned. Therefore, if she decided her family didn't deserve to have such gifts, then the magic wouldn't have returned, cause without her passion, her determination, her natural creative personality, there is no magic of any kind.
she s quite litterally the glue that held the family together
@@dreamergamer9291 Exactly!
@@lunar_nocturne1868 also what i just realised is that her view and abuela are polar opposites
what abuela sees in a family memeber is only their strenghts and dismisses their flaws becasue she wants "perfection"
what mirabel sees is the real person she looks past their facade and into who they really are and how they feel like how luisa opened up to her about the pressure she feels
@@dreamergamer9291 Right! Mirabel saw her family as who they are, not their gifts. All she ever wanted for them was to be themselves. Not their gift. And Abuela held on to the gifts too much, that she stopped seeing the person, and could only see the gift.
You know what I noticed. She never calls out Camilo, Luisa or Antonio. I think honestly she knows they are the only three who cared about her besides her parents who tries stand up for her in the movie. Imagine if she took Antonio with her as the house was falling apart.
One thing that makes me love this is that you can see that out of everyone, it's **Camilo** that tries to reach out for Mirabel.
Everyone else is either staring in shock/fear (Everyone) or are trying to get her to stop (Abuela, Isabel)
Then there's Camilo, who even though is scared, tries to *reach out for his cousin* and *is the only one to try*.
@@jmie7686 oh my gosh I didn’t notice that.
Reading these comments makes me want to see a sequel or, what I would want more, a show like tangled the series (best Disney show)
The main reason I want a series more is so it could showcase more relationships
The parents seemed to be fine with leaving Mirabel out of Antonio's picture though...
A small thing that I love is at 2:01.
Mirabel's butterfly imagery has been the symbol of her love for her family, but also her feelings of uselessness and feebleness compared to them.
At this moment, she's finally said 'screw it' and spring-boarded into her revenge plan. And those wings, for a brief second, turn from a symbol of weakness into something else.
The wings behind her aren't butterfly wings.
They're bird wings.
The wings of a predator.
The wings of a harbinger.
See I thought of the butterflies for her being the butterfly effect
OHH YEAHHH
@@themaddoctor1741 Butterflies are also a symbol of transformation and rebirth, - in this case she is spreading her wings for the first time, in the most devastating possible way, and becoming a villain.
But are they wings of a vulture? Or the wings of a Buzzard?
you my friend are a writer
"FREE FROM YOUR LOVE!"
damn on my opinion thats the best part😭
_”You whisper as if I don’t see…”_
_”Every sound you heard but your silence was deafening, each decibel dismissible to save yourself from meddling, or maybe you’re too scared to make a sound at all?”_
_”I’ll reclaim all that I’ve lost, see you understand what your apathy cost”_
This entire song is SO GOOD. These lines go HARD.
The imagery at 2:01 is honestly heartbreaking. The little Mirabel sobbing and the grown woman who has finally had enough of trying to do absolutely anything to win approval from her family. Simply heart wrenching and beautiful. Well done.
well technically, she's not a GROWN woman. she's still a child because she's only 15 years old. She's an older child, but a child nontheless
@@skyfnf8000a young you want say.
@@skyfnf8000I thought she was 20
@@JohnDoe-df7bl where did u get 20 from she doesnt even look 20
She is treated like an adult by the narrative.
THANK U FOR LETTING ME WORK ON THIS LYDIA AHHH WHAT AN AMAZING SONG
Edit: btw theres a lot of lore in the tiny details of this animatic, for example, mirabel standing confidently while casita breaks down. Theres a reason behind it 😁 I HOPE U ALL HAVE FUN TRYING TO FIGURE IT OUT IF U WANT TO!
❤ GreatJob!! Amazing song and animation! Love it!
SHURB SHURB HI TEEHEE GOOD JOB BUDDY
Wait, at 2:23, is Camilo reaching out to Mirabel? If so, I'm going to start sobbing
YOU DID AMAZING AAAAAAAA!!!!
