Why Luke Began to HATE Anakin's Lightsaber - Star Wars Explained
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- NEW STAR WARS MERCH PAGE: bit.ly/TheStup...
For all sponsorship and business inquiries please contact:
Business: tmarvelouswave@gmail.com
Twitter: @StupendousWave
I believe all content used falls under the remits of Fair Use, but if any content owners would like to dispute this I will not hesitate to immediately remove said content. It is not my intent to in any way infringe on their content ownership. If you happen to find your art or images in the video please let me know and I will be glad to credit you.
End Song By WhiteSand "Eternity" • Whitesand - Eternity (...
Composer: Whitesand (Martynas Lau)
Year: 2017
Title: Eternity
Additional Music by WhiteSand: / @whitesandcomposer
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
Bandicam: whitesand.band...
Composer: Whitesand (Martynas Lau)
Year: 2023
Title: Olympus
This is a remixed version of the previously released track "Olympus".
--
Mixed and Mastered by - Dovydas Lazdinis
/ dovydaslazdinis. .
www.studija104.lt/
studija104@gmail.com
Composer: Whitesand (Martynas Lau)
Year: 2019
Title: Honor
Album: Fragments Of Darkness
: • "Honor" - Epic Sad Emo...
Additional Music Terminus by: Scott Buckley
Released under CC-BY 4.0.
www.scottbuckley.com.au
Terminus: • 'Terminus' [Epic Cinem...
Additional Music: • Dark Choir Music | (Do...
FACEBOOK PAGE:
/ mattiacupellicomposer
► SPOTIFY: open.spotify.c....
► ITUNES STORE: goo.gl/s9VhCQ
►OFFICIAL WEBSITE: www.mattiacupel...
►SOUNDCLOUD:
/ mattiacupelli
►INSTAGRAM:
/ mattiacupelli_
►BANDCAMP: mattiacupelli....
►OFFICIAL SHEET MUSIC: goo.gl/csI8Gk
He started Disliking Youngling Slayer 9000....I can't imagine why
Lmao😂
Lmao😂
👍👍👍👍🎉
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What he started disliking was his deep innate admiration for the awesome youngling slayer!
At this point I have an obscene amount of knowledge of what characters thought of each others lightsabers
Best comment🤣🤣
One of these days were gonna have Palpatines thoughts on taking shits everyday
I imagine the Jedi council discussing their lighsabers like that scene form American Psycho: "Lets see Mace Windu's saber" and Anakin just looses it.
@@NotAuxell incredible. The sleek and handy design. The tasteful golden ornaments, oh my force, it even has a purple blade...
Anakin/Vader "I never recall asking y'all opinions"
I didn’t really think about it before, but the fact that Luke wielded the very same lightsaber Vader ended up using to kill the Jedi with actually scares me a little. I’m never going to see Episodes 4 and 5 the same way again.
Also, thank you for revealing how Luke actually got his green lightsaber crystal. (That was new info for me)
I clearly remember Anakin saying “not again, master obi wan is going to kill me” . Which leads me to believe that his AOTC lightsaber is his second which would put the graflex as his 3rd.
I said this earlier and it was deleted. It is in the droid factory when his lightsaber is cut in half. Anakin said not again.
Maybe he simply lost it once before, or maybe not.
There have been Anakin padawan figures + comics where he has a saber prior to his AOTC saber so if he has lost a saber prior it’s likely that one but I’ve always thought by “oh no, not again” he was referring to almost losing it earlier in the film which would leave him at 2 prior to Vader.
@@srka42or when dooku took it in the clone wars
I think he's referring to a chase scene earlier where he accidentally dropped his lightsaber. Obi-wan even scolded him about it.
If I got my hand cut off while holding a particular saber, I would also hate it. Plus if you’ve ever held a graphflex,they’re damn uncomfortable. That’s why Luke’s grip was smooth.
