I might be biased but I think Italy joining the Central Powers would be more than enough to assure that side's win. A lot of Austrian (and later some german) troops would be free to either push harder into France or Russia and more French troops would need to be directed to the south possibly taking some weight from the german front.
About the Axis Ending: Germany most likely wouldn't force Italy to give them South Tyrol, as in our timeline they've reached an agreement : All Germans in South Tyrol either lose their German culture or migrate to Germany
I like all of them they are all intriguing Personally while the editing is simple and smooth I think making the transition be a bit more noticeable would be nice
2:22 austria wouldnt give italy south tyrol and dalmatia they would nerver, but they could have given them the italian part of south tyrol and istria which would probably be all it takes (with the allied land of course) for italy to join the cp, and i think that italy would be the key to victory for the cp, bc of simple reasons
I think the Pope-ruled Italy would have a similar stance as Italy in ww1, and perhaps even greater as they have the lands that France took in order to support them against Austria, however unlike our timeline croats would be more willing to join a nation ruled by their religious leader though i don't think it would overpower Yugoslavism, but it would make the population more divided, and because of that i think the facist would still take power and go to a path similar to our timeline, and after ww2 the papacy would lose all their political power and only be a religious leader like the patriarc of Constantinople. So i don't think much would change, though Italy might have control over Nice, as it was Italian majority, but that's it
I think southern Italy would have been better off communist than the north but of course the only realistic way for the Soviet's to get any of Italy was the north
I have a few what if scenarios: 1 .What if Spread southwards towards what would be the teritory of Persia and parts of Pakistan , instead of eastwards towards siberia like in our timeline , maybe they could enter siberia much later compared to our world . 2 . What if the ottomans invaded Persia instead of the Byzantine empire . 3 .What if Serbia caused the 2nd balkan war instead of Bulgaria . 4. What if there was a ''Holy Roman Empire'' but for the orthodox nations .
What about the timeline where Rodolfo Graziani forces a peace with honor between Italy and the allies due to some sort of miracle at the Reno which sees the Italian social republic defeating French American and British forces in the region.
I thought there was going to be a spain/napels(dont know how to spell that) ending where spain expands there influence is spain (maby gaining savoy, lucca or tuscany) and then during the war of spanish succsetion they rebel and gain independence (thogh maby still under the habsburgs) and then after the napolionic wars they unify italy
A note on the WW2 Occupation ending, there were talks on the Allied side to make Sicily an independent state, which OTL didn't happen due to Italy signing the armistice and collaborating with the Allies to fight off the German occupation plus the Soviet Union refusing to let a possible anti-communist and western aligned country be established out of the territory of one of the most communist friendly countries. Internally, Sicily had the formation of a paramlitary secessionist militia, which had little time to train and get qeuipment before law enforcement intervention, plus an independence movement that had little luck after the initial favour they received by the Allies. Thus, it wouldn't be too far fetched that in exchange for a communist North Italy, the Soviets could've been placated in regards to letting Sicily be independent, a move that would've made the administration much easier for the British, who would've had to redirect more military resources to placate a secessionist movement that would've been emboldened by prolonged occupation by foreigners which also had more time to organize compared to OTL. The future would, of course, be more unpredictable, it would of course harm the Italian economy, and a return of Sicily to Italy would be definitely unlikely in the first generations, depending on socio-economic developments the status-quo would remain even in a post-Cold War reunified Italy. The Marshall Plan and how it's managed would play a key role, all the resources being destined and fully managed locally could either result in Sicily achieving a far better development than OTL, or worst case scenario, well, what you would expect of a mafia-run state essentially.
You remember that Monaco video?. In that video i left a comment saying "What if the 1848 revolution succeed (yes all of them)" You replied that you would do it, it's already been 3 months, where is it?
Actually I was thinking about doing some other revolution like the Hungarian one first, before I do all of them, since it would be a big video. In the next month I promise you I will do a video on it!
