Should independent India honour the soldiers of British Indian Army? | Live Debate
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 фев 2022
- ABOUT US
We believe transformation begins with dialogue. Since inception we have hosted over 200 scholars, authors, policy makers, diplomats, entrepreneurs, journalists and social activists over 100+ eye-opening discussions. Our goal is to revive the traditions of critical inquiry and logical reasoning as described in the Nyaya-sútra, the ancient Indian treatise on the art of debating. With this we hope to resurrect facts and reason into increasingly rhetoric-dominated contemporary Indian discourse. Please show your support by Subscribing to our channel and help us reach a wider audience to make a difference.
SPEAKERS
Lt. General Ajay Kumar Singh
PVSM, AVSM, SM, VSM (Retd.), former Commander in Chief of Southern Command of Indian Army, 11th Lieutenant Governor of Andaman and Nicobar Islands and currently Advisor to O.P. Jindal Global University (JGU).
Shrabani Basu
Journalist and Author of many critically acclaimed books including For King and Another Country: Indian Soldiers on the Western Front 1914-18 and Victoria & Abdul: The True Story of the Queen’s Closest Confidant, and Spy Princess: The Life of Noor Inayat Khan. Shrabani is a frequent commentator on Indian history on British television and radio and has appeared in several BBC documentaries on the subject of Empire.
Dr. Indivar Kamtekar
Associate Professor of Modern History at the Centre for Historical Studies of the Jawaharlal Nehru University. He is the Modern History editor of the journal Studies in History. He has been a member of the Indian Historical Records Commission, and of the editorial board of the journal Modern Asian Studies. He is also the co-author of the book History in the Making: The Visual Archives of Kulwant Roy.
SYNOPSIS
1.5 million Indian soldiers fought in the trenches of #WorldWar I and just two decades later 2.5 million Indians enthusiastically joined the fight against #fascism by enrolling themselves in what would become the largest all-voluntary armed force in #history. These courageous men travelled to distant lands to fight in inhospitable terrains, knowing fully well that they may never return home. And many did not. While no precise count exists, over 160,000 Indian soldiers are estimated to have died in the two world wars. Many more were wounded.
If it were any other nation, such bravehearts would be immortalised forever and revered as national heroes. But in India their memories are conflicted. Their chivalry is not open to question, but their motivation to fight under the banner of the colonial government makes them unlikely heroes for a nation that has been shaped by and still draws its identity largely from its freedom struggle against the same #colonial government.
How does one reconcile with the fact that these soldiers through their devoted services and unbending loyalty were further strengthening a foreign power that was subjugating and exploiting their countrymen? #Britain never had a large contingent in India. It was the Indian soldiers of the #BritishIndianArmy who ensured that no native ruler in India could challenge the British authority. After securing indisputable hegemony for Britain over all of India, they helped it extend its power over our neighbours from Afghanistan to Burma. Sure the Indian soldiers fought valiantly in the world wars, but the people they fought in places extending from Egypt to Malaysia bore no ill-will towards Indians. They were not India’s enemies.
We laud the mutineers of #1857 as India’s first independence heroes, then how can we also commemorate those who chose the #EastIndiaCompany over India and enabled it to defeat these mutineers and brutally crush India’s first rebellion for independence. Similarly, we cannot simultaneously valorise the Indian National Army led by Subhash Chandra #Bose and also those who defeated it so that India continued to remain firmly under the yoke of British tyranny.
However, soldiers fight for the government of the day. All over the world, good soldiers are expected to follow the orders, and not question the motives behind them. The political situation and societal values have considerably changed since the days of the British Indian Army. Is it fair for us to apply our contemporary lens and discredit the sacrifices of these brave Indian men?
EXPLORE MORE
You may also like to check out ‘Was India’s Partition Inevitable? | Live Debate’ at • Was India's Partition ...
Find out about upcoming sessions at www.argumentativeindians.com
DISCLAIMER
We invite thought leaders from across the ideological spectrum. The guests in our sessions express their independent views and opinions. Argumentative Indians does not profess to subscribe, agree or endorse the same or be in anyway responsible for the stance, words and comments of our guests.
Very interesting
It was a real pleasure to moderate this discussion.
I agree with Dr Kamtekar
Much-needed discussion.
Nice to see Kamtekar Sir and Sharbani Di as panelists to this significant and timely discussion. 👍
Really insightful session!
Interesting subject
Soldiers must be honoured
I don’t buy the “hold the leaders, not the followers responsible” argument totally, though I will accept it partially. It assumes a level of stupidity or naivete of the masses which is not the Indian way.
What are the stories we learn? Yudhishthira asks every soldier in the Kurukshetra to take sides as per their own conscience. Yuyutsu switches sides because he believes that is his duty. Dharma or duty is always that of an individual and not subject to someone else telling you what to do. At its core, Indian philosophy holds the individual at its core, which gives you both strength to do your duty and responsibility if you don’t.
39:19 sir there was a Jewish soldier in WW2 in indian army who want to fought against Nazis
But Indira sir , rajputs gave pension in the form of jagir