Military, Punjab & Pakistan - Establishment, Mullah & Pakistan - What is a Praetorian State
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025
- In this video, we explore the intricate history of how Pakistan transformed into a praetorian state, where the military has held an extraordinary grip on the nation's political and economic structures. From its early years, Pakistan’s military establishment positioned itself as the protector of the state, gradually amassing influence that has overshadowed civilian institutions.
We delve into the military’s extensive commercial ventures that have turned it into one of the largest business entities in the country. From real estate to industrial enterprises, these initiatives have provided the military with unparalleled economic leverage, solidifying its dominance across all spheres of power.
The video also examines the complex and often controversial relationship between the military and the clergy. This partnership, known as the "Mullah-Military Alliance," has played a pivotal role in shaping Pakistan’s ideological narrative and political trajectory, often at the cost of democratic development.
Through a critical lens, we analyze how this dominance has impacted Pakistan's governance, democracy, and society at large. Whether you’re a student of history, politics, or simply curious about the dynamics of power in Pakistan, this video offers a comprehensive overview of the forces that have shaped the nation.
📽️ Don’t forget to like, subscribe, and turn on the notification bell to stay updated with our latest content.
Momin' MAN of the NEXT Decade... Mr. Shahrukh, the BOOK BUDDY...
آپ جیسے صرف 10 اور ضرورت ہیں بلکہ اس سے بھی کم... اگر لوگ ان کی باتوں پر عمل کر لیں تو پاکستانیوں جیسی کوئی قوم نہیں اور پاکستان جیسا کوئی ملک نہیں ہو گا
Ek unknown num sy call I to is ny bathroom ma chup k betha hona Hy
Promoting books in Pakistan is such a noble cause & an uphill task .
Keep doing the great work "THE BOOK BUDDY".
👍👍👍
Our beloved Army Never won the War And Never lost elections 😂
Yes 👍 you are wright
Yes😂
No doubt
😂😂😂😂😂
Absolutely yes😂
Other countries have their army or military but in case of Pakistan the military have a country 😂😂
Love you sir ❤
Aj k halaat mai asi video bnanany k liye jigra chaye🫡
As a Pakistani I agree 👍💯 with you,
Being a India i am always respect your knowledge
sir you did your job of shading a light over this serious issue of Pakistan at which no one dare to do, salute you sir 💗
I Agree 100 % with you 😍
They hide their poor mindset by blaming Punjabis
They are all non punjabis
معذرت کے ساتھ
قائد اعظم کا بھی کوئی نظریہ نہیں تھا قائد اعظم محمد علی جناح کی سیاست مذہبی نفرت پر مبنی تھی 😢
Not at all. He just wanted to create an Islamic state where every Muslim live according to islam
And you are saying it in the same Jinnah's pakistan and are able to yap about him with no personal interaction with him.
wo b chotia hi ta
@khalidmufti4463 Sir, Consumimg alcohol is dangerous for your health.
جو ہمیشہ کے لیے داڑھی کاٹتا ہے اس کی نماز قبول نہیں ہوتی (حدیث نمبر 678 صحیح بخاری) محمد علی جناح کو داڑھی رکھنے کی توفیق نہیں ہوئی۔@@muzaffaralimemon5541
That is an amazing video ❤❤
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Absolutely right in 1857 Punjabi soldiers from north and Gurkha they crushed the whole campaign. Raja duleep singh sent to england and Britishers captured Punjab
most of those soldiers were sikhs. The Punjabi Muslims like Rai Ahmad Kharral, Abdul Qadir Ludhianvi, Maulana Thanesari, Murad Fatiana, Baz Abbasi etc resisted British
Mostly Sikhs don't participate in1857 British joined Sikh soilders after colonizing Punjab region because they were trained after that Punjabi Muslims participated in war Rai Ahmed khan kharal kaalay khan gujjar and many more
@@SublimeMBBSLectures
Lol I m Muslim myself and let me clear it to you Muslim punjabis were slaves to British rulers and British army not sikhs mujhy Muslim hoty hue khud afsoos hota hai par yahi Sach. Hai jitna nuqsan Muslim punjabio ne diya hai Muslims ko Yahan Kisi AUR ne nh diya
Honestly i feel proud watching your videos, This video proves your honesty.❤
👍
Wow what a courageous narration, are you in Pakistan? I'm afraid of vigo
13:25 Your Request to the Military should not be anything else but to Go back to the Barracks & let PAKISTAN breath in a space Free of any limitations & State Propaganda.