I'm grinding them premieres, so trust me, you will see a lot of them! I'm glad I start to see you consistently, I remember you speaking French at the Napoleon premiere
@@rewriting-history Not then, at Ancient Times, you know, Before the Macedonian Empire, The Macedonian Empire a way to keep greece independant and strong protected from the roman, bizantyne, and ottoman empire
Id imagine this Holy Italian Empire would be a forever neutral country that would try to act as a international moderator between the Cristian world and would have influence over Catholic nations like France, Spain, Austria-Hungry and if we want to be generous South/Latin America but I do doubt we see a pan-Catholic nation state
I’ve got an idea Plz do all endings Ireland and one of the endings is where st Brendon Set up a settlement and Ireland (Aka Irish Republic of Brendonia) defeats the brits in an alternate French and Indian war v UK it is Brendonia V UK V natives
Next year you have to post Romania all endings on the first of December, or else I'm revoking your status of honorary Romanian (today is the National Day of Romania)
I am sorry but giving Czechoslovakia Silesia makes no sense. Unless they deport all the Germans (which would not happen since the second world war didnt happen yet, the Germans wokld be the ethic majority of the country. So unless an apartheid state happens, they woild collaspe and the German reguons would join Germany again.
The pope ending at least has a unified Italy. The Never unified Italy ending doesn't mean it's bad, since all nations develop quite nicely I bet. I would say that Civil War or WW2 occupation Italy are the world
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
14:43 as an Italian from Lombardy this is the most blessed ending our unification was a mistake honestly, we are too divided already.
I might be biased but I think Italy joining the Central Powers would be more than enough to assure that side's win.
A lot of Austrian (and later some german) troops would be free to either push harder into France or Russia and more French troops would need to be directed to the south possibly taking some weight from the german front.
4.69k. This is celebration
A good reason to party!
👍
About the Axis Ending: Germany most likely wouldn't force Italy to give them South Tyrol, as in our timeline they've reached an agreement : All Germans in South Tyrol either lose their German culture or migrate to Germany
Sounds like an interesting proposal
@@rewriting-history can you do what if the Neapolitan Republic of 1649 succeded? Nobody has ever done it
Im so glad that I found this channel a few weeks ago It's awesome
Thank you very much! I'm glad you liked it!
I like all of them they are all intriguing
Personally while the editing is simple and smooth I think making the transition be a bit more noticeable would be nice
Really appreciate that you liked both the video and the editing! I will keep going with the same style
Nice video I like the idea of adding commentary to this types of videos you should to one for the UK
I'll do one for most major countries, glad you liked it!
Could you do one for india?
2:22 austria wouldnt give italy south tyrol and dalmatia they would nerver, but they could have given them the italian part of south tyrol and istria which would probably be all it takes (with the allied land of course) for italy to join the cp, and i think that italy would be the key to victory for the cp, bc of simple reasons
a roman vs mongl empire video would be so damn cool
Maybe I should make that video actually
I liked this video alot, you should make other videos akin to this one like "All endings of France". I would like to watch those
I will for sure do more all endings video, hopefully covering a lot of countries
great video, keep up the good work!
Appreciate it very much! Will do!
The mongol empire defeating rome is a beyond outrageous idea.
PLEASE MAKE A VIDEO ABOUT: “WHAT IF ITALY DISCOVERED AMERICA?” PLEASEEEEEEE
sanest italian nationalist
Meanwhile you wait you can Watch the video "what if Italy discovered america?" Made by Possible History
I think the Pope-ruled Italy would have a similar stance as Italy in ww1, and perhaps even greater as they have the lands that France took in order to support them against Austria, however unlike our timeline croats would be more willing to join a nation ruled by their religious leader though i don't think it would overpower Yugoslavism, but it would make the population more divided, and because of that i think the facist would still take power and go to a path similar to our timeline, and after ww2 the papacy would lose all their political power and only be a religious leader like the patriarc of Constantinople. So i don't think much would change, though Italy might have control over Nice, as it was Italian majority, but that's it
But what if the pope calls for a crusade against the Ottoman Empire in like 1870? This would change so much and alter the balance of power
I think southern Italy would have been better off communist than the north but of course the only realistic way for the Soviet's to get any of Italy was the north
I have a few what if scenarios:
1 .What if Spread southwards towards what would be the teritory of Persia and parts of Pakistan , instead of eastwards towards siberia like in our timeline , maybe they could enter siberia much later compared to our world .
2 . What if the ottomans invaded Persia instead of the Byzantine empire .
3 .What if Serbia caused the 2nd balkan war instead of Bulgaria .
4. What if there was a ''Holy Roman Empire'' but for the orthodox nations .
Oh hey it's Rewriting History from the discord server :D
From which discord server?
@@rewriting-history the Alternate History Guild
This is going to be interesting to watch
It will release in 2 days, so I hope you can wait and let me know later if you liked it or not!
What about the timeline where Rodolfo Graziani forces a peace with honor between Italy and the allies due to some sort of miracle at the Reno which sees the Italian social republic defeating French American and British forces in the region.
