Batman and Geralt Debate The Kill Rule (AI)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 дек 2023
- Batman, the Dark Knight of Gotham, represents a steadfast view of justice as an absolute ideal, a world of black and white where right and wrong are clearly defined. Geralt of Rivia, the famed Witcher, counters with his experiences of a world filled with shades of gray, where choices are tough and morality is often ambiguous.
These videos are written by me, and many of them are part of an ongoing, multiversal narrative. If you would like any characters to be added to the cast, particularly from gaming, let me know in the comments and I will try to work it into the story.
ElevenLabs AI Voice: elevenlabs.io/?from=partnerbu...
Discord: / discord 
Игры
First video with Geralt! Would you like to see more of him?
I want to see him debate Joshua Graham.
Done! Check out my latest video :)@@orangelinedevil2
@@TheCouriersGambit Question, could we see an interaction between Batman and RoboCop? I’m curious on what their views are like.
Like how they describe their views of justice and law
HAVE BATMAN DEBATE THIS WITH KRATOS.
I would like an AI Conversation between Geralt and Aragorn one day :0
Or a Jon Snow and Aragorn interaction
Geralt actually would have been much more agreeable with Batman as he think evil is evil regardless lesser or necessary et. It is the methods that make it so different as Geralt will kill to enact justice while Batman has a "no kill" policy.
For Batman it's a personal choice not to kill, to limit himself to not taking that route as killing would be far easier for him and if he started he knows himself well enough to know that he wouldn't stop. He'd be perfectly fine with the criminals and villians he fights getting executed by the state, the problem is just that his main rogues gallery always gets ruled as not guilty due to criminal insanity and comitted to a mental institution rather than an actual prison or death penalty. If the legal system sentenced them to death he wouldn't have a problem with it, he just won't do the deed himself for personal reasons.
Geralt: Now with that out of the way, fancy a game of Gwent?
Batman: *Nods*
I’d love Geralt and commander Shepard to have a conversation
Renegade or Paragon? Actually, either one may be interesting.
@@TryHard-tr8mn They should do sex-ed.
I'm not even joking.
First time I'm on Geralt's side.
Geralt has never said anything you agree with? You seem like someone I wouldn't enjoy but others might...
Wtf .. geralt is right like 99%
Didn't they both agree they do things practically the same way
Nope I’m on Batman’s sideb
Nope
Can we have Punisher and Batman discussing no kill rule ?
@chandllerburse737I think he meant an AI debate.
You got your wish.
Dunno why but I can see these 2 kinda getting along despite Geralt killing people and monsters which is something Batman would never do especially other people.
To be fair Geralt comes from a much more harsh and bizarre world where killing is often more or less a necessity for survival.
I agree. He dosent do it to be evil je just does it for survival and his job as a Witcher@@tylertheguy3160
@@tylertheguy3160 Geralt also goes out of his way to to avoid killing, and spares sentient/non evil monsters
To be fair Batman has killed parademons in battle but to be fair their demons I guess it doesn't count they're not sentient and their threats to Earth and other planets
To be fair, Batman IS friends with Wonder Woman, and she doesn't have a "no kill" rule.
I love these..philosophical debates between characters.
Geralt might be the only character that i can confidently say would be a match for Batman step for step. Blow by blow and thought by thought they are in essence, the same. They both rely on preparation and careful thought and adapt accordingly. If Geralt were to ever appear in the Batman verse. Batman may very well have that rival that he legitimately cannot defeat nor Geralt could very well ever defeat him except he’s willing to spill blood.
Don't believe it, Batman is known for pushing his body and mind to the human limits, I have seen many claim that Geralt is superhuman, but how could he be? If we go to the books Geralt was completely crushed by Vilgefortz in a fight, normal humans like Bonhart and Cahir can stall him in a sword fight, he was almost killed by a pack of Nekkers, he was killed by a guy with a pitchfork, and Olgierd can give him a fight, although Geralt is considered the best swordsman on the entire Continent, Batman is a master in 127 combat styles including melee weapons, as we saw in Arkham City when using Ra's Al Ghul's sword and talking about This is a guy who depended on the Lazarus Pit to live, so he must be thousands of years old, Batman trained in the League of Assassins and was the best apprentice and was able to defeat him, he can also match Lady Shiva who is considered the DC's best martial artist, in addition to Batman being also considered one of the best martial artists on earth, his IQ is 192, and from what I have researched about Geralt his IQ must be 120, Batman in his world is considered the best detective in the world, Geralt is not, he has good detective skills but not at the level of Batman, he has a suit that protects him and has Gadgets, both use concern and study their enemies and thus know how to defeat them, in a physical fight Batman would win because his skill in martial arts and his feats such as defeating characters more experienced than Geralt himself at 150 years old, Ra's Al Ghul is proof of this, in a fight with prep time, Batman wins and street because by far it has better technology in addition to its gadgets, I don't see Geralt dealing with a Batmobile.