Because Casita is the friend of Mirabel. It wouldn’t hurt the only person, who realised the family problems
“Well now my pain is ending, I’m done with this pretending, finally free from chasing your love” HITS HARD AND HITS HOME
Honestly the entire isabella part from 1:25 - 2:02 just resonates with me in ways it shouldn’t,,,,
That last shot where Mirabel exits the Casita through the doors feels incredibly symbolic.
Mirabel always wanted a room with her own personal doors when she was expecting the gift when she was young only to be denied and had no where to stay but in the nursery.
I suppose you can say she found the "gift" she wanted at this point of her life of being neglected and underestimated by the Madrigals.
Tbh i blame the house more than everything- they were waiting her to get a room but the magic system sucks
I like the concept of villains pointing out the flaws of heroes. It makes them sound more noble plus it proves the hero and villain are not entirely different
I like that concept too
I love the detail at 1:16 where Dolores still has her hands covering her ears, as if she remains terrified of the truth even after her verse was turned against her
1:43
"i suffered all this heartache i sacrificed for your sake"
"well now my pain is ending im done with this pretending"
"FINALLY FREED FROM YOUR LOVE"
hits so hard
I love the line “but I see all the thorns you hide” meaning Mirabel gained some sort of an understanding of Isabela somehow in this au, yet she doesn’t show much sympathy.
It parallels the canon ending where Isabela admits to not wanting to marry Mariano but Mirabel only cares about hugging her to fix the candle.
Obviously, in canon Mirabel and Isabela find a mutual understanding of each other, especially with the timeskip at the end, but in the au Mirabel and Isabela remain at odds with each other, even after understanding each others perspectives.
i also interpreted this as a deeper look at canon isabela, specifically in the moments where she scolds mirabel. in chasing her own perfection, isabela also pushes others to uphold her standard. so unlike luisa, who protects her sisters by shouldering all the weight, isabela reinforces the pressure that mirabel already feels to "be better", without actually helping her improve.
I read this cover as "if Mirabel had more self-esteem"
maybe to the point of being a bit self centered, but even that's arguable. just not pushing aside the harm her family has done to her. even with Isa, this is just her saying "you don't even want him, but still, you would prefer to trap yourself into a loveless marriage to preserve the family name. the family name that's done so much harm to my own. how dare you? how DARE you??"
I never liked Isabella, I mean sure she struggled as the eldest and pretend to be perfect but why does she need to humiliate Mirabel always? She always talked in her face like she's useless and pretend that she's nothing.
@@ericelestineyorfrylle1525 I think it's because she had developed unhealthy perfectionism for herself (under pressure from Abuela and the community), and now projected the same perfectionism on others, and yet Mirabel (from her point of view) kept acting clumsy and causing trouble when she tried too hard to be useful and noticed. Which, in a high stress situation, leads her to lose patience at her little sister.
Of course, we know that what happened with Mirabel was more complex than that, but from Isabela's POV (who only sees a small part of Mirabel's actions) it looked that way.
@@shiningdalek7185 But until the end she didn't apologized to her like she didn't do what their grandma did
Honestly, Mirabel deserved to have a villain song. Like it really took losing their gifts to realize she was just a special and so was Bruno. Like I love this
“I’m the villain in your fairytale now” really shows how aware she is of the harm she’s causing everyone and how it looks to them, and it seems she’s feeling absolutely no remorse. She also really sees how much everyone lives like they’re in some sort of fairytale (which they are but they don’t know this) because of their gifts, and Mirabel had to see the world from a different perspective because of her neglect and the fact that she didn’t really have a gift. This whole song gave me chills and it’s just amazing. I can even imagine this animated by Disney if this were to be what happened. Would be like a cool short for them to do if they ever saw this.
The irony of the situation they have walls to protect them from outside threats they don't know there are threat inside the wall and no gates to go out
This...kind of describes me
@@SarahMx260 I'm here for your villian arc my dude
I wish Mirabel had gotten a antihero arc. She should have been able to take the miracle away and shown them what it means to be "Average". I think encanto is a great movie but all of the things that got forgave and forgotten are crazy to me. Her uncle literally lived in the walls for a decade because he felt rejected and heart broken. Like I know Alma's got trauma, but damn girl your own kid feels like a burden to you
Did the rest of the family die?
