Ranking all Sandwiches with Chicago's Sandwich Expert

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 янв 2025

Комментарии • 290

  • @barrymccokiner6891
    @barrymccokiner6891 3 года назад +54

    “That smell is not beef it’s SAHSAUGE” great quote by Jim

    • @PoptartMeat
      @PoptartMeat 3 года назад

      I've listened to that part 4x's. I'm from the south so I respect accents and this might be my favorite.

  • @andrewlindner3148
    @andrewlindner3148 3 года назад +97

    I didn’t know I loved Jim so much but he’s a guys guy and sandwich connoisseur.

    • @BeerMe831
      @BeerMe831 3 года назад +10

      Obviously an expert in his field, but didn't come off as pretentious or a know it all. Wish I lived in the Chicago area so I could check out JP Grazianos!

  • @richiepurcell7893
    @richiepurcell7893 3 года назад +98

    Absolutely baffling that Carl has never heard of a chicken parmesan sandwich before

  • @xmakhijad7853
    @xmakhijad7853 3 года назад +26

    "I'm not going to be dramatic" ....3 seconds later..."Italian beefs are bigger than the sandwhich." lmfaooo

  • @sammykadd5950
    @sammykadd5950 3 года назад +84

    I love how Dave makes fun of a grilled cheese first round then takes a BBQ brisket sandwich man he is dumb 😂

  • @24tamez
    @24tamez 3 года назад +16

    Ice cream sandwich in the fifth round is your big bodied DH that will mash a ball into the galaxy as the first four picks just hit. Grilled cheese is the triple, chicken parm is chilling after hitting a double down the line, gyro is your streaky hitter who happened to sneak a single in and your PB&J led off with a absolute bomb

  • @bricemiller3
    @bricemiller3 3 года назад +11

    Jim was amazing in this. So awesome to have someone who knows exactly how the draft works

  • @gabelynch3529
    @gabelynch3529 3 года назад +17

    this might not be a huge thing in the middle of the country since they’re so far from the water but a good crab cake sandwich is absolutely fantastic, if you go to the beach and you find a restaurant that looks like a shanty from the outside but is really cool on the inside. chances are they have a good crab cake sandwich or maybe even a blackened tuna sandwich

  • @oklahomasooner7686
    @oklahomasooner7686 3 года назад +16

    Carl’s Chicago accent gets so deep when he talks Italian Beefs

  • @PensFanE17
    @PensFanE17 3 года назад +27

    Feels like a Lobster Roll and a Po Boy were big misses here

    • @odhess
      @odhess 3 года назад +2

      lobster roll a draft winner if it goes in the fifth

    • @davidalpeter9963
      @davidalpeter9963 3 года назад

      lobster roll debatably in the hot dog style/non sandwich category. Po Boy huge missed opportunity tho

    • @odhess
      @odhess 3 года назад +1

      @@davidalpeter9963 can agree with that for sure

    • @alessandroscuderi7300
      @alessandroscuderi7300 3 года назад +2

      and a Bahni Mi

    • @dannygibson2597
      @dannygibson2597 Год назад

      @@alessandroscuderi7300 bahn mi is a first round pick for anyone who's experienced, these aint those guys lol

  • @johnearly3985
    @johnearly3985 3 года назад +45

    carls face everytime WSD talks is my favorite

    • @SouthernSkeptic
      @SouthernSkeptic 3 года назад +6

      WSD is insanely hilarious.

    • @johnstafford9884
      @johnstafford9884 3 года назад +2

      Laughed my ass off at the Brisket sandwich one

    • @ANTIStraussian
      @ANTIStraussian Год назад

      ​@@johnstafford9884
      WSD: first round is way too early for grilled cheese.
      Also WSD
      I gotta go with BBQ Brisket sandwich first round.
      😅😅😅😂😅😂is

  • @jtark31
    @jtark31 3 года назад +8

    The Cuban Sandwich in the 3rd round is unbelievable value.

  • @xsolidduckx
    @xsolidduckx 3 года назад +30

    No one has ever said, hey I'm going to go grab me a sandwich. Then come back with a cheeseburger. By definition I get it, but grabbing a burger and grabbing a sandwich. Two separate things.

    • @junkerjorg2
      @junkerjorg2 3 года назад +1

      I get that argument - but let's be honest, a hamburger IS a type of sandwich - yes the best kind, but it is still a kind of sandwich.....

    • @matteagan1288
      @matteagan1288 3 года назад +3

      I agree with this . I would put burgers in a category of its own

    • @Mrbink01
      @Mrbink01 3 года назад +2

      If pulled pork and brisket are allowed, both of which are served on buns, then a burger must be included.

