She said in the latest Immortal song performance (you raise me up) that for Immortal songs 2 program, she sings like it is the last time she would ever sing in her life. She said she practiced so hard that she felt like gonna die and that's how IMS performance is made. People need to understand she doesn't have to do that in regular stage like in this video. Ofcourse she tries her best, but she started out chilling on a chair and tries not to use her voice too much. This performance was amazing by the way, and I don't expect her to sing like it's her last moment like she did on IMS2.
For all the discussion about her technical difficulties, however justified, I find it hard to focus on them. When I listen to Sohyang singing this rendition, I only feel grateful that she is here to share with us her spiritual journey through this soul-sh,aking song, to give those in need of empathy a guiding light to be positive, thankful, and forward-looking. Maybe I am too much a fanboy, to me, even her perceived flaws are a testimony that she is indeed human achieving great things in life. I am so glad to see this. I have been thinking that this rendition of I Raise Me Up would become just like "Everyone," never to be heard again.
The ending of this live Version is so much better than the undubbed Television Version. Especially the "more than iiiii, moree than iiiiii, uuuuuuu". However, I hope SoHyang has time so rest her amazing voice.
You wanna know how to distinguish an extremely good vocalist from normal vocalists? The former still gives a decent-amazing performance even when they are sick or have vocal fatigue. And those of you who attack singers experiencing bad vocal moments, it's super clear your knowledge in singing is 0 because no vocalist can sound at their 100% 24/7 for 365 days all round.
She may have been not feeling well, but idc if this wasn’t a perfect performance. I’m just happy she’s...well, not nowhere to be seen lmfao. This was such a surprise, I’m so happy to see a new fancam. I was really missing her a lot!
dracaryse She seems to be in bad condition on this day..😔 As you said, I'm glad to see this rare performance! I actually heard this song, but I also appreciate this video.😊
People are really overexaggerating her pitch here. She is only a bit pitchy at a few parts which is normal. Especially during the last part her pitch is really good and we shouldnt forget that the quality of this fancam is very bad. She is sick but she still did amazing here.
JS Lee Yes from my experience too. We cant judge how it sounded from that kind of quality cam. IMO she did amazing and I hope I will get to hear her perform this song more in the future
I Just thank you, Sohyang for performing this song again !! It sounds not so good but a fan who was there said this performance was really better than the one in IMS 2. Considering several factors including the place, instrumental accompaniment, her health condition and so on, this performance is not bad. And this is a fancam! We shouldn't expect too much.
People talk about her pitchy vocal but they don't know how bad health condition she was. I cry when I listened to this performance. It hurts so much. I just want her to rest.
Definitely she was in bad condition but somehow it was 90% technically refined. Imagine she is singing at her best. It is the importance of vocal technique. Your fav cannot even do a half of these performance even at their best.
곡 박자가 매우 자주 바뀌어서 호흡의 양 조절과 성구전환의 난이도가 매우 어려운 곡임. 컨디션이 안 좋아서 아쉬운 부분이 있지만 애초에 다른 가수들은 엄두도 못 낸다는 곡전개임을 감안해야 함! 오히려 박자는 일정하고 고음이 가장 많이 나오는 후반부는 방송 때보다 더 잘 소화함.
Okay, here again, after some years... And I have a question (rhetorical lol)...: Why she likes singing her better and hard versions of the songs when she's ill? Like, I would love to hear this version now in 2022 as she's healthier....
Little Lamb she wasn't going to sing this song at first because she didn't think she would sing this version again and her condition recently wasn't good enought to sing this difficult song. But because this is the concert of Choi Young ho, and You raise me up is the newest collaboration between her and Choi young ho, so she decided to sing it. Please pray for Sohyang more and more
She was only pitchy like 3 times, right? And her voice cracked once? Or am I wrong? I personally thought that this was still a wonderful performance. Her first performance of I Have Nothing is worse imo.