Geralt is basically a Deathstroke but with magic.
@@ThePalebloodHunter but if you re read what I said IF GERALT WAS EVER IN THE BATMAN VERSE meaning he could have all the Tech and advantages Batman has. Meaning he could easily match Batman. Having his mastery of blades and magic, bombs and alchemy would be a mere cherry on top.
@@ThePalebloodHunter Cope.
arkham batman and geralt... i never knew i needed this till now
I can picture the scene: Geralt and Batman on a rooftop. Geralt sitting atop a small stack of cinderblocks next to a fire burning in a metal trash can, and Batman sitting on the corner of the roof, crouched like a gargoyle looking down at the city.
I get a sneaky suspicion that "Kreia" is going to have a *Debate* on Geralt on Morality... 🤔
APATHY IS DEATH
Kreia is like the final boss to end all debates. I’ve never seen that character out-debated.
From what I know of Geralt (feel free to correct me if I'm wrong), he's always struck me as Batman but more realistic.
Batman has his no-kill rule and is always able to maintain it because of a combination of money/technology and plot armor.
His money & technology give him various means to take down criminals in nonlethal ways that they would never expect while also protecting himself.
And, plot armor comes into play in that Batman never seems to be forced into a position where he has to make the hard choice: kill or be killed & Kill or allow an innocent to die. Something or someone always comes into play that allows him to get around it.
He also has the flawed belief that if he crosses that line even once he'll become just as bad or worse than the criminals he fights.
Geralt also has a no-kill rule but he is frequently forced to break it because, unlike Batman, he doesn't have money & technology that gives him a distinct edge over all his opponents and he doesn't have the same level of plot armor that allows him to avoid making that hard choice. When he is forced into a position where it's kill or be killed and/or kill or allow an innocent to die, there is often no dancing around it. Because of this Geralt doesn't have the same false belief as Batman. He feels guilt for the lives he has taken and while it has changed him, it hasn't turned him into a monster like Batman believes. He hasn't lost his morals and continues to fight to protect the innocent.
This level of wholesomeness almost brought tears to my eyes. Nice job.
Batman: Who pays the price for this “balance”, the innocent, the weak?
Geralt: I think the same could be asked about that “code” of yours.
Geralt is right, and u can't tell me otherwise
I want Bats to talk with Postal Dude
I would love that, lol
whats funny is lore wise this could totally happen
Solid snake and Geralt please 🙏🏾
They're pretty much the same dude, lol.
@@notenoughgarlic i know it would be epic just to hear them two converse with one another they would agree with each other on almost everything LOL
if only people could debate like this on those news networks instead of just trying to talk over each other
*Harley Quinn walks up after their debate*
"Just kidding!"
*shoots Batman in the head*
Is it possible to create conversation for anime characters like Alucard (Hellsing) & Guts (Berserk), maybe with their english dubs VAs??
When is Joe Rogan gonna interview Geralt?
Now I would really love to see a debate between Batman and Haytham Kenway.
I remember when I killed whoreson jr. in wild hunt. I know some let him live, but I thought that’d be more of what Geralt would actually do, because in game, you’re walking by at least a dozen of nude corpses of women around Ciri’s age, and Geralt was extremely angry about it. Good thing jr. never actually touched her, there’d probably had been an option to slowly kill him.
Batman on the hand, would have simply beaten him to a pulp.
I would love for Batman to debate Wolverine
I belive that the world is in varying shades of black, grey, and white.
you know it's quite ironic for batman to speak his view that is mostly against himself
1:33 I believe Geralt is referring to Jacque de Aldersberg in this instance.
I would really like to see Batman debate The Kill Rule with Rorschach, Ezio Auditore or Altair, Kratos, Din Djarin or Boba Fett.
Holy crap this is epic.
That fact that you used their actual voices certainly adds a feeling of canonicity.
Wow! I love this! Such a positive message from two different people! And they’re both AI generated! That’s what crazy about it!
Please make more.
Feels like a lawful good character talking to a neutral good character
They both speak truth about justice❤
Wonder how Geralt’s react to Batman’s strength and skill, would be like. A “Human” with strength and skill that far exceeds that of a Witcher. For Witchers where created during a time of need, for “Men” like Batman where a rarity or believe to be impossible to create. 🤔
Batman raw strength definitely don't exceed the strength of a mutant like Witcher, not including their mutagenic & magic powers. the techs & gadgets are tools that can equalize it.
@@crozraven: Have you ever played the Arkham Games, my friend.
@@thedarkknight727 Played it all. Like I said, still human, his strength at its peak human level, while still clearly nowhere near close to greatest power lifter athletes (irl comparison), not superhuman. We are not even including the many inconsistency in the comic books or movies as Batman could be as weak as the writers wanted it (many times btw). Witcher in the lore supposed to be superhuman, with super reflex, super agility, & greater strength than normal human. The game clearly didn't depict Geralt like a some kind OP character for game balancing, but at least you gotta realize how much force it take to decapitate a torso very cleanly, both human & monsters.
