In reference to my comment about Lisa's styling: I've since seen more of the discussion surrouding the box braids and I'd like to make it clear that I do not support costuming cultures no matter who does it. I'm sorry for any confusion.
I don't think its appropriation though...she isn't making fun of it or anything so why is it bad? There's difference between appropriation and appreciation
really, hope not, aiiyl, kick it and stay are pure examples that teddy can write good and full choruses but for a reason being appealing to the wider audience with the title and sub title tracks he chooses not to.
Sadie Sirjue no she didn’t. There is literally no evidence or proof that Jennie wrote it. It’s fine if she doesn’t write. Not every idol is not lyricist anyways. It’s ok.
@@LM-ix7pk she wrote 70 songs on her lap top, but someone stole it. She wrote a letter to not touch her laptop. And she even said herself in Solo diaries that when you write yourself songs you get emotional. This was when Jennie cried on stage. Even Hanbin (B.i from Ikon) wrote whistle and didn't even get credited for that.
The sad thing is, if we're going to compare the songs he made for 2NE1, the structure and overall quality are on another level. IDK what's happening, actually, is it just Teddy or YG's preference?
@@jessicamariano6225 I don't know, but with 2NE1's discography, he's proven that he can produce good, even wonderful content. I can't tell if this is YG & Yan Hyun Suk (the former CEO) making him do this or if it's really of his own volition. And if it is of his own volition, then I am sorely disappointed in him as a producer. Has anyone ever heard of The Leaders? It's written by G-Dragon, CL, and Teddy, and Teddy even produced it himself. It proves that he's capable of creating quality content, so I don't know what in the seventh hell is going on but I know I don't like it. I admit I jumped on the BP bandwagon without ever even really knowing where they came from at first. I think they first got me at Whistle or Boombayah, can't remember which. All I can remember is that I don't think I'd been aware of 2NE1's disbandment at the time, I just thought they were on hiatus. By the time I'd actually bothered to do research, I was...confused to say the least. Especially when I saw the timeline of the disbandment and BP's debut. It all seemed very suspicious, and it only got worse the more I delved into the 2NE1 disbandment. To this day, I am furious with YG and it's sh*tty former CEO and it still baffles my mind to this day how this can happen. I don't know if Teddy is being deliberate with this, and I honestly don't really want to.
@@StarlightStella613 True, it's sad that this ossie is becoming more apparent with Blackpink. I undrstand that he works with other producers as well but I think in the end, YG has more of the final say (he needs to get his personal preferences in check tbh, music is ever evolving and his tastes aren't keeping up with it) In Teddy's case, I can understand that he may be pressed for time because he also handles THEBLACKLABEL but, idk what's the use of YG's other producers then. All in all, YG should really invest in good music producers. Idol content is what keeps the fans and the fame, and the most basic we need is music! They are idols first before they are models/influencers/variety stars, etc. Also, Teddy won't be in YG forever and his idols (specifically the boy groups) would often need help to produce songs. Really, YG get yourself in check with music production 😓
@Emilia Knight wow I feel the same. After KTL’s bridge and “outro” I expected to hear the chorus one more time but nope! It really does feel like something’s missing
I have been saying that since D4. Everyone was all, I love this! And I was asking where is the rest of the song? I felt like I was the only person who hated this song because of how it made me feel so disappointed and distanced from BP.
YES. KTL, in particular, felt so anticlimactic to me. I was waiting for some sick breakdown or dance break at the end to drop. But nah...just disappointment.
- intro - “blackpink” - jennie sing-rapping - lisa rapping - jisoo/rosé singing - jisoo/rosé singing - beat drop + shout the title - “yeah” - shout the title again - rap - jisoo/rosé singing - jisoo/rosé singing - beat drop + shout the title - “yeah” - shout the title again - rosé sings an english bridge - dance break ft. remix
@@catalayalafaye5337 an American ya/mystery/thriller author who legit has released so many books that people claim he is just regurgitating the same shit every time, with different named characters or sum (or ppl claim he doesn't even write all his books)
@@jharnakarki6214 But that doesnt change the fact that they all are really similar in pattern. Take mamamoo for example, every song is different in its own way. Every song except for stay is of the same genre, and having the same pattern doesn't help either. They lack versatility, and you blinks cannot change that fact.
it's hilarious to me how "how you like that" came out yesterday, i am watching this now and this entire video could just be copied and pasted exactly the same to talk about it.
Am I the only person who hates/has noted the end of the song in KTL? It seems extremely rushed and unfinished, as if they forgot something because it’s so abrupt but I haven’t heard anyone mention it
The chorus sounds empty as well, there is something missing from multiple points of this song and it makes it hard to listen to this as anything more than background music.
Fxte msp Typically after the second the chorus there would be a bridge leading to the ending, which would probably make it seem less rushed. In KTL the bridge would be “we all commit to love” part, ending at “we must kill” the bridge is soo short in this song that its barely noticeable since it just cuts to “we must kill this love”. The ‘bridge’ is so tiny its under 20 words if you count words like “as, us, we” etc. It also may seem very abrupt because the bridge is very slow, and it just out of the blue cuts to blasting trumpets and the ending.
The ending seems abrupt because it is the first song of the album. It is meant to seem unfinished so you would want more. I admit that they still could've tried to add something more so it would be satisfying by itself.
i know blackpink already get so little comebacks and it sucks that fans have to eat everything and anything up, no matter if they enjoy it or not. but this needs to be said. if you don't like the music and *still* buy and stream it, it isn't going to change. d4 and ktl are, from an outsider's perspective, blackpink's most popular and best songs, considering they have the highest album sales and youtube and spotify streams. can you blame the company for sticking with that sound if they think people enjoy it? blinks who didn't enjoy ktl (and i know a lot of them), why did you still stream the mv so much? it has *700 million* views for crying out loud. which group has numbers that high on a song that is generally disliked by the fandom? are they really going to have 2 mvs with 1 billion views and both of those songs were most blinks' least favorite comebacks? doesn't make any sense. if you really want a different sound, make it known to yg. stream only songs that you like. that's what normal people do anyway.
100% true. It bothers me when kpop fans stream and buy songs they don't like just to get their favs views and sales. If you don't like it you don't need to buy it. Makes you no less of a fan.
The worst part is that KTL's English, albeit unnatural, makes sense, but Jopping's borderline qualifies for gibberish. Both songs try to imitate AAVE (African American Vernacular English, the English dialect of hip hop), but Teddy gave up half way through and decided to go back to good ol' standard English, while SM went all the way but get AAVE all wrong-they think AAVE doesn't make sense to standard English speakers, but in truth *AAVE makes sense* as much as any language does. The only good part is a small verse of Mark's, which sounds exactly like what I would expect a North American rapper to spit out (he's Canadian). He must've taken his AAVE classes and written the verse himself.
@@mottenelf4258 and comments can be made by people watching a video on a public platform, on a video made to be commented on. it is a valid point, this is called having a conversation. try it sometime. it is fun.
@@iamagirl8056 I don't think so there will be people who like songs that majority of the fandom doesn't but some really don't hype them if they don't like it in many fandoms. But majority of the blinks not all but majority even if they don't like it they stream you know why because yg starves the fandom so whatever they gave blinks will hype them.
There’s a high chance they will. As YG focuses on their new group, their older groups will be ignored. But hopefully this will let the girls have time to write music or really focus on where they want their career to go.
@@idontfeelsogood6056 Little correction: As YG focuses on their new girl group, their older girl groups will be ignored. YG still prefers Winner over iKON and hasn't done a thing with Treasure so far. Also, the only reason they prefer Winner is because Bigbang are technically still on hiatus.
Sagit YG doesn’t prefer winner over ikon. YG prefers Mino and Bobby over their group mates. And don’t expect treasure to debut anytime soon. It took YG almost a decade to plan for bp and even with all that time they constantly changed everything from the line up to their brand name
And the worst part of this is that their songs are kinda 50% in english, but it's not the type of a decent lyric writing is more of the kind of cringing lyrics and it's not like Teddy doesn't know how to speak or write in the language bc he was raised in NY like wtf dude?!
g gasca i agree. Have you seen the English raps in the Japanese versions? BLACKPINK’s raps are the types of raps like a bunch of teenagers make up to roast each other. Like yeah they sound good and are catchy but they have no substance whatsoever.
I know I'm literally a year late but Kill This Love is also literally just a Samsung ad with many clear product placements. -Rosé showing off a galaxy watch in her car scene -All the members wearing galaxy buds in the first chorus -Lisa and Jennie holding galaxy phones during their english rap Idk what to think about this but it kinda shows that this "comeback" is more about money than giving the fans what they want.