Now, Pakistan Millitery : Isko bhi lahori churan khilna padega aur software update karna padega warna ye dhoti khol dega re baba 😂
🤦🏻♂️ ye sahi bta raha hai dhoti to ap log pehnte ho right khulenge kis ki fir? 😂 tum log itne radical brainwashed kyu hote ja rha ho Kisi ko bullying kyu karte ho kisi ke channel per aisa comment??
@@MDMUSTAFA-vy1wx
Lungi, Dhoti, tehmat..... sab ek hain
Punjabi ho to TEHMAT to pehenei hogi
Right??
Ya Auraton jaisi SALWAAR hi pahne rehete ho
@@MDMUSTAFA-vy1wxto sach bol rha hai wo Pakistan mei yeh Banda safe nhi hai outside Pakistan sahi hai agar nhi believe to jaakar dekhlo apne journalists ka haal jo sach bolte hai unka kya hota hai. Imran Khan ka recent example hai
Excellent dear Book buddy you explain reality, and l like your way of explanation and you provide good content for us ❤️💖🙏
I really appreciate u sir .. jb jb hmary Danish'war courage show krty hain esy topics py bol k .. khushi hoti hai ❤
very good analysis
really mind blowing shahrukh, one day inshallah you have views in millions
Unbiased
Logical
Tru
Analysis ❤
Very nice ❤❤❤ video excellent analysis awesome.
as a young a student of university i highly inspired by your narrative absolutely u r right we are under a cage of military....
as a student i always think about leaving the country because there is no future for us lies in here IM ALSO A DEFENCE ASPIRRANT BUT learning about pretorian state policies is makes so hard to believe on freedom and diplomacy......
Pakistan military is controling Pakistan since independence, but now people want military to dilute it's power, there is only one institute which is working professionally, and the only reason of unity in Pakistan, Pakistan has taken many steps, which are now effecting Pakistan's interest and geopolitics, but laws should must be respected and every institute should behave legally 🤲
Army puppet 💀💀
@@pahalwanathiest 😅😂🤐
❤🎉
Kp, balochistan and Fata suffered a lot from military laboratory, testing and experiments. 200 billion dollars loss, 76k people dead, F-16, drones, and military operations on the name of war on terror. 33 billion dollars aid from USA.
majority of the people is now fully aware of this scenario. But the million dollars question still pending to be answered and that is "Will Pak Army generals and chain of command will be ever be ready to start diluting its power inside civilian departments?" The clear and obvious answer is "NEVER". The state within state which they have created with hard work since 1947, they wont let it go in this simple "table talk manner".
ruclips.net/video/n_5q3d6k0wE/видео.htmlsi=FZ0hrd-lSITMxyXu
9:57 what a sad grasp on history you have ... People like you are true enemies of Punjab..... Go read about Rai Ahmad Khan Kharal, Nizam Lohar and Bhagat Singh
As an Indian i just can't see Pakistan and Indian conflict in gray. Pakistan is almost all the time was an aggressor.
Nice to know you moved to Canada
Did he?
Really?
@@ffdealers2953dream of every Pakistani 😂😂😂
Samajhdar hai 😌 jahilo se peecha choota 😂
Really ?
Good video bro love from India
Bro it’s been 4 minutes the creator uploaded the video and the video is 21 minutes and you watched the video 😂😅
Wow you have watched 21 min vedio in 2 minutes ...
