Springfield Hellcat First Thoughts and Shots | ASP Extra
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 июл 2024
- My review of the Springfield XD: • The Springfield XD is ...
Dry Fire Challenge FB Group: get-asp.com/aspdryfire and sub to the ASP Extra channel for more on getting better as a self-defender: / activeselfprotectionextra
ASP merch is now in stock in the store…go get a newly designed limited edition phone case! get-asp.com/store
Don’t forget to subscribe to the main channel for daily narrated lessons of real defensive encounters: / activeselfprotection
Our Facebook page has TONS of good info for self-defenders: / activeselfprotection
If you value what we do at ASP, would you consider becoming an ASP Patron Member to support the work it takes to make the ASP Extra videos like Springfield Hellcat first thoughts and shots? get-asp.com/patron or get-asp.com/patron-annual gives the details and benefits.
Find a good instructor in your area and get some training: get-asp.com/directory
Attitude. Skills. Plan.
(music in the outro courtesy of Bensound at www.bensound.com)
![XO (Only If You Say Yes) - ENHYPEN エンハイプン 엔하이픈 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240712](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wBT1bKKwPTo/mqdefault.jpg)
I have X-large glove hands myself. No problems with grips with either magazine. Also have had no problems with the trigger. I have put through over 1,000 rounds with no issues or failures. This is now my full time carry firearm. BTW, love the sights.
Ahh I was wondering how the gun fits with big hands. Thanks for the review.
I was turned off by the sights myself until I actually got to hold one and WOW it completely changed my preference for the type of sights I like.
I carry the hellcat with the 13 round mag here in Colorado since it’s winter and I have baggy clothes on all the time. Put about 200 or so rounds through it so far and I absolutely love it
You got kitty ears on at the range????😂😂😂
Meow.
I was going to ask where he got the hearing protection with a Minnie Mouse bow on it
@@ASPextra More like MeeeooooooWWWWW! LOL
It's a Hellcat pun. I have one of these pistols and carrying it right meow!
How Meow Halp You LoL 😆 I’m sure the cat ears drives ppl nuts haha great conversation starter though
The new 15 round magazine solves the pinky issue! Dramatically decreased the recoil for me too. Also the spring breaks in overtime and that recoil gets a little bit better!
I got it and I like it alot. Replaced my shield. I get there's alot bs around Springfield armory's name but the gun it self is great.
Every maker has had negative pr in the past. Hear more about SA because of the internet age.
Great review, John! Thank you.
I like this review. More in-depth positive and negative points than other vids I’ve seen. Been an XD fan they have similarities and manufacturers warranty is awesome.
I personally carry Springfield XD45, so looking for a back up carry. Was a little surprised that it didnt have the grip safety. Looking and researched alot on the hellcat. Gonna have to go and shot it and see how I feel about it. Great video 👏👏👍👍. Thanks...
John, I am a huge fan and really enjoy your channel! Thank you for all the great vids and gun reviews.
Great video thanks for the review!
Great review!!!
Would love to see you do one of these on a Walther PPS M2. Love your stuff John
I have the osp version and I absolutely LOVE the HELLCAT
“Grip it like a man and that won’t happen!! And maybe your right.” 🤣😂🤣 thanks again John. Great as always
I absolutely love my Hellcat. Such a great little shooter and it’s by super easy to conceal. I do run a Hyve magazine extension, which makes it 14+1. Carried it for over 2 years, just last week I went to the Sig P365 X Macro, which is the exact same size as the small Hellcat w/the Hyve extension, and I get 3 more rounds. But I’d still give the Hellcat 5 out of 5 stars. Nothing bad to say about it.
I’ve got a sig p365, can’t go wrong with the ergo of it. Fits my hand perfectly
Thanks for sharing.
Nice review..interesting trigger issue with the "birdie fingers". The M&P hinge is exactly the same for me and it did cause problems...still carry a shield..cause I'm in CA and I cant get a 43.
I'm a smaller female, 5' 105. Just purchased this, dry fired a bunch and never had issue with trigger. Fits perfectly in my hand and on my person with the 11+1. I'm super excited to shoot it. Appreciate your videos!
