PLL theory: Wren is Charles, Beach Hottie and Bethany’s brother (+ Jenna Thing explained)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
  • (Edit to A's love for fire: He blew up Toby's house, burnt Cyrus and trapped Jenna in a burning house.)
    OMG! I can't believe alloyentertainment and the Wren is -A facebook site posted my theory!! I'm so happy right now! Thank you so much for all the kind feedback!
    I literally wanted to do this theory forever! I hope you like it, but if not, please don’t be rude in the comments. Watch in HD for best quality. Please SUBSCRIBE and give it a thumbs up, if you liked the video. Forgive me grammatical errors, English isn’t my first language. Thank you! :D
    Songs: “Hey Brother” by Jada and Kyson Facer, “Too Late” by Timbaland ft. OneRepublic, and “Super Psycho Love” by Simon Curtis
    Article about my theory by alloyentertainment: prettylittlelia...
    Wren and Aria are cousins theory here: • PLL theory: Aria and W...
    Wren and Melissa are A theory here: • PLL theory: Melissa is...

Комментарии • 212

  • @floraward6163
    @floraward6163 9 лет назад +36

    Wren being A makes alot of sense in the fact that the fans are not too attached to him like it was with Toby or Ezra

    • @livnatperez9259
      @livnatperez9259 9 лет назад +9

      Well i'm really attach to Wren' since he first appeared in PLL.(Might be the actor) But.. i would love him to be A.I would be so surprised. I can't imagine anyone else at this point:)

    • @emilymcmartin2544
      @emilymcmartin2544 9 лет назад +2

      flora Ward I honestly love Wren more than Toby and Ezra :) the accent :)

    • @nicolej4383
      @nicolej4383 9 лет назад +1

      *cough* Caleb *cough*

    • @2Amethyst2
      @2Amethyst2 8 лет назад

      +Nicole Burrows when was Caleb ever "A"????

    • @nicolej4383
      @nicolej4383 8 лет назад

      He wasn't but I wrote that comment a year ago so idk what I was on about haha

  • @KNaz500
    @KNaz500 9 лет назад +39

    I LOVE 'Wren is A' theories and this one is just as fab! :D

    • @astalydia
      @astalydia 8 лет назад

      +RoxiSophie Msp ugh I hated the finale

  • @paralight17
    @paralight17 9 лет назад +9

    To add to this: When Spencer went to London for that interview, A somehow managed to get a blood sample into her bag... I don't know where Wren was and barely remember the episode, but that just clicked!
    Awesome theory.

    • @snowysummer6813
      @snowysummer6813 9 лет назад

      tiffany b Wren was with Melissa in London as well, though we never saw them until Melissa returned to that apartment without Wren, and she didn't mention anything about Wren's whereabouts.

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      tiffany b You're right, that's in my Wren & Melissa theory. Please check it out, it explains the whole London thing.

    • @paralight17
      @paralight17 9 лет назад

      KaylaSwEet06 Yeah I'll be sure to check it out! This theory was amazing, well done :)

    • @samanthayuk177
      @samanthayuk177 9 лет назад

      When Spencer's gets the text from A after the blood incident, it says "Keep Calm, but check your carry on" which is a play on from "Keep Calm and Carry On" which is so British! lol.

    • @paralight17
      @paralight17 9 лет назад

      Samantha Yuk Yes true! I always even thought, "Kisses, -A" sounds super British. Like "Cheerio" hahah

  • @Stardust198
    @Stardust198 9 лет назад +13

    This makes so much more sense than #CeceIsA 😒

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +3

      Stardust Thanks for cheering me up a bit. :) Let's consider this the real ending.

  • @christianlorensenkedde4279
    @christianlorensenkedde4279 9 лет назад +6

    Very nice Theory - Only one thing, Bethany is alive. Here's my proof, that i got together!
    Guys Listen!
    Sara Harvey isn't who she says she is!
    When the policeofficer saw that there was another girl, in the doll house, she asked the girl, what her name was. She hesitated, before saying this, in the exact order: Sara. Sara Harvey.
    This is a parallel scene. Mona did that exact same thing!
    When the 4 liars was telling Mona, that she wasn't Alison, she replied: I'm Alison, Alison DiLaurentis - She said that because Charles wanted her to pretend she was Alison, but therefore when ''Sara'' said her name in that order plus hesitating, it indicates that she was lying. Sara Harvey is Bethany Young - Why?
    Why did she say that she was Sara, instead of Bethany ?
    It's simple - We all know, that Bethany was in Radly, before disappearing. So if she said her real name - Bethany - They would have to send her back to Radly, but if she said someone elses name, she'd be free to go.