Beautiful video, I tell you as an Italian 🇮🇹. What application did you use to make the maps?
Thank you very much, glad you liked it! I downloaded a map from Mapchart and traced over it in Paint.net
Your videos are some of the best alt history videos on youtube!!
I appreciate it, that's the goal! I will keep making more and better videos
I thought there was going to be a spain/napels(dont know how to spell that) ending where spain expands there influence is spain (maby gaining savoy, lucca or tuscany) and then during the war of spanish succsetion they rebel and gain independence (thogh maby still under the habsburgs) and then after the napolionic wars they unify italy
such a interesting video! watching the San Marino video next;). Also, you gained a new subscriber;)
Thank you very much for that! Really appreciate it! I hope you enjoyed the San Marino video, it's a bit short and old, but still one of my favourites!
@@rewriting-history I did Enjoy that one aswell ;)
A note on the WW2 Occupation ending, there were talks on the Allied side to make Sicily an independent state, which OTL didn't happen due to Italy signing the armistice and collaborating with the Allies to fight off the German occupation plus the Soviet Union refusing to let a possible anti-communist and western aligned country be established out of the territory of one of the most communist friendly countries. Internally, Sicily had the formation of a paramlitary secessionist militia, which had little time to train and get qeuipment before law enforcement intervention, plus an independence movement that had little luck after the initial favour they received by the Allies.
Thus, it wouldn't be too far fetched that in exchange for a communist North Italy, the Soviets could've been placated in regards to letting Sicily be independent, a move that would've made the administration much easier for the British, who would've had to redirect more military resources to placate a secessionist movement that would've been emboldened by prolonged occupation by foreigners which also had more time to organize compared to OTL.
The future would, of course, be more unpredictable, it would of course harm the Italian economy, and a return of Sicily to Italy would be definitely unlikely in the first generations, depending on socio-economic developments the status-quo would remain even in a post-Cold War reunified Italy. The Marshall Plan and how it's managed would play a key role, all the resources being destined and fully managed locally could either result in Sicily achieving a far better development than OTL, or worst case scenario, well, what you would expect of a mafia-run state essentially.
just telling you that the traditional format is All Endings: [BLANK]
Yeah I know, wanted to do something a bit different. Might change the title in 24 hours
I love the idea of all endings video with commentary
I'm glad you do! Will upload more it it for sure!
Italy All Endings The Video I Fell Asleep To One Time GREAT
Based
I think Papal Italy would be on the Allies to support Catholic France against Protanstant Germany and Muslim Ottomans
Probably
What if the cake empire is formed before 2040 January 1st 00:00 EST
What about timeline in which Central powers won ww1 so they lost lands which is now called veneto
This is very very interesting! A very cool thinking exercise!
I'm glad you liked it! Appreciate it very much!
@@rewriting-history No problem
Last scenario was just the eu4 kingdom of God formable
Cool video from Italy
Appreciate Italy, from Bulgaria!
@@rewriting-historyDo a video on the history of Bulgaria and Italy!
You forgor the Stresa front ending
Can you do alternative history part 2
Do you mean alternate world future, or?
I can do the script
Future
Idea: What if the Ottoman Empire won the First Balkan War?
Look at the second video I uploaded to this channel! 😁
Thanks, and it's great to see your channel growing so quickly 😄
Interesting! Gonna be there! Please consider all Austrian endings!😊😊😊❤❤❤
Depends on how this video does, I will see if I will do more nation endings.
@@rewriting-history got it
Suggestion: what if Hungary stayed communist and was never invaded by their neighbours?
I want to do something similar actually, maybe in the near future I will do it!
You remember that Monaco video?. In that video i left a comment saying "What if the 1848 revolution succeed (yes all of them)" You replied that you would do it, it's already been 3 months, where is it?
Actually I was thinking about doing some other revolution like the Hungarian one first, before I do all of them, since it would be a big video. In the next month I promise you I will do a video on it!
@@rewriting-history Ah yes, doing a request after 4 months. I want to kms now
Sadly won’t be here or at the French one , though will see both when they come out
Chooo chooo and away
I'm grinding them premieres, so trust me, you will see a lot of them! I'm glad I start to see you consistently, I remember you speaking French at the Napoleon premiere
@@rewriting-history yeah , also it turns out I got today of do I’ll see the French intervention in Spanish civil war !!!
interesting video, especially since I used to live there
Nice! Which Italian ending did you like the most?
divided italy because it would be interesting to see if italy hadn't united@@rewriting-history
What if Greece didin't weaken?
