GTA 3 - PS2 vs. Xbox | Side by Side
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 сен 2024
- Side by side comparison between the Playstation 2 and Xbox OG versions of Grand Theft Auto III. The PS2 was emulated and the Xbox version was played on Xbox 360 backwards compatibility. Trails was disabled on both versions.
Support the channel: www.patreon.com/neogamertvga
ko-fi.com/neogamer
Putting almost every other difference aside, the nicest thing on Xbox was the addition of actual skeletal meshes, no more lego arms and legs, also the improved character lighting was nice.
Anti-aliasing too. Looks like they applied some MSAA.
Would you recommend the original Xbox as the best way to play?
4:25 Xbox fingers look beautiful
0:46 it’s interesting seeing the subtle changes between the two versions, like the clothing and accessories and more poly count on Xbox.
GTA Vice City on XBOX looks even better than pc, not sure about this one, but I am guessing this does too
Yup, i've been drinking again
GTA 3 on PS2 was still a very rough half-finished game. The RenderWare engine was no wonder. In GTA SA for PS2, for example, you can already see reflections on the cars like the Xbox had in GTA 3, or the characters have all their fingers modeled on PS2, etc. etc. etc. etc.
And I have absolutely no doubt that the PS2 code can be rewritten today so that the game runs at 30 fps very stably.
OG XBOX wins by far. At 8:40 it looks ike it has a green filter
That shadows on xbox is possible on ps2 and PC, only need to look in timecycle and change shadow settings
In Console versions some of objects have physics but in pc it is static
PS2 топ. А так видна конечно разница выхода, целых два года между платформами Xbox PS2. Октябрь 2003, октябрь 2001. Даже на ПК уже более менее наигрались в неё , на момент октября 2003. Через год уже должна выходить ГТА Сан Андреас.
Xemu is very viable for og Xbox emulation now I think including for GTA games at least some of them
xbox all day long. Well at least then.
It even supports custom soundtrack (can’t use it while playing on 360 BC)
While the ps2 had better lighting the xbox had better graphics! Playing this Rn on my OG modded xbox with a Hdmi adapter on my Hd tv and the graphics are great. We grew up in a time where the systems we played had great potential we iust had old technology. 3 composite cables and old fat tvs. Really ruined these games as a kid and made you think ehhh the games ok but when you get a old system now and throw a Hd adapter and Hd tv everything changes for the better
theres just something about the ps2 version, the colors are more vibrant, pallets match the mood of the game, yes the xbox version is better graphically but i think it wasnt utilized properly, like the game was too dark in some areas, the shadows tried to be realistic but just ended up making the game look weird, the rain effects were nice but can be annoying at times, would have been better if they used the droplets for when you got shot imo, and i remember on the xbox version there were some really bad glitches like when trying to stomp someone on the ground it just didnt work sometimes even after they were dead, on ps2 you could keep stomping.
Xbox is overall better BUT any version after the original PS2 print had some small changes (dialogue, music etc). So.. PS2 purely for playing the unchanged version.
PS2 has better colors
Gotta make up for art direction/visual style in what you lack in visual fidelity.
Agreed, the PS2 version is honestly my favorite version in terms of its color design and lighting.
@@acjayc for me the art style is always more inoortant than realistic graphics, always.
It depends, at 3:50 colors look better on XBOX
I think it's literally the Xbox 1.0-1.4 graphic's encoder, it desaturates everything, and the 360 emulates this. The Excalibur 1.5-1.6 Xbox would have colours on par with PS2 I feel.
Xbox seems like colour good
Xbox version looks unnatural
Exactly, much darker compared to PS2 version, which looks so colorful.
Would like to know why. And it’s not the only game, I bet, that looks much nicer on PS2 than on Xbox.
@@janklimek9972 The xbox had issues with porting games from the ps2 if you look at any port from ps2 to xbox the game will be darker or more washed out on xbox no in-betweens. I'm guessing something about porting to xbox was rigid and not very flexible. Same thing for the aspect ratio every game ported from ps2 to xbox has an incorrect aspect ratio on xbox either being squished or stretched and considering most multiplatform games where made on ps2 first and then ported over to xbox its a common issue with xbox version of games.
@@untested3344 Oh I see, that's interesting, also pitiful how it went, but thank you for your explanation.
So I guess it is also due to the Xbox different architecture back in time.
It also seems like when PS3 vs X360 era started, it was the other way around - games looking better and were also better optimized on X360 than on PS3, but that was given by the fact that PS3 had very complex architecture, perhaps even more than the original Xbox. So better porting on both systems simultaneously or there are bigger problems, if ported on PS3 later. Although some versions for PS3 already had some issues, mostly it was the framerate. I owned PS3 Slim, as a teen. Then Xbox One S, and lately was gifted by PS3 Slim again, by an ex friend. But can tell which titles had and have issues on this system.
Thanks again for your reply.
@@janklimek9972 Honestly I think it just had to do with popularities of the ps2 as to why most games of the time where designed for ps2. Which is why most games of this times always used high filtrate things because it was the one thing ps2 was better at then xbox. If you look at the rain in the gta games you'll see its downgraded on the xbox version along with other fillrate heavy things being downgraded on the xbox version.
Cool
Xbox over the top!
If hang.
PS2 FTW 🙌
There’s no doubt about the winner here - PS2.
Xbox version looks darker and colorless.
Is this trolling?
@@JV-ll1cu Haha, why? I just said my own opinion, and it is so evident that the Xbox version is washed out, bro.