I had the 2005 Anakin/Luke lightsaber that was spring assisted and made sound and it did feel weird to hold
maybe you had a realllll shit graflex, because they're not at all uncomfortable
@@MidnightNachos my first was a Parks 2.5. My second is an 89 graphlex. Two excellent versions.
Anakin’s lightsaber design was driven by pragmatism. Anakin was all about getting things done, and sometimes, you gotta change your process in order to do that.
Exactly. I dont get the premise of the video. Jedi were warriors who spent years training, so why should the handle of their primary weapon suck and a dude who creates a little bit better handle be frowned upon?
@@tnnetnattninuttn4627 I think is because the Jedi want to be known as "peacekeepers", not warriors. Jedi is about defence, not offence. They use their lightsabers to protect the peace, not to be seen as agressive, someone who starts a conflict. So, if the lightsaber is done and designed as agressive, like Anakin's, the overall concept of what means to be a Jedi, a peaceful warrior, is broken.
It's the opposite of the Sith who are seen as violent, dark side warriors, seeking only power, revenge, war, victory at any cost...
Something like this, I think...
@@EduN06 This is true and what ended the Jedi. Sidious saw this and took full advantage of it. They became far too complacent and only the most powerful Jedi could match Sith in force powers during this time.
The jedi sent Anakin to war , of course he built a lightsaber for war .
If Luke Soywalker couldn't deal with that , that is his problem .
Personally , I love Anakin's lightsaber........... it cut through druids , Sith Lords , and especially younglings just like butter .
@@EduN06 Yet in every light saber duel the Jedi is the first one to ignite their light saber. But their keepers of the peace right? If they really were keepers of the peace then the Jedi would not ignite their saber first and would not ever be the one to escalate the situation to a saber fight. But noooo they ignite their saber as quickly as possible.
Youngling Slayer 9000. Let's go!
"I won't be corrupted by the Dark Side", cut to Disney canon where he tries to kill his nephew over what would turn out to be a self fulfilling prophesy, driven by his fear and anger, and Luke thinking in absolutes.
While "resetting" continuity is usually a bad thing, I feel like the Luke we see in the Squeal Trilogy movies, and the Luke from the Disney canon comics and his appearance in the Disney+ shows are SO FAR different from each other, in their own continuity, that Disney may as well call those movies non canon at this point and redo them.
Blame corrupt Disney executives and their allies for doing that, especially if they're closet Sith loyalists.
Heh
I don't know if this was done on purpose but
"Squeal Trilogy"
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Chance has been and gone. The OG actors are dead or old, and the prequel actors aren't getting any younger if you wanna remake Kenobi or do a Darth Vader film.
@@tunebeat3809Disney is fueled by greed. Definitely sith
I prefer the Legends way of him actually creating his crystal.
I prefer the EU (Legends) EVERYTHING. Disney is total garbage.
@@MrKevin486 Yup Legends was more entertaining.
@@MrKevin486 amen, brother!!!
I believe Luke should have collected Anakin's lightsaber from Cloud City, whether to keep as a possible spare or to dismantle for extra parts. Without it, we never would have had the Rei movies, and the universe would be that much better...
If you drop something the size of a lightsaber from an airplane over an ocean, would you be able to pick it back up while you're missing a hand and it has a 3 minute headstart where you weren't looking at it? Luke was never going to be able to get it back. It freaking fell like crazy into the clouds.
Luke absolutely made the right decision, as whether you look at legends or canon material eventually Luke ends up reuniting with his father's lightsaber again after he's gone down his Jedi path, while I personally prefer how legends handled this with Luke clone it goes without saying that because he let go and didn't let his attachment rule him, he learned arguably the one lesson that would of saved Anakin from becoming Vader.
That would explain why when Rey handed that Lightsaber to him, he just yeeted that thing.
It doesn't make sense that he was using that exact lightsaber when his force projection confronted Kylo Ren.
You've got me thinking here maybe it's a kind of F.U to force users in general of what they stood for on both the light and the dark sides. By using that saber it was his will against the light and the dark in his own way as he was a sort of a grey at this stage. So using a half light, half dark saber, puts his own mark against kylo
Not a fan of Last Jedi.