❤
Well done book buddy. This is what we need in our society. ❤
Bahut badhiya is liye bolta hu sabhi muslim ko padhna chahiye 💯🙏
Bhagt singh, subhash chandra boss,khan abdul gafur khan , Sadar patel,Dahir sen, shivaji and maharana Pratap real hero our indian continent ❤
source?
All nations have armies but in Pakistan, an army has a nation 😂
As one US diplomat said the following: We don't even bother talk to politicians in Pakistan. We talk directly to the Army. The Army decides who will be in the civilian government. When we don't agree with the civilian government we work with the military to remove the current civilian government to bring in those who would work with us. Our Army is an extension of the US foreign policy. That's how loyal these Generals are to Pakistan. In exchange for a few million $$ and a comfortable retirement in the US, Canada, UAE or Europe(Bajwa) they will sell the country to the highest payer. My blunt opinion is that the Army inside the GHQ has become the biggest security threat to Pakistan, They are fast losing the support and loyalty of the citizens of Pakistan and they just don't seem to care. They have corrupted every civilian institution including the Judiciary. Our Army Generals are For Sale.
Sir..inspite of massive and unprecedented Chinese investment in infrastructure projects worth more than US$26 Bn in first phase, Bajwa still went to the US for his farewell tour where he was reported to have said.." we have nothing in common with the chinese..we dont speak their language..eat their food etc.The US designed our military." This was at the Pak embassy in the US with pentagon officials present. Chinese investment that improves the life of ordinary pakistanis meant nothing to him. The country gradually developing its infrastructure meant nothing.
@@butter0milk Bajwa's loyalty was more to his bank account than the country. These Army senior officers have damaged Pakistan. They and Mullahs caused the break up of Pakistan in 1971. They are at it still. GHQ is not loyal to Pakistan.
I love your logical thinking and your presentation are really appreciable
We have wasted too many centuries on religion. When the world was advancing in the 15th with technology as simple as a printing press, our religious establishment opposed it. When the industrial revolution arrived in 19th and the 20th century, we were told that as Muslims we should reject western learning and technology. Pictures, movies, television and countless technological advances including in medicine were declared as un Islamic, by the Mullahs. Muslims completely missed the computer age(produced nothing) in the 20th century. Now our Mullahs are misleading and distracting us from the information technology by issuing misguided Fatwas. Muslims have been systematically destroyed by focusing on after life than this life. The consequences are in front of us. A technologically advanced country of Israel with just 6-Million Zionist settlers from Europe are controlling 375-Million Arabs and may well destroy Iran and Pakistan in the coming years. Our leaders(Feudal, Politicians, Military and Mullahs) are clueless or dont give a damn about our people in pursuit of their own foreign bank accounts.
You can well imagine the wild opposition to Sir Syed Ahmed Khan when he founded the Aligarh Muslim University. He correctly foresaw the decline of muslim position of pre-eminence and the dawn of a new era where muslims could be left behind if they didnt smarten up. Even small time mullahs in every mohalla called him a heretic. The extent of their stupidity never ceases to amaze.
اللہ آپ کو ہر کالے ڈالے سے بچا کر رکھے۔۔بہت بہترین ۔۔❤
Very informative 🎉🎉
Vedio start main sad 😢 hogya but when talked about mullahs power in Pakistani society mera Dil uchal gya Khushi Sy k Chalo kisi ko tu en berio ka BHI khyayal Aya ,I hate molvis More than them Jo en use karty hai,,, Pakistan 🇵🇰 zindabad, democracy faindabad
Well presented vlog. Book Buddy is a gem. Whatever Shahrukh said is very true.
More power to u Shahrukh ❤
Wao whata nice analysis 👍👍💯💯 agree ,,,
Whenever Pakistan Army will realise and say, "We want to have peaceful dialogue with India for greater interest of Pakistan", Real development of Pakistan will start that day. Development pace may be slow, but will surely. Then most embarresed one will be Uncle Sam.😂
Allah aapko Mehfoos rakhe!!
