They claim the mother superior broke her vows of chastity. But why all the nuns are being punished? And the priest who also violated his vow, goes scot free. Even his name is not mentioned.
NOT AT ALL SURPRISED! These sex scandals are ALL due to clergy using their titles as their salvation and live faking it. You should hear what they did/do to me...."In the name of Jesus, their justice and their opinion of what is good and evil while NEVER looking at themselves!" It is called self-righteousness that EVERYONE lives by their own code vs God's way.
Mother Mary! You all need to stop this mother Mary stuff. Mary was a woman born. She isn't a deity. God and God alone is to be worshipped and prayed to. God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit and that's all. Stop it with Mary and the saints!!! Everyone who is saved/born again is sanctified. There is only one mediator between GOD and man, and that is Jesus Christ. Jesus was born for the purpose of being beaten and crucified to pay our sin debt. No one else made that sacrifice but Him. And it is sufficient for all time and for every man, woman and child who has ever lived or will ever live. They just have to accept it and proclaim it. All the others that catholics place in the way are needless. Just lies from satan to keep you from worshiping GOD. Because Satan is evil and jealous and wants people to worship Him. And that is just what they are doing when they pray to Mary and saints. False doctrine.
@@thegeeg1751 The Bishop does value nuns. There are nuns in his diocese. Why you think because of a handful of nuns behave badly that somehow “priests undervalue nuns.” If anything the post reals of sexism
The nuns have been there for years with no problem, but this bishop suddenly comes along and destroys the nuns. They gave their best years of their lives to the church, now they're too old to get married and have families of their own. The bishop should be ashamed of himself.
They did it to themselves. All nuns know the bishop is the boss. Period. They chose to say no to the boss. The Vatican backed him up. They are civilians by their choice
The nuns themselves gave the bishop the authority over them but now since things did not turn out as they wish, they wanted out. They did refuse to keep their vows so it is right they be dismissed.
These woman were called to be celibate for Christ, by Christ, I would wager that being to old to have kids and families isn’t high on their list of concerns. God has given them the grace for said call. His grace just doesn’t go away. Being a nun isn’t a job. It’s a calling, identity and a way of life thet is freely chosen by a woman. Take comfort in knowing that at least.
it doesn't say he wasn't. this particular story is about the nuns in this diocese, the report even says the priest belongs to a seperate diocese. we don't have names here so it's hard to follow up on but surely this bishop reached out to the other.
It is Saint Pius (PIE-US) the tenth. And don't ever, ever go after nuns. I would have thought that the priests and hierarchy would have learned that by now. One of the experiences that kept me a faithful Catholic during the darkness in Catholicism of the past twenty-five years was my growing up in a school taught by nuns.
@@stevevastastood up to the Bishop who was trying to take their Monastery which was donated to THEM not to the Catholic Church. If they are no longer Carmelite Nuns then who does it belong to now?
I agree, that’s where they belong. To a rebellious fake “church”. Leave the Catholic Church for people who actually do what God tells them to and obey the Bishop.
I’m sure the Catholic Church would still support them if there is repentance. If they don’t see anything wrong breaking their vows than how can there be forgiveness. I support our Carmelite Nuns here in my town and I totally respect them. I don’t think I would have the same respect if they didn’t keep their vows. I was in the military for 27 years and we had to uphold standards. There were consequences if we didn’t. I agree if the other seven Nuns were not involved they should still be supported but if there is evidence they are all involved it should be closed down. If there is even one transfer her to another Monastery. Prayers are so much needed for this Nuns.
This Bishop Michael should be investigated. This sounds very shady and why is he so focused on their order’s property. Really suspicious behavior. Is Most Holy, Most Enormous Bishop Mike trying to sell that property to developers to line his own pockets?!
@@kittypaw1111They are not anymore and I'm with the Bishop, she admitted to breaking the bow and they even found drugs. Thank God that they are out. They should leave the Monastery to the Carholic Church because it was made with donations from the Catholic People.
@@fjai2755 Well, it is a “community” and leaders that supported the crucifixion of Christ. As one person stated, the “community” isn’t always right. The Truth is the Truth whether one person believes it or no one believes it, numbers itself is never the moral compass for what is right. This also isn’t an issue of popular vote.
“Saint Peeus Ex?” Really? Great pronunciation on the reporters part. If you do not know how to pronounce something, do not be sound foolish and guess! Another example of our media’s journalistic decline.
Funny story. I love St Pius X I once had an Italian lady come visit me. She said I’m from his town. I said oh, what town is that? I knew he was born in Riese Italy. She said some long crazy Italian word I never heard of. I said he’s not from there! She looked at me like I was on drugs. I said repeat the town again ? She said Arrriessssa Italy. She said it so long and drawn out it threw me off. I apologized profusely and we laughed a lot.
The evil and greed up and down the ranks in the church is obscene. The targeting of nuns and their monastaries is prolific and outrageous. The "Bishop" who practices gluttony tried to get his greasy fingers on the multimillion dollar monastary and land around it, but the nuns circumvented his greed. He happily smears the Mother Superior in public, but nary a word about who the alleged priest is. Does the priest even exist? No wonder today's youth have moved away from the church. Anyone who supports the "Bishop's" actions is just as heinous as he is.
Interesting that they didn’t dismiss the man who was involved in this situation. Not to mention all the other people employed in the Catholic Church who were involved in far worse criminal acts than never faced prison time for their actions.
The report clearly stated that the priest involved was from outside the diocese. Meaning that the bishop does not have authority over him. Some other bishop would have to do something. I think that’s why.
The faces of the nuns show personalities of grace and compassion. One nun turned out to be only human and fell in love with a priest. She confessed. And they are all condemned by that very worldly looking bishop who probably is very uncomfortable with women or anyone who questions himself? I thought forgiveness is offered to the repentant! I think Jesus would side with the nuns.
Only one nun was accused; the mother superior. But the identity of the associated priest who allegedly broke his vow of chastity with the sickly nun remained protected. Why? We don't know. Most probably it's all been nothing but a staged thing because the fat Bishop wanted to seize their land and SELL it. Why is he trying to do that? Well, just ask him why he's fat and doesn't fast and you'll never get a good answer - what more to expect when questioned about what is he planning to do with the land. So in protest against their unwilling dismissal from continuing their lives as Carmelite nuns, they decided to join the SSPX. The Catholic Church under the current pope is a mess.
But it’s my understanding that the SSPX is not in full communion with the Holy See. Am I wrong? I could be. I’m always confused by this. Plus, why were the other cloistered nuns dismissed.
I'm favoured only God knows how much I praise Him, $230k every 4weeks! I now have a big mansion and can now afford anything and also support God’s work and the church.
Only God knows how much grateful i am. After so much struggles I now own a new house and my family is happy once again everything is finally falling into place!!
