Видео

Prof Anamika!!!

How do you explain that there has never been any famines in independent India? How do you explain that there were hardly any famines in India in the 1000 years before the British?

Why yogini are bad?

Everything is good and fine, but a discussion on Indian language is going on and no importance is given to the way caption is written in Odia and we are talking about underdog languages.

The Indus Valley Civilization ended/relocated in 1900 bc. The Vedic Aryan culture appears in 100AD with the enforcement of endogamy varna jati system on a freely, extensively mixing ANI population. Pl. Google 'caste no bar' by anupriya

In 500 years everything changed. India had new gods before only Shiva and Mother Goddess and a tree. language changed like writing in Sanskrit before its Harappa script. Eating habits changed introducing brahmin and vegetarian If it's continuous why has everything changed???? Some tribes from the West changed everything maybe they are Refugees from the West because of the Yamanaya Tribe

I’m watching the replacement with my very own eyes

41:15 We humans don’t like it when others sometimes question us about our actions so who are humans to question GOD's actions? Personal sovereignty is the best knowledge otherwise you can go absolutely MAD. Thank both of you for such a beautiful and enlightened exchange of dialogue. JAI MAA KALI🙏

The nomadic Steppe pastoralist cattle herders ( low caste Shudras) arrived in 1500bc, mixed and merged with the native AASI to create the ANI wth Steppe ancestry until 100AD. The Vedic Aryan culture (different from the Steppe influenced ANI culture) arrived and introduced Endogamy in 100AD practise to prevent the Vedic Aryans from mixing with the extensively mixed native ANI population

The indigenous urban IVC fron 2600bc to 1900 bc ended relocated to the east and south india. See the 'great bath' of mohun ja daro replicated in the rural temple ponds/tanks all over tamil nadu, south india.

Narasimhi, varahi are the powers of vishnu avatars not counter parts. In general counterparts as lakshmi only for physical worship , my opinion.

Both Beauty with Brains

Saraswati is evidently a non existant river of mythological significance. The attempt to associate the saraswati with the IVC appears to mislead Archeology and history. The Steppe people were cattle herders not the religious class who appear in 100Ad along with chariots related narratives, Endogamy, the caste system ,segregation when the population was extensively mixed and distinguighable.now known as ANI.

मेंधातिथि Medhathithi

Excellent topic and discussion. It would have been even better if the interviewer had been a little more prepared with the topic - but a good one.

Sati was not an isolated incident for Raja Rammohan Roy who witnessed the wailing of his own sister-in-law forced to die on the pyre and could not stop it as a young boy. Raja also denounced caste system.The 1829 ban on Sati was challenged by a petition signed by "several thousand... Hindoo inhabitants of Bihar, Bengal, Orissa" (wikipedia). 25 yrs later Vidyasagar fought for widow remarriage, abolition of polygamy, child marriage and female education to raise the status of women & widow.

'Meluha' or 'mel loka' means ' top world' in tamil and other south indian languages

The Saraswati is a non existent mystical river with Vedic reference. The gaggar hakra is a seasonal monsoon fed river that is part of the Indus river system.along with over 2000 other city sites. Science, Archeology and Genetic are the relevant evidence.

Don't steal the Tamil culture Aryan was nomads shame upon you

nomadic pastorolist, cattle herders on the move, a new landscape each day. In due course all horizons and all new feature look the Same.

PGW is of Steope irigins. The harappab pottery would be black and red pottery.

The Indigenous, urban harappan civilization and the rural Vedic Culture are distinctly seperate in time, histories and origins . One is not similar or a continuation if the other.

The harappan Civilization with 5 million unhabitants wound up in 1900bc and evacuated the valley. Further they migrated east and south and.in due course mixed with native hunter gatherers and bwcame the ASI Male biased rural Steppe pastoralist migrated into the indo gangetic plain on horseback in 1500bc. The male biased groups entered the plains and mixed with native hunter gatherers to be known as the ANI the PGW

I think the host should have been more patient & disciplined. He's constantly interrupting sir irfan habib when he's at the middle of his talking.