  • @lacook19
    @lacook19 9 лет назад +35

    slow down your slides a little bit when it's text. It was a little hard to keep up. Otherwise great Theory!!!

    • @Gabbyxxzz
      @Gabbyxxzz 9 лет назад

      lacook19 you can pause them.i had to speed it up.

  • @morgan9653
    @morgan9653 9 лет назад +1

    Plus, in the season 6 premiere, Spencer had mentioned that when she stood next to Charles in his vault, she felt something a little familiar about him.

  • @moonlightval13
    @moonlightval13 9 лет назад +1

    This deserves an award or something. On Point.
    This is so accurate. Great Theory!

  • @livnatperez9259
    @livnatperez9259 9 лет назад +5

    Great Theory. Looks like you put all the important pieces together. I will like it to be Wren for real. I've been thinking of him since the beginning of the show.

  • @tarintula
    @tarintula 9 лет назад +14

    this is such a great theory, but wren has a British accent which kinda suggests he grew up in England and maybe you just havent clarified it, but you suggest that he grew up with them

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +32

      Taryn Newbury I think their family broke apart after the video in Charles vault. Bethany was adopted by the Young's and Wren by a british family and they stayed in contact neverthless. But well, my personal favorite is that he's faking his accent, to throw people off his trail. Sometimes A tends to confuse the american and english spelling. Remember "A takes a holdiday"? It's "vacation" in american english, "holiday" is british. "Nos(e)y bitches die" was also a british spelling error.

    • @janaenoelle4698
      @janaenoelle4698 9 лет назад

      KaylaSwEet06 A is charles because charles is alisons brother there is a vidoe about charles bday and there is 2 boys jason and charles and alison and he wanted the lairs to recreate the prom but it back fired charles set of smoke and took mona and but her in the hole

    • @cait812
      @cait812 7 лет назад

      It's easy to fake an accent.

  • @hazhaz22
    @hazhaz22 9 лет назад +6

    Spolier:!!! This theory makes so much more sense than the real ending ...

  • @cherrygalore2032
    @cherrygalore2032 9 лет назад +2

    Let's not rule out Lucas who is suddenly MIA all of a sudden, we don't see him in the courtroom, we don't see him anywhere after the Christmas episode.

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Cherry Galore Yes, but the Beach Hottie theory doesn't work for him. Ali was seeing a guy, who's much older. I can't explain why Lucas would love Alison, only why he would hate her. He's also younger than A. But he could be a helper.

  • @willow8186
    @willow8186 9 лет назад

    Huh, this has got to be my favorite A theory so far, good thinking :)

  • @ZuzuliiiJ
    @ZuzuliiiJ 9 лет назад

    I personally don't think anything anymore, but this theory is just so amazingly good! (and crazy at the same time). Good job! :)

  • @xidiamondaces9883
    @xidiamondaces9883 8 лет назад +1

    That ties in with the whole Mrs D twin thing that's meant to be being revealed this season :) So one Mrs D had Wren and Bethany and the other had Jason and Ali?But anyways that's just my idea, I love your theory

  • @marril96
    @marril96 9 лет назад

    This was very good, I love the theory! Wren is Charles is my personal favorite theory and I really hope they go with it. However, this whole thing kinda creeps me out. The family history, the possibilities... It's make a great horror movie.

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +1

      Mariana Sertić They should totally make a horror movie out of it. If I'm not satisfied with the real ending in 6x10, I just consider mine the real one. X)

  • @arian7957
    @arian7957 9 лет назад

    MY FEELINGS ARE CONFUSED, THEY ARE EXCITED, SURPRISED, SAD, HAPPY, OMG WHAT THE HELL IS HAPPENING TO ME
    ALTHOUGH, GOOD JOB GIRL!

  • @tinablecherr
    @tinablecherr 9 лет назад

    Also when Alison was first born, he admired how she got everyone's attention but also hated it and broke her arm. Like Alison said "she" broke her arm when she was little and it never fully healed. Mrs. D sent Charles away to Radley because he was too aggressive with Alison. The night Alison was hit with a rock, Mrs. D got a call from Radley saying her son escaped Radley. Mrs. D was protecting Charles so she buried Alison alive. The email Mrs. Dilaurentis sent before she died was for Charles.

