Гениальный Гилельс, мой любимый пианист, мне посчастливилось в 1957 году слушать в живую в шахтерском городе Горловка,, где я, студент геологического факультета был на практике ,слушать два часа: - первый концерт Чайковского и сонаты Бетховена. и с той поры я не могу его ни с кем ровнять , С. Рихтер пианист хороший, а Гилельс- Гений! его игра особенная отличается не только особой яркостью и чистотой звука, а и тем как он играет. на него приятно смотреть он весь в музыке, живой и активный. так что с Рихтером его не надо сравнивать, это моё мнение.
Your words about Emil Gilels are very good, indeed. And You also are right not to compare (measure) him with Sviatoslav Richter. I also know both in her own singularity since 1958 ff. I heard them both, not only in records but also "live" in some a lot of concerts. My impressions and my opinion: No one is better than the other one, they are only different - You must consider, that the classical music is of so many rich sides and characters, that no pianist alone will be able to interprete them all. - Well, let me say in some short words: Richter´s playing piano seems to me to be of a deeper intellect, always straight ahead, sometimes with a typically integrated melancholy - Gilels without doubt has the more musical(!) genius and the more beautiful sound, may be even more than Arthur Rubinstein. Anyway, I don´t know yet who is my favourite pianist - may be sometimes him and sometimes him... PS: Let me tell You: Once, before a Munich concert I met Gilels in the street and I succeded in talking with him for some ten minutes - it has been unforgettable until today.
Concert exceptionnel ! Emil Gilels etait un pianiste hors du commun ! L'un des plus grands musicien du 20ème siècle ! Son jeu est tout simplement phénoménal ! Une pensée pour son ami sviatovslav Richter !
OUTSTANDING GENIUS ONE OF THE BEST PIANIST OF THE 20TH CENTURY. this recording is superbly done.this was recorded as old as my self now still one can hear the clarity of tone and dynamics and technical excellence of Gelil.Thank you so much for sharing this video to the world.Personally this is coming from the bottom of my heart.
I am delighted to find yet more recitals by Gilels. One of the greatest pianists ever, in my opinion. One should not forget the wonderful contribution from the ORTF orchestra. And especially the contribution of Andre Cluytens. His recordings from Bayreuth Festivals are matchless. Both these great musicians sadly passed away well before their time.
I love this recording- Gilels and the conductor are in perfect sync- What passion, what virtuosity, Every gesture serves the music non of the annoying affected movements and grimacing of many of today's performances- A truly great brillant artist!!!!!!
Gilels is my favourite pianist; for the soul and feelings he is able to infuse into his music, his sheer technical excellence aside. Somehow his playing seems so right.
Orchestra is large and sound suppose to be great if it's been recorded now , pianist Emil Giles is dynamic and passionate , he is excellent . I never expected that I could watch this concert now , great! ,thank you
+SugarTomAppleRoger comprendre: mon silence devant la performance. Le silence, parce que sans voix, parce que frappé au coeur, parce que abasourdi, émerveillé devant ce talent unique. Un silence, comme pour mieux m'imprégner du sublime...
Gilels et Cluytens ont toujours joué dans une harmonie totale. Ils se comprenaient parfaitement. Gilels a essayé d'enregistrer avec Ludwig (et le Phlarmonia ) un peu plus tard mais il est revenu à Cluytens sur ces enregistrements de la fin des années 50. Personnellement je préfère les enregistrements avec Cluytens mais avec l'orchestre de la société des concerts du conservatoire, le troisième concerto de Beethoven en 54 et le troisième concerto de Rachmaninov en 55 sont des versions inégalées, à mon gout en tout cas. Oui il y' a de quoi se lever et applaudir, même en face d'une fenêtre youtube on sent que Gilels n'est pas pour juste étaler sa virtuosité, qui est grande. Il joue sa musique avec un naturel confondant, il la respire. Nous ne sommes pas prêts de voir des pianistes de ce calibre. Le monde n'a plus le temps d'en produire. Le monde s'est mis aux paillettes au point ou même les russes ne produisent plus que du vite fait sur le gaz. Heho toi, tu peux jouer du piano plus vite que ton ombre? Allez hop on te bricole un intermezzo et tu céderas la place au prochain ou à la prochaine. Tant pis pour la musicalité.
