@@blackislepeastoo and do you think keir starmer hasn't lied he has not kept to anything that he promised he has picked on the pensioners and the poor and the vulnerable and left the rich alone he has taken donations of glasses and clothes and a lot of pensioners will freeze this winter or starve its disgusting he is one of the worst prime ministers ever along with the tories Tim Scotland 🏴 had its freedom to rule itself and get rid of Westminster government and downing Street
@@blackislepeastoo I will try again with my first answer keir starmer does not work for us he has not kept any promises he has made he is the worst labour leader we have had he is as bad as the tories the way he has treated the pensioners and the poor and the vulnerable is disgusting he is not a good prime minister and leave on this answer but then I am talking about labour not the snp they print anything about the snp but not labour or the tories
The councils are delighted with delayed discharge because the longer they are in hospital the less money it costs the councils in care packages,either home visits or care homes
Disastrous relative to who? That is nothing but a lying narrative spewed by an opposition with worse records in public services by a country mile. Put ANY English party in charge of Scotland and you lose Devolution altogether never mind ALL PUBLIC SERVICE.
Thank God for the SNP. Sarwar has to answer for EVERYTHING to his " Rob the pensioners BOSS " SIR Keir Starmer who has only interest in South of the border ie. NOT helping Grangemouth Refinery while keeping the 5 refineries south of the border OPEN. This is all part of the plan to strip Scotland of its assets and make Scotland dependent on England if Independence takes place in the future.
Typical deflection by SNP! Lets just ignore the multitude of incompetent SNP failures in the question by focusing on and shouting about one of theirs then trying to blame that entirely.
Well keir starmer and Rachel reeves are always shouting about the20 million black hole that's been left by the tories and labour cantbrun a raffle never mind a country
What do you think labour and the tories are fourteen years of a tory absolute mess and seven months of keir starmer and Rachel reeves awful and I would never vote for anas sarwar either he is the puppet of keir starmer the pensioner starver
It is devolved in Scotland. Only the SNP could stop it in Scotland. What you are saying is that if Westminster reinstated it the SNP would do the same. Shame on them for not having the commitment to the Scottish OAP,s of which I am one. Thanks John Swindle.
Why doesn’t the SNP make carers a special case and reduce their tax etc, so they can attract more people into the services that is so short staffed since so many carers left when they were forced to have the Covid vaccine. More practical measures would attract workers.
They've had 17 years, the costs at higher due to years of the SNP spending its time on independence, of course he's following his press he never answers a question in the house following his press is the only way to find out what the SNP plans are
@@stevecant3660 God help us if labour is in for long they have been in for seven months and that's bad the pensioners have been hit bad with labour it's disgusting but then they can't donate money to them
Why is Swinney doing Grays job for him? Could it be because he has no faith in him?
Presiding Officer - it would be good if the MSPs treated the public with honesty, courtesy and RESPECT - *WORK FOR US NOT THEIR POCKETS* .
@@blackislepeastoo and do you think keir starmer hasn't lied he has not kept to anything that he promised he has picked on the pensioners and the poor and the vulnerable and left the rich alone he has taken donations of glasses and clothes and a lot of pensioners will freeze this winter or starve its disgusting he is one of the worst prime ministers ever along with the tories Tim Scotland 🏴 had its freedom to rule itself and get rid of Westminster government and downing Street
@@blackislepeastoo can't wait for independence if I was first minister I would just declare independence and get rid of Westminster government
@@blackislepeastoo I will try again with my first answer keir starmer does not work for us he has not kept any promises he has made he is the worst labour leader we have had he is as bad as the tories the way he has treated the pensioners and the poor and the vulnerable is disgusting he is not a good prime minister and leave on this answer but then I am talking about labour not the snp they print anything about the snp but not labour or the tories
@@barbaraurquhart2276 If only... Then you'd be in some sort of institute where you belong.
The councils are delighted with delayed discharge because the longer they are in hospital the less money it costs the councils in care packages,either home visits or care homes
John Swinney says that the problem is complex. No chance of the SNP fixing it then.