I started pretty low, though, $5000 thereabouts. The return came massive. Joey is in school doing well, telling me of new friends he's meeting in school. Thank you Evelyn Vera, you're a miracle.
The ignorance of people here. -The nuns were u see the authority of the bishop. This is part of their religious life and vow. -the head nun admitted to having broken her vow of Chasity with a priest of another diocese, who has been forced to retire. - the bishop and other witness that heard her admitting have recordings of their meetings and in no way was the bishop rude, harsh or angry. In fact he showed great remorse. - the bishop removed her from her position and the head nun agreed. It wasn’t u til afterwards that the nuns refused the bishops judgment. - the nuns assumed that the bishop wanted their property (which he had no interest and still to this day has no interest in it) and appealed to Rome. Rome replied back saying that the bishop is in the right and they are to submit to his authority. - the nuns then rejected the Vatican's order and took the bishop to court. The court literally said that this case is not part of their jurisdiction and is a Church matter and dismissed the case. - the nuns then went into schism (meaning they divorced themselves from the church) and decided to join a group of schismatic “Catholics” called the sspx. - the Vatican along with the bishop then said that the nuns are dismissed from their religious life and no longer are nuns and now only laity. So these nuns are 1. No longer Catholic 2. No longer nuns and 3. They did this to themselves. And 4. The bishop doesn’t care about their property
thanks for clarification, people here are quick to judge with their emotions truly we should hear the full story before speaking, non sense things comes out of our mouth if we write before we think
Great summary, a lot of anti Catholic bias and assumptions by most in these comments that immediately sides with the nuns since they hate the idea of any sort of church authority and bring up unrelated abuses. One thing to note is that the status of the SSPX is a gray area. Technically the excommunication has been lifted so they are not schismatic but they are considered irregular
@@jbw53191Pretty sure that part about SSPX is malarkey. The SSPX are not schismatic, for one. The SSPX is inside the Catholic Church, has visits from Catholic Cardinals and Bishops, and is friends with several Catholic religious orders, including Traditional Carmelites, Capucins and Dominicans. There is a breakaway group that is sedevacantist, and they call themselves “ SSPX resistance “.😢
that's EXACTLY why the Bishop made waves & trouble w/lies.... no different than Trump the Catholic Candidate and convicted rapist (like priests) & convicted felon 34times - like priests have been, too. same White Supremacy cult
The bishop who kicked the Franciscan Friars of the renewal out of the poorest neighborhood in Fort Worth strikes again. These allegations were a pretext for property seizure, and I hope this injustice comes to light. Poor sisters. May God vindicate them.
@@zkeletonz001 The Vatican's appointee was a decision made for the sake of optics, and you repeating this justification explains the rationale. I certainly don't agree with the sisters aligning with SSPX, but their reasons for doing so are hardly a mystery after the way they were treated and a last ditch effort to keep the monastery.
It's a land grab. It had nothing to do with broken vows. They chose to distract the public with salacious acts to make the unseemly greed more palatable.
@@harrisonsamsonreally? then how you'd get that body by eating air? you must be a joke that's why ppl lost respect in these Vat.2 bishops cause they don't clearly practice fasting and abstinence...luxury is the enemy of fidelity to church.
Which is why, as a Catholic, I think priests SHOULD be able to marry. There once was a time when they could. It wasn't until the year 1123 that celibacy became a requirement. Prior to that, priests did in fact marry.
Paul literally advises that they be. 1 Timothy 3:2-5, and again in Titus 1:6. I've always wondered why the Catholic Church just pretends those verses don't exist.
@@jadedandbitter 2 Timothy 2:3-4, 1 Corinthians 7:32-35, when you use scripture to interpret scripture, you quickly come to find the catholic church has it right. not to mention diachronic linguistics meaning reading something other than the original transcripts can lead to certain things being lost in translation. dont know why protestants ignore this
Quite obviously, you know nothing whatsoever about priests, nuns, religious live or chastity! The reality is that the vast, vast majority of priests and nuns DO indeed keep their vows of chastity and celibacy, and breaking these vows is dealt with very seriously, as it should be!
He may not have even been a member of a religious order. And this does not seem to be about braking vows of Chastity, it seems to be about something else, that the nuns will not ask forgiveness for.
@@KenPaulsenArchitect Technically, he is still a priest, but his faculties were removed, therefore he cannot fulfill the duties, privileges of a priest.
Obviously not all details involved have been disclosed. But going by what is known, I suspect these nuns are being gaslighted by church hierarchy. I hope the nuns persist and prevail.
This stinks of a land grab. Even if one nun did this; it doesn't justfy doing that to other nuns. It sounds more like the nuns were in the way of the church taking over the land.
Bishop Sheen stood up at a USCCB conclave in the early '70's and told his fellow bishops that allowing so many gay men into the seminaries was going to result in the greatest catastrophe the Church had ever seen. His fellow bishops roundly hooted him down and laughed it off. But $2,500,000,000 (2.5 Billion dollars) later--that is the amount the U.S. Catholic Church had to pay out in the lawsuits--Sheen was proved right.
Seems quite possible that the bishop actually has a lot to learn about the Love of Christ but is too busy being judgemental and busy fostering schism to do so.
No, the bishop did what he was ordered to do and he gave the nuns every opportunity to cooperate with him. They were disobedient and he had every right to close their monastery and dismiss them!
@LordHarv @thereseklopfenstein3398 I was not there nor spoken with either party directly. I therefore said 'seems' because that is the impression I had from the video. However, I give way to your better knowledge.
@@holyngrace7806 Having been a member of a Carmelite order for five years, yes I do have greater knowledge about this subject than you or most people, and I assure you that the bishop had every right to act the way he did and the Carmelite nuns had no right whatsoever to act in such a disobedient manner!
@@thereseklopfenstein3398 Sister, thank you for bringing qualified information. That is heartening to know. Prayers have been with all concerned as well as their family and friends. The responsibility of leadership, particularly at the Bishop’s level is onerous and lonely at times. Hopefully those who guided the Sisters into this confrontation will find time to reflect and grow.
@jaykwonzzz while he may not support them his history also indicates he wouldn't have dismissed them. Forgive and repent. Only after much work and no sign of progress does he make those drastic decisions.
@@MorganMghee This is nonsense. Forgiveness doesn't remove consequence. The nun violated her oath, then during attempted removal, the nuns en masse refused the authority of the Vatican. Do you think Pope Francis is above recusing people or excommunicating them for extreme oath-indifference?
@@MorganMghee It doesn't matter. Your contention is that somehow Francis would not agree with the notion of laicizing these obstinate nuns is absurd. They're actively schismatizing and one is in absolutely violation of their clerical vows.
Sad but Good. The nuns have been in broken vows and decided to go into schism because the head nun did not like that the bishop removed her from her position after admitting to her break of Chasity. There is audio recordings on this. At no time was the bishop harsh or aggressive with the head nun.