@@jessicaribeirodesousa7878 Eventually, everyone does
My biggest issue with the movie, is like, Abuela never apologized. Like, how about we normalize older generations apologize to younger generations for being wrong. I’m a bit biased though because my own abuela was amazing and the kindest woman I ever knew. On the other hand, I hardly recall a time in my life where any of my aunts apologized to me when they were in the wrong.
@@satirical579 She did apologize, in the very end song. "And I'm sorry I held on too strong.. so afraid I'd lose you too. The miracle is not, some power that you've got, the miracle is you"
@@anneonomous4910 ehhh, “I’m sorry I held on too strong” ain’t the same as “I’m sorry I mistreated you and made you not feel like you’re part of this family”, but also, I feel like I would need the apology to not be in a song and have its own scene to be more impactful. But that’s just my opinion.
For those who didn’t catch it, at the end mirabele was standing in front of the vison Bruno had of her. This was when he told her he didn’t know if she was good or bad. While she was good in the movie this is basically what could’ve happened if she wasn’t. Bravo to the creator!
Edit: Mom I’m famous?! 😂❤
I didn't notice that at first.
Idk. I love what happened in the movie like the black sheep/scapegoat of the family breaking the generational trauma.
But I would love to see this too❤
I think Bruno meant the vision could have a good or bad ending not that Mirabel would become bad. I think he was saying Mirabel could do everything she could to prevent the bad ending but it could still happen. I don’t think Bruno said she could be good or bad.
Seeing the way everyone in her family except her parents treated her all because of a biased misunderstanding, she had every right to become a True villain with exactly that kind of symbolic song. Great cover for an interesting AU! Looking forward to what else you have in store for us.
Antonio?Luisa?
Except by alma and isabela nobody realy treated mirabel badly they just accept that she doesnt shine,this is still sucks but villan worth-
@@gabrieladapazlima7947 Mostly Mirabel was ignored and when setting up for Antonio's party she was basically told to get out of sight. but i think the biggest one was the scene when they all found out Mirabel was in bruno's vision.
They made it seem like Mirabel was actively doing something- Peppa even demanded 'What did you do?"
Mirabel also didn't know her parents stood up for her against Abuela, so to her no one was on her side.
even when Abuela and Mirabel were arguing- no one came to Mirabel's defence
@@n.jboltz599 Abuela did yes told mirabel to stay out of the decorations thats true- but nobody told mirabel to say out the party,she was probaly out because of her insecurites with her being giftless- about bruno's vision only isabela, pepa and of course abuela did blame her directly- and Pepa's "what did you do" was in my opinion ovee fear and desespation and an normal reaction in the context of the scene- i think that ppl view mirabel 's situation in the family a lot "black-and-whiteish"its WAY more compliced than the video(of couse its an villan au)
@@gabrieladapazlima7947 I was trying to look at things from Mirabel's point of view. what might have turned Mirabel into a villain.
It is easy to see things when you are on the outside looking in, but when you are in the heat of it you can't take an outside view to analyse. Mirabel also saw everyone's reaction to the news and her insecure mind could have made things worse.
I don't view Mirabel's situation as black and white- none of it is. they all have their issues which Mirabel can't see because she is caught in her own problems like the rest of them.
The details!!!! Mirabel didn't say anything directly to Camilo on his part, and Camilo ran towards her, more worried about her than afraid!
Soo cute!!!! 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I love how she metaphorically blew out a candle that never goes out. She called out everyone’s poker face, and left them to deal with their problems. It’s cruel, but that’s what villains are.
I love Mirabel’s glowing green eyes in this animation as she’s becoming a villain, like Bruno’s when he’s giving a prophecy, the thing that always made him a villain. It adds to the parallels between them and I love it.