    • @matteagan1288
      @matteagan1288 3 года назад +1

      @@Mrbink01 I just think it doesnt belong in this draft

  • @Marbles07
    @Marbles07 3 года назад +15

    How does Cheeseburger not get vetoed? I've seen vetoes for far less. Any menu separates burgers from sandwiches. You could literally do a snake draft of best types of burgers. Great draft, but big oversight

  • @lukemeyer6440
    @lukemeyer6440 3 года назад +18

    Jim just seems like a very wholesome dude. Would love to down a beef and GTLF with him and Carl

  • @corneliusyoungblood8472
    @corneliusyoungblood8472 3 года назад +7

    I guess sandwiches are super regional, but it's kinda crazy that a corned beef or pastrami sandwich didn't go in the first round.

  • @BeerMe831
    @BeerMe831 3 года назад +9

    Can't believe Patty Melt wasn't one of the picks. That's like a top 5 sandwich for me, iconic diner food sammich.

    • @Mrbink01
      @Mrbink01 3 года назад +1

      It's an iteration of a cheeseburger

  • @laxjeff18
    @laxjeff18 3 года назад +9

    Can’t believe they missed the day after thanksgiving sandwich!

  • @Joetheshow15
    @Joetheshow15 3 года назад +4

    Carl's annoyance over the allowance of a chicken parm sandwich has me dying right now haha

  • @jont4343
    @jont4343 3 года назад +2

    The real talk of this draft is how 2 Italians went 1-2 and another at pick 12. They have built a really great program and are truly making a big impact on this league.

  • @alexandershambrock6643
    @alexandershambrock6643 2 года назад

    1:21:19 When Jim says Borata I love the smirk Ed gives to Chief and then the camera lmao

  • @mattshea9516
    @mattshea9516 3 года назад +4

    Never opened up a menu and seen a cheeseburger listed under the sandwiches. Crazy 😂

  • @carsoncanonie6425
    @carsoncanonie6425 3 года назад +8

    Definitely have left a place and thought that was a great Buffalo sandwich and then specifically returned for the sandwich. You definitely can mess it up. Also I like it wayyy better than Nashville hot.

  • @3rdoffthelayoff778
    @3rdoffthelayoff778 3 года назад +14

    WSD loves Cuban sandwiches yet he thinks there is beef in it? SMH

    • @Mrbink01
      @Mrbink01 3 года назад

      My first reaction too

  • @mattydanks406
    @mattydanks406 3 года назад +3

    Breaded chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers on ciabatta or round roll oil and vinegar

    • @richiepurcell7893
      @richiepurcell7893 3 года назад

      Throw some creamy balsamic on there and you're set

  • @zackstewart844
    @zackstewart844 Год назад +2

    I watch this episode every time I eat a sandwich

  • @matthew4155-h6e
    @matthew4155-h6e 2 года назад +1

    Burger is not a sandwich... it is just it's own category. That being said, these old drafts in the old office are all classics.

  • @YouPanic11
    @YouPanic11 2 года назад +1

    Deli/Rachel sandwich, super beef 3 way, chicken kabob sandwich, Thanksgiving leftover sandwich. So many more missed.

  • @thesardyparty
    @thesardyparty 3 года назад +3

    It blows my mind how WSD fights everything until it's his benefit to not fight it.

  • @ChunkySoupfortheSoul
    @ChunkySoupfortheSoul 11 дней назад

    Not sandwich exactly, but since we are talking about Graziano's -The cannoli from Graziano's vs the cannoli from D'amato's - a complete Chicago food coma afternoon. The sfogliatelle from Mariano's isn't completely trash but you have to get it when they make it because they let it get soggy.

  • @davidcunningham5672
    @davidcunningham5672 2 года назад +1

    Jim knows what’s up. I am in disbelief that pork belly bahn mi wasn’t taken

  • @echoo12
    @echoo12 3 года назад

    I love how serious these guys are about this topic. missed out on jibaritos and pambazos. if gyro is a sandwich, can shawarma also be a sandwich?

  • @va2dubv
    @va2dubv 3 года назад +9

    A Cheeseburger is a burger, NOT a sandwich.
    Honorable mention: crab cake sandwich, pastrami, shrimp po boy

  • @manueljimenez3326
    @manueljimenez3326 3 года назад +2

    Sandwich - An item of food consisting of two pieces of bread with Meat, cheese, OR other filling....PB&J is a filling. Cheese can be grilled in a sandwich form. A peice of meat, cheese and other fillings (onions, lettuce, tomato, etc). It's people just being particular.

