Will Menaker's Review of LA Confidential on Nostalgia Trap with Dan Bessner

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 окт 2024

Комментарии • 38

  • @Swimmaroo
    @Swimmaroo Год назад +18

    Chinatown, LA Confidential and who framed Rodger rabbit are the father, the son and holy spirit of California Noir

    • @rb5519
      @rb5519 Год назад +4

      "California Noir" also brings to mind "To Live and Die in L.A." for me.

    • @anthonyrowland9072
      @anthonyrowland9072 Месяц назад +1

      @@rb5519 California re-noired itself in the 80s.

  • @deathmagneto-soy
    @deathmagneto-soy Год назад +12

    Great movie. Haven't watched it in years but it's definitely one that stayed in the mind palace.

    • @deathmagneto-soy
      @deathmagneto-soy Год назад +3

      @Shinshocks - Mind is the staging area where all the processing goes on. Mind palace is where all the precious formative memories are stored.

    • @deathmagneto-soy
      @deathmagneto-soy Год назад +1

      @Shinshocks - It's a reference to the Hannibal TV series that Menaker likes to use every so often. His mind palace is the IMDB of political pundits and operators.

  • @chasen47
    @chasen47 Год назад +4

    I think they’re being a little hard on Basinger in this, I think she gives a very sensitive performance.

  • @Oceanmachine27
    @Oceanmachine27 9 месяцев назад +1

    As I listened to this episode, I realized I had mixed up James Ellroy with Elmore Leonard. I was thinking "man, Elmore Leonard's novels are a million times darker than I had been led to believe."

  • @SpreezyFeezyDeluxe
    @SpreezyFeezyDeluxe Год назад +7

    I've never heard Hobbesian pronounced that way, that woke me up quickly.

    • @refoliation
      @refoliation Год назад

      I’m more of a Calvinist

    • @idicula1979
      @idicula1979 Год назад

      My nipples are hard, with intrigue.

    • @RumHam5570
      @RumHam5570 6 месяцев назад

      21:19 Yeah, immediate WTF moment from me too, lol.

  • @waynetables6414
    @waynetables6414 Год назад +6

    we watched this movie in high school for some reason

  • @legzdiamond2356
    @legzdiamond2356 Год назад +8

    Rollo…Thomasi…

  • @wyattrussell7496
    @wyattrussell7496 Год назад +9

    Rollo is Poppy

  • @mbryson2899
    @mbryson2899 Год назад +1

    _They Live_ was not set in Los Angeles by accident. "THIS IS YOUR GOD. MARRY AND REPRODUCE. STAY ASLEEP..."

  • @NugGarou
    @NugGarou 2 месяца назад

    I was 15 minutes into this video before I realized they weren’t talking about the video game L.A. Noir 😅

  • @jfjf-yn6wj
    @jfjf-yn6wj Год назад +5

    Isn’t the ambiguity between hero’s and villains the thematic core of all noir ?

    • @GrimReader
      @GrimReader Год назад

      Can be, a lot of noir the ambiguity is just the surface and the heroes are usually chivalrous heroes. Nick and Nora, Marlowe are heroic despite the surface action. But then you do get the hard boiled bastards like the Continental Op who could be a villain in another book

    • @onastick2411
      @onastick2411 Год назад

      @@GrimReader Kiss Me Deadly, Mike Hammer springs to mind, as the hard bitten, and not to chivalrous, if he's got a core of decency, it's buried deep.

    • @GrimReader
      @GrimReader Год назад

      @@onastick2411 Hammer rules

    • @pietzsche
      @pietzsche Год назад

      "ambiguity" doesn't really work with Ellroy's version, there's no real ambiguity, they're all evil

  • @twistedoperator4422
    @twistedoperator4422 Год назад +19

    Chapo should talk House of Cards

    • @craigtrautmanjr9393
      @craigtrautmanjr9393 Год назад

      I think I recall Matt finding it entertaining albeit middling, until Spacey assassinated someone and checked out. Couldn't take it seriously or on its own terms of this POTUS/candidate was gonna do these risky things and revealing a carelessness towards how it portrays power and how it's exerted.

    • @jackstraw262
      @jackstraw262 Год назад +4

      House of cards isn’t even a movie. “Deck of cards” would be a good one to review and it *is* an actual movie

    • @twistedoperator4422
      @twistedoperator4422 Год назад +1

      @@jackstraw262 They've done series many times.

    • @QEsposito510
      @QEsposito510 Год назад

      Eww!

  • @blakeharris58
    @blakeharris58 10 месяцев назад

    Irish/Scottish people are associated with police overall. I saw Dudley Smith as literally A COP.

  • @greenvelvet
    @greenvelvet Год назад +1

    They really should have had James Ellroy on to talk about this book.
    That would have been fun.
    that guy is crazy

  • @ultravioletiris6241
    @ultravioletiris6241 Год назад +3

    Where is Will getting this info about Kevin Spacey and the Royal Family/Epstein?

    • @craigtrautmanjr9393
      @craigtrautmanjr9393 Год назад +4

      They go into it in the second appearance trianon made on Chapo in April 2020.

    • @ultravioletiris6241
      @ultravioletiris6241 Год назад +4

      @@craigtrautmanjr9393 wow you know your stuff. Thank you

    • @AwesometownUSA
      @AwesometownUSA Год назад +8

      @@craigtrautmanjr9393 you shouldn’t have told him , that guy seems like a fed!

    • @BNardolilli
      @BNardolilli Год назад +2

      @@craigtrautmanjr9393 Hungary will rise again!

    • @BNardolilli
      @BNardolilli Год назад +1

      sugar packets

  • @Ant1Ol
    @Ant1Ol Год назад +11

    Man, I bet this Bessner guy keeps his own farts in jars.

  • @marcuswalters8093
    @marcuswalters8093 Год назад +1

    I love how Americans really emphasise the two syllables of 'noir'. Just love it.