Gilels a bercé mon adolescence... en vinyle !! le redécouvrir aujourd'hui en vidéo est déjà en soi une émotion particulière. Mon imaginaire ne pouvait que s'enthousiasmer de l'authentique. En tout cas merci de vos commentaires explications informations.
when Gelil plays just like Evgeny Kissin has a profound impact to the listener in any way such as clarity of every note dynamics.expression the passion I just don't have words to describe their performance I enjoy every bit of it.
His name is Emil Gilels. While I like Kisin and consider him as a genius in every way, he can't stay in the same row with Gilels. I am sure Kisin would agree with me since I saw him talking about maestro. I totally agree though that the effect of his playing on listeners is hard to describe and it hos interprettion goes just to the listener's soul.
Kissin over-rated! Kissin colorless ice cold piano sound! Todays pianists are boring with cold colorless piano sound like Kissin Zimerman Hamelin Trifonov Yuja Wang Buniatishvili! Old folks the beautiful colorful piano sound like Wilhelm Kempff Emil Gilels Artur Rubinstein Radu Lupu Vladimir Ashkenazy! The beautiful sound players are all dead!
Outstanding performance, as one would expect from the likes of Gilels and Cluytens. But that camera work and that editing! Hilariously inept, even for those very early days of filmed concerts. However exciting to listen to, this is almost unwatchable.
Gilels showed the best interpretation. But Horowitz doesn't seem to be human. Richter is the best pianist, but it's a pity that Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 1 is not enough to belong to the same level as gilels and horowitz.
I've only got one Complaint to Make about the Performance its to Quite at the Opening and I'm Surprised anyone can actually can hear anything from the Orchestra,and it carn't beat the Historical Recordings from 1941 and 1943 with Vladimir Horowits and the NBC Symphony Orchestra Conducted by Arturo Toscanini on CSLP-505 And LM-2319 and CSLP-505 is the best one Recorded under licence by His Master's Voice in 1956 in the Golden Treasury of Immortal Performances:and this Performance is to fast where the Orchestra is Concerned and sounds as though the artists carn't wait to get home where'as on the two Vladimir Horowits and Arturo Toscanini Recording with the NBC Symphony they are Playing at the Correct Tempo and if anyone has still got a Turn table I would Strongly Reckonmend His Master's Voice CSLP-505 to anyone
Э. Г. Гилельс - мой любимейший пианист, человек кристально чистой души и пианист кристально чистого звука!
Гениальный Гилельс, мой любимый пианист, мне посчастливилось в 1957 году слушать в живую в шахтерском городе Горловка,, где я, студент геологического факультета был на практике ,слушать два часа: - первый концерт Чайковского и сонаты Бетховена. и с той поры я не могу его ни с кем ровнять , С. Рихтер пианист хороший, а Гилельс- Гений! его игра особенная отличается не только особой яркостью и чистотой звука, а и тем как он играет. на него приятно смотреть он весь в музыке, живой и активный. так что с Рихтером его не надо сравнивать, это моё мнение.
Your words about Emil Gilels are very good, indeed. And You also are right not to compare (measure) him with Sviatoslav Richter. I also know both in her own singularity since 1958 ff. I heard them both, not only in records but also "live" in some a lot of concerts. My impressions and my opinion: No one is better than the other one, they are only different - You must consider, that the classical music is of so many rich sides and characters, that no pianist alone will be able to interprete them all. - Well, let me say in some short words: Richter´s playing piano seems to me to be of a deeper intellect, always straight ahead, sometimes with a typically integrated melancholy - Gilels without doubt has the more musical(!) genius and the more beautiful sound, may be even more than Arthur Rubinstein. Anyway, I don´t know yet who is my favourite pianist - may be sometimes him and sometimes him... PS: Let me tell You: Once, before a Munich concert I met Gilels in the street and I succeded in talking with him for some ten minutes - it has been unforgettable until today.