I know right, but it's not Blackpink's fault, it's YG. The new CEO is using Blackpink for money cause she's a gold digger, it's literally so obvious especially the new 4+1 project for their 5th Anniversary, we had to pay to see Blackpink 😢
I am a year late too but too be honest it may sound bad but if I had that fame I will make a comeback introducing brands I some how represent is not bad its Smart it doesn't kill any one
I don’t know why I am just hearing about this channel. I love the way u talk, it gives me goosebumps, and they way u say opinions without bashing the groups is everything. Why can’t other channels be like u and kpop Junkie
am i the only one that thinks blackpinks choreography is lame??? we've all seen the predebut video of them dancing in the basement to rihanna we know they can dance better
@ idk why it just seems to lag? if that makes sense? like i see what they are doing but if it wasn't for the fancy camera work on live stages it would just seem... blah? that 'dance break' for D4 was just bad.
@ at first D4 is just "easy" level for me and one year later KTL come. Lmao, i don't even trying to learn KTL because it's similar to D4. And yes, i'm a dancer.
People would have realize that 7songs are the same if there weren't a FULL YEAR in between each of the song. And you know what happens in a year?? People forget about songs and that's how they got people into believing "ho my god blackpink is the revolution"...
8 songs with Don't know what to do. The chorus follows the same pattern. A phrase (I don't know what to do without you). Onomatopoeia (yeah yeah yeah) and edm
A little old, but true. International fans don't want English, I if I wanted English would go listen to English music. Too much English screams 'Desperate to American Sucess', and you don't really need that. Besides, if A Kpop Fan says they prefer English versions, they are not Kpop fans. This not what a true I-Kpop fan signed for.
YGs method to break blackpink into the west is like a man on a bike showing up to your house to offer you his religion but instead of the Book of morman it's the same chorus 7 times
I honestly didnt like „kill this love“ Its sounded just like „Ddu-du-ddu“. also the lyrics of the Song felt really meanigless and bland. I feel like blackpinks Songs are getting More and more boring with every Comeback
I think there is a meaning behind Let's Kill This Love.I'm pretty sure its about a girl who is in a toxic relationship, its shown throughout the music video
@@mikaelarose6277 Maybe but this type of meaning is boring and unoriginal like try something else ? Something really useful ? Society ? Self love ? Youth ? Friendship ? Their is Soo many subjects you can talk about in your lyrics. BlackPink have a huge following and I don't understand why they don't use this following to spread a good message. Maybe their writer don't have the skill to it, but even writing songs about toxic relationships can be poetic at least but here most of it don't really make sense and lyrically wise it's very poor and the vocabulary is trash. Most BlackPink lyrics are trash. Hopefully one day they can write their own music even though I don't think it will ever happen.
@@-amel-9896 Its still a problem in the society tho:( Many girls still are in toxic relationships without knowing what to do. It's not as serious but it's also a problem society faces nowadays. I think they're just telling girls to stand up? Be strong? 🤷♀️
@@_wobblyjelly_2700 How many times did artists cover this subject ? Maaaany times. Honestly toxic relationships aren't something new, and they probably don't know a lot about it since they aren't even allowed to date
Xyz Xyz that’s the point tho, she was trying to say that YG made them so that they are more suited towards America and international places whereas they are a kpop group, it’s sad because they barely get any attention in Korea and are way less famous there than internationallly. YG made them so that they would be internationally famous which is fine but it’s weird since they are u know a kpop group
Very late, but when I first heard KTL, I’d listen to it on loop and still get thrown off when the Korean part of the second pre-chorus came up, just because I got so used to them singing in English. And that’s not even with the Japanese version, where Lisa’s rap in the first verse is also in English.
YouYou I think it’s their best album? After wings ofc lool. How come you think it’s a flop, everyone I’ve come across loved it. Edit: nvm, just found out you’re an anti from your other replies to comments, what a saddo 😂
Keerthi Bushan I forgot I made this comment but the user made anti comments that weren’t relevant to the video regarding bts. They were saying things against bts loll. It was childish behaviour and you saw how I respected their opinion and kindly asked why they believe wings wasn’t a good album. They deleted their comments so you won’t be able to see anyway 😂
I feel like KTL ends abruptly, I think they should have done the chorus again and then end the song. Tbh the whole song sounds very empty it needs more lyrics I think.
I feel like a scandal happened with yg so Yg just said “BLACKPINK is having a comeback” and rushed the whole entire song to get the scandal of there back.
@@Ablumeofficial Criticism is not the same as hate. The only one hating here is you, 'stoopid ass'...really haha, no one was cursing except for you..that's rude.
Guys, isnt it clear about the difference between SuperM and bp situations? SuperM consists kpop idols, but it was explained in advance they were going to promote in the usa only, thats why they made song full of English. They werent going to promote in Korea, win Korean shows, rely on their korean fanbases, have korean promotions etc - only west. They kinda officially debuted in the us. Bp otherwise want Korea to support them, but still had song 65% made of English. The difference is obvious.
he's trying to throw bp more at the American market because there are more people in American than Korea. also if there's more naive fans who don't know about yg's past then that means more money will be thrown his way
"yg's method to break blackpink into the west is like a man on a bike showing up to your house to offer you his religion but instead of the book of mormon it's the same chorus 7 times" this line made me scream
I remember honestly being disappointed they didn’t keep her blue hair in that once scene as it fit her to a t. I remember while I was still hype I definitely took a moment seeing the braids on her, they just looked so ugly to me. I didn’t mind her outfit but I just felt her hair completely distracts you from her outfit entirely.
Visiting this video again- I feel like people don’t realise the Teddy structure because they’re so thirsty for a blackpink comeback that anything will satisfy them even if it is the same recycled beat and lyrics Edit: I just watched the comeback and I am not disappointed,, it didn’t sound like ktl AT ALL and it was a completely fresh sound 💜 I’m glad that it isn’t a recycled beat and sounds like a completely new song :)
that's the problem. yg could make ktl part 2 for the next comeback and blinks would eat it up and make it chart just because yg doesn't really like to give his groups content.
@@zaic8660 True, this is disrespectful to both BTS and SuperM tbh, SM deleted their tweet after it was called out. They are be using BTS's success to make a name for their group when in reality it's not giving them any legacy. The embarrassing thing about it is that the article was making this comparison with BTS because superm sold out arenas, which is.. very ridiculous compared to what BTS can sell out. It's been years that they don't perform in arenas anymore, they perform in stadiums. BTS sell out stadiums, not arenas. Arenas are easily just the fans's waiting room.
-Amel- superm may not have bts popularity and success in America but their doing just fine and why y’all annoying bts always try and compare every Kpop group trying to break into the US market to bts, some Kpop groups just want a successful across over into the US market their not trying to be bts or to beat bts they just wanna be a global success and that means trying to be successful in the US like the rest of the world not everything is about bts or trying to compete with them be happy for bts success but don’t try and down another group also trying to be a success in the US, it’s funny that superm and bts cool with one another wanna see one another succeed in everything they do yet their sh*tty fans always fighting in stupid fan wars trying to put them against one another and it’s pathetic
@@lovelydiva06 What's wrong with you ? Why everytime someone mention BTS you guys interpret it as comparing it with other groups or hating on them ? I am talking about SM entertainment who shared an article saying that Super M is the next BTS, and this is exactly where I am mad about because this is what comparing without any reason is. SM entertainment ≠ Super M members I don't think you clearly understood what I was trying to say. You guys get offended for everything jeez
im super super gay for ryujin I mean that’s the thing sm and yg can’t seem to understand, u don’t make kpop groups targeted at the western market and expect the west to eat it up, the audience won’t prefer superm or bp over other acts just bc their songs have like 80% English lyrics. Or, in superm’s case, a kpop group made specifically for the western market. Kinda feels like how some companies tried to debut kpop groups formed solely with western members a few years ago, it just won’t appeal to the audience
I’m going to say it, I didn’t like How You Like That, I’m disappointed. One local in Twitter just said that the song is so bad that he can’t believe how people listen to it non-ironically. I don’t think the song is bad but blinks waited one year for the comeback and some of them are disappointed.
FROM MY EXPERIENCE: i was a hardcore blink from debut untik aiiyl, but then i unstanned bc i got bored. but when i was somewhat a blink again, i made some friends that are hardcore blinks. i asked them if they actually liked blackpink's latest songs, they said they did but they didn't at the same time. they said, THEY WANT AND LIKE BLACKPINK, but they don't really like their songs so much. they like it bc blackpink sings it. not the music itself. do you guys know what i mean?? i stopped being somewhat a blink because i don't wanna stream music i don't like just bc i like the artist. i want good music. not models who advertise the music. i'll still support blackpink whatever they do, but not at the same level as before. i hooe they get better treatment.
