As a Pakistani muslim as kids we are brought up reading ض as the Z sound. And let me tell you ít sometimes becomes very difficult to keep our tongue on the right track. May ALLAH guide us and make the right path easy for us ameen.
thank you, as a Saudi who always uses " ض" and "ظ" interchangeably in every aspect of my life, even in reading books and literature I never pronounce it the same when reading the Quran, nor anyone I know. May Allah bless you.
Not a big issue in daily life even in India ض،ظ،ذ all spoken as ز but in Qur'an pronounciation must be correct as explained . Even my teacher told ض is like د in Qur'an and ز in Urdu
ما هي بفصحى التي كتبتها بل اعجمية صرفة بحروف عربية جرب يا أخي ابحث عن "رغم" في القرآن والسنة أتجدها بمعنى مع أو نحن في لهجتنا نقول مع أن وهذه الفصحى الحقيقية وأيضا ترا العربية الفصحى لا تقال بل يقال اللسان العربي واستزادة ارجع إلى كتاب العرنجية للترجمان أحمد الغامدي
@@Abdullah14700 أولا القرآن أُنزل قبل وضع قواعد اللغة العربية، ولاحقا وضعت القواعد بناءا عليه وبقيت بعض الكلمات والجمل شاذة عن القواعد الموضوعة ثانيا ارجع لمعجم لسان العرب لترى ان رغم بمعنى الاكراه ثالثا ليس كل ما لم يوجد بالقرآن والسنة والمعاجم ومخطوطات الجاهلية وما قبلها وما بعدها بالضرورة ان يكون اعجميا فالعربية لغة حية تُستجَد فيها ألفاظ وكلمات لتواكب الحياة رابعا اللغة هي وصف مشتق من لسان فاللغة العربية هي ذاتها لسان العرب
This video came at the right time! Just 10mins ago I had a student reading a ض as a ظ inذرّيّة ضعفاء.... And the example with Sh Uthman Al Khamis is a great example! The problem is that some people use the tip of the tongue to pronounce the ض which is where the problem lies. The tip of the tongue is used to pronounce the ظ.
Masha Allah TabarakAllah is beautiful and reminds us all to clarify this mistake, especially for myself, who is non Arabic speaking. Jazakallahu Khayran, usthad . May Allah rewards you immensely, Ameen
Ma sha Allah!! Very much needed video.... I had this doubt for years that why different people pronounce differently for these letters.... Happy to know that I was reciting in the proper way! Alhamdullilah!
Even though I agree that we should try our best to learn to recite the Qurān in the best possible way. But for non-Arabic speakers sometimes its quite hard to pronounce some letters. So, I personally think that in such cases "intention" is what counts. Allah knows the best. But still Jazak-Allah Khair for the informative lesson. I definitely benefited from it.
@@speakerscornerchristianfil4318 seriously?? Qiraat (recitation) differences are well acknoweleged among Muslims. This is not good enough. Do some extra work a real academic work. I can understand you need "views" and lately you aren't even getting 50 views on your videos. So work hard. Make videos in an educated manner and I am sure your views will increase. Best of luck :D
the Vh, ظ is like in Russian “Vladimir” or Ukrainian “Vidd” the ض on the other hand is either a D د or an eth Ð ذ, that is pharyngealised. Pharyngealisation is hard, but think of the L sound in english. The L in english is almost always pharyngealised and called a “Dark L” think of the difference in L, in english “Lame” and Arabic “لام” Lam. Arabic L is not pharyngealised most of the time, while the english is. Then after you got it, apply the same thing with the D, or the Ð, then this way you got your ض correctly. And all praise is to Allāh, in victory and defeat.
@@pactube8833 Guys im from arabic countries, i dont know why you guys dont understand ض 😅 its just a letter and i may help you guys but i don't understand the reason of being not understand this letter
MashaAllah great video! I've grown up in my young age pronouncing ض as ز but Alhamdulillah now know better. My biggest issue is the different ways to pronounce ظ in the Quran but will be watching your video on that as well InshaAllah.
I'm so thankful for this video. Arabic is not a native language where I am from, so growing up I really had difficulty understanding and had similar confusions. I'm glad that there are videos like these being made now.
Mashallah. You are the best Tajweed teacher I have seen. May Allah bless you and your family and power you to continue producing videos such as this. Appreciate your knowledge and time. Jazakallahu khairan. Your in depth analysis amazes me.
I've been pronouncing it the same way you taught and never found any difficulty but I didn't know the authentic reason you gave.This was really helpful 🇵🇰 جزاک اللّٰہ
الحمد لله. جزاك الله خير. بارك الله فيك. What an explanation! Brother, in Tamil Nadu, South India they pronounce the letter ظ- similar to L sound. May Allah guide all of us to recite his purified Arabic Quran as it is revealed to our prophet محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم. Really there is no doubt your videos and courses help. إن شاء الله, بإذن الله تعالى
جزاك الله خيرا يا أستاذ As I am from Bangladesh, I know about the issue. I was confused how should I pronounce ض sound, /D/ or /Z/ while reciting Al-Qur'an. I considered that, Al-Qur'an might have revealed where ض sound is pronounced as /D/, thinking that, the Persian brothers might have taken this sound wrongly. So, I pronounce it like /D/. I wasn't quite comfortable, as I wasn't sure how the sound ض was truly spoken while Al-Qur'an was revealed on Prophet Mohammad ﷺ. Alhamdulillah, I finally can be sure about it.