Yeah if your finger is wide enough not to have the trigger freeze issue it's a contender.
Got my holster from Hawg Holsters. Super IWB with special Ulti Clip. Love it. What red dot sight came with yours?
It’s a Shield Mini RMS.
Looking good, John! I barely recognized you .
Thank you for being honest...👍🏽
Glad to.
Try the cardini iwb leather holster.... Very comfortable for all my carry pistols...
If you have pinky issues even with the 13 round magazine, what true sub-compact 9 mm pocket pistol can really work for you? I have XL hands myself and have yet to find a truly subcompact pistol that doesn't leave a pinky hanging. The Glock 26 should have the same issue, as would the P365, PPQ, etc. HK has the P30 but it's kinda on the thick/tall side. The single stacks that are true pocket pistols all will leave a pinky hanging. I was holding out hope that the Hellcat with the 13 round magazine and adaptive texturing would be the answer. Dang.
That’s funny how some people don’t like the grip safety, but others prefer it when appendix carry. I had the same issue with the trigger safety on the XDS .45 I have medium size hands and being the .45 ACP it makes for a longer grip between trigger. I noticed I was only getting the tip of my finger and needed to get that middle of the pad to make sure the trigger safety was engaged. Don’t have the issue any more. Looks like I might be getting a few hellcat for my self and wife.
It's like any compact 9, you have to try it for yourself and see if it works for you.
Do you get a better grip (in terms of your pinky falling off) with the P365 (or P365 with the 12 round mag)?
I have very limited experience with a 365.
I gotta say, I really want to shoot one of these. They look pretty damn impressive.
I have XL hands as well. And considering the reliability and accuracy of this little pistol, combined with its awesome capacity I love it. I wish the trigger was a little lighter but its fine. And as for the issue with the trigger safety locking up use a small piece of very fine grit sandpaper and you can take the extreme 90° edge off the back of the safety and then its a non issue. It still functions fine as an inertia block if the firearm is dropped but its able to be fired if you roll your finger onto the trigger from the side. Good luck and keep on shooting!
Never, EVER mess with a safety device yourself. Ever.
I’ve been waiting for the video!
Hickok45 said the same thing about the grip being beefier. He liked the sights though. Interesting gun.
My brother got one he put a little over 2k rounds through it so far and he absolutely loves it way more than he thought he would. I shot it too and its pretty cool. In terms of recoil it just feels like any other sub compact 9, G43, XDS take your pick. Seems to work good enough. Personally I run around with a CZ RAMI but I like the hellcat. Haven’t tried a 365.
JusticeAA i would expect that from the loss in surface area
I love mine. There's no problem with the trigger, and the pinky just fits on the extender with medium sized hands.
i have average hands, found this to be the best micro 9 for me to shoot. the P365 and many single stacks were just a bit small in diameter for me, this is the smallest of just right in feel. I do need the 13 round mag or the pinky extension to shoot it accurately. Even with the 13 round mag it conceals better (by far) than any gun that has a standard capacity of 15+1. I did have an initial issue, with out grip zone put in the frame I have no idea where to hold it.
WHERE DO I GRIP THIS GUN?!?! lol
I had to take the pinky extension off my little mag and put the flush one on. I have big ol' beef-fingers, and I can get a way better grip with 2 fingers than 2 1/2. Added bonus- less of it shows when I carry inside the waistband. Also, it seems everyone has problems with a sticky trigger if not pulled properly. I never had a problem with it, but could make it happen easily on purpose. Fixed it by barely rounding off the sharp edge on the back of the trigger safety where it meets the frame. And I mean barely, didn't want to nullify the safety. Now I can pull through if I hit the trigger first, but it won't go with only the trigger or excessive force.
I would NEVER, EVER recommend modifying any safety on a firearm by an end user. Ever. Ever.