Totally agree with you I can't understand korean So the only thing I am here for is good music and if I can't even get that whats the point of listening kpop when there is other pop other around which I can understand too
There’s this video called “why I unstanned blackpink (the k-pop industry at its worst)” that points out how all of blackpinks songs were written before they even DEBUTED. So yeah YG’s really leaving us hanging here
The reason they do not have that many albums or songs is because YG makes enough money with what they are doing already. YG makes enough money through CFs and sponsorships. Since they do, the music seems to come last. Also, if blinks continue to stream music videos, buy merch and support them financially, YG won't change their strategy. Also, they only have a comeback once a year because the longer they wait, the more demanding blinks are. The more demanding blinks are, the more popular blackpink grows due to trends demanding for a comeback. Then, when the internet is practically begging for a comeback, YG releases it and gain more money from it. This is also why I don't believe in the 'I support Blackpink but not YG' argument. If you support blackpink, you are supporting YG and giving them what they want which affects us. And also, we've seen what YG does with that money (Burning Sun Scandal, scandals where YG has been accused of giving their staff/idols sex workers, drug scandals, overworking idols...). Yes a percentage does go to Blackpink but the money is used for more bad than good.
That's unfortunately the problem. Everyone laps up all the scraps and junk that a lot of companies/producers/songwriters are putting out bc we don't want our groups to disband or become forgotten. But unfortunately it means that those same companies/producers/songwriters get complacent with the easy money and the thirst that they continue to just churn out the Teddy repetition (since this vid is about BP I'll just use the example given) until consumers make a song repeat utterly and completely *flop*. YG tosses scraps and expects praise and adoration for it and because fans know that groups live or die by the bottom line, fans of every fandom just lap it all up no matter how much they hate it, no matter how much it's the same thing over and over, because they don't want their groups to go away. The problem is, the songs that are suffering those flops are usually from new groups that come in, get a song or two, and then disappear - it's not going to change until the consumer mindset changes where we're no longer going to be content with whatever we're given, even if it's crappy - and that needs to happen to a bigger group for the industry as a whole to shake itself out of this complacency.
KTL was a hit!! I’m Brazilian and this song introduced me to blackpink. I was literally obsessed with the mv and playing this song on loop. Yes, there is a formula. But the formula works
@@bibicute942000 same. like there are some songs where I need an empty chorus because the verses are so damn dense (well emptier) like Stray Kids's Side Effects and Dreamcatcher's Scream - it gives me a chance to breathe and process what just happened in the previous verse. But... blackpinks verses are just as empty - like thx Teddy you lazy ass
... we just got the same formula AGAIN this time and the fans are about to give YG their money anyway and prove that starving them works. This will keep happening as long as we let YG get away with it.
I really like “Kill This Love”. If you listen to American pop, all the songs sound the same to me (but with different words). Same song structure, predictable lyrics.
Ronald Chan I like it aswell, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t a carbon copy of dx4. And I agree with your opinion on American pop as well; however some pop artists tend to have a different sound making them more intriguing
For me, being the same doesn’t necessarily make it good. Stop reading now if you don’t want my opinion. I like it when the songs have elements that aren’t heard with other songs. I like it when the producers experiment. I’m guessing it’s why I like groups like BTS, Stray Kids and MAMAMOO so much. They *experiment* with the tones in their songs and the concepts. Almost every song is different.I thought Kill This Love was OKAY. It wasn’t outstanding but it wasn’t the worst. Really, I just listened to it a few times over the course of a week and just stopped. In fact, I recently stopped stanning BP. They are talented but I just got BORED of them. I never really wanted to listen to their songs anymore, besides a select few. Usually, when they appeared on my playlist, I would skip them because I simply didn’t feel like listening to them. They have a lot of potential. Great singers, superb rappers, good dancing. But the way it was being used really put me off. I just didn’t have it in me to say I am a Blink when I don’t truly enjoy their music anymore.
Dang it, girl! Your content is so good. You've essentially read my mind on the whole BlackPink subject, especially that Mormon analogy. YG dropped everything, including Lee Hi and 2ne1, for something **fresh** and **new** to show America, not even realizing the love was homegrown and established from afar, not custom made for us.
Blackpink is an amazing kpop girl group whom I Stan and it's YG's fault for treating them not right Jennie: most hated Lisa: most discriminated Rosè: most mistreated Jisoo: most underappreciated
I have a love hate relationship with this MINI album, i hate kill this love's chorus like it puts me off so much and the ending is an ew. Kill this love could have been a masterpiece but teddy was like NOPE. I hope the next comeback can be better than everything they have put out until now. Also we are getting an early 2020 comeback right? Yeah fuck no they have post poned it I AM LOSING IT
Kill this love is a master piece. Periodt! It has the most views in 24hrs after boy with love. And for you the chorus part would be boring but for me it's the best thing I've ever heard!! I'm just saying dont take it personally
@@kokkiearmy3812 just because a song is popular doesn't mean it's good (it's okay if you like kill this love, ofc), but it's kinda obvious ktl was going to have a lot of views bc all the hype around blackpink (and the fact that fans had to wait a loooot for a cb). the same with boy with love, for me it's not a bad song but meh ,,,, but since it was released by bts, who are really popular and have a huge fandom, it makes sense that the song would be successful .
I think it's gonna be the same blueprint. Teddy has gotten really lazy with his songs, at least the ones released. I don't think YG has ever cared about musical intergrity, just how much money they can milk from their artists. BP makes a hell of a lot more being models than releasing music, they do the bare minimum to keep fans roped in. While it's okay to like their songs, but anyone can see the pattern and you shouldn't be satisfied. Look at any other group, they get minimum of 2 comebacks a year and other variety appearances ON TOP of their CF's. Blinks shouldn't be satisfied with a bare minimum music wise. Touring brings a lot of money too, but who wants to pay a lot of money to hear same songs over and over. Even Jennie has thrown shade at YG when she said at a concert "i'd perform more songs if I had any". BP is heading towards not renewing their contracts after 7 years. While that is still far away, who would stay at a company that doesn't let you explore your musicality. They trained for years, to be shelved as models. All their musical talent is being completely wasted by shoving them into this box that is their discography. Even if it's just b-sides, for the love of god, YG needs to let them explore more musically. And the girls likely are more than capable of producing songs themselves. THe difference between Ikon and BP is crystal clear. Ikon has a more diverse discography, because they produce their music mostly by themselves. YG is doing the bare minimum to get the most profit and Blinks, you really shouldn't be satisfied with it. And I understand it's difficult to go against YG, cause the company decides. But I think Blinks are strong fandom and could make a change. Unfortunately I don't have an answer to how. There's more than enough people in the fandom to get their attention. Hit them where the money is as that's what the company cares about the most.
I just realized DKWTD also is like this -Phrase: Don't know what to do -onomatopoeia: Youuuuuuuuu~ -the circling noises(doessn't know how to explain it)
They use so much english words to break in to America when *Blackpink* is a *Korean* girl group... Is YG that hungry for money? I hope the situation gets better but it will only happen if YG wakes up
Same honestly- It's like 95% English, I dunno if you can even categorize that in the category Kpop lmao. (no hate tho, I love SuperM with all of my heart-)
Guys, isnt it clear? SuperM consists kpop idols, but it was explained in advance they were going to promote in the usa only, thats why they made song full of English. They werent going to promote in Korea, win Korean shows, rely on their korean fanbases, have korean promotions etc - only west. They kinda officially debuted in the us. Bp otherwise want Korea to support them, but still had song 65% made of English. The difference is obvious.
I used to love BP but, once I realized the songs sounded the same I just kind of lost love for it. And the comebacks. They come like Christmas. It's blinks gift from YG.I still love my girls tho. I literally forget that BP exist until I see a Twitter post and go," Oh yeah, Blackpink".
no dkwtd sounds so generic... that stupid anticlimactic drop ruined it. sounds like a rejected chain smoker 2016 chorus. BUT the dance, and verses were so good a big step up 😍 i loved the subtle rock influence but the drop just ruined it. the best song was kick it what an underrated bop.
Kill This Love, was the song that killed my love for BP. That was kinda like the catalyst that made me open my eyes towards so many things that's just wrong about BP and YG. And, I don't want to support a group that barely has any content. I'm sorry if it seems rude, but BP does not deserve the hype anymore. There are too many new groups coming out with fresh concepts, and they aren't afraid to try new styles, and many who are doing the badass concept better.
i honestly find BLACKPINK's songs old and almost the same. i mean... all of their songs have 50% english lyrics and they never had a full korean song. i don't hate them.. i just really can't bop with the concept of the tunes.
I think some people expect too much from pop songs. They're meant to be simple and catchy. American pop does this too. It's nothing new. Honestly, if it wasn't for Teddy's trap beats, I would've never found this group. I hope they get on more trap beats. And, yes, trap beats follow a particular formula. All genres of music do.
Teddy during 2NE1 era is amazing. 2NE1 discography is so unique, way beyond their years and so diverse compare to all 1st and 2nd gen kpop gg. That is why 2NE1 become the LEGENDARY OG BADASS QUEENS they are now. Social media specially YY was not that relevant that time but 2NE1 became the 3rd biggest gg next to Spice Girls and TLC and was able penetrate western music scene. 2NE1 is Teddy's muse and in my opinion he just lost his touched when it comes to BP. It's like just his making songs for BP because it's what his supposed to do.