  • @blewsfoods
    @blewsfoods 3 года назад +1

    They also sell Taylor ham at regular grocery stores 👍🏼

  • @phow21
    @phow21 3 года назад +4

    43:47 wait... who doesn't put mayo on their BLT?

    • @SouthernSkeptic
      @SouthernSkeptic 3 года назад

      ME.

    • @hawaii5-084
      @hawaii5-084 3 года назад +1

      @@SouthernSkeptic well you’re an idiot

    • @SouthernSkeptic
      @SouthernSkeptic 3 года назад +1

      @@hawaii5-084 I'm an idiot because my tastebuds don't like mayo on sandwiches? You're definitely a millennial.

  • @hawaii5-084
    @hawaii5-084 3 года назад +2

    The McRib should’ve gotten a honorable mention

  • @joemccullough4246
    @joemccullough4246 3 года назад +1

    Carl always forms a rivalry with the “experts”. This one similar to the Frank the Tank matchup in the soda pop draft.

  • @tucker5304
    @tucker5304 3 года назад

    12:08 Carl, I wasn’t sure if I was the only one with that reaction

  • @brynwaddell8698
    @brynwaddell8698 3 года назад +3

    Also, Jim’s real name is Jim Sandler...He’s clearly Adam’s brother.

  • @benvanmeter5388
    @benvanmeter5388 3 года назад +2

    I don’t know why I am fascinated. I’ve got my board ready. Lets go

    • @benvanmeter5388
      @benvanmeter5388 3 года назад +1

      Idk about cheese burger....

    • @benvanmeter5388
      @benvanmeter5388 3 года назад +1

      Barbecue brisket is an awful pick lmao

    • @benvanmeter5388
      @benvanmeter5388 3 года назад

      PB and J and grilled cheese are simp picks. ED IS A SIMP

    • @benvanmeter5388
      @benvanmeter5388 3 года назад

      Best PB and J is wheat bread, crunchy PB, strawberry jam, toasted.....

    • @benvanmeter5388
      @benvanmeter5388 3 года назад

      Carl wins

  • @tsals2333
    @tsals2333 3 года назад +1

    Need Jim and Frank the Tank to start a video series called Sandwich Shops and Soda Pops

  • @CIARUNSITE
    @CIARUNSITE 3 года назад

    Grilling a pb&j is definitely an overlooked addition but it's fucking great. Not something you do every time, but if you're at home eating one instead of on the go I highly recommend it.

  • @JSher718
    @JSher718 3 года назад

    out here in new york is where it was born and bred the bagel gets flak because it’s a misconception in a way because it’s how the dunkins of the world do it we are onto like level 8 of BECs in NY it’s almost a reflex to add the hash brown patties inside the saltpepperketchup i personally also throw in hot sauce, it’s a hard hard miss here

  • @alexkramer6251
    @alexkramer6251 3 года назад +1

    Love a good Thanksgiving leftover sandwich. Some places are doing em as a featured item now.

  • @jakemetz1742
    @jakemetz1742 3 года назад +1

    The way Ed is saying gyro is everything

  • @MC-bh3ff
    @MC-bh3ff 3 года назад +5

    Dude jim looks 30 years younger than he sounds. Listened today at work and thought this guy would be pushing 70

  • @SouthernSkeptic
    @SouthernSkeptic 3 года назад +4

    Ah fuck, the ads are back.

  • @deibtryin
    @deibtryin 3 года назад +1

    Cheeseburger as a sandwich is PSYCHOTIC!

  • @junkerjorg2
    @junkerjorg2 3 года назад +2

    Holy crap, Ed DUMMIED this draft. Not even close. I don't want to hear ANYONE rag on pb&j or grilled cheese. Ed was the smartest, by far, in this draft. ICE CREAM SANDWICH. I mean. C'mon, some absolute genius there. I just loved Ed's draft. PS. Where do all the Ice Cream Sandwich haters come from!? One of the greatest foods, ever....

  • @forum7148
    @forum7148 3 года назад +4

    Why do I have 17 ads for this video?

    • @hawaii5-084
      @hawaii5-084 3 года назад

      I absolutely agree this is crazy

    • @forum7148
      @forum7148 3 года назад

      @Sleepy Joe yea I get that, but I got 5 ads before 18 minutes

  • @Mrbink01
    @Mrbink01 3 года назад +1

    Honorable mentions...Fried Pork Tenderloin (shoutout to Iowa and Indiana), Tuna Salad / Tuna Melt, Baltimore Pit Beef (with tiger sauce and raw onions), Leftover Meatloaf Sandwich, and one the favorites in my family when packing a lunch, sliced summer sausage, cheddar, butter and horseradish.