I am not privy to all te details. But as I understand the problem was that he had no authority as the Sisters fell directly under Rome's authority. Also the bishop used the law as a means to enforce his will. I cant say who was guilty of what and what happened to the priest if anything. What ever precisely happened. This was a mess and it's sad that it occurred.
You shouldn’t. They vowed to follow the vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience, and they broke some of their vows. What is happening is completely just.
It’s only one diocese. “Dioceses” is the plural. I notice newsreaders keep saying “dioceses” for the singular “diocese”. Could somebody please tell them?
Better a Priest and a nun rather than a Priest and a little boy besides Priests are supposed to immolate the Apostol's and while there is scripture that says they were all virgins most of them were married with children so the "they were virgins" means something else The Catholics should have realized this centuries ago and allowed both Priests and nuns to marry and raise kids.
What is particularly unfair is when a married clergyman from another denomination converts to Catholicism, he is allowed to remain married. This happened at the University of St. Thomas in Houston when I was a student there in the late 1980s. There was a married priest on staff who had been ordained in the Episcopalian church then converted to Catholicism and became a Catholic priest while married with a family.
Sex abuse rates among public school teachers are much higher, and most of them are married. Removing Priestly celibacy as a discipline does nothing at all to fix these problems.
@isaiah3872 in 1517 Martin Luther nailed his 95 complaints to the door of the Vatican. The result ultimately was the splitting of the Catholic Church. Ok, so this situation is not EXACTLY the same, but ..
@@jmenter1 But it is about dissent and over abuse of power . And God protected (via a German Prince, by which Luther was given a trial the Prince sat in and had a say about it's outcome) and preserved Martin Luther and the church he founded. Back when the "Church" normally just arrested a dissenter and burned them at the stake. Like one man who defied them and they never caught him, but after he died, the "Church" dug his remains up and burned them at the stake. 🤔😳🙄 Now the Catholic Church begun under "saint" John Paul II , has come to a "pact" with the Lutherans. Actually, what hubris to write "Luminous mysteries" to add to the rosary believed to have been given to us by the Virgen Mary complete with the mysteries. So, he places himself as an equal to Mary? Or infers her rosary was imperfect without his mysteries? And yet he's the fastest saint on record of the modern church? Something seems amiss.😢
I was mol lested by a priest when I was a child. I told my mother who slapped my face telling me a man of god would never do such a thing, then she sent me right back to him. I'm 70 years old and that still has impact on my life. Disgusting how hypocritical the church is still. Have your faith without the religion, you'll be better off. I applaud these nuns.
Parents of children like you who were abused by priests should be legally punished too. It was their blindness about the church and priests that allowed their children to be in a position of being groomed and molested by those priests. I am so sorry for what happened to you . I was also sexually abused by a man who worked for my parents and this individual robbed me of the person I should have been. Continue to be strong.
@@fatsilver5905 It did cost a bond with my parents and me for the rest of their lives. As a child you know if you have a safe person to go to, to protect you or not. That she sent me back to the abuser because he was a priest cemented in my mind that my mother would do what ever she could to assure her eternity in heaven, even serving your child up to a molester.
Hey, learn how catholic hierarchy works before commenting. It was stated that the priest was from a different diocese. That means, that this bishop has 0 authority over him.
@LordHarv I am a survivor of Catholic hierarchy. Back in the day, mother and father met at a vocation conference. Then they continued meeting clandestinely, and 9 months later, I made the scene. The story is both sad and shocking because back in the '50's this was taboo. Mother was a teaching sister who gave up her vocation, while Father kept his vocation as a parish priest, both from different dioceses. For 4 days of the week he was dad, and for the other 3, he was Father leading a double life. Mother paid the ultimate price while I Iived in the shadows. For a child, this tends to be confusing. I knew that I was loved, but I was never mentioned in social circles; it served to make me stronger as a human being.
@JoeCezus then take that up with the bishop, since hes the one who has control over the priest. The priest in this case is not under this bishop's diocese, and thus has no authority over him. Cool life story. Too bad it's not relevant.
The bishop of Fort Worth has treated these nuns shamefully! He will one day have to stand before God to explain his behavior. Let those of us without sin cast the first. We have all fallen short in one way or another.
Who's the victim? There were no allegations of assault, but of consensual relations between two adults, who voluntarily discerned & vowed to live celibately for a purpose.
@@MaricellaDunn that's not dodging the question with a "non answer" the story is about these nuns who are under the authority of this bishop. The priest who was also acting inappropriately, is irrelevant to what is going on between the bishop and these nuns, and also under the authority of a different bishop. Do keep up.
“Straight Outta Carmel.” Seriously though, I am praying for them to be guided by the Holy Spirit on to a sustainable life path after this debacle. There has got to be a lot more to this story than most of us know.
Breaking the vow of chastity is NOT a ground fro dismissal from religious life when it has happened consensually and in secret. There should be something more than that that is not being said.
Ah you let the devil stray you away from Jesus with his deceit and lies.. Away from Jesus’s teachings and His true church. Catholicism is a personal relationship through the Bible and the holy sacraments with God. NOT an emphasis on man or their wrong doings. Prayers🙏
He didn't say he was led away from Jesus. I could only find Jesus by walking away from corrupt religion. The devil hides within religion seeking to divide us when we are all part of everyone and everything. Monica, I do believe that one day you will find the true way. Peace be with you.
Do not err, my brethren. If any man follows him that makes a schism in the Church, he shall not inherit the kingdom of God. If any one walks according to a strange opinion, he agrees not with the passion [of Christ.]. (From the Letters of St. Ignatius of Antioch, Epistle to the Philadelphians)
@@unoriginalclips9923 St Ignatius was still not Jesus. All who are saved by faith in Jesus Christ are Saints in heaven. Remember Jesus said to be first, you must be last. Also, at one time in history, there were multiple popes. Also, on the Bible scriptures, there are leaders and Bishops but no Popes. The line of succession from Peter was broken long ago .
@@Antonia_D Thank you for clarifying that. So why would he record her in the first place? it seems really concerning to be fishing for evidence to use against her, like he had the motive to be vindictive.
@@daughterofchrist1775 I don't know much about this, but I **think** it was a mutually agreed on recording for the sake of having a record of the discussion. May God bless and guide you and your loved ones. +JMJ+
@@Antonia_D Thank you for the update. I think that you are right about this, as I think I read this a while back. Thank you for the blessings. May God bless you richly for your generosity and kindness. Amen
One small detail. The Society of St. Pius X is read "Saint Pius the 10th." An interesting choice for the Sisters, as it's a canonically irregular fraternity that is at odds with the Vatican on numerous key issues.
But considering it is one of the only places that's not influenced by Rome's control especially in this time, the faithful have and out were there otherwise was none. And Father Robinson in Ridgefield Connecticut of the SSPX is initiating a Carmelite Third Order. AMDG!