@@crozraven: Batman was able to defeat “monsters” like Killer Croc, Titan Joker, Solom Grundy, Clay Face, and Man-Bat, all by himself. Than there’s Deathstroke who is genetically enhanced, defeating Ra’s al Ghul flawlessly despite being over 600 years and enhanced by the Lazarus pit, and defeating several of the Arkham Knights Militias Super Soldiers. Don’t forget that he killed “Dracula” in that Batman vs Dracula, animated movie. Nah my friend I’m standing with what I’ve said Batman has skill and strength that far exceeds that of a Witcher. But in TRUTH, there’s much Batman and Geralt can learn from each other. 😉
@@thedarkknight727 Not exactly a dragon, god or demon, is it?
"Freedom without Discipline is Anarchy.
Discipline without Free Will is Automation.
Free Will without Conscience is Malice."
Someone should do Batman debates Haytham Kenway from assassins creed rogue.
A.M. from I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream converse with The Master from Fallout?
I’m absolutely astounded! This is the first AI that i’ve heard that catches Conroy’s inflections and tones! You need to show DC this process. It could mean Kevin is always with us as the dark knight ❤
Bruce went from the world is full of greys in his second debate with joshua to everything is black and white, other than that, this is great
Batman: “You physically remind me of a friend of mine. Only with long grey hair and a scar instead of short black hair and an S on your chest!”
I may be alone in agreeing with Batman. Good and evil are objective, regardless of perspective
That doesn't really sound like Geralt. I mean the voice itself does but not the message. It sounds like he's trying to convince Batman that there are shades of grey to evil but the Geralt I remember wouldn't have seen it like that. One of the more famous Witcher quotes comes as a response to a wizard trying to convince Geralt to kill a girl in the interest of the "greater good". The quote goes: “Evil is Evil. Lesser, greater, middling… Makes no difference. The degree is arbitary. The definition’s blurred". In this conversation Batman claims that the Witcher is the one blurring the lines and actually uses those words.
In all honesty, I don't know much about Batman and it might be the case that he adheres to his code of morality more strictly than Geralt has. However, even if that were the case I don't think Geralt would ever be arguing in favor of shades of grey of evil and the avoidance of responsibility by claiming difference in perspective.
What about Batman and Big Boss (from Metal Gear series) debate the kill rule and morality?
would love the addition of Max Payne
Jacky Estacado vs Solaire (Light vs Darkness)
Batman is right the greater good is a sloppy slop
“One bad day”!
Bats conceded too easily. He definitely could have argued his point a bit more.
can you do batman and Baldwin IV
Batman and ryu hayabusa
That would be awesome especially since Ryu would state he lives by a code of honor that means sometimes he does have to make that hard call take the lives of villains both human and non-human villains if it means protecting innocent lives because of the greater threat that could harm or worse kill innocents and that's resulted in most of his allies within the Japanese Self-Defense Force and other government agencies stating that "he's no hero but he's not a murderous monster either" meaning he walks that fine line between honor and justice, and vengeance and murder everyday and knows that it's fine line that can be crossed without realizing it and he's dealt with the consequences of his actions both inwardly and physically when he was cursed with the Grip of Murder.
I would like to see Batman debate Judge Dredd.
Batman meets Robocop?
I dunno, I feel that Geralt is way more of a moral absolutist than Batman, in fact Batman is even further from that
Batman and Joshua haha this puts Batman in the black and white
Geralt sounds a lot like snake.
Batman>
This debate is better than most real ones and it was made by a damn A.I. ahhahahahaha
I actually wrote the dialogue, but thank you!
Goddamn, that Batman voice is perfect! I hope WB uses this AI voice.
batman is a hypocrite, he has appointed himself as the judge and jury, geralt just added the executioner, the joker has killed hundreds, thousands of people all because batman doesn't want to cross a line
the funny thing is: Christian bale batman has the perfect answer balancing to this. 'I'm not going to kill you, but I don't have to save you either.'
After bringing in the Joker, even if Batman saw the someone trying to kill joker, he should either tell the person why it's wrong and how he will be forced to bring the attempted murder to justice himself OR let someone else do it. While true you should have the moral of: Even the worst people can change for the better. It's should be tempered with 'don't expect it to happen' or 'Sometimes people get what they deserve. And they deserve to be punished with taking responsibility for their actions.'
But, who really deserves to die? It's always so simple
Gerald = Makes the world better. Batman = makes the world worse.
No. Gotham's government makes Gotham worse. The writers should've made batman ask them to kill joker
@@sarfarazgaming121 I have never said he should kill the joker, but FFS! Stop saving him!
Geralts is way better than Batman!