Amphoreus feels strange WITHOUT March 7th in the story | Honkai Star Rail Discussion
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 фев 2025
- My name is ManCarSua also known as Manny
I like to play Honkai Star Rail and Genshin Impact. I also like to theorize about dumb things in game or in general
I am still recovering a bit my voice, but I still wanted to make a video about some of my thoughts about Amphoreus and why I like and disliked certain parts of it. The fact March 7th is not present does not mean the story is bad, it is just a small detail that I miss, so I wanted to talk about it
Amphoreus feels strange WITHOUT March 7th in the story | Honkai Star Rail Discussion
Follow my socials:
Follow me on TWITTER: / mancarsua
Watch me live on TWITCH: / mancarsua
Follow me on TIKTOK: / mancarsua
Chat with us on DISCORD: / discord
Support me on KOFI: ko-fi.com/manc...
Yanqing Abundance Theory: / discord
(A pretty neat theory, I would have doubted at first honestly, but after the small details Hoyo left back in 1.0 about Opal and Legwork, with enough evidence I will put my tinfoil hat and overanalyze it)
abundanceyanqi...
Timestamps:
0:00 - Intro
1:50 - The sense of familiarity
4:19 - Lack of Voiceovers (for English, playing in another language was nice)
7:00 - March 7th is technically our guide
9:53 - Final Thoughts, Small Update, and Thank You all for your support!
ALGORITHM SHENANIGANS HERE:
March 7th rememberance
Mem
Star Rail Rememberance Trailblazer
Black Swan Amphoreus
Sunday Amphoreus
Star Rail
Honkai Star Rail
mancarsua
#hsr #honkaistarrail #starrail #kafka #sampo #loucha #silverwolf #fuxuan #lynx #imbibitorlunae #argenti #hanya #fuxuan #huohuo #memoryofchaos #huohuo #drratio #ruanmei #xueyi #swarm disaster #blackswan #sparkle #misha #aventurine #acheron #gallagher #robin #sunday #boothill #constance #ifrit #seele #jingyuan #rappa #sunday #fugue #mydei #tribbie #phainon #anaxa #hyacine #castorice #cipher #aglaea #theherta
I think it’s pretty safe to say that whenever March DOES return to the main story, she’ll end up getting her answer to Imbibitor Lunae, and be a Remembrance character at that.
Oh yeah 100%, it is something I am looking forward to in the future of the Amphoreus story line! I hope we can see her aiding the party in new ways as well!
If the update had all the lines voiced upon release I think Dan Heng would have done well enough. Of course I could to with less "Mem mem memememememememe"
Oh absolutely, Dan Heng was honestly a really solid pick for the Amphoreus adventure because of his character, and he has been missed for so long after being away during the first half of the Loufu and Penacony. I am glad he returned for the War Dance storyline
As a whole, having Dan Heng with us was great, and listening to the JP voicelines when rewatching it made it feel a lot better, to fill in for Stelle/Caelus and Dan Heng's voices. That said, I much prefer "Mem mem memememememe" over a super high pitch voice that could become annoying. I prefer gibberish over actual voices for characters like Mem (But I get how it can get annoying pretty easily)
And if he wasn't somewhere else for 3/4 of the time for no reason.
I'm very glad they're going to improve the general presentation of the cutscenes, like lessing/removing the black screen narration. I do agree with you that March's absence for Amphoreus so far feels very intentional. We're so used to having her around and be silly and happy, that having her get sick and not come with us for once really does a good job immediately setting the pretty downer tone for this storyline. Looking forward to seeing how they implement March into the storyline at some point in later patches
Yeah absolutely, the fact that they are taking the step forward to give us these quality of life updates is great. I do love that they also mentioned how they wanted to revive characters that were old back into the meta, so I'll be eager to see what they do with Seele (And hopefully Silverwolf, if they can give her the AoE ult they gave her in that one flashback with the stellarons I'll be happy)
March getting sick and not coming with us made me so sad aaaaa ;-; Especially because of how happy she was literally moments before.
So hoyo actually made a good story? Because march's absence is supposed to be felt, this emptiness is what drives amphoreus
Yesss. I do feel like March has been a wonderful elementfor the game. So with her not being in Amphoreus it really hit how severe things are and shows how well they treat her character!
The main problem(for me at least) is Dan Heng has no voice lines. He's got 400+ lines but is completely silent. In english at least. I don''t think either of the MCs have any voices either. It kind of makes them feel like NPCs since all of the Amphoreus characters speak while we don't. The overall atmosphere also feels different because March's personality is much more bubbly and outgoing compared to Dan Heng who's more level headed and stoic. The lack of voices really made their difference in personality stand out more
VA strike is why he's not voiced
Yeah the with him and the trailblazer not being it did affected the story for the English side of things. That's why I was playing in English but also watching the story in another game's Language (KR or JP depending on how I was feeling that day). I hope we can get them back, I miss Rachel Chau and Nicholas Leung's voices in this story. And yes without March's bubbly and happy personality it really did the atmosphere of Amphoreus sink in properly as this darker story line, especially given how sick she got. I feel like putting in her in danger also did make the stakes higher of us
Edit: I did appreciate from the text that was supposed to be voiced that despite March not being there, Dan Heng still was there trying to bring in some cheery moods and cared for the photos. (Even if him being happy didn't hit because of the lack of voice lines). Which also reminds me, that one scene where he puts the camera in the Scale of Tantalon really made me happy. So I wish that ONE scene had been voiced aaa ;-;
@@DarkSeraph Yeah I knew that already which is understandable. Kind of annoying though that some of the VAs are able to work but are choosing not to 🤷
@GhostDraggon_ I wouldn't want to work for a company that wants to replace me AI after all of the work I did for them so I get it.