Mission impossible: at least after they gained their independence from the Ottomans
@@rewriting-history Not then, at Ancient Times, you know, Before the Macedonian Empire, The Macedonian Empire a way to keep greece independant and strong protected from the roman, bizantyne, and ottoman empire
Страхотно видео, новия стил обработка е супер, REWRITING HISTORY 10M subscribers!
Много благодаря! Оценявам го доста и се радвам, че си чатихме малко на лайва. 10 милиона има доста да чакам, ама защо не, трябва човек да има амбиции
@@rewriting-history like napoleon
How long will this vid be I have lunch at the time so I can only watch for 15min after Live starts
You can watch it anytime!
I’m finally back from School!
Id imagine this Holy Italian Empire would be a forever neutral country that would try to act as a international moderator between the Cristian world and would have influence over Catholic nations like France, Spain, Austria-Hungry and if we want to be generous South/Latin America but I do doubt we see a pan-Catholic nation state
Need to make a video similar to that idea. Don't have content for the HRE yet
Maybe you could do greece all endings
I will maybe do all countries all endings
@@rewriting-history cool
Wait , how would Italy stop Germany from doing the anchlus? Because I'm pretty sure the austrians were literally begging for it
in my opinion, rome protocols ending is the most interesting
(veri cool video btw)
It deserves it's own video tbh, I could explore that scenario
that could be interesting, would 100% watch it
14:25 It was called Lombardy-Venetia, the whole area of "Venice" , which is just a city is named Veneto use the right name please.
I’ve got an idea Plz do all endings Ireland and one of the endings is where st Brendon Set up a settlement and Ireland (Aka Irish Republic of Brendonia) defeats the brits in an alternate French and Indian war v UK it is Brendonia V UK V natives
Уникално! Нямаш представа колко ми пълниш душата!
Еее супер, радвам се да го чуя! Още много видеа ще качвам тия дни!
Cuold you do a all Denmark endings
Eventually yes! Let's see if people like this format and if I should continue
my favourite video! please do my home country of north korea ❤❤
Yoo in 4 days I will release a video on North Korea, you should check it out!
Oh hey the video is after nnn that nice i gess
why are you using the hoi4 map. britan is further away then it actually is irl
Yeah I saw, will fix it later for sure
Next year you have to post Romania all endings on the first of December, or else I'm revoking your status of honorary Romanian (today is the National Day of Romania)
Oh shit you have to remind me for next year! Happy holidays and a day off school!
@@rewriting-history I'll make sure to remind you, Bulgar man
All endings Greece?
I am sorry but giving Czechoslovakia Silesia makes no sense. Unless they deport all the Germans (which would not happen since the second world war didnt happen yet, the Germans wokld be the ethic majority of the country. So unless an apartheid state happens, they woild collaspe and the German reguons would join Germany again.
Czechoslovakia wouldnt join Italian side,due to them being in a little entente alliance with Romania and Yugoslavia.
German pressure would change that 100%
@@rewriting-history maybe,but the czechs would likely ask for help from the allies
Italy never Unified and Catholic Italy are literally good Endings.
So, which is the worst ending? I'm saying that the Pope ending is the worst, but that's just because I'm a staunch atheist.
The pope ending at least has a unified Italy. The Never unified Italy ending doesn't mean it's bad, since all nations develop quite nicely I bet. I would say that Civil War or WW2 occupation Italy are the world
Wheres the funni tno sea = land thing
we close to 5k #iwashere
Yeee! Will do a giveaway and Q&A to celebrate
What about a socialist/communist/anarchist Italy, using the Biennio Rosso?
As a Croat, start of the video made me suffer in agony, however by the later part of the video, it was neutralized.
I'm glad I was able to make it up! Slavic lives matter!
So sad that we got the worst ending 😢😥🤧
I came up with some a lot worse, trust me on that
Agreed there she be a Rome 2.0
4hrs to go!
Did you like it?
@@rewriting-historyjust started
🔥
Fire emoji!
cat
Cats Indeed
cheese
Wheeee
Did you like the video once it released?
@@rewriting-history yeah, it’s pretty cool
@@rewriting-history do you want to make a civilization. It’s inspired by your old one where I was Novgorod. Just comment in one of the vids
Слава Україні!🇺🇦
Слава Болгарії!🇧🇬