There are Qurra' (by this I mean certified Qurra') who pronounce the letter ض with a sound close to the letter ظ, or with a "z" sound, rather than a sound closer to a "d" which we hear today. These Qurra' have chains of narration reaching back to the Prophet ﷺ, thus their sanads are equally as valid as the others. This pronunciation also stays consistent with the textual descriptions of ض, whereas the current pronunciation does not. Many Qurra' were taught this pronunciation and went against what they were taught due to social pressures later in life, thus opposing the teaching of their sanad, yet attributing it to that sanad. An example of this is the students of Qari Anees Ahmad Khan Falahi (ra). I recently verified from a student of Qari Anees himself that Qari Anees (ra) taught the pronunciation of ض as a sound very close to ظ, and this was how he was taught. However, many of his students, such as Qari Siddique Falahi and Qari Ayoub Essack (who is a link in my own chain), actually went against what they were taught by Qari Anees due to social pressure from Arab Qurra'. Dr. Jonathan Brown also mentions he found Qurra' in Turkey who pronounced it this way. Qari Muhammad Yahya Shareef also quotes from Shaykh Ubaydullah Afghani who lists a plethora of scholars in his compilation (تنبيه العباد إلى كيفية النطق بالضاد) who pronounced the letter this way but their students evidently went away from the pronunciation despite still labeling themselves with that Sanad. A significant example of this is the great Shaykh Samannudi (ra) who argued for this pronunciation throughout his life and yet was pressured to retract it at the end of his life rahimahullah.
MASHA ALLAH! Well, sometimes I make this mistake when reciting the Qur'an this happens when I want to pronounce the word FAD-lillah then changing it to FAZ-lillah. Sheikh thank you for making distinctive clarity about these two alphabets. It is well understood and well assimilated. I really appreciate. JazzakAllahu khairan...
I never knew this was an issue. Logically the problem should be between ض and د or ظ and ذ and ز but even then as an Arab it is easy to differentiate...
@@taffem9084 for me it's 'ayn since it's a voiced ha that's the diff of Salahuddin and salah as in prayer, the pharyngealized is hard but not as far as ha iirc not English ha
Assalamualaikum! Thank you! As I am currently learning the quranic Arabic words. I am grateful to you for pointing out the right pronunciation of this particular letters. This is fun! Surely, there's more to find. Salamualaikum.
The Dhod proounciation is like reaching the tongue to the upper teeth, and Dzo prounciation is like placing your tongue at the incisors and pronounce it like you gonna pronounce Zay.
I agree with some other comments here. You should have put forward both views about the pronunciation of ض, the classical view under which it is pronounced very similarly to ظ, and the more modern view under which its sound is similar to د. Yasir Qadhi has a very useful and detailed discussion about this matter on his RUclips channel and says that both views are sound. So, it's not correct to outright dismiss a legitimate view about the pronunciation of this letter. However, to your credit, and this is something perhaps you could have mentioned in this video, we are told by the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) to recite in the way of the Arabs. Since most Arabs follow the modern view about the pronunciation of ض, it could be argued that that is the way everyone should pronounce as well.
I am from Pakistan and yes ض is pronounced very similarly t ظ ز ذ. Urdu is like the three way child of arabic, persian and hindi and it uses the same alphabet as Arabic and in Urdu it is really supposed to be pronounced to be like that. We also have گ, چ and پ.
@@GholamFareed I suggest both of you to look for this lecture " The Language (and Letter) of ض | Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi" on youtube. it will give you some historic perspective on this issue. IA
Assalam o Alaikum wa rehmatullah wa barakatuh... I am new to this channel. I could just listen to a very of your lessons. These are admirable. Please share your brief introduction. Jazakumullah Khaira Kaseera
When i was a teenager my teacher pronounced ض as ظ. That stunned me everytime she read Qur‘an. I asked her why she did it she said that it was not correct but ok.