  • @rifa3961
    @rifa3961 9 лет назад +1

    I don't know why anyone would turn down Wren. And the guy in the background in that scene where Ali is asking for a ride also looked like Ezra's younger brother, Wesley

  • @tinablecherr
    @tinablecherr 9 лет назад

    When Mrs. D got the call from Radley saying her son was loose, she told Alison to stay inside for a reason because she knows how Charles is towards Alison

  • @Andromachy100
    @Andromachy100 8 лет назад

    Oh my god I just had written down almost the same theory yesterday !! Yours is more complete though !! Amazing work ;) I love all of your theory videos =)

  • @menahshaaban8759
    @menahshaaban8759 9 лет назад +1

    Best theory ever. It's like the only theory that makes sense and I always said that Wren is A (Charles) so when I saw this theory I was almost about to cry. Thank you KaylaSwEet06

  • @AylaYildiz
    @AylaYildiz 9 лет назад +1

    at one point we see A in the ending scene with an "Ali mask" - the one side burned - it fits to your theory that bethany might have got a burned injury. great theory! i think its the best theory so far and also my opinion how the show is going to continue

    • @waterpark.asitis9564
      @waterpark.asitis9564 9 лет назад

      Wasn't the mask burned when the lodge was set on fire?? Although it's a good possibly. Good thinking

    • @sarahsulaeman5710
      @sarahsulaeman5710 8 лет назад

      yes and in pll five years forward, they mention that another person is after Alison and that person is a 'he' . I have a huge feeling 'he' is Wren

  • @buildmythronex8312
    @buildmythronex8312 9 лет назад

    WOW! This is brilliant! This would explain the *Aunt* Jessie thing. And the connections you made about how Charles loves/hates Alison, and why… WOW. I seriously wonder if we're going to find out this summer that this theory is right!

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      xceruleandream You're making me blush. :) Thank you for your kind comment. I hope I got some things right , hehe.

  • @emlc2528
    @emlc2528 9 лет назад +1

    this makes me soooo much sense! so well done!

  • @Dervxx
    @Dervxx 9 лет назад +11

    anyone else watching like every theory ever in prepration for the big reveal?!!

    • @waterpark.asitis9564
      @waterpark.asitis9564 9 лет назад +1

      In doing the exact same thing 😂

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +1

      Dervla Scully Yay! We're so close to the A reveal! :D

    • @Dervxx
      @Dervxx 9 лет назад

      i know i think it could be wren or maybe Bethany(Sara) or melissa!

    • @Dervxx
      @Dervxx 9 лет назад

      I know i saw it, can't believe its Cece! x

  • @arden8489
    @arden8489 9 лет назад +1

    I still don't know why people find the whole 'Cece is A' theory so hard to understand and are annoyed at the writers. I think it was a great ending and pretty straight forward. I think the people who wanted it to be wren are just annoyed because it wasn't what they thought. This was a great theory though!

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      +Arden Kely The CeCe is A theory in general makes sense. I don't know if you know the PLL theorist. She wrote great CeCe theories that made perfect sense. However, none of them included her being Charles, because this doesn't make much sense with the previous season's story. Looking back, there are clues for CeCe being A, but not CeCe being transgender/Charles which is very disappointing. Thanks anyway for the compliment. The revenge for Bethany was my favorite motive theory. :)

    • @arden8489
      @arden8489 9 лет назад +2

      I think either Wren or Cece would've made a good A. I understand that there were quite a few plot-holes but I still think the writers did a good job! (and so did all of the people making theories) :)

  • @IamYurialsoAfrompll
    @IamYurialsoAfrompll 9 лет назад +11

    Holy mother of Mary! one of the best theories i ever watched! Everything is just wow! great job!

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +2

      I am Yuri Thanks a lot! Hehe, is that YOU behind that mask ChArles? ;D

    • @IamYurialsoAfrompll
      @IamYurialsoAfrompll 9 лет назад +1

      KaylaSwEet06
      YES! :'D i love to play with dolls ^_^

  • @nicoleschultz4491
    @nicoleschultz4491 9 лет назад +1

    This is the best theory I have heard so far

  • @maryc954
    @maryc954 9 лет назад +1

    This is a great theory! Wonderful job!!!

  • @oldhollywoodangels
    @oldhollywoodangels 9 лет назад

    I think the mannequins of Charles' family, the little boy was biting that girl's arm and not kissing it? But honestly, I believe in this theory 200% and Id be so so so excited if it turned out that way cause Wren as A would be so thrilling tbh and imo he's the only character on the show that makes sense as a villain.

  • @littlemama8711
    @littlemama8711 9 лет назад

    From almost the beginning, I thought it was Melissa, with Wren's help. But this makes so much more sense. I hope you're right with it being Wren. And it'd make more sense of this is a cousin of Jason, from his mom's side because then the whole week kissing Spencer doesn't gross me out nearly as much. Good theory. Again, I hope you are right.