FINALLY some addresses the repetition, god I can’t even, and the new song too omg And all those non kpop fan hyping up cause it’s simply “cool” I’m like seriously non of you see/ hear this ???? God I’m dying
In reference to my comment about Lisa's styling: I've since seen more of the discussion surrouding the box braids and I'd like to make it clear that I do not support costuming cultures no matter who does it. I'm sorry for any confusion.
mera ty for saying this ♥️
I don't think its appropriation though...she isn't making fun of it or anything so why is it bad?
There's difference between appropriation and appreciation
Let Lisa wear her braids, the rest can deal
They don't actually look like box braids, they just look like braids but with pigtails
@@nixlovestrix3894 If you look closely you can see the box style the braids they are.
sometimes i feel like YG is forcing BlackPink into the US market...
Honey he is.
Honey you think he is
Well they are lmao
Why else would 3/4 members knows fluent English
Because they are.
really, hope not, aiiyl, kick it and stay are pure examples that teddy can write good and full choruses but for a reason being appealing to the wider audience with the title and sub title tracks he chooses not to.
Ikr
Stay was written by jennie*
@@sadiesirjue2835 right i forgot lol
Sadie Sirjue no she didn’t. There is literally no evidence or proof that Jennie wrote it. It’s fine if she doesn’t write. Not every idol is not lyricist anyways. It’s ok.
@@LM-ix7pk she wrote 70 songs on her lap top, but someone stole it. She wrote a letter to not touch her laptop. And she even said herself in Solo diaries that when you write yourself songs you get emotional. This was when Jennie cried on stage. Even Hanbin (B.i from Ikon) wrote whistle and didn't even get credited for that.
*HYLT comes out.*
"I mean it's not like Teddy would write the same chorus seven times, right?"
Nah, he'd write it eight times.
I CANNOT
If D4 and Ktl had a child it would be hylt
@@hoorkpop6735 it is ktl and d4's child
@@acacia2649 I think so
This will have me cackling for days
"Quality over quantity? YG, you give me NEITHER of those."
Im gonna tattoo that on my forehead.
Jay Lin teaaaaaaa
@@ikonrm7688
NGL, mera should a producer or sumn
the disrespect, these 4 girls didn’t go through hell to put out content for you to say it has no quality.
@@mysticpink4902
Question, did you watch this video or did you stop half way through becoz u felt offended by mera's opinion?
@@mysticpink4902
How about watching first then comments later?
“ I could sell yg to satan for a corn chip “ that’s too much sis I would not sell him for the bacteria in my bathroom
plus corn chips have the benefit of being tasty. but I still laughed when she said that.
Sis I would pay satan to take him
Y'all got it wrong, how YG has done their artists dirty... Satan will take him for FREE and replace him so he can get some music!
I would sell him for free
I would trade him with Satan for god damn homework. HoMeWoRk
"the teddy formula" sounds like some scientific or mathematic thing lol
The sad thing is, if we're going to compare the songs he made for 2NE1, the structure and overall quality are on another level. IDK what's happening, actually, is it just Teddy or YG's preference?
@@jessicamariano6225 I don't know, but with 2NE1's discography, he's proven that he can produce good, even wonderful content. I can't tell if this is YG & Yan Hyun Suk (the former CEO) making him do this or if it's really of his own volition. And if it is of his own volition, then I am sorely disappointed in him as a producer. Has anyone ever heard of The Leaders? It's written by G-Dragon, CL, and Teddy, and Teddy even produced it himself. It proves that he's capable of creating quality content, so I don't know what in the seventh hell is going on but I know I don't like it. I admit I jumped on the BP bandwagon without ever even really knowing where they came from at first. I think they first got me at Whistle or Boombayah, can't remember which. All I can remember is that I don't think I'd been aware of 2NE1's disbandment at the time, I just thought they were on hiatus. By the time I'd actually bothered to do research, I was...confused to say the least. Especially when I saw the timeline of the disbandment and BP's debut. It all seemed very suspicious, and it only got worse the more I delved into the 2NE1 disbandment. To this day, I am furious with YG and it's sh*tty former CEO and it still baffles my mind to this day how this can happen. I don't know if Teddy is being deliberate with this, and I honestly don't really want to.
@@StarlightStella613 True, it's sad that this ossie is becoming more apparent with Blackpink. I undrstand that he works with other producers as well but I think in the end, YG has more of the final say (he needs to get his personal preferences in check tbh, music is ever evolving and his tastes aren't keeping up with it)
In Teddy's case, I can understand that he may be pressed for time because he also handles THEBLACKLABEL but, idk what's the use of YG's other producers then.
All in all, YG should really invest in good music producers. Idol content is what keeps the fans and the fame, and the most basic we need is music! They are idols first before they are models/influencers/variety stars, etc. Also, Teddy won't be in YG forever and his idols (specifically the boy groups) would often need help to produce songs. Really, YG get yourself in check with music production 😓
*issue, not ossie
Next thing they are gonna start teaching it at school
Blackpink songs always sound short to me.
And not like I was having to much fun and lost time, but like where is the rest of the song?
Incomplete, then?
They never feel complete to me, almost like they were rushed. When in reality they have about 1 comeback a year, so how would the songs be rushed?
@Emilia Knight wow I feel the same. After KTL’s bridge and “outro” I expected to hear the chorus one more time but nope! It really does feel like something’s missing
I have been saying that since D4. Everyone was all, I love this! And I was asking where is the rest of the song? I felt like I was the only person who hated this song because of how it made me feel so disappointed and distanced from BP.
YES. KTL, in particular, felt so anticlimactic to me. I was waiting for some sick breakdown or dance break at the end to drop. But nah...just disappointment.
- intro
- “blackpink”
- jennie sing-rapping
- lisa rapping
- jisoo/rosé singing
- jisoo/rosé singing
- beat drop + shout the title
- “yeah”
- shout the title again
- rap
- jisoo/rosé singing
- jisoo/rosé singing
- beat drop + shout the title
- “yeah”
- shout the title again
- rosé sings an english bridge
- dance break ft. remix
woah woah
THIS!!
pansexual pandacakes tbh you are right
pansexual pandacakes basically most BLACKPINK songs no hate I love blackpink
@@Uloveeverglow not really, like only ddu ddu and kill this love follow this format. I mean this exact same format.
Stop using that cowboy screaming or YG is gonna use it as the next Blackpink song’s chorus
😂😂
LOL
💀SIS-
Me: oh hell no-
YG: *beat drops* yeehAw🤠 haw haw haw haw
@@summerpeach3389 why the heck am i singing that line 😂
TEDDY IS THE JAMES PATTERSON OF KPOP
Who the hell is James Patterson
@@catalayalafaye5337 an American ya/mystery/thriller author who legit has released so many books that people claim he is just regurgitating the same shit every time, with different named characters or sum (or ppl claim he doesn't even write all his books)
At least James Patterson is actually skillful and releases content
Amy Kopper very debatable
But.... I like James Patterson...........
But yeah, fair enough
I just realized what they've been doing to us...
What?
@@sophie-lu4fs giving us the same thing 6 times
@@lekhika9515 all the songs have different beat, I do not understand your ears.
@@jharnakarki6214 But that doesnt change the fact that they all are really similar in pattern. Take mamamoo for example, every song is different in its own way. Every song except for stay is of the same genre, and having the same pattern doesn't help either. They lack versatility, and you blinks cannot change that fact.
SOMEONE THAT FINALLY GETS IT OH MY GOD THANK U I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO THOUGHT THIS WAY BRO-
THIS is what people mean when they say that all of blackpink's songs sound the same.
Yes and the same concepts (toxic relationship) 😂
exactly, and we're obviously excluding stay and hope not JUST because they are ballads
Yup doesnt take a rocket scientist to realize that after 3 songs but blinks will prove me wrong 😂
@@syazminwardini1824 and even with the album,lovesick girls is still about that
@@oneiric-diary well ikr
it's hilarious to me how "how you like that" came out yesterday, i am watching this now and this entire video could just be copied and pasted exactly the same to talk about it.
Yeah me too, I just came across this video and how accurate it really is
Not really
Not really
@@kpopistherevolutionperiodt8974 yes, really
right... it's boring now
Am I the only person who hates/has noted the end of the song in KTL? It seems extremely rushed and unfinished, as if they forgot something because it’s so abrupt but I haven’t heard anyone mention it
The chorus sounds empty as well, there is something missing from multiple points of this song and it makes it hard to listen to this as anything more than background music.