في مجموع الفتاوى لشيخ الإسلام ابن تيمية رحمه الله قال وأما من لا يقيم قراءة الفاتحة فلا يصلي خلفه إلا من هو مثله فلا يصلي خلف الألثغ الذي يبدل حرفا بحرف إلا حرف الضاد إذا أخرجه من طرف الفم كما هو عادة كثير من الناس فهذا فيه وجهان: منهم من قال: لا يصلى خلفه ولا تصح صلاته في نفسه لأنه أبدل حرفا بحرف؛ لأن مخرج الضاد الشدق ومخرج الظاء طرف الأسنان. فإذا قال (ولا الظالين) كان معناه ظل يفعل كذا. والوجه الثاني: تصح وهذا أقرب لأن الحرفين في السمع شيء واحد وحس أحدهما من جنس حس الآخر لتشابه المخرجين. يعني صوت الضاد والظاء في السمع شيء واحد
شاهدت الفيديو بالصدفة , وانا سعيد جدا ان صاحب القناة متمكن جدا في شرح الطرق الصحيحة لنطق الحروف العربية لكن بالرغم من سعادتى فقد احسست بالوجع , كم من نعمة انا فيها ولست ادركها في النهاية اسال الله العلى القدير ان يعين اخواننا المسلمين غير الناطقين بالعربية , وان يجعل مجهودهم في ميزان حسناتهم وان يجزيهم خير الجزاء
Things should not be so complicated for general people because Allah knows best how sincere are our hearts, so scholarly pronunciation is not possible for all.
يقال عن اللّغة العربية أيضا لغة الضّاد لأنّ لا يوجد في بقيّة لغات العالَم نطق لهذا الحرف ( ض) من حيث وضعيّة اللٌسان و طريقة النّطق الفريد به إلّا في اللّغة العربيّة الجميلة جدّا فقط..
Thank you so much for this video! As an English speaker, I get so confused by the transliteration that puts a z instead of ظ so sometimes I would say Al azeem
To make it easy ض is the heavy form of د but ظ is the heavy form of ذ Here are some other examples with other letters: ط and ت ص and س ح and هـ ع and أ ق and ك
ض---sswhaadh is pronounced by touching the left edges of the tongue to the bottom edges of the left teeth of the upper jaw. ظ---is pronounced by making the mouth square shaped with tongue slightly pulled out Throwing air and saying zhouaa
Of course there's a difference between ظ and ض. But today ض is pronounced more like a hard د. If we look at the tajwid books we see that the letter ض has a characteristic called رخاوة which with today's pronunciation is lost. Earlier tajwid scholars write that the closest to ض letter is ظ and not د. Also there are early recordings here on RUclips by Egyptian and other Shaykhs who explain the letter ض sounding more like ظ in stead of د. Please, comment on this.
Brother, the reason why is because both are fricatives (orginally) the ظ was made with the lips, called a labial fricative (like english V, closest to a Slavic V) while the ض is the pharyngealised version of ذ, like in english Ba*the* called a dental fricative.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته ما شاء الله لا قوة إلا بالله، شرح رائع ومفصل ومفيد، جزاك الله خيراً أخي ووفقك لما يحبه ويرضاه، على الرغم من أنني عربية، واللغة العربية لغتي الأم، إلا أنني أخطأ في نطق الضاد، بعد مشاهدة المقطع أستطيع الآن نطقها بشكل صحيح.
TO DO JUSTICE with this Subject ,it is better to differentiate between د andض also with examples like ضل and دل as you have differentiated between ضand ظ or ز,so excellently. CAN you add this differentiation between ضand د as well, by editing the same video /this video of yours?JazakaAllah.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته ... أخي الكريم جزاكم الله خيرا ... أفضل طريقة للنطق السليم لحرفي ض - ظ هي بأن تنطق حرف الضاد بطعم (مذاق) حرف الدال . ضلّ = دلّ . ونطق حرف الظاء بطعم (مذاق) حرف الذال . ظلال = ذلال .
Asslamo alikom brother, I have a separate lesson specially for that matter: ruclips.net/video/_344AVeWcQI/видео.html Please watch it and let me know if you have any further questions Asslamo alikom
Woah Mashallah. First time seeing this channel. New subscriber here. I'm a Qur'an teacher so this is very important to me. I shall be teaching this to my students insha'Allah, they make the same mistakes on ض ظ ز It took me quite a while to fix ض but I still don't think I'm there🤗, soon insha'Allah
To me, it is a simple question of point of articulation and manner of articulation. ض is alveolar plosive while ظ is dental fricative. All other aspects are the same. Since the sounds are destinct, they should not be confused. However, such confusion is understandable due to the general historical tendency of plosives to evolve into fricatives.
Thank you so much for clarification. I am a Pakistani who learned Quran using sound of few of the Arabic letters such as two mentioned in this video, as pronounced in Urdu. I have been paying attention to pronounce the Quran correctly.
This is the most correct explanation that there is out there. I looked this up myself a few years ago, and this is almost exactly what the scholars said. I pointed this out to a non-Arabic speaking brother who, Masha'Allah, memorized the Holy Quran, but he never accepted my showing him the difference between the two sounds! His teacher had taught him one thing and he sticks to it! Now, when he leads us in prayer, I hear "thalleen" at the end of al fatihah and not "dalleen." Thank you for clarifying this issue.
@@IslamIsTheBest12131 ظ or ض ؟ As an Arabic speaking person, it really bothers me to hear الضالين sound more like الظالين. How confusing it must be for those who are learning the Quran and Arabic!