  • @emilygreen4876
    @emilygreen4876 9 лет назад

    this is soo good I mean there are no loose ends or anything like if Ezra was Wrens brother it would make sense that hes keeping it from the girls cause he wants to get in with him cause they were split up as kids :)

  • @stevenjoenoora3642
    @stevenjoenoora3642 9 лет назад

    My mind was blown by this theory...it's convincing though, Amazing!!! Great Job!!!

  • @chiremae1001
    @chiremae1001 9 лет назад

    Interesting theory, some parts I don't quite buy bu others are fairly convincing. At this point though I think we can clear who are not Charles rather than named who is Charles ;)
    1. The five PLLs, Mona, Caleb, Ezra and Toby, Tanner are not likely to be A given the way the event unfold in 5x25 and 6x01.
    2. Of the SOs, I think Ezra is clear, he's neither hates not loves Ali, nor was he obsessed with Ali herself, he was perfectly fine with not ever seeing her again after finding out her real age. (Aria is a different story ;P) same goes to Caleb, he doesn't care for Ali but doesn't have any history with her. Toby and Paige I not quite sure because they really seems to hate her.
    3. Is the 100 percent proof that Wren is even British? He could be pretending to be one.
    4. 'Being a favorite' doesn't always mean he loves her best, it could also means she's his favorite to torture or torment.
    5. I always thought the fact Aria is the least targeted by Mono or Charles is more a reflection of her being the least close to Ali.
    Anyway, interesting theory, thanks for sharing.

  • @adamtaucher2709
    @adamtaucher2709 9 лет назад

    You bring up A LOT OF GOOD POINTS!!!! At this point I'm ready to believe that anyone could be "A"

  • @marianatorres8382
    @marianatorres8382 9 лет назад +1

    Maybe a clue you could include is the apples the boys are takin and the hair of both. In fact we saw jason one day buying red aples and -A always eat green ones in hus lair. And tha hair of the little one was longger than the bigone. Maybe wren was eating green aples in some episode (i dnt remember). And the marlyn cuote, something about the plea. Idk maybe it can help whit something. I belive wren is -A/charles but idk anything about yhe twin's theory. I think ir toby's mom nd miss d. Kisses

  • @Sarah-tx4rt
    @Sarah-tx4rt 8 лет назад

    This is a great theorie! So maybe Wren will be A.D or Uber A. I hope so because it makes so much sense! :3

  • @mimiw2336
    @mimiw2336 9 лет назад +1

    Amazing theory! All makes way too much sense!

  • @denahobbs6268
    @denahobbs6268 9 лет назад

    I agree with a "three" theme. A newscaster said someone is going down down down and then Area had Tres, French for three, on her shirt. Did anyone notice that the mom mannequin is a male mannequin?

  • @annanielsen165
    @annanielsen165 9 лет назад

    Great theory I must say - thought of some of it myself. However, I saw leaked spoilers and one of them said that Charles doesn't like Alison, he likes Mona ...
    Still a great theory though with a lot of great details!

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Anna Nielsen Wren likes Mona, because she told him about her A-Game and he thought to himself: Guurrrl, you are a genius. Now that you're out of the way, I'm gonna steel your game and become A myself. ;) It works both ways.

  • @martina-dd6vb
    @martina-dd6vb 9 лет назад

    I agree with this theory! :3 Wren is Charles, period. He has to be. It all makes pefect sence.
    By the way, did anyone else also notice that guy who was passing by in 6x01 when Alison was speaking for the cameras outside her house? He was wearing a cap and they all thought it was Andrew. It looked A LOT like Wren to me.

  • @Caseyroseyx
    @Caseyroseyx 8 лет назад +1

    I think Wren could be Bethany's brother! Who knows?! Maybe he worked in radley so he could be with her. And even though Wren is not Charles, I DO THINK he is Charlotte's killer! Perhaps he waited until she got out of treatment, so he had the opportunity to kill her & give her no chance to live. What if he wanted to make her suffer after finding out Charlotte intended to kill bethany "that night"?!

  • @inesmferreir
    @inesmferreir 9 лет назад

    This is too good to not be true! Seriously, even if the show doesn't turn out like this, I'll still consider this the ending! xD

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      seniferreira Thank you. :D The clues, which tie Charles and Bethany together are mostly really good hidden, same goes for the Aria and Wren clues of my previous video. If they aren't explained until the summer finale, I'll keep forever wondering what they were about, lol. But I'm very excited about Marlene's ending of the A-story in 6x10 and if it's a different ending - but a logical and good one too - then I'll accept it nevertheless. Still, Wren will always be my personal A. I imagined him in that hoodie, even in season 2. XD

    • @MaryJ1889
      @MaryJ1889 9 лет назад

      KaylaSwEet06 I imagined him in that hoodie since season 2. Kayla, we share the same dream *lol* :D I really hope he's A it would be the PERFECT ending.