Are you kidding? Everyone has been saying that since kill this love came out 😂
I think teddy got lazy
Fxte msp Typically after the second the chorus there would be a bridge leading to the ending, which would probably make it seem less rushed. In KTL the bridge would be “we all commit to love” part, ending at “we must kill” the bridge is soo short in this song that its barely noticeable since it just cuts to “we must kill this love”. The ‘bridge’ is so tiny its under 20 words if you count words like “as, us, we” etc. It also may seem very abrupt because the bridge is very slow, and it just out of the blue cuts to blasting trumpets and the ending.
The ending seems abrupt because it is the first song of the album. It is meant to seem unfinished so you would want more. I admit that they still could've tried to add something more so it would be satisfying by itself.
Nobody:
Literally Nobody:
Not even Jennie & Teddy:
Girls in my school: H E R E I C O M E K I C K I N G T H E D O O R
Ms_ Penguinee that’s not jennies line so why would she say it ???
MM ik
@@milkoa9857 oof
now ima do this when school goes back
best part of the song
i know blackpink already get so little comebacks and it sucks that fans have to eat everything and anything up, no matter if they enjoy it or not. but this needs to be said. if you don't like the music and *still* buy and stream it, it isn't going to change. d4 and ktl are, from an outsider's perspective, blackpink's most popular and best songs, considering they have the highest album sales and youtube and spotify streams. can you blame the company for sticking with that sound if they think people enjoy it?
blinks who didn't enjoy ktl (and i know a lot of them), why did you still stream the mv so much? it has *700 million* views for crying out loud. which group has numbers that high on a song that is generally disliked by the fandom? are they really going to have 2 mvs with 1 billion views and both of those songs were most blinks' least favorite comebacks? doesn't make any sense.
if you really want a different sound, make it known to yg. stream only songs that you like. that's what normal people do anyway.
100% true. It bothers me when kpop fans stream and buy songs they don't like just to get their favs views and sales. If you don't like it you don't need to buy it. Makes you no less of a fan.
Say it louder for the people on the back... I never saw such a comment that I 100% agree with....
I’m commenting so I can come back to this
Even their Samsung song have more views than someones real comeback
@@weebforever4070 aWeSoMe ScReEn!
Mera : it has to much English!
Jopping, superm, SM : oh honey.... That's nothing compared to us..
i mean superm IS targeted for the western fans so... (this is prolly just a joke and im making myself look like a clown)
@@-darkyun8843 SM is dumb they don't know Western fans want Korean songs instead of English ones lol... And you're not a clown we all are..
The worst part is that KTL's English, albeit unnatural, makes sense, but Jopping's borderline qualifies for gibberish. Both songs try to imitate AAVE (African American Vernacular English, the English dialect of hip hop), but Teddy gave up half way through and decided to go back to good ol' standard English, while SM went all the way but get AAVE all wrong-they think AAVE doesn't make sense to standard English speakers, but in truth *AAVE makes sense* as much as any language does.
The only good part is a small verse of Mark's, which sounds exactly like what I would expect a North American rapper to spit out (he's Canadian). He must've taken his AAVE classes and written the verse himself.
@Tri Gustiansyahhoney... the video is about blackpink and its said in the video
@@mottenelf4258 and comments can be made by people watching a video on a public platform, on a video made to be commented on. it is a valid point, this is called having a conversation. try it sometime. it is fun.
me sitting here right after "how you like that" dropped,,,, it sounds the same
Same I'm starting to think pt like YG anymore
Facts! As usual their over hype them! Like is the best thing ever! I can't with the bp fans delusional
@@imeldafaytaren212 every fan hype their fave
@@iamagirl8056 I don't think so there will be people who like songs that majority of the fandom doesn't but some really don't hype them if they don't like it in many fandoms. But majority of the blinks not all but majority even if they don't like it they stream you know why because yg starves the fandom so whatever they gave blinks will hype them.
@@lulinafelicia8530 that's how "stan culture" works
Believe me when I say this : If YG won't do anything good this year, BLACKPINK will follow 2NE1.
There’s a high chance they will. As YG focuses on their new group, their older groups will be ignored. But hopefully this will let the girls have time to write music or really focus on where they want their career to go.
YG should not create new groups when they can’t even take care of the one he has
Black pink is Disbanding next year.
@@idontfeelsogood6056 Little correction: As YG focuses on their new girl group, their older girl groups will be ignored. YG still prefers Winner over iKON and hasn't done a thing with Treasure so far. Also, the only reason they prefer Winner is because Bigbang are technically still on hiatus.
Sagit YG doesn’t prefer winner over ikon. YG prefers Mino and Bobby over their group mates. And don’t expect treasure to debut anytime soon. It took YG almost a decade to plan for bp and even with all that time they constantly changed everything from the line up to their brand name
And the worst part of this is that their songs are kinda 50% in english, but it's not the type of a decent lyric writing is more of the kind of cringing lyrics and it's not like Teddy doesn't know how to speak or write in the language bc he was raised in NY like wtf dude?!
g gasca i agree. Have you seen the English raps in the Japanese versions? BLACKPINK’s raps are the types of raps like a bunch of teenagers make up to roast each other. Like yeah they sound good and are catchy but they have no substance whatsoever.
You can write for them. Send them emails. English part has made BP popular and will stay as it is.
mubpfc They are a KOREAN GIRL GROUP not American singers
@@sofiahassan1990 its also what made BP popular in the rest of the world
@@sofiahassan1990 its also what made BP popular in the rest of the world
I know I'm literally a year late but
Kill This Love is also literally just a Samsung ad with many clear product placements.
-Rosé showing off a galaxy watch in her car scene
-All the members wearing galaxy buds in the first chorus
-Lisa and Jennie holding galaxy phones during their english rap
Idk what to think about this but it kinda shows that this "comeback" is more about money than giving the fans what they want.
Agreed
wait what.. I actually never noticed that besides the lisa n jennie part.
I'm glad Im not the only one who noticed :D the girls slayed tho
I know right, but it's not Blackpink's fault, it's YG. The new CEO is using Blackpink for money cause she's a gold digger, it's literally so obvious especially the new 4+1 project for their 5th Anniversary, we had to pay to see Blackpink 😢
I am a year late too but too be honest it may sound bad but if I had that fame I will make a comeback introducing brands I some how represent is not bad its Smart it doesn't kill any one
Sis is speaking facts again
Ikr
lazer tag well then fuck you and get out of here duh
buttercup_ 0976 they don’t sound the same but the structure is the same, with singing the title etc
Aria
Preach sis, preach
lazer tag nah
I don’t know why I am just hearing about this channel. I love the way u talk, it gives me goosebumps, and they way u say opinions without bashing the groups is everything. Why can’t other channels be like u and kpop Junkie
winter bear exactly ,, it’s hard to keep up with the robotic voice ,, i usually turn the videos with it in like a half
Check out K-FanMan
V for Victory, K fan man is good
@@Taeyovo he is? lmao i dropped him so long ago how did he change his crappy behaviour
Pinkbangtan is also a good youtuber check her out
am i the only one that thinks blackpinks choreography is lame??? we've all seen the predebut video of them dancing in the basement to rihanna we know they can dance better
@ idk why it just seems to lag? if that makes sense? like i see what they are doing but if it wasn't for the fancy camera work on live stages it would just seem... blah? that 'dance break' for D4 was just bad.
Should we even get started to 16 shots?
@@Mondscheinstaub agreed
their choreographer changed from kyle to kiel tutin, and kiel uses recycled choreographies. kiel started during d4
@ at first D4 is just "easy" level for me and one year later KTL come. Lmao, i don't even trying to learn KTL because it's similar to D4. And yes, i'm a dancer.
I never even got into kill this love, *I didn’t even get a blonde Jennie??* BIsh wHaHt-
It was only for the teaser...
Dalisandra Parra Ik I really wanted a blonde Jennie :( it’s such a look
not even a jennie with bangs like wTf
vagoo ikr??
@@rvinbowhalo she had bangs tho?!
As if it's your last and Kick It have the best chorus of all Blackpink songs wbk
Edit: Really, Hope Not and Stay also have amazing choruses
yes they have the beat choruses definitely
Those are literally my two favourite songs from them!
I also like really tho....its pretty
Stay and dkwtd
Inyourarea idc what your feelings are on Hope Not, but that chorus was the best one they’ve ever had. It was self-reflective and heartbreaking.
Just gonna say Mera, you were absolutely spot on with the Teddy formula. One year later, How you like that is so similar to other releases.
Those three components show up at the chorus again. Classic Teddy!
Y e s I was specifically looking for this video after they released the song
@@kero5577 The first time I heard the song I was like: Teddy was making damn sure every one knows that this is his song
12:21 the rap could've been iconic if she sang it in Korean.
Shrutika Srivastava idk about that
For me nooooooooo. It's the only thing I can sing along with jennie!🙏
Not really
Nah
Nahh. English was easier for everyone and it flows with the beat more
People would have realize that 7songs are the same if there weren't a FULL YEAR in between each of the song. And you know what happens in a year?? People forget about songs and that's how they got people into believing "ho my god blackpink is the revolution"...
basically YG smart and holding all blinks in the palm of his hand...