Well done, shahrukh sb
One of my favourite channels ❤
Bohat khoob ❤
Very nice schoalaristc approach,a food for thought for every balance mind,i really appreciate you
Assalam o aalaikum shshzaib sahib, Remain blessed, safe and happy always, May Allah bless Pakistan with safety, peace, unity, stability and prosperity, ameen.
Agreed 💯
respect for your rational thinking
i'm totally agreed with you, i Appreciate your courage to speak truth
agr koi gher-punjabi ye baat kehta hay tu taqatwar log usy racist or ghaddar bolty hain.
jab k haqeeqt ye hy k hum asal cancer ki nishandahi krty hain hamen punjabi se koi nafrt nhi
punjabi mohabbat ki zaban hay or mjhy buht pasand bhi hy ❤
💯% agreed ❤
Please a book summary of these books please
A. How imade over one million Dollars by trading
Commodities last year
(By Larry Williams),
2. Trading in the zone
(By Mark Douglas)
3. New Trader vs Rich Trader
(By Steve Burns)
4. The Disciplined Trader
(By Mark Douglas)
5. Market Wizards
(By.Jack D. Schwager)
Punjabi Muslims regiment fought against Tipu Sultan. They were also the only Muslims in the subcontinent who fought against Ottoman Khilafat as a result of a British-driven coup. Along with the martial race, Brits also called them submissive and no-brainers! All of these shocking stats are well documented in various authentic books from all backgrounds and the British Gazette as well.
May Allah (swt) grant you and your family respect & happiness in this world and hereafter, Ameen!
Book buddy always portray a positive neutral image of any topic, There is no hate for punjabis but a neat fact has been said.
❤❤❤❤
When a soldier also becomes a businessman, he is a businessman first, because money increases human greed and in combination with covert & overt power, it becomes a heady concoction, toxic combination and highly addictive.
What happens when the rulers of a country themselves are addicts in some way ?
They lose unbiased decision making capacity for the welfare of citizens & the society.
And you know who suffers...
you are absolutely right
Great analysis. Thanks.
Outstanding...CSS and PMS best preparation notes
you did absolute superb job Shahrukh
Kudos to you that you've shown courage and enlightened us with an objective and academic analysis about the entrenched role of armed forces and its milbus.
The strength of the military lies in illiterate masses and indoctrinated literates. Using Framing Theory, we have to present a counter narrative which should be so compelling that it can overcome the propaganda of the military. When the youth will acquaint itself with the knowledge of social sciences, only then they would be able to counter the propaganda and make a clear and rational picture of the world.
Once again, you are doing a phenomenal job by raising awareness among the ordinary people who have been deprived of academic knowledge.
Ap Pakistani study or subjects or slaibs par video banao aik baar 9th 10th stander ke books read karo 😊
Wo propaganda syllabus to hum sabne hi parha hua hai or hamare bache bhi woi parhenge😅 video bna k unka time waste hi hoga, koi knowledge to milni nai.
Padhna kya hai wo to pdf download ho jaayegi
@@burnknuckles5906😂😂😂
You are my favorite Creator book buddy.
I like your content and kindly create this type of contents.
dhruv rathee of Pakistan ❤
Syed Muzammil is dhruv rathee of pakistan 😊
Totally Agreed ..Unbiased Analysis..
धर्म के नाम पर देश बनाना,ही सबसे बड़ी ग़लती है एवं विचारधारा की संकीर्णता है।।गलत नींव पर बनी इमारत कभी भी अच्छी नहीं हो सकती है। जब तक यह विचारधारा रहेगी, पाकिस्तान इसी दुख के चक्रव्यूह में फंसा रहेगा।
Ap logo ki bhi yahi vichar dhara badh rahi hai jo apko pandit brainwashed kar rahe hai ap bhi hindu rastra religion per based country bnana chate ho 🤦🏻♂️
@@MDMUSTAFA-vy1wx bcz some sanatani think
Bohat khub...
