I wish we could have seen Prue’s reaction to Paige. I’m pretty sure she was the first one of the sisters to realize that Sam and Patty had a relationship that was more than Whitelighter and his charge. He basically admitted to Prue that he was in love with her when he said “what matters most was taken from me 20 years ago”. She was the strongest of all the sisters, it would have been interesting to see how she reacted to having a sister she never knew about. Especially since she had to have some vague memories of Patty being pregnant with her since she was 6 at the time.
There's no doubt Prue would've been old enough to realise Patty had another baby in the oven. Phoebe and Piper were probably too young to realise it, but Prue was old enough to know.
@@yourmajesty69 no that I think about it. Being 6, she might not really have memories of it. She could have thought Patty was fat or have really blurred memories
@@lauraschoenborn3544 agree. As an adult she could realise that her mom was pregnant again when they met Sam. But as a child she wouldn't really focus on that. Especially when her mom didn't tell her about pregnancy
You did a great job on this "what if" scene; It's interesting to think about what the show would have looked like in this scenario; Phoebe is the one who was killed by The Source; Prue lived, Piper and her finding Paige. If this were what happened, it would have been interesting to see how Paige would use the power of Premonition!
Oh yeah Paige would have premonitions. I can't imagine that tho Also it would be interesting how cole storyline would go as it was centered around Phoebe. He definitely wouldn't become the source.
I definitely think that when they found out they had another sister Prue would've went looking for Paige when she found her Prue would welcome Paige with open arms she would have taken Paige under her wing helping her with her witch powers & spells
doesn't fit with what we know. we know at the end of season 3 in fighting between shannon and alyssa ended in an ultimatum being issued to the producers, fire alyssa or shannon. alyssa's popularity was rising dramatically while shannon's was stagnating, so they chose to keep alyssa. who initially caused the choice going to the producers is contested though. some say it was shannon or alyssa, other say holly forced it to stop the fighting and others say it was just the production team tired of the constant drama.the only speak of shannon quitting and always planning to have quit come from her and no other sources so i think its fair to say its not likely true.
@@dagameplayer apparently the producers reached out to her but she refused. According to Shannon l, she didn't like the way they were going to bring back Prue so she denied. I imagine that the angel of destiny would have brought her back as a gift for defeating the ultimate power
@@abelcollado1711 Yeah. I don't think I would have liked that either. If she came back at all it should be to help in the final battle. Not just be some gift that appears with a smile on her face to hug everyone. Prue was a fighter lol.
@@dagameplayer I wouldn't have liked that either. They should have brought her back to help in the fight. Her quick thinking skills and powerful combat would have helped the sisters a lot. Also i felt like Billie was a replacement for Prue. Telekinesis, can astral project and has hand to hand skills, they definitely *tried* to replace Prue.
@@dagameplayer You know what should have happened? They should have brought her back to life as a reward for charmed ones after winning the "great war" in season 8. Instead of taking away leo.
@@shadowhunter9835 it would have been cool if they bumped into her in the street during a mission. I imagine one of them commenting on how familiar she looks or how she resembles their mom
I wish we could have seen Prue’s reaction to Paige. I’m pretty sure she was the first one of the sisters to realize that Sam and Patty had a relationship that was more than Whitelighter and his charge. He basically admitted to Prue that he was in love with her when he said “what matters most was taken from me 20 years ago”.
She was the strongest of all the sisters, it would have been interesting to see how she reacted to having a sister she never knew about. Especially since she had to have some vague memories of Patty being pregnant with her since she was 6 at the time.
There's no doubt Prue would've been old enough to realise Patty had another baby in the oven. Phoebe and Piper were probably too young to realise it, but Prue was old enough to know.
She probably would have been the only one who knew patty or grams probably erased her memory of knowing about the babe or pregnancy
@@yourmajesty69 no that I think about it. Being 6, she might not really have memories of it. She could have thought Patty was fat or have really blurred memories
@@lauraschoenborn3544 agree. As an adult she could realise that her mom was pregnant again when they met Sam. But as a child she wouldn't really focus on that. Especially when her mom didn't tell her about pregnancy
Love how you've added prue into the wideshot like that! Looks so good
Thanks!
@0:25 that's excellent adding if Prue Was to Actually be in that Scene
That editing is amazing.
You did a great job on this "what if" scene; It's interesting to think about what the show would have looked like in this scenario; Phoebe is the one who was killed by The Source; Prue lived, Piper and her finding Paige. If this were what happened, it would have been interesting to see how Paige would use the power of Premonition!
Oh yeah Paige would have premonitions. I can't imagine that tho
Also it would be interesting how cole storyline would go as it was centered around Phoebe. He definitely wouldn't become the source.
I definitely think that when they found out they had another sister Prue would've went looking for Paige when she found her Prue would welcome Paige with open arms she would have taken Paige under her wing helping her with her witch powers & spells
True your right
Wow this is really good.
Originally phoebe was supposed to die but Shannen Doherty decidedly leave instead.
Nia Elizabeth Bush I wonder how that would have been Prue was always My Favorite
Nia Elizabeth Bush. I didn't know that. I'm glad she stayed.
Thats not true. This was planned all along.
nope, Shannen said from the beginning of season 3 she knew she was going to leave and she knew she was gonna go out by dying
doesn't fit with what we know. we know at the end of season 3 in fighting between shannon and alyssa ended in an ultimatum being issued to the producers, fire alyssa or shannon. alyssa's popularity was rising dramatically while shannon's was stagnating, so they chose to keep alyssa. who initially caused the choice going to the producers is contested though. some say it was shannon or alyssa, other say holly forced it to stop the fighting and others say it was just the production team tired of the constant drama.the only speak of shannon quitting and always planning to have quit come from her and no other sources so i think its fair to say its not likely true.
I wish prues ghost would have appeared.
Same. At least in the series finale.
@@dagameplayer apparently the producers reached out to her but she refused. According to Shannon l, she didn't like the way they were going to bring back Prue so she denied. I imagine that the angel of destiny would have brought her back as a gift for defeating the ultimate power
@@abelcollado1711 Yeah. I don't think I would have liked that either. If she came back at all it should be to help in the final battle. Not just be some gift that appears with a smile on her face to hug everyone. Prue was a fighter lol.
@@dagameplayer I wouldn't have liked that either. They should have brought her back to help in the fight. Her quick thinking skills and powerful combat would have helped the sisters a lot. Also i felt like Billie was a replacement for Prue. Telekinesis, can astral project and has hand to hand skills, they definitely *tried* to replace Prue.
@@dagameplayer You know what should have happened? They should have brought her back to life as a reward for charmed ones after winning the "great war" in season 8. Instead of taking away leo.
Shannen Doherty’s Eyes always look Uneven lol
0:33
man the rest of the series would have gone som much differently with prue. page would have also been a but less op.
Donde es la escena de este video
Good morning🌞 ☕🙋☀👍
What episode is this
Samantha Degennaro season 4- charmed again part 1
I am having a migrene...by me :)))
00:18 was funny
🤣🤣🤣
That's how it should of really went
I like Phoebe. They should've had all three meet Paige.
I agree! I hated Phoebe
@@shadowhunter9835 it would have been cool if they bumped into her in the street during a mission. I imagine one of them commenting on how familiar she looks or how she resembles their mom