Luv your channels, value your input/reviews. Did you ever get mag=plate-pinch? Some people get a magazine base plate that wiggles vertically and, after a time, repeatedly pinches their pinky causing blistering. I haven't had the pleasure of shooting this or the 365 as there are no rent-ranges nearby but DO want to get a smaller conceal carry with that capacity.
I haven't had that happen with this gun at all.
@@ASPextra Great to know! Thank you!
Thanks for the review. I’m relatively new to the CC world. I just got a hybrid holster from Raw Dog Tactical and I actually like it. It has 2 adjustable retention screws. The gun doesn’t fall out and it’s pretty comfy. I wear it 9 o’clock. I think that it’s personal preference as to whether they’re garbage or not.
Well, I train people to carry firearms for a living, and with a bunch of experience and expertise in the area, I would stand by what I said. If it's a hybrid, it's not good.
Active Self Protection Extra that’s fair. And no doubt do I think your knowledge is less than mine. But what’s the reasoning? Is it cause there’s no click? It holds the gun well and it’s comfortable. The trigger is completely covered.
For the record I’ve watched your videos on hybrid holsters. And I learn a ton from you every time. My thing is I don’t blindly follow people unless the truth resonates with me. My holster from the mentioned company above is fantastic. Maybe once it’s worn out and loses retention etc, my mind will change. But for now I like it. And I don’t think its garbage for me.
Just way bulky, poor concealment, and the retention will start to fail guaranteed.
I use a JHI kydex holster, all of my hybrids either wear on the leather side and get loose, or are just too large to wear comfortably. The exception is the black arch protos-m because its kydex shell wraps around the trigger guard on both sides. Even with that it is still too large for many situations.
Hey there, what kind of eye protection are you wearing?
These are Rudy Project some model or other...
I really wish companies could make a steel frame subcompact gun. It will cost more yes but is worth it at the end. Great review John.
I think demand is light for a heavy subcompact. It would have a niche, though.
Have you checked for any striker drag on the empty brass?
Trapezoid striker pin to take drag.
Where did you get the pinky extension for the 11 round mag?
Came with the gun. Sorry I can't be of more help there.
Last Saturday I was able to finally purchase the 4" Shield with the red dot. Although I only have a couple hundred rounds through it, I really like it. My first gen Shield has never given me problems.
The earlier Shields are great. Some of the newer ones, the QC has had trouble.
The only thing about my first gen is the strength of the recoil spring. Not going to drop the slide off the stop one handed, should that become necessary. Reportedly, the Gen 2 has a better trigger, but I wouldn't know.
@@757optim It is a better trigger, but the first gen was fine for me. The one I got is a Performance Center.
@@ASPextra Hopefully the Performance Center offerings are better at that!
I bought hyve mag extensions, they're about .25" longer and hold 14. Perfect for bigger hands and is still a very small gun
I will have to pick some up!
Crossbreed makes a wonderful hybrid holster.
Boy do I disagree.
thanks for the great review John. What about the grip technology?
Seems interesting. Grip works.
Active Self Protection Extra any impression with the two layer, soft to touch, but hard second layer that grabs?
Note that my pinky kept slipping off, and I have about 115lb of grip strength in both hands. That tells me a lot.
It doesn't rub me as bad as the M&P 2.0 I carried, I had to sand down the grip on that one. It feels like a good grip, the marketing speak is just that.
Wow I had no idea it was you you have lost a ton of weight great job.
I have been wanting a sub compact and I am a sig sauer fan but I have been waiting on your review with this one.. Very curious about the 1000 round review..
John,, My man. After getting your butt handed to you in the comment section regarding the "McRib" incident, and having to take "Glock Imperfection" apology tour, I was dying to see what you did here. Awesome review man,, Awesome job. You pointed out some critical details that nobody else caught in their Hellcat reviews, and maintained a generally unbiased commentary with both positive and negative points. Thank you and to quote Montell Jordan - "This is how we do it"
The XD still sucks.
Steyr S9A1 or C9A1 review?
I got mine. Really like it. Solid gun, but my front tritium sight was dead. Have to send it in. 365 still best in class for this size in my opinion.
What about the new canik 9mm sub compact?