갠적으로 소향팬이고 매일 리액션도 챙겨보는 입장에서 소향 단점 한가지 말하자면 외국인 중에서도 지적이 나온걸로 아는데 티비말고 일반 공연에서는 감정을 좀더 자유롭게 실을려고해서 그런지 좀 격앙이 되는 경향이 강함. 뭔가 소향은 방송같은 큰 무대에서 오히려 완벽하게 보이기 위해 자제가 들어갔을 태 감정과 테크닉이 딱 알맞다고 생각함.
jeonmaje 혹시 소향의 라이브는 가 보셨는지, 아니면 유튜브의 영상만 보시고 하는 말씀이신지.. 저는 개인적으로 콘서트에서는 그 '격앙' 이 어느 정도 필요하다고 봅니다. 안정된 피치를 약간 포기하더라도 그 장소와의 소통을 위해서는 감수할 수 있다고 봅니다. 그 어느 세계적인 아티스트라도 라이브를 할때는 그 '격앙' 이 있고 공식적으로 영상화할 때는 어느 정도 보정을 하는건데, 문제는 최근에 누구나 찍을 수 있는 직캠이 문제라고 생각합니다. 저는 티비에서의 소향도 물론 좋아하지만 라이브에서의 퍼포먼스가 더 감동적이였거든요
luke powell it’s not bad, just not as good or polished as her IS2 performance. This is a very challenging song for a concert which requires a lot of vocal stamina. Thought she struggled a little with her transitions in the middle but her high notes in the climax were resonant and on point. Overall still a very impressive showing.
![[HQ최고음질] 소향(Sohyang)- You Raise Me Up (불후의명곡 '웨스트라이프' 편)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/r_kaWAaW8u8/mqdefault.jpg)
She said in the latest Immortal song performance (you raise me up) that for Immortal songs 2 program, she sings like it is the last time she would ever sing in her life. She said she practiced so hard that she felt like gonna die and that's how IMS performance is made. People need to understand she doesn't have to do that in regular stage like in this video. Ofcourse she tries her best, but she started out chilling on a chair and tries not to use her voice too much. This performance was amazing by the way, and I don't expect her to sing like it's her last moment like she did on IMS2.
So Hyang's Tired vocals, Pitchy or whatever you call it, is still capable of causing extinction of pretty much the whole industry. Period.
She was sick in this 😭
Poor lady was fighting for her life. She did wonderful though
위기감을 직감했는지 바로 직립해보는 프로. 가진 40개의 음을 입체적으로 제어하는 게 항상 쉬운 일은 아닐 것. Anxiety raised her up.
Incredible Queen Sohyang 🥰🤭👍
It's really great. Her song is always amazing even though it is always live. It is a gift, the heaven gave us.
늘 부르시던 편곡일까불명 편곡일까 ,, 약 1분 정도는 긴가민가 하고 있었는데1분 뒤 me~ 나오고 불명 편곡이길래 저절로 입가에 미소가 ㅎㅎ
For all the discussion about her technical difficulties, however justified, I find it hard to focus on them. When I listen to Sohyang singing this rendition, I only feel grateful that she is here to share with us her spiritual journey through this soul-sh,aking song, to give those in need of empathy a guiding light to be positive, thankful, and forward-looking. Maybe I am too much a fanboy, to me, even her perceived flaws are a testimony that she is indeed human achieving great things in life. I am so glad to see this. I have been thinking that this rendition of I Raise Me Up would become just like "Everyone," never to be heard again.
The ending of this live Version is so much better than the undubbed Television Version. Especially the "more than iiiii, moree than iiiiii, uuuuuuu". However, I hope SoHyang has time so rest her amazing voice.
I LOVE YOU SOHYANG!!! YOU ALWAYS IN MY HEART😭😘😘😍😍❤
오랜만에 좋은 영상 너무 좋네요~^^
소향 님이 부른 You raise me up 은 최고인 듯👍
You wanna know how to distinguish an extremely good vocalist from normal vocalists? The former still gives a decent-amazing performance even when they are sick or have vocal fatigue. And those of you who attack singers experiencing bad vocal moments, it's super clear your knowledge in singing is 0 because no vocalist can sound at their 100% 24/7 for 365 days all round.
She may have been not feeling well, but idc if this wasn’t a perfect performance. I’m just happy she’s...well, not nowhere to be seen lmfao. This was such a surprise, I’m so happy to see a new fancam. I was really missing her a lot!
dracaryse She seems to be in bad condition on this day..😔
As you said, I'm glad to see this rare performance! I actually heard this song, but I also appreciate this video.😊
The recording itself is not good either
Definitely she was in bad condition but somehow it was 90% technically refined. Imagine she is singing at her best.
People are really overexaggerating her pitch here. She is only a bit pitchy at a few parts which is normal. Especially during the last part her pitch is really good and we shouldnt forget that the quality of this fancam is very bad.