P
I LOVE HIM!!!
Proud to have seen him play this and no 2 live in 1956!!
Genius Gilels ❤
Concert exceptionnel !
Emil Gilels etait un pianiste hors du commun ! L'un des plus grands musicien du 20ème siècle !
Son jeu est tout simplement phénoménal ! Une pensée pour son ami sviatovslav Richter !
Слава Богу! Мне довелось в молодости быть на концерте Эмиля Гилельса и слушать этот концерт в его исполнении. Дух захватывает!
О,Вы счастливица!!!Я мечтаю,чтобы построили машину времени и была возможность услышать эту божественную игру живьём!
ONE OF THE GREATEST PERFORMANCES BY ONE OF THE GREATEST EVER CLASSICAL PIANISTS !!!
OUTSTANDING GENIUS ONE OF THE BEST PIANIST OF THE 20TH CENTURY. this recording is superbly done.this was recorded as old as my self now still one can hear the clarity of tone and dynamics and technical excellence of Gelil.Thank you so much for sharing this video to the world.Personally this is coming from the bottom of my heart.
I am delighted to find yet more recitals by Gilels. One of the greatest pianists ever, in my opinion. One should not forget the wonderful contribution from the ORTF orchestra. And especially the contribution of Andre Cluytens. His recordings from Bayreuth Festivals are matchless. Both these great musicians sadly passed away well before their time.
I love this recording- Gilels and the conductor are in perfect sync- What passion, what virtuosity,
Every gesture serves the music
non of the annoying affected movements and grimacing of many of today's
performances- A truly great brillant artist!!!!!!
Wonderful version. Warm and committed. Gilels is great in this concerto. Even better than Richter who is a little external and cold.
Гений!!!
The greatest concert pianist ever.
Gilels is my favourite pianist; for the soul and feelings he is able to infuse into his music, his sheer technical excellence aside. Somehow his playing seems so right.
Absolutely wonderful. Listen to the music dance! Thank you!
Orchestra is large and sound suppose to be great if it's been recorded now , pianist Emil Giles is dynamic and passionate , he is excellent . I never expected that I could watch this concert now , great! ,thank you
Brilliant performance!
Τι να πεί κανείς για αυτή την ερμηνεία του solist της Ορχήστρας του Κοντάκτορα. Αθάνατη Ερμηνεία!!!!!!!!!
I can not believe that I am watching this old video
Thank you RUclips and all the people who have posted and love classical music!!!
Realmente fantástico tener acceso a esta presentación de hace más de medio siglo!!
Après quelques secondes de silence, je me lève pour applaudir. Sublissime.
+Michel Basoch I didn't hear any silence. They started applauding while he was still playing.
+SugarTomAppleRoger comprendre: mon silence devant la performance. Le silence, parce que sans voix, parce que frappé au coeur, parce que abasourdi, émerveillé devant ce talent unique. Un silence, comme pour mieux m'imprégner du sublime...