    • @GreeceCombination
      @GreeceCombination 9 лет назад

      If wren is not Charles it will be totally crap anymore..!!

  • @emilygreen4876
    @emilygreen4876 9 лет назад

    Your theories are sooo good 👏👏👏

  • @emilymcmartin2544
    @emilymcmartin2544 9 лет назад

    I Like your theory about Wren's father being Aria's father's brother interesting
    and at 4:43 it does look like him!
    But Wilden sent the lodge on fire:)
    why is it always the hot guy :P

  • @CherylHarrison12
    @CherylHarrison12 9 лет назад

    This makes a lot more sense like in (I think episode 23 season 5) when spencer is in London staying with Melissa and spencer meets Colin her roommate and he tells her something along the lines of Melissa AND Wren will be back tomorrow. Maybe wren planted the blood that dripped onto the couch in her meeting (still doubting this because Colin said Melissa wasn't there when he first opened the door but could still be possible). And in episode 25 when Melissa shows up for like 10 seconds (it may have been 24) it's seems as if she may get killed. Wren is with her in England so... great theory by the way!

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Cheryl Harrison Yep, I have a full theory about that Wren & Melissa are in England nonsense as well: ruclips.net/video/71fvv9C_8q4/видео.html&feature=gp-n-o&google_comment_id=z13hszegltztuzvkv22ujpqgwmqtspxmc

    • @CherylHarrison12
      @CherylHarrison12 9 лет назад

      KaylaSwEet06 I watched your theory it was great. The clues were spot on.

  • @vindicatorbitch5287
    @vindicatorbitch5287 9 лет назад

    I've just got a dream of Toby being A, and somehow it felt so legit. Anyways, great theory!

  • @Sparklegal19
    @Sparklegal19 9 лет назад

    This is a good theory about Wren being the beach hottie but now we know that Charles is Alison and Jason's brother. I think Wren is connected to him in some way or maybe is him. Because he's not necessarily Spencer and Melissa's brother since he was born before Jason was. It makes a lot of sense and Marlene did say we have seen Charles before so maybe Wren is Charles.

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Sarah Barter I honestly have no idea who Beach Hottie is supposed to be, if Wren is Charles. If A is CeCe or Melissa he can still be Beach Hottie and maybe helper A. But since we saw A unmasked in 5x25 (as a child, who was Charles) these ladies are basically ruled out and I'm left with Wren. I have the bad feeling that he originally was supposed to be Beach Hottie, but then Marlene came up with Charles and they just forgot about this storyline, which means we'll probably never find out who he was. :(

  • @juliaengelhardt2401
    @juliaengelhardt2401 9 лет назад

    Great Theory. Did you know that there is a british novel called Varjak Paw (by S.F. Said) maybe that's another hint that Wren is Varjak.

  • @shayshay1275
    @shayshay1275 9 лет назад

    love the ideas amazing theory:) you said Charles loves and hates Alison , kinda like what happened to Tody he is always seen hating her and now we're seening him watching and being really crazzy over her interest in the other new cop thats working with Toby. He has a reason to hate Alison for the Jenna thing . he had a thing with his sister. as for why in the dollhouse the girl has her hand to him and he is trying to grab the little girl could be she doesn't love him. But ya i like toby hate to think hes A but hes been acting a little crazzy with the odd staring at Alison and this voice when he is talking to her kinda strange
    ]

  • @antonio-cu6ll
    @antonio-cu6ll 9 лет назад

    This is the best theory ever! Thank you!

  • @kirawatson1234
    @kirawatson1234 9 лет назад +2

    This theory makes so much sense omg how did you notice all the little details like the flags? You've developed this theory so well....but hasn't Wren been in the UK with Melissa?

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +1

      kira watson No, he and Melissa weren't there, when Spencer arrived. Who can prove they were in the UK all that time? They could have been in Rosewood all along. That "flatmate" could have been paid to say they were living there with him. When Melissa arrived in London she said nothing about Wren's whereabouts. Why didn't he came back along with her? Where the heck is he? Anyway, I think these two are in all this together, though Melissa's unwillingly.

    • @kirawatson1234
      @kirawatson1234 9 лет назад

      I never thought about it that way but you're right! Melissa definitely has something to do with all of this....well done on figuring out this theory though, it's definitely the most realistic out of all the ones I've watched!