11 rounds tho and much crispier trigger. The magazine seems alot easier to load as well for what that's worth.
I just sanded the trigger safety of mine, just rounded it instead of having the ledge being to sharp.... Now it can disengage if you correct your finger even after it "locks up"
That's an interesting fix. It doesn't give me problems and my wife won't carry it because of the problem, so I doubt I will do that.
Huh. Haven’t really heard much about shields failing.
Bishop M same. Usually it’s when people tinker with after market parts. Just leave it the gun stock unless it’s going to a competent gunsmith who has the experience. Even still better to just leave the internals stock. But you rarely hear of Shields failing.
josh48315 that makes sense considering the 1.0 trigger supposedly being shit. A lot of comments I see as soon as someone buys a shield or is contemplating buying one is “oh make sure you get an aftermarket trigger!”
I was told the same with my m&p 9 compact but I don’t mind having it function the way it did out of the factory over something that won’t make me a better shooter
Did the Loaded Mag for 6+Month Test today.
(1st) S&W M&P .40 w/Conversion Barrel .40S&W-9mm - 2 S&W Mags, 1-8rd Mag fully loaded 6+Months went first, ran without issue. Next was a 6rd Mag minus 1rd loaded for 6+Months, ran without issue.
(2nd) S&W M&P Bodyguard 380ACP - 1-S&W Mag 6rd w/only 5rds loaded for 6+Months, Had a Failure to Feed last round.
My concluding thought is I “Retract” a previous statement, and submit “you should change out your Magazines more then every 6+Months” every ounce of advantage during a defensive encounter should be taken. For complete knowledge of your own equipment run a similar test, so you know for sure. But the F2F reminded me to go over corrective actions. For example, We should be able to take apart our “Firearms Blind Folded” so in Low light live situations, can correct a stoppage and place our defense back into action. Thanks Again Sensei, would not have thought do the test if it wasn’t for you covering this, 6+Months ago. I wish I would have wrote down the exact date.
BOOM!!!
“These are my first live shots...”....meanwhile, plenty of holes already in the target 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣...and his typical rant about hybrid holsters, because he doesn’t understand how they work.
Recently got a hellcat. Having trouble shooting it as well as my Glock 43x. I’m a Glock guy so I’m used to the trigger but idk if it’s the trigger of the hellcat or the grip size or what but I just cannot shoot it as well
Maybe time to seek out a lesson with an instructor who can help you figure it out.
@@ASPextra that sounds like a good ide
I've had the same trigger safety issue with my Canik TP9SFX. It is easily fixed with an exacto blade. You remove material from the safety behind the trigger, until it clears just a little bit sooner as the dingus thing is pressed. Of course if you go too far, then it will clear all the time rendering the trigger safety useless, so beware. If that happens, then you'll need a replacement trigger, which is not something that I want on a carry gun. The Canik trigger is pretty darn good out of the box, but that safety just needed a trim job. Be sure to test by pressing hard on the trigger, without pressing the safety, and be sure that the trigger is blocked from going to the rear, even if pressed hard.
Yeah, I think home gunsmithing a safety is something I am not willing to do.
@@ASPextra
Spot on for this one.
That "ear" was distracting. : )
Should pop the other one up.
757optim or not wear those ridiculous things.
@@AVKingJamesBible Halloween special
What exactly are the S&W Sheild failures on the line...? Also Sig 365's...?
Lots of feed way stoppages on both.
does this pistol have a shorter grip than your 43 that you carry?
I carry the 43 with a +2 mag extension on it, and with that, yes.
My Hellcat fits perfectly in my Glock 43X Blackhawk Serpa holster. It may fit in other brands of for the 43X.
Yeah I wouldn't recommend any of that.
If your wife is still interested in the Hellcat tell her to check out the RDP variant of it, they changed the ergonomics to the trigger to mitigate that trigger saftey issue.
In a handgun that is to be used for defence there are only two ratings that should be used in evaluating the trigger; Excellent or Not Exceptable.