What does the monastery have to do as a whole with this one nun and priest who broke their chastity vows? They should revert to lay lives. Leave the monastery alone.
Does the priest even exist? She is smeared, but the priest has yet to be identified. A ploy to wrestle the multimillion dollar monastary and land around it from the nuns' hands.
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
They claim the mother superior broke her vows of chastity. But why all the nuns are being punished? And the priest who also violated his vow, goes scot free. Even his name is not mentioned.
Because the priest is part of a different diocese, thus under a different bishop.
Because it's a man's world.
@@MaryEbr-yq7om No, because the priest is from a different diocese.
@@MADARA66613Mighty flimsy excuse. ...another diocese. A church that stands for anything does nor provide these loop holes.
@@MaryEbr-yq7omDeal with it.
Who is the Priest who broke his vows, and why is he still a Priest ????
Go learn Catholic doctrine to fix your ignorance.
NOT AT ALL SURPRISED! These sex scandals are ALL due to clergy using their titles as their salvation and live faking it.
You should hear what they did/do to me...."In the name of Jesus, their justice and their opinion of what is good and evil while NEVER looking at themselves!"
It is called self-righteousness that EVERYONE lives by their own code vs God's way.
@@VENEZIO-u8d Huh? The question was legitimate. He broke his vows, too.
@@VENEZIO-u8dEnlighten us.
@@stevevastalast I heard they don’t know who he is
Because sexy nun won’t tell them
🙏 Mother Mary....think of all those priests who were moved around and allowed to continue on...😢
Mother Mary! You all need to stop this mother Mary stuff. Mary was a woman born. She isn't a deity. God and God alone is to be worshipped and prayed to. God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Spirit and that's all. Stop it with Mary and the saints!!! Everyone who is saved/born again is sanctified. There is only one mediator between GOD and man, and that is Jesus Christ. Jesus was born for the purpose of being beaten and crucified to pay our sin debt. No one else made that sacrifice but Him. And it is sufficient for all time and for every man, woman and child who has ever lived or will ever live. They just have to accept it and proclaim it. All the others that catholics place in the way are needless. Just lies from satan to keep you from worshiping GOD. Because Satan is evil and jealous and wants people to worship Him. And that is just what they are doing when they pray to Mary and saints. False doctrine.
Even if Pius is not a common English name, the reporter should know enough to realize that capital X is a Roman numeral. So, Pius the tenth.
AI responsible for mispronouncing
There has never been a dumber time
She is an idiot and obviously not Catholic!
@@drewprice8468Seriously, even barely literate people would've known some Roman numerals from grandfather clocks
glad you caught that
Why do priests always undervalue nuns? As a Catholic school grad I can only say nuns gave us the best of education and example. My gratitude, Sisters!
Because Adam gave up a rib to create Eve and the Bible says women are supposed to obey their husband's and all religions are cults.
Not everything is sexism-related.
@@thegeeg1751 The Bishop does value nuns. There are nuns in his diocese. Why you think because of a handful of nuns behave badly that somehow “priests undervalue nuns.” If anything the post reals of sexism
@@bearbait7405but it is in this instance.
Why did this nun break her vow of chastity made to GOD?
Another seemingly poorly catechised Catholic.
The nuns have been there for years with no problem, but this bishop suddenly comes along and destroys the nuns. They gave their best years of their lives to the church, now they're too old to get married and have families of their own. The bishop should be ashamed of himself.
They did it to themselves.
All nuns know the bishop is the boss. Period. They chose to say no to the boss.
The Vatican backed him up.
They are civilians by their choice
they knew what they signed up for.
The Church put this on the bishop to get rid of the expenses. The Bishop has done a poor job but it wasn't his idea.
The nuns themselves gave the bishop the authority over them but now since things did not turn out as they wish, they wanted out. They did refuse to keep their vows so it is right they be dismissed.
These woman were called to be celibate for Christ, by Christ, I would wager that being to old to have kids and families isn’t high on their list of concerns. God has given them the grace for said call. His grace just doesn’t go away. Being a nun isn’t a job. It’s a calling, identity and a way of life thet is freely chosen by a woman. Take comfort in knowing that at least.
Doesn’t look like this bishop does any fasting and prayer.
Isn't there a "deadly sin" involved in that somewhere?
nuns innocent cuz bishop fat
Catholics don’t do fasting…that’s a “religion of peace” activity
He waddles real fast to the chow hall and prays nobody beats him there.
How would you know?
Why is the Priest not kicked out?
it doesn't say he wasn't. this particular story is about the nuns in this diocese, the report even says the priest belongs to a seperate diocese. we don't have names here so it's hard to follow up on but surely this bishop reached out to the other.
@@b00g3rs21it’s a horrible job reporting. Everyone can agree on that
It is Saint Pius (PIE-US) the tenth.
And don't ever, ever go after nuns.
I would have thought that the priests and hierarchy would have learned that by now.
One of the experiences that kept me a faithful Catholic during the darkness in Catholicism of the past twenty-five years was my growing up in a school taught by nuns.
That overweight bishop can't stand the fact that women were standing up to him. A complete abuse of power.
This report isn't clear, not a complete story?
No. I don't understand why all seven nuns were dismissed. What did they do?
@@stevevasta The backed up their fellow nun.
@@stevevastastood up to the Bishop who was trying to take their Monastery which was donated to THEM not to the Catholic Church. If they are no longer Carmelite Nuns then who does it belong to now?
They are trying to claim legal authority over the place.
@@whatsup3270 of course! Greed and power is busy at work in the Catholic world
This is about land and property grab.
What part of "vow of poverty" do you not understand? They willingly took the vow and the church enforces it...period.
No its about a nun breaking her vows. She also had drugs and a bong in her room. You know nothing
Imposed celibacy arose from church land grabs in the Middle Ages.
@@illiniwood That is how the Bishop is very thin after eating a lot. Gluttony is cause of sins.
You mean every American?
Woe to the Bishop of that Diocese....
No, he was obedient and did what the Vatican ordered him to do. Woe, rather, to the disobedient nuns!
Woe to this pope
Bless you Sisters. You and your Order are more than welcome to be received into the Anglican Church.
They will not become anglicans. They are Catholic and eill NEVET become Protestant.
I agree, that’s where they belong. To a rebellious fake “church”. Leave the Catholic Church for people who actually do what God tells them to and obey the Bishop.
How wonderful ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I’m sure the Catholic Church would still support them if there is repentance. If they don’t see anything wrong breaking their vows than how can there be forgiveness. I support our Carmelite Nuns here in my town and I totally respect them. I don’t think I would have the same respect if they didn’t keep their vows. I was in the military for 27 years and we had to uphold standards. There were consequences if we didn’t. I agree if the other seven Nuns were not involved they should still be supported but if there is evidence they are all involved it should be closed down. If there is even one transfer her to another Monastery. Prayers are so much needed for this Nuns.