8 songs with Don't know what to do. The chorus follows the same pattern. A phrase (I don't know what to do without you). Onomatopoeia (yeah yeah yeah) and edm
thinking abt it, since blinks hv only these songs 2 stream, i wonder if they caught on
@@jess290 They might just be in full denial
Yg is super smart kind of a very smart villian vibe
Dear yg: the western Kpop fandoms don't want to hear more english.
but it tru tho
true,thats what made me like kpop in the first place
A little old, but true. International fans don't want English, I if I wanted English would go listen to English music. Too much English screams 'Desperate to American Sucess', and you don't really need that. Besides, if A Kpop Fan says they prefer English versions, they are not Kpop fans.
This not what a true I-Kpop fan signed for.
I do
@@riri_caughtin4k31 1/millions.
‘tea, gunpowder and the bubonic plague’ i choked
YGs method to break blackpink into the west is like a man on a bike showing up to your house to offer you his religion but instead of the Book of morman it's the same chorus 7 times
🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭
THIS IS SO FUNNY OMFL
i- 💀
I honestly didnt like „kill this love“ Its sounded just like „Ddu-du-ddu“. also the lyrics of the Song felt really meanigless and bland. I feel like blackpinks Songs are getting More and more boring with every Comeback
I think there is a meaning behind Let's Kill This Love.I'm pretty sure its about a girl who is in a toxic relationship, its shown throughout the music video
@@mikaelarose6277 Maybe but this type of meaning is boring and unoriginal like try something else ? Something really useful ? Society ? Self love ? Youth ? Friendship ? Their is Soo many subjects you can talk about in your lyrics. BlackPink have a huge following and I don't understand why they don't use this following to spread a good message. Maybe their writer don't have the skill to it, but even writing songs about toxic relationships can be poetic at least but here most of it don't really make sense and lyrically wise it's very poor and the vocabulary is trash. Most BlackPink lyrics are trash. Hopefully one day they can write their own music even though I don't think it will ever happen.
@@mikaelarose6277 aiiyl superior ktl trash sweetie
@@-amel-9896 Its still a problem in the society tho:( Many girls still are in toxic relationships without knowing what to do. It's not as serious but it's also a problem society faces nowadays.
I think they're just telling girls to stand up? Be strong? 🤷♀️
@@_wobblyjelly_2700 How many times did artists cover this subject ? Maaaany times. Honestly toxic relationships aren't something new, and they probably don't know a lot about it since they aren't even allowed to date
Those "piano" notes from dududu are literally samples from a game called goat simulator.
That's funny if it's true 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Lulu Angelina it is true lmao
@@maithili420 BRUH 🤣🤣🤣🤣
OMG I'm wheezing rn 😂😂😂
@@luluangelina2923 lmao i know right!
HYLT was released and I'm waiting for "Is "How You Like That" worth the hype?"
Same
Me too
Yes it is worth the hype
no.... not really ( no hate ok )
I can answer: NO
I agree with all points except for the point that there is to much english... i mean this song was made for Coachella....
Xyz Xyz that’s the point tho, she was trying to say that YG made them so that they are more suited towards America and international places whereas they are a kpop group, it’s sad because they barely get any attention in Korea and are way less famous there than internationallly. YG made them so that they would be internationally famous which is fine but it’s weird since they are u know a kpop group
@@meganpeareth4841 that is bcz in the top three companies yg is the one with most shares in America
Tbh I don't mind the English
Very late, but when I first heard KTL, I’d listen to it on loop and still get thrown off when the Korean part of the second pre-chorus came up, just because I got so used to them singing in English. And that’s not even with the Japanese version, where Lisa’s rap in the first verse is also in English.
I like how you spent the first 10 mins gushing all the good points... And then proceeded to bash the hell out of the song😂😂
YouYou I think it’s their best album? After wings ofc lool. How come you think it’s a flop, everyone I’ve come across loved it.
Edit: nvm, just found out you’re an anti from your other replies to comments, what a saddo 😂
@@xylema. just because someone don't like it you should call someone a anti it's her opinian
Keerthi Bushan I forgot I made this comment but the user made anti comments that weren’t relevant to the video regarding bts. They were saying things against bts loll. It was childish behaviour and you saw how I respected their opinion and kindly asked why they believe wings wasn’t a good album. They deleted their comments so you won’t be able to see anyway 😂
Blackpink songs are the same songs but in different fonts
I agree
hylt is fucking comic sans
yes, imo its the same lyrics recycled with fillers in between and then a lame dance break... the end ahhh yess and the CA in HYLT IMO
I feel like KTL ends abruptly, I think they should have done the chorus again and then end the song.
Tbh the whole song sounds very empty it needs more lyrics I think.
YES, I'VE BEEN SAYING THIS
It’z Itzy Everglow that’s teddy for you, he should really change the structure of songs he produce
It's lazy writing gosh
Beyond The Scene I completely agree!
I feel like a scandal happened with yg so Yg just said “BLACKPINK is having a comeback” and rushed the whole entire song to get the scandal of there back.
I actually think the chorus and ending is what killed 'kill this love"
Idk the chorus sounds incomplete, it's missing something for me.
Y'all always gotta hate smh
@hairbrained if y'all got nothing nice to say don't say it tf? Stoopid ass. Keep your rude opinions to your self
@@Ablumeofficial Criticism is not the same as hate. The only one hating here is you, 'stoopid ass'...really haha, no one was cursing except for you..that's rude.
@@mewmew6158 Yes I feel the same, I do love the pre chorus a lot and Lisa's first rap is iconic. But the chorus is just a bit empty.
"English speaking fans don't want English albums, we want k-pop albums." TRUTH
Not only is she convincing and brutally honest, she's also right
"forgot to write the chorus syndrome"... *eyes How You Like That* 👀
The fact that her formula matches their new single, how u like that
Yesss!
Guys, isnt it clear about the difference between SuperM and bp situations? SuperM consists kpop idols, but it was explained in advance they were going to promote in the usa only, thats why they made song full of English. They werent going to promote in Korea, win Korean shows, rely on their korean fanbases, have korean promotions etc - only west. They kinda officially debuted in the us. Bp otherwise want Korea to support them, but still had song 65% made of English. The difference is obvious.
he's trying to throw bp more at the American market because there are more people in American than Korea. also if there's more naive fans who don't know about yg's past then that means more money will be thrown his way
Yass and he doesn'y give a shit if they like it or not. They are just cashcows to him dude.
Copying bighit.
I mean it's impossible to support BlackPink without throwing money YG's way and therefore technically supporting him
@@jenejen4351 Big Hit isn't pushing BTS in America. It was America who is drooling and begging for BTS. You stand corrected, there I said it
@@jenejen4351 army are the one who brought BTS, bighit never did anything to American and they came becos of their fans
"yg's method to break blackpink into the west is like a man on a bike showing up to your house to offer you his religion but instead of the book of mormon it's the same chorus 7 times" this line made me scream
Lmao the way she says ‘boohoo’ sounds like my French aunt
😂 😂 😂 OMG you made my day
Lol I'm french and it's kinda true
IM LINKING EVERY KPOP FAN I KNOW TO YOUR ENTIRE RUclips CHANNEL
Omg same 😂
Please don't this girl is full of shit and continued to spread half truths about bp for RUclips clout.
winnars
THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
@@winnars lol LOL
@@winnars but her points are understandable and to a point true
Blackpink: How to Make Consumers Worship the Bare Minimum
Exactly.
Nuh uh, honey, it should be *YG
I remember honestly being disappointed they didn’t keep her blue hair in that once scene as it fit her to a t. I remember while I was still hype I definitely took a moment seeing the braids on her, they just looked so ugly to me. I didn’t mind her outfit but I just felt her hair completely distracts you from her outfit entirely.
i really liked the braids on her lol
Ok lisa is pretty with everything
@@ruyaozdemir6816 Your opinion
Blue hair?
@@illetan815 same
Visiting this video again- I feel like people don’t realise the Teddy structure because they’re so thirsty for a blackpink comeback that anything will satisfy them even if it is the same recycled beat and lyrics
Edit: I just watched the comeback and I am not disappointed,, it didn’t sound like ktl AT ALL and it was a completely fresh sound 💜 I’m glad that it isn’t a recycled beat and sounds like a completely new song :)
that's the problem. yg could make ktl part 2 for the next comeback and blinks would eat it up and make it chart just because yg doesn't really like to give his groups content.
@@lillyfxx their next comeback is already gonna be successful
Believe me blinks are gonna eat up anything
What fans are for? Ofcourse they're going to eat any content about Blackpink.
Hylt was like boombayah instead of d4 pt 3 lmao
@@kwistachuchu7047 sad but true that's how fan culture works like
God said “Let there be light”
Lisa said “HERE I COME KICK IN THE DOOR”
@MICHELLE VALERI wut
@MICHELLE VALERI in the video they said “God said ‘let their be light,’ Lisa said ‘HERE I COME KICK IN THE DOOR.’” I was quoting what they said lol.