Do you think that trigger not going down is a problem in a situation where adrenaline is pumping and you may not pull the gun trigger correctly and causing the trigger to lock up on you because you panicked? Ofcourse its training and I don't see how you can pull that trigger wrong but something to think about.
I don't think it'll happen if it doesn't ever happen in practice and training. Get a rental and work from compressed ready and do some fast presentations and first shot. If it doesn't happen after a bunch of those, I don't think it'll happen ever. It's all about finger size.
I notice you are left handed cool so am I love this gun
Hey John,
How was the accuracy and the grouping? You forgot to show us. It's hard to see on my phone. 😆. Thanks brother. God bless.
I didn’t try to shoot a group at all.
@@ASPextra I know, you didn't look like you were really trying. Just testing the recoil. If you can next time try and show us the accuracy and grouping. 😀 Thanks John
@@Recon_Operator he didn't shoot well at all. Lol when you test fire a firearm u shoot for accuracy, it is a carry gun. Silly tricks are for kids.
Like to see a vs vid between caniks new sub compact 9 vs the hellcat! Not sure which to buy but leaning towards the canik! Anyone else's thoughts?
Hmmm...
I like how they send you it after you trashed their XD’s
I literally asked them if they were sure they wanted to send me one. They were.
Looking seriously at getting this to replace my Springfield XDs .45,,,I need more capacity but cant carry the extra weight of a double stack.
It's worth looking into, depending on your hand size. I'd recommend renting it first.
I have an original XDS9 for a summer carry piece. Reliable as an anvil, with a smidge under 10,000rds thru it. My best friend bought a 365 for his wife, and he bought an XL for himself. My Lord, have mercy. That is one SWEET shooting pistol. I put a couple hundred rounds thru it. Highly recommend the 365. Sadly, I haven't been able to get a hold of a Hellcat. The 365XL shoots very softly for a pistol of its size.
@@ASPextra I ended up getting this and love the capacity vs. weight. I got a HYVE mag extension that adds 1/3 rounds and a better purchase on the grip.
Let’s be real. The point of the safety is “kid hands trying to pull the trigger”. I’m glad small fingers can’t shoot it without knowing proper pull. It’s not even small hands. Some what it is experience and knowing where to pull..
No, no it is not.
thanks
Second review ive seen that addresses the trigger problem
Dont believe the hype!! Plenty people dont like the Springfield brand due to the anti 2a moves in the past. I have several xd xds and they are fine pistols go bang everytime never broke like my man said they break firing pins and springs 🤷🏿♂️. 8k rounds 5k of +p I cant take any Springfield review serious from john.
@@milleniumann28 i also own an XDs and have never had an issue but i need to try and duplicate the trigger issue on my XDs before i consider the Hellcat
@@BTeezy82 I have your answer right now because my mod2 does the same thing. If you pull the trigger at the top it wont break same for my canick s&w 2.0 1.0 all my pistols with the safety built in the trigger do the same thing. This hellcat series will be the best selling springfield yet I'll wait for the popularity to drop off and get it at 399 with bag and mags.
@@milleniumann28 sounds like a plan
Advantage Sig 365. No doohickey on the trigger that has to be depressed. Mine has yet to have any issues, and it's an early production gun. I haven't fired the Springfield gun yet, to be fair. Just saying.
With my wife's sig365 it absolutely hates Winchester ammo the projectile is taller so it doesn't go up to the feed ramp correctly so it jams up
You might ask Sig about that. Mine feeds everything, and it's an early production gun.
Concerns on the shield red dot strength and auto dim feature..other options for co witnesse??
I don't think there's any other options currently on the market for micro 9s. I have 5000 rounds through a full size RMS and while it ain't all that, it's not bad for a CCW gun.
@@ASPextra Sig Sauer's Romeo Zero will have the same footprint as the RMSc. Set to be released end of this month.
Yep, but not out quite yet and untested.
@@ASPextra I believe it's the Jpoint enterprises that's the other one to fit the hellcat
That's crazy, I've been seeing a lot of issues with H&K VP9's failing regularly on the line lately.