In Subcontinent there is a great controversy Some pronounce ض as a full mouth د or ز ، since they cannot oronounce even ظً correctly. Further they add a letter Vau و as well. For example ضا is either pronounced as Zua or زوا by the supporters of ز sound and a full mouth دوا by the supporters of full mouth د.. In Sind some also pronounce ض as ڏ ، which is a special letter of Sindhi language. Even scholar of Tajvid dispute. They dispute among themselves that in the case when people cannot pronounce ظ and ذ but can pronunce ز and a full mouth د then one group prefer the latter and the other prefer the former. Some times even practical fightings had occurred. Some people had even lost their lives in such fights. But at present such problems continue with less violence.
![[DRAGON BALL LEGENDS REVEALS ＆ STUFF] LEGENDS FESTIVAL 2024 Special Edition Part 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/mV5bGIswTtQ/mqdefault.jpg)
As a Pakistani muslim as kids we are brought up reading ض as the Z sound. And let me tell you ít sometimes becomes very difficult to keep our tongue on the right track. May ALLAH guide us and make the right path easy for us ameen.
Same for us Indians
The Pakistani pronunciation is closer to the correct sound than this fake shit.
Ameen
That's exactly what I have been taught too!
This is exactly the lesson I have been needing. Jazak Allah
Yea the lesson for ALLAH
JkaAJS
For me too
@@hailafitri6420 do you even understand what he said?
@@hailafitri6420 ..ردّك لا يُناسِب ما كتب صاحب التّعليق ..
ما دخل كلمة Allah 🤔 ؟؟
The ض is behind the the upper teeth
The ظ is underneath the upper teeth
Try it
ضرب / مظله
Thank you. Jazakallah khair
I like ur comment, very helpful to me
wtf ur acc right
Very useful thnx
May I ask where exactly on the upper teeth is it?
thank you, as a Saudi who always uses " ض" and "ظ" interchangeably in every aspect of my life, even in reading books and literature I never pronounce it the same when reading the Quran, nor anyone I know.
May Allah bless you.
We do the same in Tunisia. Always when it comes to reading Quran.. things changes and we pronounce them in the right way
Not a big issue in daily life even in India ض،ظ،ذ all spoken as ز but in Qur'an pronounciation must be correct as explained . Even my teacher told ض is like د in Qur'an and ز in Urdu
@@faizanhashmi389 ?
Ameen
You were doing it right. Sadly Egyptian propaganda got to you now
كان الله في عون إخواننا المسلمين في كل مكان على تعلم اللغه العربيه واحمد الله أني متكلم للعربيه
جزاك الله خيرا
Ameen
شاهدت الفيديو كاملاً رغم أني عربي 😂
وكتبت بالعربية الفصحى بدلاً من العامية حتى يسهل عليكم فهمي
ما هي بفصحى التي كتبتها بل اعجمية صرفة بحروف عربية
جرب يا أخي ابحث عن "رغم" في القرآن والسنة أتجدها بمعنى مع أو نحن في لهجتنا نقول مع أن وهذه الفصحى الحقيقية وأيضا ترا العربية الفصحى لا تقال بل يقال اللسان العربي واستزادة ارجع إلى كتاب العرنجية للترجمان أحمد الغامدي
@@Abdullah14700 ذبحتنا يا عبدالله وين ما اروح اشوفك
@@Abdullah14700
أولا القرآن أُنزل قبل وضع قواعد اللغة العربية، ولاحقا وضعت القواعد بناءا عليه وبقيت بعض الكلمات والجمل شاذة عن القواعد الموضوعة
ثانيا ارجع لمعجم لسان العرب لترى ان رغم بمعنى الاكراه
ثالثا ليس كل ما لم يوجد بالقرآن والسنة والمعاجم ومخطوطات الجاهلية وما قبلها وما بعدها بالضرورة ان يكون اعجميا فالعربية لغة حية تُستجَد فيها ألفاظ وكلمات لتواكب الحياة
رابعا اللغة هي وصف مشتق من لسان فاللغة العربية هي ذاتها لسان العرب
@@Abdullah14700 كل قبيلة او منطقة لها لهجتها الخاصة.
ايه المضحك؟
This video came at the right time!
Just 10mins ago I had a student reading a ض as a ظ inذرّيّة ضعفاء....
And the example with Sh Uthman Al Khamis is a great example!
The problem is that some people use the tip of the tongue to pronounce the ض which is where the problem lies. The tip of the tongue is used to pronounce the ظ.
But how is it that we should pronounce both the letters?