@@joannhacker9120
Doesn't the good soldier refuse to follow an illegal or unlawful order?
Some may view this bishop as ordering an unlawful demand .
This Bishop Michael should be investigated. This sounds very shady and why is he so focused on their order’s property. Really suspicious behavior. Is Most Holy, Most Enormous Bishop Mike trying to sell that property to developers to line his own pockets?!
So glad the community supports these women!
The 'community' isn't always right.
They are nuns
@@kittypaw1111They are not anymore and I'm with the Bishop, she admitted to breaking the bow and they even found drugs. Thank God that they are out. They should leave the Monastery to the Carholic Church because it was made with donations from the Catholic People.
They should think twice before breaking their vows
@@fjai2755 Well, it is a “community” and leaders that supported the crucifixion of Christ. As one person stated, the “community” isn’t always right. The Truth is the Truth whether one person believes it or no one believes it, numbers itself is never the moral compass for what is right. This also isn’t an issue of popular vote.
“Saint Peeus Ex?” Really? Great pronunciation on the reporters part. If you do not know how to pronounce something, do not be sound foolish and guess! Another example of our media’s journalistic decline.
That sounded like a computer reading that......or an illiterate journalist.
@@Pluviophile218 I’m not sure which one is worse…..
Pius is not a normal name in English.
I mean, she technically pronounced pius correctly in Latin…
Funny story.
I love St Pius X
I once had an Italian lady come visit me. She said I’m from his town. I said oh, what town is that? I knew he was born in Riese Italy. She said some long crazy Italian word I never heard of. I said he’s not from there! She looked at me like I was on drugs. I said repeat the town again ? She said
Arrriessssa Italy. She said it so long and drawn out it threw me off. I apologized profusely and we laughed a lot.
The evil and greed up and down the ranks in the church is obscene. The targeting of nuns and their monastaries is prolific and outrageous. The "Bishop" who practices gluttony tried to get his greasy fingers on the multimillion dollar monastary and land around it, but the nuns circumvented his greed. He happily smears the Mother Superior in public, but nary a word about who the alleged priest is. Does the priest even exist? No wonder today's youth have moved away from the church. Anyone who supports the "Bishop's" actions is just as heinous as he is.
Interesting that they didn’t dismiss the man who was involved in this situation. Not to mention all the other people employed in the Catholic Church who were involved in far worse criminal acts than never faced prison time for their actions.
The report clearly stated that the priest involved was from outside the diocese. Meaning that the bishop does not have authority over him. Some other bishop would have to do something. I think that’s why.
@@DLTFx yes
Interesting that you think you know everything and should be in charge.
@@DLTFx OP doesn't care, just a passerby that is addicted to rage.
How do you know he wasn't? This particular story doesn't say anything about that at all!
The faces of the nuns show personalities of grace and compassion. One nun turned out to be only human and fell in love with a priest. She confessed. And they are all condemned by that very worldly looking bishop who probably is very uncomfortable with women or anyone who questions himself? I thought forgiveness is offered to the repentant! I think Jesus would side with the nuns.
Crazy! God bless these nuns
Let me get this straight - they broke their vow of chastity, and then joined SSPX? The math isn't mathing.
Had me confused too
Thats what confused me too
Only one nun was accused; the mother superior. But the identity of the associated priest who allegedly broke his vow of chastity with the sickly nun remained protected. Why? We don't know. Most probably it's all been nothing but a staged thing because the fat Bishop wanted to seize their land and SELL it. Why is he trying to do that? Well, just ask him why he's fat and doesn't fast and you'll never get a good answer - what more to expect when questioned about what is he planning to do with the land.
So in protest against their unwilling dismissal from continuing their lives as Carmelite nuns, they decided to join the SSPX. The Catholic Church under the current pope is a mess.
Good idea 👍
Marcel Lefebvre > demon worshippers JP II (Assisi) and Francis (Pachumama etc)
Akita: Bishops vs bishops
But it’s my understanding that the SSPX is not in full communion with the Holy See. Am I wrong? I could be. I’m always confused by this. Plus, why were the other cloistered nuns dismissed.
What would they have done to the woman at the well?
I'm favoured only God knows how much I praise Him, $230k every 4weeks! I now have a big mansion and can now afford anything and also support God’s work and the church.
Only God knows how much grateful i am. After so much struggles I now own a new house and my family is happy once again everything is finally falling into place!!
Wow that's huge, how do you make that much monthly?
I'm 37 and have been looking for ways to be successful, please how??
It's Ms. Evelyn Vera doing, she's changed my life.
I started pretty low, though, $5000 thereabouts. The return came massive. Joey is in school doing well, telling me of new friends he's meeting in school. Thank you Evelyn Vera, you're a miracle.
Stand your ground ladies. The same old male dominance and rightness at play.
Amen
" He who is without sin, cast the first stone".
In today's church, the adulterous woman would have disappeared under a hail of stones.
😒
The problem with that is everyone will be casting stones,to appear innocent.
mom knock it off
That’s not what that verse means.
@@orborn3580 That kind of response is so tiresome. Don't just throw some blanket statement out there. Explain what you mean. Back up your assertion.
I hate that this woman is humiliated publicly for an extremely personal reason the circumstances and validity of which can't be substantiated.
The ignorance of people here.
-The nuns were u see the authority of the bishop. This is part of their religious life and vow.
-the head nun admitted to having broken her vow of Chasity with a priest of another diocese, who has been forced to retire.
- the bishop and other witness that heard her admitting have recordings of their meetings and in no way was the bishop rude, harsh or angry. In fact he showed great remorse.
- the bishop removed her from her position and the head nun agreed. It wasn’t u til afterwards that the nuns refused the bishops judgment.
- the nuns assumed that the bishop wanted their property (which he had no interest and still to this day has no interest in it) and appealed to Rome. Rome replied back saying that the bishop is in the right and they are to submit to his authority.
- the nuns then rejected the Vatican's order and took the bishop to court. The court literally said that this case is not part of their jurisdiction and is a Church matter and dismissed the case.
- the nuns then went into schism (meaning they divorced themselves from the church) and decided to join a group of schismatic “Catholics” called the sspx.
- the Vatican along with the bishop then said that the nuns are dismissed from their religious life and no longer are nuns and now only laity.
So these nuns are 1. No longer Catholic 2. No longer nuns and 3. They did this to themselves. And 4. The bishop doesn’t care about their property
Thank you!
Thank you for this clear summary. In my opinion, their adhereance with SSPX was the nail in the coffin
thanks for clarification, people here are quick to judge with their emotions truly we should hear the full story before speaking, non sense things comes out of our mouth if we write before we think
Great summary, a lot of anti Catholic bias and assumptions by most in these comments that immediately sides with the nuns since they hate the idea of any sort of church authority and bring up unrelated abuses.