I absolutely love this Villain Mirabel. Mirabel trying to make herself believe that even without a gift she’s still special like everyone else. But with everyone always turning down on her and making her be like a burden to the family she’s had enough, tired of everyone after all she’s done for them. Mirabel returns to the dark side and giving her family a taste of their own medicine, giving them what they deserve. Tired of all this suffering she had to go through, finally getting what she deserves, finally getting the revenge on her family. She blows out the candle and the house collapses with everyone in it. Now all the family is suffering and in a lot of danger and freaking out. Mirabel exits the house with a villainous smile. Getting the revenge shes been waiting for. I love these villain songs, keep up the good work.😉😉😉😉😉
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!
@@carliac52AWWWW TYSM❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Honestly, Mirabel would make a good villain. Probably the only people who never treated her differently were her parents, they still loved her
The scene where she's holding the candle and calmly watching the family visibly panicking while the house's debris falling down around her gives me chills.
@@luckystarz5895 No one, not even her parents and youngest cousin, not even Bruno and his rats....were safe
I really love how Mirabel is the only one in the family who stands up for her uncle who was pushed aside because others only saw the worst in him. Mirabel saw him for who he really was and accepted him all the same. This song is really perfect in reflecting both of their sorrows.
I can NOT get over the simple line "Free from your love"
There's so much emotion, so much anger, so much pain, and so much catharsis all mixed up into one explosion of a cry.
She's done chasing the love and approval of her family, of her grandmother. She's done chasing standards, and is free to finally be herself.
Yep
As a man who chased the approval of a man I could never earn from, it feels refreshing to stop chasing their approval.
@twister107 I wish I could do that with my own mother, despite her disabilities
This scene 0:42-0:46 hit me SO HARD. Her suddenly soft voice in combination with the bright yellow butterfly she crushes in front of a dark background, the movement of her hand, her eyes turning green and shining in the dark... This transformation was just PERFECT omg 💚💚💚
yes
I think that Casita would actually be on Mirabel's side in this situation. The thing is, she does seem to have some kind of 'gift', which is the fact that she talks to Casita the most and seems to have more control over it compared to the other family members. Basically, this means that Casita would probably be her weapon.
It would had certainly been interesting if there was a more in your face conflict, like isabella attacking Mirabel with one of her plants, then Mirabel, in anger, would stop her foot down and casita would just knock isabella down and everyone finally acknowledges that Mirabel's gift is the relationship with casita, and as such her "room" is all of casita.
There is still a possibility that everyone can do it but just offscreen
Isn't the thing that Mirabel is gonna take Abelua's place one day as matriarch and caretaker of Casita? Like her gift isn't showy like everyone else's but secretly the most important one of all
honestly if that was the case, the story would be fun to write out. I can see them having to evacuate, or be forces out of casita and have to retraverse their home for them come up to talk, most likely Abuelita, with miribel about all these issues. But they find their home has become a shifting maze makeing the family have to see all the cracks of their family and work to mend them to proseed. And in the center is Mirabel trying to work out all of these feelings with Bruno.
The mom and dad was on hee side the whole movie
God, turning the Bruno villain song into a Mirabel villain song is brilliant. It already has such dark undertones. Mirabel the anti-hero. I think I would love to see this version of the movie.
🤙 Determinism is Freedom 🤙 🤙
I love where the line goes "Finally free from chasing your love" and is immediately followed by "*Free from your love*" while little Mirabelle and her present version is there. Telling that gaining and keeping Abuela's love was like a constant struggle since even after gaining it, you are restricted to be that perfect version and what is expected from you. Such love is like a shackle rather than a necklace of roses. So such love is definitely something that you are 'freed' of rather than being 'deprived' of. The realisation hits Mirabelle inbetween the song and it's beautiful. She was finally done chasing her love, rather she was finally free from her love in that way
That, and it's the moment she gains wings.
Yep
This is incredible. I love the metaphor behind Mirabel crushing one of the yellow butterflies in her hand - she crushed the hope. And I honestly really liked how many times we could only see one of Mirabel's eyes. It really added to the terrifying effect she had.
Butterflies are a big symbol in the movie. Mirabel has them on her dress, even. Butterflies symbolize hope, as well as transformation and rebirth. The hope is crushed but the other symbols remain, in a dark reflection.
Love that Isabella tried to kill her.
