Though Karen did an okay job as Tina, and I suppose Krista was decent, I will always, ALWAYS truly only accept Andrea Evans as Tina Clayton Lord Roberts! (I am just sorry this last go round when Andrea returned, they did not know how to write her character!!!)
It had to be IMPOSSIBLE coming in as ‘the replacement Tina’ especially at a time when people watched this show BECAUSE of Andrea Evans. Karen Witter did an excellent job. It’s not her fault that she was up against an impossible task. She was as close as one could get to the original ‘Tina’. It couldn’t have been easy for her.
Karen Witter surprised everyone at the time with how instantly great she was as Tina - a role nobody thought could be recast. And that sentiment stands today. Being a fan of Andrea Evans, as I am, does not mean you're supposed to hate the actress who successfully carried on her role. AE is the reason KW was chosen, as their energies are so very similar. It's odd to see people get riled up about KW, when in this very clip you have Nicholas Walker as Max, yet no one's commenting on that elephant in the room. NW was cast solely on his strong chemistry with Fiona Hutchison, but he was SO different from James DePaiva as far as Max, the character himself. NW is a great actor, but was just way too off-track from JDP (both physically, and personality) to make an on-point Max Holden. He may have worked well as a different character.
Yeah, but the show had no chance but to recast due to Evans having to leave due to her real-life stalker. She had to leave the show and the producers had absolutely no choice but to recast. Witter was the best recast out of Clarke, Maroney, and Tesrau.
@@romanseano I only watched KW's Tina in clips . I enjoyed watching the comedy and sexual tension btwn Andrea and John L. Karen didn't have that but she maintained the sexy blonde who was bombshell. I liked Andrea's delivery. No fault to the other actresses. John Loprieno had chemistry with everyone I have watched him with. If anyone knows if there is a clip of Tina finding Milagro please point me in the direction. Thanks.
Only one Tina, and that is Andrea! I mean no disrespect to anyone. But these replacements were anywhere from adequate (Witter) to horrible (Tesreau- Tina became BORING!) Andrea Evans forever!
You could not replace Andrea sorry, that chemistry just wasn't there. this girl is too clean cut looking and acting, Andrea had that Glossy lipped wild teased trashy girl hair and the innocent doe eyes! This lollipop Mall chick here🤣
It's a rumor built on exaggeration, that actually had nothing to do with Witter. John Loprieno was burning out, as he put it. He's very close to Andrea Evans & worked alongside her through the stalker ordeal that led her to leave. John took a break in late 1991. When he returned, he & Karen Witter went right back to working together like pros. There was never a "hate" between them.
Though Karen did an okay job as Tina, and I suppose Krista was decent, I will always, ALWAYS truly only accept Andrea Evans as Tina Clayton Lord Roberts! (I am just sorry this last go round when Andrea returned, they did not know how to write her character!!!)
It had to be IMPOSSIBLE coming in as ‘the replacement Tina’ especially at a time when people watched this show BECAUSE of Andrea Evans. Karen Witter did an excellent job. It’s not her fault that she was up against an impossible task. She was as close as one could get to the original ‘Tina’. It couldn’t have been easy for her.
Loved these Tina Gabrielle cat fights . ❤god job Karen Witter . Very Andrea-esqe.
Karen Witter surprised everyone at the time with how instantly great she was as Tina - a role nobody thought could be recast. And that sentiment stands today. Being a fan of Andrea Evans, as I am, does not mean you're supposed to hate the actress who successfully carried on her role. AE is the reason KW was chosen, as their energies are so very similar. It's odd to see people get riled up about KW, when in this very clip you have Nicholas Walker as Max, yet no one's commenting on that elephant in the room. NW was cast solely on his strong chemistry with Fiona Hutchison, but he was SO different from James DePaiva as far as Max, the character himself. NW is a great actor, but was just way too off-track from JDP (both physically, and personality) to make an on-point Max Holden. He may have worked well as a different character.
Karen couldn't act her way out of a paper bag, there are some actresses that CAN NOT be replaced and Andrea Evans is the Only Tina
Agreed. Capital guy was O…K… but wasn’t Max at all. James was a legit cool 80’s guy and super likable. I was fine with him and Tina as a couple.
Haaaaaaaaa! I _knew_ that Tina's motives for returning to Llanview were far from pure.
She went to seek Gabrielle out to retaliate.
Gabrielle out manipulates Tina!
Always
Yay for Gabrielle vs. KW's Tina
Gabrielle is far too smart for Tina, LOL.
Gabrielle was almost as sharp as Dorian.
Like Dorian, Gabrielle could read people so well.
Andrea Evans is the one and only Tina clayton lord Roberts...
Yeah, but the show had no chance but to recast due to Evans having to leave due to her real-life stalker. She had to leave the show and the producers had absolutely no choice but to recast. Witter was the best recast out of Clarke, Maroney, and Tesrau.
@@travisjames3517 None shared the chemistry w/ John Loprieno (Cord) that made Cord and Tina such a popular pairing.
@@vashtix6812 It was a different kind of chemistry, but Witter definitely had sparks of her own with JL.
@@romanseano I only watched KW's Tina in clips . I enjoyed watching the comedy and sexual tension btwn Andrea and John L. Karen didn't have that but she maintained the sexy blonde who was bombshell. I liked Andrea's delivery. No fault to the other actresses. John Loprieno had chemistry with everyone I have watched him with. If anyone knows if there is a clip of Tina finding Milagro please point me in the direction. Thanks.
Only one Tina, and that is Andrea! I mean no disrespect to anyone. But these replacements were anywhere from adequate (Witter) to horrible (Tesreau- Tina became BORING!)
Andrea Evans forever!
Both Cord and Tina are so self-centered.
You could not replace Andrea sorry, that chemistry just wasn't there. this girl is too clean cut looking and acting, Andrea had that Glossy lipped wild teased trashy girl hair and the innocent doe eyes! This lollipop Mall chick here🤣
The actors that played Tina and Cord in this clip HATED each other in real-life. I don't know why.
It's a rumor built on exaggeration, that actually had nothing to do with Witter. John Loprieno was burning out, as he put it. He's very close to Andrea Evans & worked alongside her through the stalker ordeal that led her to leave. John took a break in late 1991. When he returned, he & Karen Witter went right back to working together like pros. There was never a "hate" between them.
I loved Playboy’s Tina ! Karen Witter was great 😎just like Andrea Evans - a little less Whiny 😫
Karen Witter was great. I actually slightly preferred her to Andrea Evans - I found her much more attractive.
This Tina had more of an edge