One thing to note is that the status of the SSPX is a gray area. Technically the excommunication has been lifted so they are not schismatic but they are considered irregular
@@jbw53191Pretty sure that part about SSPX is malarkey. The SSPX are not schismatic, for one. The SSPX is inside the Catholic Church, has visits from Catholic Cardinals and Bishops, and is friends with several Catholic religious orders, including Traditional Carmelites, Capucins and Dominicans.
There is a breakaway group that is sedevacantist, and they call themselves “ SSPX resistance “.😢
These nuns are judged But, the priests are not. 😢
Who said they weren’t?
Gross, gross and more gross! Shame on the Diocese! I’m in support of the nuns!
So you support schismatics? Breaking of vows?
No one cares
The nun admitted to breaking her vow, what else is there to discuss? I guess you aren't Catholic.
Then you support sin and disobedience. These nuns are wrong, they know what they have done wrong and they have brought trouble upon themselves!
I bet there are people who want to get hold of their property.
The bishop owns all property in his diocese.
Nuns take a vow of
Obedience
Poverty
Chasity
She broke 2/3
that's EXACTLY why the Bishop made waves & trouble w/lies.... no different than Trump the Catholic Candidate and convicted rapist (like priests) & convicted felon 34times - like priests have been, too. same White Supremacy cult
@@PInk77W1 This was specifically given to the nuns to prevent land grabs and sale of property
@@PInk77W1 That fake bishop is abusing his authority.
@@FranKern-j5s
The nuns are civilians
They have nothing to do with the bishop any more. They are free to start their own convent. Bye.
I side with the Nuns.
Cause you are atheist.
if they are schismatic it's a problem
@ I side with the nuns.
@@kylecurryyt
Okay bot
@@Noneomg I still side with the nuns, bot.
Would the Catholic Church do the same for acts of homosexuality?
The bishop who kicked the Franciscan Friars of the renewal out of the poorest neighborhood in Fort Worth strikes again. These allegations were a pretext for property seizure, and I hope this injustice comes to light. Poor sisters. May God vindicate them.
Well, the nun did admit she broke her vow on two occasions and it was a nun who dismissed them, not the bishop.
@@zkeletonz001 The Vatican's appointee was a decision made for the sake of optics, and you repeating this justification explains the rationale. I certainly don't agree with the sisters aligning with SSPX, but their reasons for doing so are hardly a mystery after the way they were treated and a last ditch effort to keep the monastery.
If only the superior,let superior pay the consequence of her action,and not the whole community.
Did I hear this wrong? Nun and priest break vows, bishop dismisses nun, Vatican overturns the bishop, so the bishop dismisses all the nuns?
No. They completely botched the story. They’ve no idea what they’re talking about. “Saint Peeus Ex” bruh really?
Yes That is what this report says. Shameful acts on the Bishop's part!
It's a land grab. It had nothing to do with broken vows. They chose to distract the public with salacious acts to make the unseemly greed more palatable.
Yes, you did hear it wrong.
Look at that bishop….disgraceful
That Bishop looks like he doesn't know that gluttony is one of the seven deadly sins.
You can be fat and not gluttonous
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅
@@harrisonsamsonreally? then how you'd get that body by eating air? you must be a joke that's why ppl lost respect in these Vat.2 bishops cause they don't clearly practice fasting and abstinence...luxury is the enemy of fidelity to church.
@@harrisonsamson Yes, you can. But not THAT fat!
The number of these types of comments on here is troubling...
Priest that molested children were allowed to stay in their positions and they move them to other locations. Punishment for some, but not for all.
One sin is the same
He needs to repent of gluttony! And be fired!
+JMJ Pray for this bishop who is persecuting good and holy nuns.
This type of story is replayed many times across this country. It's about power over women and money and land.
You have no idea what it’s about. And women should obey men. Deus Vult
Nonsense!
Really, like the priesthood has such a stellar record of celibacy.
Or most religious denominations for that matter.
It's a man's world.
Which is why, as a Catholic, I think priests SHOULD be able to marry. There once was a time when they could. It wasn't until the year 1123 that celibacy became a requirement. Prior to that, priests did in fact marry.
Paul literally advises that they be. 1 Timothy 3:2-5, and again in Titus 1:6. I've always wondered why the Catholic Church just pretends those verses don't exist.
@@jadedandbitter 2 Timothy 2:3-4, 1 Corinthians 7:32-35, when you use scripture to interpret scripture, you quickly come to find the catholic church has it right. not to mention diachronic linguistics meaning reading something other than the original transcripts can lead to certain things being lost in translation. dont know why protestants ignore this
Why do I despise organized religion? Here is one of many reasons.
Very strong suspicion about the bishop.
If I lived in Texas, I would be running to mass at the monastery! Did he dismiss the priest??
if all priests/nuns were to be sacked on account of breaking their vow chastity, we will be living in a world without priests and nuns.
Quite obviously, you know nothing whatsoever about priests, nuns, religious live or chastity! The reality is that the vast, vast majority of priests and nuns DO indeed keep their vows of chastity and celibacy, and breaking these vows is dealt with very seriously, as it should be!
Was the priest also dismissed from Catholic religious life? Asking for a friend…
He may not have even been a member of a religious order. And this does not seem to be about braking vows of Chastity, it seems to be about something else, that the nuns will not ask forgiveness for.
He's no longer a priest.
@@KenPaulsenArchitect Technically, he is still a priest, but his faculties were removed, therefore he cannot fulfill the duties, privileges of a priest.
It takes two to tango--who is the other culprit? Silence won't make this right!
Obviously not all details involved have been disclosed. But going by what is known, I suspect these nuns are being gaslighted by church hierarchy. I hope the nuns persist and prevail.
I can't believe how she pronounced the name of pope Pius X.....😂
Catholic priests in charge of judging the morality of others.. ? 🤔
I guess you favor Islamic sharia law?
Yes, yes they are demon.
Yes? Do you think you're making some sort of point?
@@stover14pedo-priesthood never does wrong
This stinks of a land grab.
Even if one nun did this; it doesn't justfy doing that to other nuns. It sounds more like the nuns were in the way of the church taking over the land.
Exactly. They want a quick cash cow
The Fort Worth Seven.
....I support them.
Bishop Sheen stood up at a USCCB conclave in the early '70's and told his fellow bishops that allowing so many gay men into the seminaries was going to result in the greatest catastrophe the Church had ever seen. His fellow bishops roundly hooted him down and laughed it off. But $2,500,000,000 (2.5 Billion dollars) later--that is the amount the U.S. Catholic Church had to pay out in the lawsuits--Sheen was proved right.
child molesters are not gay. They are sexually attracted to children.
So, you're defending this creep with untrue statements? Look into who the #1 children harmer is. Straight men.
PDF != gay. PDFs are attracted to positions where they can use power to get at kids.
Gay priests are not the problem. Gay does not equal paedophile. It's the supposedly " straight " priests that commit those crimes.