I personally really like March 7th, and I feel the lack of her too :(
But considering what happened to her during the story, I think she will return, maybe even with a new form like Dan Heng? Since Dan Heng didn't go to the Luofu at first, just like March with Amphoreus, while these regions associate with these characters.
I also wanted to mention that I'm glad they did March 7th a lot better than Paimon. She feels like a companion, not like the voice of the MC.
And I miss the og trio Dan Heng, March 7th, and Trailblazer :( they had so funny interactions, I need them to come back...
Have a great day!!! I hope your voice recovers soon!
I knew from the start of the game I'd like March, but not to this extent. The way the writers brought up her up into the game in general really made an amazing impression for me honestly and I have adored her at every moment since. I do hope she returns and aids Dan Heng in sort of way, since we already got the Rememberance powers (So early honestly). I want for him to get the spotlight in the future patch. Also because I wish we had seen more of him in the Wardance, but understandably it was the THE march 7th story line with her masters to grow and develop all 3 of them
I will never not bash paimon with how good of a guide they made March, because while Paimon also is oblivious of the world, her general voicelines were just so rough at many times, I like Corina Boettger's work on her, but not Paimon herself (I am STILL salty about the Furina story quest and how mean the traveler and Paimon are to her ;-; ). And yeah the fact Paimon is our voice rather than a companion hits
One day we will get the original trio back. I really wish that when we return to the Xianzhou again we can have Dan Heng in his Imibitor Lunae Form, March in Hunt, and us with whatever Hunt powers we get, just to show a bit of the growth of the story. Like having them remember belobog and comment on how different they look now after years of traveling together and growing
And thank youuuu. I been healing well and I hope you have a great day!
as a Dan Heng IL main the Dan Heng lines being missing didnt really affect me much because his voice is so ingrained into my mind that my brain just did the voiceover itself lmao
LITERALLY ME TOO. I hear Dan Heng IL's voice often when I help a friend clear content for the end game, so I started getting used to his voice and tried replicating it in my mind (It was just hard during the auto voiced moments when like, you are actively moving and characters talk about something)
Yeah it lacks the energy that March gives to us, maybe it gets to a point that March actually joins us as a stronger form, that's my theory anyways
So remember how people used to joke that TB got preservation path by getting stabbed and so did Dan Heng IL? I'm starting to think March is now suffering cause she got a pain-free path change and her costume finally became a thing. She going through Karma like Xiao or some shit...
I really hope so honestly
@SonnyFRST LMAOOOOO NOOOO not the suffering for being so pain free until moment
MARCH VIDEO MARCH VIDEO MARCH VIDEO MARCH VIDEO
We love March 7th in this household
i feel like they did this on purpose. Have march with us in every planet and then when Amphoreus comes, she's "sick". I think she has a greater role in Amphoreus because it relates to her. and her absence is just the build-up to that.
You have a great reafing voice! reading the lore is great because that makes the videos timeless, people will come back to them for reference! looking forward to the next series!🌺
AAAA Thank you! I appreciate hearing that. I have been wanting to improve so I signed up to some voice actor classes during my free time while in college, and I hope to eventually be bringing those skills into the videos too! Thank you so much for the support and kind words!
So excited for remembrance march
I really hope we get Rememberance March and they have a Memosprite that is as happy and energetic as her! :D
I need that image of Mythus 👍
I edited with GIMP honestly, just added him and grabbed the thumbs up from the praise of high morale lmaooo. I can make it into a proper png and post on my community if you want it!
3:57 Exodia curio activated 😎
Exodia Curio is the best Curio
You fiend, I wanted to see the results summary screen.
Final results were:
3 Weighted Curios:
- Most Racous
- Prayer to Comets
- Dignity and Passion
118 Blessings
81 Curios
In Insight Mode
48963 Cosmic Fragments
I will add the the summary screen of this run at the end of the next video I make just for you
tbh i'm glad she's not around. She feels more like the mc than your own character does and that's always bothered me. I dislike march for much the same reasons I dislike paimon. I would like the mc to talk and make decisions. got a whole VA for nothing basically
For this particular story, I am glad she isn't around because of how much darker the storyline, that being said. I don't find March to be annoying like Paimon. Paimon feels forced to be the voice of the Traveler. But at least March actually replies and responds to us rather than just parrot what we say. To me she feels more like a character and one that I enjoy at that. But I do get what you mean to an extent, I do wish for the Travelers and Trailblazers to speak more
Huuuge fan too :D
Greek Mythology is so freaking cool literally!
💙🫂
🫂
Play with KR voice and you’ll change your mind on March7 😂
Don’t worry, she’ll probably play a huge role coming up
Honestly fair, the thing that throws me off about the KR voice of March 7th is that she shares the voice actress with Diona from Genshin if I recall correctly(?) And I used to play Genshin with that voice pack from time to time (I like how Yoimiya sounded in it). So hearing March as Diona just breaks me aaaaaa
And absolutely, something is being built up for March for one of the future patches, and I am all for it! So I am hyped to see what will she do in the story line, and how Black Swan, Sunday and Herta will help her in her current state