  • @mattydanks406
    @mattydanks406 3 года назад

    If you go to the bodega/deli you get bacon egg and cheese on roll but if you go to the bagel shop it isn’t looked down on to get on bagel

  • @ivanarroyo2855
    @ivanarroyo2855 3 года назад +1

    You should add a link to the beef kit in the description.

  • @joeweidemann5305
    @joeweidemann5305 3 года назад

    I would just like to take credit for this idea. Posted it before anyone else.

  • @anthonyjuhasz6105
    @anthonyjuhasz6105 3 года назад +1

    Dude, Jim is the sandwich king and a great guest

  • @steveschrack9827
    @steveschrack9827 11 месяцев назад

    2 years late but the roast pork with sharp prov and broc rabe is the legit local sando in Philly

  • @mattconley6139
    @mattconley6139 3 года назад +1

    Thought Dave absolutely fumbled with the brisket/nashville hot picks but the cubano/reuben picks saved him

    • @jimmydolan3511
      @jimmydolan3511 2 года назад +1

      Him not knowing ham is on there is lunacy

  • @ChiSox326
    @ChiSox326 3 года назад

    I can't believe all the Chicago guys didn't pick a Ricobenes breaded steak . Like come on how did that not make the list . I'm surprised shwarma too didn't make the list

  • @SouthernSkeptic
    @SouthernSkeptic 3 года назад +9

    The JP Graziano's guy looks like he could be kin to Chief.

  • @blewsfoods
    @blewsfoods 3 года назад

    Congrats, boys!! Huge collab

  • @davidalpeter9963
    @davidalpeter9963 3 года назад

    penut butter sandwich with a glass of milk is such a winning combo. and i also dunked mine in milk. shoutout Chief and WSD

  • @garrettrichard5369
    @garrettrichard5369 3 года назад

    WSD absolutely deserves to have the unofficial notable voices crown

  • @robmorra4476
    @robmorra4476 3 года назад

    Can’t find the Italian beef slow cooker recipe video that they say is out on RUclips.

    • @MgBlazer77
      @MgBlazer77 3 года назад

      twitter.com/barstoolchicago/status/1389232811094183938?s=21
      Hopefully link is clickable. It’s on their Twitter, posted on May 3rd.

  • @Fred13Del
    @Fred13Del 2 года назад +1

    BUFF CHIC > Turkey Club -ALL DAY

  • @BurghMurph
    @BurghMurph 3 года назад

    Where can I get the beef kit. Edit-if I just listened a min longer lol

  • @VitaCarpe
    @VitaCarpe 3 года назад +2

    Cemita definitely the value pick of the draft, mans knows his sengwiches

    • @rafaellopez1690
      @rafaellopez1690 3 года назад

      so glad someone picked that. sad to hear the pueblas chain closed like jim said.

  • @MgBlazer77
    @MgBlazer77 3 года назад

    I wanna know if J has gotten the “Biggie” from Burt’s Deli in Libertyville. Such a great sandwhich. Pastrami corned beef on rye, just to die for. Check it out if y’all headed north sometime

  • @emoser742
    @emoser742 3 года назад

    Easily the cleanest start to a draft ever

  • @GoBirdsss
    @GoBirdsss 3 года назад +4

    Personally I don’t think a cheeseburger is a sandwich. Technically it fits the definition. But to me a burger is a burger and a sandwich is a sandwich. Nobody thinks cheeseburger off the top when you think of sandwiches

  • @jtintheuk297
    @jtintheuk297 3 года назад

    Revisiting this one and the Cheeseburger at 3 seems off....2 great sandwich picks then the burger. It grates

  • @hookster999
    @hookster999 3 года назад

    @116:08 -- when Jim is describing Cemita sandwhich, I bet WSD was googling for a picture of a Cemita sandwhich with red cabbage - why can’t WSD ever just say, oh yeah I was wrong, why????

  • @austindurham1586
    @austindurham1586 3 года назад +1

    Thanksgiving leftover sandwich would have stole this easy

  • @KevinAndrewLaux
    @KevinAndrewLaux 3 года назад

    If you ever get good authentic Brisket in TX it will always come with White Bread, Onions, Pickles, and you eat it as an open or closed face sandwich. A meat forward sandwich sure, but Chief was way off saying just the meat alone.