ظ :
A "heavy" form of the sound of ذ
ض:
A "heavy" form of the sound of د
@@xXJ4FARGAMERXx wrong explaintion because every arabic word are difference between they don't have a similar sounds
@@xXJ4FARGAMERXxض is not a heavy د
Masha Allah TabarakAllah is beautiful and reminds us all to clarify this mistake, especially for myself, who is non Arabic speaking. Jazakallahu Khayran, usthad . May Allah rewards you immensely, Ameen
Ameen
أنا عربية أتعلم القرءان و مخارج الحروف و ماشاء الله مخارج حروفك صحيحه
سدد الله الخطي ... عظم الله الأجر أخي
حياكم الله ،،
جزاكم الله خيرًا على المرور و التشجيع
أسأل الله أن ينفع بالعمل و يتقبله ، آمين
@@Arabic101 آمين
@@Arabic101 آمين
@@Arabic101
آمين
Ma sha Allah!! Very much needed video.... I had this doubt for years that why different people pronounce differently for these letters.... Happy to know that I was reciting in the proper way! Alhamdullilah!
This is amazing, the more i watch the more I'm amazed by the revision of the Qur'an
Jazak-Allahu-khair brother.......i was reciting surah fatiha wrong......now i will recite it correctly insha-Allah
Alhamdulilah .. Alhamdulilah .. Barak Allahu fik
Even though I agree that we should try our best to learn to recite the Qurān in the best possible way. But for non-Arabic speakers sometimes its quite hard to pronounce some letters. So, I personally think that in such cases "intention" is what counts. Allah knows the best. But still Jazak-Allah Khair for the informative lesson. I definitely benefited from it.
If there is only one quran then why is surah 2.184 different in the different qurans ruclips.net/video/jvqUSYAhm-c/видео.html
@@speakerscornerchristianfil4318 seriously?? Qiraat (recitation) differences are well acknoweleged among Muslims. This is not good enough. Do some extra work a real academic work. I can understand you need "views" and lately you aren't even getting 50 views on your videos. So work hard. Make videos in an educated manner and I am sure your views will increase. Best of luck :D
In Indonesian translation, we say (ض) as dh, and (ظ) as zh.
For me, the most difficult is (ض).
Keep trying Akhii...
I know you will be able to pronounce it correctly in the Quran Recitement...
Inshaa Allah...
This is why we call Arabic: The language of (ض).
Because it's very difficult for non-Arabic people.
the Vh, ظ is like in Russian “Vladimir” or Ukrainian “Vidd”
the ض on the other hand is either a D د or an eth Ð ذ, that is pharyngealised.
Pharyngealisation is hard, but think of the L sound in english.
The L in english is almost always pharyngealised and called a “Dark L”
think of the difference in L, in english “Lame”
and Arabic “لام” Lam.
Arabic L is not pharyngealised most of the time, while the english is.
Then after you got it, apply the same thing with the D, or the Ð, then this way you got your ض correctly.
And all praise is to Allāh, in victory and defeat.
Yes, they are close, but not exactly Try more and you will be able to pronounce them,Insha'Allah
@@pactube8833 Guys im from arabic countries, i dont know why you guys dont understand ض 😅 its just a letter and i may help you guys but i don't understand the reason of being not understand this letter
MashaAllah great video! I've grown up in my young age pronouncing ض as ز but Alhamdulillah now know better.
My biggest issue is the different ways to pronounce ظ in the Quran but will be watching your video on that as well InshaAllah.
That one is a very hard V. it exists in Russian names and words as in Vladimir.
I'm so thankful for this video. Arabic is not a native language where I am from, so growing up I really had difficulty understanding and had similar confusions. I'm glad that there are videos like these being made now.
Mashallah. You are the best Tajweed teacher I have seen. May Allah bless you and your family and power you to continue producing videos such as this. Appreciate your knowledge and time. Jazakallahu khairan. Your in depth analysis amazes me.
I've been pronouncing it the same way you taught and never found any difficulty but I didn't know the authentic reason you gave.This was really helpful 🇵🇰
جزاک اللّٰہ
The thing i use for detect ص،ض، ط، ظ is put them [not heavy] like this:
س
this is very important. We are blessed to have this kind of knowledge so easily in reach. May Allah reward you immensely for the work you are doing
Ameen
الحمد لله. جزاك الله خير. بارك الله فيك.
What an explanation!
Brother, in Tamil Nadu, South India they pronounce the letter ظ- similar to L sound.
May Allah guide all of us to recite his purified Arabic Quran as it is revealed to our prophet
محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم.
Really there is no doubt your videos and courses help.
إن شاء الله, بإذن الله تعالى
Impressive style of teaching....inshallah now we will teach my students like this
الحمدلله على نعمتك يا الله أنك خلقتني مسلمًا عربيّا
Assalâmu alaykum Brother,
Interestingly, in the turkish we say ramazan for رمضان, but for قاضي we say Kadı 😅
جزاك الله خيرا يا أستاذ
As I am from Bangladesh, I know about the issue. I was confused how should I pronounce ض sound, /D/ or /Z/ while reciting Al-Qur'an. I considered that, Al-Qur'an might have revealed where ض sound is pronounced as /D/, thinking that, the Persian brothers might have taken this sound wrongly. So, I pronounce it like /D/. I wasn't quite comfortable, as I wasn't sure how the sound ض was truly spoken while Al-Qur'an was revealed on Prophet Mohammad ﷺ. Alhamdulillah, I finally can be sure about it.