But I can see why Luke used it.
This is basically used as a mind game to Kylo.
What better way to further get into his head by using the very thing Vader/Anakin used.
Thank you!
I thought the very same thing about the Force projection. Where in THE HELL was the damn green saber at. Just another thing that pissed me off about TLJ. F*ck Disney is what I say.
I mean, if I was a Jedi and realized I was wielding the Youngling Slayer 9000, I'd be mad too.
Love that Luke chose to walk his own path. Becoming something greater than all those before him.
Maybe him an the saber crystal was communicating... cuz apparently thats something crystals CAN do... an it came clean with what happened to Luke... like a confession...
On Anakins Saber, Anakin's era of Jedi Order... needed to wake up an ditch they spoiled premadonna ways... Anakin WAS practial... even as Vader.. always an his Saber was one that shoulda been used as a template for others to follow too. He made it in perfect adaption an adjustment to changing times... liek having to move from a mystical intergalactic police officer to mystical general an admiral of his own small personal army on any given battlefield
It is so hard hearing about legends Luke Skywalker, after what Disney is done to him…. They’re not even the same person.
Well yeah. Male protagonists are no longer allowed.
Vaders lightsaber? No no, Youngling Slayer 9000 😂😂😂
The ones that have passed on should be at rest and not forgotten. Those you have passed are a history to learn and to pay attention to what path you are going into.
This is good. We can understand Luke's feelings. He needed to become something more. Like Bruce Wayne. Luke became new Jedi,new ways. Far better ways. May the Force be with you too😊
So they canonically got rid of Luke using a "sith designed" crystal and now he has a natural crystal that is "unconnected" to a prior user...
That sucks.
*The following are the musings of a Salty SEAGULL named EARL who just shows up in my posts whenever he feels like it!*
[EARL the Salty SEAGULL:] "Well it is the Youngling Slayer 9000! Still its probably a good thing Luke doesn't have the Force Echo ability (the one Cal Ketis has that allows him to sense echoes in the force left behind) as I imagine he would have felt all the killing Vader did with it before becoming a cyborg!"
Never understood the obsession some have with Anakin's most famous saber. It's alright, has a good pommel but it's HIS lightsaber.
Every Jedi or Sith should roll their own. Even though blue is my personal favorite color, Luke is a green. It's HIS lightsaber. His own Jedi way.
Anakin’s best saber is his AOTC one, even he reinforces that idea by using it as the template for this Vader saber and not his ROTS one.
Well this all depends. If you are a Disney clown then no he should have changed paths. If you are a actually Star Wars fan and understand what happened in legends then you know he made the right decision.
After all the people, young and old, male and female, robot and droid alike, Anakin killed for power in the Dark Side, I can't believe that not only did Obi-Wan keep the lightsaber, but that he gave it to Luke. So much hate, so much pain in that hilt and crystal and he hands it to him like no big deal. Huge plot hole. If anything could have turned Luke it would be that saber. And while we are at it, didn't Disney decide to give the same saber to Rey as well? So now, two hardcore Jedi in Luke and Rey held it.
It should have MADE Rey a Sith. She is, after all, a Palpatine. /s
Almost forgot, another huge plot hole. Obi Wan went INTO the archives against Yoda's advice and SAW Anakin use that saber, yet he doesn't toss it into the lava, no, he takes it with him as a souvenir. Whoever wrote that book needs to rewrite that part. Claiming Obi Wan took the "tool of a Jedi" from the newly minted Darth Vader, is ridiculous. I will type it again. He should have nonchalantly tossed it in the lava as he walks back to the landing platform. MAYBE take a second to look at it for memory's sake, but ultimately discard it like so much refuse, realizing it was used that way. He should have been able to feel it on the blade and feel the crystal sobbing.