I have literally not heard that from a single person. I would 100% mention it, and your pejorative nonsense is just that.
We have HKs come through the classes I teach all the time, and have not seen any problems with them. I just polled about 15 national-level trainers to see if they have seen any increase in issues with VP9s, and none have.
@@ASPextra You're right, that assumption was inappropriate. My apologies.
Thanks Chris. Have a good day.
@@chriscole4266 is this the skateboard pro Chris cole?
@@jambajoby32 🏂🏂
John, please try the new sig sauer p365 SAS.
12MRJERSEY is that some kind of cup?
@@grumpychunk1 NO! ruclips.net/video/Yku_IcAeQ6A/видео.html
Not hearing issues with p365. Is there evidence out there they are having issues?
I would say that right now, the P365 is the standard by which all other micro 9s are measured. I don't like the ones with the SAS sights, but otherwise it's a fine gun now. When it FIRST came out it had reliability issues, but Sig Sauer fixed them.
@@ASPextra good. I purchased one a few months back and have over 300 rounds, ball and defense ammo and not a hiccup yet!
I have the Hellcat, and have had the P365, liked both, but the Hellcat just fits my hand better. As far as the trigger, I’ve not experienced any issues while shooting, but can “make it” happen if I try. I think your presentation of this “issue” was accurate and well said, thanks.
If you have a regular size hand you won't likely see that problem pop up.
The safety concerns me with carrying a round in the chamber....I would be afraid of the trigger snagging in the pocket and it goes off...my 92FS has a decocker/safety so there is no way that I could have an accidental discharge while carrying in my shoulder holster.
Holstered guns don’t go off.
Good review. I do disagree with you big time on the Crossbreed holsters. IMO they are very good quality. I do find myself using my Vedder more often. But the Crossbreed is more comfortable and it secures the trigger guard very well. However I’ve never tried a hybrid with appendix carry.
I made a mistake rushing into getting my first pistol. Now I'm doing research. That hellcat I think is my next gun.
Research is good. :)
Aftermarket opportunity! Replaceable trigger shoe for tiny fingers.
Does it come with the red dot?
It can. Not all do.
I love mine so far. No optics, don’t want it. Need a mag loader though.
Maglula is life.
I’d really like to know the brand of holster
James Rodman Jr my brother has a hellcat. We get our holsters from black rhino concealment. He likes his hellcat appendix holster.
They got shipped to RUclipsrs with crossbreed holsters
I put an Apex trigger in mine
I love my Hellcat. No problems with trigger, so I guess I don't have bird fingers. I don't have beefy hands either, so it is comfortable in my hands. I don't mind the recoil, because I have learned to grip the gun hard to prevent "noodling". The higher recoil of the micro compact compared to my larger 9 mm home defense gun allows me to conceal it with confidence, so I can actually carry it.
anyone out there interested in the Bersa 380 Combat Plus???? which would you choose .... anyone????
Shields fail on the line? I have three of them never had a issue after thousands of rounds. These statements scare the shit out me because its my primary off duty gun and i shoot crap out of it and it just runs. Love ur video . Please make one on m and p shield failures.
It's mainly the newer guns that S&W started cranking out in droves for crazy low prices, and it seems the QC on them is spottier.
I just bought one today would you be willing to part with that holster to help out a right handed person?
I would not wish this holster on my enemy.
Active Self Protection Extra I hate to see ya throw away a $60 holster and I need one.
I am not going to throw it away. I am going to roast it here and then put it in my box o' shame to show to students as an example of bad holsters.
Active Self Protection Extra okay, have fun with that. I get you don’t like them, and the retention on them isn’t the best I was just trying to save a little $$ so I could carry this new gun sooner. Enjoy your new HellCat.
Love your videos Mr C. However CANT get behind Springfield ever again .....BUT I WILL WATCH YOUR VIDEOS...
Small pistols are way easier to shoot with .380. The gun won't jump around and your limited pinky grip won't slip. I noticed this shooting the sig238 and 938 side by side at a demo. I have also shot an XDS in 45acp. Way too much bang for a little gun.