She was raised to look down on her sister and in the end it made it easier for her to come to that decision than the others
Wow, dark much? 😳
"boy I love attempted familiar murder" -you basically
@Alistairs_CreativeProjects only when the lore makes it interesting
I miss Medieval times~~~
@@KikoSquirrelyis that a bad thing?
Correction she tried to get the candle back
I like how this even gives the message “I’m not doing this solely for myself but also for Bruno.” Like she gives revenge for her and Bruno’s sake
I really like that you drew her crushing a butterfly.
In the movie, the butterfly represents hope for the Madrigal family and a chance for them to find happiness and truly accept their gifts. In short, the butterfly represents a brighter future for everyone.
We even see this in the end: Pepa doesn’t try to control her emotions but dances in the rain. Louisa finds she doesn’t need to take on every single burden, she can relax and occasionally ask for help, Isabella doesn’t need to be perfect or make beautiful flowers, she can experiment with different plant species, Bruno is no longer an outcast in his own family.
Mirabelle crushing the butterfly symbolizes her throwing away that brighter future for the Madrigals, she’s destroying Casita and stripping everyone of their gifts, in a sense, she’s freeing them, but it’s a cruel freedom because Pepa still bottles up her emotions, Louisa still feels like she has to take on every burden, Isabella still feels like she needs to be perfect for the family, now more than ever, Camillo feels like no one would want him for himself, Bruno’s still an outsider, Alma’s mental health is going to be worse, possibly even self destructive because she sees how much pain she’s put her family through, but can’t see any way to fix things, and Julieta and Augustine, well, I don’t think their futures are bright either, and poor Antonio’s going to have to grow up with of this pain and despair, I don’t think he’ll even have a future because remember, he’s a child, he might try to look for his cousin and get lost or even killed, further plunging the family into despair.
why th are u writing a whole essay on Mirabel crushing a butterfly?
@@matthewc2207Because that’s what most people do with these songs and I think it’s really cool
I think the green wings Mirabel has towards the end help hold this up. They definitely butterfly wings, but they aren't the same shape or color. It is hope, but not the one they wanted.
It’s more kinda like illness, poison, maybe ill intent characterized in those wings
@@irefusetochangemyname1275 They do, but it is so unnecessary. Why do u need to write a whole English assignment on a few frames of a cartoon character crushing a butterfly
I've gotta say, "what your apathy cost" was my favourite part. Perfect visual, and the little emphasis on cost just makes it all the more perfect. Makes me think of the avenging angel, with the butterfly wings.
2:21 I love how Camillo is still trying to save Mirabell it shows that he truly cares about his cousin even though her own sister tried to kill her and everyone thinks bad of her
Yeah, i feel bad for him
i really love this moment. apparently camilo is barely older than mirabel and they used to be super close, so it makes sense that he would try to help her despite her anger
Literally!!! He and Antonio love thier cousin, and Mirabel doesn't say a bad thing about Luisa either probably because even like this she can't bring herself to hate them
Geez, I wish that would actually be the plot of the original movie. Like, Mira has been through a lot, and she just admitted what Abuela has been through. NOBODY understood Mirabel, because she restored the house, showing that she actually has powers. Like, now you see her? Great!
1:08 when it goes “she’s a curse, she’s to blame” it gave me chills, favorite part of the song
Omg same! I belt out that part every time, it makes my ears so happy 😂
@@Sasuhinagirl1 ikr!!! It’s just amazing
This is absolute masterpiece:
- delivering the truths to the 4 members who deserve.
- true concerning for bruno
- butterfly effect symbology connecting to the other possibilities Bruno saw
- the perfect flip in the lyrics to match the melody in a twisted situation
- overall aesthetic of eyes implying change of heart or mind state (very much like artists uses to depict Sans in undertale).
My two favorite parts:
- the exposure reveals peppa brought the rain for her own wedding and gossiped a lot
- Isa using her gift aggressively and losing it (seemingly casita agrees with Mirabel helping in it)
This is perfect material, and as other people comment, im obsessed !
Disney need a WHAT IF series ahahahah
Congratulations for the huge work!!!
Where is the luisa part?