That is certainly part of it but not all gays can be detected
At least they weren’t abusing little boys like the priests
Not all priests are abusers. The 1% is really blown up because some will do anything to besmirch the Catholic Church.
Agree 100 percent
More likely to be molested by a public school teacher or by a cop than a priest, but whatever.
Only you do that
They don’t seem to want to defrock priest for sex abuse, these nun are being treated very poorly.
The Vatican and the bishop needs to be relieved of their Catholic duties
That she went outside of the Diocese😂 May each nun enjoy many blessings and prayers for a wonderfully rich new life ❤
This is so very sad. My heart breaks for these carmelite nuns that have dedicated most of their lives to be “dismissed.” Let’s pray Gods will be done.
Amen
Maybe of they didnt break their vows and then go join SSPX (who are in schism with Rome)
Seems quite possible that the bishop actually has a lot to learn about the Love of Christ but is too busy being judgemental and busy fostering schism to do so.
The nuns were the schismatics, but ok
No, the bishop did what he was ordered to do and he gave the nuns every opportunity to cooperate with him. They were disobedient and he had every right to close their monastery and dismiss them!
@LordHarv @thereseklopfenstein3398
I was not there nor spoken with either party directly. I therefore said 'seems' because that is the impression I had from the video. However, I give way to your better knowledge.
@@holyngrace7806 Having been a member of a Carmelite order for five years, yes I do have greater knowledge about this subject than you or most people, and I assure you that the bishop had every right to act the way he did and the Carmelite nuns had no right whatsoever to act in such a disobedient manner!
@@thereseklopfenstein3398 Sister, thank you for bringing qualified information. That is heartening to know. Prayers have been with all concerned as well as their family and friends. The responsibility of leadership, particularly at the Bishop’s level is onerous and lonely at times. Hopefully those who guided the Sisters into this confrontation will find time to reflect and grow.
The entire TX Catholic leadership needs to go. This is just the latest in a long series of aggressive actions that are not supported by the Pope. 🙏
Yeah, I am so sure that progressive Pope Francis would throw his support behind some schismatic SSPX nuns.
@jaykwonzzz while he may not support them his history also indicates he wouldn't have dismissed them. Forgive and repent. Only after much work and no sign of progress does he make those drastic decisions.
@@MorganMghee This is nonsense. Forgiveness doesn't remove consequence. The nun violated her oath, then during attempted removal, the nuns en masse refused the authority of the Vatican. Do you think Pope Francis is above recusing people or excommunicating them for extreme oath-indifference?
@jaykwonzzz his record of public actions are available for your review. They lead me to say what I did.
@@MorganMghee It doesn't matter. Your contention is that somehow Francis would not agree with the notion of laicizing these obstinate nuns is absurd. They're actively schismatizing and one is in absolutely violation of their clerical vows.
Is Bishop Olson guilty of the sin of gluttony? Olson's bustin' out all over!
so they punish the Nuns but not the Priest? Figures
Sad but Good. The nuns have been in broken vows and decided to go into schism because the head nun did not like that the bishop removed her from her position after admitting to her break of Chasity.
There is audio recordings on this. At no time was the bishop harsh or aggressive with the head nun.
I am not privy to all te details. But as I understand the problem was that he had no authority as the Sisters fell directly under Rome's authority. Also the bishop used the law as a means to enforce his will. I cant say who was guilty of what and what happened to the priest if anything.
What ever precisely happened. This was a mess and it's sad that it occurred.
People are too eager to criticize the Church to actually understand what took place.
@@cosmicnomad8575 people usually copy paste their views on a situation.
Total BS i smell a rat here. You will know a tree by its fruits. Prayers for these victims
I am a Catholic in North Texas. I side with the nuns.
You shouldn’t. They vowed to follow the vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience, and they broke some of their vows. What is happening is completely just.
Reprehensible.
It’s only one diocese. “Dioceses” is the plural. I notice newsreaders keep saying “dioceses” for the singular “diocese”. Could somebody please tell them?
God please these pious women! God bless the SSPX!
Better a Priest and a nun rather than a Priest and a little boy besides Priests are supposed to immolate the Apostol's and while there is scripture that says they were all virgins most of them were married with children so the "they were virgins" means something else The Catholics should have realized this centuries ago and allowed both Priests and nuns to marry and raise kids.
What is particularly unfair is when a married clergyman from another denomination converts to Catholicism, he is allowed to remain married. This happened at the University of St. Thomas in Houston when I was a student there in the late 1980s. There was a married priest on staff who had been ordained in the Episcopalian church then converted to Catholicism and became a Catholic priest while married with a family.
Sex abuse rates among public school teachers are much higher, and most of them are married. Removing Priestly celibacy as a discipline does nothing at all to fix these problems.
@@unoriginalclips9923 BS
I cannot wait until the Netflix movie version
Oh my so not ok for woman to do that as the men have been doing this for years…
They never punish priests...but look how swiftly they kick women to the curb ... Ijc
Thank God for the SSPX. Thank God for Marcel Lefebvre. I will pray for these sisters.
Amen.
Olsen needs to address the sin of GLUTTONY
This is exactly what happened in 1517! Outrageous
What happened in 1517?
@isaiah3872 in 1517 Martin Luther nailed his 95 complaints to the door of the Vatican. The result ultimately was the splitting of the Catholic Church. Ok, so this situation is not EXACTLY the same, but ..
@@isaiah3872 An angry German heretic went rogue and created the “Lutheran” sect we know and love today.
@@jmenter1
But it is about dissent and over abuse of power .
And God protected (via a German Prince, by which Luther was given a trial the Prince sat in and had a say about it's outcome) and preserved Martin Luther and the church he founded.
Back when the "Church" normally just arrested a dissenter and burned them at the stake.
Like one man who defied them and they never caught him, but after he died, the "Church" dug his remains up and burned them at the stake.
🤔😳🙄
Now the Catholic Church begun under "saint" John Paul II , has come to a "pact" with the Lutherans.
Actually, what hubris to write "Luminous mysteries" to add to the rosary believed to have been given to us by the Virgen Mary complete with the mysteries.
So, he places himself as an equal to Mary?
Or infers her rosary was imperfect without his mysteries? And yet he's the fastest saint on record of the modern church?
Something seems amiss.😢
A “ family “ divided against itself cannot stand.
Hello@Helen
How are you doing 😊
Where are you from?
Notice the very high forgiveness of priests who are pedophiles, but nuns don’t receive similar?
I was mol lested by a priest when I was a child. I told my mother who slapped my face telling me a man of god would never do such a thing, then she sent me right back to him. I'm 70 years old and that still has impact on my life. Disgusting how hypocritical the church is still. Have your faith without the religion, you'll be better off. I applaud these nuns.
I’m so sorry that you were betrayed by your mother and that priest.😢
@@granmabern5283 thank you
Parents of children like you who were abused by priests should be legally punished too. It was their blindness about the church and priests that allowed their children to be in a position of being groomed and molested by those priests.