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      kira watson
      Thank you! Gonna finish my Wren & Melissa theory soon, after I uploaded the twin theory. There are good clues about her being Black Veil, can't wait to bring them on screen. :D

    • @kirawatson1234
      @kirawatson1234 9 лет назад

      Super excited for that!

  • @andreablack39
    @andreablack39 9 лет назад

    This is Amazing! But now we know that Charles was Alison's brother I don't know what to believe 😭😭

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Andrea Black He is her brother. I made the theory before season 6 began and we found out. ;)

  • @nothing2say676
    @nothing2say676 9 лет назад +1

    At 3:47, it looks like wren is colouring in Jenna? To me anyway, and its a red coat. when we see the flashback of Jenna and Ali when they met, Jenna was wearing a red hoodie. We don't know much of Jenna and Wrens past so maybe they knew each other and were close. Then when the stuff happened to Jenna, Wren posed as a doctor to see her sometimes (depending on what he did as a doctor, we dont fully know).
    As I said before, Wren looks like he coloured in Jenna with a family. Maybe they are somehow related? You never know!!
    And before when Wren was engaged to Melissa, he applied for a job in Rosewood. where did he work before?! In the place where Jenna went when she became blind??
    Moreover, maybe he hated Ali because of what happened with Jenna - wanted revenge and stuff like Shauna. Maybe, when he was arround Melissa, she influenced him to hating her more because we know Melissa hated Ali.
    Wren worked in Radley when mona was put in. We also know Melissa had a meeting with Mona to 'take Ali down'. What happens if Mona and Wren were planning stuff ready for when she got out and they were talking and agreed to allow Melissa to take part too.
    Most of these come down to Wren and Melissa.
    On the halloween train, Mona says that Melissa was the other queen of hearts. What happens if she just said that cause she knew and payed someone to 'delete all her files' at that moment and the person was actually Wren. Maybe somehow Wren and That police guy (forgot name) (who was in the other costume) knew eachother because we know Melissa and him did. But then that leads back to the idea that it was Melissa in the suit.
    I honestly don't know!
    Reply what u think cause then maybe if we all write our ideas and expand on eachothers and tell whats wrong with them, we can get closer to finding out who 'A' is!

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +2

      Nothing2Say Hi, good theory. Yeah, I guess he did know Jenna, if Bethany was near/in the garage. However, I think the coat Wren colored could symbolise Mrs. D's reddish cardigan she wore in 5x25 at the Campbell farm. I think Wren was the guy with the Ali-mask, who got all cozy with Hanna at the Halloween train (at this time he had a crush on her). Mona claimed it was her, but she's smaller than Hanna and that person was taller, so that's obviously a lie.
      Here are my fifty cents on the Wren/Charles' connection to the other characters:
      Melissa is his Black Widow, blackmailed. CeCe was Red Coat, was payed for distracting Mona and the girls, and sent the "Kisses -A" texts. Ezra is the friend of A/Wren (remember that chair Marlene posted?), he's obviouly in on it, otherwise the dollhouse clues for him wouldn't be there. He also used Wren's cabin in s4. Andrew could be Charles' younger brother. Toby could be the brother instead of Andrew, IF Marion was Jessica's sister. And Aria and Mike are Charles' cousins through Byron's mentally ill brother Scott. That's why the family picture was only in Aria's dollhouse room.

    • @Dervxx
      @Dervxx 9 лет назад

      Nothing2Say omg yes i thought i was the only one that thought that looked like jenna!!!

  • @athenaisgl4929
    @athenaisgl4929 9 лет назад

    You're a genius! it totally makes sense to everything! one week left to figure it all out !!!!!!!

  • @kimbrackin9544
    @kimbrackin9544 9 лет назад

    You are a genius! My theory is VERY similar to the beginning of yours! I've said Wren from the beginning and I'm sticking to him! Even when folks say I'm wrong! #WrenIsA

  • @jassebase
    @jassebase 9 лет назад

    I still think that Wren is somehow connected to all of this. I belive that Bethany was Wrens older sister. In 3.33 in the picture there is two children, one boy and a girl, why is he going around with a drawing like that, and the way he asks Mona about what does she feel or see when she looks at the picture, it obviously means something to him. Remember when Wren said that his father had mental problems, maybe it went on to Bethany also. She ended in Radley, wren got adopted by a british family and something happend to their mother. The new villian is Wren and he is after revenge for Bethanys murder. I also belive that he is the one who killed mrs. D. Besides they still havent told us who board short is. Maybe Wren?