"too much english"
superm: we're just gonna mosey on out of here and you're gonna pretend you never heard or saw anything ok
Superm was made for the US market though, SM themselves literally shared an article about them with "next bts" as title.
@@zaic8660 True, this is disrespectful to both BTS and SuperM tbh, SM deleted their tweet after it was called out. They are be using BTS's success to make a name for their group when in reality it's not giving them any legacy. The embarrassing thing about it is that the article was making this comparison with BTS because superm sold out arenas, which is.. very ridiculous compared to what BTS can sell out. It's been years that they don't perform in arenas anymore, they perform in stadiums. BTS sell out stadiums, not arenas. Arenas are easily just the fans's waiting room.
-Amel- superm may not have bts popularity and success in America but their doing just fine and why y’all annoying bts always try and compare every Kpop group trying to break into the US market to bts, some Kpop groups just want a successful across over into the US market their not trying to be bts or to beat bts they just wanna be a global success and that means trying to be successful in the US like the rest of the world not everything is about bts or trying to compete with them be happy for bts success but don’t try and down another group also trying to be a success in the US, it’s funny that superm and bts cool with one another wanna see one another succeed in everything they do yet their sh*tty fans always fighting in stupid fan wars trying to put them against one another and it’s pathetic
@@lovelydiva06 What's wrong with you ? Why everytime someone mention BTS you guys interpret it as comparing it with other groups or hating on them ? I am talking about SM entertainment who shared an article saying that Super M is the next BTS, and this is exactly where I am mad about because this is what comparing without any reason is. SM entertainment ≠ Super M members
I don't think you clearly understood what I was trying to say. You guys get offended for everything jeez
im super super gay for ryujin I mean that’s the thing sm and yg can’t seem to understand, u don’t make kpop groups targeted at the western market and expect the west to eat it up, the audience won’t prefer superm or bp over other acts just bc their songs have like 80% English lyrics. Or, in superm’s case, a kpop group made specifically for the western market. Kinda feels like how some companies tried to debut kpop groups formed solely with western members a few years ago, it just won’t appeal to the audience
I’m going to say it, I didn’t like How You Like That, I’m disappointed. One local in Twitter just said that the song is so bad that he can’t believe how people listen to it non-ironically. I don’t think the song is bad but blinks waited one year for the comeback and some of them are disappointed.
FROM MY EXPERIENCE: i was a hardcore blink from debut untik aiiyl, but then i unstanned bc i got bored. but when i was somewhat a blink again, i made some friends that are hardcore blinks. i asked them if they actually liked blackpink's latest songs, they said they did but they didn't at the same time. they said, THEY WANT AND LIKE BLACKPINK, but they don't really like their songs so much. they like it bc blackpink sings it. not the music itself. do you guys know what i mean?? i stopped being somewhat a blink because i don't wanna stream music i don't like just bc i like the artist. i want good music. not models who advertise the music. i'll still support blackpink whatever they do, but not at the same level as before. i hooe they get better treatment.
agreed I like Blackpink and I consume a lot of Blackpink content but I don’t listen to their music in my free time.
@@ozilsanchez5094 same now I just only listen to their songs when it’s released
Totally agree with you
I can't understand korean
So the only thing I am here for is good music and if I can't even get that whats the point of listening kpop when there is other pop other around which I can understand too
retarded comment
I miss Jennie’s rapping too. As much as I love her singing, I love her rapping even more. I’M STILL WAITING FOR A FULL ALBUM YG
Hylt didn’t age well
ΛPRΣMOR same I love bp but there music is not it anymore like I waited a year and two months for this???
Almost a month still not over it still sounds good
I’m super late but HYLT is like milk that is gonna expire in a day but the weird thing is, is that you bought it yesterday.
Also lsg and ice cream lol
You guys clearly haven't listened to it with headphones
There’s this video called “why I unstanned blackpink (the k-pop industry at its worst)” that points out how all of blackpinks songs were written before they even DEBUTED. So yeah YG’s really leaving us hanging here
It's I syp video right I have also seen it
This video describes the new song perfectly again...
1 year later.... still the Teddy formula
The reason they do not have that many albums or songs is because YG makes enough money with what they are doing already. YG makes enough money through CFs and sponsorships. Since they do, the music seems to come last. Also, if blinks continue to stream music videos, buy merch and support them financially, YG won't change their strategy. Also, they only have a comeback once a year because the longer they wait, the more demanding blinks are. The more demanding blinks are, the more popular blackpink grows due to trends demanding for a comeback. Then, when the internet is practically begging for a comeback, YG releases it and gain more money from it.
This is also why I don't believe in the 'I support Blackpink but not YG' argument. If you support blackpink, you are supporting YG and giving them what they want which affects us. And also, we've seen what YG does with that money (Burning Sun Scandal, scandals where YG has been accused of giving their staff/idols sex workers, drug scandals, overworking idols...). Yes a percentage does go to Blackpink but the money is used for more bad than good.
The facts are spoken
The dude scream singing in the hills never gets old. 😂
That dude's singing is art tbh 😂
us blinks are so thirsty for a comeback/song that yg could drop a recording of his farts and we would be pleased.
That's unfortunately the problem. Everyone laps up all the scraps and junk that a lot of companies/producers/songwriters are putting out bc we don't want our groups to disband or become forgotten. But unfortunately it means that those same companies/producers/songwriters get complacent with the easy money and the thirst that they continue to just churn out the Teddy repetition (since this vid is about BP I'll just use the example given) until consumers make a song repeat utterly and completely *flop*. YG tosses scraps and expects praise and adoration for it and because fans know that groups live or die by the bottom line, fans of every fandom just lap it all up no matter how much they hate it, no matter how much it's the same thing over and over, because they don't want their groups to go away. The problem is, the songs that are suffering those flops are usually from new groups that come in, get a song or two, and then disappear - it's not going to change until the consumer mindset changes where we're no longer going to be content with whatever we're given, even if it's crappy - and that needs to happen to a bigger group for the industry as a whole to shake itself out of this complacency.
People literally danced on "awesome screen awesome camera long lasting battery life" 😂🤣
kay Cee the saddest part is that blinks are making “new songs” for blackpink with parts from the old songs.
@@clauulv yup!! I absolutely love these girls... Thus i am patient
We have.....
Awesome screen, awesome camera, long lasting battery life
KTL was a hit!! I’m Brazilian and this song introduced me to blackpink. I was literally obsessed with the mv and playing this song on loop. Yes, there is a formula. But the formula works
When bp first debuted, I gave them a chance. Their songs were too simple/repetitive for me. The choruses are always so empty.
The choruses seem to suffer from the 'oops forgot to write the chorus' syndrome that songwriters are suffering from.
Single phrase chorus formula being used too frequently to the point of unbearable to me.
@@bibicute942000 same. like there are some songs where I need an empty chorus because the verses are so damn dense (well emptier) like Stray Kids's Side Effects and Dreamcatcher's Scream - it gives me a chance to breathe and process what just happened in the previous verse. But... blackpinks verses are just as empty - like thx Teddy you lazy ass
... we just got the same formula AGAIN this time and the fans are about to give YG their money anyway and prove that starving them works. This will keep happening as long as we let YG get away with it.
Sad truth
Guess what? How you like that is THE EXACT SAME THING
I agree. It's such a good song but it basically has the same formula and everything. Tbh, they need a new songwriter.
Geuss what? It LITERALLY ISN'T
I really like “Kill This Love”. If you listen to American pop, all the songs sound the same to me (but with different words). Same song structure, predictable lyrics.
Yeah they do sound the same but That's just only mainstream that sounds the same
Rest of the music is good tho
Yeah I don’t get why people hate it
Ronald Chan I like it aswell, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t a carbon copy of dx4. And I agree with your opinion on American pop as well; however some pop artists tend to have a different sound making them more intriguing
I don't hate the song, I just dislike how empty the background sounds from an actual music standpoint.
For me, being the same doesn’t necessarily make it good. Stop reading now if you don’t want my opinion. I like it when the songs have elements that aren’t heard with other songs. I like it when the producers experiment. I’m guessing it’s why I like groups like BTS, Stray Kids and MAMAMOO so much. They *experiment* with the tones in their songs and the concepts. Almost every song is different.I thought Kill This Love was OKAY. It wasn’t outstanding but it wasn’t the worst. Really, I just listened to it a few times over the course of a week and just stopped. In fact, I recently stopped stanning BP. They are talented but I just got BORED of them. I never really wanted to listen to their songs anymore, besides a select few. Usually, when they appeared on my playlist, I would skip them because I simply didn’t feel like listening to them. They have a lot of potential. Great singers, superb rappers, good dancing. But the way it was being used really put me off. I just didn’t have it in me to say I am a Blink when I don’t truly enjoy their music anymore.