I am so sorry for what happened to you . I was also sexually abused by a man who worked for my parents and this individual robbed me of the person I should have been. Continue to be strong.
@@fatsilver5905 It did cost a bond with my parents and me for the rest of their lives. As a child you know if you have a safe person to go to, to protect you or not. That she sent me back to the abuser because he was a priest cemented in my mind that my mother would do what ever she could to assure her eternity in heaven, even serving your child up to a molester.
Fat cat bishop punishes the woman, but the priest still gets to remain in the game. Talk about double standard !!! Shame!
Listen again. The nun in charge punished the women.
Hey, learn how catholic hierarchy works before commenting. It was stated that the priest was from a different diocese. That means, that this bishop has 0 authority over him.
@LordHarv I am a survivor of Catholic hierarchy. Back in the day, mother and father met at a vocation conference. Then they continued meeting clandestinely, and 9 months later, I made the scene. The story is both sad and shocking because back in the '50's this was taboo. Mother was a teaching sister who gave up her vocation, while Father kept his vocation as a parish priest, both from different dioceses. For 4 days of the week he was dad, and for the other 3, he was Father leading a double life. Mother paid the ultimate price while I Iived in the shadows. For a child, this tends to be confusing. I knew that I was loved, but I was never mentioned in social circles; it served to make me stronger as a human being.
@JoeCezus then take that up with the bishop, since hes the one who has control over the priest. The priest in this case is not under this bishop's diocese, and thus has no authority over him.
Cool life story.
Too bad it's not relevant.
@@JoeCezus wow! Thanks for sharing .
Question, what happened to the Priest? I hope he was dismissed too.
Thank you John Paul II and Benedict for this continuing absurdity in the Roman Catholic Church.
Misogyny, and the Catholic Church, shame on you Bishop.
Go Sisters!
this priest should be let go.
Such misogyny of the male hierarchy is the biggest reason why so many of us former catholic women are no longer members of this cult.
The bishop of Fort Worth has treated these nuns shamefully! He will one day have to stand before God to explain his behavior. Let those of us without sin cast the first. We have all fallen short in one way or another.
Let the one who is without sin, cast the first stone.
Blaming the victim. What else can you expect by a medieval institution?!
.And the gates of hell will not hold out against it...
Who's the victim?
Who's the victim? There were no allegations of assault, but of consensual relations between two adults, who voluntarily discerned & vowed to live celibately for a purpose.
Actually dates back to 33AD.
Bro listen to the tapes she admits to freely engaging with the priest, you’re just biased
WHY the entire group, and WHERE is the priest? It takes two ~
The priest is IN A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT DIOCESE. Maybe listen next time you dingus.
@@LordHarv
Dodges the question with a non-answer.
@@MaricellaDunn that's not dodging the question with a "non answer" the story is about these nuns who are under the authority of this bishop. The priest who was also acting inappropriately, is irrelevant to what is going on between the bishop and these nuns, and also under the authority of a different bishop.
Do keep up.
Nuns with the hardest album cover of the century
Ok that was funny. 🤭
“Straight Outta Carmel.” Seriously though, I am praying for them to be guided by the Holy Spirit on to a sustainable life path after this debacle. There has got to be a lot more to this story than most of us know.
Incredible there is a mispronunciation. Pius X is Pius the 10th. X is a Roman numeral
Breaking the vow of chastity is NOT a ground fro dismissal from religious life when it has happened consensually and in secret. There should be something more than that that is not being said.
Where is the priest? Does he exist? The heinous "Bishop" tried a landgrab.
Left the catholic church almost 40 yrs ago. No regrets
Good for you!
Ah you let the devil stray you away from Jesus with his deceit and lies.. Away from Jesus’s teachings and His true church. Catholicism is a personal relationship through the Bible and the holy sacraments with God. NOT an emphasis on man or their wrong doings. Prayers🙏
He didn't say he was led away from Jesus. I could only find Jesus by walking away from corrupt religion. The devil hides within religion seeking to divide us when we are all part of everyone and everything. Monica, I do believe that one day you will find the true way. Peace be with you.
Do not err, my brethren. If any man follows him that makes a schism in the Church, he shall not inherit the kingdom of God. If any one walks according to a strange opinion, he agrees not with the passion [of Christ.].
(From the Letters of St. Ignatius of Antioch, Epistle to the Philadelphians)
@@unoriginalclips9923
St Ignatius was still not Jesus.
All who are saved by faith in Jesus Christ are Saints in heaven.
Remember Jesus said to be first, you must be last.
Also, at one time in history, there were multiple popes. Also, on the Bible scriptures, there are leaders and Bishops but no Popes.
The line of succession from Peter was broken long ago .
Didn't he record her giving confession!?
It wasn’t the sacrament of Confession; it was just a discussion.
@@Antonia_D Thank you for clarifying that. So why would he record her in the first place? it seems really concerning to be fishing for evidence to use against her, like he had the motive to be vindictive.
@@daughterofchrist1775 I don't know much about this, but I **think** it was a mutually agreed on recording for the sake of having a record of the discussion.
May God bless and guide you and your loved ones. +JMJ+
@@Antonia_D Thank you for the update. I think that you are right about this, as I think I read this a while back. Thank you for the blessings. May God bless you richly for your generosity and kindness. Amen
@daughterofchrist1775 Thank you so much. You are very kind! :)
One small detail. The Society of St. Pius X is read "Saint Pius the 10th." An interesting choice for the Sisters, as it's a canonically irregular fraternity that is at odds with the Vatican on numerous key issues.
SSPX is 50 yrs old and has had 8 internal schisms, so one every 6 years.
But considering it is one of the only places that's not influenced by Rome's control especially in this time, the faithful have and out were there otherwise was none.
And Father Robinson in Ridgefield Connecticut of the SSPX is initiating a Carmelite Third Order.
AMDG!
@@mts0628 8 internal schisms in 50 years.
My ears perked up when I heard that they were involved with Saint Pius X. I thought, THERE'S the problem.
What does the monastery have to do as a whole with this one nun and priest who broke their chastity vows? They should revert to lay lives. Leave the monastery alone.
Does the priest even exist? She is smeared, but the priest has yet to be identified. A ploy to wrestle the multimillion dollar monastary and land around it from the nuns' hands.
Jesus please forgive 🙏 us weak sinners ✝️🛐
One of the nuns broke her vows but all of them are dismissed? I don't understand this. What about the priest? Something isn' t right about this.
They all backed the bad nun and brought this on themselves
That is not the issue, sadly the Bishop said things he shouldn't have.
IOIYAP: It's OK if your a priest.😊
NO ONE BROKE VOWS. it was accusations alone as far as i have heard. i live close by & have visited there.
@@LAFITZ10
I heard she admitted it to the bishop.