While Clancy wasn’t exactly what I expected I feel that Brad just had Trench 2 in his mind and as soon as it didn’t sound like that he just threw away the idea that this album could be good on its own.
Exactly, he constantly voiced how this is supposed to be trench again. I mean if youre expecting that vibe and style of writing again of course youre not going to enjoy this lighter stuff
I mean it’s also hard to not understand him cause this album was being sold as big lore Trench 2 vibes from the beginning of the promotion of the álbum because the band itself said that this was the most direct album of the lore and big finale of the lore, it was just misleading giving the general audience expectations on the sound of the album to be like Trench 2 and it was something that it was on its own
Ive noticed most live stream viewers are all losers with no real sense of self who just follow whatever the people they listen to say. With that said, this album isnt great
Bruh, brad decided he didn't like this album by the 4th song. His attitude came off as very disingenuous, and he was more focused on dunking on the album than actually giving it the same grace he gave Trench. If he listened to trench for the first time today, he would've hated it with this mindset. I understand a few of his complaints, like how chaotic this album is, but there a lot of shocking takes in here.
Can agree with some things: album is too all over the place; it has too little lore, and when it’s there it feels too dumpy; some songs are maybe a bit too saturated, and some a little bland. But it is not that bad, it’s not even bad at all. Sure it isn’t Trench, and there are obvious lacks. Nevertheless it is still a solid collection of songs. Maybe a 7-8/10
If Cut My Lip were on Clancy it’d be the worst thing ever, and if At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb were on Trench it’d be the best thing ever. I mean listen to even Chlorine and tell me it’s a good song and doesn’t have the problems you had with many of these songs.
@@sunny.litty353i love cut my lip and at the risk of feeling dumb, its all preference, id say the reason trench is so beloved is because of the high the production quality is, the intentional cohesiveness of it all and how put-together the aesthetic is, i think Clancy does lack some of these aspects - (production especially) but it is not a bad album at all, id say its good even, but not amazing
Cut my lip (like all of the tracks in trench (except maybe smithereens) worked perfectly with each other and are entirely interwoven. Atrofd/Clancy are paceless and directionless. Besides, cml is a good-sounding song, and atrofd completely ruins any tonal consistency that the album AND the song pretended to have. Finally, chlorine is a good song that doesn’t have the problems that Clancy does. It’s expertly paced with five segments and styles. It’s very subtly mixed, which helps the big parts hit as hard as they do.
@@jayp7552 This is basically true, and I agree for the most part. Only problem is that atrofd is objectively worse than cml due to the glaring tonal inconsistency that cml completely lacks. But yeah, when it comes down to it, anyone can like any music they want and shouldn’t be shamed for it. Just don’t mistake preference for quality.
No, I can't take this guy seriously. He hated SAI, but somehow, he gave it a 6, and Clancy, a 3? Are you serious? If you wanted to be different, congrats, but it's a steep hill to he standing on.
I swear this guy just has an extremely picky music taste 😭😭 (and no, I'm not hating on his opinion, I don't care or mind whether or not someone likes a specific artist or song or album or whatever. Just an observation lmao)
I usually get the points youre trying to make, but every adjective you used to describe this had me swirling my eyebrows and squinting my eyes. Even if we disagree, i get why we do. Not here lmao
Brad tends to use as many negative words as he possibly can to describe how much he dislikes something lol. You really notice it when he reacts to the boys.
Gonna be honest. I've been a TØP fan for a long time. This album was slightly less disappointing than SAI. Is it because i wanted a Trench 2 and this wasnt close? Perhaps. But also this album all over the fucking place. did it have to be Trench 2? No, but goddamn you could have at least made a cohesive album. this was not it. Theres no lore, the songs are somewhere in-between Vanilla and French Vanilla. Dont get me wrong, some of them are good. Craving is beautiful, at risk of feeling dumb hits, and backslide is a vibe. But besides that all the other songs are the same with different lyrics. Brad, this is not Blurryface 2. Because at least blurryface had bangers. There are no bangers, and i know bangers.
While Clancy wasn’t exactly what I expected I feel that Brad just had Trench 2 in his mind and as soon as it didn’t sound like that he just threw away the idea that this album could be good on its own.
Exactly, he constantly voiced how this is supposed to be trench again. I mean if youre expecting that vibe and style of writing again of course youre not going to enjoy this lighter stuff
I mean it’s also hard to not understand him cause this album was being sold as big lore Trench 2 vibes from the beginning of the promotion of the álbum because the band itself said that this was the most direct album of the lore and big finale of the lore, it was just misleading giving the general audience expectations on the sound of the album to be like Trench 2 and it was something that it was on its own
Honestly just can’t get on board with a lot of these takes. Navigating absolutely slaps from start to finish.
Chat is a bunch of sheeps
I mean yeah people tend to jump on whatever opinion he holds
Ive noticed most live stream viewers are all losers with no real sense of self who just follow whatever the people they listen to say. With that said, this album isnt great
brad got thanos snapped by tyler joseph himself
I would Agree that the sound is all over the place in terms of continuity. But I like most of the songs none the less.