Thats why glock 42 is my fav cc gun.
What’s with that eagle on your shirt?
That's the Gunsite Raven.
I get the appeal of the small guns for comfort, but I have never had a problem concealing a Glock 19, and I shoot it so much better than these micro wonders. The other thing about my Glock is that at night and I am ready for bed, I can just slap a standard light on it. These small guns are hard to find lights for so it limits their role. Do what works for you. Just don’t compromise shooting proficiency for comfort. If you have to use it, you want make sure you have something you can fight effectively with.
Does ASP offer training?
Yep, check our website for upcoming classes! www.activeselfprotection.com
I learned to shoot with gripping only with my ring and middle finger from Hickok so short grips are not an issue for me.
Well, the problem with that is you're giving up 30-40% of your grip strength. ruclips.net/video/ypsUsNJ9Z4g/видео.html physics and science and anatomy and physiology and all that.
Active Self Protection Extra I don’t necessarily like the FBD you drew. It implies that there exists a coupling force between the forces from your fingers and the palm of your hand. (I.e. remove the force vector from the barrel and you’re left with your grip force vectors causing coupling. In reality just holding the gun does not cause rotation of the firearm)
If I were to draw the FBD wrt the firearm I would draw it in such a way the grip force vectors are in opposite directions on the same axis.
The torque that actually counters the rotation of the firearm exists in the wrist and it is our body that induces a moment reaction on the joint of our wrist that counters the moment caused by the firearm and is not because of the moment we put on the grip of the firearm (because like I said before we do not induce a moment on the firearm since our grip force vectors are on the same axis just opposite in direction). Thus I don’t believe the pinky on the grip provides as much as is said.
But they’re not on the same axis.
And the counter torque in the wrist comes from the forward pressure on the fingers by the frame.
Active Self Protection Extra
Just want to let you know John my intentions for this conversation are with the up most respect for you. I hope you can enjoy putting on your nerd cap for a bit and debate nerd stuff with me.
If the force vectors created by holding the gun were not on the same axis then the gun would rotate (assuming the gun is massless which if we consider mass then that’s a whole other story on where the center of gravity is located and how the weight of the firearm plays a factor just assume massless for ease of conversation)
Basically take your FBD and erase the force due to the recoil and what is left over is the grip forces that are in opposite directions however exist on different axis. They are displaced causing coupling.
Think of a stick that’s laying on the ground and u push on opposite ends in opposite directions; the stick will rotate.
Your point on the wrist counter torque is from the forward pressure from the fingers I don’t think is correct because
1) I can apply a moment reaction force from my wrist without the interaction of my fingers
the forces induced by grip strength and wrist rotation are completely independent (i.e. my grip strength is independent of my ability to rotate my wrist forward with force (stick ur fingers straight out you are still able to resist a moment induced on your wrist))
Edit: I would like to do actual tests and experiments on this to get quantitative data for sure it sounds interesting
Good to know about the trigger and little hands/fingers.
It's a no go for me. I'll stick with gen 1 shield.
Well John after months of reviews and renting many compact & subcompact 9mm, plus dangerous old men symptom ( aging eyesight) I purchase a Hellcat today, I want to add lipstick and bows later, the red dot and holster I not to sure of cause one I’m left handed and left eye dominant but shoot with both open. Any recommendations on affordable red dots and safe holsters?
Check out Big Tex Outdoors on red dots: get-asp.com/507atBTO .
There are lots of holsters out there that meet the 3 criteria of an acceptable holster (ruclips.net/video/Ox7GrdjqRXk/видео.html), but these are the ones I have used that I like and recommend:
Full Kydex
Dark Star Gear - get-asp.com/darkstar
Henry Holsters - get-asp.com/henryholsters
KSG Armory - get-asp.com/KSGArmory
Three Quarter Kydex
Black Arch Protos M - get-asp.com/protos
For more information - get-asp.com/holsters
I think this gun with a comp on the end would be less snappy
Wow I love how honest you are 100thumbs up great job.
Canik tp9 sc?