@@arccedar1132 Luisa does not sing in We dont talk about Bruno =O
@@ayrtonsantana7185 oh I missed read it I thought that isa using her gift was Luisa. I thought it said Luisa my bad
it could be that since Mirabel has the candle (and canonically she was meant to take over anyway) she had the ability to take away their powers.
YES!!!!!!!!! While reading the comments i was hoping someone else would list out everything! I agree with everything you said!!! ❤❤❤❤❤ Masterpiece! The Anna one is really good too! Lydias team is killing it!
Can we take a second to appreciate that quick frame in 2:23 (and maybe 2:21)?
The small detail that looks like Camilo is running away from his sister and towards Mirabel - not out of anger or in an attempt to stop her like Isabela did - but out of concern?
Whereas the rest of the family expressed rage, fear, or even apathy during Mirabel’s “monologuing”, Camilo seemed genuinely concerned for his cousin.
“Little late to be concerned, ‘Milo.”
- Mirabel probably
I definitely noticed that and it's a really neat detail! I mean, out of the family Camilo seems to have been the closest in age to Mirabel, and maybe even hurt her the least out of the family.
Dunno, but fun to speculate!
@MajjesticSquid Camilo's whole thing was making people feel better and entertaining them. Pair that with them being so close in age, him being just a little bit older, It makes sense that he would be the one that would comfort her. He was probably raised to be protective of Mirabel because he was the older boy, and she was the younger girl. But, he had to keep up appearances with the family and do his job and as he got older, he was just pulled away so much and didn't have as much time for her, but that doesn't mean he doesn't care.
Also in the movie when the house falls down, Camillo is also trying to save Mirabel. Sweet cousins ❤️
Love the tiny details here.
That her family either tries to run from Mirabel when confronted with their mistakes - literally running from the uncomfortable truth - or in Isabela's (maybe a little of Alma) case, attacking her - just like she had been verbally and mentally been attacked by them for years.
How when she addresses the family she above them - like in the flashbacks. Theyre golden and gifted and above her. But now theyre tarnished and so below her love.....
This was so good! But what makes it so scary is her accuracy and how in a sense she’s right.
Over half of her family abandoned her as she was “the odd one” and from what we see made little to no effort to know her let alone understand her so for her to be so mad and have so much pleasure seeing their terror
The singing was so good! I love it, not to mention the animatic really hit it home especially the scene with Antonio crying, gosh so heartbreaking
Yes, so much yes! I love this villainous Mirabel! She has every reason to turn her back on her family, tbh, so this dark version of her story makes an eery sort of sense. I love how haunting you made your voice, those whispers in the background, the background vocals in general... and the art is amazing as well! The whole thing is just so well done and I think it's my new Princess Villain favourite.
abuela,isabela and maybe Dolores?yes idk about the whole family.
Definitely my favorite villain cover, to be honest. I watched it like a dozen times already just looping. it's super good!
@@EvelynFTTEtheirs some good evil Mira fanfics
@@gabrieladapazlima7947
I don't understand why with Dolores, but Abuela and Isabela for sure!
@@TaraConway16 I think Dolores because she's the one person who must have heard every single thing. Every time someone told Mirabel she wasn't enough. Every time she was belittled by a family member. Every time she cried in secret. And she did nothing. (In this version at least. I'm not talking about canon)
Oh my god, absolutely cold. The visuals were stunning and felt vibrant despite the lack of color. Not only that but the usage of Mirabel being the butterfly after destroying the golden one and knowing the symbolism behind it. By far that was absolutely brutal how she left her entire family to be buried underneath Casita's remains. It's amazing how the vocals remained composed and cold even when everything was breaking down before them, this wasn't a moment of hysteria in fact it was just the culmination of everything to the point it tipped over and just coldly let anger take its course.