Pefer legends crystal lore better
Nothing would have made the Emperor or Vader happier than for Luke to find and reembrace his father's lightsaber. They obviously would have seen it as a sign of Luke's compassion for his father and a longing to reconnect. This moves him closer to Palpatine's dream of Luke becoming his new apprentice and a body strong with the Force to transfer his essence.
I always thought lukes green crystal came from Qui Gons saber Obi Wan had stashed away in his hut on Tatooine. And i always thought it odd Palpatine would say to Luke "much like your fathers" when speaking to him about his newly constructed lightsaber. To me it looked "much like Obi Wans" perhaps he was referring to its function as a weapon like vaders and not its appearance🤔
didnt know about this
really like the idea that yoda himself acknowledged that luke was becomeing a new better kind of jedi
Maybe the tiny youngling with a hat etched into the side it with over a dozen marks for his kills scratched in
I prefer the way Luke got his lightsaber in legends continuity, where he took the process of the Sith and used it against them. In legends, If I recall correctly, he returned to Obi-wan's hut on Tatooine to find his journal and lightsaber schematics. He then did a Sith process of creating an artificial crystal (which is how you'd normally get a red color) but instead of forging it with the dark side, he imbued it with the light within himself.
This is correct, Luke's crystal is a synthetic crystal like most Sith's, unlike the Jedi who used naturally occurring crystals. Synthetic crystals were frowned upon by Jedi because they resulted in a much more powerful crystal. Usually the process resulted in a red colour, but it could be made to be other colours with enough willpower and focus. Luke had no choice but to construct his new crystal this way, though, as the Empire and Sidious had either totally cut the galaxy off from places like Illum, or had mined out the crystals from many of these spots to build things like the Death Star Laser.
Remember also the synthetic crystals had a particular snap to their activation, which is legends canon why Luke's loghtsaber sounded different in RotJ
So...nobody's gonna ask about the other video that I and others were watching then just stops halfway.
I watched the whole video before this one came out. Weird that it happened.
@@Templefamily I thought it was some sort of glitch. Closed it and then searched in my history to re-watch it. It was gone, especially in my notifications.
@@revansdisciple4636I thought I was tweaking I saw the notification for that one then 10 mins later this one came up but oh well
@@revansdisciple4636 that’s unfortunate. Obviously Someone must have messed up and released the wrong video. Hopefully they release it soon to be able to watch it.
Uhm.. It wasnt his first lightsaber on geonosis.. He tells padme that obi will be mad it happened AGAIN so he had at least one previous saber
Family is important, but that lightsaber carried a lot of baggage, and in a universe where the Dark Side could taint even objects, and then let that seep into other people, tainting them, I think it was better for Luke to find his own.
Palps was stupid in that regard, Vader made a Saber that he knew and could use well, not one he would have to retrain with
Day 464 of asking for a part 3 of what if anakin was trained by qui gon
Well, then it was DEFINITELY not meant for Ray Palpatine! I think Luke was right to seek out his own crystal and imbue with his own power, instead of appropriating the crystal/saber of another. Every Jedi or Sith should do the same because it improves their abilities vastly with the lightsaber. I'd definitely want my own crystal because I'm a big Form 1 fan, which by its nature requires a stronger bond with the force and your weapon to reach higher levels of potential.
Luke created his crystal like the Sith do. A synthetic crystal, as the majority of natural crystals were either inaccessible due to the Empire, or mined out for things like the Death Star. Luke had to resort to using the Sith method of forging his own crystal, as it was the only way to get one. Ironic, since he was using the Sith's method against them.
I thoguht his green saber was because he took the crystal from Qui-Gon's old saber
I always thought anakins lightsaber was cursed after he fell to the darkside and killed all the jedi with it in the temple sorta tinted with its own darkside aura
Luke needed the new lightsaber. It signified his growth in maturity and in the Force. I feel maintaining his Anakin saber would have held him back. Also, consider Vader's line in ROTJ. Vader and the Emperor took note of the lightsaber. It may have all been the will of the Force.
