Magi | Sinbad Analysis - Hero or Villain

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 95

  • @saneelahaseeb8375
    @saneelahaseeb8375 3 года назад +184

    Ugh I miss sinbad and the entire cast. I see Sinbad as both an inspiration and a lesson. He is hardworking, witty, charismatic, cunning and built to be king. I was pretty much smitten by his third appearance on the show. I never see magi get any love, it pains me I will never see the djinns and this world building come to life.

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  3 года назад +10

      for real! i wish there was a season 3

    • @GorgeousHotRat
      @GorgeousHotRat 2 года назад +1

      @@AttackonTiago theres a season 3

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад +7

      @@GorgeousHotRat thats the sinbad spinoff, otherwise no

  • @azure5orizons
    @azure5orizons 11 месяцев назад +18

    I would call him neither/both. He's the embodiment of a duality, eventually deciding to combine those feelings with his belief that he established over time that he's entitled and the only one capable of ruling the world. This depravity is further influenced by David, and it is him who truly made Sinbad go off the edge and try to break through the extra-dimensional construct - known as the sacred palace - through absorbing everyone and their rukh. Although he was swayed by the light that is Aladdin and Alibaba, and regained that balance, instead choosing to side with good and sacrifice himself. That's how I see it anyways.

  • @WShoup9818
    @WShoup9818 Год назад +81

    Sinbad isn't good or evil he's just human doing what he thinks is right and will do anything to achieve and protect his goals/assets.

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  Год назад +7

      that is true yes! but his actions that he thinks are justified could be argued to be villainess

    • @SNNewsIndia170
      @SNNewsIndia170 Год назад +1

      @@AttackonTiago Like can you give some examples which makes people think that he is a villain

    • @dragoncat5767
      @dragoncat5767 Год назад +6

      ​@@AttackonTiago well yeah,he is a villain,his character is meant to be,he admitted that he was wrong in the manga to what he did
      But he did all of it just for peace.
      He is one of the most xooolest
      I say he is much more cooler than a villain like Madara

    • @zillva
      @zillva Год назад +2

      @@SNNewsIndia170 He is a villain because he intentionally tried to kill everyone in the world in order to achieve his own ambitions, as well as the fact that he made the entire world bend down to his will as a dictator. I think that can be said to be pretty much objectively evil. Still I love him very much, and know he did it because he truly believed that he was in the right. That doesn't make him good though

  • @lilyhudson8470
    @lilyhudson8470 Год назад +24

    In the show, one guy said Sinbad was manipulated. He does put certain ideas in your head tho. But on the other hand, he gave people he rule a better life. I have to say he is neither a Hero nor a Villain. He is just a good king. It's hard to rule millions of people and keep them under control. I guess sometimes you gonna have to manipulate them to keep them under control if things come to it.

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  Год назад +1

      thats a great point

    • @pn2294
      @pn2294 Год назад +6

      Of course, there’s also a lesson in knowing when to let go.

    • @dragoncat5767
      @dragoncat5767 Год назад +3

      His reasons were good,but as Aladdin said, everyone must have free will

  • @ImVeryWholesome
    @ImVeryWholesome Год назад +6

    Well, he is definitely a antagonist, but a villain or evil guy? Nah bro is a GOD, a First-Class Singularity, unbound by date and can choose his own path down it, unfortunately that doesn’t mean he knows the road, he just knows where the finish line is, and in the end, he stopped himself from fully committing to his ultimate utopia, because the world isn’t perfect, and neither is he

  • @narenkarthikeyan2429
    @narenkarthikeyan2429 2 года назад +34

    I really like the video but I feel like mentioning how he becomes by the end of the Magi manga is crucial to understanding and appreciating his character. Great job though it’s nice to see a small creator make his way up. Kinda like Sinbad lol

  • @krakenskull2557
    @krakenskull2557 2 года назад +30

    I think Alibaba and Hakuryu are the underrated gems of Magi.

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад

      thats a fair assessment

    • @isthislunar
      @isthislunar Год назад +2

      Alibaba is the main protag lol

    • @hello9470
      @hello9470 Год назад +1

      ⁠@@isthislunarAlibaba isn’t the main protagonist the main protagonist is Aladdin.

    • @isthislunar
      @isthislunar Год назад

      @@hello9470 "Alibaba is the main protagonist of Magi. He is also a minor character in Adventure of Sinbad, making brief appearances in some panels."

  • @JabamiLain
    @JabamiLain 9 месяцев назад +1

    Sinbad is kinda what the Prince of Persia could be with access to godlike power.

  • @REYDANTAN2006
    @REYDANTAN2006 10 месяцев назад +2

    Life is a matter of perspective

  • @mythking3913
    @mythking3913 3 года назад +11

    I haven’t watched this but this vid makes this character seem nice , nice work as always

  • @dregeonsheart3823
    @dregeonsheart3823 2 года назад +11

    He is a god like literally the top god....read manga.

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад +4

      i read the manga, and hes insane :) just didnt wanna spoil to everyone how powerful he gets

    • @nickelmiller23
      @nickelmiller23 5 месяцев назад

      where can i read?

  • @nickytats39
    @nickytats39 Год назад +3

    Sinbad the only final villain good enough to get his own spinoff

  • @iamjordanj
    @iamjordanj 2 года назад +8

    I feel like after he became a slave and was freed he started to changed

  • @maxleon61702
    @maxleon61702 Год назад +7

    Alternate Title: The time where Jotaro (Daisuke Ono/Matthew Mercer) became an Arabian King.

