It's *always* broken my hearts that he *always* knew how it would end and could never tell her, never even allow her to suspect he knew something so horrible. Every time he saw her, he knew. Every time he asked her who she was, he knew. Every time he kissed her, he knew. Through the entire night on Dirilium, he knew! How strong he has to be, to be able to never let her know, and still be able to be with her. That's why I have always loved the Doctor. Forever willing to set aside his own feelings, his own pain, in order to be kind and caring and helpful - and in River's case, loving - to others, no matter who they are, or how much it hurt him. How can someone *not* love a hero - a Doctor - like that?
Same. It was so painful seeing River appear after Forest of the Dead, with the Doctor always knowing she would die, saving him. That was so heartbreaking.
every time I see ten sitting helplessly handcuffed and staring and river's charred remains with nowhere to run and no idea what he's lost, I break down weeping, because the not knowing makes the losing so much more bitter and cold.
so I paused the video at 4:25 and just looked at the blue diary... and saw how worn out and full it was, and that hit me really hard. I cried, because they were so wonderfull. and he still had that entire story to come. and how easy it would've been for him to pick it up and start reading, I wish i clould read it all from Rivers perspective...
the 'flashback' after "you've seen me before then?" just made it so much more painful. i mean, that was already what was happening in my head every time i watch that scene, but still, actually seeing it... amazing job 👌👏💖
3:50......gets me every time...... "It's okay... It's okay. It's not over for you, you'll see me again. You've got all of that to come. You and me, time and space. You watch us run. " - River Song - "Forest Of The Dead'. I wrote it and started crying all over again, thank you for making this.
As much as I loved Eleven and River I really loved her and Twelve so much more, even though they only got one episode of air time together (but twenty four years, though!!) Also after watching this video it really made me realize how tragic/ yet special the Doctor and River's relationship is
I still think that River pulled a sneaky and didn't actually die in the Library. Like maybe she was in the Teselecta rather than being directly linked to the planet's hard-drive, an the Doctor uploaded a copy of her consciousness. Just a theory of mine :-3
I've watched this video so many times and it still hurts as much as when I watched for the first time. But hurts in a good way, you know? This relationship is seriously so painful but beautiful it just hurts to watch most of their scenes now. Great video and wonderful song choice!
Amazing video! Each time you upload a doctor who video and watch it I cry with happiness that you put so much effort into these videos. It shows true craftsmanship that you don't get in many places these days! Thank you for being a part of my day.. till then next video cya.
Your editing is so wonderful i can’t stop crying you took the best clips and the music you chose for the video just match perfectly , I love it , good job ! Thanks for that Masterpiece :)
I don't even know their whole storyline yet (just started S6) and of course this edit had a lot of spoilers for me but damnnn worth it! My heart's just breaking over here but I'm totally fine... not.... But really great work, absolutely loved it!
Oh my gosh! You really need to stop making these videos. They are making my eyes go all wierd! It's like theirs water in them!! Stop it. Also, there is this feeling I get when I watch these!! It's so wierd!! I want it to stop!! (Jk, I absolutely love your videos, keep making them, they are beautiful)
GG PRODUCTIONS At first we thought it was for the Doctor but it turned out that it was for Rory. It one of the few great Rory moments. And that was the brilliance of it... But who the Frak cares when the video is so nice 😆👍
It's *always* broken my hearts that he *always* knew how it would end and could never tell her, never even allow her to suspect he knew something so horrible. Every time he saw her, he knew. Every time he asked her who she was, he knew. Every time he kissed her, he knew. Through the entire night on Dirilium, he knew!
How strong he has to be, to be able to never let her know, and still be able to be with her. That's why I have always loved the Doctor. Forever willing to set aside his own feelings, his own pain, in order to be kind and caring and helpful - and in River's case, loving - to others, no matter who they are, or how much it hurt him. How can someone *not* love a hero - a Doctor - like that?
Same. It was so painful seeing River appear after Forest of the Dead, with the Doctor always knowing she would die, saving him. That was so heartbreaking.
Mary Ann Bittle that is so true. Well said
every time I see ten sitting helplessly handcuffed and staring and river's charred remains with nowhere to run and no idea what he's lost, I break down weeping, because the not knowing makes the losing so much more bitter and cold.
so I paused the video at 4:25 and just looked at the blue diary... and saw how worn out and full it was, and that hit me really hard. I cried, because they were so wonderfull. and he still had that entire story to come. and how easy it would've been for him to pick it up and start reading, I wish i clould read it all from Rivers perspective...