Hey Stupendous any updates on the Ulic Qel-Droma Bio and Power Scaling video, like you did with Satele Shan, Count Dooku, and Arcann. We have 6 vids on Exar Kun, 3 of which are about his double bladed Lightsaber. Not one video on the only man able to duel him to a draw though, let's make this vid happen. His story is worth being told in the holocrons from Jedi, to sith lord, to his path to redemption and peace. Let's get this holocron made, your friend and patron Samson
Script is done, it’s Very Very long.
@TheStupendousWave Excellent. I know when The Accolyte comes out, you'll be super busy with content for that show. I think this vid would be the perfect vid, before The Acolyte show starts. I can't wait to see this one, keep being awesome 😎
My thoughts on this are kathleen kennedy sucks, rian johnson double sucks, and disney triple sucks.
Just like they're ruining marvel, why?
So much lost potential with Star Wars. When Mark Hammill, a huge company man/social "activist" begrudgingly talks about it; you know its bad.
My red saber is throbbing
I think he should’ve just kept it but just locking it away
Who here has watched Epic Rap Battles of History: Darth Vader vs Adolf Hitler?
love a deep dive on made up baby nerd workings that have no basis except "this sells"
it always makes me laugh that Anakin's is supposed to be some pure weapon when it is one of the least comfortable to hold and swing.
Big surprise the Jedi hated yet another thing about Anakin and then have the gall to act shocked when he snapped.
I prefer the Qui-Gon Jon fan theory of Luke using his crystal.
Good video, but not giving any sources is pretty annoying.
#MeridianCU 🌎💘💰
Hate is not a Jedi way.
Which canon is this? I don't recall this in EU or Disney.
I think this is EU, Disney might’ve dipped into it but I highly doubt it. A good rule of thumb I follow is if there is a lot of information or something that seems more powerful than I though, go with EU
690th like!👍
Awesome video!🤘
Disney canon gets too mystical about lightsabers
At least get Anakins Saber so no dummy gets it and hurts himself or others.
I think Luke reasons were completely right to dislike while Obi-wan’s and the rest of the old Jedi order did have some points was largely wrong. Luke’s lightsaber was what all lightsaber should be weapon a symbol of Jedi ideals and values while at the same time weapon with practically in mind.
The Jedi were to focus on their image they forget the lightsaber was also weapon and need to used wisely but also effetely. Any Jedi can have a lightsaber that looks more like a Sith’s and still do their Jedi duties while any Sith can wield a lightsaber maybe more fitting for a Jedi all is needed to do horrable actions with it. For it is the user and how they wield it that’s important about the lightsaber not which order they belong to.
Dooku and Luke though in deferent ways proved the point ,though one was more agarent but right point of view while the other was more humble and the need for surrival.
star wars explained huh? lol
Bah, I have no need for expanded universe or Disney lore. I will breath my last believing Luke's green crystal as Qui-Gon's old one. Stored away in old Ben's hut, awaiting a worthy master. A master who seeks justice, not just order.
Not to get too eclectic, but in Matthew 23:23 Jesus rebukes the Pharises for paying their tithes but neglecting the more important matters of justice, mercy, and faithfulness.
Might be one of the reasons he tossed it away.
So thats why he really threw it over his shoulder
Well simple, Anakin’s lightsaber was made for War; Made for a different enemy. Founded upon conflict and battles.
Luke wanted peace, and Anakin’s lightsaber couldn’t offer that.
Luke’s lightsaber was made for peace and rebirth.
Even more reason he throws his dad’s lightsaber over his shoulder in The Last Jedi.
Whose lightsaber would you want to have?
My own design!
Dooku
Exar kun
Aayla’s lightsaber
Because the writers are trying to justify Luke throwing it away in The Last Jedi by retconning shit.