Dang it, girl! Your content is so good. You've essentially read my mind on the whole BlackPink subject, especially that Mormon analogy. YG dropped everything, including Lee Hi and 2ne1, for something **fresh** and **new** to show America, not even realizing the love was homegrown and established from afar, not custom made for us.
Blackpink is an amazing kpop girl group whom I Stan and it's YG's fault for treating them not right
Jennie: most hated
Lisa: most discriminated
Rosè: most mistreated
Jisoo: most underappreciated
i don't like your username, its disrespectful to onces. Im sorry to say this but some blinks can be so toxic.
@@leeminhomademestraightagai4134 just some of us tho :
@@summerpeach3389 ya...i feel bad for the NICE blinks....
Guys they’re blonks HSHAHA
oh my gosh I’m so sorry once’s just ignore her username
I have a love hate relationship with this MINI album, i hate kill this love's chorus like it puts me off so much and the ending is an ew. Kill this love could have been a masterpiece but teddy was like NOPE. I hope the next comeback can be better than everything they have put out until now. Also we are getting an early 2020 comeback right? Yeah fuck no they have post poned it I AM LOSING IT
Kill this love is a master piece. Periodt! It has the most views in 24hrs after boy with love. And for you the chorus part would be boring but for me it's the best thing I've ever heard!! I'm just saying dont take it personally
@@kokkiearmy3812 For you is a masterpiece, for me is a mediocer song, of course i am not taking it personally we just have different opinions
@@kokkiearmy3812 just because a song is popular doesn't mean it's good (it's okay if you like kill this love, ofc), but it's kinda obvious ktl was going to have a lot of views bc all the hype around blackpink (and the fact that fans had to wait a loooot for a cb). the same with boy with love, for me it's not a bad song but meh
,,,, but since it was released by bts, who are really popular and have a huge fandom, it makes sense that the song would be successful
.
The end was cringe for me.
I think it's gonna be the same blueprint. Teddy has gotten really lazy with his songs, at least the ones released. I don't think YG has ever cared about musical intergrity, just how much money they can milk from their artists. BP makes a hell of a lot more being models than releasing music, they do the bare minimum to keep fans roped in. While it's okay to like their songs, but anyone can see the pattern and you shouldn't be satisfied. Look at any other group, they get minimum of 2 comebacks a year and other variety appearances ON TOP of their CF's. Blinks shouldn't be satisfied with a bare minimum music wise. Touring brings a lot of money too, but who wants to pay a lot of money to hear same songs over and over. Even Jennie has thrown shade at YG when she said at a concert "i'd perform more songs if I had any".
BP is heading towards not renewing their contracts after 7 years. While that is still far away, who would stay at a company that doesn't let you explore your musicality. They trained for years, to be shelved as models. All their musical talent is being completely wasted by shoving them into this box that is their discography. Even if it's just b-sides, for the love of god, YG needs to let them explore more musically. And the girls likely are more than capable of producing songs themselves. THe difference between Ikon and BP is crystal clear. Ikon has a more diverse discography, because they produce their music mostly by themselves.
YG is doing the bare minimum to get the most profit and Blinks, you really shouldn't be satisfied with it. And I understand it's difficult to go against YG, cause the company decides. But I think Blinks are strong fandom and could make a change. Unfortunately I don't have an answer to how. There's more than enough people in the fandom to get their attention. Hit them where the money is as that's what the company cares about the most.
this girl could talk about anything and i would listen to it. im quarantine binging, and this is great content.
I just realized DKWTD also is like this
-Phrase: Don't know what to do
-onomatopoeia: Youuuuuuuuu~
-the circling noises(doessn't know how to explain it)
Yeah, and I can't like that song lol that one and forever young
Honestly, it was the first kpop song I ever heard/liked so I can't really hate it
Lol Too
They use so much english words to break in to America when *Blackpink* is a *Korean* girl group... Is YG that hungry for money? I hope the situation gets better but it will only happen if YG wakes up
Good point.
As if it’s your last is blackpink’s best song that’s the tea
whistle says helloooo
Waiting for your opinion and analysis on blackpink comeback ! I love the way you explain things
12:17 Lmao now I'm *soooo* excited to know your opinions about jopping 😂😂
Same honestly-
It's like 95% English, I dunno if you can even categorize that in the category Kpop lmao.
(no hate tho, I love SuperM with all of my heart-)
Guys, isnt it clear? SuperM consists kpop idols, but it was explained in advance they were going to promote in the usa only, thats why they made song full of English. They werent going to promote in Korea, win Korean shows, rely on their korean fanbases, have korean promotions etc - only west. They kinda officially debuted in the us. Bp otherwise want Korea to support them, but still had song 65% made of English. The difference is obvious.
And i guess i am the only one who didn't like that song just baekhyun's high notes
@@Khanquirat Honestly if not for Mark's rap and Baekhyun's high note i wouldn't like that song at all
@@fightingnimo7 true
I used to love BP but, once I realized the songs sounded the same I just kind of lost love for it. And the comebacks. They come like Christmas. It's blinks gift from YG.I still love my girls tho. I literally forget that BP exist until I see a Twitter post and go," Oh yeah, Blackpink".
Honestly i thought ktl and 4xdu were not my favorite i really hate those songs but i loveeeeeee dkwtd like omg that song was art
Omg same 😂 I had the same feeling I heard dkwtd more than ktl
@@lucienvana4655 forever young more than dududu
I really liked dkwtd as well
no dkwtd sounds so generic... that stupid anticlimactic drop ruined it. sounds like a rejected chain smoker 2016 chorus. BUT the dance, and verses were so good a big step up 😍 i loved the subtle rock influence
but the drop just ruined it. the best song was kick it what an underrated bop.
@@MM-ex5kz the drop was good for me! I like EDM and k-pop so.
I need to get this entire video tattooed to my forehead
love your points ❤ aaaaand I totally agree with "Kick It". It's my fave BP song of today.
Kill this love has been out for a long time but I can't even remember how the song goes. I always get it confused with du du du
"Making good music is possible if you actually care about music." - exACTLY! THANK YOU!!!
Kill This Love, was the song that killed my love for BP. That was kinda like the catalyst that made me open my eyes towards so many things that's just wrong about BP and YG. And, I don't want to support a group that barely has any content. I'm sorry if it seems rude, but BP does not deserve the hype anymore. There are too many new groups coming out with fresh concepts, and they aren't afraid to try new styles, and many who are doing the badass concept better.
I'm gonna tattoo the first sentence of your comment on my forehead.
Yeah the recycle the songs and choreo. It's all old now
Came back to this comment and well, their new song justifies what we have all been feeling.
Can we just love and cherish these girls and thanking them for being in our lifes then pointing out their mistakes
Love you blackpink
THANK YOUUUUU
i honestly find BLACKPINK's songs old and almost the same. i mean... all of their songs have 50% english lyrics and they never had a full korean song. i don't hate them.. i just really can't bop with the concept of the tunes.
and istg some of the fans are choosing to completely ignore this. like at this point yall only like their music cause theyre the ones singing
this video came out over a year ago and can you believe it??? they have....FOURTEEN SONGS NOW
*Help, I AM IN LOVE WITH THIS CHANNEL*
I think some people expect too much from pop songs. They're meant to be simple and catchy. American pop does this too. It's nothing new. Honestly, if it wasn't for Teddy's trap beats, I would've never found this group. I hope they get on more trap beats. And, yes, trap beats follow a particular formula. All genres of music do.
If it wasn't for their visuals and the money they put on the MV production, their songs wouldn't do as great as they are doing now
Kill this love was basically a fashion show with some background music
True
True
Did you even watch the video?
@@kingexplosionmurderfuckoff9376 yeah
*FACT* : Kill this love is not bad but it’s not memorable either
True
Teddy during 2NE1 era is amazing. 2NE1 discography is so unique, way beyond their years and so diverse compare to all 1st and 2nd gen kpop gg. That is why 2NE1 become the LEGENDARY OG BADASS QUEENS they are now. Social media specially YY was not that relevant that time but 2NE1 became the 3rd biggest gg next to Spice Girls and TLC and was able penetrate western music scene.
2NE1 is Teddy's muse and in my opinion he just lost his touched when it comes to BP. It's like just his making songs for BP because it's what his supposed to do.
FINALLY some addresses the repetition, god I can’t even, and the new song too omg
And all those non kpop fan hyping up cause it’s simply “cool” I’m like seriously non of you see/ hear this ???? God I’m dying
Am I the only person who genuinely likes ktl
IKR!
Nope, I love it as well c:
Nope you're not the only one
I love it i dont understand why people hate the song so much
MALEK TRAD eh I don’t hate it.... I just feel like we’ve had it before lmao
The way you use language and expressions show how smart and creative you are. I love hearing you speak.
"I would trade YG to Satan for a corn chip"