Gilels et Cluytens ont toujours joué dans une harmonie totale. Ils se comprenaient parfaitement. Gilels a essayé d'enregistrer avec Ludwig (et le Phlarmonia ) un peu plus tard mais il est revenu à Cluytens sur ces enregistrements de la fin des années 50. Personnellement je préfère les enregistrements avec Cluytens mais avec l'orchestre de la société des concerts du conservatoire, le troisième concerto de Beethoven en 54 et le troisième concerto de Rachmaninov en 55 sont des versions inégalées, à mon gout en tout cas. Oui il y' a de quoi se lever et applaudir, même en face d'une fenêtre youtube on sent que Gilels n'est pas pour juste étaler sa virtuosité, qui est grande. Il joue sa musique avec un naturel confondant, il la respire. Nous ne sommes pas prêts de voir des pianistes de ce calibre. Le monde n'a plus le temps d'en produire. Le monde s'est mis aux paillettes au point ou même les russes ne produisent plus que du vite fait sur le gaz. Heho toi, tu peux jouer du piano plus vite que ton ombre? Allez hop on te bricole un intermezzo et tu céderas la place au prochain ou à la prochaine. Tant pis pour la musicalité.
Gilels a bercé mon adolescence... en vinyle !! le redécouvrir aujourd'hui en vidéo est déjà en soi une émotion particulière. Mon imaginaire ne pouvait que s'enthousiasmer de l'authentique. En tout cas merci de vos commentaires explications informations.
Genius!
Touching & especially this was happening in the old days !
Wonderful !!!
Bravo bravo bravo brilliance grandiose genial music concerto super
Quel jeu pur ! splendide
Mamma mia!!!
majestic!!
WOW!!!
Un leone!
Brilliant
when Gelil plays just like Evgeny Kissin has a profound impact to the listener in any way such as clarity of every note dynamics.expression the passion I just don't have words to describe their performance I enjoy every bit of it.
His name is Emil Gilels. While I like Kisin and consider him as a genius in every way, he can't stay in the same row with Gilels. I am sure Kisin would agree with me since I saw him talking about maestro. I totally agree though that the effect of his playing on listeners is hard to describe and it hos interprettion goes just to the listener's soul.
Kissin over-rated! Kissin colorless ice cold piano sound! Todays pianists are boring with cold colorless piano sound like Kissin Zimerman Hamelin Trifonov Yuja Wang Buniatishvili! Old folks the beautiful colorful piano sound like Wilhelm Kempff Emil Gilels Artur Rubinstein Radu Lupu Vladimir Ashkenazy! The beautiful sound players are all dead!
splendide
Гениально
32:28 - Lift off!
Spassiba bolchoï !
Outstanding performance, as one would expect from the likes of Gilels and Cluytens. But that camera work and that editing! Hilariously inept, even for those very early days of filmed concerts. However exciting to listen to, this is almost unwatchable.
Gilels showed the best interpretation. But Horowitz doesn't seem to be human. Richter is the best pianist, but it's a pity that Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 1 is not enough to belong to the same level as gilels and horowitz.
This piece was used in the Looney Tunes cartoon "A Corny Concerto." ruclips.net/video/m735o_eEwgg/видео.html
Сумасшествие!
20:35 -- and I thought that public was smarter at those days
They were, but it's Gilels, so you just can't fight the urge....
Ai nunca elijas la opción de estabilizar la imagen. RUclips es una mierda.
I've only got one Complaint to Make about the Performance its to Quite at the Opening and I'm Surprised anyone can actually can hear anything from the Orchestra,and it carn't beat the Historical Recordings from 1941 and 1943 with Vladimir Horowits and the NBC Symphony Orchestra Conducted by Arturo Toscanini on CSLP-505 And LM-2319 and CSLP-505 is the best one Recorded under licence by His Master's Voice in 1956 in the Golden Treasury of Immortal Performances:and this Performance is to fast where the Orchestra is Concerned and sounds as though the artists carn't wait to get home where'as on the two Vladimir Horowits and Arturo Toscanini Recording with the NBC Symphony they are Playing at the Correct Tempo and if anyone has still got a Turn table I would Strongly Reckonmend His Master's Voice CSLP-505 to anyone
Предлагаю удалить эту запись, её качество только компрометирует великого Гилельса.
Tí Francúzi tomu nerozumejú
Dumb audience clapping between movements, as well as, right before the last movement was over.
Кунц лучше
Эдуард вообще играет по другому...