    • @Mrbink01
      @Mrbink01 3 года назад

      White bread on a bbq platter is mainly for sopping up the juices...not intended to make a sandwich out of it.

  • @lornemalvo4492
    @lornemalvo4492 3 года назад +1

    Jim picking Roast Pork then immediately naming off Dynex and John's lets me know he knows what the fuck he's talking about. Definitely a sandwich savant. Nobody picked arguably the greatest sandwich a steak bahn mi!
    edit: Oh they talk about it at the end.

  • @patrickhennes3251
    @patrickhennes3251 3 года назад

    Can someone explain how someone gets left off the graphic? Who determines that? And where do you vote? Thanks for your help in advance.

    • @MgBlazer77
      @MgBlazer77 3 года назад

      Voting is on the DogWalk Twitter page - since there are only 4 votes per Twitter vote, 1/5 is the reply to vote aka never wins spot.

    • @patrickhennes3251
      @patrickhennes3251 3 года назад

      @@MgBlazer77 Much appreciated!

  • @stanelhombre8438
    @stanelhombre8438 3 года назад +1

    Clem traded in his Mets stuff for chicahgo and morphed into Jim.

  • @darekshuba3808
    @darekshuba3808 3 года назад +1

    Jim is absolutely electric.

  • @mattt2226
    @mattt2226 3 года назад

    Sorry if this is a spoiler. But you can just tell WSD is a crunchy peanut butter guy. Not a knock against the crunch but it just fits.

  • @GoBirdsss
    @GoBirdsss 3 года назад +1

    1:21:00 how tf to all of you pronounce caprese wrong? Cuh-preez-ee phonetically spelled

  • @bolddailysports5985
    @bolddailysports5985 3 года назад

    Peanut butter sandwich with a piece of cheese is unbelievable

  • @woozywoods
    @woozywoods 3 года назад

    Does Jim ship the beef kits?

  • @connorgreen9181
    @connorgreen9181 3 года назад +2

    I already thought WSD was dumb but he proves draft after draft how much dumber he is than i originally believed. Amazing.

  • @griffnuelle7870
    @griffnuelle7870 3 года назад

    Is a Gyro a sandwhich or a wrap though?

  • @alessandroscuderi7300
    @alessandroscuderi7300 3 года назад

    No Bahn Mi or Po Boy is ridiculous. Bahn Mi is such an under the radar sandwich.

  • @christoskaradis4340
    @christoskaradis4340 3 года назад

    Hell yeah Eddie! Franksville shout-out place has awesome Gyro sandwich!

  • @AL74AL
    @AL74AL 3 года назад

    Love the collab. Guys being guys 👏🏻

  • @Queebo127
    @Queebo127 5 месяцев назад

    Chief is right. Brisket (in Texas) is a better meat but pulled pork sandwich is the right move

  • @brianjohnson8588
    @brianjohnson8588 Год назад

    They totally missed out on the Banh Mi.

  • @bentonleach6730
    @bentonleach6730 3 года назад +2

    On most menus there are different sections for “sandwiches” and “burgers”. I don’t count a burger as a sandwich.

    • @NoahFulkroad
      @NoahFulkroad 3 года назад

      If a burgers a samdwich, then a hot dog should be a sandwich

  • @Spawn303
    @Spawn303 3 года назад +1

    Is Dave part of the lollipop guild?

  • @ianthompson3038
    @ianthompson3038 2 года назад

    I’m sorry but when you think of sandwich, you definitely don’t think cheeseburger. You’re not going to go into a deli and ask for a cheeseburger, just like you’re not going to go into a burger place and ask for a sandwich.

  • @tylerdemers3017
    @tylerdemers3017 3 года назад

    only people from jersey know that pork roll/Taylor ham egg and cheese spk is a first round pick

  • @guruthetank
    @guruthetank 3 года назад +1

    If ricobenes steak sandwhich didn't make the list y'all can't be from Chicago you guys gotta be from Naperville

  • @Herbaugh
    @Herbaugh 3 года назад +5

    Cheeseburger not a sandwich

  • @wch7251
    @wch7251 3 года назад +6

    east coast guy wouldve swept this

  • @peterktemple
    @peterktemple 3 года назад

    Where’s the poll

  • @funandfighting6287
    @funandfighting6287 3 года назад +1

    Dave with the absolute worst explanation of a Cuban sandwich of all time

  • @louieb8413
    @louieb8413 3 года назад

    when I saw the thumbnail I thought that was Clem

  • @danlehman4646
    @danlehman4646 3 года назад

    Don't know if I can argue with a professional sandwich man, but a Rachel is made with Roast Turkey, not Pastrami.