Dang. Midwest Indigo is my favorite track😭
When I first heard Routines In The Night, I thought it sounded like Greedy by Tate McRae
Bruh, brad decided he didn't like this album by the 4th song. His attitude came off as very disingenuous, and he was more focused on dunking on the album than actually giving it the same grace he gave Trench. If he listened to trench for the first time today, he would've hated it with this mindset.
I understand a few of his complaints, like how chaotic this album is, but there a lot of shocking takes in here.
Can agree with some things: album is too all over the place; it has too little lore, and when it’s there it feels too dumpy; some songs are maybe a bit too saturated, and some a little bland.
But it is not that bad, it’s not even bad at all. Sure it isn’t Trench, and there are obvious lacks. Nevertheless it is still a solid collection of songs. Maybe a 7-8/10
I understand the Midwest take
that song grew on me since I listened to it on 17th (yeah leaker shame on me) but yeah, it grew A LOT
If Cut My Lip were on Clancy it’d be the worst thing ever, and if At The Risk Of Feeling Dumb were on Trench it’d be the best thing ever.
I mean listen to even Chlorine and tell me it’s a good song and doesn’t have the problems you had with many of these songs.
EXACTLY. (I do like Chlorine tho)
Exactly what I was thinking, CML sucked ahh, I don't care it's on Trench.
@@sunny.litty353i love cut my lip and at the risk of feeling dumb, its all preference, id say the reason trench is so beloved is because of the high the production quality is, the intentional cohesiveness of it all and how put-together the aesthetic is, i think Clancy does lack some of these aspects - (production especially) but it is not a bad album at all, id say its good even, but not amazing
Cut my lip (like all of the tracks in trench (except maybe smithereens) worked perfectly with each other and are entirely interwoven. Atrofd/Clancy are paceless and directionless.
Besides, cml is a good-sounding song, and atrofd completely ruins any tonal consistency that the album AND the song pretended to have.
Finally, chlorine is a good song that doesn’t have the problems that Clancy does. It’s expertly paced with five segments and styles. It’s very subtly mixed, which helps the big parts hit as hard as they do.
@@jayp7552 This is basically true, and I agree for the most part. Only problem is that atrofd is objectively worse than cml due to the glaring tonal inconsistency that cml completely lacks.
But yeah, when it comes down to it, anyone can like any music they want and shouldn’t be shamed for it. Just don’t mistake preference for quality.
No, I can't take this guy seriously. He hated SAI, but somehow, he gave it a 6, and Clancy, a 3? Are you serious? If you wanted to be different, congrats, but it's a steep hill to he standing on.
This is a grower for me
Music Videos Really Enhance these songs imo.
I adore this album but I always like to learn Brad's opinions even if they are different than mine.
we gon' eat with that DELUXE VERSION 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️
its not rap, its not hip hop, its not another attempt to make the voices stop, its spoken word with a little rhythm to it
I swear this guy just has an extremely picky music taste 😭😭
(and no, I'm not hating on his opinion, I don't care or mind whether or not someone likes a specific artist or song or album or whatever. Just an observation lmao)
I usually get the points youre trying to make, but every adjective you used to describe this had me swirling my eyebrows and squinting my eyes. Even if we disagree, i get why we do. Not here lmao
Brad tends to use as many negative words as he possibly can to describe how much he dislikes something lol. You really notice it when he reacts to the boys.
No way did he say Lavish was the worst track...
I’m a huge top fan and I didn’t even like it
@@toontales2479Same
Cannot be surprised.
It's crazy how differently people hear music, it flows amazingly to me, loved every song except for Vignette 9/10
Bad Taste bro...
Clancy music reminds me of me of the deluxe album
wdym
Bro wants to be different so bad
this is insane
I liked this band when i was 12 yall gotta keep finding new music
I’m definitely disappointed with the project considering it was supposed be like Trench.
oh no
Here it comes the toxic part of the fan base, oooooooooow boy
oh no he hates it
anyone have the link to part 2?
F
so are we starting another live or what
Oof. Nah I cant agree with anything on this review.
Some of the worst brad takes ive ever witnessed but we all know he has a crush on Tyler so maybe he just wants attention
L man
Yea
Clancy topped Trench imo
Swans < TØP
I think your ears are broken
Biggest L take I've seen in a while. Don't fully agree with this review but your comment is 👏👏👏 wrong!
Gonna be honest. I've been a TØP fan for a long time. This album was slightly less disappointing than SAI. Is it because i wanted a Trench 2 and this wasnt close? Perhaps. But also this album all over the fucking place. did it have to be Trench 2? No, but goddamn you could have at least made a cohesive album. this was not it. Theres no lore, the songs are somewhere in-between Vanilla and French Vanilla. Dont get me wrong, some of them are good. Craving is beautiful, at risk of feeling dumb hits, and backslide is a vibe. But besides that all the other songs are the same with different lyrics.
Brad, this is not Blurryface 2. Because at least blurryface had bangers. There are no bangers, and i know bangers.
Clancy is literally Vessel 2.