There are Qurra' (by this I mean certified Qurra') who pronounce the letter ض with a sound close to the letter ظ, or with a "z" sound, rather than a sound closer to a "d" which we hear today. These Qurra' have chains of narration reaching back to the Prophet ﷺ, thus their sanads are equally as valid as the others. This pronunciation also stays consistent with the textual descriptions of ض, whereas the current pronunciation does not. Many Qurra' were taught this pronunciation and went against what they were taught due to social pressures later in life, thus opposing the teaching of their sanad, yet attributing it to that sanad. An example of this is the students of Qari Anees Ahmad Khan Falahi (ra). I recently verified from a student of Qari Anees himself that Qari Anees (ra) taught the pronunciation of ض as a sound very close to ظ, and this was how he was taught. However, many of his students, such as Qari Siddique Falahi and Qari Ayoub Essack (who is a link in my own chain), actually went against what they were taught by Qari Anees due to social pressure from Arab Qurra'.
Dr. Jonathan Brown also mentions he found Qurra' in Turkey who pronounced it this way. Qari Muhammad Yahya Shareef also quotes from Shaykh Ubaydullah Afghani who lists a plethora of scholars in his compilation (تنبيه العباد إلى كيفية النطق بالضاد) who pronounced the letter this way but their students evidently went away from the pronunciation despite still labeling themselves with that Sanad. A significant example of this is the great Shaykh Samannudi (ra) who argued for this pronunciation throughout his life and yet was pressured to retract it at the end of his life rahimahullah.
Mashallah my brother. You provide a way for us to maintain confidence in our reciting Alla tu alas glorious Qur’an.
Great information ❤️ Love from Indian Kashmir 😘
MASHA ALLAH! Well, sometimes I make this mistake when reciting the Qur'an this happens when I want to pronounce the word FAD-lillah then changing it to FAZ-lillah. Sheikh thank you for making distinctive clarity about these two alphabets. It is well understood and well assimilated. I really appreciate. JazzakAllahu khairan...
Wow what a clear explanation. I am so happy. Even though I knew the controversy but was never clear about, being a non-arab. Thanks for this.
Ma Sha Allah you are looking great work I always learn something new from your channel Jazak Allah brother❤
بارك الله فيك على كل هذا العمل الشاق
شكرا جزيلا لك، وجزاكم الله خيرا كثيرا...
Jazakallah kharan khatira
Jazakallah my brother in Islam may ALLAH grantee all of us jannatul firdowzal a'laa
I never knew this was an issue. Logically the problem should be between ض and د or ظ and ذ and ز but even then as an Arab it is easy to differentiate...
same. im not even arab but ض and ظ are quite different to me
@@nmpoy They are like "T" and "Th" in English
Right, and my biggest problem is ض and ط actually
@@taffem9084 for me it's 'ayn since it's a voiced ha that's the diff of Salahuddin and salah as in prayer, the pharyngealized is hard but not as far as ha iirc not English ha
7 vs h
Assalamualaikum! Thank you! As I am currently learning the quranic Arabic words. I am grateful to you for pointing out the right pronunciation of this particular letters. This is fun! Surely, there's more to find. Salamualaikum.
شكرا جزيلا على هذا الفيديو الذي احتاجه اسحق ان شاء الله
شكرا جزيلا لكم ، الآن أنا أفهم الأسرة بشكل أفضل
iam very happy because you learn in your youtube Arabic and me arabic man وانا ايضا اجيد الانجليزية
بارك الله فيك
Terima kasih dari Indonesia
The Dhod proounciation is like reaching the tongue to the upper teeth, and Dzo prounciation is like placing your tongue at the incisors and pronounce it like you gonna pronounce Zay.
I agree with some other comments here. You should have put forward both views about the pronunciation of ض, the classical view under which it is pronounced very similarly to ظ, and the more modern view under which its sound is similar to د. Yasir Qadhi has a very useful and detailed discussion about this matter on his RUclips channel and says that both views are sound. So, it's not correct to outright dismiss a legitimate view about the pronunciation of this letter.
However, to your credit, and this is something perhaps you could have mentioned in this video, we are told by the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) to recite in the way of the Arabs. Since most Arabs follow the modern view about the pronunciation of ض, it could be argued that that is the way everyone should pronounce as well.
Assalamu alaikum brother, i advise you to not listen to individuals such as Yasir Qadhi due to the enormous blunders they've made
clsssical means old. earlier it was similiar to Zao. They were more closer to PBUH. Why then follow modernist view
I am from Pakistan and yes ض is pronounced very similarly t ظ ز ذ. Urdu is like the three way child of arabic, persian and hindi and it uses the same alphabet as Arabic and in Urdu it is really supposed to be pronounced to be like that. We also have گ, چ and پ.
That's due to Persian speakers pronouncing the ض as a z namely wuzu instead of wudhu & Azaan instead of Adhaan.