    • @sarahsulaeman5710
      @sarahsulaeman5710 8 лет назад

      +jasse basse Board Shorts is Ezra. Beach hottie is Wilden. I think Wren and Ali are related

  • @melissag0448
    @melissag0448 9 лет назад +1

    I was thinking hard one day.
    Byron has a BROTHER who has mental illness
    Wren has a DAD who has mental illness.
    Maybe Byron's brother & Wren's dad are the SAME person!!!
    Meaning Aria & Wren are cousins

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Mmartinez G Yes!! :D I have a two part cousin theory on my channel. Please check it out.

  • @tine4203
    @tine4203 9 лет назад

    Waouuh 😱 your théories are really amazing 👍 we'll know alla about A soon anyway 😄

  • @flowerpower6111
    @flowerpower6111 9 лет назад +6

    a shoulda been wren ughh hes def not innocent tho. hes prob the one going after ali in the flashforward and had killed mrs d

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Tabbie R. "He" is probably just another red herring. It's gonna be a girl again - as always. There's no point theorizing about the guys anymore, because even if a guy is A, he ends up being a "girl".

    • @flowerpower6111
      @flowerpower6111 9 лет назад

      KaylaSwEet06 Aw I hope not. This whole thing is ridiculous I mean, there are so many unexplained things that make Wren look extremely guilty you know? Juliann Morris even said Wren would be back so we can only hope.

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Tabbie R.
      Maybe he'll be back. In the last five minutes of the show. Standing randomly next to Melissa and waving as the screen goes black. PLL style. Rofl.

    • @flowerpower6111
      @flowerpower6111 9 лет назад

      KaylaSwEet06 hahaha ikr wouldnt be surprised if they did that tbh. but i still believe hes involved

  • @drcgurlstm7073
    @drcgurlstm7073 9 лет назад

    Anyone think Cyrus is Charles? Not completely sure, but it's a theory- He looks a bit like Jason and Marlene (the writer of the books) said that we have seen who "Charles" is before maybe they wanted to make it less obvious as we don't see him as much as other people and will forget about him and think that he is some random person. Ps this is just my theory and I'm not saying that i know that it is Cyrus, it's just a possibility.

  • @malaikakhan339
    @malaikakhan339 9 лет назад

    Wait..how do we know the baby Mrs.D was holding in the video was Alison? She didnt say it was Ali. Was it Bethany? Mrs.D wanted to spend some time with her other daughter too. Also i think the person shooting the video is -A

  • @katelyons4182
    @katelyons4182 9 лет назад

    THIS IS AMAZING!!!

  • @orbitgabby
    @orbitgabby 9 лет назад

    Jolly Good Show. I've always believed Wren was -A

  • @jdjd6792
    @jdjd6792 9 лет назад

    Great theory! good job!

  • @mickeymouse2311
    @mickeymouse2311 9 лет назад

    Amazing theory! I Really think Wren is A!!

  • @dumbo3xtreme453
    @dumbo3xtreme453 7 лет назад

    2:47 LOL look at the picture to the right (the one of the family) and look at Keegan Allen's (Toby Cavanaugh) face!

  • @topazbarel4823
    @topazbarel4823 9 лет назад

    remember that jason said that ian made all the videos af the NAT club but he had people helping him.

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +2

      whip lala Yeah, I think the person Ian and Garrett filmed the videos for was Wren. If he's Beach Hottie, he was probably obsessed with Ali's life. I guess he might have killed Ian too to protect his identity, and because he was insanely jealous and thought Ian snatched Ali and Melissa away from him.

    • @topazbarel4823
      @topazbarel4823 9 лет назад +1

      it's a really good theory

  • @albanianqueen9928
    @albanianqueen9928 9 лет назад

    Some people are so smart i love this theory

  • @isahidalgo3713
    @isahidalgo3713 9 лет назад

    best theory ever!!

  • @allieadams8132
    @allieadams8132 9 лет назад

    Great theory! Also what songs are playing?

  • @OceanSapphirez
    @OceanSapphirez 7 лет назад

    I think the younger boy isn't Andrew .. it's Lucas .. they have a lot of similar features

  • @ItsKelsey
    @ItsKelsey 9 лет назад

    lol haha keegan allen at 2:48😂😂😂👍🏻👍🏻

  • @xmi31
    @xmi31 9 лет назад +1

    Nice theory but the music was really distracting.

  • @didi1422
    @didi1422 9 лет назад

    I always thought wren was A. good Theory!