You know why almost evey other nation copied startups and business models from the western world because the industrial revolution had started in the west so western countries were the first to invent something new and rest of the world applied the technology for their benefits

Brother If you want real history of Ashok please you read Samart ashok ka sai ithas which was written by rajendra Prasad singh.and you read his INSCRIPTIONS.We not got ashok 84000inscripitions. Fir that we can't say about ashok

Extremely interesting and insightful

To quote our great current national hero “button khula hai aapka “ to the host😂

I think Kanisetti is less history and more his own personal opinion. Don't need your opinion. He likes to hog airtime, it seems. That religious violence was endemic to India is well known, but when Kanisetti tries to use it to justify Islamic religious violence, it comes across as biased.

The Steppe ancestry appears on the Indus Valley landscape only after 1500bc. So all cultural and linguitic actvity will have reference to a period only post 1500bc. The IVC dissppeared in 1900bc. No human remains found to suggest an invasion So, the IVC was evacuated safely and it appears they migrated east and south -mixed with the native hunter gatherers and became the ASI

I appreciate your ideas Mr. Nilkantan. New to me and may I say forced me to think afresh! But I really appreciate the lady much more. She tried to cope up with the subject and try to extract more out of you.

Harbans mukhiya is a Bastasrx snd najayaz aulad of mughal

adolf hitler = Winston Leonard Spencer Churchill

The great Bath replicated in temple ponds/tanks in tamil nadu. Jallikatu history in thr Indus Mukopadyays analysis of the lamguage. Pi pilu pallu for ivory.teeth etc.

It appears the Indus Valley was entirely abandoned in 1900bc as a strategic response to an imminent invasion by warring horseriding Andrenova/Sintashta/Steppe cultures. The unexpected evacuation preempted the invasion. Subsequently the IVC it seems continued east and South of India mixing with the native hunter gatherers and becoming the ASI. The IVC lay abandoned for 400 years until pastorolist from Europe and Central Asia settled the valley bringing new language religion and the Vedic age. Other male biased groups it appears❤moved into the indo gangetic plain and mixed with the native hunter gatherers giving origins to the AN.

Irfan is a fraud historian as his father planted by Nehru to whitewash the genocides by Moghuls invaders.

This was not a debate on the intricacies and philosophy of history but a bitter political debate. Each trying to press on the other, what history is and should be. Could not have a better show on occupational closure.

This discussion takes it for granted that the oddly assembled bits of geographical area left behind by the British is somehow a nation. Compare it to Europe. Norway and Italy have more in common than do Gujarat and Maharashtra. Europe has cultural unity, and is not a nation but a civilization. So is India. Nation is at best, to use Anderson's phrase, an imagined community. Language on the other hand is real in every sense of the word. In any political entity a common platform of discussion is needed if people are to have a say in their affairs. Neither India nor Europe has such a common platform. Europeans are sensible and don't seek to combine all of Europe into a single political entity. The idea of India as a nation exists only in the prejudiced mind of the ruling anglophone elite. English is the language of everything in india that has to do with India as a whole. Columns written in English are often published in vernacular languages and the editors don't bother to inform their readers of their anglograph provenance. I have never come across in any english language newspaper in India a column written originally in any indian vernacular. More books on indian history are written in Korean or Russian than in all Indian vernaculars put together. In the bibliography of any book or academic article on indian history, i have never come across references to anything written in any indian vernacular except in infrequent instances when a primary source is cited. Access to English is cruelly restricted by the ruling elite because the only way that Indians learn English is by attending exorbitantly priced English medium schools. Public libraries in most big cities in the US make a wide range of resources available to anyone who wants to learn English. In contrast, it's impossible to learn English as an adult in india,, aa most entities that promise to teach English to adults are run by crooks far from fluent in English.

I always praise clarity of thoughts of Mr. Karnad.

Pretty conclusive then, largely Britain's fault and a wonderfully impartial moderator. The offer by the United States to give grain to India scuppered not because of British reluctance to allow them to poke their bugle in, but more on the grounds that the Bay of Bengal was rife with Japanese submarines. A moderator who is particularly forgiving of his fellow country men who shot their own people.