@@GholamFareed I suggest both of you to look for this lecture " The Language (and Letter) of ض | Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi" on youtube. it will give you some historic perspective on this issue. IA
I'm from india and very happy with the tajweed explaintion because in india most of people arabic proucation is wrong
أنا عربي وشاهدت هذا المقطع😁 جزاك الله خيراً
Masha Allah very informative jazakallah
Thank you very much. I can recite correctly after this. Because arabic not our language we have to learn in detail
Assalam o Alaikum wa rehmatullah wa barakatuh... I am new to this channel. I could just listen to a very of your lessons. These are admirable. Please share your brief introduction. Jazakumullah Khaira Kaseera
When i was a teenager my teacher pronounced ض as ظ. That stunned me everytime she read Qur‘an. I asked her why she did it she said that it was not correct but ok.
في مجموع الفتاوى لشيخ الإسلام ابن تيمية رحمه الله
قال
وأما من لا يقيم قراءة الفاتحة فلا يصلي خلفه إلا من هو مثله فلا يصلي خلف الألثغ الذي يبدل حرفا بحرف إلا حرف الضاد إذا أخرجه من طرف الفم كما هو عادة كثير من الناس فهذا فيه وجهان: منهم من قال: لا يصلى خلفه ولا تصح صلاته في نفسه لأنه أبدل حرفا بحرف؛ لأن مخرج الضاد الشدق ومخرج الظاء طرف الأسنان. فإذا قال (ولا الظالين) كان معناه ظل يفعل كذا. والوجه الثاني: تصح وهذا أقرب لأن الحرفين في السمع شيء واحد وحس أحدهما من جنس حس الآخر لتشابه المخرجين.
يعني صوت الضاد والظاء في السمع شيء واحد
شاهدت الفيديو بالصدفة , وانا سعيد جدا ان صاحب القناة متمكن جدا في شرح الطرق الصحيحة لنطق الحروف العربية
لكن بالرغم من سعادتى فقد احسست بالوجع , كم من نعمة انا فيها ولست ادركها
في النهاية اسال الله العلى القدير ان يعين اخواننا المسلمين غير الناطقين بالعربية , وان يجعل مجهودهم في ميزان حسناتهم وان يجزيهم خير الجزاء
In Bangladesh, we are learnt Quran like that. I really like the way how you give example of "Romadon" & "Romazan".
Masha Allah.
I am Russian and watch the video in English about Arabic.
الحمدلله على نعمة الاسلام و اللغة العربية
Very helpful.Jazakallahu kheir
Things should not be so complicated for general people because Allah knows best how sincere are our hearts, so scholarly pronunciation is not possible for all.
يقال عن اللّغة العربية أيضا لغة الضّاد لأنّ لا يوجد في بقيّة لغات العالَم نطق لهذا الحرف ( ض) من حيث وضعيّة اللٌسان و طريقة النّطق الفريد به إلّا في اللّغة العربيّة الجميلة جدّا فقط..
اللغة العربية في الحقيقة هي لغة الظاء وليس الضاد
Thank you so much for this video! As an English speaker, I get so confused by the transliteration that puts a z instead of ظ so sometimes I would say Al azeem
To make it easy ض is the heavy form of د but ظ is the heavy form of ذ
Here are some other examples with other letters:
ط and ت
ص and س
ح and هـ
ع and أ
ق and ك
Rarely do I see an Englishman with such eloquence.. God willing, and may God bless you
ض---sswhaadh is pronounced by touching the left edges of the tongue to the bottom edges of the left teeth of the upper jaw.
ظ---is pronounced by making the mouth square shaped with tongue slightly pulled out Throwing air and saying zhouaa
الحمد لله على نعمة الاسلام و اللغه العربيه .
ما شاء الله مقطع مفيد جدا والله يوفقكم ع المقاطع المفيده والشروحات الطيبه
I love it how you give Ramazan as an example it is very common in India and maybe in Pakistan.
If u write pashto with grammer , There is no mistake , Its same both ways , in Urdu there is a high chance for you to interchange them
Terimakasih paparannya 😊
Of course there's a difference between ظ and ض. But today ض is pronounced more like a hard د. If we look at the tajwid books we see that the letter ض has a characteristic called رخاوة which with today's pronunciation is lost. Earlier tajwid scholars write that the closest to ض letter is ظ and not د. Also there are early recordings here on RUclips by Egyptian and other Shaykhs who explain the letter ض sounding more like ظ in stead of د. Please, comment on this.
sheikh Ludhiyanwi wrote a big treatise on this. Check out
Historically informative
Brother, the reason why is because both are fricatives (orginally)
the ظ was made with the lips, called a labial fricative (like english V, closest to a Slavic V)
while the ض is the pharyngealised version of ذ, like in english Ba*the*
called a dental fricative.
@@awehornet thank you, but I couldn't find it, can you point me to the name of the book or where to search, Ramazan mubarak for you in sha' Allah
It doesn't mean that ض can be replaced by ظ.