Absolutely phenomenal and downright chilling! Marvellous work to everyone who worked on this!
that looks more lika a moth honestly. It's also a better symbol that mirabel can either become a golden butterfly , the savior of the family or a green moth, the toxin that is going to ruin them all.
i got so many chills from it i love it! Bruno's profecy goes both ways in the movie so this scenario is entirely plausible had mirabel not being that strong mentally and not giving in to the build up negative feelings from her family's abuse
@@-zozet-5996 Ohh that honestly is cool! Because a moth and a butterfly are the same in some ways but so different, I just love how ironic it all is. And also like how intense the whole song is in message but if you try to sing it you rarely ever raise your voice only at the climax when the emotions have hit its peak.
My god I still come back to this video after its upload cause I absolutely vibe with the music, it fits to well and the lyrics just gives it so much crunch!
I like how Isabela try’s to attack Mirabel with a vine but when she destroys the vine the light on her door goes away. Does this mean she could remove magical powers?
Could be possible
Ooh, like Touma from A Certain Magical Index, except he negates them while Mira outright deletes them altogether.
I think it was either good timing or, the idea that I prefer, that they still had some semblance of family bond, but Isabela trying to attack and seriously harm Mirabel was the last straw. Sort of like “Knowingly and willfully trying to harm a family member with this gift given by Pedro’s Love for his family is too far beyond the pale.”
I like to imagine the reason she turned evil is from the idea Bruno died in this universe. She finds Bruno was living in the walls, shunned from the family. And despite all of his efforts, he dies never being embraced by his family again. With all the crap she's been put through and recognizing she's essentially becoming like Bruno because of her lack of powers, she finally snaps and the song occurs moments after.
When I rewatch it with this mindset,it makes a lot of sense😅
I thought the exact thing after hearing the song!
I like to think Bruno is going villain and he and Mirabel become allies.
The line about "sands having run out" could be alluding to Bruno being dead
That's what I'm saying!!!!
Bruno in the walls be like "The f*ck's going on out there?"
Seriously though, this is fantastic. You captured Mirabel's emotions so well, and the animatic is absolutely beautiful! Major props to both you and Shrubbug!
🤣
xD
The rats: stills vibing
But listen....... what if Bruno was dead in those walls? He was the family's dirty little secret and Mirabel wasn't going to be their next.
@@rebeccascholtes1438 Oh. Oh dear.
Mirabel has the every right to be a villian. THIS SONG GAVE ME LITERALLY CHILLS !! This is the realization of mirabel that she would be like bruno. Forgotten, shunned and put to shame to the point all you can do is hide. Just because of her abuella being a " perfectionist " and the only way to stop her from having a miserable future was to make theirs worse. Love this song and appreciate the effort!! ❤❤
Bro just that dude who delivered the party supplies was enough to start a village origin story. "I hope this year is better than last year's. Last one being yours and you didn't get a gift "
I like how the animanic points out Luisa and Camilo during the 'apathy' part.
Yeah, they didn't DO anything to her, but they didn't stand up for her either.
Camilo tried to reach out to her
I love Isabela being the only one who tries to swing on Mirabel. It speaks to the level of enmity between the two that's higher than anyone else's.
I love how from 0:55-0:57 you see that Dolores has always heard the whispers about Mirabel but never decided to do anything like lend out a hand towards her to feel loved. Much like how she kept Bruno hiding in the house all these years a secret from the rest of the family because of the whole "we don't talk about Bruno". It's great to see her feeling guilty about staying silent and not helping Mirabel despite knowing all the negative things people say about her.
And I love the jab at Alma just because that's what every grandkid and Pepa are doing, constantly trying to get her love and approval by being at her perfect standards. That's why Isabella is Alma's golden child who's pretty, has a flowery gift, and most importantly is Alma's version of "perfect".
Edit: After listening for a while you can hear background whispers from the moment she starts singing all the way up to the start of Isabelle's section. This shows Pepa always bad talking about Mirabel and keeping the family form talking about Bruno, Delores hearing it all and Alma not doing a damn thing but encouraging it. It's sad.
Late to this, but
The detail of her Cushing the butterfly was SO GOOD. That butterfly was the catalyst for the ‘happy ending’ in Encanto, and the fact that it’s destroyed shows she’s never going back and that’s such a good detail. This whole animatic gives me chills. Well done.
Stuck thinking about just how ethereal Mirabel’s hair looks because of the movement lines and volume. Love it. Immediately sets her up to look less approachable and more powerful.