Yajur Arora, in answer to your question were Germans held accountable for killing their own people, Germans, Ukrainians and Poles who found themselves in the Einsatzgruppen or other units who killed their own people and others were prosecuted. Not every one, some escaped, but largely yes, a serious attempt was and has been attempted to bring to book those who took part in this. Further, you make the point that India has not had the problem of people starving since independence. That's not my memory of events - India has suffered from famines that brought loss of life, particularly in the 1970s.

I want a panel consisting of prof.romila thapar,prof.richard eaton and William dalrymple to talk about the history of indian subcontinent from ancient to britsh period.

This panel should had include romila thapar

Thank you for choosing to talk about this. It means alot. The problems and struggle of women are real. I am ok to be wrong in my thoughts which I mentioned earlier in my comments but please talk about this. Please bring it up and create awareness. Thank you again.

12. Also, parents and elders in today's family are no longer valued they are being taken as additional responsibilities and duties not out of love and respect. Nobody has time for them. They have become like weight on the chest. 13. The moral compass has gone for a toss because the women who are so important and can do it all and be it all are no longer available to their children and the future of tomorrow. The generations gen z and millennials have no Moral compass or values. Forget that they don't think it's necessary to have a moral compass and values. 14. We should actually sit back and think what are we raising? Who are these kids of future generations ? Haven't we proved already that women can do it all and be it all ? So many years of women working has been a slap to all those who demeaned the woman.. but the question is until when ? Until when do we have to keep proving ? The future (kids) is getting affected in the process and if only the men understand the importance and value of women and her responsibilities outside of work and the smallest and menial jobs then the imbalance we are facing in this current world today can be restored. No force to the women who WANT TO work. I am talking about the women who HAVE TO work.

I think you missed a few points to discuss in this topic I would like to list them down and would be happy to see a talk on that 1. Increased rate of depression in women 2. Increased rate of depression in other genders 3. Increased rate of depression in children (young & adult) 4. Increased rate of depression in new born babies. 5. Lack of importance given to mental and emotional well being 6. Increased rate of divorce 7. Increased rate of extra marital affairs cause the women are no longer feminine in their energy and are so masculine in energy 8. Everyone wants the money that comes from when women work but nobody wants to be a part of the sacrifice and challenges that come in. 9. I think you also have to view from the millenial and Gen z point of view and how their thought processes have changed in a way where they don't want to take up responsibility or provide in their own (men especially) 10. Relationships and marriages are no longer relationships and Marriages they are more like business deals and projects. 11. One big challenge comes in where one partner has to support a bit more this generation cannot take that. And this generation in that situation runs 100 steps backwards from the relationship. Talk about this. Maybe also bring in someone from today's generation and also bring in a home maker along with this same panel.

NO OF MEN SUSIDE MORE THAN WOMEN ONLY ONLY THESE FEMINISTS LAW.

TODAY SITUATION AND TIME OF MEN SPECIALLY COMMON MEN IS NO WHERE SAFE FROM HOME TO PUBLIC PLACE AND WORK PLACE FALSE COMPLAIN IS SUFFICIENT FOR DESTROYED MEN AND HIS FAMILY LIFE BY SO CALLED FEMINISTS LAW EXIST 100 NO IN INDIA

remove this ridiculas, misoginistic, bullshit thing in law called as, False promise to marry as a RAPE. Accoding to our laws and Supreme Court, a Women above 18 can vote, be a CEO, Fly fighter jet, Work as men do, but does not bear enough sense give consent for sex. She can be manipulated easily by a man in name of marriage or job or toffee, candy, chocolate etc. Is this women empowerment, Women has right to say NO(No means no, Absolutely correct), But (Yes is also an YES) . THE consent cannot be changed after the sex has happened as long as it was not by threat or influence of drugs etc.

Agar alimony sahi h to dahej bhi sahi h….man sucide kr rha h…ladkiya ladko ko fasane men lagi h…false case krje lagi h… Agar ladkiyo k liye kanun banaye h..to freedoms se ji sake..khud ki liye kamao or khao..koi bat nhi..lekin alimony kyu le rhi h..kha jata h self respect…