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  Год назад +1

      ooo true though! LOL

    • @maxleon61702
      @maxleon61702 Год назад +1

      Yep. This isn't the only time both Ono and Mercer shared the spotlight, both in Japanese and English as they did so like five times.

  • @sakuti
    @sakuti 3 года назад +11

    good shi man, although i haven't watched the show, your summary and logic made complete sense

  • @genericusername_Xx
    @genericusername_Xx Год назад +5

    Technically he captured eight the the djinn of that dungeon said he was already too strong and refused to make a contract with him

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  Год назад +1

      insane, hes too OP lol

    • @dragoncat5767
      @dragoncat5767 Год назад

      It was the 7th djinn he captured that made the contract with him

  • @---fn7lh
    @---fn7lh 2 года назад +5

    I'm of the belief that only the intention matters not the means by which you attain it

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад +2

      interesting

    • @dragoncat5767
      @dragoncat5767 2 года назад +1

      That depends on how good the intention is compared to the means

  • @tylerjeske9092
    @tylerjeske9092 3 года назад +3

    Fire as always

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  3 года назад

      thank you. i appreciate that coming from the STUD from highschool

  • @flamynoi
    @flamynoi 3 года назад +6

    Great Analysis man!

  • @snax_125
    @snax_125 3 года назад +6

    Good as always ❤️🔥

  • @fiahiinukiie1276
    @fiahiinukiie1276 Год назад +2

    What’s a hero or a villain to a GOD?

    • @JabamiLain
      @JabamiLain 9 месяцев назад +1

      Children with woodsticks.

  • @FGoetia
    @FGoetia 3 года назад +3

    Another banger of a video 🔥

  • @tylerjeske9092
    @tylerjeske9092 3 года назад +3

    Always love the intros

  • @amtis2548
    @amtis2548 2 года назад +4

    He went sasuke in the end...trying to create a new world 😂😂😂😂

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад

      haha

    • @dragoncat5767
      @dragoncat5767 Год назад +1

      Atleast he was nearly successful in what he tried to achieve.
      He had nearly achieved what villains like madara or sasuke weren't able to do.

  • @AshaDisco
    @AshaDisco 2 месяца назад

    The World Needs Benevolent Dictators💟

  • @sw4t435
    @sw4t435 3 года назад +5

    cool 🔥🔥

  • @HEisHIM678
    @HEisHIM678 2 года назад +4

    why did the world bring life to sinbad if it was just going to reincarnate king Solomon

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад

      :thinking:

    • @cieltempest8794
      @cieltempest8794 2 года назад +3

      So is Solomon good or evil because he seems very similar to Sinbad in wanting peace I mean

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад +3

      @@cieltempest8794 yea thats a tough one, hes very similar to sinbad in that regard

  • @kingoffools7511
    @kingoffools7511 2 года назад +7

    I like to put him under the villain like hero who not totally evil but need to understand it impossible for one man to choose for the what is right for the whole world it the people

  • @peterkap5338
    @peterkap5338 2 года назад +2

    Sinbad=hero ❤️👑

    • @dregeonsheart3823
      @dregeonsheart3823 2 года назад

      Wrong....sindbad is god ( the god) literally. Read manga.

    • @peterkap5338
      @peterkap5338 2 года назад

      @@dregeonsheart3823 yes i know bro

  • @richardanderson1008
    @richardanderson1008 Год назад +3

    Sinbad is a great character, but if you want an answer to this question just read the manga

  • @slightly_techy
    @slightly_techy 3 года назад +2

    Lit ⚡⚡

  • @thatguywithquarters454
    @thatguywithquarters454 2 года назад +10

    I’d follow sindaddy anywhere

  • @TheAdventangel
    @TheAdventangel 8 месяцев назад

    Definitely a villain

  • @randomthings4571
    @randomthings4571 2 года назад +3

    when i see sinbad i automatically click sub:)

  • @naveed7143
    @naveed7143 Год назад +1

    Sinbadass

  • @daniel_587
    @daniel_587 3 месяца назад

    anyone know where i can read magi colored if there is been holding off on reading the manga

  • @mr.villain3xist
    @mr.villain3xist 2 года назад +4

    please tell me about the next season

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад +2

      sadly idk if we're getting a next season

  • @aeaadal9430
    @aeaadal9430 2 года назад +2

    Sinbad reminds me of The United States of America

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад

      in what way?

    • @hongyu3614
      @hongyu3614 2 года назад +1

      Idk if op is joking or not but this is a pretty sound comparison; a “rags to riches” story, fighting against “tyranny” and winning against the odds, becoming a major superpower in the world, and becoming power hungry and misusing their power to attempt to align the world to their own philosophy (the “my way is right” that was mentioned in the video)
      Btw, good video! Your analysis was really interesting and your points were on the mark. Personally, I’d never call Sinbad a villain, but he doesn’t fall completely on the side of heroism either. He’s a really fascinating character that explores the question of “how much is too much?” and I think you summarized the points well.

    • @AttackonTiago
      @AttackonTiago  2 года назад

      @@hongyu3614 thank you so much! im glad you enjoyed it! hes in my top 5 favorite characters of all time because of his complexity

  • @ZestyZinny
    @ZestyZinny Год назад

    short video...

  • @devoncampbell7073
    @devoncampbell7073 2 года назад +1

    I love hero ❤️

  • @tomato-kun5946
    @tomato-kun5946 3 года назад +3

    Only gets better and better 🥱