جميل جداً... بارك الله بك
MASHAALLAH you deserve more subscribers allah bless you my brother all videos helped me alot.
The ayah
وما هو على الغيب بضنين
actually has both these letters if you check the riwaayaat
thanks for sharing. needed this
Assalamu alaikoum. What a fantastic channel! Mashallah. Shukran jazeelan, may Allah swt bless you n accept this beautiful excellent deed.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
ما شاء الله لا قوة إلا بالله، شرح رائع ومفصل ومفيد، جزاك الله خيراً أخي ووفقك لما يحبه ويرضاه، على الرغم من أنني عربية، واللغة العربية لغتي الأم، إلا أنني أخطأ في نطق الضاد، بعد مشاهدة المقطع أستطيع الآن نطقها بشكل صحيح.
و عليكم السلام و رحمة الله وبركاته
حياكم الله و جزاكم الله خيرًا على التشجيع
I was searching for this
TO DO JUSTICE with this Subject ,it is better to differentiate between د andض also with examples like ضل and دل as you have differentiated between ضand ظ or ز,so excellently. CAN you add this differentiation between ضand د as well, by editing the same video /this video of yours?JazakaAllah.
Jazak Allah
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته ...
أخي الكريم جزاكم الله خيرا ...
أفضل طريقة للنطق السليم لحرفي ض - ظ هي بأن تنطق حرف الضاد بطعم (مذاق) حرف الدال . ضلّ = دلّ .
ونطق حرف الظاء بطعم (مذاق) حرف الذال . ظلال = ذلال .
Asslamo alikom brother,
I have a separate lesson specially for that matter: ruclips.net/video/_344AVeWcQI/видео.html
Please watch it and let me know if you have any further questions
Asslamo alikom
This is a very good lesson it helps Alot especially to correctly read sourat Al Fatiha
Woah Mashallah. First time seeing this channel. New subscriber here. I'm a Qur'an teacher so this is very important to me. I shall be teaching this to my students insha'Allah, they make the same mistakes on ض ظ ز
It took me quite a while to fix ض but I still don't think I'm there🤗, soon insha'Allah
بارك الله فيكم
To me, it is a simple question of point of articulation and manner of articulation. ض is alveolar plosive while ظ is dental fricative. All other aspects are the same. Since the sounds are destinct, they should not be confused. However, such confusion is understandable due to the general historical tendency of plosives to evolve into fricatives.
Thanks for teaching us the confusing topic
Thank you so much for clarification. I am a Pakistani who learned Quran using sound of few of the Arabic letters such as two mentioned in this video, as pronounced in Urdu. I have been paying attention to pronounce the Quran correctly.
ربنا يكرمك و يحفظك
Jazak'Allah Khair
JazakAllah.. Your Explanation is so understandable.
الله يفتح عليك بكل خير وبركة يا رب
Jazaka Allahu kheyran
Masa shaa allah thank u verry much for sharing
The Tamizh language has a similar differentiation of ழ (ض) and ள(ظ). We Tamizhs, struggle the same way as Arabs to differentiate the two.
Transcripted Tamil letters sound "L" rather than "DH" "ZH" approximately. Thats a big pblm for Tamilans.
This is the most correct explanation that there is out there. I looked this up myself a few years ago, and this is almost exactly what the scholars said. I pointed this out to a non-Arabic speaking brother who, Masha'Allah, memorized the Holy Quran, but he never accepted my showing him the difference between the two sounds! His teacher had taught him one thing and he sticks to it! Now, when he leads us in prayer, I hear "thalleen" at the end of al fatihah and not "dalleen."
Thank you for clarifying this issue.
@@IslamIsTheBest12131 ظ or ض ؟
As an Arabic speaking person, it really bothers me to hear الضالين sound more like الظالين. How confusing it must be for those who are learning the Quran and Arabic!
Can you clear also the difference between ذ and ظ. Which really sound similar to me and the difference is much more subtle.
they are quite diff imo
Can you understand urdu so i can easily explain you
In Subcontinent there is a great controversy Some pronounce ض as a full mouth د or ز ، since they cannot oronounce even ظً correctly. Further they add a letter Vau و as well. For example ضا is either pronounced as Zua or زوا by the supporters of ز sound and a full mouth دوا by the supporters of full mouth د.. In Sind some also pronounce ض as ڏ ، which is a special letter of Sindhi language. Even scholar of Tajvid dispute. They dispute among themselves that in the case when people cannot pronounce ظ and ذ but can pronunce ز and a full mouth د then one group prefer the latter and the other prefer the former. Some times even practical fightings had occurred. Some people had even lost their lives in such fights. But at present such problems continue with less violence.
JazakAllah Khair for sharing it's helpful and may Allah SWT bless you Jannah Tul Firdaus Allahumma Ameen
Jazakhallah Khairan
Jazaak Allahu Khairan
You are the best Mushulla brother
Yes please give head to head explaination of ط ظ and ض
❤❤❤ Masha allah my brother me allah continue bless you you and your family