Anakin's Lightsaber during the Clone Wars was a thing of Beauty & that's a Fact ✅
Think he should have stayed and got it if he was strong enough, but simply not used it/ignored methodology
Even if simply to be thrown into storage I imagine it's technically a relic at that point, after all it killed a bunch of force sensitive kids
Wonderfully done 🚀🚀🚀
I love how I always hear about how Yoda didn't approve of Anakin's lightsaber, yet their sabers were almost identical. Actually, Yoda's looked even more like Vader's than it did Anakin's. But I guess we're just going to overlook that
You're not alone in this world the creator of heaven and earth wants a personal relationship with you through his only son Jesus
It’s literally a weapon designed to cause the most damage! The skinny emitter in Jedi lightsabers aren’t just for looks (they encourage more restraint in strikes). I guard you won’t find a single Sith with a lightsaber that has a skinny emitter! But Anakin’s lightsaber is sturdy, complex, and designed specifically for combat.
Knowing Luke, it’s clear why he would late this lightsaber! 😂
I think kyber crystals were a poor story choice. Diamonds or amythyst are ok, but not Kubaz Zirconia. Luke facing Vader with a dual-phase blade or a Lambent-core blade would be very interesting.
I still wouldn't toss it aside. If it stinks so much, let MaRey Sue Palpatine keep it.
... they should have made it a Skywalker for real. Father and daughter.
Once again I ask the question: “Didn’t Luke get his Green Kyber Crystal from Qui-Gon Jinn’s Lightsaber?”
Anakin's lightsaber was a weapon Yoda thought,well Yoda just like yours yes it's a weapon. I don't care what anyone wants to call it,it's a fuckin weapon
I love how the practical movie making decisions (using a camera flash handle for the hilt, using a green saber so it would stand out against the blue sky) have all of this lore.
Those who deny history are doomed to repeat it. He didn't seek to understand Anakin, instead distancing himself from his image of him. While this can work on a personal level, he was unable to help others facing similar issues (both in legacy and cannon).
Luke’s connection to his fathers other crystal in his lightsaber might also explain why Luke was able to to tap into dark side abilities but remain Jedi (when he force chokes the gammorian guard in RotJ)
If only Luke realized just how awful the faithful Jedi of the Fallen Republic were to Anakin, then and maybe then will he realize that his hatred wasn't meant for his father, but Yoda and Obi Wan who literally failed Anakin from the start. Anakin may not think that Obi Wan failed him, but that is merely a lie that he can only tell himself as his split persona because that is all he can do.
I prefer to believe that Luke was using Qui Gon's green crystal. Great video though!
I still have a toy version of Anakin's and Vader's lightsaber and gave it a few swings and I don't understand how anybody is supposed to fight with that thing the hilt is uncomfortable.
I know the feeling, I have Dooku's lightsaber and can not swing it around without gloves unless I want the grip textue pressed into my hand for the nexed 20 minutes.
I always found it odd that the fore shaft of his saber is a smooth metal considering his right hand is robotic. I would imagine a tacky surface would be needed.
I also wonder why his right hand is limited in rotation, unlike general Grev
"used to maintain peace"
yall killed grievous, maul, dooku, and even decapitating jango.
Man I can't tell you how happy I am I found your channel. Peace is a lie, brother!
"This wasn't a tool to defend the innocent, this was a weapon." My brother in Christ, weapons are a necessary part of defending life.
“it was a weapon” NO SHIT it’s a LAZER SWORD ofc its weapon
I wish he did find that lightsaber. So Disney didn't make that new crap
I missed the bit where you explained where this information comes from?
Still don't have a clear answer to how Anakins saber got to Maz
We Try to ignore that terrible trilogy and unimaginative she Yoda.
@The_blind_Jedi If only we could burn it from existence and fill it with movies/stories from the real EU.
S
this is a real good one
Nah I'm pretty sure his green crystal is synthetic.
😎
The merch link isn't working. 403 forbidden.
lightsabers don't exist. This is all very silly
He should have given it another chance
Fans can go way too hard sometimes.
Luke's personal feelings on his lightsaber, echoes of Anakin's crystal.
😊