The snp are not as bad the awfull tories and labour the pensioner starver and pensioner freezer and leavebon this answer
@barbaraurquhart2276 The SNP stopped the winter fuel payment in Scotland. A few more facts please.
@ianscott3180 keir starmer and Rachel theives did it first so you getcyou facts right getbrid of starmer the pensioner starver
@@ianscott3180 labour stopped it first and they ate supposed to be for the people
The NHS being used for political points scoring should be stopped it is absolutely disgraceful.
Almost 18 years of disastrous SNP rule in Scotland and Swinney spinning the same record about what they will look to do.
Disastrous relative to who? That is nothing but a lying narrative spewed by an opposition with worse records in public services by a country mile. Put ANY English party in charge of Scotland and you lose Devolution altogether never mind ALL PUBLIC SERVICE.
Thank God for the SNP. Sarwar has to answer for EVERYTHING to his " Rob the pensioners BOSS " SIR Keir Starmer who has only interest in South of the border ie. NOT helping Grangemouth Refinery while keeping the 5 refineries south of the border OPEN. This is all part of the plan to strip Scotland of its assets and make Scotland dependent on England if Independence takes place in the future.
Typical deflection by SNP! Lets just ignore the multitude of incompetent SNP failures in the question by focusing on and shouting about one of theirs then trying to blame that entirely.
Well keir starmer and Rachel reeves are always shouting about the20 million black hole that's been left by the tories and labour cantbrun a raffle never mind a country
Swinney is a total failure
What do you think labour and the tories are fourteen years of a tory absolute mess and seven months of keir starmer and Rachel reeves awful and I would never vote for anas sarwar either he is the puppet of keir starmer the pensioner starver
The tories are labour thebworst two parties in history
I wish we could reincarnate William Wallace and Robert the Bruce
@@barbaraurquhart2276 bworst? Is that some kind of German sausage?
@ianscott3180 keie starmer is always talking about sausages
Full on John must be gone Scottish narcissist party, and a hopeless presiding official
Get Rid of the god awfull tories and labour whocis freezing pensioners
Full on russel findlay and keir starmer the pensioner starver hope they get kicked out of Scotland 🏴 at the next election
😂😂😂 your delusional the Scottish narcissist party days are over ..wee jimmy krankie is pumping big val...the snp are pumping Scotland
It should really be More-on John...
More on russel findlay
@@barbaraurquhart2276 Time for your Deludamol there Babs.
@@peterpaszczak4013 you must be daft if you vote tory or Labour
It is devolved in Scotland. Only the SNP could stop it in Scotland. What you are saying is that if Westminster reinstated it the SNP would do the same. Shame on them for not having the commitment to the Scottish OAP,s of which I am one. Thanks John Swindle.
Why doesn’t the SNP make carers a special case and reduce their tax etc, so they can attract more people into the services that is so short staffed since so many carers left when they were forced to have the Covid vaccine. More practical measures would attract workers.
Thank goodness we have John Swinney as our FM and not either of the two opposition dimwit puppets.
How does this man get up every morning to destroy Scotland???
Because Nicola tells him to.
At least he is not trying to kill of the pensioners
Scottish labour wouldn't do much better.
Swinney the poo!!..seems a more appropriate nickname name….
Tell that liar Sarwar to get lost
They've had 17 years, the costs at higher due to years of the SNP spending its time on independence, of course he's following his press he never answers a question in the house following his press is the only way to find out what the SNP plans are
@@stevecant3660 God help us if labour is in for long they have been in for seven months and that's bad the pensioners have been hit bad with labour it's disgusting but then they can't donate money to them
Onist John 😂😂
Oist ker starmer and Rachel theives
Blah blah blah its no oor fault ,, its somebody elses fault and once ive spoken to spin doctors i,ll tell you whos responsible
So this must be a yoon site , think you lot forget what labour are doing to Scotland
YET MORE SUNSHITE