She is sick but she still did amazing here.
JS Lee Yes from my experience too. We cant judge how it sounded from that kind of quality cam.
IMO she did amazing and I hope I will get to hear her perform this song more in the future
exactly! the f#5 here is actually better than the immortal songs version imo
Definitely she was in bad condition but somehow it was 90% technically refined. Imagine she is singing at her best.
she needs REST......please QUEEN SH... get a rest...for your voice.....we want you to sing more for us...your voice is such a treasure!!!......
She wasn't in the best condition here but, the ending tho, sounds so bright
항상 느끼는데 이런 편곡을 외우시는게 더신기함...편곡이 진짜 재창조수준인데 어떻게 다 외워서 구현하시는지 신기;
Finally this version!!!😍😍😍 I always love you...sohyang
I Just thank you, Sohyang for performing this song again !! It sounds not so good but a fan who was there said this performance was really better than the one in IMS 2. Considering several factors including the place, instrumental accompaniment, her health condition and so on, this performance is not bad. And this is a fancam! We shouldn't expect too much.
I Love You For Posting This!
Despite being sick, she's still able to hit those f#5.
Wow... 😮😮😮😘💗💗💗💗😘
Omg that f#5 belt 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
For me she' ll always be an angel...😇😘😍
와......ㅠㅠ 건강 때문에 컨디션도 안 좋으셨을텐데 여전히 대단한 ㄷㄷ
People talk about her pitchy vocal but they don't know how bad health condition she was. I cry when I listened to this performance. It hurts so much. I just want her to rest.
Mệt nhưng chị still slay nhé 😘😘😘
소향님 요즘 미친듯이 달리시는데 왠지 이러고 장기휴식하실듯 부디 건강을 1순위로 챙기시길
Definitely she was in bad condition but somehow it was 90% technically refined. Imagine she is singing at her best. It is the importance of vocal technique. Your fav cannot even do a half of these performance even at their best.
곡 박자가 매우 자주 바뀌어서 호흡의 양 조절과 성구전환의 난이도가 매우 어려운 곡임. 컨디션이 안 좋아서 아쉬운 부분이 있지만 애초에 다른 가수들은 엄두도 못 낸다는 곡전개임을 감안해야 함! 오히려 박자는 일정하고 고음이 가장 많이 나오는 후반부는 방송 때보다 더 잘 소화함.
When will she sing this version again
그녀의 목소리를 모두 담아내긴 힘든영상이었지만...
영상만으로 진심이 느겨진다 ㄷㄷ
역시 소향
Okay, here again, after some years... And I have a question (rhetorical lol)...: Why she likes singing her better and hard versions of the songs when she's ill?
Like, I would love to hear this version now in 2022 as she's healthier....
Sounds so tired and pitchy. Queen please get some rest.😭😭😭😭
Little Lamb she wasn't going to sing this song at first because she didn't think she would sing this version again and her condition recently wasn't good enought to sing this difficult song. But because this is the concert of Choi Young ho, and You raise me up is the newest collaboration between her and Choi young ho, so she decided to sing it. Please pray for Sohyang more and more
_ Hwang Definitely😭
I hope people dont force her to sing this version again suddenly , this song need alot preparation before go to stage
Definitely she was in bad condition but somehow it was 90% technically refined. Imagine she is singing at her best.
황님 여기 가신건가..? 대단하시다..😯
Queen!!!!!
I HAVENT EVEN WATCHED IT YET N IM ALRDY SCREAMING
afro jack omg sammmeee
My queen 😍😍😍
OMG I CAN'T BELIEVE SHE PERFORMED THIS PERFECTLY 😱😱😱😍😘
Finally,, she perform this song live, still amazing....😃😃
😗☺☺☺😘
오옹? 드뎌 불러주셨군여
This was actually better than the original one, especially in the climax parts, she gets less pitchy here compared to the IS2 one
Omg she slayyyyyeedddd. Im so happy rn 💜💜💜💜
처음보는 영상이다.. first time,, 편곡 정말 어렵게 했네...
She was only pitchy like 3 times, right? And her voice cracked once? Or am I wrong? I personally thought that this was still a wonderful performance. Her first performance of I Have Nothing is worse imo.
대단히 어려운 곡이였군요..