I like how, at the end, she stands in front of Brunos vision he had that either the house would break or not
Its kinda like showing us the bad ending! IT'S AMAZING!! OUTSTANDING JOB
Has anyone realized this may be connected to how Bruno saw Mirabel's future? Felt being neglected, alone and wasted for the family and now decides to finally stand up for herself? It may be how the future he saw, it's like the citizens of the city said as their fate is sealed once Bruno sees your future.
I mean yeah he thought it was so weird for Mirabel to have a split path in her future which will determine what will happen to the family. I'm guessing if she walked out on the family they would've fallen apart anyways because it was all caused by the generational trauma Abella was pushing onto her children and grandchildren, and would've continued pushing onto her great-grandchildren if Isabella actually went through with the arranged marriage she didn't want.
One thing that makes me love this is that you can see that out of everyone, it's **Camilo** that tries to reach out for Mirabel.
Everyone else is either staring in shock/fear (Everyone) or are trying to get her to stop (Abuela, Isabel)
Then there's Camilo, who even though is scared, tries to *reach out for his cousin* and *is the only one to try*.
W camilo for that.
Same here because Mirabel is not only camilos cousin but also his best friend and like other friends out there he wants to try and reach out to her even though he's scared. Respect for camilo down here.
👇
Perhaps reaching a bit, but you could argue it was reciprocated. Pepa, Dolores, Isabella. Their verses were turned against them individually. Camillo's, was addressed to the entire family instead. Nothing especially against him personally.
"Well now my pain is ending i'm done with this pretending finally free from chasing your love, free from your love!" That line hits hard😭-
Very wonderful and dark take on what it means to chase love. Mirabel only ever wanted acceptance, to know she was a part of the family. But the love came as conditional to her. That she needed a gift, or she was not worthy of attention, of helping, of having as much love as everyone else. Mirabel worked and bled for any love she could, and that turned her bitter as she realized that love was not worth chasing, but unfortunately, she fell to villainy before she could have that revelation, and now she will destroy her family's gifts and possibly more as she brings down their home.
Definitely. I do think that when she met Bruno it was Mirabel’s turning point to either become the Hero or the Villain of her story.
Also notice how she doesn't point that rage at her parents, who did care for and about her gift or no gift, the younger ones who haven't done anything yet like Antonio, Félix who got along with everyone and has no gift, or Luisa, whom she knows is carrying way too much and who also loved her unconditionally (and directed her to Bruno in the first place).
Even as a villainess she's not unjust. Maybe without Gifts her family will learn something.
@@leatonjenkins6810I hope she got him out of the walls before crumbling Casita o.o
@@RavenSutcliffe That I do believe she was directing it to her grandmother and her flowery sister as well as miss eavesdropper.
@@leatonjenkins6810 basically the people who badmouthed Bruno and then her, her arrogant sister, and the source of everyone's issues
ETA well and Dolores didn't exactly badmouth him but the fact that she knew about his living conditions and how he actually left but said nothing... Yeah
This makes me imagine an AU where Bruno is also a villain and he has successfully managed to turn Mirabel against the family. He saw himself in her as a fellow black sheep. Together, he leaves with her, raising her as his own.
👍
The movie, in my opinion, would’ve been much more awesome if Bruno *was* the villain after all, I was kinda let down when the song was insane and the character wasn’t great
To be honest I think bruno like die? because he didn't show up in the video or he just know this whole thing will happen and run away
@@juniejunechannel May B he used his bucket and head-butted out his way like in the og?/nf/nm
YESSSS OMG DAD BRUNO AU IS PERFECT
Can I just say that Mirabel’s smile at 2:06 is so villainess and creepy that it sent chills up my spine it looks so good!
Fr
I'm actually impressed that all three main daughters have a legitimate reason to end up as the villain yet the movie never goes that route. I mean Luisa is essentially the Cinderella of this family, Isabella is the Snow White/Aroura, and Maribel is Belle/Ariel/Mulan. All of these girls could have been a villian because of how the family demanded too much sacrifice from them.