  • @inspirediy3158
    @inspirediy3158 9 лет назад

    this is a great thory, just a question do u know why ali went away for two years to her "Grandmas"

  • @kimberlycorbin13
    @kimberlycorbin13 9 лет назад

    I don't think that Charles is anyone we have already seen and after seeing a poster I realised something that maybe when Alison was young Charles "died" because the poster said a heart that stopped beating can still beak-A but like Alison was never really dead because Mrs D was upset over Charles death she wanted another child not to really to replace him after finding this out Charles got annoyed and always wanted revenge on this child although I know that Alison is Charles favourites she might be his favourite because he is her brother. Everyone is saying Charles is a transgender and stuff but I don't nesaseraply think that

  • @danikavanagh1985
    @danikavanagh1985 9 лет назад

    Maybe Mrs D wanted Bethany to call her aunty because she didnt want Bethany to call her mum.

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Dani K Doubt it. She couldn't have hidden the pregnancy from Kenneth and her friends and give the child away without anyone noticing. And I don't think they would have mentioned the Aunt Jessie Thing if it isn't t true.

  • @UnknownUser-rp1zv
    @UnknownUser-rp1zv 7 лет назад

    This is so funny watching this now because it's great but it's so wrong it was Cece the whole time 😂😂

  • @charlottevelsen5457
    @charlottevelsen5457 9 лет назад

    wren is A he works in Radley and loves Spencer

  • @whyimsammi8598
    @whyimsammi8598 9 лет назад

    It's amazing how PLL is the only show (I've watched at least--) that leads to the British hottie not to get a single chick! XD

  • @tvdplltheoriginalsig4847
    @tvdplltheoriginalsig4847 9 лет назад

    But Charles is Alison and Jason's brother.
    But it was a good theory

  • @torimartin3240
    @torimartin3240 9 лет назад

    The handwriting doesn't match. When Mona points out that Wren forgot the 'g' in 'diagnosis', you see his handwriting is small capitalized letters where the notes that Charles leaves for the Liars is more messy and spaced out lowercased letters.

    • @waterpark.asitis9564
      @waterpark.asitis9564 9 лет назад

      He could change/fake his handwringing?? He's smarter than that

  • @kewlkiwi8871
    @kewlkiwi8871 9 лет назад

    Remember Shana did the fire at the lodge NOT A

  • @gabigotcher4031
    @gabigotcher4031 8 лет назад

    Charles is CeCe (Charlotte Dilourentes) And Bethany Young killed Toby's mom. tbh

  • @GreeceCombination
    @GreeceCombination 9 лет назад

    Good job 👏🏻💚👌

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад +1

      тнє нoє кιℓℓαz † ► Thanks! Team Wren is A forever. XD

  • @codezero7981
    @codezero7981 8 месяцев назад

    if only this would have happened!

  • @xxTazJaa
    @xxTazJaa 9 лет назад

    Great theory, but isn't Wren in London with Melissa, and has been for a long time now :)?

    • @KaylaSwEet06
      @KaylaSwEet06  9 лет назад

      Natasha Milo He's not in London. He didn't even came back from is "visit" in the U.S. with Melissa. No one knows where he is, lol. XD And none of the girls seem to be interested.

  • @raquelandreocasaseca2647
    @raquelandreocasaseca2647 9 лет назад

    and why would Wren and Bethany be in the garage with jenna and tobe the day of "the Jenna thing"?

  • @buzzybea2148
    @buzzybea2148 9 лет назад

    That could be why wren joined radely

  • @alejandrita2195
    @alejandrita2195 7 лет назад +1

    if wren is arias cousin bethany her sister and bethany is spencer's twin spencer hookup with his brother WTF

  • @isabellstjernstrom1762
    @isabellstjernstrom1762 8 лет назад

    I think Wren has something to do with Elliot

  • @thedemiselenaa
    @thedemiselenaa 9 лет назад +2

    omg this is so good quhshbsdhw

  • @isabellstjernstrom1762
    @isabellstjernstrom1762 8 лет назад

    Wait... Wren left Melissa because Charlotte told that she killed Betheny! :O

  • @flowerpower6111
    @flowerpower6111 9 лет назад

    and he mustve given mona those riddles in radley bc it wasnt cece

  • @janisblackwell9510
    @janisblackwell9510 7 лет назад

    wait in the video the boys are older than the girl, in the drawings the girl is older than the boy

  • @dodkdosnsn3334
    @dodkdosnsn3334 9 лет назад

    I think Ian is a because he might not be dead even though they show his dead body they show Mina's dead body but she wasn't dead also they found Alison's dead body but she is still Ali and Mona is still alive😇😊☺️

  • @torimartin3240
    @torimartin3240 9 лет назад

    I love the video and I think that Wren is Bethany's brother but I don't think that he is A

  • @monamood1667
    @monamood1667 9 лет назад

    pause at 5:01 you will see a baby face and smth like cradle..