드럼 소리가 너무커 ㅠㅠ
근데 컨디션은 좋은편이 아닌것 같네요ㅠㅠ
드럼 에바 너무큼 곡 너무 템포가 빠른 듯 노래 부르기 핵 어렵겠다
목 회복하세요ㅜㅜ감기걸리신건가 흑흑
폐렴이요 ㅠㅠ 목쓰시면 안되는데
직캠으로들어 보니까 미친 난이도로 부르는곡 이네요 ㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷㄷ
불후곡들은 오케스트라 사운드가 아니면 당시 느낌을 살리기 힘들꺼같네요
하지만 소향님의 보컬은 여전히 놀랍습니다 👏👏👏
떳다 황님 영상 홍대공연 1st(첫댓글) 놓칠수 없음 🐹👍 피곤으로 잠자서 못감 2시간자고 일어나니 폭우가☔ (24시간 근무에 축구응원 여파 장사가 쓸어짐😴) 그냥 홍대가서 남는자리 들어갈라했는데 😭
좀 쉬셨으면 좋겠는데.....폐 건강 나을때까진.
헐 소양 왕팬인데 핸드폰으로 찍어서 그런가요? 음정이 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
컨디션이...............
갠적으로 소향팬이고 매일 리액션도 챙겨보는 입장에서 소향 단점 한가지 말하자면 외국인 중에서도 지적이 나온걸로 아는데 티비말고 일반 공연에서는 감정을 좀더 자유롭게 실을려고해서 그런지 좀 격앙이 되는 경향이 강함. 뭔가 소향은 방송같은 큰 무대에서 오히려 완벽하게 보이기 위해 자제가 들어갔을 태 감정과 테크닉이 딱 알맞다고 생각함.
jeonmaje 혹시 소향의 라이브는 가 보셨는지, 아니면 유튜브의 영상만 보시고 하는 말씀이신지..
저는 개인적으로 콘서트에서는 그 '격앙' 이 어느 정도 필요하다고 봅니다. 안정된 피치를 약간 포기하더라도 그 장소와의 소통을 위해서는 감수할 수 있다고 봅니다. 그 어느 세계적인 아티스트라도 라이브를 할때는 그 '격앙' 이 있고 공식적으로 영상화할 때는 어느 정도 보정을 하는건데, 문제는 최근에 누구나 찍을 수 있는 직캠이 문제라고 생각합니다. 저는 티비에서의 소향도 물론 좋아하지만 라이브에서의 퍼포먼스가 더 감동적이였거든요
직캠영상들 보다보면 간혹 그런 라이브가 종종 있는 것 같긴해요 (박자라던지 피치가 )
그런게 좋을때도 있지만 가끔 지나치면 컨디션이 많이 안좋으신가 하고 생각이드는
불후의명곡이나 나가수같은 티비프로와 이런 라이브공연은 엄연히 다를수밖에없어요 티비프로는 보정작업이들어간버전이라고 생각하심될듯하구요 쉽게말하면 음원과라이브의차이라고 생각하심될듯요 컨디션도 한몫하겠지만 또대부분 폰으로촬영후 영상을올리기때문에 현장소음?으로인해 좀더 안좋게 들릴수도있죠.....그래도 소향님은 머다? 사랑입니다
im in love with her but this performance was bad. she was so pitchy and her voice kept cracking. I really hope she focuses on her health and rest.
luke powell it’s not bad, just not as good or polished as her IS2 performance. This is a very challenging song for a concert which requires a lot of vocal stamina. Thought she struggled a little with her transitions in the middle but her high notes in the climax were resonant and on point. Overall still a very impressive showing.
Considering her health, I don't think this is bad performance.
Still amazing. That's all I can say.
Whats exactly wrong with her health? People have been saying that for over a year.
luke powell She has pneumonia and a weak immune system due to her cancer years ago and is therefore really easily attacked by colds and flus.
Definitely she was in bad condition but somehow it was 90% technically refined. Imagine she is singing at her best.
nghe hát cứ lạc tone :v
Bệnh r bạn ơi
so messy...
Lẹ gớm
it sounds bad, seem like she really weak
Shadow Filed she wasn’t feeling well, which is understandable.
Because So Hyang is also human, there may be health and condition problems😞
and the sound problem seems to be included.
불명버전 또 불러주실까 ?..(간절)
개미쳤군...........폐렴 완쾌하실때까지 좀 쉬셔요 1절 피치가 살짝씩 이탈되네요 후반부는 방송때보다 잘한듯한ㅋ