Bhai aap aisi video bna kr aag se khel rhe ho 😮
I agree with 95% of the things you mentioned.. For usa it doesn't matter what system a country has instead they focus how the country can be controlled. But you mentioned about gher ke chirag se aag lagi, all political chirags are lit and kicked by army in the past. It's only public who decided to stand for one chirag.
abhi sari video ni dekhi aur like kr di ha....achi hi hogi video ♥
It's not punjabi army. It is army of pothohar. Only 4 districts of hilly Punjab (attock, jehlum, rawalpindi, chakwal). U can confirm it by visiting graveyards of pothohar and rest of punjab. Even mehmood khan achakzai mentioned this point in parliament.
Why did you miss Dula bhatti , Rai Ahmad Khan Kharal, Diljeet Singh ,Bhagat Singh, kishan Singh , Lala lajpat Rai and many many more, they all belong to PANJAB , still you are considering PANJAB as a submission, amazing.
how can you title yourself as a teacher !
Sochne ki baat hai! Thanks for mentioning ❤
Absolutely BRILLIANT ❤🎉
Good upload sir👍 Stay blessed.
Well analysis 👏
Well said. Calling spade a spade. But difficult to get out of the trap.
I'm Indian but I agree and appreciate his knowledge
Agr pakistani es trha sochne lag jaye to Pakistan great ban jayega
That is why pakistan is day by day black
well articulated analysis
Sad to hear something derogatory about Imran Riaz Khan. Dear book Buddy we expect you to speak some more clearer then this then I'm quite hopeful that you'll understand the pain of people who are fighting against the tyrannical regime. Imran Riaz spent 5 months under brutal torture for the sake of this country. Imran Riaz speaks with clarity. You can not, if you speak then you won't be available to upload the next video. So please don't try to act much smarter. We are fighting. Let us fight and do your work of lifting people intellectually. "All the political assassinations are carried out by Pakistani military" Imran Riaz Khan. Book buddy, this is not propaganda. Please do say this in the next video then you'll realize that no one is an idiot to do such propaganda that endangers life, family, honor, business, everything. We don't need army to control this fabric because we know that it is the army who developed this fabric. Once the Army is in barracks, the mullah monopoly will automatically weaken.
Superb❤
excellent
Right sir very very good
V informative
Just like a wow video ❤❤
Great video
Zabardast 👍
You are hundred percent right ✅
all wars pakistan lost were under non punjabis, 2 out of 3 operations in balochistan were done by non punjabis, 3 out of 4 dictatotrs were non punjabis
Only in 1971 Pak lost
1947 Pak Gained Territory
1965 Defended and push BACK
1998 kargil war political defeat only tigerhill was recaptured by Indian army after Pak left
Point
@@KhanLikeNo0ther😂😂 wake up from dream.
@@KhanLikeNo0ther😂 Totally brainwashed
@@KhanLikeNo0therread more about 1965. Not your army dictated school books… pak had attacked India taking advantage of a weak India in turmoil after death of Nehru and loss to china and economic crisis… pak had superior USA supplied weapons and thought it was their best chance to get Kashmir…
The sudden attack surprised India and by the time they could respond pak army was within close distance of Srinagar.. had India tried to send troops to defend Kashmir, it would be late…
The great strategic decision was taken to attack Lahore.. mind you India wasn’t aiming to capture Lahore., the aim was to surprise Pakistan and force them to pull back forces from Kashmir to focus on defending Lahore. It worked and pak forces left Kashmir to defend Lahore….
It was a stalemate as far as territorial loss or gain is concerned… but as far as loss in men and materials was concerned. Pakistan lost much heavily….
And yes, pak was the aggressor and attacker in 1965, just like other four wars….
masterpiece😍😍😍
Ok sar❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Good work
Jazak ALLAH Sharukh bhai ❤❤❤❤
Exmuslim mulhid apostate jindabad
You Are 1001% Right