Valerie Assema I paused the video at 2:25 to look at Melody's "Time Head"
River song is the best comppanion ever!
Aaro The Wanderer I AGREE!
Not comppanion is wife
thanks I didn't need my heart anyways
the 'flashback' after "you've seen me before then?" just made it so much more painful. i mean, that was already what was happening in my head every time i watch that scene, but still, actually seeing it...
amazing job 👌👏💖
3:50......gets me every time......
"It's okay... It's okay. It's not over for you, you'll see me again. You've got all of that to come. You and me, time and space. You watch us run. " - River Song - "Forest Of The Dead'.
I wrote it and started crying all over again, thank you for making this.
As much as I loved Eleven and River I really loved her and Twelve so much more, even though they only got one episode of air time together (but twenty four years, though!!) Also after watching this video it really made me realize how tragic/ yet special the Doctor and River's relationship is
I still think that River pulled a sneaky and didn't actually die in the Library. Like maybe she was in the Teselecta rather than being directly linked to the planet's hard-drive, an the Doctor uploaded a copy of her consciousness. Just a theory of mine :-3
Crying. So much crying. This is so wonderful.
U watch us run😭
easily my favourite show
I think my heart just shattered
Why must you do this? This ...amazingly beautiful tribute? I...can't...cry...AT WORK!!!
I've watched this video so many times and it still hurts as much as when I watched for the first time. But hurts in a good way, you know? This relationship is seriously so painful but beautiful it just hurts to watch most of their scenes now. Great video and wonderful song choice!
So good! But so sad. 💙River💙
This was brilliant and sad and everything in between and just holy cow I'm crying
This is wonderful and heart-breaking and amazing. I love it. Thank you.
This is one of my favs so thanks for all the space and time u have crammed into this video
Also what is the song in the background called
Jake Cake 'You Are Memory' - Message To Bears ;)
GG PRODUCTIONS thanks
Amazing video! Each time you upload a doctor who video and watch it I cry with happiness that you put so much effort into these videos. It shows true craftsmanship that you don't get in many places these days! Thank you for being a part of my day.. till then next video cya.
LewTGM #EPIC thank you so much :)
I love to be dead! What a videoooooo.
people who aren’t whovians are gonna be so confused when they look at the comments
also this made me cry cause of course another character had to die
So much pain, this video is perfect, you are amazing...
Amazing
Awesome work. Crying now, though. Such a painful, heartbreaking and still beautiful story.
RIVERRRRR ;-;
this is so so beautiful
Your editing is so wonderful i can’t stop crying you took the best clips and the music you chose for the video just match perfectly , I love it , good job ! Thanks for that Masterpiece :)
this is PERFECT. ❤
ughh why did I have to watch it so early in the morning >,<
because nw I'm crying of how beautiful this is, great job!
This is incredible, as always! 👏🏻👏🏻
This is brilliant!
This is incredible!!!! Absolutely amazing!!
I don't even know their whole storyline yet (just started S6) and of course this edit had a lot of spoilers for me but damnnn worth it!
My heart's just breaking over here but I'm totally fine... not....
But really great work, absolutely loved it!
Epic!!! ❤❤
O noooo, it's beautiful
i come here to cry :’>
cool
WOW! Great editing job!
hey kids what's trending now?
*_pain_*
Oh my gosh! You really need to stop making these videos. They are making my eyes go all wierd! It's like theirs water in them!! Stop it. Also, there is this feeling I get when I watch these!! It's so wierd!! I want it to stop!! (Jk, I absolutely love your videos, keep making them, they are beautiful)
Which ship is more popular?rose/ doctor or river/ doctor
Does anyone know what song was used
0:20 Or is it after???
Awesome video, but why didn't you inlcude the scenes where the doctor runs to 'save' her?
Omega Alpha maybe cause it would not be as sweet as just them together
Can someone please name this song?
Message to bears I think, cannot remember who by tho :))
@@ggproductions6269 Thank you! (Also, may I say, incredible video!)
thanks satan
😰😰😰
But that speech by Amy was meant for Rory...
wishvesh chaturvedi I know, but I twisted it around a bit 😂
GG PRODUCTIONS At first we thought it was for the Doctor but it turned out that it was for Rory. It one of the few great Rory moments. And that was the brilliance of it... But who the Frak cares when the video is so nice 😆👍
wishvesh chaturvedi I totally agree. One of the best Rory moment, and thank you very much :)
Will river get pregnant with doctor babies if river return to show one day?